Bad Apple!! but it's made of YouTube captions

Recommended: Mac, Android, Linux
Windows is fine, but spaces look off because the font has a wrong width for braille space.
iPhone/iPad app can only play captions at about 5 fps, but it works with browser version of KZbin.
Original: • 【東方】Bad Apple!! ＰＶ【影絵】 nico.ms/sm8628149
Caption videos playlist: • Caption videos

[@OtterSou]

Braille blanks are misaligned on Windows due to a font issue. Try changing the caption language to "Japanese - for Windows". (replaces blanks to "⠁") 2024-04-28 update: thank you for 2 million views! If you liked this video, check out other caption videos → kzbin.info/aero/PLMb28FDEyWTm9Nz8k23YyC5Cd3hLYIjrb 2021-01-16 update: added lyrics. 2021-01-30 update: uploaded a sequel to this video → kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYm2dIWLYsyFr5I 2021-07-05 update: uploaded part 3 → kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpPTna2LpNxsp7M 2022-11-14 update: thank you for 1 million views! I've never expected this video to become this popular. 2023-08-11 update: uploaded part 4 → kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2PZi6aBjruAhZY 2023-10-22 update: changed "English" to "Japanese - for Windows"

[@CloroxBleach0]

I use windows, and I don't know if it's like that for everyone but at least for me the japanese subs seem fine. I also use firefox.

[@FeixiaoLiao]

It looked like a small video on android, or is it normal?

[@a0_l]

the lyrics looks completely fine for me in windows

[@CloroxBleach0]

@@FeixiaoLiao it's normal, that's how it should look :)

[@noori2105]

Looks cool

[@peppercornucopia_]

"If there are two colors, it can be turned into bad apple" - Sun Tzu, probably

[@kelvinlee8629]

“this applied to both the mv and a real apple” - albert einstein, i guess?

[@Candelitarex23]

"Sun Tzu said that!" Rip Rick May...

[@landsbergnascimento3008]

@@Candelitarex23 rip...

[@deleteduser8652]

This is the 3rd worst thing that happened to those orphans

[@Kriegsploink]

uHhHH hE dIdNt eVeN sAAy ThaT

[@hiiloveu1521]

You can never stop looking at three things: 1. How water runs 2. How fire burns 3. *How people make different versions of Bad Apple*

[@mintiistrqwberri5483]

Made on random things

[@emithelastidiot1817]

what about writing with led?

[@DritBail]

Is like the people that run DooM in everything that have a screen

[@hasanmuttaqin464]

damn, water in my country didn't run, it must be hard to live if the water runaway everytime you need it

[@hiiloveu1521]

If it's gonna be a rickroll then you failed, I love this song and I always vibe to it Edit: you have no power here

[@kotitaHanoi]

"You can play Doom on every device" Bad Apple: *Laugh in captions*

[@_ren777]

lol

[@MattStarzing]

lol

[@2chill2bbored72]

@@SebaCape55 well it’s not that possible.

[@annotated_]

playing bad apple on Doom

[@amquasi1907]

Caption: **laughs in captions**

[@霞谷]

fun fact: if you change the color of your subtitles in accessibility settings, it just looks cool af

[@heavenlydusk]

It does

[@deebayn1561]

holy crap it works, i never knew how bad i was at technology until you said this.

[@Azyne]

oh you're right it does

[@Zjznzzzzyzjsvzzbz]

Very cool thing.

[@chickenmanv7]

Mine's yellow.

[@Joe_Mama.also_YTHandlessuckass]

Imagine the person who didn't get the title and is just staring at a black screen

[@viniciusnishiyama704]

I almost didn't got, I stood for 10 seconds thinking what "captions" are lol

[@gdbigbuggygaming4791]

I have them on

[@zero_star3534]

Thats me

[@sleepyhead_toby]

You don't have to imagine I'm right here :')

[@viniciusnishiyama704]

@@sleepyhead_toby So, have you figured it out by now?

[@EpreTroll]

they keep finding ways to do this I love it

[@teraspeXt]

Verified comment with 0 replies and only 4 likes :thinking:

[@user-dz2om6cj7s]

@@teraspeXt i was thinking the same thing

[@pixxL_]

There's so much bad apples in my recommended. Next thing I know, I find a good apple. Edit: well well well I found it before it gets recommended to everyone kzbin.info/www/bejne/boKUp4FrZtRgesk

[@pixxL_]

@XxItzJiroxX It’s 5:53 pm for me rn, still the holidays

[@stevin9026]

oh hey its epretroll

[@Max0r]

excuse me

[@flyingpotato2521]

Didn’t expect to see you here Max0r

[@itsJegus]

Max why are you here?

[@pillow7554]

Max this concerns me

[@motomd19]

its fuckin Max0r. hi.

[@pascalghifar6932]

oh no

[@kaeudomt]

"wish i could turn off the lyrics, it's distracting me" turns off caption "oh wait"

[@koturoshi_]

POV: you've seen 60 fps text first time in a life.

[@zeddman]

it looks so smooth

[@NoName-kb3xe]

It’s like 5 FPS for me.

[@wenelol]

@@NoName-kb3xe Read the description

[@N.Nocturne]

@@NoName-kb3xe that's because you're on Apple. Use a browser to open the video

[@syawalhamidi]

It's my 2nd time, I've seen this kind of video from another video which also uploaded by the same person...

[@V4N9U15H.]

Finally, youtube captions are 100% accurate

[@SammyZu.]

Unless ur on phone it displays as 5 fps which is technically not accurate, cuz it doesnt display every frame.

[@steveluvscows2490]

I'm watching this on mobile, and it's at surprisingly high FPS.

[@BigBebOb7274]

Underrated

[@1unar_eclipse]

@@SammyZu. ios*, android's fine

[@Keshely]

Maybe because it's programmed and not automatic k

[@RinkuSonic41]

Those are Braille characters Imagine a blind person raving to this shit

[@iegendary-r8r]

Lmao

[@OrangeC7]

I'm gonna be disappointed if braille displays don't already exist

[@cyannbutler4100]

how would they--nevermind lol

[@genevie1998]

Blind people can hear though

[@RinkuSonic41]

@@genevie1998 i know dude it's a joke

[@carrrag]

He even put the lyrics alongside it, now that's dedication

[@LgdFanta]

would be way more understandable if it was English too but yeah

[@Kariyu101]

It's like, silky 60 FPS smooth too, this is so mesmerizing

[@yami7805]

Its 30 FPS

[@Exc4Iibur]

It's in 30 Mr PC gamer

[@Morgana95]

and now the person that is in every vtuber clip is here

[@smallcatgirl]

I see you also got recommended late

[@lordderpingtonII]

Got a whole inconsistent 7fps here

[@SeedOfLight0101]

"what app did you use to animate?" This guy: "English caption."

[@user-ve6ln8sc5h]

Lol

[@Mcford70]

The Japanese caption is better and clener

[@ItsHonski]

@@Mcford70 yeah

[@requiem165]

@@Mcford70 yh

[@kamikamieu]

In both ways you get jp captions anyway

[@sussyneet8463]

Fact: this is prolly the only video in KZbin that can be watched in HD with any quality.

[@Zharque]

Is it possible to become an animator youtuber where all your videos are just captions?

[@sussyneet8463]

@@Zharque probably, but it'll take a lot of time, skill and dedication to do it

[@doggo_woo]

@@sussyneet8463 or making a program that converts a black and white animation to KZbin caption dots

[@starlene_1696]

@@doggo_woo I think it uses Braille

[@lenoobxd]

@@starlene_1696 yes that’s a braille

[@raeofsunshine8377]

it is unbelievably funny to me that "touhou bad apple animation in an unexpected and time-consuming medium" is an entire genre

[@shatteredslime1593]

its like the doom of visual mediums

[@Khim_0129]

Oh my god... The saying is true. "If there is a screen, there is Bad Apple. If there isn't one, people will make their own".

[@enabledseal]

Life uh finds a way

[@quibblemellow]

-sun tzu

[@MisterSleep1123]

The rule 34 and 35 of touhou

[@emllxk709]

Isn't it like rule 86 of the internet?

[@culturedcrazygirl]

There’s another saying I heard “if there is two colors than there’s a bad apple”

[@thefunny9]

"what do you animate with" "youtube subtitles." "no i mean-" "Y O U T U B E S U B T I T L E S"

[@OriginalSniperLol]

@@RaiBlu10 who tf cares

[@Nauta_]

@@RaiBlu10 I bet he/she wont

[@SoccerballAnim]

@@Nauta_ what did they say?

[@Nauta_]

@@SoccerballAnim stolen comment

[@SoccerballAnim]

@@Nauta_ mmm

[@elizabeth5189]

Within the *"if it exists there is a bad apple version of it"* phenomenon this has to be the most weirdly impressive one I've seen yet.

[@shatteredcrystal0909]

Rule 34 all over again

[@verner3600]

I'm still waiting for bad apple on typewriter

[@josesaldana2624]

Rule 54

[@finger3030]

Rule 34.5 right here lads

[@fyretnt]

@@verner3600 if I get bored one day I’ll make that

[@deseoselasticos2349]

I just technically saw a black screen for 3 minutes

[@racoonu]

turn on youtube captions

[@deseoselasticos2349]

@@racoonu ik

[@racoonu]

@@deseoselasticos2349 wait did the subtitles show up

[@0_zsR]

Touhou rule: if a device exist, it can run Bad Apple

[@tudbut]

*object

[@renaiky2652]

something*

[@monicaaviee]

Anything*

[@lukalux5511]

TI (Texas instrument) 1800 calculator powered by potatoes

[@april5356]

Then could we play bad apple on a heart monitor

[@dheatlyblaze2846]

Cant believe only just now youtube recommended this

[@Endmoonyearsago]

Same

[@trollingnoobs8384]

Same

[@amethyst4578]

Same

[@XericIsNotMyName]

agreed

[@enneu]

SAME

[@Keokithederp]

Broke: can it run Doom? Woke: can it run Bad Apple?

[@aleksaaleksic4353]

Both are woke, honestly, this is incredible

[@RealRexRiplash]

Bespoke: Can DOOM run Bad Apple?

[@creeperdude3480]

@@RealRexRiplash someone has to mod that

[@KAT-bt5qg]

Bwoke: can it run both?

[@vytah]

@@RealRexRiplash The answer is yes, there's footage on KZbin.

[@LemonPlayzYT]

i love how the video is in the captions, but theres also captions underneath the video inside the captions

[@koza.]

dislikes are from people who couldn't turn their captions on

[@Kuribonker]

My samsung smart tv only have auto caption so i just open this on my smast frige.

[@taxisalad]

I normally hate the kinds of comments but that was pretty good ngl

[@bakirokunn]

@@Kuribonker bruh nonono i cant do it😱🌝😑

[@Nyxcodes]

This is actually insane

[@personifulsob2847]

Literally

[@springsuck12]

Fr

[@user-rw4vv7es9j]

Ikr

[@theelilac113]

Nyx, goddess of the night?

[@renytentoea657]

hell yeah

[@baguettegamer5313]

the sad truth is because the video itself contains no "visual activity" is probably why the youtube algorithm isnt picking it up.... this deserves to blow up EDIT: YE BOI IT BLEW UP

[@ItsHonski]

yeah

[@leoelbocchifan]

I think it's starting ti recomend to touhou fans but in a small scale

[@LyfeFPS]

@@idonated50jellybeanstothew56 sameee

[@teraspeXt]

KZbin algorithm is gonna wonder why I liked a video with a black screen

[@ishdx9374]

what about podcasts? they usually just have a static picture

[@avananana]

The framerate is scarily impressive honestly

[@hithere-lr2iv]

“ Turn on captions “ The *english* captions: - japanese - edit: im talking about the actual words in the caption, not the animation.

[@sorae42]

yeah its not translated

[@WhoTfAmI_HuH688]

captions: *english* english:

[@animesenpai1163]

Lucky for me I already memorized the English translation.

[@glossylucian6673]

Turn off the captions then you'll see why

[@siin_07]

English captions made it easier to view on Windows, see pinned comment

[@kaedekurosawa]

I can't imagine how long this must've taken to make...

[@znefas]

i like to think whoever made this is just a very talented programmer, i don't think it's even possible to get such a smooth result without a program to do it

[@OtterSou]

@@znefas Yes, I made a program that converts an image to Braille pattern and run it with each frame of Bad Apple to make a caption file.

[@znefas]

@@OtterSou that's pretty sick, which programming language did you use, and how did you approach it?

[@dennisunderscore]

I wanna know too!

[@OtterSou]

@@znefas Python

[@cheeseandrice107]

"The creativity is immeasurable and my day is made"

[@personifulsob2847]

YES

[@ghostquagsire985]

Lmao yes, also nice profil pic

[@kayagorzan]

Indeed

[@mazinga8600]

Yeah Also hi fellow Watamate

[@BlueMonkeXD]

People who don’t know how to read and didnt know to turn captions on: “????”

[@SunnieD_]

I can't wait for this to eventually be killed by some KZbin update in the next few years. smh

[@CanOfSpriteFoundInNewYearsEve]

Then I'm leaving this app

[@omgman5745]

Sounds about right

[@bradleypearl2986]

@@CanOfSpriteFoundInNewYearsEve Same here

[@NijikaAirConditioner]

they would probably remove youtube captions because only 10% of the people on youtube use them or something

[@catvapee]

@@NijikaAirConditioner lmao the silly youtube move that remove it

[@PrimoBambino]

this is the clearest 144p youtube clip I've ever watched. edit: thanks for the likes guys, but please calm down, I can't handle the notifications, I have a family too, please send help.

[@sihibrizi]

Lmao

[@zarballa517]

This is just mesmerizing

[@sihibrizi]

People who watch it on 4K 1080P : Why we still here... just to suffer

[@SanHydronoid]

Lmao true that

[@that_green_neko]

Way less than that, actually. The actual resolution of the image is 43x39.

[@usermanager8942]

this is what the blind people be listening to when the captions go: [MUSIC]

[@Marie-do1df]

Uh and braille? XD

[@The_OriX_LoL]

You mean, deaf?

[@Archimedes.5000]

Wait what

[@the_honored_one_06]

@@The_OriX_LoL no, they have brail keyboards....

[@The_OriX_LoL]

@@the_honored_one_06 I mean, blind can't read flat screens, deaf can read, to deaf related [music] captions meme.

[@JulianAntonioMendoza1]

I thought this was already pretty impressive until I went to the youtube website and realized that in the app everything is laggy

[@lustsans6362]

The words are synced with the music. Not only is it with the dots, but that extra detail is legendary

[@xnike9004]

yes

[@misirtere9836]

Hey, might as well if you're already updating the captions every single frame, right?

[@Eroornate]

Plus the words are actually the ones that in the song

[@sans5955]

This just happens to be how Japanese is: each character is one syllable, rather than English’s one sound. For example, the character む is “mo”. This means that it’s really easy to sync each character appearing with the music, because every time there’s a syllable (which in music also ends up being one note) you simply show the next character.

[@lustsans6362]

@@sans5955 fair

[@JDexpialidocious]

When subtitles have better animation than ex-arm

[@alfin9189]

Lmao

[@alfin9189]

I don't get it but lmaoo

[@laurinneff4304]

@@alfin9189 this winter, an anime called ex-arm came out, and it's all 3D animation (unlike the usual where it's mostly 2D with a few 3D scenes), and it looks like shit.

[@alfin9189]

@@laurinneff4304 it looks alright to me, kind of reminds me of Fire Emblem.

[@codenamepyro2350]

@@alfin9189 Ex-Arm, looks, ALRIGHT?

[@bronzebell]

People who dont have captions on: Whats going on

[@eriskhaos7311]

I HAVE captions on and don’t know what’s going on. Did someone change the captions or are they meant to be that?

[@eriskhaos7311]

OH

[@lazii5289]

People with captions on: You’re missing out the fun

[@Omegaloid]

Wait, you're supposed to turn on the captions?

[@_zaymoon]

@@Omegaloid LOL

[@FieryFue]

The talent of bad apple enjoyers scares me

[@ikeadjungelskog]

The fact that the caption acts as a visual and live lyrics Give this man a respect

[@littlestsnowy8177]

I am so STUPID. I had no idea that what I was viewing was from SUBTITLES. I realised after this comment once I removed them

[@loopolollipop775]

It has that many likes because it’s true

[@ikeadjungelskog]

@@iiiiiiiiiiiiiii3081 ok then

[@GabHowDoI]

I cant comprehend the fact that this is smoother than my computer

[@MegaNut6238]

Oof

[@blytical]

Oof

[@wheatleythe_bigmoron_1179]

F

[@otesunki]

oof

[@Trashcanvance]

So me

[@chimata21]

press F for people that turn off their cc thanks for the likes and replies comrades

[@lolsaw14]

F

[@ThatOneMalaysianGuy]

E

[@oksanamiller9830]

F

[@NadRK]

F

[@notmo.]

F

[@turkia6148]

Thank you, my blind brother finally can listen to Bad Apple🙏

[@ChickenTenderBender]

*I didn't even notice those WERE the captions until I turned them OFF-* THIS IS AMAZING OH MY GOD

[@Vi-ry4pi]

Me too😂 and it was amazing! They put a lot of hard wokr in making the caption! They need more appreciation!

[@-hollythekitsune-7086]

same like i have them on normally

[@averagebriarmain]

@@Vi-ry4pi its a program.

[@Aresydatch]

SAME

[@reandoessomething9933]

When the yt captions can animate better than you can: •~•

[@RightJackAtYa]

Don't worry, you'll get there someday

[@Kudosco59]

pain.

[@u-508]

I mean, that was me before I read the actual title so... yeah👁️👄👁️

[@gibupleb]

You misspelled most of us

[@supersto5459]

True

[@YangDoesAThingIDK]

"Guys im not getting it, its just music" ~someone who turned off captions

[@877toro_ch]

ﾊ?ﾁｮｯﾄﾏｯﾃﾁｮｯﾄﾏｯﾃ 天才ですか

[@mikono8280]

We have got the point that "Bad Apple" would litterally can made out of anything

[@Matteuze]

even an apple

[@mimis_jail]

even spit

[@seacrystal6189]

@@Matteuze Someone actually did that lol kzbin.info/www/bejne/qITMgJupfNyWf6s

[@_CrazyCatKitty_]

I can’t believe I just discovered the world of Bad Apple on anything but a screen. First I saw an apple, then Minecraft sheep, and now KZbin captions. I like this a lot

[@matrick2227]

join the rabbit hole of bad apple playing devices.

[@sihibrizi]

40 years later : Bad Apple but its played on your mind everytime you play the video

[@celceusiguess]

I saw it on a calculator once, it's pretty funny

[@tashanavarro3631]

Oh you are only at the tip of the iceberg hun

[@alistar5326]

..they did one in discord messages

[@RayMak]

We needed this

[@clovertea2979]

y e s

[@tekamaze]

y e s

[@dancingcorpses39]

y e s

[@lesbean7829]

y e s

[@ejej2305]

s e y

[@davidkristandio9208]

The only youtube video that doesn't matter what res you play with, what devices you use, it's will be the same

[@ultrio325]

the 2 horsemen of compatibility: DOOM and Bad apple

[@Kamirasu]

now to play bad apple in doom and doom in bad apple to make it go full circle

[@13thk]

@@Kamirasu play doom inside bad apple, and then play that inside doom or vice versa, and you get an infinite recursion

[@plantlinqq1789]

and their cousin, pokemon red blue n yellow LOL

[@goldenpig6453]

Bad Apple! but its in doom but its run on an atm

[@rhysbaker2595]

@@13thk emulate an emulation that copies the emulation files from the computer above so that you always run more emulations

[@TheEngieTF2]

Anything that has 2 colors: **exists** Bad Apple: *Reality can be whatever I want*

[@no_maidens4you]

*THAT ENGINEER IS A SP-* DED

[@the_real_kel]

Anything that's related to technology or has a screen: exists Doom: *Reality can be whatever I want*

[@verner3600]

Bad apple on a traffic light would be the peak of human bravery and intelligence.

[@Endmoonyearsago]

The subtitles must be changing like every second, this is epic

[@OtterSou]

30fps to be exact

[@Endmoonyearsago]

@@OtterSou Cool

[@zusukoriotomo]

wow

[@zusukoriotomo]

also wtf this comment is from ten years ago?

[@Quangzq]

@@zusukoriotomo it was from a day ago

[@Nekotine]

The transcript broke my KZbin compleatly until I reloaded it. 10/10!

[@ponpaerostar]

Fun fact : You can turn the video quality to 144p to avoid the lag.

[@GoldenKingDS]

Fun fact: i have it on 480p (maximum on my phone) and it goes at 60fps.

[@burushifudara]

@@GoldenKingDS the.. the video is on 360p

[@brotundwasser]

i wish there was a higher quslity

[@Keshely]

@@GoldenKingDS The video cant go on max than 360p Lol

[@KhezuOnYourScreen]

@@GoldenKingDS fun fact: You're a liar.

[@VincentVanJoYT]

**blind people reading this in braille** "This song is fire"

[@BakaTaco]

⠠⠹⠀⠎⠰⠛⠀⠊⠎⠀⠋⠊⠗⠑

[@troncis2940]

@@BakaTaco what

[@BakaTaco]

@@troncis2940 What are you, *not* blind?

[@troncis2940]

@@BakaTaco idk

[@SammyZu.]

You know they can just listen to the song right

[@Jasperlul]

Started from a guy carving bad apple onto an apple(or at least the first one i saw) to a guy who made bad apple with captions

[@cosmosisrose]

I don’t think that was the first

[@daleryanaldover6545]

I've seen many ways people have done Bad Apple and it is truly a masterpiece, each one of them

[@PopTap]

Bad apple but the lyrics describes what is happening, bad apple hdd drive / pc components thing , bad apple flash mob dance, bad apple on an apple , bad apple Minecraft, bad apple sans, bad Apple Music video by adridaus and musical ghost, bad apple discord messages, bad apple on ti-84 calculator, bad apple 3D animated colored, bad apple frame by frame drawing, bad apple ROBLOX usernames, bad apple metal edition, bad apple gacha life, bad apple nightcore, bad apple switching vocals, bad apple English dubs, bad apples miku, bad apples beat saber, bad piano public piano, like bruh why is there so many versions lol

[@dinganiphiri9711]

That was the first one I saw too

[@calicon00b77]

i love how you can see each individual frame with the transcript.

[@memegumin]

I don't even know captions can go that high

[@cupunculus]

You can even make the captions have color or have a different font, turn on the captions for Copycat from Gumi

[@gator_productions]

200

[@timezone6094]

@@cupunculus how?

[@mllosmusic]

you can make them cover the screen bc ive watched a video that did cover the screen with captions it was terrifying

[@queenelle81]

I recommend you guys to watch Aishite Aishite Aishite by Kikuo then turn on ENGLISH caption. Crazy, right? The more further the video, the more crazy the caption

[@waterman4633]

All jokes aside, this person is talented as fuck

[@cosmosisrose]

You’re allowed to say fuck on the internet

[@chrizze6542]

Nah. He used something where he converts pictures into brail. Just read one of the top comments he explained it.

[@chrizze6542]

On one of the replies

[@websitelink]

@@cosmosisrose and you can just not if you dont swear

[@Joe_Mama.also_YTHandlessuckass]

@@cosmosisrose KZbin has been kind of an a-hole lately and randomly just deletes some comments with specific words in them so it's much easier to just censor yourself sometimes

[@0xC2]

this is one of the most unique things ive found on this website

[@solarknight3942]

That is a very clever use of Braille. I hope it was fast and didn’t take like 5 years to make.

[@norukamo]

Blind people after reading the captions in braille: "why does Napoleon want to nuke East Asia?"

[@izperehoda]

>blind people >after reading Something doesn't add up

[@CosmosPandemonium]

@@izperehoda I mean, they can still read, via braille like this person said. •-•

[@Lifeisconfusingimlost]

@@izperehoda blind people can read braille

[@izperehoda]

But it's on a flat screen lol

[@goldenpig6453]

@@Lifeisconfusingimlost if blind people can't read braille then how come its designed for blind people? Checkmate atheists.

[@TheEngieTF2]

Nobody: Touhou fans: *My goals are beyond your understanding*

[@TARRSS]

Engineer gaming

[@HelterwithoutSkelter]

engineer gaming

[@hyacinth0001]

engineer gaming

[@trollingnoobs8384]

Engineer gaming

[@trollingnoobs8384]

Can confirmed

[@theblackmidi1383]

“So, what’s the resolution of your TV?” “Uhh, About 760fps of Captions.” “What” “What”

[@elatronion]

760fps

[@cosmosfacade8836]

760fps

[@lucio-ohs8828]

This comment makes no sense

[@N.Nocturne]

760fps

[@izzyd6894]

760fps

[@chrideefer]

This is CRAZY. How is this even possible?!

[@pinkocean310]

Touhou fans are really built different

[@trollingnoobs8384]

Congratulation i will add this video to my "Bad apple but playing on weirdest thing playlists"

[@BernkastelW1tch]

Can't believe you actually have a playlist for that

[@Sussyb3ka]

@@BernkastelW1tch ye he has cause im his friend >:)

[@poct13]

Thanks for the playlist)

[@god_of_dorayaki]

すげぇ…字幕でこんなに細かくアニメーション作れるんか…

[@subeana_okage]

細かく設定

[@1kachan]

努力の賜物やね

[@俺の夢記録チャンネル]

粒子レベルで細かい

[@Zambo_Animates]

それは奇妙です。彼らはどうやってそれを作ることができますか?

[@tomiy319]

最初どうゆうことだと思ったけど、字幕onにしたらびびったw

[@cryptologicalMystic]

How does this have less than a thousand views, holy shit

[@SamiTheAnxiousBean]

because youtube doesnt push/promote content that takes effort to make often

[@iplxel7888]

@@SamiTheAnxiousBean like smh why does a video that's 10-15 seconds long get more views than an actual video with actual effort put into it

[@GE-0530RN]

The views rose!!! Its getting its share of the algorithm!!! KZbin is promoting small accs now!!

[@floofysvoid9806]

@@GE-0530RN yeah but that was a week he posted comment

[@GE-0530RN]

@@floofysvoid9806 yep, im telling them and filling em in☆

[@arcturus-kun2701]

No matter which video quality you using now, this video will always run at the highest quality *Happy mobile data user noises

[@SigmaSyndicate]

You know, if you think about it, this is probably the first time Bad Apple has ever been done in Braille.

[@Sucullentbutter]

As a blind lerson i aprove the use of braille

[@jackdog06]

@@Sucullentbutter uhm….

[@normanclatcher]

@@jackdog06 did ge stutter?

[@jackdog06]

@@normanclatcher you’re right, I’m sorry.

[@shy.guy_]

@@Sucullentbutter as a blind person, i also approve the use of braille

[@Absbor]

that's a dedication i can't bring bc i'm impatient

[@mattm7220]

As someone who has created subtitles for series before, I truly admire the amount of sheer determination, willpower, time, effort that would have gone into timecoding the text to be fluid 30fps motion 🤯 I can imagine this must have taken literal months (if not a year or 2) to get perfectly synced to match the original video as perfectly as it does

[@bobssmith7524]

most likely a script, but still an impressive feat

[@hamzerpanzer]

It's definitely not frame by frame, there's probably some code behind it. Still impressive and even more impressive is that the captions go word by word

[@drippymissouri]

He probably uses a program to do it for him

[@AkshayShukla.]

you know, there's something called coding, which is used to make doing large amount of repetitive tasks easy.

[@fastlearner292]

The whole point of both bad apple and doom on stuff it's not supposed to be on is to use code and see how far you can push things. Yes you can animate this stuff (and some have animated this) but those are the exceptions

[@ananya4119]

Me: *turns off captions * The whole vid: *guess I’ll die*

[@oleevv]

10/10 animation here just look at this! * black * someone put so much effort into this!

[@denvertikky4088]

I thought it was just the lyrics Took me a bit to realize, and then I confirmed by turning off captions. I was surprised.

[@consumeproduct]

took me a second to realize that the captions is the video itself

[@dinonuggets755]

i like how without captions its just bad apple audio

[@UHCAKIPII]

字幕職人は限界まで極めるとこうなるんだなぁ すごすぎ

[@マイケル-マイケル]

俺だったら最初の一コマ作る前に失踪する

[@victorkazi8172]

相当時間かけただろうに えげつい

[@そけつ]

字幕職人あるある「プログラミングする」←強すぎ

[@maikha8963]

I can't even begin imagine what kind of unholy python code (if any) was involved into making this, THIS SHIT ROCKS

[@blacklight1000]

Agreed lmao

[@heelturn2]

i like to imagine they did this all by hand LOL

[@jesusanguian0]

That code is hidden in the darkest of places 💀

[@Kurtheoraizor]

"Noo! you can't make visual effects with captions only" "hee hee programming skills go beep boop"

[@raviedavieu]

(insert 1:30 sound effect here)

[@adriansookai]

It's just a bunch of dots though

[@zesty3353]

@@adriansookai the creator actually programmed a software to make this possible lol do you see how smooth it is? remember that captions don't usually move smoothly and require a bunch of frames to move as smoothly as in this video lol

[@adriansookai]

@@zesty3353 Oh I get it now lol

[@adriansookai]

@@zesty3353 I thought that was the video itself

[@voltsu]

I've captioned a few of my own videos, and holy shit this must've taken so long.

[@dustux]

He made a python script "Work smarter, not harder"

[@voltsu]

@@dustux i am infact a dumbass

[@calitreesweet]

this feels a lot better than other videos like this cause in other videos it feels like watching something prerecorded and just played back while here the whole thing is happening right in the captions which are processed locally so it feels a layer more closer to me.

[@calitreesweet]

love this video BTW ❤️

[@TheWeeklySlopYT]

Hey whats your instagram or discord? I like your pfp its so cute!

[@noo635]

dude's a predator 💀

[@anzion1037]

@@TheWeeklySlopYT ok

[@calitreesweet]

@@TheWeeklySlopYT ...

[@こぐみ-t4w]

これが字幕職人の最終形態か…

[@choco-3939]

普段何してるんだろうね…

[@MADE-IN-CHINA1949]

エグいてー

[@user-untiburiburi]

@@MATSUKO-BIGBOSS- 結構有名なやつだし急にどうしたんだよ

[@3度目の転生したら道路標]

これエグいスッゲーーー

[@シュタージ]

@@MATSUKO-BIGBOSS- 自動字幕に字幕職人潰されたってことか()

[@cllncl]

Blind people: ayo this beat is fire

[@ilikeyacutg69yearsago99]

Chotto a minute...

[@Megasaphire]

Yamete kudastop they'll hear you talking shit about them

[@eddrickwilbert7315]

@@Megasaphire Yeah! What if they see this joke and get offended?!

[@Megasaphire]

@@eddrickwilbert7315 shit I hope they won't see it

[@roleye]

69

[@nocad4759]

Imagine you got stomachache from writing caption for a single episode of your Faculty's talkshow. Then you go online to relax and find this.... Imma go to the hospital now @@

[@CrimCrim]

New rule: if it exists, there’s bad apple!! of it

[@akariscarlet4039]

rule 99

[@mrantler2310]

Soon it'll be made from comments

[@mimis_jail]

air

[@catmagedsproductions1998]

Rule 69420

[@justaperson15_78]

"why do I need the captions?" *turns them off* *confused screaming*

[@e_du]

exactly me when I first saw it

[@ishaanpandey]

Ikr

[@iliketurtles89-c6v]

Idiot

[@System64MC]

"Recommended: Mac, Android" Me on Linux seeing this perfectly fine:

[@crackzonemobile2264]

Android's kernel is based on Linux

[@sei_onmusic]

I’m on an iPad (Apple) - it’s pretty good.

[@offishelly]

@@sei_onmusic same

[@memorymimic]

Me on redmi: uh

[@N.Nocturne]

@@memorymimic Redmi is pretty much Android, ain't?

[@cqdiamondman1146]

Here when yt suggestions suggested this masterpiece to me.

[@zahrakeren123]

*Why youtube is recommending me master pieces.*

[@skysorcerer]

When the caption's FPS is higher than your PC can do

[@rinreborn7364]

I SWEAR TO GOD, THIS JUST GETTING CRAZIER AND CRAZIER. TOUHOU FANS ARE ALL GENIUS, I SWEAR TO GOD

[@3dscartridges]

not all people who made versions of bad apple actually play touhou lmao

[@SamsonTheMaid]

Not sure about "all' ._.

[@krishellenberg5715]

IM NOT A TOUHOU FAN, NEVER HEARD OF IT BEFORE THIS, I WANT TO DO ONE OF THESE BAD APPLE THINGS

[@Terasenai]

@@krishellenberg5715 good luck doing one thta hasnt been done yet

[@peika8324]

They are just like 4chan users, they got to many time on their hands. Nice

[@masaya9798]

今の今までこの作品の存在を知らなかった。すげぇ

[@istabbedpurotodeath]

This is insane! It's incredible that someone would spend their time making a literal 3 and a half minute animation in KZbin CAPTIONS.. Absoloutly amazing and i pay my full respects to this because it is so high quality! Love it!

[@rhaskia7807]

was mostly likely a script that would have done it, but still amazing regardless

[@suffering9481]

@@rhaskia7807 if they animated it themselves. Absolutely insane. If its a script, its still absolutely insane. After all, the script needs to made by someone and it takes alot of work to do that

[@sseulgistar]

@@suffering9481 yes! Even if it's a script it would take time, you will have to code everything and it will need some mathematics to sort everything out

[@NaThingSerious]

@@rhaskia7807 yeh, in the replies of another comment they said that they coded it in python to convert the image into braille

[@esprero]

agreed

[@IsaacFoster..]

People who didn't turn on captions : I see... Nothing...

[@ultrasuper6353]

Imagine some one who don't know English and Japanese just randomly click on this video and don't turn caption on.

[@keepyourshoesathedoor]

They’d get stuck in a rabbit hole.😭

[@statesecurityserviceoflith4783]

Nah they just would be vibin to music

[@garrelriper3764]

@@statesecurityserviceoflith4783 lol that's literally what I was gonna say

[@SirDella]

Hello fellow mdk fan

[@stevenparsoe7231]

Holy shit this looks so cool and so clever at the same time.