Bahco vs. SOG vs. Gerber (Folding Saw Review)

[@Patriot36]

Thank you! Will do, buddy! I appreciate you taking the time to watch.

[@susanpowell4684]

i just brought a bahco due to the good reviews it recieved....you have just told me i made a good choice ....thank you

[@SRpwr]

Its great to see a new vid from you Patriot! I always look forward to one of your reviews. Keep it up man!

[@cadrician]

I was almost out of breath just by watchin you cut! Lol! I did in the past use these kind of saw. But I switched for bigger ones, two hand operation and longer stroke, less time and energy saving. Of course more weight and bulk, but fits great in my systeme whit cold steel big blades. Mostly I change my line of taughts on these because I broke every single one I bought,so. Awesome review non the less, love it, very nice spot. Take care buddy.

[@Patriot36]

Very welcome! Thanks for taking the time buddy.

[@Cr0cket20]

great comparison of the three saws.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks Daniel! Different place that I typically shoot. The nice think about AZ is that we have so much public land that you can shoot just about anywhere you can find a dirt road. In the summertime, I prefer to head up to the pines! :)

[@Patriot36]

Hey, it's VP427!!! Thanks for your testimony of the PS30. I'll definitely have to check it out sometime! I had a Maxpedition Stacked MP5 Mag single pouch but I haven't seen it for a while. If I remember correctly, it held the Bacho but should would with the others as well.

[@GREY1551]

Great review as always! I would be curious to get your take on the Silky saws though. I'm looking forward to an updated EDC vid! Now get back to work on the large knives testing! ;-)

[@Boy777USA]

Thank you for video. I was thinking about Bahco, and now I definitely go for it.

[@Patriot36]

You got it! Since this video I've done a lot of work with Silky saws as well but I still prefer the Bahco as an outdooring, emergency, "bushcraft" saw.

[@schmanto313]

Great vid. I'm looking forward to the E.D.C. Backpack update.

[@WanderingBeast]

nice work, solid testing, any deer?

[@rennybarr]

I have the Gerber an it's a good saw. I also have a Silky Gomboy and is my daily carry as a carpenter and stays with me when camping or pruning around my property. Silkys are the Cadillac of saws. I like Dave Canterbury but think his reviews are biased to what he sells on his online shop. Becoming a Silky distributor is tough and margins for resellers are not great, so take that for what it's worth.

[@Patriot36]

Great saw! I own the 15" version. It simply falls into a different category other than "pocket folding saw" so it wasn't included in this line up. It's larger, heavier and more capable. In a backpacking role the pocket saw is usually all I like to carry.

[@Patriot36]

Yeah, just reviewed what I owned. Dave Canterbury mentioned that he's seen two of the Silky's fail at pathfinder events and is why he carries the Bahco. Other notable bloggers have mentioned tooth failures as well. I don't have an opinion but bahco is certainly preferred in the hunting and bushcraft circles.

[@n2dabloo]

I wanted a Silky, bought a Bahco. Have yet to get my hands on it. You did a great review. Thanks!

[@tonymengela]

you made a better choice

[@swibo6]

Nice review, very useful. Scenery reminds me of my backyard lol.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks buddy! No deer, mostly turkey and elk. They didn't make it onto this reel I guess.

[@Patriot36]

haha!! The desert is neat be even I get tired of it, especially when it's hot. This is the start of the nice time of the year though. Even at that, we've had a week of about 90F. Will do buddy....and thanks for the encouragement!

[@TennesseeSlim]

excellent video really enjoyed your information exactly what I was looking for.

[@Patriot36]

It makes me happy to know that it was helpful to someone. Thanks a bunch for watching Marshall!

[@TennesseeSlim]

I'm leaning towards a silky pocket boy but bahco is my runner up. is that Gerber the exchange a blade model?

[@vettepilot427]

Patriot, Thanks! I knew if anyone would know on the pouch, you would! The Stihl saw has a curved blade which gives more contact area and teeth for a given length. Also, the rubber grip sections and the rear quillion or bolster make it really positive in the hand during use. I'm sure that it's made by someone for Stihl but definitely give it a try if you have the chance.

[@thegreekanrican7533]

Another informative video by Patriot36, thanks for the review...

[@SZAPP68]

Nice video. What stock do you have on that rifle?

[@rachavya]

You make a good point. Also, I've GREAT respect for DaveC; his direct observations count for A LOT in my book. My leapt-to conclusion is based solely on personal tests of low-effort (i.e., low-calorie) cutting performance, head-to-head with the Bahco (curiously, my 1st saw, based on many positive reviews). Even if Silky saws outperform as cutters, it's critical to test their LONGEVITY when used per spec. I need to research tooth failures, their impact, weight of a spare blade, etc.

[@Danielshorsemanship]

Good video. Just wondering I am in Az. also and was wondering is this the same place you go to shoot cause it is real nice country if so where is it. Again good video I have to sog and it works good.

[@Patriot36]

haha! Yeah, this one was a little bit of work but I enjoyed it. I've got the larger saw's to but the smaller ones do everything I needs them to for a hiking application. At camp, I always use the larger saws. Man! I've broken a couple of coughland saws but never a decent one. You're a brute! :)

[@Patriot36]

Ok, sweet! I'll check them out formatC2! Thank you for the info!

[@Patriot36]

The silky looks okay but I've not used one. Dave Canterbury hates them because he's seen two Silky's break in his classes. "catastrophic blade failures" he says. Some other notable bloggers have also mentioned cracked blades or broken teeth. I don't have and oppinion and don't own one but I really question the design of the locking back. It's similar to the SOG and it proved to be a point of mild concern.

[@Patriot36]

I have the 15" and really like it. I usually can't justify carrying it due to the capabilities of the pocket saw. Kinda nice for backing into a base camp though AND if you have to routinely cut work greater than 3.5" in diameter.

[@CampfireTalk]

Most of the time I just use my teeth : ) Great review as always brother. Here in my camp I've been using folding saws for years (almost decades). I have a Sven saw & have used a sawvivor, but the folding saws for me are the most universal & my go to choice here in the south eastern US. If I'm setting up a base camp then I'll go for a big bow saw, but again that's a different set up. Rock on!

[@MaliciouslyCompliant]

"They do have different models. The one I'm talking about is "Fiskars 9564". I gave the pruner to Mom, and I've been using the saw since. I'm happy with it.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks Jim!

[@vettepilot427]

Patriot, excellent review as always. Thanks for taking the time to put this together. My personal favorite is the Stihl PS30 and I've used both the Gerber and the Bahco. It is my hands-down favorite in green wood. For dead, dry wood, the Bahco is a good choice. BTW, do you know of a good MOLLE sheath for these kinds of saws? Most General Purpose pouches are way too large and most mag pouches are too small. Thanks again!

[@CyberCacique1]

Great vid. I'm a big fan of the Bahco.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks man! AGP Arms stock and barrel.

[@Patriot36]

Yeah, it's a cheapy, but again, for light, occasional cutting, it seems to be fine. I've been using it for 8-10 years. After getting the Bahco, I've tasked the Gerber to a low priority car kit.

[@baseballman74]

thanks for the info. i will continue to watch your videos. thanks again~

[@quevoy6611]

Instead of timing each saw as you cut, try counting the strokes each saw needs to complete the cut. The ease of used. Which saw required the least effort to cut.

[@baseballman74]

hi~ many people prefer sawvior over others... what are your thoughts on this?

[@DiscoverTrails]

Would you consider a sawvivor and if so which model, 15in or the 18in?

[@graynightblue]

Have you tried the Sven Folding saw? It's the one I've been looking at.

[@questtrinity]

Have you used the silky saws? Silky probably makes the best folding saws they are well built.

[@rachavya]

Probably is a great review of the three you chose to evaluate. One drawback: didn't include the world's best (Silky).

[@jimmyggh1]

Great review! Thanks!

[@MaliciouslyCompliant]

Fiskars makes a good folding saw too. I think it's called the "Fiskars Softgrip PowerTooth ", and it isn't bad at all for ~$10. You can find it at home depot.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks brother!

[@fartunique]

Really enjoyed this review and kind of backs up my point as to why I brought the Bahco over other saws. Here in the UK we don't really have any native softwood, only have one native pine (Scots pine - rare down south) and one semi-native pine - The European larch (quiet uncommon) and one common but none native fir tree (Lawson cypress) So I think geography is worth taking into account when it comes to choosing a saw. And for those living in the UK are definitely better opting for a Bahco or a Silky.

[@cool_hand_luke97]

i wish you could live in the desert for a couple years make me a dvd then i would have something to watch every night love them camp outs keep it up when you can

[@Patriot36]

I saw them and almost picked one up. I looked at the amazon rating and it wasn't quite what I was hoping for. The price is ok if one doesn't need something perfect.

[@toddwilkinson9476]

good workout there patriot,good saws aswell,gerber doesnt seem to work good to good,definetley bahco and sog did a really good job.thank you for reviewing them,take care

[@Patriot36]

Yeah, except that your trees might be bigger, not sure. :) P.S. I mailed your package today. I caught the flu last week and completely forgot about it.

[@bg147]

I have one that has a laminated wood handle with Made in Sweden printed on the handle, but I have no idea who produced it.

[@Patriot36]

Thanks Cyber! Kinda hard not to be, right! :)

[@stgeorge6947]

I got an Irwin from home depot is that good for bushcraft? 😀

[@zebatkins2966]

The over extension on the sog is for dense or hardwood. You put the palm of your hand on the butt of the handle for a better bite.

[@apuuvah]

Thanks for this great review man! U from Texas ;-)

[@kuli557]

Cool vid dude.thanks

[@Patriot36]

Glad you liked it man! Thanks for watching!

[@tonymengela]

something to add to your saw kit is a small WD40 prevents binding as well as many other uses including starting fuel for fire if needed

[@stgeorge6947]

viberunner and never use wd40 on food prep tools 😂

[@floppinfish]

Right. Think man think.

[@JustaSimplefact]

The Gerber it looks like it is intended to be a pull cut saw exclusively. Silkies will also bend if you try to push cut with them.

[@WORRO]

Good video ma...I just got me a Bahco like the one you have here. Have not tested it, as it just got here a few hours ago. Anyway good vid bro, keep up the good work!~~John

[@Patriot36]

Thanks man! Yeah, it's a great little saw and I think you'll find it very handy.

[@WinStunSmith]

It seems like pretty much everyone agrees that the Bahco is one of the sturdier folding saws. And, most people seem to agree that the Silky line cuts considerably faster, but the blade is more likely to snap. I’m taking off on a cross country trek at the end of April. Im quite confident with my gear choices. But, I simply have no experience with folding saws. On one hand, using a Silky, I can except less effort, and burn fewer calories than I can using the Bahco for the same job. But, from the reviews I’ve seen, the blade is far more likely to break than the Bahco blade. I’m not terribly concerned about the trek between the east coast and Midwest. It’s so densely populated, I’d really have to work at getting myself into a sketchy situation. But, when I reach Kansas, I’m heading north. Most of the coniferous trees are pretty soft, but there will be times when I’m 3, even 4 days, from civilization. So, I don’t really want to leave anything to chance. Suggestions, from anyone, would be appreciated. Sub’d. 🤙

[@Patriot36]

Thanks Wingman! You'll have to feature that Sven saw on your channel if you haven't already!

[@Patriot36]

Your new nickname is JAWS! :) I've got my little 15" Sawviver but perhaps like you, can't really justify carrying it when these little pocket saws do 90% of what I would like them to do. I think it's a romantic idea to fell 10" trees, lumberjack style, in order to process but honestly there's usually a more efficient option ESPECIALLY in a "survival" or calorie critical scenario. I know I'm preaching to the quire though...lol. Peace brother. :)

[@wolfman011000]

Does anyone have any idea if it is possable to resharpen the saw blades ? Where i live it is cheaper to buy a new bahco or gerber complete new than the spare blades.

[@mcginty9200]

What size of teeth is your Laplander?

[@highonimmi]

nice video....drink lots of water when in a higher elevation to keep any headaches down...thanks for the info...I am thinking of a silky bigboy:) your video showed my that my preference for longer blades will help me saw easier....(I'm a chick) and to stay away from the short bladed gerber....thanks I was watching a dude named virtuovice sawing with a silky bb 360mm lg teeth. he cut about an 8" thick downed tree starting the process on his knees. about 1/2 way thru to 2/3's thru he positioned the blade past the straight one normally used. then he was able to stand and finish sawing the tree. I know I don't make sense but, if you watch the video you will get a huge "holy shit" moment. subbed

[@Patriot36]

Sure, Dave COULD be biased towards things he sells but having exchanged conversation with him over the years, I don't think he made up examples of gross blade failure during his pathfinder classes. He also sells titanium cups but will be the first to tell you it's not his thing. As mentioned, he wasn't the only source to bring up Silky QC but it doesn't mean it's not a decent saw. Personally, I just don't care for the top lock on any of these saws but don't have anything else against them.

[@190055joe]

What I have found is the quality of Bahco steel is amazing its almost indestructible from hacksaw blades to their long nose pliers.

[@bigbuck762]

Bahco I love it I just went out yesterday and cut a solid dead oak 7 inches around in 3 to 4 minutes I've also cut through pine trees with lots of Sapp no problem my fiance used it the other day for a project for our wedding and she said I want one so I guess I'm going to have to buy her one so she don't steal mine

[@Patriot36]

Wow...awesome! I haven't cut anything that large yet but kind of want to try that out. I figure that any woman who appreciates a good folding saw is a good catch! :) Thanks for the feedback.

[@MaximusPanin]

I bought Bahco.

[@bibleprophecy1st]

I think it's the Silky that also has that "overtravel" and it's for under cuts. You hold it with the teeth facing up and cut from the bottom of a branch. I had a gerber that broke. It split where the blade connects to the handle and it became useless. The Bahco I have is easier to cut with, and fits in my gerber pouch perfectly with two extra blades I bought at bensbackwoods.com for $12.00 apiece. I am now a Bahco fan when it comes to saws. Axes are a different story. I own a Wetterlings 19" small forest ax, or large hunters ax. And my larger ax is a Council Tool boys ax. My work horse saws are my 25" and 36" bow saw blades and I make an easy quick buck saw from materials in the woods and key rings for the holes in the ends.

[@paulie4x1]

Say Heah, The Wicked Tough Saw is prolly one of my Fav's folding saw in that size, But I have a Wooden Handle Fiskar's with the Power Teeth that holds its own in the Bush, not bad, , ,

[@WR3ND]

Bahco Laplander with their 396-JT replacement blade.

[@WR3ND]

And that way you have the other blade as a more durable but less efficient backup option.

[@paulie4x1]

Say Heah Patriot, I realize this is a older video. But I find a new sharp saw works pretty good regardless who makes it. The better ones last a little longer, you do get what you pay. But I find my Wooden Handle Fiskar Power Teeth Folding Saw is still working pretty good. I also think most blades are made with the same steel by the same saw blade maker IMHO.,,. p

[@Patriot36]

I agree with everything that you stated. The differences are small and not significant enough for me to complain about any saw of reasonable quality. Here's a slightly new video of the bahco and silky. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3vahqqjatahmrs Often, the differences only become apparent when you're using them side by side and you're actually using them to the point of being tired, which isn't the typical scenario.

[@anthonyknight1534]

the over travel is for cutting over head more less for pruning

[@FishinBoat119]

The bahco is amazing. The gerber is flat out a poor excuse of outdoor gear. Mine broke on the handle. It literally crumbled in my hand.

[@paulie4x1]

Hi Patriot, if you want a bomb proof folding saw, look no further, and do yourself a favore, and watch some video's on the Wicked Tough Saw, it's made by Wicked Tree Gear, I was almost ready to buy a Bahco Laplander, then I found the video on the Wicked Tough Saw, and no regrets, it's bomb proof, work's like a charm, and very tough too, made out of cast aluminum, it's probably the toughest saw made, but as far as cutting, it doesn't back seat to any other saw out there, life time warranty, tell's you right away, it's a professional quality saw, I bet if you check out the video's, you will be getting one too, have a Nice happy New Year.

[@MrHDChevy]

sog looks like it kicked ass very aggressive teeth

[@Patriot36]

Yeah, just reviewed what I owned. Dave Canterbury mentioned that he's seen two of the Silky's fail at pathfinder events and is why he carries the Bahco. Other notable bloggers have mentioned tooth failures as well. I don't have an opinion but bahco is certainly preferred in the hunting and bushcraft circles.