Barbie Extra VS LOL Surprise OMG! Doll Comparison & Review!

[@jdollies1971]

I think they’re good compared to other barbie products, but when you compare them to the competition like rainbow high that has 3x more quality for the same price they’re very inferior. And one of the factors that made this line a miss for me are the pixelated faces. No way they can compete with Mga looking like that. At least now that I see that so many people complain about it, maybe Mattel will hear us about the face quality, But it’s Mattel so it only tends to get worse.

[@bunny-eq5qe]

they definitely act as the competitor to rainbow high

[@michelleduval27]

Exactly. If they were a competitor with OMG LOL, it would be more about preferences. OMG has their downs and ups too. They dolls aren't everyone's taste but Rainbow high? I don't want to buy anything from Mattel after Rainbow High. MGA does a great dolls rn. Other companies make interesting dolls time to time. Barbie Extra? If I will buy them, I will buy them only on sales. I'm not ready to pay a full price for them. But I will probably prefer to get another doll by MGA

[@ALT-vz3jn]

Rainbow High has gone down a lot in quality; they no longer offer the second outfit and the hair is so thin and terrible now. I’m selling off a lot of my Rainbow high as I won’t be collecting them anymore. I like 18 inch dolls a lot more now.

[@joshuap7757]

Bratz are now Instagram doll models. Which I hope become actual dolls

[@Deeviiouss]

I’m from the future and their now doll

[@jdollies1971]

Personally, i like and appreciate that there’s at least effort and quality put into them, feels like a step in the right direction, but being completely honest, I don’t like the fact that Mattel copied the concept of LOL OMG without developing its own unique brand, and still has the nerve to put pixelated dolls in a line that’s supposed to compete with MGA, whose playline quality is better than all collector Barbies released in the last years. These don’t even come with stands!! It’s like Mattel copied LOL but forgot to incorporate the most important factors that made LOL OMG successful: Edge and Quality. Like they’re to afraid to risk more cohesive and fashionable designs, these feel very “Made for Karens”. The pets also feel very very out of place, it’s like they’re trying to appeal to everybody but lack cohesion and sense. They should’ve used the pet budget to fix the pixelated face paint that no one likes, and add a STAND. But thats only my opinion.

[@ubastiblack9558]

Yeah OMG dolls, they have unique and specific concept and you can easily differentiate them from another OMG doll. While the first 3 Barbie Extras just have garish and over-the-top fashion so they can be just somehow called Extra.

[@Weirdos22146]

Yes I agree bc as a collector you need a stand and not having a messy face for a doll

[@rickdeckard3692]

You couldn’t say it better, Mattel right now... SUCKS

[@geraldwilliams9504]

MGA just set the bar to high and Mattel cannot reach it

[@Tiffqrvst]

Facts OMG dolls have been rlly popular even rainbow high and I love omg dolls and Barbie is not as good she keeps trying and trying but she ISNT as popular and doesn’t rlly have personality like omg dolls and Barbie HASNT been able to compete lately DONT get me wrong Barbie isn’t that bad but cannot CANNOT compete

[@lalasarchive1]

I wish they hadn't copied so explicitly and wish they had decided to make the Extra line more unique to Mattel, because it feels like an LOL copycat.

[@stefdems5781]

The fact that each OMG girl has a unique personality and character whereas Barbie and her friends just have numbers is enough to convince me they didn’t put much thought into this line

[@barbatostea]

@@timepasstubee it's the truth don't be mad lmao

[@JackWetherill]

I love how the Barbie Extra dolls look. Especially the one with the furry rainbow jacket. I love the OMG! styles, but I just can't get on board with their faces 😩 I'll stick to Rainbow High for now

[@nomattel1254]

The Omg doll faces remind me of funko pops so it’s not that big of a deal for me

[@stephanieladeinde3224]

True

[@Dextertheimpawster]

I can’t stand their bug faces

[@barbiedolls3708]

@@Dextertheimpawster funko pops

[@nelliithebroskii1867]

I like that Mattel is doing something new but they should’ve chosen a different name🤦🏽‍♂️Even their theme songs are similar in a way...

[@kittymae335]

I often look at the outfits on OMGs and wish that I liked the actual dolls because they're clearly good quality, but I just don't like them xD

[@bobbysmith8095]

Same I really don't like LOL/OMG doll face. Hence why I prefer hairdorables cuz their face are just sooooo much better. Their outfit and concept are really cute though.

[@JeeMeeVee]

The head and eyes are just too big 😅

[@nomattel1254]

@@JeeMeeVee they remind me of funko pops

[@thegirlleastlikelyto]

I used to think that but then I got one and in person I just adore her. The faces remind me of Betty Boop.

[@em84c]

They are too cartoony for me.

[@judy5052]

I wish they ditched the pets and added more to the doll and include a stand and maybe I would of gotten one..

[@Tony-lv9op]

Barbie always gets better when she has competition with other dolls but when there is not other doll around the Barbie's quality is not good.

[@barbiedolls3708]

And Barbie extra flopped and there won’t be a series 2

[@machinedean]

Considering they're both in the same price range I'd say you get a much higher quality product with the LOL OMG's but it seems like Mattel is offering more a more 'modest' look with a familiar brand and possibly aiming for a younger demographic? Guessing by the addition of the pets.

[@cutelolpopvids530]

whoever designed their hair deserves a raise because that is the single reason i will be buying the extra. other than the articulation ofc !

[@melissarichard2168]

I prefer the OMG dolls. Happy to see Barbie not looking so cheap.

[@onlyalisaawilliams]

I purchased two of them “Afro puffs, & rainbow hair”, their cute, but Mattel skimped on quality. I agree with you Mattel bit off OMG, and their music videos. By the way, OMG music video’s completely slay Mattel’s, in the grown....Barbie was my first love, but hey , MGA’s killing the game.

[@flowermeerkat6827]

What I don't understand is that nobody mentions that the OMG doll's don't really have bending legs. I've had 5 of them and I still have two but all of them had "bend and snap" legs that didn't bend or snap! I think OMG gets a pass on quality by a lot of reviewers and I don't understand why. Is it the hype? Plus the OMGs all have the same face???!!! What's up with that?

[@STARONTOP292]

@@flowermeerkat6827 they don't have the same face, it's just the shape Most of the dolls I've seen have way different details like eyes downward instead of in the middle and makeup is different, but you can't judge because of the face think of the fashion and details

[@flowermeerkat6827]

@@STARONTOP292 to each his own. I’ve kept my Rosie the Riverter OMG because I liked her. I donated the rest to the charity shop so someone who loves them can have them. It makes life more interesting when we as doll collectors like different things.

[@shinigamikiro]

The shoes! I’m glad you pointed that out because it’s been bothering me since the promo pic came out. Barbie usually does one color shoes but it stands out and looks extra tacky when the doll is extra fashionable every where else.

[@AllenChibi]

Oh, i wish you had talked about monster high vs bratzillas too

[@tamasbalazs01]

Barbie should really bring back the fashion fever line from the 2000s and make it with recent fashion trends. I mean the quality and the attention to detail back when the first FF line came out was on point. If Mattel would bring back that quality and fashion forwardness, I think it would definitely sell.

[@WuffKawaii]

It's embarrassing that Mattel fell behind when there was no competition. Now that MGA took over the fashion doll market, they only now decided to release dolls with articulation and actual fashion. I still would like to find these new Extra dolls for sure, but I think for the price you still get more for your buck with the LOL OMG because of the quality and they come with stands and 2nd fashions for the most part.

[@Theofficialfanboy1492]

I’m new to Barbie’s so I’ve really enjoyed the Extra dolls. I think they are gorgeous.

[@BlakeGildaphish76]

Those are the EXACT two dolls that i want from the Extra line!

[@gabemexx]

The shoes are the Jeremy Scott lines I believe it was in 2012. They were made for Adidas

[@flora1496]

I'm also happy to see Barbie more detailed but as you said the O.M.G dolls have a more unique style, the Barbie's are just "extra" but not stylish... that's a shame, I would prefer something more "clear" because at the end they looks like more fashionable clowns to me, I can't relate the fashion clothes they wear. Barbie looks like she's going to a Music festival, but the other doll darker looks like she's going to the Gay Pride and at the same time to a Basketball Match... it's weeeird... if you wear a Rainbow jacket your clothes should have someting related to it to me, not sport... so wtf ? But the Extra doll I really hate is the pastel one, her "dress" is awful. If you wear pastel you're supposed to be cute not a "ghetto unicorn".... But I hope Mattel is going to improve the Extra dolls if they do more...

[@melm9769]

The Barbies remind me of the '90's aesthetic big time.

[@Deimos985]

The black Barbie Extra's plastic legs are shiny from hip to half thigh then they become opaque: why???

[@BrookeRyde]

i noticed that too! wtf is up with that??

[@Alagboriel]

So, we are getting Jem and the Holograms x Barbie and the Rockers all over again.

[@WayGaijin]

Takara has come out with a Licca doll that is clearly inspired by the OMG dolls as well. Seems to be the trendy thing to do! I love that Barbie finally has some good quality in a play line doll. I think I’ll actually pick up a few of these. Thanks for the review!

[@vittoriopiorosariosavasta7590]

I appreciate the fact that Mattel has raised the quality a bit, but the pixelated faces convinced me not to buy EXTRA dolls, and then if they wanted to compete with OMG they had to replace the pets with a stand I’m agree with you, I prefer OMG too, because every doll have a unique, specific look, and this makes them more cool, and their quality is simply TOP I don’t intend to consider Mattel again until the ENTIRE playline returns to the quality of the past Today I bought a Barbie Color Reveal Mermaid, which will be my last Barbie because from now on i will only buy MGA dolls

[@jomiguel5113]

Extra Extra like, O.M.G. i love when people are looking at me...

[@VeronicaStorm98]

I feel that the inclusion of the pets and the accessories not being in surprise packaging are more unique to Mattel. I don't like how you cannot tell the quality of the hair or the face ups of the OMG dolls from the outside of the box and risk ending up with a doll with slightly wonky eyes, or choppily cut bangs. I also feel that the Hairdorables Hairmazing dolls copied OMG more directly, as those also have the boxes that turn into play sets/backdrops as well as the accessories packaged in blind boxes/bags. The Barbie Extra dolls, other than the packaging and inclusion on pets, do kind of feel like imitators though. OMG is the original and feels much edgier with the clothing and quality which makes them better in my opinion. But it's nice to see Barbie come out with quality dolls and fashions again. If the success of this line makes them end the era of molded on tops/painted on tights, and sewn together clothes with their dolls, I'll be happy.

[@Tiffqrvst]

Personally there fashion or quality isn’t as good but I do agree that Barbie did step up at least

[@weaponman3872]

So great to see an objective comparison of these!! I like Barbie because she's classic but the OMGs are so fun to collect and mix and match with. Fantastic video.

[@walterrjamess]

In my opinion there is a bit of comparison BUT the omg dolls have WAY too much details to compete w Barbie extra. Mattel tried but it didn’t workout, too bad cuz Mattel all what it wants it’s just the money and MGA listens to the people and it gives what we want which AWESOME.

[@bunny-eq5qe]

u made rly good points about raising the bar for barbie extra dolls!

[@rexbesong2157]

Im Glad Mattel is stepping Up their Game and going in the right direction this Line gives me birds of prey Harley Quinn vibez i Love both btw and dont think mga ows extra fashion Just Like Mattel didnt own the goth asthetic hence why bratzillas exsisted History is kinda repreeting itself with Barbie extra

[@Weirdos22146]

Whelp let's hope their history with court don't repeat itself

[@matthewomalley8990]

I agree I feel like the lol OMG surprise big sisters have more detail and Barbie absolutely agree 😍

[@mawana8478]

Mattel has been so lazy this year so much Barbie needs to step up there game right now honey!

[@MichelleJune]

I love how the barbie doll has a ring pop

[@Weirdos22146]

I'm not a huge fan of barbie extra dolls and I do like the lol omg dolls a little bit better idk I've always felt mga did a better job in recent years

[@myfab_dollserika4326]

I got the Barbie extra #3 She’s soo awesome.. love her.

[@marlenevilchez547]

In my opinion the extra Barbie dolls look like clowns.The clothes just look tacky to me.

[@Tiffqrvst]

Same to me lol surprise omg dolls have fashion to and I feel there not as “childish” this is my opinion

[@swansparadise]

Despite knowing that Rainbow High and OMG dolls are much higher quality, I can’t get behind them. I love the proportions of Barbie and how many different face molds there are. The OMG/RH faces just aren’t my taste, OMG in particular makes me a little uncomfortable bc their cartoony/childish faces contrast harshly with their mature body shape and weirdly detailed hands. RH dolls have a very vacant stare and their faces in profile are so flat it looks horrible imo. In terms of fashion, I think OMG has wonderful quality and really fun/unique clothing. RH is a lot less inspired and a lot of the dolls already feel like their style is too similar to each other. I also think having everything branded with RH and Sparkle is a little tacky. It’s true that Barbie is copying OMG but MGA’s lines also take HEAVY inspiration from specific brands and celebrities. I am happy though that Mattel is getting some competition to encourage them to branch out and up their quality.

[@mohdhanif4209]

When i first saw Barbie i thought The one with pink jacket has pink hair but actully pink and blonde

[@nyreewashington439]

I like Barbie dolls they were queens when they were first made and I love Barbie dolls so much

[@jordanjohncarloj.8878]

The fact that even rip off dolls don't have pixelated faces shows how mattel is so inferior against MGA!!

[@michaelmcgee8543]

Back in the fifties the Cissy doll was controversial because it was the first doll that had a adult women's body.

[@kevinflaherty2704]

Omg Dolls are unique but unfortunately I just hate their big overemphasise eyes and their heads are just a bit too big and to be honest I prefer a slightly more prettier doll but I do love their outfits and attention to detail I’ve always loved Bobby but have slightly gone off of her because of the lack of quality so I’m really liking what they have done with this dollline was really disappointed that rainbow high have the same overemphasised heads and eyes just a bit bored with that type of cartoon look wish that son something completely different but still love the quality and the design of the doll

[@queenmoreau2098]

I agree. The OMG Dolls are cute, but they're a little too cartoony for me. If we had their style and quality for the Barbie Fashionistas, I'd have it made.

[@lilac5877]

I want more Joey s Luca on isolation videos. They were so funny

[@sunidollfun]

I hope the Barbie Extra dolls do well, too and we see more funky fashions and articulation at a reasonable price. I haven't unboxed mine yet. Crossing my fingers that their hair is going to be ok.

[@antonyetta-]

My opinion is that Barbie (Matel) try be cool and "EXTRA" but never go to far so other dolls company came and go above and beyond .

[@darrellwallace8491]

I completely agree with you all the way!!! I, like you, am very happy that Barbie (Mattel) is taking the hint from the fantastic-ness of the OMG dolls and making better Barbie's. The "EXTRA" dolls are a definite step in the right direction. The dolls are in and of them selves wonderful, with body articulation and the wonderful hair is cool styles and fantasy color's and I like the different body types! Great review from you as always. Please keep up the excellent work!

[@Fairy.Oncieee]

Lol surprise omg is way better

[@lyn100]

i'm biased bc i've collected them all, but i ADORE omgs so much!! i like to think of them as 3d fashion illustrations, where they're super conceptual and unique. i've yet to find one i don't like tbh

[@benjaminanonymous8593]

Mattel definitely copied MGA, I still love you Mattel

[@porfiriodiazcarrillo7551]

i've been, recently, start to collect vintage Barbie dolls ( i manage to get the 1990's holyday barbie!!!) and omg!! the quality was off the charts!!! the hair, the fashion, the shoes!! why they can't back to that?? they can, since they re-releaze a few years ago the Totally Hair Barbie, the most saled Barbie ever!! they should analize why there is a boom nowadays for the vintage dolls and translate it to the new millenium.

[@OnePieceConnitopi]

Mattel really steal Ideas from mga, because they want to be successful. But Mattel clearly lost interest in Monster High and Ever After High, which were the most popular and detailed dolls around this time.

[@Lichtspuren]

You should try Integrity Toys dolls... they’re addictive! 😍

[@sophiaclarisseflormata3597]

The fact is ...i love the omg dolls 😍😍😍😍

[@Sara-nc1xd]

Barbie should go back to their marketing from the 60s with some core dolls and then selling high quality fashion packs and leave these ultra modern fashion dolls to MGA with OMG and Bratz.

[@Jessica-ml6td]

Love the rainbow fur jacket

[@vanessamccreadie6429]

🎆🎇😘🎈🤦🏻‍♀️🎄❎🎇😘🎈🤦🏻‍♀️🎄🎄😴 I love your Barbie doll extra and lol OMG dolls

[@abromeroba]

And speaking of objectivity I love so much how objective you are in your videos. I hate the very low quality that Mattel has being given this last years too, so disappointing. Love ya

[@stephaniemcphearghuis2124]

I have one lol OMG doll. I love her but Barbie is my first passion. ❤️ I love the extra line outfits. I enjoy your vids very much. Thank you for making me smile. 😀

[@stupidhead7993]

Barbie extra for me

[@12Tecpatl]

I liked this review but the editing on the music video part gave me a seizure

[@Iheartreviewingstuff]

I love both - I really like Doll 4 & 5 for Barbie Extra - I did collect doll 3. Omg dolls sometimes the $34.99 US price is expensive to collect even $26.99 considering they charge $26.99 for Rainbow High but you get 2 looks I sometimes wonder why omg costs the same as Rainbow High. I also wish omg dolls weren’t blind since they can be quality issues. 👍👍👍

[@noradennis4361]

I liked what you did to the Barbie Extra #1 with her braids around her buns. It looks better that way in my humble opinion. 🙂 I intend to get the dolls, hopefully. Usually by the time I can get them there way out of my price range.

[@matheusmedeirossilverio6630]

I want to have a friend like you 😭😭 i play Barbie alone

[@dollelectrique8436]

barbie extra definitely doesn't come close to OMG but they are still really nice and a step in the right direction and i will probably be purchasing one

[@keithvanallsburg4848]

Lol dolls are better cuz I don't get them a lot

[@zaneidaos8012]

Сomment not in topic: I wonder, why after Novi Stars no one create alien dolls??

[@timeladyxx]

“and you know what they say about the bigger the hoop” JOEYYYYY🤣

[@sprinklesplash810]

I don’t like Barbie Extra but if it means she will stop having awful quality, I will support the line!!!

[@dimetrebucknal9644]

Wait didn't mga ripped off monster high

[@jeffbrave8678]

No bratzillaz were witches and monster high were monsters so they weren't copy of eachother

[@tohplayer727]

My sis LOVED her brats plz notice me!

[@olliesdollies7832]

I like the quality of the MGA products. I wish they would revisit the America's Next Top Model doll line.

[@haruhiprince1127]

i heard they arent gonna revive that due to contoversy and body image issues and theydont wanna accosiate witht the show anymore unless ur talking about the teen top model becasue thats amazing and i think they do reprouctions of those

[@ちもちも-f7p]

R u not gonna buy blue hair black Barbie girl one of extra?

[@jennierose3781]

For me the Rainbow High Dolls are just the Best! I also love the Lol Omg Dolls & have bought many, Barbie Dolls have really lost their way recently sadly :-( now though I am so pleased to see & buy The Barbie Extra Dolls as they really are a breath of fresh air, the Wing Boots are super! the Jeans frill is so brilliant sorry BIAB to disagree , just the price £29.99 (uk) for the Extra Line is a tad pricey in my opinion. Love your Videos Thanks.

[@Jessica-ml6td]

I still prefer the OMG dolls they are high quality. I feel that Mattel had their chance. I remember when even the basic Barbies were poseable and had nice hair.

[@Tailscutie123]

I feel like the barbie extra dolls are TOO extra, they wanted to throw everything and every color on those dolls but none of the pieces are cohesive. Like they put on everything in their closet as opposed to the omg's whos designs have a clear theme..idk I think the current barbie designers need to be fired because they don't know anything about fashion

[@keyg5429]

I really like what they did with the Barbie Extra dolls. I think this is a step in the right direction if they continue with this kind of quality and make it better. But at the same time I know what I can get for the same price with the lol omg. So I like Barbie extra and I’m happy they made them but I feel they still have a long way to go. Thank you for doing this video. I’ve been watching your videos for a while and you’re a part of the reason I got back into doll collecting this year!

[@notslick.2729]

I have two omg lol dolls

[@fnaf__3ditz158]

OMG DOLLS IS THE WINNERS REEE BECAUSE THE OMG, LOL SURPRISE ARE THE BEST THEIR ARE SO COOL, 2 ITS THE BRATZ AND OF COURSE 3 ARE THE BABRIE :P

[@SailorMoonFan92]

Nothing original about Barbie. The original Barbie was a clone of a German doll called Bild Lili. In the 80's in response to Hasbro's Jem and the Holograms dolls, Mattel came out with Barbie and the Rockers. In the 90s Disney Princess dolls (which would later be made by Mattel) were becoming popular so Mattel came out with a lot of Fairy tale themed Barbies. In the 2000's they came out with MyScene to take on Bratz and now Barbie Extra has come out to compete with the LOL OMG dolls.

[@glamgecko2281]

😍OMG dolls are the 1st who came out and show there very own unique style , and original personality based on how they style themselves 💕😘💕🥰😍 O.M.G dolls don't make us all disappointed 💖✨ everytime MGA present they new dolls it's very beautiful , very high quality, unique ,and so original 🥰💖💕✨MGA entertainment, BRATZ ,LALALOOPSY , OMG & RAINBOW HIGH are the BEST , ICONIC , & TRENDY😘💖💕✨

[@sunidollfun]

I love Lalaloopsy. Do they still make them?

[@latishaanderson5891]

I think the omg is the original bratz doll just with different styles and body

[@jhonlloydbergado49]

I really love your dolls 😊😊

[@DannyoffireAwaken]

*Parents are upset about OMG dolls* I have 4 daughters, and they all want OMG dolls. *I have every OMG doll made*

[@theNuMrsKL]

I love both! I also really like the oh my wow music video🥰 Enjoying your opinions!

[@JArkeder]

I love Extra's line and They are amazing with quality clothes! I hope Mattel makes another extra wave 2 new dolls! I've been collecting Lol OMG dolls, Bratz dolls, Rainbow High dolls, Fashion Royalty dolls, Monster High dolls, 80's & 90's and 2000's Barbie dolls, and collector Barbie dolls since, and now I'm collecting Extra dolls!❤🙂

[@nikim6986]

I love omg dolls but some of their fashions could be too much for kids so i understand why parents would be concern about them. Good thing is there are so many options to choose. Love them 👍

[@stephanieladeinde3224]

Love omg 💕 dolls and now Barbie needs to stop raining on omg parade..I forever love Barbie but that attitude isn't supported by me

[@houseofvanity8]

Wait a minute....is it the same girl singing in both music videos...or do they just sound the same?

[@DollzBeLike]

My 8 year old daughter is angry that Barbie copied Lol Omgs video, lmao. I told her that maybe they were inspired and were paying homage to LOL OMG dolls. It doesn't matter why to me, as long as we get affordable, articulated, and stylish barbies. :)

[@staycgirlsitsgoingdown]

the way people saying omg dolls have competition now. definitely not. barbie still is trash 😻💕

[@staycgirlsitsgoingdown]

@Love Barbie 💖 never ❤️

[@staycgirlsitsgoingdown]

@Love Barbie 💖 barbie no longer has quality and the only good thing they do is give us diversity 💀 took them 30 years to start it tho.

[@staycgirlsitsgoingdown]

@Love Barbie 💖 printed on fabric isn’t quality lol barbie is just the definition of a bimbo person.

[@poshbarbieboi]

So, the OMG dolls are NOT original. Their style and aesthetic were stolen from an artist called Tassel Fairy. She is in a lawsuit with MGA over them stealing her looks from her Instagram profile.

[@haruhiprince1127]

i think it is original they might have copied one look but not the rest

[@poshbarbieboi]

@@haruhiprince1127 nope, several of her looks were replicated on the dolls

[@lynneweir5842]

loved the Bratz as a child, would love to collect them all again as an adult. But couldn't get into OMG. I hope they bring back Bratz, I especially loved their small dolls.

[@novepipps]

I kinda want to see the fluffy coat that you wear to festivals! 🌞

[@TheChocoDoll]

LET THEM FIGHT.. just brings out better stuff for us consumers haha

[@colehotwheelschannel1260]

Barbie doll I like more

[@michaelmcgee8543]

I heard that Brats might make a come back.

[@Radiospossessor]

I still like OMG dolls a lot more, this line just feels a rip off. Mattel is very late to the party.