Barstool Pizza Review - Casaletto Pizzeria (Sleepy Hollow, NY) presented by Curve

Dave's trip through the Legend of Sleepy Hollow gets extended after walking by a new pizza place.
Go to curve.com/bars... to receive $20 in Curve Cash once you've downloaded the app, opened an account and made your first transaction
Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: onebite.app/do...
Follow on Instagram: / stoolpresidente
Follow on Twitter: / stoolpresidente
Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
Follow Barstool Sports here:
Facebook: / barstoolsports
Twitter: / barstoolsports
Instagram: / barstoolsports

[@Space_Gauche]

That pizza had 7.4 written all over it.

[@vincentfalcone9218]

That's what I guessed

[@jpablo700]

@@vincentfalcone9218 same. That's three of us for sure so definitely a trend.

[@kda9456]

Maake that 4

[@chrisphallheatlover9848]

7,4 is more fair in my opinion

[@kdenishere]

Yep thats the score I had in my head too

[@Nighthawkforever147]

That slice looked like a perfect “it’s lunchtime, I want a quick slice”.

[@BurntFishy]

Man this looker way better than a 7.1. Reheated or not that looked like a quality slice.

[@chrisphallheatlover9848]

I was thinking the same

[@InDisskyS131]

I’d say 6.8-7.1 Looks like a typical semi decent slice. I’ve seen better slices at state fairs…

[@ericnstuff]

That's the most 7.1 pizza to ever 7.1, let's be real.

[@yourface3154]

@@ericnstuff Steve knows the rules.

[@tacobell8764]

I agree that slice yes looked good like a football pizza but had zero flop , nice crisp and was reheated so thats a 7.4

[@charlesrocks]

All American pizza slices with bonus garlic bread. What a world.

[@TheGlassbro]

*garlic knot

[@thegoldrobber]

@Daniel Hollingsworth That's pizza-pie technician to you, buddy

[@MidiPunk]

@@danielhollingsworth3701 They're lookin like 'should we call the cops now or wait'.

[@FlySoto]

@Daniel Hollingsworth i wonder what part of Europe he's from

[@TheBrownSys]

@@danielhollingsworth3701 That's how you know it's good.

[@mikeb2430]

GO STEVE GO!!! One Steve everyone knows the rules!

[@mrkitty6078]

😆

[@michaelsokolis6376]

Getting old

[@mikeb2430]

@@michaelsokolis6376 you're old

[@michaelsokolis6376]

You right playa.. I'm 33 with a bad back

[@mikeb2430]

@@michaelsokolis6376 boom, roasted.

[@CarmineTavernaPhotography]

Dave, your Left shoulder went up during taste chew..7.1...nailed it

[@shakomilorava154]

One bite, everybody knows he's real name is Steve. Let's go Steve!!!

[@surfboard396]

Steve is his name when he hands out shit scores.

[@surfboard396]

That score was higher.

[@avilionstars]

That joint used to be owned by an italian family a few years ago, it was called fleetwood and it was easily in the 9’s. Place has never been the same since

[@coldcrush9]

"Support the new guy if you want." Pizza sales just plummeted

[@wombat5252]

Let's just support Biden. Trump was a better choice.

[@jpablo700]

@@wombat5252 yes. He won because he's not the other guy. Not because people like him.

[@jonv1776]

@@wombat5252 hahahahahahahahaha

[@BaronBacon]

@@wombat5252 They're both trash. Open your mind and see the puppets dancing for the puppeteers (the super rich)

[@MrJEM13]

Another great review Steve

[@nicholeannjeremy621]

Dave your a part of y i want pizza at min 1ce a frikn week. These vids help me never 4get "the" rules. Grew up on it from east 2west. Thanks much my dude.

[@dreichert1438]

Honestly looked a little better than a seven one

[@nighthawk0077]

Plain cheese usually looks boring.

[@dreichert1438]

@@nighthawk0077 completely agree but that's what the man likes and always judges

[@tchombre1992]

I agree. He always says "you have to take into account when we don't get the full pie".... Do I take that into account of does he?! lol. I feel like if he chooses to get a slice he should take into the score if it doesn't seem 100% fresh out the oven. That looked/ sounded mid-high 7's at worst.

[@wombat5252]

@@tchombre1992 Definitely not in the 8's. Looked closer to a 7.5 or 7.6.

[@Entroxity]

its not scored on looks buddy

[@BelowAverageMan]

this was a decent review. keep it up you may have a future in pizza reviews!

[@schucker88]

this was a decent comment. keep it up you may have a future in youtube comments!

[@J_Nicks]

Great review steve

[@Evebr]

Mr. Dave , ty for helping out so many businesses. You are a God-send.. or whatever u call it.

[@surfboard396]

He can also break a place with a bad score cause it’s not his style or they piss him off.

[@cannonfodder15]

Dave was gone for 3 days. Thought he was passed out in a ditch somewhere after a crazy coke filled night!

[@mbuckholz]

No he's been hiding from Alex stein

[@calvinbaII]

@@mbuckholz qrd?

[@TeeterTuckin]

No reviews on the weekends

[@lancefromohio]

Tossing the review on the garlic knot was a class act. TELL EM STEVEDAVE. Somebody get that reference pls.

[@surfboard396]

He did toss the knot , at the guys head.

[@monicabrandt6234]

Your grind while being rich is why I subscribed! Dave try Brunis in Hammonton, NJ. I grew up there and travel from Pa when I go to the shore. Original owners past, but they represent my childhood, right AC expressway.

[@jeffreymacintyre2711]

sitting in the back of a top of line SUV and stopping for pizza is grinding??? Wow! I'll take that job!

[@DJCISCO1119]

You guys have to go to Quatros in Carbondale IL,!!!!!!!!!! How do I get you guys to try it!? Lol

[@iliketocomment8144]

Dave will never fall asleep in Sleepy Hollow because of all lines of cocaine he does off camera. A couple bumps, everybody knows the rules.

[@InDisskyS131]

Dave?

[@briannickel6813]

@@InDisskyS131 Yeah Dave, he's a coke head and flying hi during this clip!

[@InDisskyS131]

@@briannickel6813 I’m sure it’s Steve…..

[@magnomnz]

Steve doing another solid review

[@davidpowell9770]

Steve absolutely fucking blasted. Everyone knows the rules

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@lukecasio9810]

How high is Dave? That slice looks like mall food court pizza 😆

[@adolf-8834]

It's official Steve comes out every time after a couple of pops

[@jadenbyrns783]

For only being 3 months old it's pretty impressive getting a 7-1

[@WRKellogg]

2:01 perfect crunch

[@tristancharbonneau5241]

Good reviews as usual

[@kinggzz]

sounded great! wish they had a spot down here in southern ky.... 😁

[@brucehutch5419]

The Headless Pizza Man lurking around Sleepy Hollow.

[@justinherbert9146]

When you order a whole pizza pie the pizza is better then when you buy it by the slice. We have two favorite pizza places in our area and when we order the pie for take out it is far more substantial, generous on the ingredients - then when you buy it by the slice from the same pizzeria.

[@VanValdenburg]

"than"

[@surfboard396]

Some places make slice pies and are not quite the same as a whole to go pie.

[@BajaB]

My father lives in Sleepy Hollow.. going to all the wrong pizza spots lol

[@EJCTV_]

I said 7.1 in my head

[@sandwichgode]

He needs to start interviewing calzones. Its like an evolved version of a pizza.

[@eric_in_florida]

yes they have a lot to say

[@mierezsaturday1452]

Balancing a garlic knot 9.1

[@diamondjosh6631]

I get so hungry watching these videos

[@srsieg1155]

Steve, you’re the man.

[@TomWatsonB1]

Dave has no idea who Washington Irving is. Everybody knows the rules.

[@timetowakeup6302]

The girl who appears at 1:06 knew exactly who Dave was and wanted the tossed salad on the side instead of the garlic knot....Everybody knows the rules!

[@johntrueconservative2547]

Nice She looks cute Is she receiving the tossed salad or making the tossed salad Either way Count me in 😊😊

[@MrEvannelson]

Next time you’re in Los Angeles you have to go to “Tomato Pie Pizza Joint” in South Pasadena.

[@Oh_You_Know_]

For a bigger slice like that to have that much crisp... pretty respectable!

[@surfboard396]

Yeah, should have a higher score. Looked like pretty good pizza, something of a neighborhood go to.Have a good holiday.

[@louiem2]

One slice that didn't look crispy but had the crunch, everybody knows the rules

[@avalon449]

You’re all over the place with your scoring now. Thick, flop gets a 7.7 the other day and now crisp, no flop gets a 7.1……

[@Speculite]

I love how the people inside were trying to see if you like it or not lol.

[@JDubs518]

This dude hasn’t given out less than a 7 since business insider.

[@katjerouac]

Steve is on a roll right now

[@bigeazy3852]

Also gave me a bonus garlic knot and moments later, well we’re not gonna score that lol

[@michaeldallen234]

One scoreless garlic knot everyone knows the rules

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@surfboard396]

He probably whipped that knot at the guy.

[@Ryan_Owens]

Dave you gotta go a size up on the fitted hat. Will fit better and look better. Love the videos.

[@michaelarnold838]

Fire the jamoke that gave Dave a cold garlic knot...

[@SMAC-wv5rw]

The horse-less headman

[@benjaminjudge6232]

Nice Choo-Choo hat Steve 🚂

[@audibertcubahiro8443]

✌🏾one bite every one knows the rules Steve

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@trollingisasport]

LOL The first place in the background had the leg lamp from A Christmas Story

[@SushiBandit28]

You can always tell when Dave is under pressure by someone in the crowd

[@shaneoleary9919]

Raven amazing video pizza rocks

[@masteryoshi2196]

Keep up the good work Steve!

[@surfboard396]

Steve 2024

[@leahbratt187]

Love what you do!

[@jacklutz9705]

Dang, where's Dave? All I see is a floating pizza and Red Sox hat...

[@jeffreycunningham4521]

he gave our stubborn brother 8.1.. im proud fr

[@actuallynotsteve]

Under 3 minutes, score no higher than a 7.0, everybody knows the rules

[@chrisphallheatlover9848]

Honestly I was thinking 7,4-7,5 it had good crisp, would have liked to see the full pie, tbh

[@Майкл-е9ь]

Steve back it, let's gooooo!

[@joereilly8925]

They need to open a pizza joint called Headless Horseman's Pizza Pub!

[@Tommy24552]

Lighting good? 'Yeah', Dave in complete silhouette. Everybody knows the rules.

[@BeepasGarage]

The two workers just watching in the background, everyone knows the rules.

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@sniffableandirresistble]

That crunch was 8.1 🍕

[@nfglasoe]

only making pizza reviews in the highest quality of lighting, everybody knows the rules

[@RMPalm2000]

Dave - Pizza Time in St Augustine and Moon River in Jacksonville. Get moon River slightly well done.

[@miker7233]

The garlic knot was the bribe to raise the score lol. Everyone knows the rules.

[@rms2365]

Hey, passing by,stopped,new place, got their name out there. Reviewed -7.1...win win. Everybody knows the rules,free garlic knot with a slice.

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@samburke8595]

Thanks Steve. That looked like a quality slice from Sbarro!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!....................................................

[@hawndove6992]

7.1 🤯🤯🤯🤯 because it wasn't burnt and thin as a tortilla 💩 that slice looked like the blue print for how a pizza slice should look.

[@mitchfletch]

Was not expecting that crisp tbh

[@krisfrederick5001]

That slice had better posture than a Marine. Everybody knows the rules 🍕

[@ericlatawiec3659]

Check out d'Berto Pizzeria in Mahopac, NY. I highly recommend it.

[@mrkitty6078]

Where is dave!?!?! That right there is Steve!!

[@eric_in_florida]

Was certain that knot would roll off and hit the ground.

[@BiggestPartyyEver]

Cold knots don’t get a rating, everyone knows the rules.

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@surfboard396]

Cold as the knots in his pants. 😂

[@alexmandara8922]

The pizzia is nice and light,Very Good!

[@Nothing-qq4hd]

7.1 slice probably would've been a 7.5 pie. I think the trick is great tomatoes, coal fire, dry cheeses light on grease and love in the oven let it crisp.

[@Romafood]

Casaletto is the name of a street near my district in Rome 😄🇮🇹👋

[@Schabo1234]

The garlic bread….definitely „one bite“ ! Cold 3.1

[@OmnikouraBB]

One bite, merry fucking christmas.

[@briannickel6813]

Dave is flying high, you know the rules.

[@sticksteve13]

This review had a severe lack of 'one bite everyone knows the rules'. Pretty good score for what looked like a not very busy place.

[@everettjohnston1931]

you gotta hit up Pizzeria de Mario in Toronto

[@Ligma_ki]

Yo we wanna spend 24hrs with u for a video!!

[@MrBlakej0323]

Just got a pie and I agree for the most part would rate 7.5

[@Lousasshol]

Lol 2 hombres sweating in the back

[@overdoer3562]

One bite everyone knows Dave hates dough balls

[@D.H.1987]

Everybody*

[@scottmcwave9479]

Place was empty! Nothing to do but stare at Dave!

[@garrettchapman8170]

That crunch was 7.9 worthy

[@sslapshots5277]

Sounds good and no flop. 7.1 ouch

[@SolarErazer]

I'm from London and I want to go and try new York pizza

[@niki420yuh]

Ahh another refreshing score called to the .

[@vincentfalcone9218]

Was expecting higher than 7.1 with that crisp. First time I've guessed wrong in awhile.

[@jpablo700]

Agree. I guessed 7.4. What were you thinking?

[@joey-wagons-beneventi3604]

Got that choo choo sittin high

[@AsentrixYT]

Shortnoy stood on his tippies while eating

[@simonsays525]

I'm curious...was that an All-American pizza slice?

[@davejones5316]

I seen him rank 🗑 higher. Thought atleast 7.6