Battlefield 3 Original vs Portal - Weapons Comparison

[@chillglobe]

for a 2011 game, BF3's animation and sounds is amazing and ofc the technology is limited at the time but on 2042 you can feel the laziness in the animation and sound design despite being released in 2021

[@Bynho85]

2042 it's a failed game

[@yellowcrayonkid]

They look like mw animations

[@jerelistokorpi1502]

@@Bynho85 nope that is very good game and those who say that is trash they are stupid kids

[@thewiz0ks]

Before game were made with passion for the player but nowaday it's just for money it's like they say : If you not come someone elso will come. They do not care anymore of the fan ....

[@kivnokai]

The laziness on the animation? I think in 2042, the animations are just fine. Animating takes a lot of work, and I'd imagine the Battlefield 2042 animations were a lot of work, so calling the animations lazy just feels like a bit of an insult.

[@GFL_IrohaKun]

The funny thing that the M16A3 in BF2042: Portal incorrectly has a 3-rnd burst selection, which was suppose to be for M16A4

[@HomeboundBark66]

I think they got lazy and just made the A3 also an A4 with that option

[@bellman4336]

@@HomeboundBark66 probably, knowing dice

[@deutschlipinoblazer3976]

Burst mode is only available on the M16A2 and the R0905 variant of A4

[@ALX_6.11]

More funny thing is that the selector set to semi In bf3

[@hewhobattles8869]

Of course they managed to screw that up.

[@matthewjamesdonaldsmith4858]

The original has better sounds and the animations are good

[@griz312]

Of course BF3 is the work of DICE but I’m still puzzled if a 3rd party developer worked on PORTAL.

[@Maximka45]

2042 has better gun sounds but the rest is true

[@Fruggggg]

@@Maximka45 it doesnt at all, the guns sound like they were recorded with the mic under a pillow

[@Maximka45]

@@Fruggggg but this is better than same sounds in BF3

[@Fruggggg]

@@Maximka45 what?

[@Medicgames94]

Just noticed that in Portal every 3rd round is a tracer round which is actually pretty cool because that's how we did it in the army

[@waynereloaded87]

Too bad that the tracers themselves look cheap

[@gebrelius7442]

@@waynereloaded87 nah the tracers look good you're just being biased now

[@mateusz_0]

@@waynereloaded87 nothing wrong with the tracers

[@anttitheinternetguy3213]

Thats True, didn't notice that. Too Bad The weapon recoil looks amazingly wrong 😩🤦🏼‍♂️

[@3217491]

I know the armies use tracers for mg's. Never heard of them using them in "assault" rifles.

[@Freedomlander_101]

For 2011 the sound effects in Battlefield 3 we're ahead of its time, 11 years later, the sound effects in Battlefield are now a joke.

[@nealang9520]

Enter Fart-like Battlefield theme remix EDIT: Sorry, I actually meant kazoo-like remix. Yeah...

[@Breakinzaworld]

I wish it didn’t own by EA

[@2142rex]

@@JuanCruz-in2bd My God, kid. It was an amazing game for its time, and they are mostly comparing it to 2042. Now fu*k off, because you're acting like a child trying to desesperatly defend a dead game.

[@KA-vs7nl]

@@Breakinzaworld same. Thankfully they have zampella and lehto now who both have publicly acknowledged how fans want a gritty and grounded modern bf game COMBINED with EA looking to sell, hopefully that works out, but its shaping up to look semi decent for the future

[@Breakinzaworld]

@@KA-vs7nl but still I think DICE team as a whole should change COMPLETELY because look at their behavior from the customer and the service of “live up to fan expectations” is a joke and they clearly don’t understand a live service game is (aka Bf 1,5,2042) and sure Zampella is there but don’t forget Battlefield require a big ass team to actually do it and so so many part of DICE is so wrong.

[@GoldInk-ds5up]

10 years later, they still don't know about pressing the spas button when loading shells.

[@moomachinegunner999]

2042 they don't know about how to reload LMG to

[@beanother1an690]

And yet the original COD MW2 knew how to animate the gate release being pressed.

[@totalguardian1436]

​@@beanother1an690 You mean the remastered?

[@beanother1an690]

@@totalguardian1436 Yeah. The OG version didn't have the animation.

[@waspinator_nick]

For those wondering why the portal’s animations are pretty bad, shaky, and robotic, it was animated by a relatively new studio that wasn’t EA DICE who did 2042’s base game animations, which are actually alright.

[@Nazrat84]

The worst offense is how inconsistent the Portal animations are. Some reuse animations from the 2042 equivalents, some are decent animations the look just fine, but some look like they are 25 years out of date in the jank factor.

[@maildump4395]

Ripple Effects are the ones who are making the Portal Content who were formerly DICE LA which ironically were the ones that saved BF4.

[@chuzic]

That's actually not alright, they are supposed to make games, especially after when they lost money bcz of bf 5, and yet they made the same mistake as Rockstar did

[@lizardspacecadet5595]

Most of the animations were eh, not horrible but def not up to the standards of most AAA games today. My biggest gripe was the aks-74U reload. My god was that a load of fucking trash. It was so stiff and felt like you were a robot trying to reload like a "normal" human.

[@Uladzya]

They also tried to copy the style of weapon animations and weapon recoil from CoD MW 2019, but they've failed even with that.

[@vptknrn5939]

It's honesty tiring seeing every game having tactical reloads since MW 2019.

[@theandrzej2890]

Yeah every single game nowadays apparently needs them.Battlefield had an amazing and iconic style of reloads,now every shooter needs them to be more tacticool.

[@hogyalbani3288]

Actually KF2 and MoH Warfighter had these tacticool reloads first before MW19.

[@vptknrn5939]

@@hogyalbani3288 But MW 2019 was the one to truly popularize them,indirectly leading to this oversaturation nowadays.

[@Danknic1234]

@@hogyalbani3288 I was gonna mention KF2 as well but It kinda surprises me much people don't seem to know about it since it came out years before

[@lionn00b]

Far cry 6 has some really nice original reloads, and even weapons like the asval which have clearly taken inspiration from mw are actually done really well

[@jrapcdaikari]

I wish more BF3 guns were in Portal, and I wish I could mix and match them with Bad Company 2 and 2042 Guns with my BF3 Classes

[@Nottagilla]

Or for any other game featured in portal.

[@thestørmcrier2024]

We all wish the bfbc2 and bf3 stuff was in 2042

[@infinitsai]

1:54 its amazing how modern devs can make a firing animation look so retro... its almost like its animated fir a ps2 game or some kind of 2010s mobile shooter

[@totalguardian1436]

But early 2010s mobile shooters are the best

[@epicgames2051]

BF3: A bit over-the-top, but cool as beans 😎 BF2042: Tries to be realistic and cool, and fails at it

[@magnus6683]

The bf3 guns sound alot more ¨realistic¨ than the muffled bb guns they put into portal bf3

[@Yea___]

Over the top, haha I get it

[@michaelmalocu7963]

Well if you look at the day on bf3… you never turn the slot

[@c0rruption775]

@@magnus6683 Still WAYYY better than cod

[@3Guys1Video]

@@c0rruption775 wrong objectively

[@JustAnotherUser565]

One thing I will give Portal credit for is that the 93R is modeled more accurately to the real-life gun than its original counterpart (which use the 92’s slide).

[@lopanreturns7085]

and the AN-94 magazine

[@Nsodnoajdjksl]

@@JannickFarrellManuelOlii Also "kids": **are 25**

[@serj1110]

16:22 LOL, the projectile does not fly out of the RPG in aiming mode.😆

[@SQUIRKY10]

Do you like that when you see buges?

[@serj1110]

@@SQUIRKY10 There is nothing else to look at this piece of program code

[@SQUIRKY10]

@@serj1110 well glad you'v asking for that and I have to go fucking myself.

[@czar_fz]

Another big distinction is how Portal has an awkward side profile of its guns which emphasizes the jittery animations, while in BF3 you're actually behind the gun's sight

[@kamarulzamanbinyahaya4637]

bruh they just stole valve game name portal ya know glados and portal gun is

[@amalayperson7208]

@@kamarulzamanbinyahaya4637 I know you're joking but fyi this is a different "portal"

[@kamarulzamanbinyahaya4637]

@@amalayperson7208 if valve is making a portal 3 we would see chell holding a weapons or something

[@lunchpin403]

I really feel like they lost ALL the flair and finesse of the BF3 animations and the ones in their place are jerky and sped up. The excessive use of camera shake/movement is jarring too, it's like they saw MW2019's animations and amplified them

[@christsang9728]

Mw's animations looked like motion capture and aren't exaggerated at all. 2042 tried too hard to be COD and lost their identity.

[@dodiandhika6684]

Another event where a remastered version is like a rip off of the game

[@Simon-S01104]

compared to a game from 11 years ago... BF3 was way above the time... and speaking really, bf 2042 is an insane downgrade compared to BF3

[@DiegoAlanTorres96]

4:58 unfinished recoil

[@clerky771]

I'm honestly this is bug

[@pyrolick2]

The BF3 empty M1911 reload will always be my favorite reload of all time. It's so good and the sound design makes it even better.

[@Oberfaust]

First multiplayer game i ever played. My dad showed me how to play. Within a few days i was able to get more kills than him in a match. i fell in love with the G3a3. RIP BATTLEFIELD

[@Qanqs]

Damn I have pretty much the exact same experience

[@xekoan507]

@@Qanqs same

[@MikeHawk-s2g]

Hell yeah the G3A3 is my favorite gun. Love the high damage!

[@NathanSF-qr2ds]

"RIP BATTLEFIELD" bs

[@jaywerner8415]

Conclusion, Battlefield 3 guns have more "character" to them, and i think they sound a bit more PUNCHY then Portal does.

[@StarkRaven59]

Something interesting to look at here. There are outliers in each game, but in general, Battlefield 3 features far less camera animation. In Betolfeeld 3, the animators tended to only use camera movements in periods of intensity, such as slapping in a magazine or giving the charging handle a pull. Even then, the motions are small. Some would argue the lack of movement makes the animations feel robotic, but it also makes them significantly more readable at a glance than in BF3 Portal. I'd argue this is also slightly more realistic as your brain would generally filter out the small movements and reactions your body makes to reloading. Portal is animated by modern animators, which means it makes significant use of camera movement to intensify its animations. The problem with this modern styling, is if the camera animations aren't executed well in conjunction with the weapon animations, the actual operation of the gun becomes harder to see in all of the point of view shifting. It can variably be like trying to watch something on a swaying ship, or trying to hold something steady while hopped up on stimulants. What's happening in your hands becomes harder to see due to what's happening to your head. Alas, Porthole suffers rather heavily from bad view bob while reloading, in addition to some confusing and unpolished weapon animation.

[@iansmith3406]

So many modern FPS games do this as a person with motion sickness the screen shake actually made cod cold war totally unplayable for me.

[@StarkRaven59]

@@iansmith3406 Cold War is _really bad_ with its camera movements too. I don't get motion sick, but I can easily see how it could make you sick.

[@arandomperson5434]

I’m not arguing or anything. But I actually wonder, how df do you go from “Battlefield 3” to “Betolfeeld 3”?

[@StarkRaven59]

@@arandomperson5434 Watching Birgirpall and phonetically typing bad accents.

[@CalDal_22]

i cant stand the awful new twitchy camera shake animations. they feel like somebody trying to show off in a gunrange by speed reloading rather than a standard soldier reloading. Bf3 animations all the way for me!

[@Dillon4599]

4:11 "Yeah, that animation looks pretty good. Put it in the game!"

[@modyphantom]

Bf3 : better sound, animations and somehow the models Bf3 portal: nothing Winner: your mom

[@Freedomlander_101]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5-xkIZrotZqgJY

[@gignriotofficer214]

Wtf?

[@fatihsakarya6528]

Support your mom.

[@NexosKTR]

Wtf what happened to DICE? I mean listen to that awesome sound design of BF3 and compare it to BF2042. Sounds worse than COD

[@Simon-S01104]

And yet the portal manages to have worse animations than the cod bocw

[@NexosKTR]

@@Simon-S01104 I miss the smooth animations. Dice wanted to copy the cod animations where you feel like robot wtf

[@Simon-S01104]

@@NexosKTR In fact, they wanted to copy the animations from MW 2019, which at the time was a fad for the people to want a tactical reload, and it was so perfect, then there was this totally disproportionate animation...

[@EnOrangeSoffa]

the dice that made bf3 isnt the one that made 2042

[@noobthro5630]

11:52 they can't afford to animate the Mk-14 EBR action. 💀

[@Fridgemasters]

the fuck are those iron sights as well

[@SlowLude]

Props to 2042 for having a separate animation for retaining partially spent mags. The slide on the BF3 handguns are way too slow

[@awesomezombi1026]

are you dumb that's the bar having two seperate animations for spent mags and not is the standard

[@raihanlaurent_hime9369]

Battlefield 2042 animation is something out of early 2000's games

[@Itsshaunbewarned]

the portal anims are done by 1 guy what do you expect

[@CoreRealm]

@@Itsshaunbewarned so... Why didn't they hire more animators?

[@bukitcengkeh1]

@@CoreRealm That puzzles me

[@Itsshaunbewarned]

@@CoreRealm go ask dice, I don't know but only 1 animator

[@Itsshaunbewarned]

@@bukitcengkeh1 I think it's because the development was a disaster they all had to focus on AOW

[@FOXYTOONS-OFFICIAL]

BF3 sounds better the BF2042 so as the animations, I think DICE should've remastered the old reload animations... but, BF2042,s weapon models looks more realistic... of course

[@Vert_GreenHeart]

One thing i truly miss from newer Battlefield game is when you put 3 or more C4's or explosive charges and then detonate them, explosion sound is so loud it deafens and muffles every other sound around. BF3 C4 charges were my favourite thing in the game.

[@FOXYTOONS-OFFICIAL]

The reload looks pretty freaking good, It just needs to have less of a shiver while in motion, it's like the soldier is on hard drugs 9:16

[@totalguardian1436]

This one actually just reused from Base game

[@FOXYTOONS-OFFICIAL]

@@totalguardian1436 The AC-42

[@cyathoris7530]

@@totalguardian1436 the only good portal ones are directly ripped off the base game

[@totalguardian1436]

@@cyathoris7530 MP-443, P90 and G3 are pretty good tbh

[@swampwitch7313]

Thats my issue with mw2019. Animations are sick but if looks like an earthquake is going on

[@BurritoLuvr]

Gotta love how the rpg projectile stays in after firing when ads in 2042, what a joke of a game

[@joshfriedman7099]

Battlefield 3’s graphics still hold up a decade later.

[@ctm479]

Looks mid

[@GrommX]

Сразу видно над какой игрой старались профессионалы своего дела. В игре десятилетней давности звуки и анимации выглядят на порядок лучше чем у прошлогоднего кала

[@djadjaRusja]

Причем главный вопрос "нахрена"? Они что папку "Weapon Sounds (BF3)" пролюбили где-то что ли? Смысл записывать новые звуки, которые хуже к тому же.

[@maxeone5449]

That Colt 1911 reloading from BF3 is just legendary

[@snekhuman]

bf3's animations look pretty cartooney sometimes, but 2042 looks way too shaky and wild sometimes. I'd say that both games have weird-looking animations at times, but bf3 at least has a consistent style

[@H-GHN]

can't believe BF3 still looks like a 3A game in 2022

[@w7u]

Imo the only guns that BF2042 wins in animation-wise are the SPAS, the A-91, and the P90 HK416 empty reload in BF2042 could be better if there wasn’t that awkward gap in the middle M39 EMR empty reload in 2042 reminds me of the M14 and M21 EBR reloads in MW2 and BO1

[@anri4774]

DAO-12 is also pretty good

[@snakeeyes941]

the bolt on the m39 doesn't even move

[@w7u]

@@snakeeyes941 ye I was just pointing out it looks like a cod reload

[@Ajay-dy3xw]

I agree with the two opinions but NOT the last one.

[@hoppinggnomethe4154]

nothing good about the SPAS-12 animation. they still got it wrong like 99% of other video games

[@black01_aut90]

2011 = smooth realoads and nice sound 2022 = looks like a a free to play game and even f2p games have better reload and shooting animations ..... i remember back bf3 times wher the world was fine and you wake up early on weekend to play bf with your friends and go to sleep when the sun is shining out of your a** (or fall asleep in your gaming chair) 💭💭💭

[@totalguardian1436]

CrossFireX have better Rex reload than in 2042

[@Hiraeth-0X]

Well Bf3 already won because bf3's Animations are finished unlike Battlefield 2042's

[@i_nameless_i-jgsdf]

The G3A3 in BF2042 is absolutely beautiful and i really like the animations.

[@bagasangga]

i s t h i s a s a t i r e o r w h a t

[@i_nameless_i-jgsdf]

@@bagasangga ?

[@bagasangga]

@@i_nameless_i-jgsdf 2042's G3 Animation way, WAY Robotic than BF3's G3 Animation

[@i_nameless_i-jgsdf]

@@bagasangga I dont think you understand the definition of robotic animation, because that s not robotic at all, my man.

[@i_nameless_i-jgsdf]

@@bagasangga Just for helping you better understanding of what the ''robotic animation'' is like, here is a great example: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5WYY4mrjNl7epo

[@horrorfanandy4647]

How does the 2011 game look better than it's supposed remaster?

[@Smokey348]

BF3 sounds more visceral

[@snehasishbiswas8759]

Finally, been waiting for this video so that everyone else can see what a disgrace is portal to bf3.

[@НиколайЛопатин-м8ф]

Everything you need to know about sound design in bf 2042 10:26

[@SQUIRKY10]

Пушечный огонь звучит так тихо

[@FlyinJMan]

I like the careless slamming of the RPG rocket into the launcher.

[@K_LeShaeya]

when an 11 year old game has been sounds than a game that came out 5 months ago... Makes me wish I could re-buy BF3

[@K_LeShaeya]

@@anhluu9417 I have 2 dollars

[@OwO-nk1zv]

i love how the mp412 ex in bf3 doesnt show the bullets you fired and those who haven't when you reload, but in 2042 portal, they...still don't show, they could've added that like in bf1 and 5 but just didn't for some reason

[@Mr_Callahan]

i love that in bf3 the shots actually sound impactful but in, 2042 they sound half assed

[@oddforoddssake3751]

Here's my take: BF2042's animations are still good. Whether or not they're a downgrade is undecided to me, because if they were truly a downgrade, they would be on the levels of BF2, which, while still great for their time, have not aged well in comparison. BF2042's animations do feel snappy and most certainly feel life-like. BF3 in comparison just has something a little off. Don't get me wrong, I love them just as much as any other guy whose first Battlefield title was BF3 (i.e. I fuckin' love them), but the hand slaps to the quick-bolt release on the ARs and the mag insertion on some guns doesn't feel right. Maybe I'm spoiled by newer games, such as MW2019. In fact, I most definitely am. But BF3's animations feel kinda robotic in comparison to BF2042, in the sense that there's no finer details by comparison. The camera shakes, to emphasise movement, feel delayed and even visual recoil doesn't look as impactful in BF3. To counter this, however, BF3's anims still have a flair, in some cases. For instance, the AN-94 and the mag ejection. It's just cool. Forgoing function for form. And you do see this in BF2042, yes. But, the big thing that the newest game has problems with is this: Expectations. Yeah, I know. "Big fucking surprise there." The game that was hyped to be a return to the franchise's heyday, circa BF:BC2 and BF3, and subsequently false-cummed and went limp. But, think of it this way: BF5's animations were a decent step up from BF1. And BF1's animations were practically a turning point for the series. They were to be the animations all future titles' animations were compared to, to see if they stood up in terms of quality. And like I said, BF5 was a decent upgrade. Whereas for BF2042... even I, someone who has yet to play BF2042 (but has played both BF1 and BF5), thinks that there wasn't enough of an upgrade between the latest two titles to satisfy my delight for punchy, action-filled reload animations. And going back to BF3 real quick, comparing BF3's animations to previous games, such as BF:BC2 and BF2 (hell, even BF1943 if you want), you *did* see marked improvements. There was more detail, they felt more active than BC2. Not that BC2 was bad at all, it was just that BF3 was a product of further experience, so much as to say that BF3 animations were made possible by the experience they had gained from the previous titles. Is this exclusive to BF3? No, the same went for BF4, BF1 and BF5. But the point is that BF3's animations showed effort and development, where development was possible. Whereas with BF2042... well, I feel like they're reaching a sort of "critical mass", I feel. As in, there's only so much a human can do to make an animation feel fun and exciting to simply watch, within a realistic setting. Any further, and you'll end up applying strange, almost cartoonish logic to the animations that start to become disjointed with the atmosphere of the game. And yes, I wanna see something creative done with these kind of weapons, but I'm fairly certain the animators and asset designers were simply not allowed to, whether that be because of design goals or pressure from higher-ups or a mix of both As for the sounds, however, I will concede to the vocal populace in this comments section and say that BF2042's sounds are lacking. They are bassy, yes, which is what I gather all gunfire sounds like when wearing protective ear equipment (like in Escape from Tarkov, for instance). But, I prefer gunfire to sound... ear-piercing? Is that the right word? Basically, if a gun firing for a prolonged period doesn't leave your ears ringing a tiny bit, then that's not a proper sounding gun, in my opinion. Which is why I love mil-sim games, where the gunfire from even an SMG is close to deafening. I end up turning the sound down, since my hearing is already sensitive as it is and I'm a coward, but I love it. And BF3 has that kind of quality. I feel like, with the right volume level and enough gunfire, BF3 would leave my ears ringing a little. BF2042, meanwhile... I dunno, I feel like there's too much bass to sound impactful. And I don't think that's what is needed for an AR or an MMG. Autocannons, artillery, missiles and explosions? Yes! Blow out my fucking eardrums with bass, please! But automatic rifles? No, I prefer a "higher pitch" to them, for want of a better phrase. So, to sum up: BF3 and BF2042 have both good and bad points with their animation designs. BF3 showed more effort whereas BF2042 promised too much (again). BF2042 is still good, whereas nostalgia has blinded us to the retrospective flaws in BF3's animations. And in terms of sound, BF3's guns sound loud and gritty, whereas BF2042's guns sound too bassy for mere small arms. Also this is my opinion, feel free to agree and disagree with whichever part you like. It's a free country, after all. I'm not forcing you to take sides with me here. :P

[@G1000-r5c]

@William Taylor who knows but I agree with this comment

[@oddforoddssake3751]

@William Taylor when inspiration strikes, time becomes nebulous

[@ExoShadow]

bf3 has that distressed and sharpness look to it. even the sound is beautiful.

[@stuff9680]

Portal's reload animations are more intense like DICE tried to mimic COD modern warfare

[@aminalikhany2988]

But where is the mighty m4? Why they didn't remake all weapons? This is a huge rubbery!

[@CeriseChi]

That scar reload though felt super nice

[@waffleboi8508]

DICE questioning their life rn

[@MackieLevyn]

why is 2042 trying so hard to be like MW2019. it used to be cod trying to copy BF but i guess things have changed for the worse

[@B3N_Youtube]

Bruh, 2042 animations are so jacked. I just noticed that the empty reload for the M14 doesn’t even rack the bolt.

[@Ray-lf1eo]

I can watch this without sound and still hear the correct gun sounds in my head..

[@dankovac1609]

People tend to forget that less clean textures and lighting can still make amazing results... The kind of people who buy games just because they saw cool lighting and hyper detailed textures will see a couple of smudged textures and a few sharp edges and get all offended like "tHiS iS sO bAd, HoW cAn YoU mAkE sOmEtHiNg So BaD wItH tOdAyS tEcHnOlOgy" Like, bruh... It's about how carefully you put everything together, and how much effort you're willing to put into it. I don't care if I'm going to see semi 2D grass and bushes, or see a few pixels in the said bushes, if they're going to be placed into the world well and look amazing while you're actually playing. Same with the guns. Sure, i also like when my chrome lined deagle looks like i could eat from it, but if it sounds like a sandal being hit against concrete and the game I'm using it in looks like the first attempt at an AI generating a map, i don't care one bit about the prettiness. It's all about new, new, new, and people don't realise they could expand on like, 2011 graphics and make them look incredible.

[@driver_gagash]

Battlefield 3 has its own charm ❤️

[@dingo2106]

Bro it took me a second to realize you were talking about battlefield portal so I thought Valve portal had guns

[@CoreRealm]

Of course the animation is better in Original because it's less wobly and more natural And less call of duty style reload

[@harveyknguyen]

it's not really natural either in BF3, it just looks less janky when there's no extra movement

[@Yousefgamez9884]

There are some weapons that don't exist like Battlefield 3 like Assault rifles:L85,AEK-971,AK-74 Or AK-74M,KH2002,famas,AUG Or AUG A3,F2000 Carbines:M4,mtar-21,hk53,qbz-95b,sg553,g36c Machine guns:pkm,qpp-95,lsat,mg36,m249,rpk,pkp,l86 lsw,m27 lar Sniper rifles:sv-98,sr-25,sks,m82,m417,m40,L96A1,JNG-90 Shotguns:USAS-12,Saiga,M26 MASS,M1014,MK3A1,Model 870, Pistols:M9,G18,G17, Revolvers:.44 Magnum

[@kirklowe5608]

Reloads in 2042, wtf is he doing with his left hand after the reload? He moves it offscreen instead of going straight to the gun.

[@danilopineda7892]

More videos of Battlefield Portal comparison pls 🙏🙏

[@hogyalbani3288]

Why Battlefield series doesn't have fire selector animations?

[@totalguardian1436]

BF2: Let me introduce myself

[@ivan5595]

I like both. One is somewhat 'authetic' while another is 'snappy' MW19 style

[@reekidmike7911]

8:36 OH GOD

[@kiIIer_b]

Im exhausted and bored of the double mag reload being put on every single weapon. We get it. MW2019 was a hit, but that doesnt mean do what they did.

[@polnet3217]

In a few years the guns will sound like would you always shoot with a silencer because now honestly where is the bang you want to hear from a gun?

[@thanachatlertwiram6939]

BF3: Masterpiece Anthem 2.042: When gun reload is louder than gun fire.

[@abraxo]

Графика, конечно, на стороне Portal, но исполнение как-то лучше у оригинальной BF3

[@SolisFactor]

4:11 Literally what the fuck

[@michaelmalocu7963]

Bf3: reloads casually Bf2042: DRAMATIC RELOADING INTENSIFIES

[@aslightlystablefootsoldier9838]

Everything about the gun to the friggin iconic view models are perfect in bf3 2042 just isn’t trying anymore, It looks like a nexus Fallout 4 mod

[@u.nforcesalx9892]

The fact that the animations and sound are beatable even by COD MW2019 is hillarious

[@SerbonOfficial]

You’re acting as if MW2019 has bad sounds and animations? It probably has some of the best in gaming history.

[@u.nforcesalx9892]

@@SerbonOfficial I'm saying that A game that came out 2 years ago with barely 2-1 years of prep time managed to beat a recently released game which I'm not gonna lie, is Embarrassing

[@w7u]

@@u.nforcesalx9892 I mean a lot of older games beat 2042 ngl

[@SerbonOfficial]

@@u.nforcesalx9892 I’m pretty sure MW2019 got 3 years of development. But yeah, this game is an utter disappointment, and I’ve got no clue why DICE didn’t delay the game.

[@Itsshaunbewarned]

1 guy who animates the portal guns, what do you expect? mw19 level anims?

[@Lemont95]

I knew this franchise was going downhill once I saw the BF1 trailer. Yes it was an amazing game and one of the best yet but it showed the limitations and lack of creativity. I’m worried we are seeing the demise and eventual end of the best first person shooter to exist.

[@C0T0HA]

Battlefield 3 remains at the top of the series in terms of weapon sound and feel. I don't know how or why but all following Battlefield games had weaker gunplay. BFV was alright but gunplay was the only thing it had going for it. Outside of Battlefield I'd say Insurgency Sandstorm is the ony game that did modern weapons justice in terms of sound and feel.

[@janthiele8191]

Tarkov should be considered. I know it is not a mainstream shooter, but still. The attention to detail and precision the wweapons are made is insane)

[@C0T0HA]

@@janthiele8191 I've only seen Tarkov, haven't played it, but you're probably right, it does look and sound great

[@samderanzer8568]

Why the rocket still attached on 16:24

[@CK-uu7ce]

DICE head at Zoom meeting: Guys, learn from COD devs, they recycled animation from previous titles like MW2019 to save time DICE animators: K. *Proceed to do exactly what was being told, which was recycling animation from MW2019* DICE head after playing the game at the beta: AYO WTF? I THOUGHT I TOLD U GUYS TO REUSE BF3 & BC2 ASSETS?

[@Nsodnoajdjksl]

It wasn't DICE, it was another industry

[@ImDmainguy]

I swear sniping in bf 3 was soooo satisfying Whereas in bf 2042 it's kinda blank

[@imSkrap]

It’s impressive how ass the weapon models (they all lack any level of detail or realistic feel, the black metallic/plastic in 3 is much cleaner) look in 2042 but the sounds are god awful too, it’s like every gun has the same sound just pitched differently

[@saber_2_6]

This comparison is like comparing a broken bike with a Lamborghini

[@AdaptiveCombatRifle68]

Whats so annoying about the animation for the 2042 version of the ACR is that the charging handle reciprocates. It does not do that in real life and they got it right back in battlefield 3. So they wasted time animating a reciprocating charging handle when they did not need to.

[@0neider582]

Can’t believe I have to say this “the old one is more better”

[@RockingRooProduction]

BF3 sounds, animations, etc. was ahead of it’s time and still holds up today. It’s awesome. That said, everyone’s shitting on 2042 just for the sake of shitting on it. The 2042 animations and sounds are very well done too. BF3 had it’s own style whereas 2042 took a slightly more realistic approach and majority of sounds and animations, in my opinion at least, are very satisfying too. Another thing to note, Portal wasn’t DICE’s main focus on 2042. Some of the animations look like they need a little TLC, but that doesn’t detract that they still like better than a lot of modern shooters. Obviously, BF3 is better than 2042 (and IMO Battlefield at it’s best), but that doesn’t mean that 2042 doesn’t look and sound great. You take 2042 sounds and animations, refine it a bit, while tweaking the gunplay, and you’d have a helluva Battlefield game.

[@breekiwalker]

I'm sorry but Portal's animation are decent at best, and it's really not what should be seen in a AAA game. Indie games or even Free to Play shooter have way better animations than these. From the lack of impact, the obvious resets of certain weapon parts and a pretty bad readability, these are frankly not great at all. And I don't see why those are more realistic than BF3 either

[@carryhandleenjoyer7411]

I'm sorry but bf2042 doesn't look like a 2021 game at all

[@aryscheffer9183]

Look how they massacred my boy..

[@venommagnus]

Damn BF3 even looks better graphically then BF2042.

[@tripplesix8459]

animations and sounds of portal looks like a cheap dev'd f2p shooter you can download from a browser lol

[@HIEHIMIKO]

Original BF3 = True Battlefield Game Portal = low cost mobile game

[@Nsodnoajdjksl]

Graphics = High and cool

[@noobthro5630]

@@Nsodnoajdjksl which game exactly?

[@Nsodnoajdjksl]

@@noobthro5630 MW2019, I guess

[@scar1ful]

I don't remember the Portal games having this many weapons

[@a1phasa1ty90]

bf 3s animations and gunplay are smooth as hell, battlefield 2042s look like a damn robot

[@theconsulfromthehl2betagam446]

Portal vs BF3 Sounds: BF3, Principally with the War Tapes option on Animation: BF3, They feel more natural and Portal Tries too hard to Be Tactical and some are Straight up Garbage Modeling: Portal, The models are More Realistic and the M93R is an Actual M93R not a Converted M9 Accuracy with real World guns: About the Same, but Portal Fixes the M93R but it Makes the M16A3 be a 3-Round Burst Winner: BF3, It's Sounds are Better, More Natural Anims but Portal Weapons look more Realistic

[@ronaldraygun5089]

Coming from a year in the future to say that Portal guns have improved in animation and style.

[@germanwarrabbit]

how does BF3 look, sound, and just feel better than BF2042 oh wait nvm...

[@veritassyfer1185]

My god BF3 was ahead of it's time. The graphics and sound still on par with today's games. There is clearly signs of laziness or lack of details with portal version. Audio is not as authentic IMO.

[@kimutkirby]

That sound, love that

[@heastner]

Bf3 reality mod: Can I join later, when I’m finished?

[@kompst_tu]

I'm convinced the original Battlefield devs didn't make 2042. It just doesn't feel possible for this game to exist knowing the original BF's dev's passion.