What a waterboarding reconstruction looks like - BBC News

*VIDEO CONTAINS SOME DISTURBING IMAGES* The BBC's Panorama programme witnesses the first accurate public demonstration of waterboarding. A team based in the United States showed the BBC Panorama's Hilary Andersson what is involved.
Panorama: Fighting Terror With Torture is on BBC One at 20:30 BST on Monday 3 August 2015 and available later via BBC iPlayer (UK Only).
Subscribe to BBC News HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
Check out our website: www.bbc.com/news
Facebook: / bbcworldnews
Twitter: / bbcworld
Instagram: / bbcnews

[@marchella9693]

I was expecting some serious questions but then "aRE YOU BORN A *_BUNNY RABBIT_* "

[@永続的な改善若い]

Yeah wtf

[@sacheverelle]

Is that some necessary part of the waterboarding process?

[@anonymousperson7438]

duff mckagan 😂😂

[@TubeYouGuru]

I think that was to demonstrate just how agonizing this actually is. One may have laughed or smiled during that, but he didnt, he was in obvious torment and had zero direction towards laughter.

[@makisjnx007]

It's an old morbid joke about torture using a fictional competition among groups of agents of different intelligence agencies of the world, to find who's best they're commissioned to go into a forest an retrieve a bunny rabbit as fast as they can using any methods at their disposal, the fastest one wins the contest, so the CIA goes first takes X amount of time, then KGB goes in takes them less time, then MI5 turn comes and it takes them way less time than the other 2, finally it last turn comes to a thirdworld intelligence agencie, the agents go into the forest and they come back in the longest (some versions the shortest) possible time, also they come out with a complete different animal (like a bear), everyone laughs and asks them what took them so long and also point out that they brought a different animal to which they reply confident by asking the animal "Hey you! What kind of animal are you?" The animal breaks down crying in pain and answers: I am a bunny rabbit! I am a bunny rabbit! I swear I am one! I am anything you want but please stop the insert torture technique here (like waterboarding)... Waterboarding is a long time known torture technique in some countries, like in Mexico, they used a special kind of really bubbly fizzy water, they tie the victim upside-down, give a good shake to the bottle of water and spray it directly into the subject nostrils and repeat until he starts giving the desired information.

[@mixedman841]

This is the problem with torture. People will say ANYTHING to make it stop.

[@benmgr4981]

@ Mixed Man Yep, you are correct

[@enevy3165]

Exactly.

[@drewtheboo9108]

That’s the point

[@ZekeMagnum]

Torture doesn't work. It is proven for the reason that people will say anything to make it stop. Being friendly towards the captured person gives a lot better results

[@yagirlalyxx]

@@drewtheboo9108 Yeah, but if you will say anything, there is no way of knowing if what you say is true or not. Something like waterboarding will only make a person say what their torturers want to hear, not necessarily the truth.

[@Youre_Right]

I didn’t think it would be that bad so I had my friends waterboard me. It’s crazy. I went in thinking, I know I’m not drowning so I will just hold my breath and tough it out. Oh how wrong I was. Literally seconds into it my brain totally short circuited and went into fight or flight mode. I was panicking. I could not rationalize that I wasn’t really drowning. It was truly a horrible experience. I would admit to something I didn’t do, to make it stop.

[@FelineEnjoyer]

“So I had my friends waterboard me” That’d look great on a gravestone 💀

[@flack2998]

imagine if the friends just didn’t stop

[@that_weird_StarWars_teen]

CHILD WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT!? YOUR GONNA MAKE THE NEXT TIKTOK CHALLENGE THAT SHOULDN'T EXIST

[@Youre_Right]

@@that_weird_StarWars_teen Kids have known about water boarding for over 20 years. It was a big deal when it was deemed torture and the US was using it against terrorists. I disagreed with it being torture and had it done to myself to prove it wasn’t. I quickly changed my mind it is terrifying and I would admit to just about anything to get it to stop.

[@SB-kp2gz]

@@that_weird_StarWars_teen Or put the idea in their head by saying that… 🤨🤫🫣

[@dblfsy6729]

Us government: we support human rights. CIA: huh what is that new word

[@nihilisticbarbie]

Sike the government wouldn't say that 🤪

[@TsukasaElkKite]

CIA: I do not see it

[@ladygrace7585]

The Filipinos: america supporting human rights? Woulda been nice to know that in 1900 😃

[@themicronationleague9441]

CIA: we support democracy Also CIA: If u not mi frend u get murded

[@JBguitar-cj8pc]

When did the government ever say that?

[@tnty1561]

It's just the painful thought that some people could and had to endure days, WEEKS to that stuff is mind-boggling. This man couldn't last half a minute.

[@livewiiiiire]

And some of those people have been proven to not be threats at all (a few Guantanamo Bay residents for instance)

[@lytlspeeze]

The people that are getting this done too have killed people. Cut people's heads off on video. This is not torture. Torture is the people that had to jump out of the buildings on 911.

[@Nezumi99]

Those people are literally trained

[@zoybean]

@@lytlspeeze America deserved 9/11 because they invaded Muslim countries. 9/11 only killed 3000 people, US invasion of Iraq killed 300,000 people.

[@Thisisonlyavailable]

​@@lytlspeezemany of the people that were subjected to these tortures were innocent, illegally and wrongly prisoned bcz of the stupidity of CIA. Twenty years later they are proven to be innocent like Ahmed Rabbani and his brother while others like Abu Zubaydah are still suffering for the crimes they did not even commit

[@BlckCloud73]

....isn't there supposed to be a cloth over his face?

[@santinothebambino1528]

I think it works either way

[@ryanzer0170]

CheneyWatch1 try breathing through a wet cloth or towel. Water will go into your nose and mouth. now try it as more water is being dumped on your face. don't forget that the cloth or towel will also blackout oxygen. perfect simulation of drowning.

[@ryanzer0170]

CheneyWatch1 I know there different methods. but the cloth and towel is better which was my point you missed. notice how he was still able to breathe? if he was more clam and disciplined he would have lasted way longer. There is a way to continue breathing (not by much) with the SERE method.

[@ryanzer0170]

CheneyWatch1 try not breathing through your nostrils? mind blown!!! when you exhale, squirt any water in your mouth out at the same time. When you breathe in, do not open your mouth as much, and Continue to squirt out any water in your mouth. sounds hard to do? because it is, but it's doable. and also, of course they use way more water than that in a real waterboarding torture. but being declined would make it harder as water will get in your nostrils. just hope they have you flat or "inclined" like you stated.

[@ryanzer0170]

CheneyWatch1 and he could have lasted a little longer if he had discipline. who cares how long I lasted? were you waterboard? I won't be waterboard either, but I had similar situations were I had to do irregular breathing with water involved. you will never last minutes. and I never claimed it. I just simply said I like the waterboard with a towel or cloth. and that he could have lasted longer than he did, if he had not panicked. and also, he should have not answered their questions. he should have just stayed calm and focused.

[@todo8328]

Lmao "you are a bunny rabbit!!!"

[@Aidzeyn]

lol wtf why bunny rabbit

[@slimmthicclegend9454]

Why does this comment with 1.1k likes have 1 comment

[@todo8328]

@@slimmthicclegend9454 - I don’t know why it has 1.1k likes tbh

[@VishalKumar-nz2mz]

bot likes

[@wanderingkernel5002]

"I am asking question now" "You're drowning" I don't think that's a question mate

[@notanarsonist7348]

Jordan Joestar buddy, if you're going to make fun of someone's English, you should use the correct you're

[@pauulkubasek1815]

“You’re drowning, eh?”

[@Elizabethvelasquez9321]

@@notanarsonist7348 😂 That's a bruh moment right there.

[@MarySchipke]

According to anti-torture laws "Being forced to watch another person being tortured is a form of torture."

[@TheGreenTaco999]

source?

[@saw1898]

Yet you willingly watched this. That’s odd.

[@justintrouble8]

@@saw1898 it's almost like this video shows someone who can leave the situation at any time, so isn't really torture but rather demonstrating that a person could only handle 18 seconds of this before breaking. You are dumb.

[@vladimirputin8285]

I think no. Kind of. I don't think anyone should be forced to watch it. But know exactly what the victim feels.

[@LathaLatha-si6ti]

Yeah the jews💀

[@burntpieceoftoast4148]

Love the accent of the guy pouring the water. Super slick, subliminal programmers, super slick.

[@edgemo3000]

Right. On top of that the watered down the waterboarding torture method for the viewers.

[@madladokogott7130]

Makes it look like they're russians.. While it's actually the CIA.

[@adampustos1155]

​​@@madladokogott7130that was absolutely not a russian accent

[@flamejob4260]

Who's here after reading all the messed up stuff about McKamey Manor

[@martagomes3182]

Me , Im foreign and didnt understand the concept of waterboarding . Its awful if he really does this to the people going through his "manor"

[@flamejob4260]

@@martagomes3182 right? i didn't know what it was either but that's so fucked. they said it "it's literally drowning"

[@hannahmarshall4687]

How did you know 😱 I came here cause I knew what waterboarding was I just didn’t know it was called that

[@nicolareddish9626]

Yup

[@landonbuckley6747]

Sammeeeee bro

[@BladedHorizon]

As someone who has almost drowned, it feels awful. My body was screaming at me for oxygen while I couldn't get my head above the water for over 18 seconds. It feels like this kind of torture would make someone lie just to make it end and nothing more.

[@Nezumi99]

Your brain wouldn't be even able to lie. Try it yourself

[@popff7]

dude i have the same experience, waterboarding with trauma is absolutely horrifying

[@connorbarr7314]

​@Nezumi yeah I kinda doubt anybody is going waterboard themselves after reading this

[@Broodkast8]

@@Nezumi99 So, you're stupid? Alright.

[@peacefulviolence2660]

I'm kind of surprised 18 seconds was as long as it went. I have nearly drowned before by being held under water from a rip current and in total it was definitely longer that 18 seconds. Now I was being thrashed around and not always in a position where gravity was allowing water to funnel directly down my nostrils which probably makes a big difference... I'm still just kind of blown away by that.

[@calicoheart4750]

A huge part of it is the restraints. Having control over your limbs means your body is telling you "you csn fight, you can do something, do anything". Being restrained, all your brain can do is scream "you're going to die" over and over.

[@jixdahac]

@@calicoheart4750 makes a lot of sense

[@artorias6502]

Remember: the real victims of this torture have NO means of making it stop. Sometimes it goes on for days, weeks even months at a time. And the Americans say it isn’t torture. Unbelieveable.

[@dritemolawzbks8574]

The Americans do say it's tortue. Do you think this is tolerated in American courts?

[@rickysanders6487]

"Americans say it isn’t torture" Bootlicking right-wingers said it isn't torture (some of the more psychotic among them are honest enough to admit it is but still say it's ok). NUMEROUS Americans, regardless of politics, condemn this shit for what it is. The people who approved this are nothing less than war criminals.

[@jacobshirley3457]

@@dritemolawzbks8574 He's talking about many random American citizens. And they're right.

[@dritemolawzbks8574]

@@jacobshirley3457 Many random Americans also believe extraterrestrials are kept inside of US military bases. Is that relevant at all either? The US government is the legal representative of the majority of the American people and not random surveys. If you're that upset with waterboarding and why it was tolerated, you should take the time to find out why so many Americans gave the Bush Administration a blank check to do whatever it wanted in the Middle East.

[@AbdirahmanIdris-ku9xm]

​@dritemolawzbks8574 9/11 was terrible but if you look at it deeply, you'll find the CIA had connections to the attackers. The torture was just sadism not revenge. The CIA plotted to kill Americans(operation Northwoods)

[@victorunbea8451]

This isn't waterboarding, it's drowning torture. Waterboarding uses a cloth over the face to minimize water inhalation while keeping the drowning effect real. There is much less chance of death due to asphyxiation in waterboarding than what was done here.

[@JoeZelensky]

Ya, that is what I was looking at as well.

[@peterreid]

who else came here to see some sick watersport tricks?

[@miwwie1504]

nobody

[@peterreid]

2 people say otherwise

[@paulkevinson7295]

*53

[@FadeingRevolt]

lmaoo u a clown

[@kentuckybruce6816]

I mean... it’s pretty sick either way

[@Carbide195]

Is that title supposed to be a question? It looks a lot more like a statement with a question mark after it.

[@BBCNews]

Prubbs thanks for spotting it. All fixed now.

[@antone_s]

Anyone here from mini lad?

[@shellfrances01]

me

[@gadgetshowboy]

Prubbs BBC actually replied? Nice!

[@Ash-cb2li]

Prubbs man corrected the BBC’s grammar

[@kazitox]

yes, they're supposed to use a cloth or a rag over the head. Of course they do not, as this makes the situation far worse. simply enduring this must have been extremely unpleasant. this was simply a demonstration of how effective it can be at the most basic level, they're not going to actually torture the dude by going all out.

[@Thisisonlyavailable]

Kid you they actually have. CIA has been doing it for years on INNOCENT people. Search Abu Zubaydah. He was waterboarded 83 times

[@LeeDee5]

Man I can't stop thinking about that Spongebob episode where Patrick is choking on snow but then it melts so he drinks it instead.

[@dlvox7415]

I was waterboaded in SERE School. I learned later that the approach was used as a test as to how advanced interrogation techniques might be used against our advisories. We were told it was prisoner of war training. Either way, it works and I was glad to be a part of the control group.

[@Widdekuu91]

It doesn't work, people admit to anything...he just said he was born a rabbit. Didn't you watch the video?

[@Black-mq3xn]

@@Widdekuu91 So the idea behind those sorts of questions is to get psychological control. The reality is, yes, you'd say anything for it to stop. I could ask you things like: "You like to suck cock?" "You like to touch children?" "You hate your country?" "What is your country?" "Do you hate your country?" Those sort of things, more or less, establish a picture for further propaganda that will be generated. In that case, you're feeding into what they plan on using you for and it may be beyond just getting information. Additionally, what you say may be verified. If you are not telling the truth, then back to hell you go.

[@DarkShroom]

@@Widdekuu91 no it works... but just like any torture, what if you have the wrong guy? that's why it crosses the line

[@Widdekuu91]

@@DarkShroom Many people will admit to something immediately, the first thing you say to them or will make something up. You want names of ISIS leaders? They'll give you names. They will give you fake names, or innocent acquaintances, they will send you on your way to look for them. John Oliver has an educational video about this, it's been proven that good cop -bad cop- works a hella lot better, especially since hardly anybody "enjoys" being in a terrorist or gang or other violent group. They want protection and help and if you offer them that, they might be willing to speak. It's not about trying to be worse than what ISIS has in store for their family. You have the option to help them and have them on your side. Think.

[@lockheedload]

You shouldn’t be talking about what went down in RT. You know that’s classified.

[@MT-mx7um]

the other guy holding him down was obviously thinking "now that you mention it, he does kinda look like a bunny rabbit"

[@TerryTanktop]

Looks fun.

[@tutsecret499]

Hummm. Fun? Then you should be there in his place.

[@MegaScumbucket]

Josh Matthews That is such a ridiculous comment.

[@gabrielmarinescu4965]

i laughed at this comment so thumbs up to you!!

[@steezgeneral7715]

Josh Matthews 😂😂😂not fun considering most of the people this was done to was innocent 😂

[@toafafaamoana5044]

cancerous wast of organisms

[@tattoodrdoke]

This is nothing compared to my dad washing my hair

[@fourseven9121]

Same

[@dynactivelearn]

I hope he's not a CIA terrorist.

[@tattoodrdoke]

@@dynactivelearn Me half drowning "Dad?" Dad "Yes!" Me Karate chop the side of the bath "They teach you THAT! In the CIA?!?"

[@bubbleytoons5683]

tattoodrdoke ummmmmmmmm now does he wash your hair is it just like I. The sink or the ummm bathroom any your n@k*d

[@tattoodrdoke]

@@bubbleytoons5683 easy their fella! Seems like a strange question to me.

[@JennyG.COW5]

Has hard as it might be to watch, I'm glad you're sharing this important lesson. Thank you for sharing the truth. 👍

[@rnqtn]

Just being immobilized with a pillow over my face is unsettling.

[@amyd58]

He can't move his head, can't see when the water is coming, is being screamed at and is strapped down to a hard board. Um, rag or not, this would be terrifying.

[@CEOkiller]

"I'm a rabbit! I'm a wabbit! Look at my big floppy ears!!"

[@OdinMMA]

This isn’t even remotely as bad as it is. Normally it is done with a towel or cloth pulled extremely tight around the nose and mouth and the head bagged in total darkness. The water stays soaked on the cloth even when the pouring of water stops.

[@ruben4869]

imo it is okay

[@oisin_doran]

Completely fine ‘Your drowning ya’ Starts acting like a fidh

[@xjaydent1579]

damn imagine waterboarding a fish. the fish would probably die.

[@chelleshell7033]

xJaydenT if it doesn't pass Over the gills the. Yes it will die

[@youtubecommenterorsomethin4138]

Dammit I was supposed to search up wakeboarding not waterboarding! darn you autocorrect!

[@BenKryger]

My friends and I actually did this in one of our basements to each other back in the high school days. Call us stupid, but we wanted to see what it actually felt like. I thought it was going to be easy to resist the discomfort, but i gave in within 10 seconds. This is really no joke and absolutely feels like you are drowning.

[@juanllorente3504]

Of course is not joke. Do you think that when the government is using this methods they want to know whether you are or not a bunny rabbit?

[@woodchuck321]

If they can get you to say you're a bunny rabbit, you can get them to say anything.

[@thebuccaneersden]

Where is the cloth that they put over your face in order to inhibit breathing? Had to down vote this. Not actually realistic, when it advertises itself that way. People will look at this and think waterboarding is a joke.

[@Chris-xs3vu]

Because waterboarding requires people to lie down, the water would just flow into your nostrils by gravity, so the problem isn't about whether or not you can hold your breath. The water just straight up flows down your nose, effectively causing you to passively 'breathe in water', and thus, causing extreme distress. That is unless you can exhale with such force that you can blow out all water that is flowing in your nose, otherwise, the water would just flow into the nose and down your lungs. Though you could block the path of the water down your nose with your tongue, this prevents any further breathing and the water flooding your nose would extremely torturous anyways. Once you are unable to hold your breath anymore, things become very exciting.

[@sierraburmese4083]

Your last sentence scares me

[@lynette599]

@@sierraburmese4083 LOL

[@JajaTheBalls]

Holding your breath wouldn't change anything because the receptors of your airways will feel the water obstructing them making you go in panic mode. Also, you have a limited expiratory volume and the water flows constantly, and your tongue won't be able to block the water going to your lungs through the nasal pathways. All that to say I think anyone would panic within 5 seconds.

[@bigwolf-ts3ht]

KZbin: wait did that guy just cuss!?!?!?!??? Age restriction, demonetized Also KZbin: reenaction of actual torture? Okay that's cool

[@SurvivalMistakes]

Having undergone a session of waterboarding as a video on my own KZbin channel, I can very much empathize with how just how unpleasant and scary the experience of undergoing it is - Zoe x

[@bumpasaurus487]

I coulda lasted longer than that, especially without the towel. I wouldn’t have given up my bunny-rabbit past for way longer

[@jonhammer5799]

The fella's and I are bored in rehab we're gonna try this and see who can last the longest getting water boarded tonight.

[@jonhammer5799]

Well its awesome try it out.

[@grouchychappie]

Thanks. Now my brother WILL confess that he ate my leftovers

[@noahlakes4487]

The people in this comment section are downright terrible people. You say that the man was a coward for not being able to endure the torture - it was torture! And there are others saying that the method was not done in the correct way to make it as painful as possible, without realising how sick you are. Go ahead, support people who want to use this on others for their own terrible actions. Just know that if we keep on trying to one-up each other on who can be more cruel, we're doomed.

[@timcrouch2415]

Most of these videos still seem to be missing something from a very early report I remember seeing about the time "waterboarding" entered the national discussion: I thought the board "see-sawed" backwards as the water was being poured to give both the feeling of falling and the water on the face to kick-in the full instinctive panic of drowning. I also definitely know that a cloth is supposed to be over the face and that is pretty much consensus.

[@utkarsharyan]

Reports say that waterboarding is mostly used by US military. It is also used alot in Guantanamo bay.

[@shelde8344]

Lol.before they begun his heart rate was 117 on the ECG and then when it panned to it during intergoation it was 95!!! He got more relaxed . I think he's into this S&m style

[@ChrisVaz92]

not relaxation, the mammalian diving reflex to conserve oxygen

[@Oops.Hii_28]

Wattpad authors: WRITE THAT DOWN WRITE THAT DOWN

[@Br0teas]

This made a very good point, torture does not work to get effective answers.

[@buuzzsawtouchedme194]

+Matthew Brough, exactly, as people will say anything to escape torture, as it's kind of natural to do that. But what if you think someone does have the answers you want? Well again, people will say anything, so they can always lie, and if you found out that person to be lying, of course you'd never know as your reaction would be "people will say anything to escape torture".

[@chrisjunior7881]

And the BBC proved in only 2 minutes why “enhanced interrogation” doesn’t work.

[@mparryuk52]

I have a friend who at the weekend actually pays for this particular activity at a specialist dungeon.

[@MyDadsNotACellPhone]

I'm preeeeeeety sure it's not water, tho

[@gblake5560]

Right. But it’s still not the same. He’s brave to volunteer and I’m certain it’s nasty. But he knows he’s safe. He knows they don’t want to hurt him and don’t hate him and would be upset if they did. Having this done by people who hate you and want you to suffer is likely much more terrifying. Which would make it much worse

[@Chance57]

You don't know any of that shit when you're drowning. You forget everything.

[@idontknowmuch3441]

@@Chance57 you’re missing the point

[@bumpasaurus487]

18 seconds is nothing, I could hold my breath for way longer than that at least

[@Steamlazer]

Well, obviously, but this remember, this is a CONTROLLED environment. Real waterboarding is a lot worse. They put a towel over your head to make your brain think you're drowning, and it goes on for longer

[@bumpasaurus487]

Steamlazer I understand, and it’s more than lack of breathing because water goes into your sinuses. But still, you would think people could last at least 30 seconds 😂🤷‍♂️

[@theultimatehoomanperson6701]

*so this is the way to get someone to say yes.*

[@kade1849]

i thoguht there were gonna be some serious questions like why did you leave her but .. " WERE YOU BORN A BUNNY RABBIT?"

[@ha6ni6el6]

Doesn't this renew the perennial question as to the value of information obtained under torture? Even if the subject is able to withstand for a limited period, the information given may well be at the prompting of the interrogater in the form of the questions, as well as the subject liable to answer simply to stop or pause the pain/discomfort. Even brain-washing techniques, such as sleep deprivation, isolation, disorientation, light deprivation, etc. with the implantation of false memories in the sub-conscious, may serve in the subject admitting tearfully to the admission of all sorts of crimes before a People's Court may be of use, but is of no use when trying to extract genuine valuable information! Just a thought.........!

[@deyithe9597]

They just had to include the Russian accent 😅

[@adameve2647]

Interogators:Were you born a bunny rabbit Him:yes

[@katscardsandgames]

I feel like to truly deliver an authentic waterboarding experience, one must be screaming at the victim in a Russian accent. Notice how the victim's heart rate jumped from 80s to 110s as soon as the the man turned his Russian accent on. It clearly creates a more visceral experience for the victim.

[@Rusty.77]

"I'm pretty sure it wouldn't take long to break... truely break" Is the guy that just said he was born a bunny rabbit saying he didn't break? hahaha

[@MrIncorr3ct]

thats not how ive seen it demonstrated... they used a towel over the face and poured it onto the towel. this means you cant breath in or hold ur breath. much worse

[@jordanpillinger7337]

you liberals used to be leaders of freedom but now are just trash

[@notanarsonist7348]

Jordan Pillinger o- ok?

[@ZInChat]

Someone has to say it... *THIS IS NOT HOW WATERBOARDING IS DONE!*

[@pilisjose]

And still he broke. If done 100% accurate, will be way worse.

[@hannahdyson7129]

So you wanted them to fully torture someone fir a demonstration? Dear God....

[@Emg2463]

I know someone who was waterboarded twice as part of his military training. It was preparation for the possibility of being capture by an enemy and how to prepare your mind for any possibility of torture and how to best get through it sane.

[@ShiningN0vA]

The woman was only there for the shocked face 😂

[@mattyb859]

Compared to some of the instruments in the medieval "torture museum" near where I am, seems pretty tame...

[@dave1927p]

so was he born a bunny rabbit or just identifies as one?

[@SarahDawesFilms]

Brilliant comment lol 😂😂

[@YuriNoirProductions]

i still don't get why you can't hold your breath in that situation. when i'm diving and turning headsup i just put a bit of pressure in my nose so nothing can get in and i can remain quite a while like this. is it because it's not a steady flow of water so you can build that pressure? i assume it somehow must just go in your nose with any ways to prevent it.

[@freestylestuntkayak]

I also still dont get it. Could you be trained to stay calm and hold your breath? As a stuntkayaker the first thing you go through is learning to stay calm underwater for 60 seconds while strapped in and upside down. It was quite easy. I did experience a near-drowning due to being trapped underwater. It was bad, but I have no idea how that compares to waterboarding

[@shadzyalex]

The world has never been so creative with these tortures. its kinda sad

[@gneu1527]

Medieval or modern times which has worse torture I'ď say modern times but in modern times you can't get tortured out of nowhere

[@jparaneta13]

“It would take long to break... truly break” You just told them your secret that you are a damn fine bunny rabbit

[@ammonal244]

Do you speak English, mate? He said "It *wouldn't* take long to break... truly break."

[@grobsop6688]

1:50 Lol, you truly broke in an instant.

[@THECrackasaurus]

Well to be perfectly honest, in my humble opinion, of course without offending anyone who thinks differently from my point of view, but also by looking into this matter in a different perspective and without being condemning of one's view's and by trying to make it objectified, and by considering each and every one's valid opinion, I honestly believe that I completely forgot what I was going to say.

[@lulumoon6942]

Totally agree!

[@b.p.emma.]

its so weird. it doesnt even look that bad... i cant imagine how it feels when it looks so just... annoying more than anything

[@numbnuts375]

"YOU'RE DROWNING YOU'RE DROWNING" lmao

[@Al-yb2nc]

looks like he was trying to drink the water first 😂

[@CaspersSVT]

“Roll To The Right, Roll To The Right”. The Entire Time He Is Rolling To His Left Side. DuH!

[@Chrisallengallery]

Is this an advert??

[@earlgrey6375]

Yes, for Black Water Military Contractors.

[@biggiesmallsyalls7674]

Earl Grey BlackWater or Academi doesnt do any of this shit. They are just veterans who fill in the gaps where we need more troops

[@mjenkins91]

There’s not even a towel? That’s the whole key to a water boarding? this dude was playing into it. He knew what the cameras wanted and why he was there.

[@claymodelexpert]

I thought they just drip water on your forehead until u get the sensation of drowning, not actually drowning you lmao

[@Widdekuu91]

That's a different technique. Not sure what it's called. But this is waterboarding. Letting it go into the nose and mouth.

[@bigwolf-ts3ht]

I did this to myself as a kid all the time I saw a fun little challenge to keep my breath for as long as I could But apparently the US government sees it as a good way to extract information

[@bigwolf-ts3ht]

Actually now that I think about it could someone that knows about the human body answer this? Can waterboarding myself as a kid contribute anything at all Two problems with swallowing? I seem to choke a lot even on my own spit and I'm not sure why

[@DBSmith-]

I came here from mini ladd save rump lmao

[@tanhalife_5649]

Same XD

[@nejx8711]

DBSmith_0511 same

[@munsifalikhan3230]

me too

[@potatogaming5140]

DBSmith_0511 yup me too

[@jaivaja7316]

DBSmith_0511 yaboiii

[@aneeshprasobhan]

I think Trump will legalise this again

[@iorbit]

Yea. Like it atcually matters to the american intelligence agaencies if it's leagal or not.

[@tamamanitohei9334]

iorbit That's coming from someone who can't spell "legal."

[@iorbit]

Tamama Nitohei yes

[@clubalbert]

that's nothing compared to what they do to the people in Guantanamo Bay

[@clubalbert]

***** if you bothered to check out the interviews with the victims you would know

[@Bobby_boucher31]

"People." I hardly consider terrorists people.

[@clubalbert]

+Bobby Boucher anybody can end up in Guantanamo Bay even you but all the detainees there are called terrorists without due process. shouldn't everybody be innocent unless proven guilty?

[@juanllorente3504]

+Egalitarian Ethos Oh yes, ythe other day I went to the super market and they ended up taking me to Guantanamo Bay. This war cannot be fought with democratic rules, The sooner we understand that the most likely will be that the good ones, wins this war.

[@clubalbert]

+I'm a butthurt mgtow and women suck because I'm butthurt. you got that right!

[@liubeiwushijiu8168]

If put in this situation, hold your breath till you pass out. And drown in your sleep

[@benmgr4981]

@fuegomylego It does not work that way, I tried it!

[@Steamlazer]

They pour the water directly into your nose as well

[@dirxclvck]

Why did they choose this accent for the perpetrator😂

[@BladiMoyano]

Why the torturers have Russian accent? When the ones who actually uses are the Americans??

[@e-boy111]

Bladi Moyano the guy was Russian

[@sadas3190]

Er, no. Waterboarding is not just pouring water over the face and shouting in a ridiculous accent.

[@another420day]

Fail!!! I breath through my ears.

[@larssral-n8942]

BBC: lets ask if we can get demonstration about waterboarding Reply: of course. We will test it on Me: chris has bigger balls then my head

[@Shlooomth]

I wanted them to ask him afterwards if he remembered what he confessed to.

[@marco9352]

I came here after hearing about Donald Trump's latest statements.

[@ecdesperados5524]

Cameron Smyllie -1000 subs without any good content I wouldn't mind you getting waterboarded

[@this_is_afiq]

Donald Trump wants waterboarding to be legal in US? He should try waterboarding first himself for 1 minute. :)

[@AbovyantsiAper]

Exactly why I came to this video

[@minnakay6378]

+Nur Afiq Bin Mahadi Why should he, he never killed anyone. This is a torture method to extract information from an insider terrorist/criminal who won't confess up. This isn't for a random civilian, this is to get more information from a criminal we happen to have alive on our hands.

[@this_is_afiq]

+The Screaming Midget there are still other ways to extract information with showing mercy. If the person is at fault, still a person must not be tortured. If you have simply broken a law, there are consequences but not torturing or tormenting the guy. Waterboarding is one of the few most dangerous torture method. If you don't drown from it, you may unlikely suffer from lung infection due to liquid entering their lungs.

[@minnakay6378]

Nobody would get waterboarded for jaywalking. Nobody would get tortured for mugging or robbing or even raping. This is a more serious method for hard criminals and terrorists...you can either maintain peace for innocent civilians or you can show love and affection for killers and terrorists. You cannot do both at the same time. "Lung infections" are nothing. To be honest, I would support much more serious torture methods for brainwashed terrorists who actually think that killing Americans and Europeans will give them eternal paradise. If I could, I would kill them with my bare hands. Those kinds of creatures are not people at all. Once you can kill an innocent person with no remorse, thinking that a "god" will be satisfied, you've lost all mental sanity and such vulgar acts don't show a human's empathy or conscience. Waterboarding isn't for people who broke a law - there are many people that rob / steal / kill accidentally or while suffering from mental disorders, etc. and those people need therapy primarily. I don't mean to sound cruel, and I understand your point, but it's necessary to remember that in such situations you can either protect your country or protect the people who want to destroy it. If we continue to let people step on us, that would destroy more lives than if we stopped ISIS, etc. instead. Not that I think waterboarding will be that useful. These are people who are so brainwashed from the day they were born, being told that America was the enemy and we deserve to be killed. The number of supporters / people funding ISIS, al Qaeda, etc. are no joke - there are too many people involved. There are so many people who even don't publicly support or fund them, but they support them internally / mentally, you know? It's crazy shit, I also wish we weren't at this point.

[@this_is_afiq]

+The Screaming Midget No matter how harsh is the crime that a person has committed, that doesn't mean the person must be tortured to be interrogated for information. You got the wrong idea. Small or big crime, there has a consequences for the person who commited a crime. And no torture should be legal whether by a higher class citizen or higher authorities. But there are consequences and punishment but no torturing methods to be involved.

[@AWSMcube]

Freedom >>>> Security

[@Unyt]

The hardest part looks like having water squirted or squeezed down ur nose

[@sizwen9391]

After this i would need a raise

[@joshs6405]

I must admit this is pretty sick. But you cant deny that what ISIS is doing is MUCH worse. I hate the thought of torture like this, but i partially agree with Donald Trump's views on doing this to terrorists and the families of terrorists. You've gotta be tough if you're gonna win.

[@jkthedudeman]

+Josh S I agree that terrorists need to be interrogated, obviously. But I can't say I could abide torturing them. It is just too barbaric. No human being should have to suffer like that.

[@joshs6405]

Darth Shale Compared to what ISIS is doing, i dont think we would be necessarily overstepping the boundaries. As long as we're very careful with the treatment. ISIS has to stop killing people, burning them, beheading, drowning in cages...its terrible. This is the best way to send a message that "we're being tough".

[@jkthedudeman]

Josh S Yes, Isis needs to be stopped. But I don't think we need to resort to barbaric methods of torture to make that happen. Its been proven that torture is not an effective method of getting information anyway. Under torture, people will tell you what you want to hear, even if its complete bs, and they don't know what they're talking about. Just to make the pain stop.

[@fortaleza9642]

There are far more effective methods of getting information. Torture is almost useless

[@joshs6405]

Darth Shale Now you are sounding like the politicians who say "lets have the people out there cooperate with us to defeat ISIS"....but it doesn't work that way. The civilians not only refuse to cooperate with the US military generals, but they also stand in our way, thus protecting ISIS. If only they would write down names/house numbers of known ISIS members, and turn them in, and warn other civilians to evacuate. But there is basically nothing happening from their part. The American and Canadian soldiers could count on European resistance movements to be working from the civilian base during WW2, and that's how they would take out German meeting halls, storage areas, officer quarters, etc. Either the civilians have to help, or the civilians have to get out. We shouldn't have to wait 5 years for them, and still be knocking our knees together in worry. Send a message loud and clear. We're gonna start bombing soon, help us locate Islamic terrorists, or gtfo. Idk...I'm no military expert or intelligence agent.....so my judgement may be way off. But i do know that the way we're doing it now is just wasting time, money, blood, and bullets.

[@enoch327]

I think if I wanted to brainwash someone this would be how I would do it. You could get anyone to confess anything. You could get them to believe anything. And we did this.

[@ethaniovino9908]

Holy shit, and Trump wants to do this?

[@nekozombie]

Gott Mit Uns It is torture. Less intense and damaging, but still torture.

[@gneu1527]

"ARE YOU A BUNNY RABBIT" "YES"

[@ClipCrew]

ARE YOU BORN A BUNNY RABBIT?!?!?

[@AWSMcube]

Amendment VIII of the United States Constitution: "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."

[@omarluatia736]

AWSMcube it’s not punishment it’s interrogation you dumb fuck.

[@cellachestrace1665]

AWSMcube that right only applies to us citizens

[@danielivanov439]

Cellache Strace Incorrect. See the 1896 Supreme Court case Wong Wing vs. US which is also the reason illegal immigrants are required by law to get a court hearing before they are deported.

[@kenneth9452]

your an idiot, the US only uses waterboarding, solitary confinement, sleep deprivation. It does not beat prisoners, it does not starve prisoners,.

[@satisfactioninajar7668]

Toxic Waste Radioactive did you not read the cia book where an innocent man died of hypothermia shackled to a wall after them having stuffed his rectum with blended food using a pipe? Maybe you dont know your country as well as you think

[@globalspiritualrevolutionmedia]

I Agree with enhanced interrogation vy the CIA. We must protect our great nation of the USA.

[@GoMrTom]

American way of "human rights" and "democracy". Like killing of american natives and nuclear bombs in Japan.

[@epikUnreal]

Joshua Rugger or we could just kill whoever made anime

[@melancholics_7808]

GLOBAL SPIRITUAL REVOLUTION RADIO & MEDIA GROUP But it's wholly ineffective.

[@saintpablo4878]

Disgusting....

[@marianneszymanski2332]

Firstly, it's TORTURE, not "enhanced interrogation". Call it what it is, i.e. an enormous breach of human rights. Secondly, no one deserves what was dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, least of all the thousands of innocent civilians that lived there. You can't blame an entire race for the actions of a few soldiers- if that were to be the case, we are all guilty.

[@slaughteringgg]

Were you born a bunny rabbit? You're a bunny rabbit?!

[@L3HuLeHu]

Good thing I can hold my breath longer than 18 seconds

[@hazelberlinguette2104]

Were you born a bunny rabbit? Yes