BCS Battle of the Blades. Spyderco Manix 2 vs Paramilitary 2

[@GearedTowardGear1]

Love the Manix much more than I used to. It’s grown on me quite a lot. Both fantastic knives, thanks for sharing brother. Welcome back!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'm with you the manix I'm just a huge fan of and it's one of my most carry knives in my EDC rotation. Go to be back and I'm hoping to talk to you guys a lot more now, thanks brother

[@Eldofarmboy]

I can promise you the PM2 won't break. I have two videos where I've tried to break it. For me the manix loses mainly due to the weaker lockup. I'm sure it will do just as well if not better than an axis lock but the compression lock is up there with the triad lock. After borrowing my co-worker's manix for a little bit during a shift while he tried out my PM2 I actually felt that for my hands the PM2 was a bit more ergonomic plus I like the more aggressive jimping and steeper ramp. Add in the slicier blade on the PM2 and you just have a boss of a knife. A lot of people say the tip would be easy to break on the PM2 but I have stabbed it deep into wood and wiggled it around with no tip failures. To each their own but I know for my preference I'd take the PM2 all day every day. My co-worker sold his Manix to buy a PM2 so I'm thinking you're just weird. Lol. Good video man!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I know you have abused that pm2 for sure. I really like both of these knives just me personally I think I just prefer the little bit thicker handle of the manix just makes me feel like I got a little more in my hand.

[@pauldayton5285]

Woodland Tactical , you are incorrect. The ball bearing lock is stronger than the compression & frame locks . In fact the only lock design / system that is stronger than the ballbearing lock is the back lock. Another fact about the ballbearing lock that makes it superior in my opinion is that it self adjusts with wear guaranteeing no wiggle or blade play. I'm a South Paw so I've always gravitated twords the ballbearing or back lock. I've tried many different styles from different companies & the ballbearing lock from Spyderco is my favorite. The S.O.G. Arc & Benchmade Axis locks are badass too ! A Manix 2XL has been my EDC for 6yrs now & the performance of the ballbearing lock has been flawless , never having one issue in the thousands of time's it's been opened & closed.

[@pauldayton5285]

How do you figure that the compression lock is stronger than the ball bearing lock? The ball bearing lock is the second strongest lock design made with the back lock coming in first. You can look the lock strength tests up on you tube. The ball bearing lock is ambidextrous where the compression lock is made for right hand use only. That right there should give the ball bearing lock the win over the compression.

[@BigRedEDC]

So good to see you again brother!! Would have to go with the PM2. I prefer the slimmer, more slender knife and the PM2 is more comfortable for me! Prefer the compression lock over the ball bearing lock by far! Great video brother!!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Definitely glad to be back JB! I knew there'd be quite a few people that actually prefer the paramilitary 2 over the manix 2. For me the manix 2 just fits my hand a little better and I like the little wider blade. Don't get me wrong I still carry my paramilitary 2 quite often. Thanks JB

[@BigRedEDC]

@@BlueCollarSurvival Right on brother!!!

[@jcoolG192]

Awesome vid! Great to see you back! You know how I feel about the PM2! Love the Manix!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

It's good to be back Kurt! I'm definitely a bigger fan of the man acts as you could see for my comparison but I don't hate the PM 2 by any means.

[@plainscrafter5374]

Welcome back. I'd call these comparisons BCS Breakdown

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Thanks brother it's good to be back! That's actually pretty good name for this series. Thanks for the idea brother

[@hilltopknivesandgear8103]

Manix wins all day every day. Twice on Sunday!!! Glad to see a BCS video! Missed your content! Hope all is well!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

What is up BJ!!! Glad to be back hoping to get some more content going I'm glad to see that you started a channel.

[@tomweingart2337]

Justin, was beginning to think that you'd run off with a Rock N Roll band! 😂😂 Glad you're back!!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

No rock and roll band just a whole lot of work and zero time for myself LOL. Glad to be back I appreciate it Tom

[@timbo4374]

It's damn good to see you back bro..I missed ya! Hope all is well with you. Personally, I like both, but the Manix gets my vote. I carry one of my Manix's far more often then I carry my PM2. ( I have 2 Manix's, only 1 PM2, if that says anything ) The Manix just feels so natural in the hand..like it is part of my hand. I just feel like I have a little more control on fine work. The PM2 is not a bad knife by any means though....the Manix just edges it out for me. Everyone has different likes, different hand sizes, and we use our knives differently, so I can't fault anyone for liking the PM2 better. They are both big sellers for a reason..they just work, and you really can't go wrong with either one. I like these head to head comparisons..and I'm happy to see you back!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

It's definitely good to be back brother! I agree they are definitely both great and eyes and like you said everybody's feel is different and in my opinion the manix just fits my hand a little better and I feel the same I have more control at the Mannix than I do the PM2. definitely hoping to get back in the swing of things now that stuff starting to slow down some

[@markjg2275]

I like the Manix 2 better, I was lucky to purchase a limited release Spyderco Manix 2 with M390 steel and brown G-10 , looking forward to getting that one this week. As for this baton nonsense who would baton with a folding knife it makes no sense this baton issue has gone nuts and now many knife buyers expect every knife to be able to baton otherwise it is useless in this survival mentality which is extremely rare even if you had to survive you do not need to baton logs of wood . Knives are cutting tools number one that is what they were designed for . Though these big modern fixed blades can baton with 1/8 or thicker blades I have no use for that . A folder and a small fixed blade 3-5/8 inch blade current fixed blade is all I need with me anywhere I go ,so I carry both and other small items lighter ,flashlight etc. . I have the Manix 2 in translucent blue with the CTS Bd1 steel it works great and excellent steel in my opinion , I never had to fully sharpen that steel just touch it up and it is sharp , the M390 version should be great too , nice feel in the hand even with the finger cutouts on this knife handle. I never had the cage lock fail though it can get dirty with dirt and stuff and can be difficult to clean but I just rinse it out and oil it. I like the Manix 2 to me it is a very good choice for a everyday cutting tool.

[@ocomegashadowstacking5886]

Wow really awesome Spyderco knife video about Spyderco!!! :D

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Thanks Amos I appreciate it brother

[@ocomegashadowstacking5886]

@@BlueCollarSurvivalyou're very welcome 😊 And I just subscribe your back friends😄👌

[@johnscarborough4746]

Welcome back, so I guess sales guy finally escaped from the corn maze...I’d have to agree with you on the Manix 2, mine is such a good fit in my hand and I really feel like you have much better control in use than the PM 2.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'm surprised he figured his way out of the corn maze . most of the time he can't find his way out of his own ass LOL. I agree the ergonomics of the manix 2 or just a little better in my opinion that I have more control with that knife in my hand and I do the pm-2. Thanks John

[@JustRobHere]

Glad you are back.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

It's good to be back I'm hoping to be able to get on a little more than I have this summer.

[@radwayb]

I agree. Good to see you back!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Thanks Brian it's good to be back brother I miss all you guys!

[@glockgaston2922]

#ilikeknifes Great to see the sales guy!!! Great video Justin!!! Manix2 all day!! Thanks for sharing brother!!👊👊👊

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Great to be back bro! I missed all you guys and I'm hoping to get more content in now that things are slowing down.

[@Outpost_76]

Manix 2 all the way. The PM2 is an ergonomic fail with the compression lock. It's a huge hot spot, doesn't make me dislike it, however, for use the Manix is just way easier on your hands. Yes I have over 10 Manix but i also have 5 PM2 so it's not like I hate it. It's just not the user the Manix is.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'm with you Gerald you are actually the one that turned me on to the manix, so there you go on that. I do enjoy both knives just the manix for me is a clear winner. Thanks G

[@Outpost_76]

@@BlueCollarSurvival that's awesome brother.

[@inthepocket7405]

Yeah buddy🤘🤘 good to have you back! That intro was gold, by the way 👌 I’m with you man, that’s why I’m down to one PM2, and I think he’ll be leaving shortly.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Great to be back bro! Yeah I was a big fan of the pm2 until I got my manix 2 and then my Spyderco world was flipped upside down LOL

[@menacewithaknife4045]

Love my pm2 LH, would of bought the manix 2 LW if they didn't make a left hand pm2. Glad you're back 🐱

[@JOMO_EDC]

Holly shit! I’ve missed you brother!!!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I miss you too bro I'm hoping to get back in the swing of things.

[@JOMO_EDC]

I always consider those to a draw. I love them both!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

That was a tough decision for me but I've just been such a huge fan of the manix. Don't get me wrong I still love the pm2 as well.

[@Watchandcutgearchannel]

Very good video.. nice to see you back! Missed you!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Alex!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It's great to be back brother I missed all of you guys too.

[@jeffsmith6441]

I like the new style video. The Manix has my vote. I've never had hands on either of the 2 but the Manix just looks more my style. I'd like to own them both eventually though.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Yeah they are both very good knives I just kind of prefer the manix a little more just cuz it seems to be a little more of a beefy knife and just fills my hand better

[@JadeSchafer]

Good to see you. I'd go with the manix 2. It's one I've always wanted to try where with the PM2 I've never really had that itch to try it.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'm telling you you just can't go wrong with the manix 2

[@junichiikeda5860]

I'm thinking the Manix 2 with the back lock, but I also like the PM2. Good comparison. Thx

[@adamedwards3921]

BCS ARMY SHOUTOUT! it's been a while brother due to my work schedule but I'm glad I seen the notification for this video .. my suggestion for a name of this comparison war is.............. #SPYDERSENSE...

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Well welcome back looks like we both been gone for a while because of work. I'm hoping to get back in the go of things once my work schedule kind of calms down some and it usually does in the winter. Thanks Adam I appreciate it bro

[@rhino5419]

Hey Justin. Great to see you back, hope you are well. The knife sales Guy has been missed. Good health and stay safe.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Thanks brother it's definitely good to be back I've missed all of you guys as well. I'm surprised sales guys missed doesn't he make your head hurt???

[@rhino5419]

@@BlueCollarSurvival Never, i like knifes too. lol.

[@rodneypearson6986]

Glad your back Brother 👍

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

It's good to be back!!! I missed all of you guys Rodney I'm hoping to get more involved again.

[@rodneypearson6986]

@@BlueCollarSurvival I've been in a low lately trying to crawl out. Take care Brother 👊

[@mikelikesknives428]

The Manix has been my go to Spyderco. Their are still a ton of great sprint runs and dealer exclusives. It’s also great that the Manix blades have been Rockwell testing a bit better than the PM 2 blades in the same steel. Not actual scientific proof, but just looking at the numbers. Thanks for a great video.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I've loved my Manix ever since I got it. I had mine Rockwell tested and the M4 came back at 64 HRC. Don't get me wrong, the PM2 is a great knife but for me the Manix is just better all around. Thanks Mike

[@eugenemonica5890]

The battle of the blades awesome to see you back brother missed you not sure how I feel about Spyderco don’t own one not in my budget but look like both are decent knifes awesome to see sales guy back thanks for sharing brother 🔪🔪

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

That's actually a pretty good name for this series! BCS Battle of the Blades! It's good to be back and I definitely missed all of you guys. Thanks Eugene I appreciate it bro

[@eugenemonica5890]

Blue Collar Survival glad you like the name and it’s awesome to have you back Brother 🔪🔪

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

The name is on the video now! Thanks bro, it's great to be back.

[@TheOutlaws9295]

Two greats 👍

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Definitely, that's why I kind of figured it'd be a nice comparison between the two. Thanks brother

[@survivalist9818]

Well come I was knocking on the knife store door and nobody answered I'll be back. Great comparison .

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Even if sales guy was there if he would have heard knocking on the door his confused ass would probably just spin in circles lol. Thanks bro!

[@Ronnieleec]

Manix 2 and Dragonfly 2 are my favorites

[@John..18]

Tip down is the way to go for the PM2,,, imho,,,

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I believe you're right John actually flip the clip after I read your comment. Thanks brother I appreciate it

[@John..18]

@@BlueCollarSurvival Yep, when you retrieve it from your pocket, your thumb is right there on the blade hole,, also, I find it keeps the pivot away from the gunk in the bottom of your pocket,, ha ha,, Atb,, buddy,,,

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Mine is tip down now!

[@edrader]

yep. just like it comes

[@rhino5419]

Hi Justin. Hope you are well. Long time no news. All the best

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I miss you guys as well. Everything is well I just have a lot on my plate at work right now. Hoping to get done extra time soon. Thanks brother

[@rhino5419]

@@BlueCollarSurvival as long as you are ok. See you when you can. Stay safe brother.

[@Orochi_001]

I like the Manix 2 in its lightweight configuration best, and prefer the PM2 overall.

[@ShortcutReviews]

Only a Sith would pick the Manix. The PM2 is a more elegant blade for a more civilized user. Great video, thanks

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

You know me Chuck I'm down with a Sith Lord. Maybe that's why I like the manix better cuz I'm not an elegant guy LOL

[@garyjacobs2789]

I think the manix2 is a better all around knife. I bought a flytainum ball lock replacement and put it in the box as insurance. I also have paramilitary new in the box waiting its turn . But the ball lock is just easier to use .

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I really should look into one of those flytanium ball locks. Yeah I think the Manix is just all around with its ergonomics and feel and hand just for me is much better than the paramilitary 2. Thanks Gary

[@garyjacobs2789]

@@BlueCollarSurvival 40. I think . Mine is in the manix2 box . Just in case .

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

That's not bad. I'll definitely look into one. Thanks Gary

[@adamedwards3921]

I just realized you needed a name for the series smh . Any ways I would call it # UNDENIABLE RELIABLE WHITH BCS !!!

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Now that is a mouthful my friend. That's what she said bwahaha

[@mt_baldwin]

I own both, for me the pm2 is the easy winner. Maybe I got a sub par manix 2, but my pm2 has way better action, the lock is stiff on the manix, plus the pm2 has tiny bit more blade yet the manix is heavier and takes up more space. I'm not a huge fanboy of the pm2 tho, unless you want that bigger blade I'd say the sage 5 is a better buy.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

They're definitely both top sellers and for good reason. For me the manix fits my hand better and the action is great plus I really do enjoy the bearing lock over the compression lock. I still carry both knives depending on the day. The sage 5 has been one that has been on my radar. Thanks brother I appreciate it

[@edrader]

love the sage 5 but the PM2 blade is way more useful to me

[@Brewhound77]

Manix vs shaman next!

[@Outpost_76]

That's over before it starts, the Shaman with that compression lock is a huge fail.

[@Brewhound77]

@@Outpost_76 how so?

[@Outpost_76]

It's a huge hot spot once you start using the knife. The inside of the scales are sharp and feel too far apart. A back lock and closed spine would have made it a favorite for me even though it has thick blade geometry.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'm definitely not a fan of the shaman I actually did a review on one not too long back. The cut out for the compression lock is way too big and is a major hotspot for me plus the blade to handle weight ratio feels quite a bit off for me.

[@TheGamerGuy1981]

Love both, but manix of the two. Stronger lock, better ergonomics. Compression locks fun to play with but a knife is a tool and the ball bearing lock is way wayyy stronger. I have a para 3 LW I use for light tasks, but I'd never rely on it like I do my Manix.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I love my Manix! Like you said though with great egos. I actually just sold my PM2 this week. Not much use for it ever since I got the Manix. Thanks man!

[@HSTMachine]

The bearing is on a track, but also on springs. Ball bearing lock may be stronger, but the compression lock's fail rate is next to zero.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I agree with that.

[@paddyspotatopeelers2154]

Nice to see you back mate. Send me your address and I'll send you a sticker. Atb paddy 👍😀☘️

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Thanks Paddy it's good to be back and talk to all you guys again! I'll hit you up with my address on Instagram later.

[@talik777ful]

Ball bearing lock is twice stronger then compresion lock, tested by BladeHQ

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

I'll have to check that out! Thanks man.

[@talik777ful]

@@BlueCollarSurvival here is this test kzbin.info/www/bejne/e4PbeYiOdquJqZY

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

Right on! Thanks bro

[@kenroman777]

@ Blue Collar Survival I have zero idea where you got your PM2 but I would return and get one with the normal handle shape.

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

It is the original handle shape but it has an added skull crusher back spacer.

[@kenroman777]

@@BlueCollarSurvival thank you for clarification .

[@BlueCollarSurvival]

No problem Ken. Thanks for watching my channel.