Bee Gees - When Do I [ REACTION ]

[@duckigrrl]

Robin’s voice never ceases to amaze me, thrill, and comfort me.

[@ingridneumann8196]

Nobody can switch there Voices like the Bee Gees ❤❤❤

[@saphirzafiro7777]

such magical vocals by Robin

[@haratriantafillou3208]

Thank you Chad. I am glad that you liked it. Robin was unique. He could sing everything and with his heart.

[@marciamaria7796]

Você tem razão Chad, Robin brincou com sua voz, que por sinal linda voz. É por essas , e outras que sou muito fã, desse artista espetacular 🇧🇷👍❤❤❤❤👏👏👏👏👏👏Linda canção 😍

[@carolespinoza8469]

My god, robin has a vocal range so dam crazy. 😮. I love this, 🥂💞💞

[@suzannescriber6073]

Sweet precious Robin Talent personified

[@RuthBair-ht1fj]

So beautiful. Don’t think i had heard this one before. Thank you for introducing me to another wonderful song. Vocal range amazing. They all have such great voices. ❤

[@kimbarrett4179]

Love Robin's voice . Nice song. Great reaction and totally agree robin is my fav but all 3 of them made the bee gees with out any one of them no bee gees .

[@LeonieJose-c5u]

Robin at his best, with a range like that how could it not be great. Thanks Chad, I love your reactions to Bee Gees music ❤

[@danielnavarro4085]

One of my favorite songs on this album along with Dearest.

[@ellenmontgomery8533]

Barry and Robin wrote this one together. There is a demo of them singing this together, but I'm glad they decided to let Robin go for it on his own.

[@wisconsindoc3869]

Robins voice is truely unique and amazing. Nice reaction. Have a great week, Chad!

[@bartalinigibb]

Great reaction to the amazing Song from a masterpiece album ❤

[@rwilson7197]

Fantastic reaction!!! I feel exactly as you do. Robin's vocal range and abilities are AMAZING and beautiful. I love it when he hits those deep low notes. We don't usually get to hear his lower range.🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️

[@kimbarrett4179]

I agree

[@susieq9801]

In some of their music they were very big on orchestration. Bill Shepherd was their musical arranger. For "I've decided to join the air force" they were backed by a 67 piece symphony orchestra, a choir and the RAF (Royal Air Force) marching band at the Royal Albert Hall (often used for operatic and orchestral performances). Stigwood wanted to make a big splash! Maurice's piano on both this LP and on Odessa was absolutely brilliant and all self taught. Robin had a five octave natural range plus falsetto (FALSEtto not being a part of a singer's "natural" range) although he didn't use falsetto much. His vocal gymnastics could be pretty amazing. Thanks for the weekend and have a great week.

[@mickc7388]

Bill Shepherd didn't get enough credit for his amazing arrangements on so many Bee Gees records.

[@_Beth__]

@@mickc7388 He didn’t! Talented guy!

[@tonydecobellis1234]

One word? AMAZING

[@TheLobocantaore]

I have been waiting for this one ! for ever !!! Thanks Chad

[@carolinegilles9181]

Celestial Robin’s voice. ❤️ Maurice Ernest Gibb FOREVER 🙏💔🕊️😭💎🇬🇧

[@Scuderia_Fan]

Hi Chad, thanks so much for your reaction. It must have been close to two years since my request for this one, but being patient definitely pays off. 😀 I have always really enjoyed this song, musically and of course vocally. Indeed not to many songs come to mind where Robin plays around with his voice just like this. Maybe the song "Dairy" has some of it, but not to this extent.

[@hereonthe3L]

@@Scuderia_Fan Sorry, my friend, 2 years. I feel terrible about that... 😔

[@Scuderia_Fan]

@hereonthe3L No need to Chad, good things come for those who wait. 😀

[@haratriantafillou3208]

Thank you Chad for this reaction. His voice range is one of a kind😁

[@bethanyhuber2598]

Robin always sounds best when he sings with his brothers. His unique voice is a true gift to the world. Haven’t listened to this one for a long while! Beautifully crafted song and a great testament of Robin’s ability. Thanks, Chad!

[@miriamkirk7293]

I've been listening to Trafalgar just lately and love most of the tracks. Robin's vocals on this are so unexpected initially and I found myself impatiently waiting for the next lot of note changes. He had such an amazing range. Love, love it. Thanks Chad. Great marathon. Have a good week.

[@trishafaulk2067]

It wouldn't let the like light up when I hit it Chad, don't know what is going on, but know I liked it.😊 I remember once hearing an interview where they were asked what they considered themselves and they said musicians and writers of music, and that when they started there were no real music genres so they didn't really like to put themselves in a category.

[@marieskapars4766]

Great robin ur voice that of an angel. Wow, shows you're voice at it's best at all levels. Beautiful. Top as always. Ur the best at this n eternal so for ever. Just a one off. Stunning. ❤❤❤❤❤ I'm not surprised I loved u since u were a Manchester kids. As we were. Bless him n brothers too. Xxx

[@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey]

I wondered if he was representing all the varied voices of the men on board ship at Trafalgar. You did do 'Somewhere' where he played a lot with his lower range but certainly showed off his upper range too.

[@lt6134]

Yeah his range is pretty amazing. And this doesn’t even include his falsetto!

[@mathieubuchholtz460]

Thanks a million dear Chad ! What a delight ! When I bought the LP in 1971, I was so bewitched by this track that I could'n't help listening to it several times in a row. Robin's ton of voice from low to high range is a treat. The Bill Shepherd's orchestration is outstanding. Love when Robin sings in a low ton of voice such as in "Terrible way to treat my baby" when his rendition is inspired by Bill Medley of the Righteous Brothers.

[@marialoyola2423]

Beautiful song, I love the entire Trafalgar Album, thank you for this reaction Chad, Bee Gees Forever 💞🌈🌹🌹♥️

[@terezinhafernandes8164]

Eu percebi o alcance vocal de Robin e do Maurice quando assisti a uma entrevista dos Bee Gees e fiquei surpresa com a voz grave dos dois. Então entendi por que, juntos com Barry, eles sempre foram tão incríveis. Essa música é uma prova de que o talento deles é único. Obrigada Chad!

[@willow_wise]

Thank you for the reaction!

[@Judy-mf5cw]

Howdy Chad, This really showcases Robin's vocal range and vocal control. Robin has a very unique voice. Love this song. Thanks for this reaction. Bee Gee fan forever. ❤

[@karis_H.2000]

Somehow, watching you react to, yet, another Bee Gees song I’ve never been into before, has made me, once again, realize just how amazing it, actually, is! I completely agree with you. Robin does indeed have a ridiculous range and it's absolutely amazing! I've heard Robin go into a low range while singing a few times before, but only early/kind of early on in their career. It's shocking every time I hear it, even though I know he did it sometimes, because of how rare it was. I wish he'd sung that low more than he did, not that I don't enjoy his regular and high ranges, at least, as much, possibly more than it; I just love it enough to want to hear it more than we got to. But, yeah. I don't recall him going this back and forth between ranges in any other song. It's crazy and shows off his amazing talent. I don't care which Gibb bro's/bros' singing you react to, even if Mo is my favorite. I love them all enough to be perfectly happy no matter who's singing. In fact, I love that you try to highlight each bro as much as you can! Thanks for, yet, another amazing marathon! I look forward to the next one!

[@CeciliaRodriguezRoge-eg6nl]

😮😮 oh, CHAD!!! Another request of me!!!😂😂 THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!! ❤❤❤ THEY WERE SO YOUNG!! Trafalgar is a VERY special album, underrated. . Oh, ROBIN...He's increíble... ❤❤... Remember " teach your children" for THE next week end , of another beautiful groupe, Nash,Bill ...)...but in THE FILM "MELODY", WHERE ALL SONGS ARE GIBB, BUT THE END YOU CAN LISTEN AND WATCH THIS FABULOUS SONG IN A FABULOUS PICTURE!! And "GIVE THE BEST TO YOUR FRIENDS".. AT THE SAME PICTURE!! THE VIDEOS ARE ON KZbin, YOU PUT "THE NAME, BEE GEES,MELODY" AND YOU FIND THIS PRECIOUS GEMS...❤❤ THANK YOU, THANK YOU SO SO MUCH..I LOVE HOW YOU REACT, WITH EMOTION AND SENSIBILITY AT OUR ANGELS!! SORRY , MY ENGLISH WITHOUT GOOGLE TRANSLATE IS SO BAD...😢 WE LOVE TO SEE YOU ENJOY WITH THE GIBB'S SURPRISES!! VERY, VERY HAPPY WEEK FOR YOU !!!😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤❤❤ Don't search a musical genre where "put" THE BGS... THEY ARE A SUI GENERIS GENRE!!! SIMPLY!!!! THERE ARE a Lot of SONGS where ROBIN sing bass, after falsetto, AND another acrobaticos voice changes... "FANNY BE TENDER WITH MY LOVE", LOVE SO RIGHT, ETC ... MAURICE TOO CAN DO THAT... THEY ARE A NATURE'S MASTERPIECE... SIMPLY❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Zlata1313]

@Cecilia RodriguezRoge I have seen you in some Robin fan groups on Facebook. I contacted you there with a link for another special one!

[@natashyahendrix2]

❤ I like this song

[@LillyMarz777]

😊

[@CeciliaRodriguezRoge-eg6nl]

"NEVER BEEN ALONE" by TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN.... AND "PAPER MACHÉ" ... PLEASE....😁😁🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@dubivxler]

👌👌👊

[@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey]

There was such a lot of Robins range and talent that seemed to be written off by the record producers as redundant. Perhaps the decision to give up the instruments in favour of voice was his but why give up so much of his range too! Mo was rightly praised for his musicianship and versatility; Barry for his tremendous range again, rightly so, but you often heard Robin laughed at as the brother in the middle who couldn't play, couldn't dance and sang the chorus. And that was back in the day.