Why Pakistan’s Democracy has Failed | Prime Minister Problem - 1971 War Story:Tilak Devasher TRS 351

[@beerbiceps]

Check out my Mind Performance app: Level SuperMind levelsupermind.onelink.me/CsSR/youtube Join the Level Community Here: linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommunity

[@safiullah-fg6gp]

Please bring on Shahbaz Taseer, He's the son of Salman Taseer a sitting governor that was killed by an Extremist because he defended a Christian woman who was falsely accused of blasphemy and later his Son (Shahbaz Taseer) was kidnapped by the Taliban and escaped after 4 years. He has an amazing story

[@drvaishnavivadlamudi4229]

Hi ranveer pls bring atif aslam to the show

[@kalindajaej]

Mere bade bhai... House tour ka video lade❤❤

[@jayeshjani6357]

U are behaving like idiot boy who didn't understand his own history. Atleast read ur own history before making podcast with stalwart like Tilak.

[@gopalratnamn.m6720]

😊😊

[@starzee15]

Tilak sir had come to my school as a chief guest in 2018. Absolutely loved his speech and I'm very excited excited to listen to this podcast. Thank you ranveer, for bringing such amazing guests!🎉

[@NDA2202-n6m]

W school

[@DrABC2025]

Thats pretty amazing that your school brought such a distinguished personality

[@irfanfaiza7079]

Many thanks to you Tilak Sb!! I am going to read your books - loads of respect from Lahore!

[@sunitamukherjee2500]

I am watching every episode and I am so thrilled to see what kind of knowledge and exposure you are offering to the youths. We owe you Ranveer! Thanks a lot! We want more Ranveers like you, but you are rare.. :) I am a mother of 15 years old and he is the one who introduced me to you.

[@hkaur2268]

See, now, this is the kind of comment I'd like ranveer to acknowledge and like! Yours is the kind of audience that he also perhaps wished to reach🙏

[@drrabiairfan993]

Hi! My ancestors were from Bihar India and got settled in Karachi.....i really enjoyed ur show and listening to the whole saga from an intellual across the border.

[@namansinghrao7876]

Tilak sir...Vikram sood... ranganathan sir...J sai...shiv khera..shiv aroor..a lot more...these guys are the best to listen to...i hope u'll keep inviting these legends❤

[@baala9]

Because they tell you what you want to hear. Half truths.

[@jamesfairbanks9798]

@@baala9 and we should suppose that you are the purveyor of truth?! Hahaha

[@itsover9008]

​@@baala9 Source: trust me bro? On what basis are they saying half truths? Proof please.

[@_armni]

36:48 As a citizen of GB (Gilgit Baltistan) specifically from the Siachen region, it is accurate to acknowledge that our region lacks certain essential facilities that are available to the residents of Ladakh and Kargil. The condition of our roads is subpar, healthcare services are notably inadequate, and the region is serviced by only two universities throughout Gilgit-Baltistan.

[@youttt27]

Honey, you reap what you sow…don’t grumble! Read Quran go to the mosque afterall Jannat awaits…

[@adityamathur5972]

@@youttt27 aw cmon man hows it his fault?

[@RamCharan-oc1ow]

So who controls & administers your region? Is there a separate Prime Minister and Budget for Gilgit Baltistan?

[@Ludu692]

@@youttt27why spread hate 😢

[@raobilaltariq9379]

Compare it from ladakh infrastructure of skardu is way better

[@sudaiskhan232]

Your guest has more knowledge about our country than many of our historians. The best bit is that he is totally unbiased and all his history is based on factual documentation. Absolutely loved the podcast!

[@TamerlanVliyev]

I am watching frome Azerbaijan you.Your podcasts are very good🇦🇿🇦🇿🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@PulkitAgrawal1999]

Sorry to mention this buddy, but India has totally sided with Armenia in the Azerbaijan Armenian conflict.

[@TamerlanVliyev]

@@PulkitAgrawal1999 No problem bro.This is the choice of the current government.But if you look at the past for example the 20th century you will see how deep the economic cultural and political relations between Azerbaijan and India are

[@TamerlanVliyev]

Choose Indian government

[@PulkitAgrawal1999]

@@TamerlanVliyev Yeah true. Anyways we individuals are not governments. We can definitely respect and admire each other even if the governments don't 😁

[@TamerlanVliyev]

@@PulkitAgrawal1999 absolutely bro

[@biprareigns7930]

The amount of sufferings the Bengali Hindus & Punjabis have suffered because of these radical islamists is beyond explanation !! I still remember my grandmother telling me how Hindus were butchered during direct action day & Noakhali riots !! These jihadis are still the same today & way worse !!

[@nafisanajnin7045]

Absolutely

[@Tasnim33]

There are stories of Muslims in Bengal being tortured out of their homes too. It was all an unfortunate situation 😞

[@biprareigns7930]

@@Tasnim33 Still negligible !! The atrocities on the Bengali Hindus from 1905 -1947 , 1946 Noakhali riots , 1971 or even till today by the Muslims ( Both bengali & others) is beyond explanation!!

[@BeastBoy-ph6gc]

May be there is certain section of extremist in every culture religion and society. As a human we cant accept any of these thousands of muslims killed and murdered by extemist hindu groups and sikhs there are thousand of stories and we all share same soft corner for everyone who were targeted

[@Seevawonderloaf]

@@Tasnim33an entire army came to murder Hindus in bangladesh. In kashmir Hindus were killed by Muslims. Don’t tell me it is the same level

[@74abdulkhaliq]

I really have to THANK YOU for showing us another side of the coin & this was truly an inspirational but more of an eye opening Podcast. I remember that renowned & educated journalists have commented about understanding this perspective about the history taught to us. My heartfelt gratitude, please continue your amazing work. Now, at least I can evaluate our stand & the so called broken system we live in

[@Shubham0514]

Mr Tilak have written few books on same context. You can try them I’m currently reading “Pashtuns.”

[@74abdulkhaliq]

Unfortunately I prefer audiobooks, so if you have a link for Pashtun please share it

[@youttt27]

There’s only one truth though…and it’s not subjective.

[@parthdeshmukh1112]

Ranveer should really consider hiring some other talanted interviewer to ask question the more I see him the more I realise he's just a dude who likes ask random question and put it on KZbin to some of the best minds out thier .No research,no homework, no prerequisites just straight up asks random question at back of his mind I bet he doesn't even prepare them before the podcast I mean seriously dude I've really loved some of your podcast but you're being increasingly amature you should read Mr.tilaks books and asked him to expand on them, indo- pak war are basically general knowledge at this point IN ALL IN ALL REALLY DO SOME REDING AND RESERCH ON RELATED TOPIC BEFORE THE PODCAST BEST WISHES ❤

[@anujnigam12]

Haha nailed it. I had the same thoughts. He didn't do any pre read. Forget that, things that are quite basic these days like 1971 scene, assassination of ziya before George Bush running for presidential elections or Kargil facts are news to him. Do some research man before calling these eminent people

[@puravin]

Well said👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@nethravathidr]

I agree, when the guests hold so much knowledge, it's wise to come prepared to get more information which isn't available for easy access

[@niveditamishra6875]

Tilak sir, please speak about the condition of POWs. During 1971 War, my dad (Corp of Engineers) was posted at Jagannath Gunj in Assam at India-East Pak border. This issue is very close to the hearts of many army kids like me. It could have been my dad. I wasn't even born then, but still. Why can't we get our "Missing 54" back?

[@prasheeldesai]

My god! what an episode!!! I was so waiting for Mr. Devasher to be back on your show for 2nd episode. Please bring 3rd one soon. Just wow. Thank you, Ranveer.

[@muhammadqaiserkhan6598]

Enlightening conversation. Thanks for keeping it truthful and unbiased

[@tarass8737]

Jinnah not knowing about the violence that will take place is an absolute joke. He knew exactly how violent his Muslim brothers could be. There were plenty of regular examples of that pre-independence dating back decades and centuries. He was the one to incite the Kolkata killings by calling for direct action day. He knew what kind of violence would erupt. He just didn't realise Hindus and Sikhs will fight back equally hard 😂 that's what he didn't expect. In other riots prior to the 1947 violence Muslims were only faced with regional communities of Hindus and it was also never something that was as big as partition which involved displacement of people and what do people value more than their roots and Heritage in India? Nothing! Plus before this Hindus were almost always caught off-guard with these violent riots started by Muslims this was different. So, when you say Jinnah didn't know the kind of violence that would erupt it's just that he didn't expect as much muslims to die 😂

[@genericguy_]

Infantilization of leaders is something that buslims are very fond of doing 😂 Notice how they claim that their prophet was illiterate, couldn't read or write, how could he have known this or that??!! similarly jinnah, the UK educated barrister, had no idea the violence that would have happened??!! hilarious 😭

[@genericguy_]

"He just didn't realise Hindus and Sikhs will fight back equally hard"...... How could he when our great leader gandhi decided to side with the buslims during the 1921 moplah roits and 1946 noakhali roits. This is what he said - 'Hindus should not harbour anger against buslims even if the latter want to destroy and kill us all. We should face death bravely. If buslims established their rule after killing Hindus we'd be ushering in a new India" 😭🤣

[@puneetmishra4726]

Spot on.

[@gunjanroy07]

U nailed it

[@shivthakur1957]

Another attempt to show these radicals as Human just to gain more views 😂

[@yaqoobrox3537]

If you can get Syed muzammil shah on your podcast (Pakistani journalist) then I’d go crazy. He’s the one that unapologetically spits facts and he would be so very important to discuss the truth

[@rizhas9008]

Muzamil is on pay role of Pakistani army and just speak to win the hearts of Non Pakistanies.

[@yaqoobrox3537]

@@rizhas9008 ok what proof do you have for this. I’ll believe it but you need to have sort of backing for your claim, otherwise it’s just your opinion.

[@Hammasmhmd]

Yeah you should bring Syed muzammil a Pakistani journalist.

[@mikejoeinc.1478]

You are right . Am a pakistani and this all is eye opening . I Will have to do More research on it, but after what our army is doing to our own people these days . there is no telling

[@sarangvyas4767]

Dear Ranveer, please call Tilak sir for the third episode soon! Amazing Podcast! Hats off Tilak Sir

[@vivekanandadas2463]

It’s naive to think that Jinnah didn’t expect violence of a massive scale considering that it he who incited the Direct Action Day killings in 1946.

[@Nationalist04]

Exactly I think the reason he thought it was a mistake is it would have been difficult to run the country without the major business class (hindus n Sikhs)

[@Shuvorgaan]

16:43 As a Bangladeshi I would like to add that A K Fazlul Haque, one of the prominent leaders in Bengal wanted three separate countries in a conference arranged at Lahore in 1940. But after the 1946 Kolkata riot, everything seems to have changed. And as the heat of the moment of Muslim brotherhood rose the separate East Bengal movement hadn’t seen any light. Till this day I feel ashamed of being ruled by Pakistanis and feel the pain my people went through pak military atrocities.

[@inchlund413]

Are u a Muslim Bangladeshi?

[@DC-pm9lc]

Why are Bangladeshis so hateful towards us nowadays tho?

[@abhimanusingh66]

​@@inchlund413why does it matter?

[@humayounmustafa2173]

We did not give you the rights which you constitutionally had, starting from 1958 onwards. We created the reasons to split up. As Pakistanis we are ashamed with what we did to our brothers.

[@WadoodsWorld99099]

which 3 countries kindly explain AK Fazlul haque views

[@kumudjaisinghani534]

Unfortunately Not all Hindus who came to India at that time got a property because my and Grandmother small around 14 years old when they came to India and they suffered alot bt with God's grace they made it Really good living in less time I know all this because since my childhood I have grown up listening to their stories .

[@ankitakapoor7252]

Exactly!! It’s very true

[@NovelTuber]

Bring Abhijit Chavda sir back pls, so much has happened since his last episode

[@harshb747]

No, he is just conspiracy theorist

[@Sameer-rj3kc]

Self proclaimed historian . Who whines about Nehru

[@PastelNuages]

​@@Sameer-rj3kc as he should.

[@Aj-ev3dn]

@@Sameer-rj3kc is nehru you baap ? Why you take so personally?😂

[@UltimateFarmer007]

​@@harshb747no he isn't he is the best

[@thehaidered]

A well explained and near to realism.....what a podcast 👍 @beerbiceps Tons of Felicitations from 🇵🇰 Tilak Sahab 👍

[@sahelishkumar4281]

This guy is ocean of knowledge (Gyaan ka sagar) As a Pakistani agrees to him to a great extent

[@ahad78]

hello from Islamabad - good insights and perspective by Mr Tilak … well done !

[@prasadshinde1092]

Bring back J sai Deepak

[@poojasingla9693]

Ofcourse.. and also deep dive his books

[@theteacher9933]

Bro JSD has been accused in court because he freely answered ranveer

[@BharathiFromSouth]

The title should be "Do we need POK or Not" As a Bharathiya we don't need.

[@adityabhatia1035]

​@@BharathiFromSouthwe need the land not the people of it

[@bhonsle-family]

He too busy

[@ALJVD]

Every Pakistani needs to hear this man.

[@Shehryar89]

To get deluded 😂😂😂

[@WajidAlinylonandsteel]

I may not be familiar with this guest, but I want to express my sincere respect for him. As a Pakistani, I believe that discussions on history can sometimes be influenced by nationalistic propaganda. In my opinion, this individual is the only Indian voice I would consider listening to when it comes to discussing Pakistani history

[@vaibhavtiwari2102]

You should watch the previous episode of him also

[@TruthPrevailz]

A lot of Indian voices say the exact same things tilak devershar does !!!!

[@yashpednekar331]

Bro a lot of Indian and Pakistani experts say the same thing. So why you feel he is different?

[@ramanroach9702]

Long story short you can't deny the fact that democracy has failed in pak that means something is wrong...it may be some of the facts are not correct as you wanted them to be...but majority are correct

[@pashamuna2190]

Okay

[@kshuny]

The episode looked like Ranveer had no idea what and how to keep the communication going. None of the questions felt you have brought the real perspectives of Tilak Devasher .

[@imranahmed2640]

Bring someone with Knowledge of Afghanistan , their history is quite interesting too, the one country in the Asia Pacific which the British found very difficult to manage..

[@tubhaykar]

Firstly, I want to commend Ranveer on a great podcast-there’s so much to learn from it. The perspectives presented by Tilak sir were so rich and insightful, shedding light on the "whys" behind the "whats" of such a complex topic. That said, I recognize how challenging these discussions can be. At times, it seemed like Ranveer was so focused on keeping the conversation relevant that it led to some moments where his lack of familiarity with certain topics, like Gilgit-Baltistan, became evident. Some questions may have felt a bit off-track or unprepared. However, considering all that Ranveer brings to the table through his incredible lineup of guests, this is a minor issue. It’s also worth noting that he’s young and unafraid to ask questions, which is admirable. At his age, I wasn’t half as sharp! Overall, it’s a fantastic podcast. My only suggestion for Ranveer would be to invest a bit more time in preparation when hosting such knowledgeable guests, to fully do justice to the value they bring. Keep up the great work!

[@TruthSeekerAlwaysOfficial]

With all due respect, Ranveer and his generation are so American aligned... one could easily see via questioning Ranveer was finding it difficult to comprehend why India did not align with US and Russia supported India in 1971.

[@rizhas9008]

Cry cry

[@adhirbose9910]

They are not allied with anyone except themselves. They think the west, especially the US is cool and happening, and if we ( India) had very good relations with the US and west it would be so much easier to get tourist and work visas to go there. And after coming back to India I can boast to my friends and family of how great the US is, and what a blast we had there.

[@kharkhuadexor]

I noted that too lol. His face..why was it so difficult to understand that we were not taking sides. I think it was such a strong move to take for such a nascent country. So that we don't get sucked in the power battle of two superpowers. Even now our position is not too far different, though we call it multialignment. I mean there is ofcourse a difference, we look at our interest 1st but yk.

[@shibi.raj3]

Russia stood with us when none of the others did… so even though Russia might look weak or rebellious, it’s that massive respect and loyalty that we have towards Russia and we continue doing the same

[@garfieldzzzzzzzzzz]

Very true.

[@venkatarohitpunyapu8449]

A suggestion would be, read the books written by your guest or any relevant information about the guest. The depth of your questions would increase

[@tejamysore3699]

Ranveer, please invite Chandrachur Ghose to discuss his new book 1947-1957 India: The birth of a republic. Fascinating book about how politics formed in India and how those thoughts shaped our entire political conscience and are relevant to this day. Can be a long discussion. Thank you 🙏

[@kashmirasawant-i8f]

Both the episodes of Tilak Sir was fantastic ❤, was very keen to know how Indo- Pak happened.

[@Jojo19062]

When is abhijit iyer mitra episode coming??

[@sanskarzade3358]

🫡

[@thisissalvi]

Bhaaaaaaisaab .. !!! Salut boss .. u have come a long way bro .. ** Just awesome .. now in your fan club **

[@vikrantpathak7165]

I was really waiting for this episode I don't know why it took you so much time after you told us that next episode will be a week ahead! But still thank you for this one. This is really very unbiased information from sir!❤❤

[@poonamjaisinghani8437]

Sindhhi Hindus came to India, they didnt get any properties. They started from zero. No one has acknowledged their sacrifice truly.

[@enterashutosh]

this perticular podcast is good, the editing, the jokes, it's quite a revamp, looks more like "content", love it.

[@tejamysore3699]

Ranveer, please also do a podcast on why the Pak economy has fallen to such an extent. Many young folks may not know, but for the longest time, in the 70s 80s and 90s, Pak was waaay ahead of India and always had better prosperity and projections. It was not inconceivable that Kashmir would go to Pak. It can't be as simple as no more funding from the US and hence economy has faltered, there have to be systemic issues and it would have to be a sequence of bad decisions - a chain reaction. Hoping that this discussion will raise a number of issues that even India should be mindful of.

[@sandeephalder2562]

Pak was waaay ahead of India? utter bull

[@davesprivatelounge]

@@sandeephalder2562 PK was ahead for a few decades during the cold war because it would get billions from the US

[@rachanacparmar]

They would send out their army personnel as mercenaries for hire eg In Jordan , black September, General Zia and troops killed all the Palestinian refugees...

[@Ravi9A]

It is that simple.

[@niyaspkd]

dude they are facing everything because of zia and mushraff and their policies when they came to power. radicalisation. no democrary. etc etc. it took 30 years for the after effects to be evident.they were too much obsessed with india instead of focusing on building their nation. they focused on planning to destroy india.they spent all their money on unwanted stuff . its very simple

[@9741vijay]

@beerbiceps - Correction at 23.11 ,it was US seventh fleet and not 6th . Commendable podcast and enhanced our knowledge on neighbour . Would recommend you to cover more of geo politics , some speakers from PAK .

[@varun7104]

1. हम सभी को घर वापसी कराने वाली संस्थाएं जैसे संजीव नेवर जी की "अग्निवीर संस्था" की सहायता करना चाहिए 2. आज के समय में अपने बच्चों को अपना नैरेटिव स्वयं देने की बहुत अधिक आवश्यकता है, इसीलिए "kritinova" पर उपलब्ध पुस्तकें अपने बच्चे, मुख्यतः बच्चियों को अवश्य पढ़वाए 🙏

[@bilalraza9406]

Mr. Devashar beautifully portrayed the Indian side of picture. Not agreeing to all of what he said but huge respect for him 🙏

[@Direct_Dil_Se15]

Extremely Rich and Accomplishing Video that Replenishes the Aura of History Across Radcliffe Line........

[@muhammadabdullah6466]

please do a podcast and get to know pakistani prospective you should cover both sides of the story

[@ShahidHaider-g1p]

tilak devasher is gem i read his book about pashtun history as a pashtun i do not have much history of pashtuns as he did in his book

[@shreyasi9816]

Fantastic and illuminating conversation as always. Next time you meet Tilak sir, you can ask him what went right for India. I mean we've heard so much about corrupt politicians that we've had, but then what worked out for us, so that we are in a good position today on the world stage 😊😊

[@cyrusthegreat3081]

USSR collapsed Rajiv, a socialist assassinated World refused to loan money IMF out conditions to open economy PVRao brought in Manmohan, a socialist, who understood the mistake implemented IMf conditions flawlessly!

[@hammadrehman1682]

However crippled or imperfect it was, you had democracy. We have never seen a day without military's rule. 240 million people at the behest of handful mindless Generals.

[@diyashome7002]

I think it is the honest middle class

[@cyrusthegreat3081]

@@diyashome7002 does that mean india never had honest Middle class before 1991? Learn about license Raj and how Nehru family had iron grip on business! Learn about failed socialism!

[@diyashome7002]

@@cyrusthegreat3081 I am just saying that our middle class household is every honest ... Till today you will see many people buying local railway tickets...they will buy tickets , monthly quarterly ... Yes there is a certain level of dishonesty also but the middle class household is still doing its part in instilling values

[@harsha737]

The guest was perfect, may be B M Hegde ,dr aarthi VB , Jai Sai Deepak of course

[@davajohn7151]

Please invite lhador lama from Dharamsala is Tibetan Liberay incharge and former DalaiLama tranaslater, is very deep knowledge of modern living from ancient Indian thought.

[@urviashokwaghela1427]

The topics felt scattered but honestly this was way informative than any other sources.. I hope Tilak sir comes back and they carry forward their conversation from the topic left.. Ranveer was amazing as always but I hope next time he is much prepared with the podcast.

[@umair5940]

No one in GB and POK is asking to be included in India. Yes they want rights but it is absurd to think they want to become part of india.

[@multiversegirl3725]

I will see this podcast after doing my school homework I know this podcast will also be full of knowledge like other podcasts.

[@maithilideole6703]

Please even invite Marathi superstars singers and also kashmiri pandit history topic 1990 Kashmir files ! Also invite Vivek agnihotri and pallavi Joshi

[@akshatatapashetti]

My 7 year old is listening to your podcast . Thank you Ranveer!

[@aniketlad1736]

Syed muzzamil one person you should have on show. The only pakistani I trust.

[@sanjay2306]

Thank you sir too much knowledge learned❤

[@VRihanna]

Do a sindhi history podcast. I want to know more about sindhi history which we don’t get to read

[@tayyabshahzad688]

Tilak Devasher is a national treasure.

[@AryanPaaji]

From POK 🏔️ to Kashmir exodus 💔 to Bangladeshi intention 🇧🇩 and further, they are the major geopolitical negative scenarios 😥.

[@Abdul.Haseeb70]

We are sandwiched between the big powers Russia USA UK 🇵🇰 even INDIA ironically speaking that’s actually true and this shit goes own

[@adityagupta-en8eb]

Bro the sad part is our past politicians knowingly did all those things. They very well knew we were being used and were divided so that we don't become big powers and they idiots still let them do that just for power. But it's never too late , we still can grow peacefully together

[@Jai_Hind88]

Tilak Sir a genius and Navratna of Bharat. Jai Hind, Bharat Mata ki Jai

[@akatfun]

think the anchor jumps from one topic to other quickly without getting indepth answers. Mr Devasher is having answers but being pulled to different topics so quickly..

[@SandeepSingh-ty9yu]

Ranveer, when you have such an experienced and distinguished guest for a complicated topic. I expect you to be a bit prepared. This was all over scattered. Glad that you acknowledged it however didn’t attribute to your preparedness. Just my 2 cents as a critic. Otherwise love your guest and what you are doing! Cheers! 🍻

[@nikeetdesai9364]

Beautiful podcast. Knowledge, Stories, Real Life Experiences and Quality Time spend watching it. As I will call it in Hindi - Jigyasa Ke Madhyam Se Anand Ki Anubhuti ( my version of your tagline - Happyness Through Curiosity ). Keep up the good work that you and your team are doing.

[@asadabbasmirza9519]

Tilak wries very well just like a story.

[@themillennialchico]

If someone wants to know about 1971 war I would recommend IB71 movie of vidyut jamwal sir & It's a great that same topic is included in today's podcast.

[@hkaur2268]

I was actually thinking about that movie when they were talking about the land mass in between and the logistics.. IB71 is such an underrated movie.. it has so much for us to realize what all defense has to do behind my scenes .. 😢 also I see ranveer always gives movie references in such situations... he din in this one so it appears he hadn't seen it ..

[@basit5]

Sorry, can't watch that clown's movie. I will stick to books and documentaries.

[@harjassingh6786]

What should I say about you... you and palki sharma have cracked, how to reach your audience and pass information in most simple way...

[@usamanizami4935]

Lot of knowledge , Best podcast

[@surajshivan4976]

While I have criticised Ranveer in the past earlier on how he handled questions and general flow of the podcast, I have to admire he’s done a tremendous job of sticking to timelines , bringing the audience along and keeping this very vast topic easy to understand.

[@josephandrews5467]

21.27 Not the 6 th Fleet. A flotilla of the 7th Fleet headed by US Aircraft carrier Enterprise .

[@shankey311992]

Bhai I really enjoy your podcasts, you are doing a great job. Now having said that there is one thing that I want to suggest is that it's better you do some basic research on the subject that you are discussing in your show, because if you are inviting an expert like Tilak sir you should take that opportunity to have a deeper understanding of the matter rather than barely scratching the surface. Earlier podcasts with Tilak sir were much better this one looks very basic as you were just probing the commonly known facts.

[@AhsanShah-xm6vp]

43:06 = He was mentioning General Chishti => Corp Commander of 10th Corp at the time

[@aishu-bx4qz]

I was so sure Vijayadasami episode would be devi part 2 with rajarshy nandi sir 😂😢

[@ronitlenka9205]

Exactly...this is what I also thought. Disappointed to be honest!

[@babyishuu.3653]

Yes..we wanted rajashri sir❤❤

[@shambhuprasad8434]

Excellently summarized by Tilak Deveshwar sir

[@sadhanakarve9113]

Proud to have great ppl like Tilak sir 🙏🙏🙏

[@pankaj29904]

When the US sent it's Seventh Fleet in Bay of Bengal, general (later field marshal) Sam Maneckshaw openly said let them send it, I know how to deal with it.

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

O plz . Jinnah declared direct action day wasnt that violence? So after partition what was he expecting ? Moth eaten bcz jinnah didnt get entire bengal and punjab Not bcz hindus left 😅 What bs

[@roman5782]

Finally, a sane Bengali spotted.

[@darpansingh7982]

great episode but ranveer was not listening to what tilak sir was saying, it looked like he was more focused on the questions.

[@KuhuAlba]

Hello ranveer., I love watching your podcasts. Please bring back abhijit chavda sir again…. We really need to understand what is happening around work and how will it affect us now or in coming future….

[@prateekmonirba]

Correction Bhutto never made the comment idahr tum udhar hum. It was published in paper as his comment and news paper owner later acknowledged the fact that it was not Bhutto comment

[@guruprasadshetty9735]

With the number of geopolitics beerbiceps had covered, this conversation should have been in flow instead of getting scattered and moving here and there… many times I felt like the guest is explaining something and then the next topic is 25-50 years later or before and at least the host should have read the guest’s books and that should have enlightened him about what questions to ask in a flow so that it keeps the conversation interesting to viewers when one is talking to such an elite expert

[@rohanagarwal6848]

After watching so many podcast of your show .I feel you have some soft corner for Pakistanis waisa mindset ki hum ek he toh hai which is dangerous for our country

[@jethiya7990]

Happy Dussehra Ranveer 🙏🏼 Always keep shining and help us also shine 😊

[@librasays1806]

So far I am at 16 mins couldn't resist to watch whole for the acknowledgement. My grandparents are from indore and still we have relatives, my great great grandfather bought the haveli from a Hindu family in Karachi where both families lived for some time together and than they left for India. Muhajir is the term used in derogatory manner but yes muhajir is the term as the identity for the ethnicity. Urdu speaking Muhajirs.

[@catchjyoti]

Ranveer - for these kind of topics a bit less exhuberence will help. Also be a bit more prepared for the shoe. Some ofthe questions were scattered.

[@Dr.Aditya-Agrawal]

The podcast clearly shows the distinction between a professional and an amature. Ranveer comes out with half baked information, which Tilak sir corrects politely. It clearly exposes the tribe of You Tubers who claim to be opinion makers, but who do not invest enough in knowledge, who cover a lot of breadth, without going into depth. I watched by skipping the questions and just listening to Devasher sahab.

[@bedanga748]

The non alignment movement actually was a great move initiated by Nehru and initial Congress government. Despite the all the hate, we have to appreciate Nehru for the forward thinking that has benefited us majorly today. Even today, India follows the same ideology in terms of foreign policy.

[@dasgupta8602]

Multi - Alignment is our Policy now, under the Garb of Non - Alignment we were always tilted towards THE USSR, Indo- US relations got better only after the 2008 Nuclear Deal.....

[@NewWorld413]

Non alignment policy was okay but multi alignment is best policy which we are doing right now. But in any situation when you are not in any group... the most important thing is building own security army with good weapons where nehru just done worst things so he get the flake of the people. You say you are not with anyone but you are not remain ready to fight or secure the nation then you remain very vulnerable... which made them almost go in USSR group which defeated main non alignment 🤦‍♂️

[@let_it]

Wrong....grossly wrong...we were never non aligned. We were with USSR all along. It costed us our permanent seat in UNSC, it costed us kashmir, it costed us balonchistan and coco island....Nehru was not far sighted, he was selfish...

[@harjassingh6786]

Friends... please speak to some one of that era .....what they felt when India got independence... How our leaders got India out of British hand's....what were the geo political powers at that time...how weakened we were economically... don't forget...our constitution give us India togather....we were fighting British for freedom but we were fragmented into 546 princely states... so don't jump the gun.... those leaders had empty hand's to begin country progress.... world around them was different.. just out of 2nd world war....... don't criticise Nehru bcos he was Congress man...he was the pm of nation..... maybe 50years later current PM could be judged poorly for his performance.....each PM irrespective of the political party...they work best in the current geo political environment.... India is our motherland and collective conscience is prime.... 🙏🙏

[@let_it]

@@harjassingh6786 yes this is coming from a person whose family was massacred due to Nehru's stupidity. Sardar vallabhai Patel was from Congress and I admire him even with his flaws. And instead of asking please READ history. India was not united because of constitution but because of the military of India which was against the democratic rights of the princely states. READ the constitution. The very constitution discriminates among the Indians. The very constitution upholds the judiciary as a form of feudal parallel without any accountability. The very constitution will break India one day if not mended on time. The so called masterpiece of Ambedkar is ridden with flaws so instead of praising the idiots of that time please READ

[@a.mishra1835]

Nice insights😊

[@jerrysoni412]

Bring Arif Mohammed khan sir to your show please 🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@mahrukhagha]

One correction . GILGIT is paradise on earth and has zero crime rate . I v been there ... interacted with locals . Their education is 99 percent . They don't want to be a part of India and get killed by Indian army . They also love China because of support they extended to GB during Attabads lake incident

[@theanalyst1367]

i think ranveer you should read more to ask better and much more relative questions , i realised in the podcast that it was going here and there . Otherwise tilak sir is a legend and he spoke well .

[@MitrasenS]

First Comment on reality. Ranveer, bro you're champ, but it takes a hell lot of another levels effort in interviewing intellectuals like Tilak Ji. No offence, but you can even prepare in advance and keep a notepad, no shame in it. You're still cool.

[@AshwinMaloo79]

Dhanyavad 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@sudipbiswas5185]

All the muslim properties in India given to Waqf by Rajib Gandhi. Not to the Hindus who had came from Pakistani....J Sai Deepak.

[@saugatjarif8272]

Love from Bangladesh ❤

[@rajkothari4232]

Hello Ranveer, Please have a podcast with jain terapanth sadhus and sadhvis. It would be enlightening..

[@muthurs00]

It was the 7 Fleet deployed by the US ...not the sixth fleet...The Russian fleet turned up and the 7 Fleet supposed to be the most advanced Flotilla at that time slowly sailed away

[@immv.7]

Please bring Jain experts to explore Jain dharm and history.. My suggestion is to bring Mehul bhai .. Jain Media's Guy.....

[@supreethrn2335]

I have two guest suggestions: 1. Someone who can narrate the first hand account of the partition (very few people left of this generation and they deserve to be listened to before they vanish) 2. Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed who wrote a few books on partition and known for his contrarian view of Pakistani establishment back then

[@DevKotak23]

Do a 2 guest podcast. Abhijit Chavda & J Sai Deepak together 🔥