Begg, Carter, Lawson, Sproul, and Sproul Jr.: Questions and Answers #1

[@mikewalsh7997]

Alistair Begg always strikes me as such a even, fair and openly loving Christian.

[@evbennett1]

After going to the Ligonier conference,I was so very blessed by the love of God these men of God have for one another,they are truly so very real,and when you hear the word of God being preached what a difference ,so refreshing to hear the word in whole with out it being taking out of context and giving the hearers the whole truth,being very challenged and encouraged to continue the race,to serve God with all my heart,to seek God and to study the word myself and to go deeper in Christ,being renewed in mind and spirit by the Holy Spirit to God Glory.

[@John_3-16_Psalm_34]

I love him too.

[@BasedBalboni]

His voice is so soothing. I could listen to him preach or even talk for hours

[@alexz31cujo31]

He has a shepherd's heart.

[@reneeb.1255]

Amen.

[@subiramukami9157]

R.C. Cracks me up every time. Awh, it brings a smile to my face to know that he is with Jesus now!

[@davidstone5595]

*May* be in heaven.

[@Elite_Evolutions]

me too

[@tiramisu5901]

“The best of men are men at best.”-Alastair Begg

[@lainegordon5831]

J c Ryle quote, but yes, a great one toquote

[@mesafintfanuel3627]

Something supernatural happened to me when the black guy preached. When he said Christ invites us to his spiritual kingdom not the other way around. There was a sudden understanding of this truth but the understanding was an almost divine understanding, a revelation. I just saw the tuth of the supernatural kingdom of God folks.

[@tiramisu5901]

Pastor Anthony Carter

[@ibperson7765]

Awesome. Important and profound point. But it is both ways. He in the Father and in us and we in Him. I hear ya, but saying that inviting Christ into your heart is bad... is insane🙄. I’ll still be doing it daily. But yes and Amen “the Kingdom is among ye”.

[@freespeech24]

@@ibperson7765 either way you are responding to His knocking. So you are asking Him to come because He called you first

[@ibperson7765]

@@freespeech24 Agree

[@freespeech24]

@@ibperson7765 simple isnt it to understand but these people so superficial

[@timspark_jt]

Who's back here in 2024?😊 It's always a delight to listen to these men. I thank God for them.

[@willowbrook2717]

Thankfully Allistar Begg is on this stage. Wisdom and grace combined with eloquence.

[@Renewed85]

I am so grateful for men that speak on what the Bible says! Hate it or love it, The Word of God says what it says. No apologies given.

[@robertevras6577]

Just love the deeply thoughtful way that Alistair Begg shares the Gospel. Even in disagreement he is seeking the highest and best truth of our Father in Heaven.

[@ILfarmgirl1970]

After looking into the Ligoneer's and R.C. Sproul's son's perversions and protection, to see Alister's name with these men broke my heart. From your comment, I may watch this. But for now, I am just thankful to know he disagreed with these men, even in some form.

[@neverpc4404]

@@ILfarmgirl1970had RC jr. had his issues prior to this or after? I think it was after as this is 10+ years ago. I don’t know for sure just wondering out loud

[@freespeech24]

Pastor Alistair has a gift of wisdom and discernment

[@David_Lindblom]

Thank you Ligonier for these videos. Even after nine years being able to go back and watch and learn and be blessed by them.

[@live4truth100]

Thanks for leaders who care about true theology

[@andreateran3829]

☑☑☑💙 la claridad de R.C. para explicar es increíble, todo el panel es maravilloso.

[@candeyeldred2655]

I was hooked from the first question and smiled and applauded all the way through. Beautiful, well done.

[@lisabblessed6629]

Oh yes! He draws us or we would not go looking

[@tawidin9686]

God bless these men of Jesus the lord

[@lisabblessed6629]

Amen!! I have heard invite Him my whole life. Holy Spirit testifies to the Truth you are speaking.

[@tessiedoyle]

Scottland is the land of the Reformation and great speakers for Christ. And I love John MacArthur!!!!

[@hikerJohn]

I'm still neutral on MacArthur. He's pretty hard to agree with some times but he's usually good and Ive been listening to him for 38 years. I agree with his basic theology but he gets into the weeds on to many specifics. I cannot understand why he holds on to a per-tribulatin eschatology for example.

[@2mexpesos]

John Because is clear in the Bible :) the rapture will occur at any time this is the rapture of the Church, Jesus will "raptured" us from this earth in a blink of an eye! Like a thief in the night! Therefore we have to be ready and repent daily to be in obedience. Now, I think the confusion some have is about the second coming of Jesus which is at the 7th trumpet 🎺 all eyes will see our lord Jesus coming back to earth as the King of Kings. I'd recommend John MacArthurs book on the second coming ... God bless!

[@newhorizon1355]

John MacArthur has not apogized nor retracted his words that a Christian can except the Mark of Satan and still go to heaven when they die. So, sadly, I no longer listen to him.

[@newhorizon1355]

@@2mexpesos Theologian Walter Martin exposed the falsehood of the Rapture. a little girl 147 years ago had a so called vision then a Puritan preacher formed the Rapture idiology. The Church did NOT preach, teach, or instruct on the Rapture. They taught that at the Second Coming then we will be gathered up with Jesus in the clouds....... So MaCurthers rapture idiology is now effecting his theology. He said because no Christians are left after rapture, anyone living in the time if great testing can place Satan's Mark on them and still die and go to heaven.

[@kellystrauss9888]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHjIfH2bq9WjraM

[@davidmoore3329]

This is one of my favourite Ligonier Q&A’s. All panellists were excellent.

[@jackeedaimary2669]

It's a Very very authentic conference

[@wally1452]

I love Rc Sproul. It's 2023 now and I have been hearing & reading his books since 1971 & on. I also Loved Anthony's answer on we being compelled to come to the Lord rather than we are approaching Him or deciding for Him.

[@olgaburgos7780]

I see that all of you think very necessary to belong to a church, I am not a member of any church due to the fact that I have not found ,in the several that I was a member, not a pure gospel was preached, there are false beliefs, requirements and added things to have the assurance of salvation, Jesus is not enough, is always Jesus plus. Now, as an old woman, listening to wonderful sermons by many of you ministers and searching the scriptures for proof of truth, I do not miss church going.Thank you Pastors, I learn different biblical truths from many of you, and I know that I am saved by Gods And Jesus grace, and I am waiting for His soon coming.✝️🥰❤️😃

[@jeffrenshaw]

Amen sister. Love and blessings Jeff

[@dkimphoto]

the problem could also be you.

[@poompoom500]

I thank the good LORD GOD for these men of GOD. The LORD blesses me with the information I get from these believers in our LORD JESUS!

[@raebrown6278]

This was extremely interesting. It proves that opinions can be view differently, but still respective of each persons view. This is such an important lesson for every church that professes the belief in the Trinity and Jesus.

[@Whatashek]

Wow, didn't realize RC had such a great sense of humor haha. What a brilliant mind and teacher!

[@divinegracejesuslovesyou1466]

Rc sproul is for me a log of wood in my ocean of grief. I am crossing through by God's grace 🙏

[@OldVillagePaint]

Perfect explanation of God invites us in…

[@brittanykrieger5828]

Thank God for this ministry.

[@ads06.1]

Another amazingly beautiful, insightful, illuminating, and educational Q&A. I'm getting hooked on these! I very much enjoyed the topic discussed at 23:42 regarding salvation through faith, the forgiveness of sins, and accounting for our sins on the day of judgment. I wanted to express that I connected with Dr Begg's response, particularly when I read about and pray/meditate on the rewards, although it is very infrequent. At this point on my journey in life and walk with Christ, I find my thoughts wandering to the day of judgment and imagine what it will be like, although I know that it's only based on my limited and spiritually immature mind. My thoughts are filled with joy, humility, sadness, reverence, and to be completely transparent and authentic, fear. Joy for being in YHWH's presence, humility as I know I am truly nothing on my own and do not deserve His grace and mercy, sadness in knowing that my sins put Yeshua on the cross and that my knowingly repeated sins were like continually pounding the hammer on the nails that caused Him pain that is beyond my comprehension, reverence in coming face to face with my creator and Savior, and fear as despite knowing and believing that I am saved by His grace through faith I am ever fearful of being separated from Him which my knowingly repeated sins demand. All that to say, Dr. Begg's response connected and resonated with me-not being separated from Him is more than I deserve.

[@coswyn]

I say this with all due respect, but I think Alistair Begg is the fifth Beatle.

[@Theranchhouse1]

I love that brother ...'beatle''' lol...a mighty man of God !

[@christinemosley1475]

coswyn I’ve been saying that too!!

[@BasedBalboni]

😂🤷‍♂️

[@reneeb.1255]

❤️❤️❤️😆😆😆

[@sharonendler1467]

Pastor Begg loves the Beatles !

[@mesafintfanuel3627]

I just saw a divine revelation of the supernatural kingdom of God when the black guy preached. An divine understanding of this truth. Wow unbelievable.

[@tedpatriot2963]

I pray for our LORD CHRIST JESUS to come back sooner than later for I can longer stand the sin in this world.

[@truss601]

What will the new heavens and new earth look like. Doctor Begg : "Scotland" I could not stop laughing lol

[@bonniemoerdyk9809]

+Cody Russell Me too!

[@fyodor48alyosha67]

Bonnie Moerdyk me too, but mainly because it will prove to be *TRUE* 😀 Oh!! I am Scottish 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧😀

[@BigHonkinGoose]

Scotland IS pretty.

[@trozan2796]

Was watching this at 11:47pm and couldn't stop laughing when I heard that

[@MariaSantana-ul5wd]

Praying for these men of God who speak truth. Thank you. An analogy to the gay lifestyle is somewhat similar to a heroine addict (in a spiritual sense) for those who practice it. They are falsely comforted by what ultimately will kill them. Heartbreaking.

[@raybo632]

The last question was ,what will Heaven be like. I can't believe Jay Mac wasn't there, however I'll answer for him. I heard him say, not streets or gold but to be free from sin. Me to.

[@stevenfromer3806]

I love these men.

[@mtfrosty2cor471]

While I appreciate and smiled at some of the jokes, I've come to appreciate even more so that some of these men refrained from laughing. That example was good for me to see. We need to keep in mind that these are serious questions being asked that involve serious issues. Sometimes I can be too quick to make light of something that is a lot weightier to someone else...

[@canucktruckerbear]

Why am I not surprised in the least that it would be A witty little Scott that stands up to the legend himself😂

[@loveofreedom777]

The lies and deception going around re Luther's hatred of Jews just angers me -- These lies come from those who disagree w Calvinist views - I am extremely grateful RC explained here in this conference the truth about what happened and why -

[@robertevras6577]

Love all these Brothers....you can find them speaking on BOT Radio Network all day every day. I love to put it on in my car and have turned that time into my own private rolling university.

[@matthewsmall1817]

What’s the station

[@jamesjones536]

I enjoyed Begg and Carter's input over both sprouls and Lawson.

[@miskittt]

What??? They all were great. The young Sproul only only uses scripture to answer questions. I have much respect for that.

[@davidstone5595]

@@miskittt his *interpretation* of scripture.

[@debjesic]

All Ppl struggle! All have clay feet we all come short and have missed the Mark., how many of us fail everyday?

[@mistybrown338]

If I could ever go visit a church, it would be Allistair Begg’s.

[@betts338]

To answer to the question of the homosexual child with straight mom this is not a hard question but a very harsh answer we must love our children and continue in faith to wait on God; will He deliver them from it ? we will continue to pray and we ourselves must stand strong and in love no matter what because love will always conquer always keep the faith 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@almamoore8446]

Peace, perfect because jesus is there.

[@evelynmariayeshua]

Truth: All things came into being THROUGH HIM, from the foundation. Science can search and learn, they, the scientist can also twist and Mar truth...

[@lancezenner6177]

Lol, with all those Dr.'s " One might think your in a hospital" , great stuff to reflect on.

[@ErnestAdewoyin]

so that Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. And I pray that you, being rooted and established in love (Ephesians 3:17) telling people to accept Jesus into their hearts is definitely biblical

[@garyallum9589]

Ernest Adewoyin You're missing the entire point of what Carter was saying. Noone is denying Christ dwelling in us, but the use of "Inviting Christ", as our supposed path to salvation.

[@ErnestAdewoyin]

Gary Allum ... Isn't it? Only people with Jesus in their hearts can be saved from hell and to heaven. Everyone in hell don't have Jesus in their hearts.

[@garyallum9589]

Thats right, but Jesus isnt in our hearts because we invite him, HE invited us

[@ErnestAdewoyin]

Gary Allum ... I dont get you?????? Are you saying that Jesus invited us into our hearts? #GodBlessYou

[@mchristr]

Ernest Adewoyin I think the issue here is the accurate presentation of the Gospel. Encouraging someone to "invite Jesus into your heart" doesn't communicate what Christ has done on our behalf, nor does it command us to repent and believe (Mark 1:15).

[@rlyle5804]

in regards to question 10. I would suggest he preach the sermon Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. preach about sin and Gods judgment. One of two things will happen; repentance or unemployment. You are good either way

[@angelashort1331]

The hardening of the heart , by mankind , is the gateway ,that brings on justifying persecutions of any other .human. The tree of life is represented , in the Menorah , TO despise The people who carry that torch forward , representing the Lord, even though they don't recognise Him . To love those whom God loves is what we're called to do. No more,no less. we're called to Bless , not curse , How can we ignore that instruction .How can we augment our judgements and vilify a people God tells us to Bless , if Jewry had been treated differently , who knows what great rivers could have flowed , rivers of blessing instead of rivers of blood ? ❤

[@doctor1alex]

What an excellent answer to the first question!

[@ibperson7765]

Only half right. He is in the Father and in us and we in Him. The part about coming and the kingdom was profound, but claiming “it’s bad to invite Christ into your heart” is just ridiculous

[@PauloHenrique-th2iz]

Seria muito bom se fosse dublado ou Legendado para edificação de todos.

[@lovely_time1771]

Begg is correct in his “fellowship” ideology!

[@gustavoosorio471]

I agree. But still digesting the responses. Can you elaborate on why you are led to think so?

[@olgaburgos7780]

Not every Christian belongs to a church and depends on a pastor or elder to counsel or confront a problem. The Bible has all the right teachings and guide and answers, so if a parent is a believer ,he can depend on his biblical knowledge and the love in his heart for his child to try to change his behavior and the rest , pray,pray and pray and leave it in the hands of the Holy Spirit.

[@vcharles93]

I like how God created a balance world as (in a scale). but, then there are those who wish for it to be unbalance . God always get his way. In the end he will get his balance kingdom.

[@efficientfuture]

I really like Lawson

[@WimbledonChurch]

Sorry to see crude and ungodly comments with bad language posted here from those claiming to be more godly than the panel! Having said that I am loathe to be critical. However, ministers let their guard down a bit at fraternal conferences with one another so it may not be ideal to publish these discussions. For example to get a response to the final question "What is your view of what heaven and the new earth will be like" that begins with several silly jokes is absolutely appalling. How grievous to hear these men speaking that way. An audience giving applause only encourages this. Ministers of God don't need to be clapped when they give a doctrinal answer to a question. If I was on such a panel I really would have to ask for more reverence.

[@SlaveofChrist1]

Sir, would you mind expounding? Are you saying you want no humor? If so, why? Or maybe I'm misunderstanding you?

[@WimbledonChurch]

Dear Fred,I hope the following helps. If not , get back to me. There are two points here: 1.Ungoldy commentts posted against this video. 2. That there are strange matters in the video itself. 1. The foul language used by many posting comments about this video. It is all the more strange as while such posts criticise the video, they are themselves so ungodly as to have no credibility themselves! 2. The humour of the panel speakers does not need to be wiped out but could do with being reigned in at some points, e.g. toward the end when asked about the glory to come, the speakers respond with jokes. I find that hard to reconcile with holy men. I cannot imagine that they would joke about Jesus dying on the cross and I am sure that they would not. But the heavenly hope is so precious and holy that I cannot understand how they can respond with jokes. Why? Is it embarrassment? Is it something they only consider in an academic way and not a deep part of their hope to sustain them through the trials of the ministry? Are they really holy men? What is the explanation? It may be "conference cultural" and especially a fault of conference panels where men feel it necessary to lower themselves to a status with which they do not give the impression of superiority etc. Or is it just that they feel relaxed at a ministers' conference and let their hair down a bit too much?

[@LittleHatori]

Mill Road Church SW19 i think when they were joking around to me it didnt seem immature, or appalling. Tbh i got the impression that these men were all so genuinely comfortable with each other that they could be friendly and not stiff. It gave the whole Q & A a casual feel that i really liked. It didnt feel like a sermon (which can feel stuffy and underwhelming.) These men were happily discussing things as if they would at a family picnic. Plus i'm not appalled bc i know these men have a heart for God and r much wiser then me. I know they meant to be playful for the sake of having a nice laugh. Not to leaf anyone a stray. That's just my perspective. And i appreciate urs. C:

[@andyz3925]

Mill Road Church SW19 (est.) 10% humor 90% theology. If flipped THEN it becomes blasphemous.

[@hikerJohn]

Any foul or abusive speech should be reported as SPAM. I have not read any yet but if I do see it I will report it

[@nalun9829]

Pr Lawson said in 19:30-46. "God hates sin and He hates sinners". Respectfully, I believe that is the most outrageous theology I have never heard of. If God hates sinners, then Jesus death was in vain." I think Pr Lawson needs to correct his theological understanding on the character of God, "GOD IS LOVE" You are presenting to the world an angry God instead of a loving God who loved the world so much that He gave his only begotten Son that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life. I hope I can cheer someone who got discouraged by that discourse. cheers.

[@arclemons1967]

God is Holiness and He is righteousness. His Holiness and righteousness cannot abide those unregenerate in their sin. They are anathema. It's a Biblical truth, albeit one contrary to the 21st century ideal of a lollipop-dispensing, beatific Heavenly Father who loves all of us regardless. You've some studying to do.

[@doublediamond1234]

I'm just curious about the context of the Pastor who has little control of how his church operates.....I'm wondering if he is a pastor within a multi "campus" (personally can't stand the use of that word) church and has to follow the rules, like some sort of a franchise. I used to go to a multi location charismatic church and the "location pastors" had little to no autonomy whatsoever.

[@lainegordon5831]

i always look forward to hearing alistair begg, ..on the question of baptism, however, i kind of got the feeling he was backtracking, covering his bases a little. which i guess illustrates the complexity of views on baptism,,my own is covenantal .. the "and your household" would necessarily include children, particularly in light of first century households,..what was the chance of a household then NOT having infants?

[@gracepilditch9388]

I heard John MacArthur (believer’s baptism) and RC (covenant baptism ie baptism of infants) debate on this issue and both presented their cases extremely well. I’m with John MacArthur and was baptised when I came to faith in Christ having come out of RCism. Right now I can’t bring to mind the verses which helped shape this view. I love both these men and thank our loving Heavenly Father for them. I think you read the scriptures and make up your own mind. It’s not salvific issue. We may not agree with one another but we love one another as we are loved. One question I have, maybe you could answer? If you’re baptised as a baby could you be baptised again when you come to faith in Christ? 🤔 I ask this in all sincerity!

[@lainegordon5831]

@@gracepilditch9388 Probably because of Martin Luther, I always felt infant baptism was a sign of the covenant . "to be baptized in God's name is to be baptized not by human beings but by God" . but I agree with you- it isn't salvific,..and I think everyone would agree the thief on the cross was saved, despite no water/ baptism. Neither the act of circumcision nor the act of baptism saves someone, but what it represents.Circumcision was a symbol of the covenant, much like baptism could be considered an outward expression of an inward renewal, a new life, a new covenant. I haven't really studied this all enough, and not for several years. But this is where God has me now, I am leaning less toward infant baptism than I used to, but consider both sides to have valid points. Is the Abrahamic Covenant still in effect? Galatians 3:17 seems to imply that Paul views that covenant as a promise by God to bless Abraham and his offspring. Some would argue this is only for Israel perhaps., others say he is calling that covenant the gospel. Is the Abrahamic covenant -that in Abraham all the nations shall be blessed...in effect now? God's covenant promise was to bless all nations in Abraham, and a reference to the coming Messiah. Infants were included by God in the Abrahamic Covenant.Infants being circumcised did not comprehend what was occurring to them spiritually . If the Abrahamic covenant is still in effect -- by being equated with the gospel - would infants still be included in that same covenant? Where is the biblical admonition to exclude infants if that is still in effect? none of the epistles include a restriction of infants being included in God's covenant via baptism? Possibly less convincing support would be households, though I still agree this is a good argument.Acts 16, where the jailor and all his household were baptized, after the jailor had asked how he could be saved: And he called for lights and rushed in, and trembling with fear he fell down before Paul and Silas, 30 and brought them out and said, “Men, what must I do to be saved?” 31 And they said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.” 32 And they spoke the word of the Lord to him and to all that were in his house. 33 And he took them the same hour of the night, and washed their wounds, and he was baptized at once, with all his family. pel of Luke: "And they were bringing even infants to him, so that he might touch them. And when the disciples saw this, they rebuked them. But Jesus, calling them together, said: “Allow the children to come to me, and do not be an obstacle to them. For of such is the kingdom of God." (Luke 18:15-16). In Col 2:11-22 Paul posits circumcision and baptism, from old law to the new law. Re support for believers baptism, In the old Testament when a man wanted to be a Jew he had to believe in the God of Israel and be circumcised. In the new Testament to become a Christian we are to believe in Jesus and be baptized.That belief is obviously beyond an infant's comprehension. For a believer,the transformation (regeneration) by the Holy Spirit is the sign and seal of the New Covenant. Paul does seem to suggest some kind of a link between circumcision and baptism , and some of our doctrines are not explicitly stated in Scripture, so could that be the case here? There are centuries of disagreement on the question of infant baptism. I think if you have been baptised, there is no reason to think God wasn't working in that. But God would not mind it, I think, if you really wanted to, I err on the side that He is gracious towards us. Usually there is an objection about the extent of the work of God's grace in the lives of infants, ...but do we speak the Word of God to the spiritually oblivious unbeliever? ; is the unbeliever saved by the grace of God through the faithful preaching and teaching of the Bible? Maybe there is some measure of grace given to an infant or child whose parents are faithfully engaging in a covenantal upbringing. Possibly less convincing support would be the households argument, but first century households undoubtedly contained infants.Acts 16, where the jailor and all his household were baptized, after the jailor had asked how he could be saved: And he called for lights and rushed in, and trembling with fear he fell down before Paul and Silas, 30 and brought them out and said, “Men, what must I do to be saved?” 31 And they said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.” 32 And they spoke the word of the Lord to him and to all that were in his house. 33 And he took them the same hour of the night, and washed their wounds, and he was baptized at once, with all his family. Gospel of Luke: "And they were bringing even infants to him, so that he might touch them. And when the disciples saw this, they rebuked them. But Jesus, calling them together, said: “Allow the children to come to me, and do not be an obstacle to them. For of such is the kingdom of God." (Luke 18:15-16). In Col 2:11-22

[@lainegordon5831]

Sry about the duplicate paragraphs, won’t let me edit

[@gracepilditch9388]

@@lainegordon5831 no worries about the duplication, it happens! Thanks very much for your detailed response, I appreciate the time you took to explain and it’s highly informative. I’m still pondering and reading through Acts found this verse: Acts 2:41 41 Those who accepted his message were baptised. Suggests these were adults. Maybe there were no children present? At any rate this is not a salvation issue and we are free to settle the matter by reading God’s Word and coming to a decision.

[@myscabula]

Well let me ask this which one is worse slavery or hating God. Any brother or sister that believes it’s hard to forgive Christians for things like slavery, remember, you hated God. Which one is infinity worse. Yet The Lord forgave both for the elect.

[@doug2993]

Amen

[@almamoore8446]

In Christ we move and have our being and He is perfect. The body of Christ is the church and it is not carnal or earthly. Just as the prophets had to bring sharp words to the children of Israel so must the pastors must say what the Scriptures teach.

[@rojas2428]

I CORINTHIANS 12 ; must be given attention to Pastors because it teaches diversity and gifts in the Body of Christ . To avoid contentions and debates , every true born-again Believer , must know his gift and how to administer his group and how to relate with other groups , because we are All of One Spirit .

[@PennySmart]

Based on Alistair Begg's extended view on fellowship, women do not have fellowship in some churched, including his at Parkside Church, since they neither can preach nor be elders (rightly so in my opinion) but it shows that pastor Begg can't have really thought out his position very carefully though he's holding fast to it, while saying that in other circumstances, he would agree with RC's definition of fellowship...

[@bobvadney7240]

@ the 4:33 mark Mr.R.C.SPROUL did a great job..on the 3 fold principle of Salvation....Justified: were saved ( Past) Sanctified: being saved( Present)Glorified: will be saved(Future) i.e.Justified: fm..the Penalty of Sin...Sanctified: fm...Power of Sin...Gloried: fm....Presence of Sin..The Past: Redeemed...The Present...Reforming..The Future...Rewarded...my question is How does one receive all this 3 fold principle of Salvation...the text is fm..Titus 2:11-13 material fm..Mr.Warren Weirsbe..

[@jarvisnelson4701]

Do you know why pastors do not want you to listen to the audio bible on your e devices? They want to control your inputs and thereby make you dependent. Matthew 23:13

[@funmilolaawomuti1675]

Could it be that when one says 'he/she invites Jesus in his/her life" they speak of the eagerness of having Jesus come in even before He stands at the door of their hearts... knocking

[@ibperson7765]

Inviting Christ into your heart is GREAT. I get his point but it goes both ways not just the way he said. So he was only half right.

[@nalun9829]

@@ibperson7765 respectfully disagree, Rev 3:20 Jesus is knocking even before a sinner recognizes. Truth be told, Jesus is already inviting himself in and all one has to do is to open the door. In reality, it is not you coming to Christ, but it is Christ coming into your heart because of your response to His invitation. Blessings.

[@SetWillBill]

On R.C. Sproul Jr. answer to the question "Why is God angry and wrathful toward those He never predestined to salvation?". R.C. Sproul Jr. answered that the Holy Spirit through Apostle Paul's writing in Romans 9:20 "Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God?", while this is an answer (the answer in the subsequent verses) to those who are proud, it is a clue to the correct interpretation of Romans 9! God is a God of logic, reason, justice and more importantly, love (For God is love, 1 John 4:8, 16). Many interpret Romans 9 to the effect that God can do anything, including evil and so God is the author of evil (they cover it up by using the word 'ordained' to deny their interpretation is accusing God to be the author of sin), God ordained all (including evil) to come to pass. However, the truth seekers would do well to put more emphasis on verses Romans 9:22 & 23 to balance what these verses said to better understand what God is saying in Romans 9. The truth seekers' ultimate goal is to arrive at Jeremiah 9:24 in which God's lovingkindness is clearly shown in His dealing with every man (including Pharaoh), judgment, and righteousness, these are God's delight!

[@robertamaloney1867]

William Lee f

[@keikot4998]

William, Your comment makes sense only if the human history starts only after the Fall and subsequent struggle. However, the Bible must be read in the whole context to make sense. The human history revealed in His Word starts from the wonderful paradise where there was no death, no punishment, no sin, no shame and with all good food whenever they wanted to eat, etc. It was our ancestors' desire to take place of God by becoming the Judge, as smart and righteous as God Himself. Even though Serpent's enticement was so irresistible, it was out of his/her innermost desire to disbelieve the 100% benevolent God and compete against Him, just as the Serpent suggested. -- Romans 9 passage suggests that the Creator in the age of Adam and Eve chose to desire the lie, while the reality was that God had created them and the entire world as the vessel to reflect His perfectly benevolent love - because the Giver gets the ultimate glory. The more difficult to give, the greater glory He gets as the Giver. And He is the Giver of all things as He created them from nothing. He is the "First Causer," which is different from any other "created." Is there anything in this universe that can exist without any cause, except for God? ... This is basically what the Romans passage is revealing to us if you read the whole context of the Bible. -- For more thorough and clear understanding, can you try reading the book, "The Unity of the Bible"? This is very interesting book for someone who seeks logical coherency, as well as moving beauty of the Bible. -- Shall we read with my friend? I read this book many years ago and got shocked for the clarity and beauty .. I learned of God Himself personally talking with me and .. with you.

[@SetWillBill]

Thank you for your reply! After reading your comment several times, we are in agreement! You see many theologians over-emphasized God's sovereignty (this is not reading the Bible in the whole context!), specifically, they over-emphasized Romans 9:13-21 and neglected what is said in verse 22-23! Because of this, they misinterpreted 2 very important verses so that their idea of God is stop-short of accusing God to be the author of sin and evil! They said "God ordained sin and evil", but when you read closely into what they really meant, they meant to said God is the author of sin and evil! The 2 verses are Exodus 7:13 and John 12:40. Search what they said about these 2 verses and you will understand my earlier comment! They often use Romans 9:20 to silent the valid questions, thereby missed the blessing of correctly interpret Romans 9.

[@keikot4998]

Hi William, When Paul was writing Romans 9:20, he was thinking about God's authority as the Creator and the Ruler of the entire thing that He Himself created. Nothing exists in this universe that He did not cause as the ultimate cause. Even meaning or concept or emotion, etc., could not exist without His creation. Where have those "awareness" come originally from? "This kind of God who can create the first material from totally nothing can be compared with what?" There is the absolute distinction between the Giver of all good things and the recipients of all of them. God initially created the whole creation as the vessel to crown Himself as the Giver of all. That is what this passage is communicating. -- To see this discussion further, you can read The Unity of the Bible, by Daniel Fuller.

[@saraheme5048]

William Lee 🙌🙌👏👏

[@rickybanks9024]

Zachariah 1.3 Therefore say thou unto them Thus saith the Lord of hosts Turn ye unto me saith the Lord of hosts and I will turn unto you saith the Lord of hosts. Psalms 24.9 Lift up your heads O ye gates and be ye lift up ye everlasting doors and the King of glory shall come in. James Draw nigh unto God and he will draw nigh unto you.

[@frankwalter9705]

Mr Begg, God did make a prerequisite for salvation. Yes, repentance, confession and faith in the lord Jesus Christ. He who does not believe will be damned says Jesus.

[@tomfuschetti202]

See Ferguson, Godfrey, Lawson, & Sproul

[@almamoore8446]

If we do not say what God has said in his Word then we are against God.

[@thenowchurch6419]

The Power of Christ compels you ! This is too funny.

[@ibperson7765]

Haha. I get it. Few will id guess

[@lainegordon5831]

thank you for the defense of calvin,,the principles of tulip seem under incessant attack, notably the total depravity and limited atonement. i prefer the wording of perseverance of God in the keeping of the saints,..semantics i think

[@lainegordon5831]

excellent point to start. it is always God drawing the sinner...unless God draws you...i have chosen you... name in the book of life from before the foundation of the world...honestly, apart from people wanting control and not wanting to be indebted to God in some way, there is no justification for espousing free will in regard to your salvation. in an abundant life of grace, we can obviously make some pathetic stumbles along our pilgrim progression, so i can see where it might appear to be free will when in fact God allowing you to make them or not, still has God in control. seems to me our tendencies will always be to choose badly unless the Spirit helps us...any helpful insights would be welcomed on this a couple passages seem free will-ish yet the lion's portion of scripture points to God's hand in everything to me

[@samanthayoung8777]

Good

[@samanthayoung8777]

Yes yeah

[@laurapug5389]

Rc Jr. can't answer a regular question at all! I was confused with all of his answers, he didn't help clarify at all.

[@cheapscott8631]

@Laua Pug I agree. Can you imagine being a member of his St. Peter Presbyterian Church (before he was defrocked in 2006)? I worry for anyone who joins his new tongues-speaking church that he just formed, Sovereign Grace Fellowship.

[@laurapug5389]

@@cheapscott8631 really oh speaking in tounges ? He's so different from his father.

[@cheapscott8631]

@@laurapug5389 He says Sovereign Grace Fellowship is Reformed but that they'll "exercise the gifts of the Spirit including speaking in tongues." So Reformed Pentecostal? Or maybe Pentecostal Reformed? I think all his years of alcohol and opioid abuse has messed with his brain.

[@laurapug5389]

@@cheapscott8631 haha.. ughh didn't he learn anything from his dad?

[@lindadevito7363]

Is Anthony related to Ben Carson?

[@joffreynoahalcantara8522]

First question was not answered. A simple question but not understood. The question was, "is inviting Jesus into our hearts save us, or the way to salvation?"

[@dalicaminade3677]

It was answered perfectly! He said simply, it is Jesus Christ who invites not us the people. Therefore, salvation is of Jesus Christ inviting us people to follow him - his work finished on the cross - blood shed, his death and resurrecrion completed our redemption from the wrath of God. We walk IN THAT LIGHT - JESUS CHRIST, believing in him - John 3:16 teaches.

[@lisashaw8]

❤️

[@markrademaker5875]

How's R. C. Sproul Jr. doing?

[@mattmatias4666]

I'm honestly curious if this panel happened before or after RC Jr's Ashley Madison scandal

[@fundacionsembrandovida5579]

I guess this panel was before that scandal. This session was on 2013 National Conference of Ligonier Ministries and the scandal was on 2015 i guess. Blessings!

[@Noone-dc9si]

Hes a sinner who fell into sin just like king David and just like me and you

[@LittleHatori]

Gasp! I haven't heard of that. That's so sad... I hope RC jr. repented.

[@laurapug5389]

@@FledMendota yes he did

[@cheapscott8631]

RC Jr registered for an Ashley Madison account the year after this conference. He outed himself in 2015 on the day The Impact Team publicly dumped the AM database. Wouldn't be the first, and wouldn't be the last time he found himself embroiled in a sex scandal.

[@ILfarmgirl1970]

Has anyone dealt with the accusations against this ministry's dealing with R.C.'s son?

[@lovely_time1771]

Can I marry a man with vows before God only? I cannot loose my husband social security. God alone will provide is not an answer though he always has. I’m just not finding work at my 64 years of age though so capable physically & mentally.

[@diggnl1230]

Al is the man

[@discardedvinylandsuspectth5950]

Where is John Macarthur?

[@circleh5173]

I didn’t know that alistair was a calvinist like rc or am I missing something

Circle H have you never listened to him preach?

[@Psalm119-50]

No person being born again and saved in Christ, would ever stay or remain in Catholicism! How could they? The Holy Spirit would convict and compel them to leave!

[@marysanchez2981]

They look very healthy

[@midknight5812]

MAYBE, Anthony Carter was mentored by Dr. Sproul . I can see Dr. Sproul reaction when Carter was answering the first question.

[@WasLostButNowAmFound]

Begg > Lawson

[@stuartbowlerwell2845]

34:52 love a cheeky Begg wink 😉

[@olgaburgos7780]

Jesus will not tell us the sins we did that He saved us,that goes against what the Bible says, that is that once we repent and are forgiven, the sin is washed away, that is erased, that is not remembered, so, no remembrance exists, He sees on us only Jesus righteousness.

[@stephengorman1025]

'God hates sin and hates the sinner' - there needs to be a far more rigorous defense of such a statement than was put forward here. God is Love and from that love comes the wrath towards the sin that defies his good creation. Christ came to destroy the works of the devil not those through whom he works. Please Mr Lawson be careful when asserting God hates some because it leads religious people to very dark places. God is Light and in him is no darkness at all. Read I John and a little book 'On the Incarnation' by St Athanasius. Grace and Peace.

[@madhavaraogideon3281]

Though salvation is by Grace and through Faith in Christ yet the Rewards are according to our works and Faithfulness towards God in our walk in this world. After God in His grace saves a person ,he cannot live a careless life that displeases God. One day a believer has to stand before the Judgement Seat of Christ to give an account of himself to God. (Romans 14 : 10-12 ). (2. Corinthians 5 : 9,10.). The rewards will be based on both good and bad things we did in our bodies. The Holy Bible Says He is coming for those who love His appearing.He has prepared for those who Love Him what the eye has not seen ,nor the Ear has heard ,neither entered into the Heart of Man. Those who Love Him (obey His Commands) and are Faithful to Him will be rewarded. There is a difference between a believer and a true Follower of Christ. This I believe. I have a great Responsibility in this Life after Receiving Christ in my Life as my Savior. In most Churches this teaching is not given. Once saved you can live as you like is the tendency one gets today. To the Apostle Peter , The Risen Lord told him "...What is that to thee? Follow thou Me" (John 21:22.)

[@js-pw6uk]

John Calvin: "Justification, moreover, we thus define: The sinner being admitted into communion with Christ is, for his sake, reconciled to God; when purged by his blood he obtains the remission of sins, and clothed with righteousness, just as if it were his own, stands secure before the judgment-seat of heaven. Forgiveness of sins being previously given, the good works which follow have a value different from their merit, because whatever is imperfect in them is covered by the perfection of Christ, and all their blemishes and pollutions are wiped away by his purity, so as never to come under the cognizance of the divine tribunal. The guilt of all transgressions, by which men are prevented from offering God an acceptable service, being thus effaced, and the imperfection which is wont to sully even good works being buried, the good works which are done by believers are deemed righteous, or; which is the same thing, are imputed for righteousness."

[@ibperson7765]

Only a pontificating theologian could claim inviting Christ into your heart is bad. 🙄🙄 Bible says we are in Him and He in us ✝️❤️

[@paulbacon5056]

Oh you mean like the apostle Paul did? Oh wait?

[@ibperson7765]

@@paulbacon5056 I believe you are implying that since Paul did not write “invite Christ into your heart”, then it is therefore actually a bad thing to do so. Is that the idea, or something else? Paul didnt write, “Pray to God that you may honor Him better” or “Tell JC you love Him”. By this logic (if it is what you are saying) those are also bad things to do.

[@bobvadney7240]

@ the 10:23 mark...why so much confusion among Christians... on various topics issues & themes..& his answer was " because we dont...listen.." & I agree...& the best examples of not listening comes fm..the panel of men.....that listen to their Westminster Confessions of...faith...more than our Lord..!! i.e. Christ says..." you will not come to me that you....might have...life" Jn. 5:39,40 ( didnt say they...CANT...said they....WONT..) But the Calvinists say.." they cant come to Christ til they,ve been regenerated & they csnt be regenerated til they,ve been Elected/Chosen..before the foundation of the world" i.e " Regeneration precedes...faith.." it's in Mr.R.C.SPROUL,S book Chosen by God p 72...like someone said in the comments " I'm so glad he in heaven...now" & so am i..in fact he the only Reformed Theolgian.." I ever heard the gospel fm... as he was giving his testimony..." he always thot that believing in Christ effected the new birth...that is til he saw the words on a black board.." Regeneration Precedes faith" or causes faith.....& as he said..it changed his life forever...to which I agree...his gospel message was never the ssme... & fm then on we lost a really great one to carry the gospel around the world & here @ home...had his Soteriology..been as sound as his Philosphy & Church History...ya wouldn't be sitting around asking all these dumb questions....& as a Speaker....there was none better...but all that was nullified & negated the day he saw that calvinist gospel...written on a black board sooooo...very long ago...& that was our lost & a great lost it was....!! But he,s home now in spite of his calvinism...😇

[@debjesic]

Has anyone on the panel, ever heard the Lord in a audible voice?

[@iamjohnyboy]

No. But according to the apostle Peter the scripture is more sure than a voice from heaven!

[@debjesic]

Are you on the panel above?

[@Noone-dc9si]

Deborah Jesic they don't belive God is speaking today

[@bouquetoffood8918]

Hebrews 1:1-2 God speaks to US through his Son! We need to embrace the teachings of Jesus and having been baptized in and through HIS WORDS, we gain the unction (guidance, leading) of HolySpirit more clearly, more deeply. NO, I'm not on the panel, but the panel is not in the comments section either. Hope this helps. BeBlessed!

[@dalicaminade3677]

The audability and immutability of God .... we could all "see" and "hear" from His HOLY SCRIPTURES .... THE WORD .... 📖.

[@sheldonbass4238]

As for the pastor who is seeking sound counsel from men who he obviously looks up to as instructive leaders of the church universally, as do I, there are myriads of circumstances and situations where resolution does not so simply and easily arrive. As an elder of a church in very similar straights, who not only encouraged but actually preached expositorily, the opposition usually, as is often the case with the enemy's nefarious schemes, comes slowly and incrementally. In my case the others, particularly new elders and a pastor sought the elevation of themselves and the church as a business before anything else and slowly showed a liberal heart and mind-set, entertainment and comforting the flesh became elevated. It was difficult to notice at first. Occuring with shrewdness and secretive, behind the back assaults against half the members and one elder (me--adult Sunday Scool teacher) who wanted to worship a Holy God, grow in faith and godliuness through better understanding of and presentation of the scriptures, we were ostracized. For two years I tried to leave, yet I felt the Spirit's love for those other members who remained true, many of whom became shut-ins, this love caused me to not abandon them. But eventually I was replaced by the wife of another elder as teacher, and my eldership position filled by another woman. Leaving, we held services in homes for a while and finally dispersed to other congregations. I know for certain that I personally grew in patience, in love and understanding through this hardship.

[@samanthayoung8777]

Because