Best College QBs of All Time (Ranked)

#football #collegefootball #cfb #floridagators #oklahomasooners #auburntigers #lsufootball #aggies

[@chasingourfuture7250]

NO VINCE YOUNG IS WILD..

[@samuelmunoz1464]

I was about to comment that Vince Young was a better Cam Newton in college.

[@anakinskywalker8992]

@@samuelmunoz1464quit the cap

[@ghostknight7901]

@@anakinskywalker8992he’s not wrong

[@samuelmunoz1464]

@anakinskywalker8992 Young single handedly beat what people thought was the best College football team of all time for the National Championship. No cap.

[@anakinskywalker8992]

@@samuelmunoz1464 nuh uh

[@Cbusslayer]

Young people. Not doing their homework.

[@rodneywilliams5090]

I get he was entertaining but he lost to lsu everytime.

[@acoustic_soul03]

Tebow & those alligator tears are one of my favorite Tebow memories!!! Roll 🐘 Tide🐘 Roll🐘 !!!!

[@noaheadie503]

Baker better than cam?

[@ezrasheppard2954]

Riiight😅

[@shogunjobu]

110%

[@Noproblem2241]

Dude is 15 years old

[@BlackMountainCycles]

Has to be.

[@priest21]

Must be.watching football only 10 of those years

[@ConsistentlyInconsistent21]

Like so many people nowadays, he didn't use the word literally correctly. I have no idea why thats such a pet peeve of mine.

[@jaqueltucker7833]

Must be

[@TheGlycerine1]

Tell me you were born in 2007 without telling me

[@Ramfreak23]

Mike Vick was insanely great at Va Tech

[@NoFace-ke9pc]

Well he should of stayed another season. But his family was poor poor and he was a 1st round lock. Poor beamer was cryyyying when he declared.

[@chefhosanna]

It’s amazing the disrespect anything pre 2009 gets. Truly baffling.

[@Itszachmiller]

Joey B was good but a one year resume is not top 5

[@osamabinsmokin3287]

Exactly

[@chrison4k177]

Idm Johnny is quite literally the greatest college qb ever 😂

[@chrison4k177]

Bro didn’t even care abt the game

[@carlfrye1566]

Gen Z thinks the world revolves around their reality.

[@PescadoDelDiablo]

Vince Young destroyed USC in 06. He was incredible

[@nickpeck3386]

05

[@PescadoDelDiablo]

@@nickpeck3386 the 2006 rose bowl. Slap yourself.

[@ArchMania16]

Vince Young 2005/2006 season alone was enough to make top 2 best all time.

[@LIONHEART360Young]

THANK YOU💯

[@legendfrst1073]

“Team was selling bricks and killing people on the side while their offense was ran by a pastor”😂😂😂

[@cameronroberts7930]

This shit had me weak 😂

[@craziermicrobe327]

This comment won 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Elitehokie]

Michael Vick was a better college QB than Baker Mayfield

[@Parkertay55]

Fr

[@A.J.920]

More electric maybe, not better though. Stats wise it isn't even close.

[@Been1311qw]

He has that dog in him

[@MONKMODEJ]

1 Tim Tebow 2 Cam Newton 3 Tommie Frazier 4 Vince Young Tie at 5 Ty Detmer and Charlie Ward

[@jamesfountain6183]

Exactly

[@zanenorris6808]

Leaving Vince young and including baker is craaaaazy

[@Himmyjewett]

Baker was him

[@brianmiller1977]

Pat White not being on that list is straight up disrespectful... Pat White was fkn cheat code bro.. NO way Baker Mayfield is a top 5 NCAAF QB...

[@cameronallen6146]

Baker won a Heisman Trophy that accounts for a lot.

[@Jorkinit247]

2 QBs that never won national titles in your top 5 is crazy

[@mrh3085]

Tommie Frazier is the #1 College QB of all time. Started as a true freshman. Won 3 MVP’s and 2 NC titles in four years. He was the MVP of the NC game they lost against FSU his freshman year. Outplaying Charlie Ward, who won the Heisman that year. Tommy lost only 3 games in his entire college career. Tommy Frazier in the GOAT.

[@dcsr4770]

👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾

[@dexterwestin3747]

This is the correct answer.

[@noahtristenwright4838]

I was literally looking for someone to comment Tommie. Because he probably had the best college career of all time for a QB. Im a huskers fan but even if i wasnt id say the same thing.

[@lucio989]

Mvp?

[@johnnyc5422]

This youtube kid wouldn't know Tommy Frazier from Frasier from Cheers.

[@Yoboy22314]

The disrespect to Vince young and Vick is WILD!?!?!?

[@johncenter2743]

How in the world is Vince Young not on this list….

[@Sam16Walker]

Recency bias, no 4 year college QB made the list is crazy

[@aikful2005]

@@Sam16Walkerbaker is 4 year?

[@papasanders996]

​@@Sam16Walker it is funny kids skip over Leinart, young, and the most commonly skipped tommy frazier

[@joemicer4816]

He hasnt watched much college football

[@kenhightower5672]

Nick Fairley was drafted off that Cam Newton team. He played with the Lions

[@michaelhuff3653]

Yeah he went 13 and was projected top 10

[@davewinchester2790]

Vince young needs to be on this

[@chargersina]

Let’s forget about Kellen Moore’s all-time record.😅

[@byrdgotti1040]

Matt Leinart was legendary at usc

[@skylimitkt]

🐐

[@camr0408]

Baker AND Manziel ahead of Vince Young, Peyton Manning, and Michael Vick?

[@JRock90TEN]

Vince Young is #1 He was electric! Resurrected the longhorns and beat USC, in the Rosebowl. USC the best and most complete team we had see in a long time.

[@tziegner1539]

Vince Young gave the greatest college football season and championship performance of all. 2005 Rose Bowl v USC's Leinart. Invincible!

[@truthhurts95]

False joe burrow had the best season in college football history by a qb stats don’t lie bro

[@brian2440]

@@truthhurts95 well by ratings, polls, and basically every sportscaster in existence 05 Rose Bowl is still the greatest championship game of all time….. And stats? I don’t think you really want to play that game, when A. Case Keenum did what Burrow did 3 times in his career and B, if your talking actual records Burrow doesn’t own the record anymore and the only reason he even broke the record in the first place was because LSU played two more games than the previous record holder. Granted did LSU play tougher teams? Yes. Most Top 10? Well I’d argue the SEC rankings have been overrated af since 2006 (and if you think I’m just hating, I have a lot of examples, and that’s really not a road you wanna go down). Alabama at #8 beating literally ZERO top 25 teams til their bowl is a joke, Clemson at 4 with ZERO Top 25 wins til the playoffs is a joke, and Florida at #7 with 1 Top 15 win to their name is also extremely questionable whether they were legit or the SEC padded the f out of the rankings to get 19 GOAT honors…. Put it this way, children are actually trying to say 19 LSU was more dominant than 95 Nebraska, yet every Top 10 team Nebraska played actually beat a Top 10 team during the regular season, unlike 90% of the teams LSU played. And yet 95 Nebraska still maintained a larger margin of victory than 19 LSU, and scored more ppg than 19 LSU.

[@truthhurts95]

@@brian2440 how have the sec ratings been overrated when they’ve won 13 of the last 17 national championships? you need to get out of your moms basement and go outside it’s not that deep to the point of you sitting behind and keyboard being a pompous douchbag on KZbin. 😂 there’s no logical examples you can give when the sec literally holds win loss records of every power 5 conference out there. You also sound completely ignorant when you say a team from the 90s when the talent in football was no where near what it is today is better than 19 lsu or teams like 20 bama 21 Georgia those teams would blow out 95 Nebraska. So there’s that but like I said Kyle go outside once in a while

[@whitandwestonvids]

Bro wrote a whole essay of why Vince Young’s national championship was better than joe burrows

[@brian2440]

@@whitandwestonvids Well not exactly Vince Young was just for the beginning, but the rest is more about how extremely overrated the SEC is. 2019 LSU was a great team, but they certainly get the benefit of extremely favorable rankings for opponents they beat. The idea that 3 Top 10 teams that LSU beat, beat themselves a grand total of 1 Top 25 team prior not even in the Top 10 prior to the post season is pretty suspect….

[@ef.juniorr]

Colt Brennan 🕊️ From Hawaii had crazy college football career.

[@huggs3044]

He sure did until he met them Ga Dawgs…

[@michaelreynolds2440]

Tommy Freaser...the greatest winning record of all time in 4 years, 2 national titles. Should have been 3 titles

[@thmaginnis1]

How blessed are we to be alive now. The greatest college qbs of ALL TIME ALL happened to have played in the last 15 years.

[@bliine]

Baker and Johnny gotta come off top 5 gotta have Heisman and a Chip

[@phillyfan3942]

Johnny?? Hell no. Young needs to be top 3, get rid of your number 4

[@bliine]

@@phillyfan3942 top 5 gotta have a Heisman and a natty

[@jeremycremeans1854]

Truth. J football was gimmick. If everybody was given his role on their offense, they would be a ironic as well. So, his career was literally a circus show due to no other weapons.

[@chrison4k177]

@@bliinenigga Johnny is number wtf u on about this Nigga wasn’t even trying bro lived a party life and was laying the belt to every team hungover no qb you could’ve done that shit

[@harrisoncornett]

Vince young not on here is a crime

[@kingdiego1921]

Jameis Winston literally only lost 1 game his entire career

[@ILLMANNEE]

Lol for real almost made it 2 nattys and undefeated

[@lanceweaklegs6896]

Did he win two consecutive championships?

[@TrueBreadGetterTv]

@@lanceweaklegs68961 natty 2 ACC ships and a CFP berth 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@yaddameen2102]

Won every award an offensive player can win

[@gogators1522]

he was on drugs the whole time

[@purpstuff919]

Love how every QB played after 2000

[@Ryan-mx2kr]

Tim Tebow=GOAT

[@scottieboy415]

Ya Vince Young has to be on this list

[@kart_blanche2506]

Selling bricks and catching bodies is crazy🐊😂

[@ajl9772]

Case Keenum deserves consideration. Dude still holds some records

[@markdouglas1601]

Dan Lefevour

[@russellallen3136]

Vy for sure carried that Texas to the natty

[@DV87777]

Mayfield and Manzel over Young and Lienart? Crazy.

[@caseyripz8354]

Jameis Winston And Mariota Oregon and FSU teams would be ball on all these boys

[@tspacebaby5264]

I agree but that Joe Burr LSU team was stacked asf

[@Htownrecords52]

Keeping Vince Young off this list is criminal..

[@tiaaug283]

Mariota is college football GOAT at QB…He finished games at halftime

[@shaneturner7990]

Dude VINCE YOUNG. Obviously your to young to understand. Greatest individual performance ever.

[@alexj3483]

Discrediting Joe burrow for being surrounded by nfl talent then hyping up Tim Tebow is a wild decision

[@aaroncombs9348]

What about tommie Frazier, Jerry tagge, and Brook berringer (who played with broken ribs)?

[@joshuatryon7636]

Brook had a collapsed lung

[@joshuatryon7636]

How bout Eric crouch

[@pluggdn4443]

Cam wasn’t the only player off that team drafted😭 josh bynes, nick fairley, neiko thorpe…

[@xavier17th]

and what did they do?

[@GPtwo]

Vince Young Charlie Ward Tim Tebow Joe Burrow Matt Ryan (check the tape) Tommy Frazier Peyton Manning Michael Vick Doug Flutie Ty Detmer

[@MattLindon-wv8jy]

Doug and Matt are out. Staubach needs to be on it and so does Patt White. Also probably need to put Keenum (dude owns nearly every career record in existence like passing for 20,000 yards...)

[@Luckyproductions777]

bro trevor lawrence

[@aaronax726]

Young cfb fan. We can tell. Keep grinding with the videos young man!

[@HawgHomer]

Thanks man I appreciate it and I will! 🤝

[@aarongraybeal6583]

Vince Young???

[@TrU-STaR--31]

Bro forgot Mike Vick was the most disrespectful Qb to use when you played Ncaa Football. Dude was a real life cheat code

[@WesOnTheWorld]

Replace Manziel and Baker With Vick and Vince Young and you have yourself a list!

[@connerwildlife7243]

Tommy Frazier the best option quarterback of all time should be on this list

[@HiFi5280]

List is invalid without Vince imo

[@jacobheileson9750]

Kellen Moore? 1. Frazier 2. Tebow 3. Carter 4. Burrow 5. Moore.

[@UncomfortableConversations7]

1)Frazier 2)Jalen Hurts 3)Peyton manning 4)cM Newton 5)Mike vic

[@KoachKardo]

FLORIDA STORY IS HILARIOUS LMAAAOO

[@TN_vigilance]

Sh*t is wild bro 😂

[@deandreray3500]

Man being old enough to remember I never thought Florida’s dominance over college football would ever end

[@Youngchot]

Me to

[@stacimiles3278]

Marcus Mariota should be up there he was one of the most talented college football players of all time but just didn’t show out in the NFL

[@pewpewlife3958]

No Ken Dorsey? Dude had a 34 game win streak and lost only 2 games in college.

[@hamwambam4098]

Burrow at 4 is crazy

[@TylerLutseo-rp9uu]

Deadass it wasn't like dude only played one season. He only had 1 good season.

[@mrwoods12]

As a overall career he had one good season with the best wr corp in nfl history

[@snakyYT]

Bo Belichec. Nebraska 1990s. Even as a second string his character was amazing. As a player he's a monster. Played a nat championship with a deflated lung.

[@marcabrahams4099]

Vince Young cmon

[@Gretsch-s8j]

SO PROUD OF MY GATORS!!!!!!!!!

[@emoney34567]

Cam at three is crazy

[@MattLindon-wv8jy]

Arguably shouldnt even be on the list...

[@emoney34567]

@@MattLindon-wv8jy who yo plug?

[@MattLindon-wv8jy]

@@emoney34567 5 QBs who have won at least 2 titles: 1. Tim Tebow 2. Tommy Fraizer 3. Roger Staubach 4. Charlie Ward 5. Matt Leinart So if titles are what matter most Im not sure how you can have anyone else above these guys. Otherwise then you get into records, and then you have to decide what matters more records or titles. Cuz from a record standpoint - Pat White and Michael Vick absolutely dwarf Newton as dual threat QBs.

[@cureton04]

I don't know. He left a bunch off but watching Cam was crazy he did literally take the entire team on his back and drug them to a Natty. They sucked before and after. Only knock was it was only 1 year.

[@donttagmebroong]

jjetas, joe burrow and lahjay all drafted is a dream bro

[@diegohernandez9584]

Don't forget about Vince Young

[@douglasbiss3364]

Only one quarterback in history won the Heisman as a Freshman, won the National Championship as a Freshman, Went 26 of 27 games 96%+ winning percentage. Draft #1 by NFL as a Sophomore !!!! Jameis Winston, Case Closed !!!

[@tonyguidry1388]

Burrow too low. Vince Young should be on list

[@bobcalder4996]

Remember folks, this is an opinion piece.

[@robertgordon7983]

Top 5 realistic edition 1 Vince 2 cam 3 Vick 4 tebow 5frazier

[@travisrock1640]

Its absolutely crazy to think that not one of them have a Super Bowl ring to there name. It goes to show that even if you have the best QB in college history or whatever he still can mean absolutely nothing if you do t have the right team around them...

[@adamwallace7638]

Cam Newton is regarded as the greatest college PLAYER of all time, not just QB. remember that

[@kenjf1009]

By who?

[@NoSnowFlakes1]

Said no one ever. Tebow is the greatest college QB (not even close) and arguably the greatest college player. If we go outside of the QB then its Charles Woodson or Barry Sanders

[@travisrichard8148]

Tim Tebow

[@cwebedstuy]

​@@NoSnowFlakes1Tebow for you...Cam for me🤷🏻‍♂️

[@dcsr4770]

​@@NoSnowFlakes1Tebow is a Poor Man's Tommy Frazier.

[@adamhicks9597]

This kid needs a CFB history lesson. No Vince Young or Tommy Frazier is crazy.

[@andrewretherford8622]

Manziel😂😂😂

[@Tyu769]

I agree he’s top 10 but not top 5. And Vince is top 2

[@jamescarroll1101]

What made that manziel play so good was the block in the back way upfield by the line man on the play .lol crooked cheat looked great in that play

[@dcee1412]

#1. Vick #2. Watson #3. Mariota #4. Young #5. Tebow

[@jakolby6511]

Trash list

[@DaNew_Nutty]

Johnny Football Was The Modern Day Broadway Joe

[@davidjohnson5451]

Best College QBs since 2010. Only way to justify this list.

[@jasonpruitt4491]

Vince Young, Michael Vick, Deshaun Watson, Trevor Lawrence

[@issaSeeK]

Vince Young and Matt Lienart belong on this list. 2006 rose bowl texas vs USC best game in any sport ive ever seen

[@ellisbarlow4626]

Case Keenum held the record for most passing yards at a school that no one talks about

[@Gr8Stowe]

T. Frazier C. Ward M. Vick V.Young L. Jackson

[@Fiercetits]

Vince Young was great but all 5 of these guys surpassed what he did. Although USC vs Texas is definitely the best college championship of all time.

[@jacobkriger9763]

Cam was not the only one drafted off that team. Nick Fairley was 13th overall the same year Cam went 1.

[@hondahaney6404]

Agree 100%. Good picks! No dog in the fight

[@skepticalmonkey7263]

#1 Tommy Frazier #2 Vince Young #3 Peyton Manning #4 Sam Bradford #5 David Klingler

[@tonyreeves7584]

Damn the disrespect that Tua is getting like he hardly ever played a 4th quarter and in the SEC 😂😂😂

[@gabriel9492]

Crazy the things Jonny manziel did while hungover and not watching any film

[@seymourbunyan9474]

Funny he didn’t mention the nfl players Tebow played with 😂😂

[@raybrozzo7850]

Manziel over Vince and Vick is beyond disrespectful

[@kalltryone4823]

How is Vince Young not on there. I think you need to make another video

[@offdacorner]

The 2019 LSU team is the greatest college football team ever. Joe Burrow was the best player on that team. It was like watching an NFL team take on college teams that year.

[@TeterBot]

Did you hear what he said. Joe burrow had the best college football season ever, but he isn’t higher on the list because he has the avengers on his offense. (2001 Miami is better btw) and it was like watching a nfl team

[@vloghog1]

Four players on that 2010 Auburn team were drafted including Nick Fairley who was drafted in the first round.

[@tycalvert6011]

No Tommie Frazier is more unforgivable than no Bryce Young and I’m an Alabama fan.

[@cody7259]

As a Georgia fan, out of complete respect, Cam should be 2 and Tebow is in the correct spot. Those were two once in a generation type QB’s

[@jacksonmatthews3713]

This man said top 5 all time, and didn’t name a QB that played before 2006. Major L

[@EALegend22]

I’m so glad the comments are validating Vince and Vick, Don’t forget RG3 Baylor was nobody until that man. Trust me, I’m from Texas and a UT fan, plus Murray at OU was better than baker anyways. 🛑 Murray is literally one of the best highschool Texas QBs of all time too look it up.

[@ETCollectibles]

The pain he carried having no choice to admit Baker is top 2 lol

[@noahtristenwright4838]

If you have deep knowledge of past College football teams and QB careers, then you know the real answer is honestly Tommie Frasier from Nebraska. The accolades and wins speak for themselves. 3 nattys in 4 years. The team lost but he outplayed Heisman Winning QB Charlie Ward in that bowl game. So even they lost he was wrecking defenses. Which was only 4 times in his playing career. 3 time MVP in national championships even with one of those being a loss.

[@paulhat3310]

Heisman Trophy winner Doug Flutie HAS to be on that list!🎉

[@Danielhernandez-hu1nk]

Tim Tebow the goat 🐐

[@kylejohnson5225]

I’d take Dennis Dixon and Marcus Mariota over baker. Dennis Dixon went from being literally a nobody to the heisman front runner in one season and would have won that and a national championship with the ducks had he not blown out his knee that 2007 season. He still got drafted to the stealers after all that and played as a backup. He was just as electrifying to watch as Lamar Jackson. 2007 was the year chip Kelly became the offensive coordinator for Oregon which is a big reason he had that breakout season.

[@ellisbarlow4626]

I’m taking Baker Mayfield off the list and moving Tebow to #2 with Vince Young as #1. The 2005-2006 rose bowl was the greatest college football game ever and he won against one of the greatest teams ever

[@OreoWaffles44]

i’d put vince young definitely top 10. i respect your video though🤘🏽

[@cammac389]

Baker in the top 10 is WILD😂😂🤣🤣

[@reconnecting8815]

The problem with Joe burrow is, if Tua doesn’t fumble LSU doesn’t even beat bama