Best Drugstore Brown Liquid Eyeliners

We all love a good black liquid eyeliner but what about BROWN?! Today, I tested out 6 different drugstore brown liquid eyeliners. From brands like Essence, L’oreal, Physicians Formula, and much more! Find out which one is the best and worst drugstore brown liquid eyeliners.
1:25 - Essence Eyeliner Pen vs. Wet n Wild Felt Tip Eyeliner
6:02 - Maybelline Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner vs. L'oreal Infallible Liquid Eyeliner The Super Slim
9:55 - Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner vs. NYX Epic Ink Liner
PRODUCTS:
Essence Eyeliner Pen: rstyle.me/+1jt...
Wet n Wild Felt Tip Eyeliner: rstyle.me/+2O4...
Maybelline Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner: rstyle.me/+Fzw...
L'oreal Infallible Liquid Eyeliner The Super Slim: rstyle.me/+5sW...
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Ultra Fine Liquid Eyeliner: rstyle.me/+E-u...
NYX Epic Ink Liner: rstyle.me/+fwT...
My Favorite Amazon Products: www.amazon.com...
#drugstoremakeup #liquideyeliner
Instagram: / maesitler
Tik Tok: / maesitler

[@MaeSitler]

What’s your favorite drugstore brown liquid liner?

[@leeora1718]

I never tried a brown liquid liner, only pencil. But I'll try the Loreal one!

[@CaityCat05]

I love the ELF eyeliner pen and the LA Girl Line Art Matte Eyeliner Pen :) neither were tested in this video!

[@MaeSitler]

@@CaityCat05 Maybe I’ll do a part II of everyone’s favorite drugstore brown liquid eyeliners 😊

[@honeykumquat]

L'oreal Infallible Flash Cat Eyeliner WP is my HG (love both the brown and black eyeliner) and it's a brush tip!

[@mich515]

@@MaeSitler omg please do!! brown eyeliners do not get enough recognition on KZbin, especially the true brown liners

[@portia7854]

I've recently switch to brown liner (pencil and liquid) and it's the best decision I've made regarding eye makeup. It's more natural and because it's softer than black, it enhances the shape of your eyes in a non-obvious way.

[@kailynbickerton5367]

I have had that experience with NYX brown liner. I have bought it three times but it dries out and then clumps off quickly. I'm glad I'm not the only one. Thanks for the review! I hope they adapt the formula for it someday!

[@MaeSitler]

It’s so weird especially since I don’t have that experience with the black eyeliner

[@nikolapechova7751]

As a European I would love to see more Essence, Maybelline and other drugstore product reviews since we dont have the others here. Love you ❤

[@CaityCat05]

Brown is so underestimated!! You can totally pull off an amazing look with it!

[@slr6027]

This was just the type of video I was looking for! Thank you for such a thorough review!

[@MaeSitler]

No problem! Thank you for watching!

[@leeora1718]

The fact you only have 22 views is a crime.. I saw the Essence one in the drugstore today and almost got it, thank God I reconsidered and found your video😅 (P.s. that mascara transitionnnn gurllll🤯)

[@MaeSitler]

Girl, not Essence! 😁 thank you!

[@adnilgreen1727]

I didn’t enjoy the Physicians Formula eyeliner because it wasn’t great over eyeshadow. It would pick up the eyeshadow and get dry/patchy. Thanks for your thorough review!!

[@nicollettes4665]

The same thing happened to me with the NYX brown liner. The funny thing is it only had enough wetness for one eye application. When I went to the other eye the pigment was dry and disappeared. So sad because I love the black liner.

[@Elemiriel]

I am a combination true/warm autumn in my coloring, and planning a little makeup revamp, so this was SUPER helpful! Thank you!

[@MaeSitler]

No problem! Thanks for watching Katherine

[@choosnau]

Same as a soft autumn!

[@afterallthistimealways1783]

I know this is an older video, but the Nyx one becomes less stiff and dry after a few uses, just stick it out! I got it pretty recently for my birthday and was super disappointed until I'd used it a few times and now it's my new favorite!

[@mysaria7641]

I really liked NYX's shade too but hopefully with the Physician's Formula one it'll fade to a lighter color with use

[@Inismoon]

Physician Formula review exactly what I needed. Thank you! 💗

[@samantharose843]

I would love to see a showdown with drugstore and higher end. Just the overall best liners 💚

[@MaeSitler]

There will be a high end brown eyeliner pencils video up later this month 🤎

[@samantharose843]

@@MaeSitler yay thank you! Love your content!! 😊

[@subiediva]

Thank you for this video. I'm transitioning from high-end makeup to drug store and I love brown eyeliner over black

[@kitsune.422]

I’ve been using the NYX and love the brush tip and shade. But agree that it dried out so quickly!

[@ashleyparker-kalfin2670]

This was the exact video I was looking for!

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you for watching!

[@xlovinghearts]

Thank youuu!!! I've been on the hunt for a good brown eyeliner! Great video :)

[@MaeSitler]

Thanks for watching Cathy!

[@MariaAlvarezzz]

Ty so much. I love brown eyeliner and you are the only youtuber with a BROWN eyeliner review!! I use the Revlon colorstay skinny liner. You would love it, super fine tip and doesnt smudge. I also use colourpop brown, its good too!

[@MaeSitler]

I’ll have to try that one out. Look out for part II brown pencil eyeliners will be going up later this month.

[@MariaAlvarezzz]

@@MaeSitler yesss! I would love for you to include that one in your video if you could ❤️

[@sophiaturner8204]

I had the same experience with the NYX one too! I love the black one but the brown one is so bad it's confusing

[@hummie3]

This video was exactly what I needed! I was just about to buy several eyeliners to compare, which felt really wasteful. Based on your review I’m going to try the NYX because I’m looking for a more medium brown :). Thanks for the awesome video!

[@MaeSitler]

Yay! I’m so glad this video helped you ☺️ Thanks for watching!

[@lexijones8019]

Thank you for this ❤. I love your lipstick.

[@phoss8717]

after buying the nyx liner more than 5 times i can confidently say that theres a major issue with the packaging because after a few months it spills everywhere like crazy and it wastes SO much product!! its my favorite liner out of all but i will say it lasts very shortly + its very messy and ive seen other people in this comment section saying it too. i hope they improve it someday 😩

[@vanessaarroyo1620]

I have the same problem after buying multiple times too, it spills during travel too 😭

[@lauren7376]

Ty for all your hard work! PF aren't cruelty free, sadly, so I'll settle for trying out the nyx!

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you for watching! 😊

[@cozyverbena1574]

Loved this video. Going to buy the physicians formula

[@MaeSitler]

Good choice! 😉

[@carold8950]

Please try the heroine brown liner... You'd love it! Brush tip and very natural brown

[@MaeSitler]

Ok! I’ll do a part II of this video

[@elizabethzacharias1757]

Thank you!

[@wendy99ish]

Great review

[@zarmena_khan]

hey, love ur lip colour! which one is it?

[@张伯伦-d6j]

Elf eyeliner in coffee works great for as well, except not available in Europe now😔

[@asmjoss2961]

Thank you for the review 😊

[@PinCushionQueen]

My NYX dried out in less than a month -it’s a no-go for me. I had both brown & black. How did the physicians formula hold up over time , drying out & such. I need one that has some longevity! Thanks.

[@kellywolfe5930]

Great video 💙💛❤💚💜

[@motheranddaughterabroad]

Your skin! Wow! Also, thanks for the eyeliner tips haha.

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you ☺️

[@stormchii]

i want to find a light brown all day stay eyeliner but i can’t find any :(

[@delilahvillafuerte4313]

hello,what's the lip product you have on this video?

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics Lip Cushion in Faded Clementine

[@rapunzelinpearls]

Amazing video

[@valentinadestefano2650]

It 's impossibile for me to found the Brown Phisician formula eyeliner in Italy 😣😣😣😣

[@Elizabeth-mn6lm]

ugh, I'm looking for a nice brown eyeliner (as a blonde) for so long and cannot find any. I hate using pencil eyeliner, I can only use the ones in a little bottle but there are harder to find and if I do, they look almost black. I'm looking for a lighter brown :(

[@ummuhanketenci9992]

Same for me,please let me know if you can find any :)

[@kryssygee4814]

Cool vid! Question? Best way - or product - to remove the make up?

[@MaeSitler]

Cleansing balm or cleansing oil

[@lataanand8937]

Omg ur lipstick shades are awesome, could u pls give us details of that

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics True Gloss in Faded Clementine

[@lynndubai4984]

I liked Essenes color the best but agree it doesn’t wear well

[@livymandonguilles]

I don't like the essence one. It's too watery and not black enough. It rubs away with just water or saliva and it's just not nice. I've heard good reviews about the waterproof one tho

[@MaeSitler]

I didn’t know there was a waterproof option

[@chongmoua816]

I bought the NYX brown liner recently and was very disappointed. I did not apply like the video. It was very sheer and has a barely there application. Based on the video and my experience, it doesn't seem to be a consistent product in application.

[@nah_.]

Wow your eyes are so glossy and elegant looking if that makes sense lol

[@feebeelong9432]

OMG let alone everything else this kind of review/test is soooooo good I love that you wear it for a whole day before concluding.

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you for watching! ❤️

[@StillDollSyndrome]

Hi, new subscriber here! Thank you so much for doing this its so hard to find a good brown liner. Honestly, I've been really into brown mascara recently too but there aren't many options. Any recommendations for a good brown mascara?

[@MaeSitler]

I've been thinking about creating a video all about brown mascaras...maybe something I can film this summer.

[@kajamichalska5008]

I like L.A. Girl Volumatic and Yves Rocher Sexy Pulp

[@Mish4Mello]

I tried the Maybelline Master Precise brown liner and it didn’t work for my hooded, oily eyelids. I use the Physicians Formula liner but in black everyday. I go back and forth between it and NYX.

[@moninaninanina8201]

Loreal and Maybelline looked the same and formula is the same because they are literally made by the same company.

[@moonshine9858]

What is the stubby l’oreal eye pencil you used to tight line? Is it the pro-last waterproof one? Thanks ☺️

[@vanieLuna]

you deserve more subs and likes… your content is reliable

[@MaeSitler]

@@vanieLuna thank you! I appreciate the support ☺️

[@cinnamon2062]

I dont like the wet n wild brown eyesliner liquid.......u were right about it.......u are beautiful......

[@90798]

This is the best review a person could ask for. Thank you so much ! Sub !!

[@MaeSitler]

Thank for your kind words ☺️

[@Happykarla4000]

Can you make a video about brown mascaras also? Please

[@MaeSitler]

Great idea! Any ones you would like me to review?

[@Happykarla4000]

@@MaeSitler nop whatever you picked high end and drugstore I'm fine thank u

[@magpiesneedle2575]

@@MaeSitler I’d love to see brown waterproof-hopefully drugstore.

[@belovedobserver]

I got the nyx brown one and was so disappointed. I wish I could find one in that light shade but with a better formula.

[@magpiesneedle2575]

If you ever see this 1) brown eyeliner pen and especially 2) a true brown mascara Aeeing black//Rowan mages my head explode.

[@lyly7664]

U look very pretty but the blush placement ist not so right🙁 it makes your cheekbone looks like it is placed lower and u look older. No offense at all i just want to help😙

[@lindseylegtenberg8587]

love to see a high end one🤩

[@MaeSitler]

Anything specific you would like me to review?

[@labornurse]

Benefit roller liner matte brown is great.

[@marianacervacio6533]

Mac liquid liner is very good!!

[@smashleydevin]

Please do one with higher end liners!

[@Gxport]

Great thorough review!

[@MaeSitler]

Thanks for watching!

[@nowmia2181]

Can you please tell what lip shade are you wearing in this video? It looked so good on you

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics True Gloss in Faded Clementine

[@magpiesneedle2575]

I’m devastated. The title made me so happy. The video took me to the brown/black world. Only the Essence and the NYX (which I have) even look brown (I can pray to the makeup gods it’s my monitor) on application. Strange. More so brown on your hand. The contrast is strange too. But that’s what we get. As for you, you are charming and pleasant to listen to. I did enjoy the video, as far as you and your personality, it’s nice to see an adult acting like one.

[@roxxanezavala4809]

Can I ask what you’re using your lips on the first day video they look great!

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics Lip Cushion in Faded Clementine

[@farahfarrah4224]

Please review the L’Oréal infallible ink eyeliner pen in 🤎