Best Drugstore Brown Pencil Eyeliners

[@jessaagbuya8154]

You dont know how much your videos helped me a lot! Thankks very much 🤗

[@maeflower522]

I stopped buying black eyeliner and started using brown, I’ll never go back to black

[@lindseysreptiles]

How come ? I am thinking about switching too but not sure why 🤣

[@soohoonsusu]

@@lindseysreptiles the black eyeliner can look more intense and bold. whereas the brown one can make it look more natural and pleasing for everyday looks.

[@lindseysreptiles]

@@soohoonsusu thank you!

[@priyankadey2620]

Same man I am never getting a black eye liner ever

[@riwrawr]

brown eyeliner color doesn’t look good on my skin

[@lexic6081]

I’ve always loved the Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Liner but it’s getting harder to find in stores so I’ll definitely try the L’Oréal or Nyx next.

[@trac6009]

Love the video...ty first time her and I'll be back...I have oily skin n this is exactly what I was looking for to try new eyeliners

[@CJM279]

Definitely going to pick up the Revlon one. I’ve also heard the L’Oréal Le Liners are good-a dupe for the Marc jacobs highliner pencil.

[@bobby3292]

This is such a well done video, love love love! subscribed

[@NYCHILATX]

Coincidentally I just bought the Nyx retractable eyeliner in Bronze. I heard it was fairly dark compared to other brands' version of Bronze. Thanks for this review. This oily t-zone, Asian gal with a really long torso has been really enjoying your reviews.

[@MaeSitler]

Thanks for watching! ❤️

[@kaweii5170]

How is the eyeliner in bronze ? Is the colour a light brown ? :) Im searching for it so bad

[@MaeSitler]

Lighter and there's a slight shimmer to it

[@kaweii5170]

@@MaeSitler thank you will try it 🤩

[@thelouisejust]

Did it last all day?

[@GeminiGlitters]

Your bronzer and base in general looks beautiful! I need to get a brown liner 😊

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you ☺️

[@Beautylove-m87]

Brown eyeliner looks very subtle and give a no makeup glam look...love your vedio.. ❤❤

[@RizwanaHaque-c4l]

Just can't get over your beauty 😍😍😍😍😍

[@sabasiddique73]

You alwayysssss seem to have the videos I NEED! i bought the clio mascara after watching your video, I LOVE IT! now i need a brown eyeliner to pair it with the clio brown mascara I'm about to purchase 😂❤

[@MaeSitler]

Yayyy! I’m so glad to hear! ☺️

[@shakeiteasy4539]

You’re so good on applying the eyeliners. Do you ever experience the eyeliners kind of bleed/transfer down to your under eye area after a certain time? Any tips on how to avoid it? I find myself often wiping my under eye area with a wipe to clean the messy liners.

[@MaeSitler]

I do sometimes in my inner corner. I typically apply eyeshadow primer on my eyelids and under my eyes. Apply concealer and then go in with a loose setting powder.

[@maryjoytinambacan1611]

@@MaeSitler how much po mam ey liner

[@stephaniepink7533]

Wow, this really helps. Sometimes I like to wear a bit of make up when I go skiing and now I know which ones to buy next. Thank you so much for your review!

[@MaeSitler]

No problem! Thanks for watching 😊

[@byaltheamae]

Brown liner >> Thanks for doing this video, it's been super helpful in choosing a brown liner! I love your lip combo as well, what are you wearing? :)

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you! Em Cosmetics Lip Liner in Teddy and Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Topaz

[@sunbun3499]

I don’t know if it’s the way the camera happens to pick it up but the revlon one looks smokey and intentional at the end of the day and looks really nice! I can see maybe the creaminess would make it really good for purposely smudging it

[@Monkeymeee]

Awww thanks for the review, super helpful and thorough. Also youre GORGEOUS

[@MaeSitler]

No problem and thank you!

[@rainyrae1296]

What sharpener do you use on the L’Oréal? This video was super helpful! And I LOVE your makeup look

[@MaeSitler]

I use the Ulta Beauty Dual Sharpener

[@thelouisejust]

What blush were you wearing from the start of this video? Thanks

[@daphne6463]

You explained and showed it PERFECTLY🥰🫶🏻THANKS A LOT I WILL NOW GO AND BUY ONE OF THEM YOU RECOMMENDED❤️❤️❤️Thank you soooo much🧚🏻‍♀️🧚🏻‍♀️🧚🏻‍♀️

[@worthigirl2946]

The new Maybelline Liquid liner that looks like a pen is really great! It's similar to ND's liner!

[@MaeSitler]

I’ll add it to my list!

[@MariCatherinee]

This is my first time watching a video of yours and I loved it! Some actual useful advice with real life experimentation done, thank you, ! Subscrided

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you Marianna! I appreciate the feedback 😊

[@samiratahri6932]

Hello lovely! Thank you so much for the recommendations! May I also asked what you used on your cheeks/lips?? I looooove this look, so classy and elegant!

[@MaeSitler]

I think I was wearing a Tower 28 cream blush and the Maybelline Lifter Gloss on the lips

[@Aninha-em9sp]

It seems like this loreal pencil has been discontinued in the uk ☹️. Do you have any suggestions of a good replacement?

[@ChrystineCC]

Essence is my favorite, I replaced it for the IT cosmetics no budge gel liner for $20, total dupe!

[@MaeSitler]

Great dupe!

[@anja1627]

What lip product did you use here? The shade looks so good.

[@tanyamarie3022]

I’ve tried the L’Oréal infallible pencil and love it but it was impossible to sharpen. How do you sharpen it?

[@MaeSitler]

I use the Ulta Beauty sharpener but I don’t sharpen it too much

[@meaghanholbrook9029]

I absolutely agree! I have used this pencil for a couple years but I cannot get it to sharpen without breaking (on multiple pencils). I stopped purchasing due to this! I would love to know which sharpener she uses.

[@mimisashimi5006]

Thank you for this video, it was so so so helpful! But correct me if I'm wrong, I think the Nyx eyeliner you tested in the video was their "Retractable Long-Lasting Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil" but the one you linked to in the description is their "Slide On Eye Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner." The one in the link is a shaved pencil, but the one you used is a retractable pen. Just wanted to make sure I was getting the right one! 😊

[@MaeSitler]

You are right! I just fixed it in the description. Thank you!

[@Vaxedia]

Can we make eyeliner less creamy? Or at least prevent it somehow from smudging?

[@magdalenatomalak3445]

May I know what lip products do you use ? You look gorgeous❤

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics Lip Liner in Teddy and Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Topaz

[@TheRashmi20]

I was searching for this comment 😂

[@JellyAsian]

Could you do a video for mascara? I tried so many waterproof mascara but at the end of the day i always get panda eyes because of my monolids... :(

[@heyo8118]

I have the same problem No.7 longlasting mascara in the gold tube is the only one that doesn’t!

[@JellyAsian]

@@heyo8118 Thankss i will try that one! :D

[@MaeSitler]

Good idea! This one might take me a little bit longer since I like mascaras better when they dry up.

[@mahiko1961]

USE TUBE MASCARAS!! THEY DO NOT SMUDGE. I USE MAYBELLINE SKY HIGH! NO MORE SMUDGES EVER!!

[@lenadahling]

You're gorgeous! Thanks for this. x

[@ninab5161]

Can you please do best/worst lip liners? 😍😍

[@MaeSitler]

Drugstore lip liners? I could do that

[@hyphen-minus]

Brown liners are the best!

[@MaeSitler]

🙌🏼

[@dannitalopez6037]

Love your blush

[@SaucerJess]

Love this type of video! ♥️

[@MaeSitler]

I'm so glad to hear!

[@hahahaitsjenny]

I just stumbled on your video but thank you for doing brown pencils, I was using Maybelline but now I must try the loreal. Can you please do a video on brown drugstore mascara next? I'm tired of all the ones I've tried and being disappointed.

[@MaeSitler]

Definitely adding that video idea to my list!

[@SonamYangzom851]

What blush are you wearing? 😍

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics Heaven's Glow Radient Veil Blush in Faded Clementine

[@thelouisejust]

I tried the L’Oréal brown Mechanical, and it smudged really bad. I think I will go back to the Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise Skinny Gel Pencil. If you can suggest a waterproof that doesn’t budge that would be great.

[@ShashaaTirupati]

How do you choose between a liquid eyeliner and pencil eyeliner? Is there a better one or is it only with the effect you want to achieve? What do you prefer? :))

[@MaeSitler]

It really depends on the effect you want to achieve. Lately, I prefer a pencil because it’s a softer look and it’s more user friendly.

[@ShashaaTirupati]

Thanks, girl!@@MaeSitler

[@dreamie9868]

You are stunning! I love your makeup. Do you remember what you were wearing on your cheeks here?

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you! I think I was wearing a Tower 28 cream blush.

[@nicole4131]

Please compare drugstore eyebrow pencils next! 🙂

[@MaeSitler]

Sure! Adding to my list 😊

[@DeborahKezia]

Your video is very helpful! Soo, which one is truly the best, Loreal or NYX? 😁😁

[@MaeSitler]

Don’t make me choose 🙊 haha

[@RochelleAndersonOfficial]

What lip products are you using? Such a gorgeous color.

[@MaeSitler]

In this particular video, I don’t remember but I do have videos on my favorite lip products. Hope that helps!

[@SaucerJess]

The only eyeliners that stay in my waterline are the Haus Labs ones ♥️

[@MaeSitler]

Never tried that brand before

[@зайкамоя-м5о]

Very bad eyeliners , don’t waist your money

[@Peanutwhiskers77]

Thank you so much, so helpful for a makeup beginner like me! Love your makeup - lips and blush 😍 may I know which blush you used?

[@MaeSitler]

I believe I wore Tower 28 Beauty cream blush

[@kellywolfe5930]

Great video 💙💛❤💚💜

[@majdarahmaoui6349]

Hy Wich bronzer you have on?

[@andreataylor1805]

Thank you! Very informative 😊

[@MaeSitler]

Thanks for watching!

[@Strawbettys]

Hey mae! Do u find the Loreal to be hard to sharpen?

[@MaeSitler]

Not at all!

[@Miki_1111]

Hi thank you for the recommendations I will purchase the L'oréal one, just one question. How do you sharpen it? I checked other reviews and everyone is complaining about being to difficult to sharpen.

[@MaeSitler]

I use the Ulta Beauty Dual Sharpener

[@ItsJessAHandle]

Was wondering the same thing! Did you end up getting it? Were you able to sharpen?

[@Miki_1111]

@@ItsJessAHandle Hi, yes I used the ulta sharpener and it worked perfectly

[@icarus6087]

I don't know how to use the infaillable one. I need to use force for it give some color but if I do so the tip bends and breaks so I put it into freezer but the same issue persists what am I missing? I'm not an eye pencil type of person :(

[@MaeSitler]

That’s odd…I’ve never experienced that. Maybe you have a bad one? 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@kimarr95]

Could I ask you what brushes you were using to elongate the eyeliner wings out?

[@MaeSitler]

elf Cosmetics Precision Dual-Sided Eyebrow Brush

[@Happykarla4000]

What's on your lips I love it

[@MaeSitler]

Em Cosmetics Lip Liner in Teddy and Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Topaz

[@Happykarla4000]

@@MaeSitler thanks so much 🙏 I hope you can review the eyeko cocoa edit collection please 😊

[@christinarussell6306]

Thank you!

[@MariaGonzalez-mo3lb]

What blush do you use?

[@MaeSitler]

I think I was wearing a Tower 28 cream blush

[@strangerperson7177]

What's your lipgloss?

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you! Em Cosmetics Lip Liner in Teddy and Maybelline Lifter Gloss in Topaz

[@chantrac3446]

What mascara do you use? I have this problem where my eyes get oily and my mascara will end up smearing at the bottom of my eyes :(

[@MaeSitler]

The new Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Mascara. I have a review on my channel!

[@irenedorsey6564]

My goodness you are beautiful!

[@dr.shery.mua.]

Love the review ❤😊 I subscribed so fast ❤ love your channel ❤

[@MaeSitler]

Thank you! ❤️

[@alejandramenesesfernandez8174]

i just discovered your chanel and love it so much you seem so sweet ly

[@MaeSitler]

Welcome Alejandra 😊

[@brittanydanong8486]

you're so pretty

[@elbanowilliamprovenzalilar8800]

3:06

[@mahiko1961]

rimmel scandalous has good reviews from oily lid youtubers...im trying it now.

[@MaeSitler]

I’ll have to check it out!

[@cloudcanoe]

Brown adds richness and black is too harsh on me

[@SaucerJess]

♥️🌻♥️

[@nataliel7637]

you are so beautiful, oh myy god

[@audreyso1201]

i think LOREAL is the best.

[@shelley_nw]

Loreal is Israeli so that one is a no go for me.