Best Practices for Procedural Narrative Generation

[@GabrielRicardoFreeman-Gabe]

Um, what's up with the blurred out sections on the screen? I get there's a link that's no longer good at the end, but it covers up speakers names, Twitter handles, slide images etc for a lot of this video

[@stumbling]

The dove flew down to the stream. The ant insulted the dove. The dove ate the ant. _A kindness is never wasted._

[@javedakhtar1435]

literally how a primitive story generator would work.

[@NeoShameMan]

@@javedakhtar1435 the dove got a feast, not wasted

[@javedakhtar1435]

@@NeoShameMan bro i don't even remember when i put this comment dpwn lol

[@NeoShameMan]

@@javedakhtar1435 that's the fun of this

[@baronvonbeandip]

Dwarf Fortress: The most namedropped game regarding procedural generation.

[@xDMrGarrison]

and deservedly so :D

[@JTX30000]

I think you might be misunderstanding what this video is talking about.

[@sechmascm]

​@@JTX30000 At 2:25 Dwarf Fortress is name dropped and shown. How did he misunderstand again?

[@_equalo]

In the process of designing a game following some of these principals. I’m really curious to see if the bigger limitation is the designers ability to anticipate and effectively codify all the various motivations and influencing variables, or the computational power to actively simulate all these variables

[@RakijaveObloge]

How's the game designing going? Did you learn something interesting?

[@alexkennedy4990]

I really want to see more games using this.

[@JTX30000]

I'm working on it...

[@feelsunbreeze]

I am working on one in cpp console it won't be big but it will deeply intricate and complex. sort of like a life simulator.

[@alexkennedy4990]

@@feelsunbreeze Anywhere I can follow the development?

[@StarContract]

From an algorithmic / computer science pov, this is interesting. But I will never implement something like that in my game.

[@maksmaisak4917]

Ilan Lakan Why? Please deliberate.

[@StarContract]

Because implementing the algorithm itself will take me much longer than create a decent sized hand made story dialogs of good quality

[@DarkJ0hn4r]

well thats looks very likely HTN planners, already they are very abstrac, just define task, and will get compund task. Maybe i will try this some day but actually i thoght its better a auto-narrative gameplay. Dark souls dont need tell nothing you can always deduct what happened.

[@comrademartinofrappuccino]

so you have made games in the past? which of them are worth playing for the public?

[@BADC0FFEE]

you are missing the whole point. it's about generating a lot of different stories in a procedural environment, not a single story

[@ZoidbergForPresident]

Starting with the immersion fallacy eh? :P

[@GrantBrenner]

I love the cross-section of engineering and art.

[@android272]

Why is it that halfway through this video some parts are blurred out?

[@TheAssassin642]

I assume it's the link being blurred out because it's not safe

[@android272]

MadsterV that makes scenes.

[@AZTECMAN]

If you look a 20:40, there is a person's face behind the blur.

[@android272]

@@AZTECMAN Nice!

[@poe84it]

@@AZTECMAN she is not "a person", she is the other realtor. so I think the blur it's pointless if it's for that. I think it's for something else. 14:30

[@marksmithcollins]

WHAT THE HECK IS THAT BLUR

[@nichan008]

a bad url

[@Joel2Million]

Seems like the narrative interactions would be good to crowd source, just send out lots of random verbs and objects and ask people to give suggestions of what they lead to, do that a billion times and you'd have good data for an AI...

[@nullvoid3545]

Look up GPT-3. its an AI built just like that, but instead they just used a massive amount of text from the internet. Its very impressive.

[@bradleetulio4801]

Caves of Qud is another really good proceduraly genrated game

[@PepeSi7via]

Why are parts of the video redacted?

[@Brainstrain]

It had a naughty word

[@SadSmileGames]

so, this is basically logical programming like in prolog, no?

[@NocturnalJin]

(at Darmok and Jalad, Tanagra)

[@juandesalgado]

shaka(A and B) = (shaka A) or (shaka B)

[@franknord4826]

@GDC: Is this video available on another platform? KZbin automatically blurs whole slides in this…

[@rewindcat7927]

Cool! My video had censor bars on it .. ??

[@qeshi]

7:52 Is this logic programming?

[@dciug]

Reminds me of Prolog as well. It's nice to see these old ideas implemented in games.

[@qeshi]

Yeah I've been thinking about using core.logic in clojurescript for games. Interesting though to use it for the narrative in the game.

[@KarolMarcjan]

On GitHub, there was some preliminary work by Chris and some Scheme/Kanren people about doing this in a system similar to core.logic.

[@andrewpomorski549]

This is a lisp like syntax

[@svart-rav8072]

I'm really curious where these eather novel deep learning language models will take this!

[@tsukinoko_kun]

Why is the presentation censored?

[@MistaSmith]

the blurring is super weird.

[@moncyn1]

12:55 doves dont eat ants

[@IkeFoxbrush]

They actually will if the ant insulted them first ;)

[@stevetaylor5290]

Happy to see the thumbnail for this is from the old Sinclair Spectrum “The Hobbit” game!

[@ironyelegy]

no kind effort is wasted... great philosophy

[@directorn8]

Yikes, wish I read the comments before going to the website. I clicked the I am Human button, but hopefully that didn't do anything nasty.

[@XMaster340]

What about it? I didn't see any comments about the website.

[@anybard]

💌

[@jacobmakob1]

I'd love to learn more about this, can anyone recommend some sources?

[@TheAssassin642]

Check out Emily Short I guess. There are other GDC talks on similar subjects as well

[@victornoagbodji]

thanks!

[@bodnotbod]

Anyone else keep thinking of Crusader Kings 2?

[@MrFusselig]

Yeah, I thought about it as well

[@AlexVoxel]

Nice talk, not that great for a game tho (a Ton of time required unfortunately)

[@feelsunbreeze]

so it consuming time makes it not great? this is such a dumb thing to say

[@diegoantoniorosariopalomin4977]

these kind of automatic generation its only in its infancy , further developements in artifcial neural networks will take to a new level

[@littlebigphil]

ANNs don't seem very well suited to this task.

[@diegoantoniorosariopalomin4977]

+littlebigphi are you up to date with their developement?

[@littlebigphil]

Not really. I've just taken a machine learning class, and done some external reading. I don't know if there's anything in particular you had in mind, but I'm aware of recurrent neural networks.

[@meneguzzi]

Controlled generativity is in a much cruder state in neural networks. They are excellent and (mostly) unbeatable for classification and regression, with the proviso that you have a ton of data to train it. But it's not, and likely will not, be the be all end all of AI. Even the researchers who developed the techniques that overcame the problems training large neural networks admit that they have no idea of *why* and *how* the resulting trained models do what they do. Deep neural networks in summary. To deal with noisy data from the real world: great. To generate behaviour with any remote semblance of control over what is generated: years away, if at all possible.

[@diegoantoniorosariopalomin4977]

Completly false ( innacurate ) neural networks excel in obtaining result in a controlled way , intituively

[@bodnotbod]

I kept thinking about Crusader Kings 2.

[@Twixmonster2]

I kept thinking about that somebody probably kept thinking about Crusader KIngs 2.

[@rei1789]

Man he sounds like Kermit the Frog.

[@bodnotbod]

Anyone else keep thinking of Crusader Kings 2?