Best Scrooge movies of all time? 🎄🎩A look at Christmas Carol adaptations on TV, film, animation

[@lightwork11]

Alister Sim, absolutely. I watch this version once or twice yearly, not necessarily at Christmas. The black and white film and darker scenes make me feel like I'm back in the time of the story. You can see Sims' vulnerability through his meanest scenes. His jubilant Christmas morning is humorous, heart-rending, and uplifting.

[@nancyevans7946]

Absolutely 👏👏

[@ChrisHyde537]

You’re right and more so because London was black and white in the 1830’s 🤔

[@oceanelf2512]

It's my favorite too. The Crotchet family are so warm and believable, the ghost of Marley tragic, Scrooge's giddiness after being so terrified and finally redeemed, I'd probably act exactly the same way in that situation. The music is beautiful. And I love everyone's accents.

[@neclark08]

...I WANTED to Love the Alastair Sim B-&-W version of ACC -- but Sim's expressive face is perpetually So CLOSE to bursting into Laughter that it Derails my Suspension-of-Disbelief...

[@jackieroberts3048]

I like the George C Scott version the best, with the Patrick Stewart version coming in a close second. I don't believe you talked about the Patrick Stewart version.

[@PC-dc1kv]

Without a doubt, Alistair Sim. He was the perfect Scrooge.

[@moscabianca2054]

Alastair Sims set the benchmark. Magnificent performance.

[@bixster2260]

I’m 71 and have loved the 1951 version of Scrooge forever. Completely authentic. Alastair Sim is a treasure. Cast is perfect. Even Patrick Macnee as a young Jacob Marley is a treat.

[@patriciayohn6136]

I am 73 and the Alastair Sim version is my very favorite as well!

[@martinhaub6828]

And yet it deviates further from the original Dickens than most all of them.

[@bixster2260]

@ including the Muppets? LOL

[@tiffsaver]

I'm 75-years old and I have seen ALL the different actors portraying Scrooge. NONE of them even come close to the 1951 version, starring the fantastic Alistair Sim. He is quite simply, irreplaceable. And btw, MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!

[@RickW-HGWT]

And to you as well, and a Happy New Year !.

[@laurelg9586]

ABSOLUTELY! I will not any other version! He plays the character superbly!!

[@jltrem]

Agreed.

[@airving]

That is so damn TRUE, FACTS, FACTS, FACTS, FACTS.

[@antidemonic806]

Merry Christmas

[@reginalddavis7578]

There is two that I truly love, The Alister Sim version(1951) and the Albert Finney version(1970) these are two of my absolute favorites!

[@codyflake3080]

I’m not sure whether to call it the best since I haven’t seen every version of A Christmas Carol but my favorite version is the 1984 version starring George C. Scott for 2 particular reasons. For starters, I love the way Scott portrays Scrooge. I also still get blown away by Edward Woodward’s performance as the Ghost of Christmas Present. He starts off merry but when he takes Scrooge to the Cratchit home and afterwards to where a homeless family is staying he really drives in the same point that Scrooge’s nephew made in the beginning of the story except it’s done with guilt and fear instead of patience and love.

[@deborahminter6231]

Agreed!

[@philjones3824]

Edward Woodward's ghost is one of my favorite portrayals in any of the versions.

[@deborahminter6231]

@@philjones3824 👍 He's y favorite ghost from all of the adaptations.

[@petermillward6070]

I have to agree, I like the 1951 version, Alistair Sim fantastic as Scrooge, he is very good. But the actor who played the Ghost of Christmas Present treated it a bit like a walk in the park and didnt really show much emotion or concern in the important parts he should have done....also the music didnt do much to elevate those important moments with the Ghost of Christmas Present. On the other hand the 1984 version - Edward Woodward absolutly nailed the part of playing the Ghost of Christmas Present and the music was excellent in conveying the impact of the words made by Edward Woodward. It was his acting ability which made me understand exactly what Charles Dickens was trying to convey through writing A Christmas Carol. Its not just a Christmas story, its a social commentary upon the way things were when Charles Dickens wrote it.....and as a social commentary - it still stands as relavent today as it did back then.

[@vintagelady1]

Agreed absolutely that the Ghost of Christmas Present is a highlight that raises this version up, tho I don't care for Scott---feels like overacting, too much crouching about.

[@xact13]

Great video! Albert Finney fan here-Cratchets visiting of Tiny Tim’s grave while Tim’s voice sings overhead is very emotional. Ghost of Christmas Present singing “I Like Life” is amazing. Cheers!

[@bbb462cid]

My attitude is such, I thank you very much

[@geslinam9703]

Yes! The best of them all. Reminds me, have yet to watch it and Christmas only a few days away. Not really feeling the spirit this year - maybe it will help.

[@xact13]

@@geslinam9703 I need to S well. I could use a shot of spirit this year

[@Dreadmonger2025]

@@geslinam9703 My favorite.

[@keithworx]

the best IMO...

[@EmJones-gu6fv]

No other version needs to exist because the 1951 Alistair Sim version is perfection.

[@RichardStanczak]

My favourite scene in the Sim version was when he went to Fred’s house to make amends and he stopped at the closed door to the party, and hesitated. You almost feel like he doesn’t have the courage to enter, and he turns to the maid, who, with a smile and a nod, urges him to go on. He smiles back to her and then opens the door. That scene, and what comes next, never fail to touch me deeply….no matter how many times I have seen it.

[@johnburns2940]

@RichardStanczak I hear you friend, that scene is so very touching. Underscored with beautiful music is indeed the moment and point of redemption 🕊️💟. Wishing you the very best of the Christmas Season.

[@davewilliams1157]

Interesting that you included a shot of Patrick Stewart as Scrooge in the intro but left him out of the other segments. His is one of my favorites after listening to his audiobook for several years. He also produced a one man stage show of A Christmas Carol.

[@mariahunter9882]

I wondered about that too. I really like the George C Scott version but I think Patrick Stewart is my favorite. His clumsy attempts to be charming after his redemption are a reminder that he has been unsocial for so long that he has forgotten how to be in society and has to relearn it.

[@smullis7]

The Patrick Stewart version s absolutely my favorite version too.

[@LuckyStone888]

I wanted to write something similar but keeping it all in the same conversation might make it more obvious. Parick Stewart is a remarkable actor and does a stellar Scrooge presentation in many adaptations.

[@davewilliams1157]

@@LuckyStone888 go onto Audible and get his Christmas Carol audiobook. You will not be disappointed!

[@annie6506]

Totally agree. Shame it was missed, don’t think anyone does it better that Stewart

[@keithbk]

10:30 Albert Finney's Scrooge is incredible, especially once you realize Albert Finney was his younger self in the flashback sequence. Too often, the attempt to make younger people look "old" fails in the makeup department, but Finney is so good, you believe he is that old man. From his bent-over demeanor, to his dirty fingernails and slightly unkempt face, it comes as an actual shock that he is that strapping younger version of himself in real life. Also, Jacob Marley is portrayed by none-other than Alec Guinness of later Star Wars fame. Long before he was ever Obi-Wan Kenobi, he was Scrooge's old business partner in this film. Another reason this version works so well is that it is entirely a British production of a classic British work. It feels authentic as a result, which is often lost in many "Americanized" productions of "A Christmas Carol." And the music is a holiday favorite, making this one of the greatest Christmas films of all time in our family, right up there with "It's a Wonderful Life."

[@rubyxfinity8634]

Yes! I showed it to some friends and noted that after the movie was done, and it blew their minds. They could not believe it was the same actor.

[@aruglaempire2518]

His voice was grating and hard to listen to.

[@anthonylester2837]

You are spot on!

[@isabelbeckerman9226]

No matter how many revitalized Scrooge movies are broadcast during the holiday season, undoubtedly none can be compared to the beloved and superb version enacted by Sir Alastair Sim in the 1951 classic A Christmas Carol, HAND's DOWN.

[@judynichols2904]

Absolutely !

[@esmeephillips5888]

He wasn't a Sir. He refused a knighthood in the early 70s. But three other British Scrooges got a tap on the shoulder: Hicks, Caine and Stewart.

[@isabelbeckerman9226]

​@@esmeephillips5888Regardless of his refusal to accept his noble knighthood, Alistair will always be known as "Sir Sim" among my favorite British actors of the glorious past.

[@jaybirdjargon]

Sim was TERRIBLE

[@isabelbeckerman9226]

@@jaybirdjargon Your dumb assessment appears to be influenced by an excessive consumption of whiskeynogs, huh Jaybirdjargon?

[@Salad64]

1951 version with Alastair Sim by far is the best. The musical adaptation with Albert Finney is excellent too. “I don’t deserve to be so happy”. Then he throws his pen….love it

[@JFAOwner]

It's not Christmas without seeing Sim throw the pen at the end of the movie.

[@willsingourd2523]

#1 Alister Sim #2 Albert Finney #3 Patrick Stewart (Stellar though he was!)

[@waynemartinmartin4128]

The 1984 version with George C Scott is my favorite. He gives an amazing performance.

[@carreyperea9856]

i totally agree!!

[@eldour6101]

I also think this version is the best. The protagonist, the language used is more reminiscent of the time the play was written. I think it presents the story as the author would have wanted it to be...

[@intuitive7274]

Absolutely correct no one plays it better

[@bluethelucario6194]

YESSS! I WAS HOPING SOMEONE WOULD MENTION THIS ONE!

[@intuitive7274]

@bluethelucario6194 absolutely the best of all of them

[@Scooby-Doo84]

1951 version starring Alister Sim is our absolute favorite. We watch it every Christmas Eve around midnight.

[@deeanneburke2960]

Alistair Sim's version is hands down the best version in my book. It's a MUST WATCH every year❤

[@toddtaylor6594]

The 1938 Version of A Christmas Carol is my favorite overall....... The 1951 version is The Second Best

[@bondgabebond4907]

@@toddtaylor6594 There is only one Scrooge and that is Alister Sims. His performance was perfect. All others just played the part, Alister became Scrooge.

[@Wilkins_Micawber]

I was brought up with Alister Sim, so I am biased. In fact Dickins wrote the book with Sim in mind for the part. A very cleaver trick, seeing about 100 years elapsed from the writing of the book to the movie. His version takes me back more than 70 years to my chilhood memories. SIM was a wonderfull actor and much loved here in the UK.

[@suzannepottsshorts]

Muppet Christmas Carol with Michael Cain is absolutely glorious and absolutely my favorite.

[@carolannjeffries5862]

And that's why he is "Sir"

[@punky19761]

I love it too! 💕

[@carollund8251]

I love it too and now they cut out that beautiful song " When love is gone"

[@SwayneIII]

more partial to the Albert Finney version from 70

[@dianeorsino6570]

Mine too, every year this is the one I watch.

[@jlanderson21257]

Alister Sim...that's the one I cry to every year. Love them all, but the acting was superb in this one.

[@nanasewdear]

My favorite version is the one with George C. Scott. My husband loves the musical with Albert Finney. It is always a treat seeing June Lockhart (who is still alive!!) in the 1938 version playing along with her father Gene Lockhart.

[@josephinerimmer6888]

My favourite is also George C Scott, he was quite menacing before his redemption.

[@brianmatt4822]

I have not seen the Lockhart version,family affair for real! Thanx,a must- find& see! - b

[@Salad64]

I didn’t like George’s acting in this version… I’ll have to watch again

[@nanasewdear]

@@Salad64 It's okay! We all have our favorites. I'm still sentimental about the Mr. Magoo version.😜

[@HuntingViolets]

She's 99 now. Her mother plays Mrs. Cratchit in that version too.

[@ObservantHistorian]

Alistair Sim, of course, and thanks for including "Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol" in the runners-up section! I'm a big fan of it, and although I won't argue it's the best of the animated versions, I think it's a gem in its own right! If anyone hasn't seen it (or shied away because it's Magoo), the premise of the TV show is Mr. Magoo playing Scrooge in a live stage production. Only the opening and closing scenes of the program feature Magoo bumbling around the stage _before_ and _after_ the play's performance; in the telling of "A Christmas Carol" - the bulk of the program - Magoo plays Scrooge straight, with no attempt to incorporate Magoo's blind bumbling into the Christmas Carol story itself, so that the telling of the story is fairly true in dialogue and scope...and there are a few great songs in it, too! Perhaps not the best of the animated bunch, as I said, but worth a view, if you've never seen it.

[@michaelhemsley1470]

I've loved Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol since I was a child. "Rassaberry puddin".

[@meh8982]

I have a fondness for that one. As a child I saw Mr. Magoo playing Scrooge and Don Quixote, and he introduced me to some great literature that way. He really rose to a whole new level when he went on the stage! But the best traditionally animated version is surely the 1971 one with Alastair Sim playing Scrooge again. The visuals are striking, often dark and scary, but beautiful. Unfortunately, it's just too short.

[@adeleosther4442]

Mr. Magoo is my favorite animated version of A Christmas Carol. I watch it every Christmas Eve.

[@susandevitte2137]

My favorite A CHRISTMAS CAROLE.

[@vickyrun8796]

1984 with George C. Scott is my favorite. I watch it almost every year, occasionally watching other versions. Thanks for this review. You even covered a couple I didn't know about.

[@ruthking7884]

Scrooge with a US accent? Nope.

[@DrewHall-un8sn]

vickyrun8796, also my favorite. I watch it every Christmas eve. I feel like it hits the right notes and the production feels like you can smell and taste the grit of old London.

[@asinglegreatarmada1998]

Alister Sim is definitely my favorite. His "morning after" persona is a perfect rendition, of being overwhelmed with the foreign emotion of cheer that it borderlines lunacy. I feel like the "morning after" for Patrick Stewart's version is the only weak part of his performance. You done did Obi Wan wrong!!!! Did you know Alec Guiness plays Jacob Marley in the albert Finney version? You absolutely can't recognize him, or even his voice. Guy Pearce's version is revolutionary, because behind every monster, there is a mountain of trauma, and this version really goes into what made Scrooge into a monster. His redemption is also much more realistic psychologically. I have to set up a schedule every December to fit all of my favorite versions in.

[@MarkWYoung-ky4uc]

My favorite version by far is the 1951 version titled "Scrooge" with Alister Sim. The actors and actresses all are outstanding in their roles. 2 of my favorites are Michael Hordern's Jacob Marley and Kathleen Harrison's Mrs. Dilber. Both shine in their respective roles. While the movie is dark overall, it is light during the good times such as when Bob Cratchit is getting off work on Christmas eve or when Scrooge dances with Fred's wife. This is reflected in the music which fits each scene perfectly.

[@patriciagerresheim2500]

Merry Christmas...if it ain't out o' keepin' with the sitch-you-why-shun...

[@normano3573]

@@patriciagerresheim2500 love it!

[@georgeedward1226]

I agree 100%. It's the best one.

[@kokovaleto]

For sure you haven't watch George C. Scott's version

[@patriciagerresheim2500]

@@kokovaleto Yes, I have. As far as I'm concerned, Mark Strickson (Turlough on 'Doctor Who') as Young Scrooge was the best thing about it. I was totally unimpressed by Scott's portrayal of Scrooge.

[@NicholasTesluk]

I’ve long loved the Alistair Sim version!❤

[@HarlequinDrFaustus]

Alastair Sim is my favorite, with Finney, Caine coming in close seconds, also Hicks & Scott also up there. Dickens was a favorite writer from childhood, and some years ago got a collection of his Christmas stories, especially to re-read this story again, as it is a favorite. (even the not so good versions tend to get me teary).

[@bonnie43uk]

Albert Finney for me, i watched it at the cinema in Swindon UK in 1971, and it had a lasting effect on me, I watched it yesterday here on KZbin. 🙂

[@rehconcepts935]

same saw it in an old cold dark theater when I was a kid and it has always styed with me - we watch every Christmas eve -Thank Ya Very Much....Thank Ya Very Much

[@tomheinle1049]

The musical with Albert Finney is my favorite. The redemption of Scrooge is made so much stronger with the songs.

[@okmrocksU]

Scrooge with Albert Finney, is my favorite version. It was awesome to see in the theater.

[@beachcomberbob3496]

Some people watch other movies on Christmas Day, but this one is mine. Equal parts funny and light hearted, with the counterpoint of tear jerking emotion, and who can not like Anton Rogers singing 'Thank You Very Much'! (R.I.P. Anton - top actor!)

[@okmrocksU]

@@beachcomberbob3496 Of course we all know how the story goes in each version. However the way the whole story was put together, acted out and filmed, was a joy to watch in this version. To me, no other holds a candle to it.

[@anjkovo2138]

Every year for the past 15 years we watch SCROOGE the Musical at 10am on xmas day morning. THANK YOU VERY MUCH👍😀👍🎄

[@MetaCinema]

It is a great version full of Christmas spirit with all that music. Your welcome and thank you!

[@LocalFoe]

My family celebrates with the same film. Merry Christmas

[@anjkovo2138]

A Merry Christmas to you and your Family Too. All the best to you🎄🎄@@LocalFoe

[@marywalters9463]

You should try a new musical version from 2022 called Spirited and stars Will Ferrell and Ryan Reynolds. It is told from the spirits' point of view and is quite a different take on the story.

[@Video81501]

The best part of Michael Caine's performance is his duet with Belle, the only time he ever sings on screen. Takes some work to find. One of the best things Disney ever produced. Melts and breaks your heart.

[@Indylimburg]

The music in that film is top notch. It really deserves the Broadway treatment.

[@fredsmith3456]

Absolutely Albert Finney! That was a masterpiece of acting, not only by Finney, but many others in this engaging musical extravaganza.

[@gracebutler6568]

Sir Alistar Sim is the best Scrooge of all, hands dowm! He is incredible at being mean and also at being happy and good to all around him. Loved it and watch this every year at least once.

[@paulajaneabel5205]

George C. Scott. He's perfect. Add the wonderful supporting cast, and the production values and you get the definitive Christmas Carol.

[@intuitive7274]

Absolutely the best of all

[@songsmith31a]

The use of Shrewsbury, an ancient Shropshire city, plus quality production values certainly helped,

[@Chris-lc5ql]

I do like this version too. I like the voice of Roger Rees who played Fred. I just like his enunciation and his style of speaking.

[@robbyadkins6367]

Almost the only version I will watch at all. The best by a good bit. Not to say the others are bad.

[@RonKelmell]

I like th e1951 first and the G.C.Scott second. The further one goes from the original script, the lesser the impact for my $$$.

[@hughwalker5628]

I always said Alastair Sim. I was a committed Sim supporter. Then The Muppet's Christian Carol came along and Michael Caine's performance changed everything.

[@netherfield2000]

I saw Patrick Stewart live performing his one-man show version on Broadway in the 90s. It was amazing.

[@MetaCinema]

I didn't even know he did that, that is amazing.

[@helgabruin2261]

That would have been wonderful!!

[@coffeegrinder6319]

TNT did a Patrick Stewart film called Scrooge that was very good.

[@esnstrider46]

I actually saw Patrick live on stage in Los Angeles

[@Babette-cr2zu]

@@coffeegrinder6319That version, and The Muppets are my favorites.

[@nancyhansen7484]

Alistair Sim owns this character. He absolutely embodies the ,forgive me, the spirit of the tale Mr. Dickens is trying to get across. To watch him turn from the penny- pinching curmudgeonly, sour old man to the open hearted, generous , loving genuine gentleman never gets old. When I was a 6th grade teacher, we read The Christmas Carol in class. We then watched the Alistair Sim version of the movie. They were enthralled because they understood it, having read and discussed it beforehand.

[@bobrech3661]

My favorite character in literature is Jacob Marley. My favorite line is, “it is a ponderous chain”. I like the George C Scott version best. He is great as Scrooge, and Marley is terrific. I really liked your review.

[@thefilmwatcher1216]

My favorite is Michael Caine. I love how seriously he plays the role, but he's also incredibly joyful at the end. He sells every moment of Scrooge, even his awkwardness as he tries to have fun.

[@greybone777]

Cain played every role to perfection.

[@Indylimburg]

Agreed. He becomes extremely likeable.

[@PellyjellyMom]

I don’t think I ever saw him as Scrooge. I will have to look.

[@debbieroberts5866]

Agreed!

[@scottvasquez1401]

The 1984 Version is the Best version. Not only does the movie hit all the beats of the novel and gets all the emotional moments of the novel right on cue, but Scott is the Best Scrooge. It is a toss up between Sims and Scott on who the best Scrooge. I love Sims subtle version and he looks miserable, and his redemption feels a lot better, but I give Scott the edge because I love his Business man approach, as Scrooge is a stockbroker in the original book, and he is not trying to be nasty, he just wants anything sentimental to keep their distance. When he observes his visions, he really takes it in with his expressions, and even pulls it off without any dialogue. But the biggest reason I put him above Sims is his redemption. Scott really lets the Joy out and he is just happy to live again. Scott is 100% Natural as Scrooge.

[@josefj1776]

I like the 1990’s Patrick Stewart version.

[@aruglaempire2518]

Scott has an American accent NOT a English accent. Scrooge was NOT American.

[@Tiberius_Productions]

The 1951 version is better in my opinion.

[@MsAppassionata]

What? You don’t think that Sims let the joy out and was happy to be alive after meeting with the ghosts?! I disagree. He’s positively giddy. That’s why I love his performance the best. Not saying that the other Scrooge performances are bad, but I believe that the Sims version is the best.

[@seanryan3020]

Although I'm generally not a fan of musicals, the 1970 version of "Scrooge" with Albert Finney is my absolute favorite! At 54 years old, I'm still moved to tears by "Thank You Very Much!" And I love Alec Guinness' portrayal of Marley!

[@stephaniecranston8134]

I love the Alister Sim and George C. Scott versions, but recently saw the muppet one and really enjoyed that. And now I want to see the Albert Finney one again. Thank you.

[@riverotter68]

Albert Finney - hands down the best Scrooge

[@anthonylester2837]

100 percent

[@jimbeaux89]

Albert Finney’s rendition of Scrooge will always be my favorite. He did such a wonderful job playing the old miser.

[@brianmatt4822]

I regret I have not had the pleasure.- b

[@hollytooker507]

Albert Finney hands down, Thank you very much!

[@willsingourd2523]

Hey, that line was copyrighted! 🤣🥴🤣

[@modernjosephus356]

I laugh with Scrooge every time at the end of the Alistair Sim. That is how good it is. It gets you involved.

[@kathykoeven]

Alastair Sim, George C. Scott, Patrick Stewart, and Michael Caine/Muppet in that order. I just watched all of these yesterday and today.

[@kathykoeven]

Another one I watched was a comedy, a bit of slapstick. It was kind of odd but fun. “A Christmas Carol Goes Wrong” - I enjoyed watching it and thought it was good with some laughs.

[@songsmith31a]

The Alistair Sim version with its perfect choice of music has to be my selection. It is probably fair to say that if Michael Caine had been around and played the part with the same brio that he brought to the role of Scrooge in his Muppet Movie version, he would probably have come close to Sim's own definitive performance.

[@petermorris9818]

I only watch one really, I also was brought up on the peerless Alastair Sim version. Every Christmas Eve a few decades ago, our dad would collect my brothers and I from a grenwich pub and take us back to our folks' place for loads of hot snacks, port and Scrooge.

[@chessthecat]

1951 Sim is the definitive version for many including me. The line delivery is the one most people are subconsciously quoting when they quote Scrooge or Tiny Tim. "I've not taken leave of my senses Bob, I've come to them." You just read that in Sim's voice.

[@ravingartist1]

Another vote for Alastair Sim's portrayal of Scrooge! The 1951 version also has the best Bob Cratchet.

[@dbird1356]

There are many great versions. I prefer the George C Scott version 1984. The Ghost of Christmas Present portrayed by Edward Woodward in that version is sublime. 🎄🎅🏻😊

[@budnbess]

My favorite Scrooge is George C. Scott in a brilliant performance. Of the versions I have seen, I find the Patrick Stewart closest to the novella, but this also brings out how detailed and heart-wrenching the book is (a book which I have read more than any other, sometimes alone, sometime with others.) In a way, watching several versions every year is akin to a group reading in which different nuances of character and the difficulties of life in Dickens's time are introduced by the various participants in the reading.

[@susanfanning9927]

George C. Scott for the win. He is perfect in the role ("Don't beg on this corner, boy!") and is surrounded by a stellar supporting cast. The production values are astounding, and not one detail is overlooked. Tiny Tim is adorable, though I think he had to learn his lines phonetically--he is a very little boy in this case.

[@ruthking7884]

Scrooge was not American and Scott played him with an American accent. He should have done better. Sim for the win.

[@stanhaselton3620]

I watch the Patrick Stewart version every year. Best? It’s hard to choose between him and Michael Caine. These are the two best Scrooges for me.

[@ellennewth6305]

Albert Finney was my favorite Scrooge, but Jim Backus (Mr. Howell) rocked it as Mr. Magoo! But the music in both versions was phenomenal! Finney's 1970 adaptation was scored by Leslie Bricusse (who composed music for the original Willie Wonka (Think "Oompa Loompa" and "Pure Imagination") and the Magoo version was written by Jule Stein ("Funny Girl," "Gypsy," "Peter Pan") and Bob Merrill "Funny Girl" "Carnival" & "How Much is that Doggie in the Window?") It's a joy just to listen to these awesome holiday tunes!!!!!

[@craiganderson7986]

This right here. Mr Magoo’s Christmas Carol was TV’s first ever primetime animated special, and it is special indeed. It’s set up as Broadway production (although the opening and closing scenes that make this obvious are usually cut to make room for more commercials). The songs are some of Broadway’s best, the animated performances are all you could hope for, and the voice acting is the best in the biz! It was even performed LIVE at New York’s City Center a few years ago! It is truly a delight, a great version that deserves to be seen every Christmas!

[@willsingourd2523]

Finney comes in at second place for me. (Sim #1 - I know! OBvious, BORing! And Patrick Stewart gets my bronze.) Thank you for all the musical detail here, and I couldn't agree more! (I compose piano etudes for begining/intermediate students.)

[@jannibal9273]

I only discovered this year (2023) that I could watch the 1935, 1938 and 1951 versions here at KZbin for free! I grew up watching the 1951 version. When the 1984 version came out, I was floored. Always loved George C. Scott and Susannah York - who had starred in an earlier movie "Jane Eyre," my favorite rendition of that story by far. To see them, although not face to face, in the 1984 version of "A Christmas Carol" was a thrill. The acting quality in that made for TV version was wonderful. Then came along the 1999 made for TV version with Patrick Stewart, whom I had only known as Captain Picard from Star Trek. I also enjoyed the American version during the Great Depression starring, of all people, "Fonzi" a/k/a Henry Winkler from "Good Times" placed in my home town of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. I purchased the George C. Scott and Patrick Stewart versions so I will have them until I'm 6 feet under, but the other versions I would hunt for to watch for free on "over the air" TV and streaming platforms that I have subscriptions to (just a few). I haven't watched any of the animated or musical versions. I would say my favorite is the one with George C. Scott (1984).

[@paranormalskeptic3893]

I can’t find the Reginald Owen one here for free.

[@theblitz9]

I'm stunned that he didn't mention the Patrick Stewart version. BTW, he was actually a serious actor. Especially doing a lot of Shakespeare plays.

[@sophiak8599]

appreciate your comments. just a note: Henry Winkler played Fonzi in Happy Days :)

[@brianmatt4822]

Agreed. As I said,my opinion, that man just shows up & doesn't act- he just is who he is in his script. Just there,& I'll bet few rakes to get it perfect. 😊 - b

[@TimothyFair-zg4wm]

The 1938 version with Reginald Owen was my favorite

[@todwest]

Sim's performance isn't just the best Scrooge, it's one of the finest performances in cinema history. Rarely does an actor inhabit a role so convincingly.

[@stephenb5jones476]

My favorite is the George C. Scott version. He does such a great job of both versions of the character.

[@MetaCinema]

That is a great point because the actor must play two opposite personalities, which I don't think many fully pull off (while also not making the character unlikable). Seymour Hicks is another that had this full range.

[@rodneyhamilton2562]

My favorite is Albert Finney from the 1971 version. His utter bitterness and hatred of everyone is really good, and I also really liked the depiction of how he lived. How he got food, clothes, and the condition of his home are excellent.

[@sonegirl5010]

Albert Finney has always been my favorite.

[@maccagrabme]

Most underrated too.

[@MsBackstager]

@@maccagrabme Luv the song THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

[@checkmate9111]

Albert Finney.

[@rubyxfinity8634]

Albert Finney in the Scrooge musical, hands down. It is perfection from beginning to end. I watch it every year, usually sobbing all over the place (especially he Happiness and You songs, which have me, a grown man, bawling every time). This time for the first year watched it on an expensive big OLED TV (where black = LED switched OFF). The Technicolor really pops, I saw details I'd never noticed before! MAGNIFICENT!

[@willsingourd2523]

Finney takes the Silver after Sim's Gold! Splendid music! (Captain Picard/Patrick Stewart gets my bronze.)

[@JSDevivre]

So glad to know I'm not the only one who sobs during this version. My eyes were practically swollen shut after yesterday's traditional Christmas morning viewing!

[@johnbrowne2170]

Alastair Sim's performance is the gold standard.

[@suzannahdarcy6903]

The Alister Sim version is the gold standard. I enjoy how it feels like it was filmed in the actual Victorian era instead of 1951. The Muppet Christmas Carol is also a favourite with my family. And I don't mind the CGI version ever. It's fun to watch.

[@monicacall7532]

Albert Finley is my favorite Scrooge. Who can forget the song “Thank You Very Much”? The Muppet version with Michael Caine is my other favorite. The scene at the Fozziwig’s Christmas party is priceless!

[@JSDevivre]

Same 😃

[@mikemccormick8115]

Albert Finney “Scrooge” by far. Classic British musical of that era like Oliver!

[@tbasho1441]

I 2nd that. Finney's performance is fantastic. I watch this every Christmas. The solo sung by Scrooge during the Ghost of Christmas past sequence to his lost love is just a killer, as is the end.

[@MichaelJohnson-vi6eh]

Alistair Sim is my favorite - although the one with Albert Finney has music that is fantastic! I actually have never seen the mapper one- I'll try to find it this year somewhere.

[@MetaCinema]

The 1970 version has some very catchy songs. Which is the mapper one?

[@Amm1ttai]

@@MetaCinema I think he means Muppet.

[@overthathill]

My family and I watch the Muppets Christmas Carol every year. What an amazing soundtrack.

[@carollund8251]

Yes but they cut out the best song " When love is gone". So disappointing. We have it on an old videotape, but our VCR doesn't work anymore..On Disney channel that beautiful sad scene is cut.

[@PamArtsValentine]

My favorite is Scrooge with Albert Finney! The music is fantastic & Finney plays both young & old Scrooge perfectly!

[@bbb462cid]

I hate all the ignorant classes sitting on their ignorant asses

[@PamArtsValentine]

@@bbb462cid People are despicable creatures / loathsome, inexplicable creatures, good-for-nothing kickable creatures!

[@willsingourd2523]

I believe Finney is the only actor of ANY of these movies who played both young Scrooge & old Scrooge. And as you say, ideal performances, both.

[@rayofhope1114]

Sim is the best and most closely mirrors the harshness of mid 19th century life for the surplus population in the inner city. Very well acted by all.

[@rehconcepts935]

Albert Finney Scrooge is my favorite - but honorable second place to Magoo in "Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol is a 1962 animated musical holiday television special" absolutely great memorable songs/music in both versions!

[@earlymorningtwilight9119]

Alister Sim is my favorite. He frightened me as a child but I loved it.

[@skizzwhizzle6840]

Scrooge 1970 - because of its uniqueness and great acting - and three amazing original songs (and some okay ones too)….is my gold standard

[@NancySanders-om4ic]

I think the 1938 version with Reginald Owen IS the Best " A Christmas Carol," with Gene Lockhart,June Lockhart. I think All of the actors were Very good in their roles and the atmosphere,feel of the movie was so Good.

[@kennyhuskisson2684]

I agree with you, I have that version on VHS, I'd like to find it on DVD, but it's my favorite version, Merry Christmas☃️🎄👍✌️

[@RickW-HGWT]

​@@kennyhuskisson2684It may be available on KZbin or for download, copyright might have expired already.

[@NancySanders-om4ic]

@@kennyhuskisson2684 Merry Christmas🎄⛄🎄⛄🎄⛄🎄⛄🎄🎄

[@porkchopexpress2437]

Agreed. The 1938 version will always be my favorite. Amazing that June Lockhart and Terry Kilburn are still alive to this day. Both in their 90's.... Cratchit knocking off Scrooges top hat and then having it run over by the horse/carriage was a great scene.. "Is this your idea of a Christmas joke!"😂

[@BobUeckerRocks0]

Yep. And underrated

[@scottsellars6468]

Thanks for putting this together, some in there I haven't seen but, like many, the 50s version with Alistair Sim is my favourite and I ensure I watch it every Christmas.

[@nancysewing773]

Patrick Stewart is my favorite. That's because I taught Junior High literature, and I always felt it was a good version to watch after we read the book. I also showed them A Muppet Christmas Carol because I like Michael Caine too.

[@kennethwayne6857]

One thing that stood out for me in the Stewart version that nobody talks about is the music. I mean the songs sung by Mrs. Cratchit while preparing the table, by Fezziwig at his party, and by the party guest at Fred's house towards the end whose name I don't recall. If they aren't authentic Victorian songs, they certainly sound like they are!

[@SamJones-qs2cw]

Without a doubt, Albert Finney‘s 1970s Scrooge was the best portrayed ever! His portrayal of the character was absolutely convincing and spot on. No other version comes close to this in my opinion. It truly embodies the spirit of Christmas and pays true homage to Charles Dickens story!

[@jaguar6519]

1951 version with Alistair sim or the original classic version from 1935 with Seymour Hicks both excellent versions of scrooge. Scrooge has to be seen in Black and White to get the full atmosphere of the film the coloured versions don't have the same appeal, Charles Dickens book was called Scrooge not A Christmas Carol but when the 1951 version I think went over to the United States they changed it to A Christmas Carol for the American audience why they thought they had to do that only they know.

[@JohnSmith-be1vl]

Oddly enough the US release is more correctly titled, contrary to what many Americans think (which I get... why would we misname our own novel?!) as the book was indeed 'A Christmas Carol. In Prose. Being a Ghost Story of Christmas', or (from the front cover) just 'A Christmas Carol'.

[@xray86delta]

My favorite is the Alistair Sims version. It was also the first one that I saw as a child in the 60s. Notable mention to the "Muppets Christmas Carol".😉

[@akshaytrayner1960]

Patrick Stewart one is my favourite because they got details that weren’t in other adaptations same with the 1984

[@alexkoeslag5699]

Allister Sim version ....the black and white version gives a great feel of the era....watch it every Christmas

[@atreb56]

Albert Finney in Scrooge. Love this musical. Genius.

[@RickW-HGWT]

If you can get the songs , add them to your Christmas Playlist, "Thank You Very Much " and "December the 25th" will cheer up if your feeling blue.

[@mikeburkhart8336]

Albert Fenney will always be the best Scrooge to me. The musical version of Scrooge is a tradition that I've watched every year since I was a kid.

[@njtnjtnjt_]

Man for me... Between George C. Scott's performance and that beautiful score, '84 is bumped to the front on my list.

[@chieftandriver703]

Agree completely about Michael Caine portrayal in the Muppets Christmas Carol The whole film is so beautifully executed and written and bizarrely the puppets voice actors make you forget they are puppets. For me (in my 60’s now) it dawned on me quite recently that Michael Caine is my favourite actor I was watching Miss Congeniality of all things and he was in it. He was absolutely brilliant in it. He made the film for me and then I realised he was in most of my favourite films. The Man who would be King, A Bridge too Far, the Battle of Britain, Alfie, The Italian Job, the Harry Palmer spy films, even the sympathetic Nazi in the Eagle has Landed………….on an on his film credits go. He was an icon of the 60’s, yet for some reason it never dawned on me he was the glue that held them all together. And ultimately the Muppets Christmas Carol was the film was one of his best films because you saw beyond the silliness and connected with a brilliant story, written by a genius author and acted by a superb actor

[@cindyhuffaker6357]

I liked the Muppets Ghost of Christmas past best, as a child.

[@Indylimburg]

A bunch of my favorites as well. Can't forget him playing Alfred in the Dark Knight trilogy either.

[@debbieroberts5866]

Agreed!

[@davemandaro2138]

Sim version had more story, but I grew up with the 1938 version on tv every Christmas,my personal favorite .

[@Yeoman1346]

My favorite is the Alastair Sims version. I have read it year’s ago and my high school English class performed it. I love the way Sims shows Scrooges transformation. I love George C Scott but always felt as though George Patton was playing Scrooge. He was a great actor but his Patton role just stuck with me. I felt like Patrick Stewart was just hurrying through the production to get it over with. I know he wanted to do it originally as a one man show and was disappointed when he couldn’t do it. Others were alright but Sims was my number one Scrooge.

[@donridgway7269]

Alistair Sim, yes, especially for his giddy performance in the last part.

[@timjones4146]

Absolutely Alistair Sim. And despite all the fine versions, I hold a special place in my heart for Mr. MaGoo, "and razzleberry dressing." 🥰

[@theproplady]

The Alistair Sim version hits every major beat of the story and portrays a Scrooge that's multilayered and even funny. I could believe that he was once a good man who was changed by his sister's death and by his fear of the world. And his redemption scenes are beautiful. Michael Caine does a phenomenal job in his portrayal of Scrooge and the Muppet's Christmas Carol has lots of fun breaking the fourth wall. The George C. Scott version has the best Ghosts of Christmas. Angela Pleasance's Ghost of Christmas Past is androgynous, mysterious and faerielike. Edward Woodward’s Ghost of Christmas Present starts out boisterous but becomes more serious and accusatory as time goes on. The Ghost of Christmas Future (which I'm sure was animatronic) is the most terrifying portrayal I've ever seen, looking every bit like the Doom that Scrooge has coming to him without being just some lame guy under a black sheet.

[@mikerobertson4041]

My favorite Ebenezer Scrooge, hands down, is Alistair Sim! He was quite believable in this role. I watch this every Christmas!

[@robincochran7369]

Oh, without a doubt the 1951 version with Alister Sim. If I had to choose a second, I would choose the 1984 version with George C. Scott. I watched several versions and it's still interesting to see how each actor approached their roles.

[@MetaCinema]

Going by the comments so far I think many people agree: Alastair Sim then George C Scott a close second. It is interesting to see how each actor portrayed their role, including the supporting characters such as Cratchit, the ghosts, etc.

[@RickW-HGWT]

​@@MetaCinemaLove this post and video, ,maybe some on who's the best supporting cast , i.e. the best Bob Cratchit, Tiny Tim , etc. Merry Christmas and thanks again for this video.

[@songsmith31a]

I recall reading that Scott gave credit to Sim for setting the gold standard in the role of Scrooge.

[@sherribrtn]

Very good video; Alistair Sims version is my favorite. I watch it every year. "God bless us, everyone!" Merry Christmas to you and yours.

[@ralph0901]

I agree, it is my favorite too

[@aivoryuk]

I have watched most versions and my favourite is the George C Scott version. It is an incredible performance and the way he switches between being bitter to joyous is amazing. His facial expressions really tell a lot and it is a very strong supporting cast. It has the right balance of spookiness as well.

[@dazblue5515]

As a huge fan of the Dickens novel, for me my favourite version is the Albert Finney version... I watch it every Christmas eve, the songs are wonderful.

[@janbarrett4544]

My brother is an actor with many different theaters in The Berkshires in Massachusettes.He has played Scrooge many times and his redemption is his favorite part. My favorite Scrooge (aside from Glenn) is the 1951 Alistair Simm film...and my favorite part is the scene where he goes to dine with his nephew and he reconsiders the idea but the house maid takes his hat and coat and gives him the most heart breaking look of encoragement. I watch it every year and I wait for that scene.

[@Loulizabeth]

That scene at the end is one of my favourites too and it shows one of the most significant reasons that Sims is my favourite Scrooge, and that is his new humility. Scrooge in this version does not only like people and Christmas now, he has been truly humbled and can laugh at himself, and no longer sees himself as better than others and their position. His attitude with the maid here really exemplifies this practically asking her if it's okay to enter the room. As does his words to Fred's wife and his self deprecating humour. And even when he sings to himself about not knowing anything. You really feel that the years have been rolled back and he's finally able to enjoy a second childhood, which really wasn't much the first time round. His utter joy at the end and his acknowledgement that he doesn't deserve it shows truly how much he's changed.

[@songsmith31a]

With considerable "atmosphere" from the fine Richard Addinsell score and its deft use of "Barbara Allen"...an inescapable "tear-jerking" episode of redemption.

[@janbarrett4544]

@@Loulizabeth I wasn't sure anyone ever noticed that scene..the house maid has no lines...but there is kindness in her face...and this year while I have watched people suffer I have made KINDNESS a priority.Thank you so much for your oomment.When I watch it on Christmas I will think of you.

[@esmeephillips5888]

From the comments I estimate that Alistair Sim is the clear winner, followed by George C Scott and with a notable write-in vote for Patrick Stewart. Can't argue with the #1, but this is a story that has brought out the best in film and TV makers for 90 years, so let's hear it for Mr Charles Dickens too.

[@elizabeths4371]

@@Loulizabeth I agree with you TOTALLY

[@KnightRider-hm4kn]

Albert Finney's Christmas Carol is the BEST Scrooge movie OF ALL TIME. Plot, drama, music, characters, etc I have seen other versions and no one comes close.

[@marthaloss3114]

My absolute, all-time favorite, and the first Christmas movie I watch every year, is the 1951 version with Alistair Sim. It keeps very close to the book and is so well acted and believable. It fits with the Victorian time period in it's costuming and sets and there is no unnecessary special effects and glitz to detract from the honest feeling of this wonderful story. It will get my vote every time.

[@iczerman]

Alister Sim....Nuff said. Very philosophical without trying. " I don't know anything. I never did know anything. Now I KNOW that i don't know."

[@paulaatkins4955]

Seen them all, love them all. Just acted in a community theater production of Christmas Carol, the Musical. Surprisingly it followed the book faithfully. Thank you.

[@MetaCinema]

I didn't know the musical versions were done locally so much, that's great!

[@marywalters9463]

Try out a new musical version from 2022 called Spirited. It is told from the spirits' point of view and stars Will Ferrell and Ryan Reynolds.