BEST & WORST "ONE & DONE" EYESHADOWS

Today I’m sacrificing my face real estate for the sake of science to show you all my one-and-done/single-pan eyeshadows in 4K to compare the best and worst. And yes there are true BEST and WORST in this category!
Amanda Z's video of the same concept!: • One & Done Eyeshadows:...
The shadows:
Supergoop Shimmershade:
Violette_FR Yeux Paint: shop-links.co/174341410146172...
MILK Makeup Color Chalks: shop-links.co/174341412866919...
Auric Cosmetics Smoke Reflect: shop-links.co/174341415240958...
Hourglass Scattered Light: shop-links.co/174341417834695...
Vesca Moonlit Dream: shop-links.co/174341431987766...
Illamasqua Iconic Chrome Paints: shop-links.co/174341433162999...
Victoria Beckham Beauty Lid Lustre: shop-links.co/174341434311797...
Phytosurgence Cream Eyeshadows: shop-links.co/174341437310383...
Smashbox Always On: shop-links.co/174341440543933...
ROEN Quads:
NYX Vivid Brights: shop-links.co/174341448780251...
Glossier Lidstar: glossier.79ic8e.net/PNN6q
Glossier Skywash: glossier.79ic8e.net/nmX07
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brighteners: bit.ly/3jZmLBs
Danessa Myricks Color Fix: shop-links.co/174341464425032...
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerize: shop-links.co/174341466472522...
Rare Beauty Liquid Eyeshadow: shop-links.co/174341469372841...
Natasha Denona Chromium Liquid Eyeshadow: shop-links.co/174341471663272...
Chantecaille Mermaid Eyeshadow: shop-links.co/174341474066387...
Covergirl Lid Paint: shop-links.co/174341476417864...
What else is on my face:
Beekman 1802 SPF Primer Milk: shop-links.co/174341477863100...
Thrive Buildable Blur Concealer (Fair): bit.ly/34ZBTJN
Glossier Boy Brow in Brown: glossier.79ic8e.net/X3Yay
Thrive Causemetics Lip Filler Long Wearing + Plumping Lip Liner in KACKIE: bit.ly/2I98NMY
Glossier Balm Dotcom: glossier.79ic8e.net/Dzzkq
Other Discount Links:
50% your Italic Membership: bit.ly/3q4qLDv (code KACKIE50)
$25 off at Daily Harvest: bit.ly/38WXVQq
$21 off at Jungmaven: RWRD.IO/J4Z6JZP
30% off Bundles at Salt New York: bit.ly/2OvuWIs code (KACKIE30)
10% off at Glossier: glossier.79ic8e.net/gkoXg
10% off at Thrive Causemetics: prf.hn/l/K9NlQaL
15% off at Farfetch: farfetch.mention-me.com/m/ol/...
20% off at ICONOLAB: bit.ly/2YV2MJE Use code KACKIE
1 month FREE at Rocksbox: www.talkable.com/x/3I6wPX
$2,500 off your complete smile makeover at The Cosmetic Dentists of Austin: Mention my name on your first call!
FTC disclosure: This video is not sponsored, but some items have been gifted. This video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links.

[@MarjaCamargo]

That was fun to watch and it looks like it was fun to film as well. PS: Oyster Pearl was originally called Marie Antoinette. ☺️

[@nisapl]

This is DEDICATION. Period.

[@kackie]

this is so nice thank you!!!

[@annetteprice]

On a practical level this was so fantastic to be able to really study these shadows and see how they reflect light and play up or play down texture. I’m always wary of shimmer because it can make my eyes look older, so I loved this! 🥰 The best shimmers I’ve found for avoiding this issue: Thrive eye brighteners, Phytosurgence, and Yeux Paint.

[@emilylerman9028]

I love phytosurgence!!!

[@sarahzinn1221]

I’m home with a sick kid today (after also being up all night) and this video makes me so happy. I ❤️ you and your eyeshadow covered face! I needed this today. Thank you. Truly.

[@rachelfox2622]

I kept having to rewind and watch sections because my brain couldn't get the "Somebody that I used to know" music video out of my head watching this 😂. Also, I'm really hoping you do a video on the new Salt New York adjuster shades. I'm so interested to see how these work!

[@Jellyrouge]

Completely agree with your review of Violette's shadows. She is known for doing an effortless look at bars and restaurants so how the heck are we supposed to use her eyeshadow when it's so messy and requires a makeup wipe? If you look at her IG stories, she fast forwards through what I presume is a lot of fixing and fussing when she's using her eyeshadows. I also feel her look ends up being "ok" because her bangs cover up some of her eyelids. It's ok if a product works in a specific way. What I don't like is that it seems to be marketed as an easy breezy thing and it's not.

[@kackie]

THANK 👏🏻 YOU 👏🏻

[@taggarca]

This was AMAZING. Please do these more, it’s so helpful to see the swatches here. Maybe a blush face swatch ?

[@apc0301]

Your faves would never put eyeshadow on their face. All hail Kackie!

[@sarahroberts1833]

I just keep thinking about how often my husband finds me looking like this on the weekends because he catches me “organizing” my makeup. 😂

[@kackie]

Sounds like you need a channel!!

[@rosaotterstetter7282]

I really enjoyed this! Especially because I was able to look at all the colors at all times. You can't really do that when someone swatches on their wrists.

[@kackie]

I think this is my new format for my roundups. The reaction has been so positive! (Thanks Wayne Goss!)

[@karentingay1966]

Loved how you rant "that just feels so bizarre to me, that would never be part of my routine!" while putting eyeshadow on your forehead 🤣 Great reviews!

[@swinche95]

God bless you literally covered every one and done ive ever been interested in except the bodyography one and thats pretty damn impressive

[@kackie]

AH I need to try bodyography!! 😂

[@penelopefongers2384]

Loved your demo and your humor. Another one and done from the Drugstore is Maybelline Color Tattoo in High Roller.

[@heatherwalsh7036]

Love that shade and also socialite!

[@miamorse7979]

I actually found this super useful as got to see the eyeshadows as you moved and made expressions. Also quite sensible as you can just cleanse your face thoroughly rather than severely irritate your eyes also the shimmer and glitter might scratch the delicate eye area I do this sometimes as I have sensitive eyes and prone to blepharitis.

[@Rin-sr2ml]

Look at that artist makin a sparkly, shimmery palette out of her whole pretty face! 😜🤩 So fun!

[@kackie]

😂

[@frumtheground]

Love these thorough reviews! Thank the makeup gods for Kackie!!

[@mbwhims]

You and this video win the best thumb nail award! Lol 🤣 informative and funny! It literally couldn't get better!

[@ymahopkins]

This is what I call Educational Entertainment. 10/10 on all accounts.

[@nicolekryzhan3442]

I have the Cover Girl one and it’s beautiful! It doesn’t crease on me with a light layer and I have very hooded eyes. I got it free from Ulta and they have a bunch of colors all less than $10! I’m a luxury makeup lover, so I was really impressed and will definitely buy more shades. 😊

[@Morgan-tn4ki]

I just bought the Hourglass shadow in Ray, I was hesitant because they're expensive af but I'm turning 27 this year and I think I'm beginning to age out of the super glittery Colourpop supershock shadows. 😕 This review came just in time, so thank you!

[@sarahzinn1221]

I have it in Rapture and Smoke and love them. They have been my go to for Zoom make-up over the past year.

[@montananerd8244]

Btw, I am 52, and don't love aging myself with too much sparkle. Have recently discovered that an extremely light, specific touch with glitters and metallics does some amazing brightening. A butterfly whisper of glitter eyeliner above my pupil creates a twinkly eye effect.

[@kellydowning806]

Thank you for this video. I appreciate your time and dedication to delivering reviews like this. It helps me feel more confident in what I choose to buy. ❤️

[@ruthvanmunster4434]

I LOVE THIS ALREADY I REALLY NEEDED THIS VIDEO !!!

[@freyaalice9593]

I love this style of video, please do this with other types of products!

[@morganwentworth2041]

I am going to start working in an office again so I’m interested to see how you do this because my plan is to bring one quad or one pot shadow with me

[@LittleMissTiff]

You have the BEST reviews I swear 🥺💓

[@kackie]

AWW thank you!!

[@janethana]

It’s crazy how helpful this was!

[@Rickerov]

This is the video I’ve always needed. Thank you.

[@laurenmorrillauthor]

Literally searched KZbin this weekend to see if you had done a video like this. Yay!

[@Luna04567]

Fantastic video. I’ve been in the fence about getting either roen or vesca as a summer easy eyeshadow

[@inforequested6178]

such an amazing video. I learned about some new brands that I'd never heard about. Thank You!

[@mslane1106]

So well done, thank you. I am all for one-and-done!! Keep filming and talk about the cleansers that removed all these shadows.

[@kackie]

hahahahaha just regular face wash. the good molecules in this case.

[@emilykerrigan5413]

If you like the Auric duos you MUST pickup the third one, brown with the gold glitter. I have a similar skin tone/undertones to you and it is my absolute FAVORITE! The brown is perfect and can sheet out for a shimmery wash, or be built up, and I use it as a liner for a similar effect to VBB bronze. The glitter doesn’t mean too gold and I love to tap it all over my bare eye and it’s scattered enough but also punchy enough that you look like an ethereal disco ball. Can’t say enough good things. Thank you for this committed review!!!

[@kackie]

I want to but she still hasn’t restocked. I think she had her baby so I’m not going to rush her hahaha

[@honggoh4027]

Thanks for the video. I was looking for cream eyeshadows and this is really helpful.

[@aprilk569]

"It's not that they're bad necessarily? It's just that they're STUPID." 😂 A perfect example of why I love you so much lol

[@kackie]

Hahahahahaha

[@schnuspelconny]

I find facial swatches very helpful because it gives me a better idea of what they might look like on an eyelid.

[@clairantoine8230]

💗 your last few videos have been giving me "DayQuil Kackie/Aries" vibes and I'm here for it

[@ameesully3673]

I use the CT Eyes to Mesmerize as my all over color and then top with either the Hourglass scattered light or the Bodyography Glitter pigments every single day. My absolute favorite, so simple but looks like I did something look!!!

[@artchick07]

Chaotic goodness! I love one and done shadows for my deep set hooded eyes.

[@FuriedHearts]

Damn haha. You kinda popped off at 5:30 and I'm living for it. I'm glad you call it like you see it and don't sugarcoat things.

[@Spark1221]

OMG, this video! Incredibly helpful--and honest. Thanks for this! :)

[@sarahevans2929]

Bringing it home to face finger painting. Giving me life.

[@earstoheareyestosee9254]

My new fav beauty/life/attitude influencer 🥰

[@nicoleouten1010]

LETS MAKE SWATCHING ON THE FACE A THING PLZ. I actually loved this 😂

[@kackie]

😂😂😂

[@RMD28]

New and totally impressed follower! Watching some of your older videos and honestly cant understand why you don’t have a million subscribers! Looking forward to celebrating that day with you. Happy Holidays!

[@rachaelr7567]

The new Lidstars are actually quite lovely. It’s wild to me that it took this long to get standard neutrals in this formula. Makes me think that something was lost in translation between the initial product concept and execution.

[@gloriakillen9440]

It was helpful. It was crazy. It was fun. Thanks.

[@michelesalter9564]

What fun creativity and a great nod to Wayne Goss!

[@stefwoods6202]

Why, yes, I just made a chart with hyperlinks so I know what my next purchases will be. Thank you, Kackie! This was amazing!!!

[@AmeliaKohut]

i watched your undone beauty review a day ago and i’m binging your videos

[@kimmcconnell3854]

Ipanema Gold was my one and done in junior high. Can't wait to watch all the way through.

[@glazedtalons]

Loved it! ❤

[@Stephanie-yr2ct]

Yes!!! I almost jumped out of my chair. 😝

[@Gorditavont33se]

Not the beauty guru chatter reference ☠️☠️☠️😭😭

[@kackie]

We dare not speak its name!!!!! 😂

[@sandrapaul4828]

Hello. Thanks for the video. I am a fan of cream eyeshadow. I really like the Sidney Grace cream shadow. THey are really affordable also.

[@leasmith4890]

Super Helpful!!

[@akcire29]

Question for you, I wore the vbb kajal pencil and lid luster on top of my skin prep which was supergoop vitamin c daily dose and I found it kind of creased and spread out. I know you've worn both products separately but what about together? Do you typically prime with something for vbb honey lid luster?

[@irenevanriper7285]

This was great! Loved your short impressions of each formula.Thank you! I’m interested in going over to Wayne Goss’s channel, now! 💕

[@olilianasanchez5026]

Best one and done video!!!! Thanks heaps!

[@findsmiles9282]

Great video!!

[@meganchandler9078]

That hourglass one though 😍

[@mayhemchaniewski]

How stinkin cute are you💕 also I’m dying to see the wash off bc those violette shades look like they want to make themselves at home

[@kackie]

Lol they held out the longest FOR SURE

[@gdimu23]

I was SO NERVOUS you were going to get eyeshadow on your shirt! But the anxiety was worth it hahaha, such a fun video!

[@olgadorable]

You had me at the thumbnail... Can't wait to see what transpired in here 🤣 "Liked" even before watching 😁👀

[@heathersaibena4878]

I love this video-it reminds me of the devil wears Prada when she hold up the two belts and declares how do you choose? They’re so different. 😂 These shadows are nuanced, and I still want them all!

[@kjalight]

The Chantecaille mermaid eye satin shadows are my only eyeshadows that made the cut in my minimalist collection. They are beautiful and can be worn sheered out or built up and they last nicely and don’t have any glitter/visible shimmer (which I really don’t like). I even decluttered their gel powder eyeshadows because I found the glitter to be too noticeable/shiny for the vibe I like.

[@sophieedelsohn9391]

I love this video! (I was high key getting anxiety, like how is she going to fit all of those on her face?!?)

[@CrystalLynnBeauty]

This is me every time I get a new palette! I thought I was the only one!

[@nataliec.9524]

Love the thumbnail haha!

[@sarahlittleton8175]

Kackie, which shade of the smashbox did you swatch? I think Sienna but just making sure? Sorry if I overlooked it!

[@ShanrellsStash]

I’m sorry if I missed it, but what shade of the Covergirl did you swatch?

[@kackie]

Oh sorry it’s called Sorry Sweetie

[@ShanrellsStash]

@@kackie thank you!!

[@TracyD2]

Smashbox always on are amazing. They have a few shimmers now but I have all the mattes. They are just that Always On. You can wear them to a root canal 🙋🏻‍♀️ and they will stay on. Nothing else will though.

[@PriestessTarotpist]

hi Kackie, vbb honey or chiffon?

[@artchick07]

I'm still trying to figure out skywash. Terra is just the right shade of red that it looks like my allergies are acting up. It's honestly too red for my undertones, and I can't get echo to lay down with it.

[@alannajoanne]

Same thoughts on the colours/titles of the Rare Beauty liquid eyeshadows. "It could be 'nearly ANYTHING'" EXACTLY. They would have been more aptly named: Nearly Pink 01, Nearly Pink 02, and so on. Love the formula but come on now.

[@kackie]

Hahahahahaha

[@everythingin3466]

With the Auric I think you are supposed to be able to do them alone or put the glitter on top of the cream, I do and I love that.

[@kackie]

Yep. The glitter is still weak IMO!

[@saraha-happy_hooligan2244]

Are the kosas 10 second eyeshadows long wearing?? Love this video!

[@kackie]

not especially, they dry down but they crease!

[@hannahlapham4638]

What's the CoverGirl shade you have?

[@trishhykes5574]

Do you have Wild Oak from Phytosurgence? I feel like it’d be a similar shade to Oyster Pearl!

[@Beautyonthebrain_]

THANK YOU!!! I've been lusting after the auric duo but I have the hourglass scattered lights in ray, so I'm not going to buy the auric.

[@racheyrox724]

6:38 lmaoooo instant follow 😂😂😂

[@rjimenez1608]

Lol!! Kackie, i agree with you 100%. I love Violette and her style but When i heard her say she made them to resemble liquid lipstick my eyes literally cringed 😬 sounds painful, looks extremely hard to use. Products that are hard to use like that just collect dust in a lot of peoples collections

[@stephaniezao2474]

"It's not that it's bad... It's just stupid" 😂😂😂😂

[@niamh3610]

Oyster pearl always fricking creases on my eyes!!!! Non stop! I'm so upset about it lol

[@Carolll9]

It’s funny, I have the oiliest lids but the CT eyes to mesmerize don’t crease on me. The color Bette, now Amber Gold, is another amazing one and done.

[@heythere8917]

Creased on me too🥺

[@niamh3610]

@@Carolll9 do you have deep set or hooded eyes by any chance? And do you use a primer with CT?

[@niamh3610]

@@heythere8917 omg I'm so glad that I am not the only one!

[@Carolll9]

I have hooded eyes and I don’t have a primer. I do put on a light shade or bronzer on my crease before though, so maybe that helps.

[@pame7694]

For an inner corner highlight, you need the Stila kitten eyeshadow single!

[@1hayleykat]

Do your Illamasqua Iconic Chromes smell kinda vinegary? I got Alluring the other day and it’s so stunning, but it hits you once you open the lid

[@meepmoopmeep1]

Now I want to swatch across my whole face just for fun 😂

[@BidenSUCKSS]

17:41 what is the name of the brand please?

[@angeladenow6145]

Are any of these products packaged in glass? I am searching for a great one and done shadow packaged in recyclable or refillable packaging. The Thrive Brilliant Eye Brighteners seem great, but so much plastic 😢. I was also super interested in Hourglass-Ray until I realized it was all plastic too… sooooo pretty!

[@ElizAbeth-xq4il]

Auric has a glass base. Dose of colors also has a glass base.

[@aslbyweller]

So it was totally cute you used fawn on your nose.

[@graceordung4680]

I thought this was going to help me make a decision, but now I just want all of them.

[@victoria6471]

The video I needed! I'm terrible at eyeshadow, so a one and done shadow is my savior.

[@lisa-lisa-lisa]

oh I cant keep up! why dont we like hourglass and the new Roen people? also I love these swatches, it is much easier to see and compare. I have very small eyes and you putting them on your eyes is like a completely different species so I appreciate the effort.

[@ShanrellsStash]

Oooo Kackie, Kackie I can’t wait to watch!!!

[@laurenoliveira2800]

This video made me dizzy!! But I still kinda liked it! Obviously would rather see on ur eyes but still!

[@annamoehagen3447]

I bet your sink was fun colors

[@jessicag1431]

SO EXCITE

[@nisapl]

I really want to give a hundred thumbs up to this 🤣

[@kaitlinbeste328]

Ummmmm yes! Why did I just now find this

[@aaronddp]

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@FuriedHearts]

I totally agree about the weird red color (6:13 top right). It's like a weird, unflattering coppery orangey red. Like it has no true undertone and isn't vibrant or pretty at all to me. Such a bizarre color for a liquid eyeshadow. You think she'd either go fully copper or fully red. Such an ugly color LOL

[@briar.b.b.]

I argue that the glossier one you put on your nose actually does flatter your coloring, now you might not want to wear such a a color, but you can pull it off.