Beware Of Transgressing In Takfeer! Shaykh Sulayman ar-Ruhayli

[@MuhammadAli-wy6ku]

Jazak Allahu kheyr for the translation, May Allah protect the Sheykh

[@premiumuser5942]

this should be written in gold

[@knowledgeseeker8425]

indeed mashallah

[@amekran26]

May Allah protect the shaykh

[@AISHAHALI05]

بارك الله فيك

[@cushconsultinggroup]

Amin duas ya sheikh.

[@umar_abuhafs]

BarakAllahu Feekum akhi, Who is the translator here ?

[@billbb]

Knowledge

[@rafhaelibnumar2194]

Allahu Akbar

[@user-xw3ih6un5v]

If someone transgresses with takfir and it returns to them, why are the khawarij considered Muslims?

[@HilyahAsSalaf]

Because if takfir were to be made upon them, we would fall into the same trap they did. And this is along the lines of what 'Ali رضي الله عنه said as well when he was asked if they are disbelievers. Therefore, the most we can do is affirm what the Prophet صلي الله عليه وسلم said, that they will be in the Hellfire, and that if they are aggressive they should be killed. However, their innovations make them deviants and not kuffaar.

[@carljohnson2194]

@@HilyahAsSalaf so takfiring without evidence is a sin or kufr?

[@foufoua]

It is not the takfir wich returns to the person but the sin of cursing or offending the person. So when someone makes takfir and the takfir was injust then the person gets the sin of the one who cursed or offended another person.

[@fw_uzayr2196]

Ikhtilaf, some scholars consider the khawarij to be kuffar