Beyoncé, Shakira - Beautiful Liar

[@lindorplays5900]

the person who made this beat is an absolute genius. they don't get enough recognition fr

[@Sweet-hk1kr]

А их танец, это нечто!

[@omunomundo]

I wonder if they won at least one Grammy for this song

[@omunomundo]

Obs.: Besides being the performer, Beyoncé also produced the song 🤯

[@omunomundo]

They didn’t win any 😭

[@sgh37]

This beat is mixte with arabic

[@nirzara7176]

I love how everyone is super respectful and not even trying to compare these phenomenal women. Thats the crowd i need.

[@yourfavoritepessimisticexi8041]

I wish they were like this with other females celebrities

[@anastasiawall3924]

we respec women out here

[@daf1678]

Me too

[@itzelvenmage7434]

Because every woman are unique with her specific beauty.

[@perlaguerra693]

amen

[@whootheeem2719]

This is one of the best Female collabs of all times in music industry 😍💞

[@diegourbina6427]

Imagine this at Coachella live

[@senseypuffle]

slaveniusss 3 love She said: This is ONE of the best female collabs of all times No: This is the BEST female collab of all times

[@perrellcooper2422]

One Word: Telephone

[@patrickstar1807]

@slaveniusss 3 love I disagree listen to Ariana grande feat Nicky Minaj side to side the best female collab

[@jeniferfitz2044]

@@diegourbina6427 wuau

[@aracelyelizalde6270]

No lo sabíamos, pero Shakira salvó a toda la LATAM con esta colaboración. 😮

[@SantiMoreno-mq1ii]

Siii o sino ya estuviéramos ☠️

[@brissmlb]

??

[@LucianoMorales-k1n]

​@@brissmlbEs un meme

[@brissmlb]

@@LucianoMorales-k1n ay jodeme. Si, ya se que estan todos los pelotudos de tik tok repitiendo la misma idiotez como si compartiensen todos la misma neurona. Mi pregunta es ¿por que? o ¿de donde lo sacan?, o mejor aun, ¿que tiene de gracioso? teniendo en cuenta que la mina se hizo re contra millonaria por hacer un video con beyonce y no salvó a nadie. Pq hacer video con una mujer que era amiga de un abusador iba a salvar a alguien(???, pero bueno, como dije, al ser downs mentales, solo se entienden entre ellos

[@maty9330]

Nuestra diosa😂

[@AnjaliKumari-nl9zw]

I love how Shakira happily decided to collaborate with all the fellow singers of her generation instead of taking them as competition. That's reAl WONEN EMPOWERMENT you all

[@lucassantospessoal]

I din't see Shakira and Lady Gaga joint yet.

[@AnjaliKumari-nl9zw]

@@lucassantospessoal let's hope they do soon😊😊

[@mahesa_mp]

@@lucassantospessoal because Lady Gaga is not at the same level as her seniors, Beyonce, Shakira, and Rihanna.

[@tommiedam4167]

Same for Beyoncé, she collabbed with Shakira, Lady Gaga, Nicki Minaj, Alicia Keys and so many more

[@mahesa_mp]

@Love Only in your dream. Beyonce is the first lady of music. Beyonce's followers are 4 times that of Lady Gaga's. Even so, Beyonce is rarely active but has a much higher number of followers.

[@jhonoliveros__]

Shakira only has two female collabs, Beyoncé and Rihanna. She knows how to be iconic.

[@pieckiss4991]

Lady Gaga?

[@jhonoliveros__]

@@pieckiss4991 She hasn't collaborate with her.

[@pieckiss4991]

@@jhonoliveros__ oh sorry... I thought you were talking about Beyoncé

[@robertolopezherrera8100]

3, whit Mercedes Sosa

[@becon9779]

Rihanna is the queen👑

[@siminsimin]

Don't worry .... you're not the only one who is listening this masterpiece in November 2024 .

[@siminsimin]

@@jamiqahuseynova6294 Hello 😊🌹🌹

[@jamiqahuseynova6294]

@@siminsimin lets become acquainted?

[@mzmums7515]

Listening from ph🇵🇭

[@luisa5601]

hi

[@siminsimin]

@@mzmums7515 Lots of love to Ph 😍😍💖💖💖💖

[@ivanestrada7993]

Shakira is our Latina queen and Beyonce is our African-american queen. I'm so glad they worked together as opposed to competing and hating on each other like most of these female artists.

[@johanneemmanuel6974]

I though it was j.lo

[@Daydreamahify]

Shakira is not even latina though.. shes Lebanese/Spanish. She just happens to be born in Colombia.

[@ivanestrada7993]

Cirozel She is a latina. Latina isn't a race nor is it an ancestral background. She was born and raised in Colombia and her culture is a Latino one, her native language is also Spanish. So, by definition she is. Most Latinos have Spanish ancestry, and what? we're still Latinos.

[@Daydreamahify]

(in North America) a woman or girl of Latin American origin or descent. That's the definition of a "latina." So, by definition, she isn't :)

[@ivanestrada7993]

Cirozel Clearly you don't know what you're talking about. The world recognizes people from Latin America as Latinos. It's a geographical location South to the USA, for the most part. It can get confusing because not all Latino nations are in one specific area, but they're still Latino nations, dumbass. Cubans, Colombians, Panamanians, Mexicans, Hondurans, Puerto Ricans, Dominicans, etc; are all Latinos. What makes Latin America is Spanish speaking countries, similar cultures, and former colonization of Spain. Why do you think these countries are bonded together diplomatically under latinoamericano agreements, hoe? Why do you think they refer to themselves (including shakira) as Latinos? Shakiras nationality is Colombian, her ancestry goes back to Spain and Lebanon (but we don't 100% know that because she hasn't done an ancestry test, so she just my not be of Lebanese or Spanish ancestry, or at least significantly.), her ethnicity is latina/Hispanic, and her race is white. Three different things, mami.

[@tazeemparveen2620]

The fact that Shakira taught Beyoncé how to belly dance in just 40 mins and they didn’t have a choreography for this video and just went with the flow, makes this perfect 🤩

[@davidjuniorlopes-zu7lg]

siim

[@Sadsongillusion]

If you notice it's actually on shakira in the video

[@johnnycruz9782]

@@Sadsongillusion I had to replay it! They tricked us back in 06!!

[@MauricioSierraM.]

Actually they used a computer to move Beyoncé's hips and then duplicate the Shakira's body

[@theelementor6560]

yeah

[@aryadoa]

Before I change the song I want to thank Beyonce

[@JohnRobertSaldo-ql5is]

(2)

[@nailvss]

real

[@clarissamorales5401]

I hate it here 😂

[@MariaLibinson-j2w]

😂

[@Caseyking-ut2su]

man this song is amazing though

[@anumehakaushik9514]

They both compliment each other. Sometimes its hard to distinguish between them.

[@atlf3357]

Ikr! The scene at around 2:42 where Beyoncé disappears behind Shakira’s torso only to emerge as Shakira herself was the trippiest sh!t ever. They’re so different from each other yet so in sync and indistinguishable at the same time in this music video

[@adammarazzo576]

i think they took shakiras hip ability into consideration and they put a gold band around beyonces waist to draw your eye to her to balance it out. just a theory though lol

[@Blueluise]

Boris, oh mannn.......

[@Blueluise]

Luggage, Bagage, da wird Klimt sauer..haette gern was teures...

[@QueenVeronica92]

@@atlf3357 pause it at 2:43 .....that's not Beyonce that's a double look at her chin

[@hyoyeonyyy]

Latina Queen + Black Queen = Perfection at its finest

[@farhiyamohamed___]

Yessss I love this

[@abhirudrasingh726]

Is that Jennie in your profile pic ⁉️

[@hyoyeonyyy]

@@abhirudrasingh726 yes

[@TyeArtisik]

Yup

[@m2yiu]

And Arab queen

[@toasty8357]

I’ll never understand why they never got Shakira and Beyonce to perform together at the Super Bowl. The stage presence of both of these women would be INSANE

[@travishenderson9635]

It's because too many dudes would simultaneously nut themselves at the same time

[@estepaulo]

exatamente. Todo mundo esperava um beautiful liar ao vivo, com direito a muito mais do que isso![

[@mahwishjabeen9648]

As you say, "The stage presence of both of these women would be INSANE" this is why, they never got these legends to perform together.🙃

[@eviiriivera]

@Stardust dont do selena like this 😕

[@imbuffysummers]

Never say never! (Unless someone hears this phrase and thinks of the song then suggests Justin Bieber for halftime instead)

[@joell.20]

Gracias a esta colaboración agradezo a Shakiraa por salvarnos a toda latinoamérica y principal a Beyonce por despertar cada dia 🥺

[@matiasalejandrofernandez4172]

Gracias Shakira y gracias a Beyoncé por permitirlo

[@HelianaBonsi]

Vine en busca de comentarios así jajaja

[@cesarruiz9810]

😂😂😂

[@ingridchavez2057]

Par de brujas

[@ranita_fina]

expliquenme este mame porfavor

[@niharikabhardwaj5518]

Shakira and Beyonce in a song together.....that's when music industry hit its peak. There won't be anything more iconic than this ever again.

[@TharikTharikdisneydescendants]

Mm ya

[@yohanvillafranca5471]

The best in W English (🇺🇸) and W Spanish (🇨🇴) but singing in English

[@edzioedy4601]

True!

[@Joce-uk5lz]

Gs fera car recherche vendredi gaz car catégorie fat c'est gzej catholique cash d'athlétisme se français crash carte cash dates cadre visage c'est fat c'est cette veste veux sévère vert

[@Joce-uk5lz]

Gs dag ce que va cette stratégie car certains détails fariboles cash cause des dag dvdhdi cefhu c'est destination c'est de cash cash c'est d'argent cette créature des dates cerveau c'est carrément dégradation

[@hermetickitten]

They are in sync, almost like sisters. What a great collaboration, after so many years it still gives me the shivers!

[@VikashKumar-dk9gp]

Fhrihfk

[@jansvanda22]

Totally agree :) it’s very well made video very artistic and not unnecessary provocative, same with the shivers:)

[@dyryanysaavedra5374]

Kiki jajajajja no pensé verte por aquí

[@robertthomson8970]

Yeah there like sisters

[@zrlyz3482]

@@robertthomson8970 mhm

[@michaelmorgan4039]

This would be hot if they perform this at the super bowl lol

[@josephwilkes768]

Yessssssssssss

[@chikkachica162]

Michael Morgan omg i was thinking the same thing ,then i read ur comment! it would be epic

[@babymario2099]

Yessssss please

[@endibaku7269]

Oh yesssss

[@hannha.martinez5915]

YES

[@MelisaFelip]

Un dia mas escuchando esta canción gracias a Beyoncé, mañana la escuchare si Beyonce lo permite ❤

[@matdelph]

P diddy, she knows 🤮

[@saidakhaitar8915]

Moysaiacicicavec,todo,1,top,looord,merci,300000000000000000000000000000,vit

[@sgjoyder2890]

XD, como todo cambia, antes era la queen b y ahora le tenemos un miedo increíble uff

[@cessortega5471]

😂

[@sandrapalmamacizo6533]

JAJAJAJJAA

[@um.5199]

*I want another Shakira and Beyonce collaboration*

[@part6jotaro302]

I want a Lady Gaga and Selena one

[@GSutton]

@@part6jotaro302 you're trying the break the whole entire world, huh? 🔥

[@babymario2099]

Same!!!!

[@blackpinkx6622]

@@part6jotaro302 🖤💖

[@part6jotaro302]

blackpink X 👸🏻👸🏻👸🏻👸🏻

[@campo_rojo]

This song is so relevant today for Shakira. I wish Shakira happiness, she deserves it

[@isaacortiz4617]

Agreed.❤

[@twit9129]

Wdym

[@mimiwrld]

@@twit9129 pretty sure her husband cheated on her

[@furkanbozdag8198]

​@@mimiwrld she is not that innocent either

[@furkanbozdag8198]

She deserves nothing she is not innocent

[@brandoncole5533]

This probably the healthiest song I’ve heard Basically saying Sis let’s not be mad at eachother no drama no bullshit It’s his fault not ours Let’s go out for some mimosas later

[@katharynemartins8320]

Mimosas?

[@lucasok5147]

exactly what I thought. They put out this message yeaars ago. sorority at its finest

[@michaelj2711]

@@katharynemartins8320 its a drink.

[@IMONEY16]

Whoever smashed both of them is a LEGEND

[@nurseray6866]

Yesss

[@jairalvarez4753]

Osea que Shakira salvó a toda LATAM 😮

[@bladimyr4847]

si

[@SantiMoreno-mq1ii]

Si

[@deuzzycool1]

Jajaja hora, si ella es la mera 😈 un rango mayor a Beyoncé

[@sgjoyder2890]

​@@deuzzycool1No se tiene confirmado nada, solo tiene una foto con puff daddy, hay que esperat a ver que pasa.

[@valeuwu250]

Así es Shakira tiene más carrera que Beyonce nacio primero

[@Elisama]

2021

[@baosophia7346]

Yow

[@pacco.b27]

hey

[@ceeset5472]

I never left

[@reyliy482]

Hey

[@vibhorejaiswal2997]

Ya from india😁❤️

[@carmensuarez9046]

Beyoncé + Shakira=Perfection

[@isaicuamatzi1838]

perfection yess diosas

[@scorpion77floridasgirl5]

Yesssss!!!!!

[@shyloorchard5952]

Usual

[@Blueluise]

there are lots of feat. even with Rihanna, Eminem, Jay, b u t this now is really...stole everything, beauriful liar, its like Robin Schulz does a sctiption, though like oriental back ground and music, something is weird about that, oriental not South American..

[@DominiqueMideleine-hu1qo]

❤❤❤❤

[@watijamir456]

Shakira and Beyonce have proved that real singers can really blend no matter how different or unique one might sound.....Thats the beauty of music ...Thats the sweetness of being a singer...

[@DavidsRandomPlanet]

I agree

[@НаристеЭмильбекова]

Да верно

[@extrm161]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/moaxn4RooN6lh6s the masterpiece👆👆

[@Rtbj335]

Facts

[@didomarshal7024]

truth the real perfectionist🥰🥰

[@SantiMoreno-mq1ii]

Shakira hizo esto con Beyonce para salvar a toda latinoamerica

[@monsepazos4]

Contexto?

[@mafiaonline7132]

Do you really think that diddy could take over all latina scene?

[@soda3069]

the most legendary collab to this day, amirite?

[@juliealex4141]

kimchi true

[@Beatlesfanish]

kimchi definitely

[@Drex576]

miia no Monica and brandy

[@sams_not_here]

Drew Brazzy what about the lady marmalade remix? It had girls from 4 different music genres make one amazing collab

[@Drex576]

Epic Sam your right too

[@QueenReina21]

It's wonderful to see people coming back to this song after all these years

[@phatpussytingz1595]

Yes

[@keefe951]

V true, two queens

[@redouanebenmorid4654]

Yes

[@ejemima]

Here because my favorite artist is coming out with a song, next week, called 'beautiful liar' and I thought I remembered that title from another place too. It's completely different sound and feel though, from the teaser I've heard 😅

[@lindaaluvale4534]

@@redouanebenmorid4654 I I ihhhu hi huh I g uh hi I I uh uuuuu hi I h uh. Hughhhhhhhhhhhh

[@usrparo]

*I still cannot believe this collab exists. the power this contains-*

[@Mxxnlightbaex]

Literally tho

[@swaagitario]

Grande Shakira, hizo está colaboración con beyonce para salvar a toda latinoamérica

[@Dlizz15]

JAJAJAJJAJAJAJAJAJAJJAJ nos salvó a todos 🤣🤣

[@ElisandraLeón]

MEMEO JAJAJAJAJA

[@SantiMoreno-mq1ii]

Siii o sino ya estuviéramos ☠️

[@Jorge_Herrera1]

De hecho está muy involucrada también ella, tampoco se salva

[@Dlizz15]

@@Jorge_Herrera1 Ohhh, no me digas 😭🤣

[@Velvet_Rosee]

Whoever the guy was, he clearly has a type.

[@tyler515752]

B r a n d i yeah Bad bitch

[@jewelsforthedome1672]

LOL

[@RandomPerson-hw3te]

At least he didn't cheat with somebody ugly and/or broke like most do💀💀

[@GODDESS1966]

Brandi Yeah GODDESS!

[@laurenmungaray3912]

Big hair gals?

[@rachelnicole8640]

This song is so perfect because it's two women supporting women instead of hating on each other cause of an ignorant man. Smh we need more songs like this

[@ٴٴٴٴ_0]

Rachel Nicole Also it's about leaving the past behind instead of revenge against the guy. It's really a rare kind of message for a pop song.

[@rachelnicole8640]

Dr. Elijah exactly!! I love it so much.

[@amycavas969]

Exactly 👏🏻

[@IsabellesLullabies]

It's a perfect message, I agree!!

[@smilervslovatica]

Rachel Nicole beyonce Shakira And Britney never talked bad about others for publicity... even when back in the day the media wanted beef between them. .... we can't say the same of JLO, Mariah and Christina.

[@Svengali764]

Imagine a song with Rihanna, Beyonce and Shakira.. just imagine..

[@NoNo-fq1nh]

Antahvasin YES DAMN

[@ketaarianamendes6601]

With NICK MINAJ TOO

[@queenhall3905]

Keta Ariana Mendes YASS we need this collab

[@Svengali764]

It'd break the internet for ages to come.

[@queenhall3905]

Antahvasin LMAOO

[@markdwighttadina7655]

Thank You Beyonce for confessing through a collaboration with Shakira.....

[@archivesunset4214]

confessing what? that her and shakira had a cheating man?

[@zaeemakhan1170]

This slayed our entire existence before slaying was even a thing. And that's the goddamn honest TRUTH!!

[@breeshaunamb1188]

Zaeema Khan exactly

[@nomdeplume1358]

xD So true

[@bastiangonzalez6957]

omg amen

[@tonispengler4185]

hahaaaa!

[@JustinRodriguez123]

so true

[@soumyea]

The director honestly did an amazing job shooting this video the way he/she gives them both equal representation is perfect!!

[@xxxkama7xxx]

It's not that hard actually,they may not be similar facially but they have similar hair and body shapes, just Bey is taller and a bit curvier.

[@torquettalk]

I like the contrasting elements between beyonce and shakira

[@sattabrima3312]

I love it I love the song

[@lac3222]

Fractura Teruel techumbre Fhmffj

[@NeolithicMan23]

IKR even tho that's not the best song out there it sure is a nice peace of work with that video.

[@miikemonroe48]

This song deserves to be performed in the Super Bowl.

[@distorted3271]

beyoncé won't perform at the super bowl again lol.

[@georgepreston1411]

Wouldn’t that just be amazing

[@miikemonroe48]

@@distorted3271 unfortunately :(

[@miikemonroe48]

@@georgepreston1411 it would be 😍😍

[@sarahmurabito9391]

and medicine

[@guillermoalzates.1763]

Shakira thanks again for saving my life, and also thank mainly to beyonce

[@tspopstar512]

Can we talk about how talented the director was beyonce and shakira dont look alike but he had us not knowing who was who in some scenes

[@kimerietate8372]

But they DO look alike.People kill me acting like "Black" and non-Black people can't look alike.

[@tspopstar512]

@@kimerietate8372 people of different races can look alike but when I saw shakira at the superbowl she looked nothing like beyonce who was in the audience

[@shojogrl]

Tj Anthony @ 2:56 they look exactly alike to me 😁

[@tspopstar512]

The only reason they look alike in this video was because of the dim lighting and they were styled similar

[@khailloyd2722]

Tj Anthony also they switched places a couple times

[@juliarodriguez9557]

Wow, the Black Goddess and the Latin Goddess together, we totally need another Bey and Shak collaboration ❤💋

[@wwesuperstars9528]

Yes

[@juliarodriguez9557]

Ahhh... Yeah

[@sp4cegrl27]

E you thought she wasn’t? 😂

[@hastinae.8166]

@E have u been living under a rock lol of course shes BLACK💀😂

[@hastinae.8166]

@E lol😂

[@interlude776]

2 queens coming together to maximize their joint slay

[@master_celestial]

Tf is this cringe😂

[@master_celestial]

Song slays tho

[@lonelynights7395]

😻 purr

[@hayatguzel819]

😅😅😅😅😅👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👌👌👌👌

[@JunNicolas-k5q]

Thank you Beyoncé for another day of life 🥺

[@KirashiUchida]

XD

[@antrianacrawley764]

“Beyoncé and Shakira have a music video together, it’s called....beautiful liar. It’s probably one of the most amazing things that you’ll ever see. Just saying” - Cameron Boyce 💔 Watching this just for him 😔❤️

[@avarose6753]

Same😭

[@alexcookie9620]

OMG i never thought i would actually find you guys here from Cameron!! He would be so happy to see us everywhere and united❤😞 Rest In Peace beautiful human..

[@chadiaworthy4642]

chadiaworthy

[@sehrlol4689]

Sameee😭

[@sevval_mr]

Same omg

[@jhongallagher]

I was trying to live my life peacefully, and suddenly, for no reason at all, my head was: *Beyoncé Beyoncé, oh! Shakira Shakira* That’s why I’m here.

[@ansantos23]

lol

[@chelsyg.1493]

SAME

[@MaYen1]

😂😂😂😂Same bro

[@andalorahpaillant6476]

Same

[@esther589]

Same 😂😂😂😂

[@marianapaz8202]

almost break my hip trying to dance this as a kid

[@AdriiiVlogs]

Me and my sister tes

[@vassilgeorgiev801]

Your hips don't lie

[@user-uu3oo4nz4r]

I eventually got it right🤭

[@melissacolon4010]

I know I wasn't the only one lol!

[@nadiagaskins9246]

The just dance💀💀😂

[@micbetancur9131]

Made history with this song honestly

[@starlisejun.from.1799]

I probably shouldn’t have been belly dancing to this against the wall at 6 😭

[@sadiecrystal1653]

sksks omgg 😭

[@nana2357]

Bruhh same 😭

[@RockyLuvsJonghyun]

I still do lol 😂

[@dianamarcekova9615]

😂😂

[@Jadorelainie]

Definitely should've had! It was a dishonor to these queens not to.

[@diegovip4831]

Someone else wants to see Shakira and Beyoncé shaking their hips together on stage at the Super bowl 2020?

[@GjenevaGjeneva]

Yesss. Wish they wouldve performed together today!!

[@tombullard123]

DIEGOOD VIBES unfortunately we got jlo instead

[@limpisisa.1664]

@@tombullard123 what are you trying to do I have got some words for you Read carefully shut up

[@ghitaelfilali335]

Limpisis A. Lol be calm it’s just Jlo

[@viksaggu9085]

Would Jay z allow it?

[@applbttmjns]

The best black-latina duo I’ve ever seen

[@syedsajjadhassan8955]

Racist

[@applbttmjns]

your mom is watching you I’m not racist AND I AM BLACK AND IM PROUD TO SAY THAT

[@user-xz3lz2cp1q]

your mom is watching you What is even racist in that statement? Your inferiority complex is showing bbg.🤦🏽‍♀️

[@bella-ss2ri]

@@syedsajjadhassan8955 wait ur joking right or??

[@user-bz6ql3iu6f]

Kristin Saynova music the melody are arabs not Latin

[@szymszymi]

thank u beyonce for allowing me to listen to this piece of art

[@stephanieholder7063]

Beyonce: How badly do you want to confuse them? Shakira: yes

[@Asterix_Angel33]

Ikr

[@mimozar4746]

Still confused:))

[@yvie914]

Exactly! 😂🤣

[@hanbaebummie3215]

I am not confused tho o.O

[@alexisveach216]

Its not actually that confusing...a guy cheated with both of them..simple!

[@juancastillo2139]

Beyoncé and Shakira taught us that the answer is simple "HE'S THE ONE TO BLAME"

[@nirajanpradhan5416]

😅😅😅😅😅

[@yourman5293]

😂😂😂

[@pieseldatches]

The best anti victim blaming anthem

[@ohhsooill]

I’m not even gonna lie I haven’t heard this song in over 10 yrs I’m just now realizing what the song is about lol

[@suziesue7767]

What about after Jay-Z cheated 🤣🤣

[@Lavishlyashleyy]

The parts where Shakira couldnt help but smile because she knew they were killing it!!😭🙌

[@marianbortan3670]

😭🙌

[@lareinaar]

gets me every time!!!!

[@andresito0404]

Favorite part! They both look like they are having so much fun

[@brendamarambio9285]

Anyone nov 2024 ??

[@shaunasmith211]

🙌

[@Claudia-i2x]

🙌

[@alibabar864]

Me!

[@ayelenmonges-nm1eh]

ME ❤

[@barchilarlequija]

​@@shaunasmith211😊😊😊😊

[@lautaroadam604]

It would be great if Shakira and Beyonce came together again to make another song!

[@DDominoGeronimo]

Factssss.her and ri did that too though.

[@mwanahawarutona7582]

Ofcz t wll be fantastic✌

[@mathfreak2521]

Or at least sing this live .

[@MrNasiem]

It would be great if they came to my house but i dont think that will happen

[@paytonnolide481]

How iconic do you want the collab? Bey and Shakira: yas

[@cristinaguzman8554]

I remember being a child and watching this on repeat and thinking "woah, they're so pretty". It hasn't changed

[@Hi-lh7yc]

same👁👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩

[@divinendote2692]

Ha ha ha

[@aleximoon5094]

dude right!? I'm 18 now and still can't get over the bellydancing part...

[@sanzuswife1080]

Yeah same and now I’m bi 💀

[@Pacman69420]

They've truly aged with grace

[@LettyHernandez-fz9jb]

I thank i Shakira For collaborating with Beyoncé and saving all of Latin America

[@geovannybernal156]

😂😂😂

[@amberkashauna]

Younger me couldn’t tell the difference between them for years.

[@minellebitch6651]

Me too 😭😭😭

[@RukiaSailormoon]

I'll take signs I needed glasses for 300 Jerry

[@clickbiat]

Sameeee 🤣🤣🤣

[@kennedyxhulu4933]

Neither could I tell the difference

[@capn_l]

Especially at the end

[@CorCor89]

The crazy thing about this video that it is so much of an illusion to how much they really look similar in a way. Even when they were constantly switching between the two, they both had on outfits that the other one would wear, making it hard to keep up with who's who. I think this video is beyond amazing.

[@burakmutlu7102]

exactly

[@smal5898]

true

[@thesonofmanlordjesus4616]

+jcr89---*whom's whom...But yes, this video is amazing!

[@tasneemabdelsattar2722]

lpo!kj aqwžw yrtfnb

[@amaka637]

+jcr89 agreed

[@Odurs]

Its February 2024, let’s see how many legends are listening to this masterpiece❤

[@sophiauzor9839]

Meeeeeeeeee❤😂

[@IAMNYXEN]

🙋‍♀️

[@utubeuser00]

😭😭

[@ArturoMartínezPresentado]

te juro q estoy igual q tu

[@botshelokganya7622]

Here

[@rafaelarguellesflorez6052]

Shakira lo hizo para salvar a Latinoamérica.. gracias por otro día más de vida ❤❤❤❤❤

[@mreycaballero9250]

Beyonce, Shakira - Beautiful liar Shakira, Rihanna - Can't remember to forget you Beyonce, Lady Gaga - Videophone Lady Gaga, Beyonce - Telephone Shakira, Jennifer Lopez - Superbowl

[@Milascanio]

cuando shakira hacia buenas colaboraciones con Artistas de verdad,hasta que canto con maluma y ya la perdimos para siempre,ni sabemos quien es ella :´(

[@roizeldiez3500]

Legends only club!

[@chupameusculh0es493]

@@Milascanio continua a ser a única com a Rihanna que ainda são relevantes tho. Rainha shakira nunca vai, ficará sempre aqui no seu trono.

[@meencantamamarpenes5380]

@@Milascanio seguro no escucha sus canciones como nada , amarillo, toneladas para hablar que fue para siempre 🙄

[@LucasSantos-pw9xv]

@@chupameusculh0es493 sei que tu é brasileiro, menino que coisa doida, essa pessoa aí acima falando da Shakira cê viu? Logo ela, rainha latina pqp olha

[@itskylierae]

This song was recommended by Cameron Boyce in one of his interviews so here I am watching it while bawling my eyes out. I can’t believe he’s gone

[@sylvanalozano110]

Omg, yes, i still can't believe his passing, im heartbroken... RIP Cam 😪

[@SrmthfgRockLee]

whos cameron boyce tho

[@sylvanalozano110]

@@SrmthfgRockLee Cameron is the person who acted as luke in "Jessie" as well as "carlos" in descendants

[@avarose6753]

I know😭

[@tyven7807]

Ikr I just can't even believe it... RIP Cameron

[@raphaelmgbeme3767]

This is one of the most powerful moments in pop culture.

[@АбайБайызбеков]

👏👏👍👍

[@extrm161]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/moaxn4RooN6lh6s the masterpiece👆👆

[@samuelesierra]

Aquella vez que Shakira colaboró con Beyoncé para salvar a toda latinoamerica.

[@Imaanyi]

This song never gets old- just like Shakira and Beyoncé never lose their fire. 🔥

[@natapp8733]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🔥🔥🔥

[@Atsuki_]

Pom

[@Atsuki_]

😊Le llegó loñ

[@Atsuki_]

😊Le llegó loñ

[@Atsuki_]

unan

[@kayyx12]

10 years later and I still remember all of the lyrics. 2019 anyone?

[@pua99100]

@rock2418 This son is for Gabriela Di monaco Azi e Natani a Di monaco Azi

[@なやむ-f7h]

13*

[@lest3136]

That's IMPACT

[@justiceforartpop6600]

Why do dumbass kids who can’t grasp the fact music existed before KZbin make comments like this pretending they’re so grown and get the nostalgia.

[@Erika-o2n]

👹👹 ILUMINATI. 😂😂....

[@zaymandy9333]

This song is truly unforgettable! the choreography is insane,I'm still in awe🥰

[@nahuchoa]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bnm7iGyJmNN1nbc

[@RukiaSailormoon]

@Jaqueline Santos ??????

[@foxlisas]

@Jaqueline Santos you have 24 days to live

[@fetele067]

I want to thank Beyonce because without her I wouldn't be alive yet ❤

[@Hugooo_fbr]

THATS SO REAL

[@abboss4013]

If this was made in 2019 they are going for billion in a month

[@mistyriazi1108]

So true bro....

[@shadowtheneoson6605]

Nah more nudity would have been required. That's why riri and shakira are almost at a bill

[@2starredout]

ShadowTheNeo'son not really, people will watch it because it’s queen bey

[@anuragsharma1793]

Song was released in 2005 and at that she didn't upload this on KZbin. After almost 4 to 5 years she released it with almost 25 to 30 videos on Oct 2,3 2009 and without promotion, still racked up this much views is powerful. And also it got very very heavy rotation on MTV

[@familyguy6668]

Ab Boss Beyoncé didn’t age as well as Shakira did must be the Latín genes

[@fino1908]

I miss this era. Late 2000’s songs are timeless.

[@marinagranados9234]

I love Beyonce

[@robloxplayer7927]

So true

[@BEAUTY11923]

@Pink Panther there’s no reason to hate her

[@BEAUTY11923]

@Pink Panther you’re just jealous cuz your NOTHING you have nothing going on in your life

[@mikkys.572]

Soooo truth...😩

[@dodobirdsrock]

Ughhhh we need another Beyoncé and Shakira collaboration.

[@beyzanuryasar5723]

dodobirdsrock I agree

[@kubragunduz3338]

dodobirdsrock tghbh

[@bettygolden6975]

dodobirdsrock

[@JorgeRodriguez-ez3md]

dodobirdsrock u right

[@lubalubov7012]

yes

[@AlexThee]

Their voices together are AMAZING

[@darrylskylar8757]

Not enough praise is given about the camera work, editing and choreography of this video!!! There are times when you think you see Shakira but then it’s Beyoncé or the other way around!!!✨✨✨✨

[@michellefootman8077]

Yes!!

[@anyaaa2801]

Yes. It's perfectly put together: the editing, the background, their voices, etc.

[@Blueluise]

gues im nin does not make it better...LOL.....?

[@gokidd2242]

i just commented this. its so good i marvel at the transitions every time. that film work and those ladies yowza

[@adrianasalte9427]

It's because the whole time the one who was doing the belly dance was Shakira

[@sadrama3512]

This song never gets old. No matter how much I listen. I will never get bored

[@onlinestar4536]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZpKydZimiLuog80

[@extrm161]

, kzbin.info/www/bejne/aniZlmeKlq-roas Tricks to be a better ⬆️

[@emmoss1129]

OI⁸lflģTģotýef

[@damn6362]

bot comment

[@ElbisPen]

🌷❤Temazo Shakira es lo más hermoso 2023 🌺

[@luisasedre8962]

Beyoncé + Shakira = PERFECTION.

[@depressedgaming8704]

Luis Aluveniyali, Beyonce + Shakira = Bhékira

[@GhostyKilla615]

Shakira + Beyonce.

[@jorgeromero7847]

Gracias Beyonce por un nuevo día y gracias a Shakira por habernos salvado a todos los latinoamericanos 😢❤

[@nobody5010]

Beyoncé: He's not worth the drama Shakira:He's not worth our time both: Ya lets just belly dance **both belly dance** Both: YASSS SIS

[@christinaheard7106]

Lmao

[@ulisesamezcua2937]

Perdón crítica mundial

[@shashuwilson2219]

Beyonce broke the pact

[@DDominoGeronimo]

Lol okayyyyyyy

[@wifeuofartemwing]

LMFAO HAHAHAHHA

[@mercuryminded]

One of the best collabs of all time

[@fashionovawigs]

it always will be

[@underthebrigde4771]

could more agree with u !

[@fashionovawigs]

Wandi Kurniawan yas

[@Indecisive2]

Without a doubt.

[@miklospalotas901]

Jazzmin Maria

[@AngelusLabyrinth]

This collaboration is like "when two goddesses meet" kind of scenario.

[@andrewbservin]

The two baddest at the time in one vid 🤯

[@itsroxie9818]

Love shakira and beyonce but plz don't compare them to God.

[@AngelusLabyrinth]

@@itsroxie9818 Yo mythical goddesses

[@kameera]

It's Roxie Goddesses. No one said anything about God Goddesses is WOMEN

[@iridiumSerpent]

There are two goddesses in the book I’m writing modelled after them lmfao

[@Lilacs_are_Lilac]

THANK YOU BEYONCE FOR THIS BEAUTIFUL MASTERPIECE

[@emmamikaelyan9104]

If Shakira and Beyoncé are getting cheated on, what hope is there for me?

[@optimistic_psyche1574]

Only if you find the right guy

[@emmamikaelyan9104]

@@optimistic_psyche1574 yeah true

[@emmamikaelyan9104]

@Awesomebaker20 What do you mean?

[@emmamikaelyan9104]

@Awesomebaker20 It's what the whole song is about

[@dayburks]

Emma Mikaelyan I thought you was indicating that you are a lesbian 😳💀💀💀

[@lulujuma4418]

When this song came out,,I couldn't differentiate Beyonce and Shakira, they looked so alike

[@applecupcakes86]

They still do look alike.

[@hamidpirxada151]

Sure too much resemblance both of them

[@kielyahyisrael-evans7909]

exactly

[@melodyprays7581]

That's so unfair that they didn't sing it live together

[@pinnaryokubo3563]

@asapdammoh 😆

[@lkez2]

they are both too big to be on the stage at the same time

[@melodyprays7581]

@@lkez2 that's a stupid excuse .. makes no sence ..

[@lkez2]

@@melodyprays7581 no it's not, you idiot. Try getting two global superstars to get their schedule to align. Fun fact : they couldn't meet to do this song for 5 months, because they were both so busy and Shakira had to wait for her tour to end. They couldn't even record the song at the same time.

[@melodyofthecursed]

Its already hard enough for Beyonce to learn belly dancing from Shakira for this video. Dance on stage maybe harder for her.

[@PerlaVicente-q7l]

Thank you Beyoncé fr letting me write this comment

[@kennedyxhulu4933]

This is the best Black - Latino collaboration of all time. No arguments

[@googlymoogly908]

Point 👏🏾 Blank 👏🏾 Period 👏🏾

[@itsroxie9818]

U mean or like black and Arab cause shakira is half Lebanese and the song has Arabic influences.

[@kennedyxhulu4933]

@@itsroxie9818 I have no idea that Shakira is half Lebanon. Its good to know.

[@saulsaab8753]

@Shurkf De78rore No way! She's Latina like me!

[@julial150]

Black-latina-oriental(shakira is half libanese)

[@laurapiacentinicasarin8205]

When they say "Beyoncé, Beyoncé, Shakira, Shakira" i felt that

[@tianalynch996]

gave me chills

[@AlexisCardine-v4p]

❤❤❤❤😂🎉😢🎉🎉😮😮😮😅😅😅😊😊😊​@@tianalynch996

[@danielquirco1]

They've always had admiration and respect for each other, and in this video it shows! It's amazing!

[@angelabell8725]

I love the mixture of 2 cultures.Great match up.

[@onlinestar4536]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZpKydZimiLuog80

[@CamiloandresLondoñolugo]

Shakira colaboró con beyonce para protegernos

[@RAYFANTY]

Best female collaboration in history.

[@melihyigit2848]

Telephone says hi

[@stealth9237]

One of them

[@arethawhite3712]

I agree 💯 percent with you Ray, this video is hot!!!! You know!!!!!😀👍 LOL at myself for the last line of this comment 😉!!!! I loved it the first time I saw it, no doubt 👍👍👍👍 great job on the belly dancing part, that's my favorite part!!!👏👏👏👏🔥🔥🔥🔥 so hot!!! From Aretha White from Bunn NC Peace out homie 👊 👊!!!!!

[@purplearies9746]

Can't Remember To Forget You waves

[@alexandroskaravergos9657]

Me against the music,britney-madonna

[@avateraangshoe5025]

The song and its message aged like fine wine

[@AD-kp6wu]

Indeed

[@galamelamu236]

Lol...I like your expression

[@rogetpickens7776]

The director captured both of their best moments

[@BirdiePlaysYT]

the hip movements in this...damn. but i'm so jealous of those bodies...

[@towiseas6965]

Birdie Birdie

[@jaygee6738]

and their upper bodies don't move much when the hips are moving... I loved it.

[@jhonnyareinamo2815]

karina

[@jessicalhomme5349]

Birdie Birdie jeu

[@aliciealvarez1063]

jessica lhomm

[@VALENTINA-os9nn]

Why y'll are comparing Shakira and Beyonce? They both are very talented artists. Beyonce is one of the greatest american singer and Shakira is one of the greatest latin singer, their success and recognition is international so we can tell they are on the same nivel. That's my opinion.

[@carlosreina5017]

Shakira rules!

[@Daniel-iz2ug]

Beyonce is a better singer and shakira is a better dancer and songwriter, also shakira is more popular but i love both

[@coreyadavis6466]

Navy sorry but Beyonce is richer, a better singer, and dancer than Shakira. Shakira sound like a frog in her throat she can dance to though to but...

[@Daniel-iz2ug]

Coreya Davis shakira is a better dancer than beyonce, we all know that. And beyonce is richer because of her husband

[@carolineastley900]

1w334v4578₩₩(/÷×+++÷€ .. ¡♢▪▪- .q q 6 the UK and I will 1st. This email address. Please note, 111w345tty5667o99, I am not a problem with the following week00

[@OfficialPrettyLittleLiars]

still waiting for a collab to be more iconic than this

[@ericklosner3181]

Britney Spears and Madonna

[@Love.less.]

Rihanna and Shakira

[@xa1551]

We are the world...

[@thephantomzone1884]

Eric Klosner yeppp u right

[@makangajulius98]

@lucas nicki and bey says hey 🤣

[@Edithvgr]

Gracias beyonce por dejar participar a Shakira en tu canción. Te amamos

[@9Risky]

It’s DECEMBER 2021, let’s see how many legends are still listening to this masterpiece 🤍.

[@shilpabagde3344]

:)

[@mjor2431]

Yess !

[@Pigeonpng]

Hi

[@keviasdailylife4462]

Me

[@arielfarra7979]

Hey!

[@klnguyen279]

Singing lines were distributed really evenly in this song, even in the chorus. A perfect harmony.

[@veronicasikhosana9758]

One of the best collaborations ever, both in dancing and singing... these women can move their hips man and can both sing, they have powerful voices. still love the song.

[@DeepKaur-ir1wy]

THEMBY VERONICA SIKHOSANA AwaEE ANDA

[@jenniferperez1634]

zs odlodxoxl d lxxlllddllalxlxodlxld de lddssdxlp20e0epñ de rll2ooofo X lxlppdssplddpldlddsldo0e

[@i3igounce762]

THEMBY VERONICA SIKHOSANA well shakira taught bionce to belly dqnce

[@veronicasikhosana9758]

Big joe fat ...And she is doing it like pro, that she is...

[@Aurora-skiess]

big joe fat now Beyoncé should return the favour & teach her how to sing