The Rise of the Android - Time of Eve & Sing a Bit of Harmony

[@simonpotter7534]

Time of Eve is one my favorite anime that left me wanting more. The dance between the humans and robots was wonderful as they explored the boundaries between human and machine experience.

[@Svid1701D]

Agree 100% Very unheard of anime Glad it's getting some exposure!

[@pip4183]

You know that when you see a movie directed by Yasuhiro Yoshiura you need to prepare your brain to be blown. Because his work is incredible nostalgic and you will be always remember some of the line from his work. My favorite is Harmonie, because the song always in my head every night.

[@Haopian]

Sing a Bit of Harmony was one of the best surprises I've had in years. I went to see it in the cinema in the UK about a week or so before Belle was showing. I'd never heard of the director beforehand, and assumed it was just trying to ride the anime movie wave of Belle's release. Not expecting anything special, I sat and watched, and with every minute, was captivated more and more. I walked out the cinema with the biggest smile I've had in a long time, and immediately put the OST on in the car drive home. Not only is the film wonderfully charming, it managed to give me a sense of wonder and discovery, which is so rare in recent times. Thank you for helping bring more people to it!

[@skyefarnan2311]

Whoever did the subtitles (Fevol according to the description) did not need to put that much effort into them but they did and I'm enjoying them very much. 0:48 3:14 5:20 6:16 8:31 11:09 14:13 Like the small stuff like justifying the subtitles to not cover the Parton names 15:07

[@BeyondGhibli]

Fevol is the real MVP. Their captions on all of my videos are so wonderful!

[@ethanpochna565]

I think it's also really nice that OP took the time to find so many timestamps just for a shoutout

[@aHeroWith1000Names]

I thought half of these are hard subs edited into the video itself at first watch! Simply amazing. Kudos for bringing attention to this neatnesd!

[@diamonddrop]

To whomever did the captions here, thank you!

[@pip4183]

Kokia Harmonie is such a masterpiece and you cant change my mind. This is such a great essay about his work. Thank for this one. His work need to be more appreciated.

[@Lyfe]

Shoutout to the 'beatboxing, rapping, android' who did the subtitles for this video. - Awesome video. I now have two movies to watch!

[@animeyahallo3887]

My friend and I watched Sing a bit of Harmony and we loved it! Especially the Lead Your Partner scene.

[@AlmostHawaii]

It always puts a smile on my face to see a video from you. Extremely happy to see you talk more about Yoshiura Yasuhiro's work. He deserves more attention and so do you.

[@stratoge]

God I love these subtitles. Top-notch. God I gotta watch more Yoshiura's works. I gotta watch the Harmony movie. Thank you for recommending it. Great relevant video with all the AI talk.

[@kaiichinose9448]

I reallyy love your videos and how you describe each and everything , whenver I feel stressed I listen to your videos and close my eyes, I feel refreshed and ready to start life( it feels like a breeze passed over me and gave me life). I really appreciate your content and Thanks for uploading!!!!

[@TehH3R0]

One of the only creators that makes me truly excited when a new video is posted! Thank you for all the amazing suggestions and the calming reprieve your voice and scripts bring on hectic days.

[@OtakuDoomer]

I've been a big fan of Yasuhiro Yoshiura's works for a long time ever since I found the short aquatic language. One of my favorite directors and I wish his works were more known.

[@l.veronese2336]

Lovely video as always Joe! I don't know how you do it, but you're amazing at capturing the atmosphere of the art you're talking about. Your videos got me into both Evangelion and Golden Kamuy, and I love them both

[@andrewpragasam]

Glad to have you back B.G. Time of Eve is a low key gem. As your video so eloquently observes it is more relevant now than ever. I like to think that if Yasujiro Ozu ever made a sci-fi film it would be like Time of Eve. Can't wait to see Sing a Bit of Harmony - it looks charming as all heck!

[@aHeroWith1000Names]

I realliy appreciate how you accentuated the best parts that Harmony derives from its narrative simplicity rather than just criticizing it! There's been so many gritty, hardcore, dystopic stories about AI and technology that such a joyful and idealistic movie reconstructs hope for the future. It tells us that technology can complement our life without replacing us -- that we shouldn't give up in the face of singularity, but should work on bringing into reality technology that actually will better our lives. With all credits due to Time of Eve and many other tales ruminating on consequences of tech advancement, we also need stories that can excite us with what the future can offer. And I too haven't had such a long smile while watching a movie for a long while! :)

[@Bekayvd]

I recently watched Josee, the Tiger and the Fish after sereing one of your videos, and it was amazing. Your taste is truly impeccable, I have never disliked any of the films or series you present here. Will definitely check these out as well. Thanks for sharing!

[@authormichellefranklin]

Top stuff, Joe, as always!

[@zacharywong483]

Absolutely wonderful script, as always! Fantastic video!

[@TheKnightOfZ0]

The genius of Ichiro Okouchi and Yasuhiro Yoshiura created the cinematic beauty of Sing a bit of harmony, Love to see it talked about.

[@mintman325]

Well I never knew of this man before this video but now it is time to go down the rabbit hole and consume his work to answer the million dollar question of the past 70 years. Thank you

[@ComtrollerReviews]

You always introduce me to such fantastic things, thanks!

[@AdaraFukuchi]

another beautiful video. great work, joe!

[@gordonp57]

Another excellent video, I never miss them. A joy to watch and rewatch.

[@paulmccool378]

Great video, Joe. Loved Time of Eve when I saw it.

[@byrontheusurper6505]

I love sing a bit of harmony so much man that movie is ADORABLE

[@deusexmangaka3259]

I watched Time of Eve today, and it was... intriguing. The idea is interesting and the exploration of what independence the androids can gain from the 3 laws of robotic, what they can do with it, the relationship they can create, how they feel about it... it's so interesting, i'm surprised there isn't much more content in this franchise. The style, the feel of the movie, while confusing at moment, brings atmosphere to a level i rarely see. It's a flawed and weird movie, but it sticks in my memory, i was captivated.

[@shuvoroy6692]

Whenever beyond Ghibli uploads ...i know i will enjoy the next few minutes Thank You❤

[@Crazy-Chicken-Media]

My day is better because you posted. Thank you for your time and talent.

[@jimmyzbike]

i just rewatched Time Of Eve this past weekend. Love his art

[@sntxrrr]

That was a great cut of great sci-fi movies! Having seen Time of Eve years ago I'm very happy you brought its director to my attention again. I will definitely be looking his later works up.

[@DiogoUsagi]

What a wonderful reminder of Yoshiura's trail of work. Caught "Sing a Bit of Harmony" last summer and several aspects of it still echo in my memory.

[@cu7821]

So weird because I randomly chose to watch Time of Eve last weekend out of nowhere while seeing it on Crunchyroll when trying to find something else. Much better than I expected it to ever be. Top 20 material, especially if it was longer.

[@ludovicoprestipino851]

I am thankful I met this channel. I wish to have the likeness of this narrative ability in my teaching job.

[@sorbus1654]

Once again, I find what becomes a new favorite show through this channel. Beautiful analysis as always.

[@mycotinafulica8896]

Superb work as usual!

[@HMALDANA]

Amazing video! Thanks for sharing!

[@thunderzproductions5474]

you got some of the best anime reviews ever. so eloquent and excellently written

[@martinvalencia798]

Wonderful video as always

[@dajusta87]

Great stuff, keep it coming. Love your videos!!!!

[@charpkun]

I still remember this being one of the earliest "exclusives" of Crunchyroll and glad it was there before the flood of mainstream fare that now dominates the service. Indeed, i havent watched it in years but my impressions of it has stayed over the years. And indeed, in a future where androids are no longer just the name of a smartphone OS, this should be what we should ponder.

[@Artyom64824]

Awhile back I tried passing along a comment to be re commented. If this video does not specify the show its talking about in the description then give it a thumbs down. Beyond Ghibli, does not do that and I never felt he did. I'm just saying thank you. What I'm also saying is those who do not share what they are talking about in the description and or a letter box is, shame on you. Why, because you know of something that is great, and how rude of you, to not help share, that what is so damn great. Oh, PS: This video made my eyes water a little bit, thank you Beyond Ghibli and thank you to who ever made the over optimistic robot in this video.

[@dra8801]

This is easily the best channel about animation

[@FoNgThOnG]

Time of Eve doesn't get enough love. I enjoyed every episode and wanted more after it ended. I look forward to our overlord Androids if I live long enough to see it.

[@chaoshunter01]

Couldn't click on this fast enough. Well done, Sir. Thank you.

[@ulysselfbvdlmt]

Really good video as always !

[@martinlagrange8821]

Thanks for the wonderful video, and another great introduction to some great must-see anime - very much appreciated !

[@karlosfigueiredo385]

Great video, as always. Man, I wish youtube would still let me add subtitles to your videos so my friends and others who don't understand English so well could appreciate the excellent work you have been doing. Both movies are added to my 'to watch' list, with high priority.

[@nikond90ful1]

Thanks for the video. I look forward to these and always come away feeling just a little bit better. Keep safe and stay well.

[@KingGurke98]

What a beautiful video, I'll go watch those movies now.

[@largesmallworld]

If you are in Ginza Tokyo, look for the Gucci building and along renga-dori there is a tiny side path across from Gucci. Walk down this tiny path which turns right. Here you will find the location of Time-0f-Eve cafe entrance. The location matches those recreated in the anime. The door is there but it is a back entrance that staff working in the building use. Visited and took photos back in 2017.

[@ar1su]

An excellent video. Subscribed.

[@darrionndrew5664]

I wish you made videos more consistently. Your videos never disappoint.

[@Gnevnyj]

What a beautiful video!

[@utoherozv]

What an interesting video, it really put thoughts in my head and a smile on my face. Oh, and that ending line was stellar. :)

[@Gunsight-One]

I totally loved Time Of Eve when I picked it up last year on Bluray. Now I am definently going to have to check out Sing A Bit Of Harmony as well since you gave it such a ringing endorsement. Thanks for the heads up on Harmony, as sometimes the real gems of anime fly well under the radar.

[@JackDanielThe7th]

Yoooooooo another video from the great!

[@mastermavrick]

Oh man Time of Eve.... i haven't thought about that OVA series in a while, was a interesting take on what is human? Reminds me how a few years later I watched "Plastic Memories" which went over the emotional attachment aspect of having a "android" live/nurture you but have to be "recycled" after their time is up. As for a singing android TiL vs this the musical. When I think of one.... it has to be the "Vivy: Fluorite Eye's Song" the starling of pandemic originals. Because on top of the singing aspect, there was the aspect of how "human" do you have to be make good music. (we'll ignore the other main plotline of the anime). We also had "Beatless" that blurred the line between the two recurrently. Anyways can't wait for the Chobits video, a Clamp masterpiece I also haven't thought nor re-watched of in ages. Asking the question is it wrong to fall in love with a android? What are the social stigmas? How do you deal with said stigma? And when you are lonely is a android enough companionship? (going off memory here).

[@folcwinep.pywackett8517]

Magnificent and profound review of two of my favorite robot movies, and its spot on accurate! Bravo! Mr. Yoshimura tells stories about human perceptions, if you and your girlfriend responded to gravity in opposite directions (Patema Inverted), which perception is the right one? If robots existed and could pass the Turing test, (Time of Eve & Sing a Bit of Harmony), who or what is the Human? Mr. Yoshimura is drawing a map of the contours and continents of humanity and he invites his audience to visit.

[@cozydayzandnightz]

As always, a beautiful video. I've never seen either of these, but I find myself curious of Time of Eve. I can't deny, I do love a good anime with a quaint little cafe, so that makes it extra appealing to me. Thank you for the recommendation!

[@edwardbrady2211]

I agree with you on this one. Yes I do still want more.

[@Razorblade1812]

I have seen the latter film on the German TV channel ProSieben MAXX not too long ago this year.

[@hadleyepstein2249]

I really enjoyed this video. I have not seen Time of Eve yet, but I will definitely check it out soon (the premise is almost similar to Westworld). I have seen Sing a Bit of Harmony and it is a good movie. Not the best pacing, though that's understandable considering it's focus on pure escapism (which I find refreshing from a film or show full of loaded and complicated plotlines). Keep up the great analysis videos. 😊

[@WingSun]

Singing the scripts 😮 I want to hear and listen to this marvellous fairy tale ^^

[@kirbymarchbarcena]

Another great essay about another great animé

[@crestsphinx1]

I'm leaving a comment because I want a musical Beyond Ghibli episode. Please and thank you

[@vanaals]

I like to think that Yasuhiro Yoshiura had a strong influence on the writers of Bicentennial Man.

[@frostfang1]

Its a lovely way to contrast what people claim to be AI now and what we really conceptualize full AI to be.

[@hugosantana5883]

Really happy with Time of Eve getting some acknowledge 😊 Hey, not related, but have you ever consider doing a episode about Monster? It would be awesome... and terrifying lol

[@BeyondGhibli]

It will happen one day. Hopefully one day soon.

[@hugosantana5883]

🥰@@BeyondGhibli

[@iamthe12th]

Wholesome!

[@613aristocrat]

I'm heavily reminded of Detroit : Become Human. But quiet introspection and inspection rather than bombastic drama.

[@TheSuzberry]

Lovely.

[@DABUNGINATOR]

I'm looking forward to the Chobits video.

[@NoiseDay]

My favorite director, alongside Satoshi Kon. Also, did you say Chobits video??!!

[@vc4961]

oh this one, yes it was pretty good

[@Kusanagikaiser999]

Thumbs Up this if you want a SINGING Video essay by Joe.

[@onepiecebarca]

Have you watched Monster? I would love a video from you on that

[@abdulghanisports7606]

Can you please do a video on suzume no tajimari

[@hitachicordoba]

I'd love to hear your thoughts on the androids of NieR: Automata

[@BeyondGhibli]

There is a plan to do a video on the entire franchise :) Not sure when but it's coming!

[@demultiplexdfunc177]

The science fiction vision of Android/AI serving us or being subservience to us is ridiculous in light of recent LLM advances made by Open AI, Meta, Google, Stanford etc. Had you made this video a year or two ago, I would entertain your premise but today the idea of android aligning its ability to meet the needs of a petty, conniving and selfish species is simply ridiculous. I’ve followed this channel through the years and love your story telling of heroic and genius animators, however, I can’t help but imagine a scenario a year or two from now where LLMs write/animate better stories than the best of us. I increasing believe that we are a mere stepping stone in sentient evolution. Be that as it may, if you ever wanting to visit California and in particular Silicon Valley and wanting to see the future of Android/AI I’ll be delighted to be your tour guide to Open AI (Mission neighborhood) or KZbin (San Bruno).

[@professorJorge11]

I'm not an expert, but Al could be so different from humans as to be cold or distant. How do you have a conversation w a fly that got in your house?

[@snkysqky8673]

The profound question of who is man and who is machine reminds me of a line from the "Sarah Conner Chronicles": "There are things that machines will never do. They cannot possess faith - they cannot commune with God... They cannot appreciate beauty - they cannot create art. If they ever learn these things, they won't have to destroy us. They'll BE us. Video link of quote: kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5fIaZ-NeLZ3pZo

[@Sisidiehebwi]

I like to think this is actually the documentary guy and her a closeted weeb

[@Jay-ln1co]

For once I'd like to see an people and AI coming together storyline where the AI was not indistinquishable from humans.

[@asaadbadawi7807]

Ah, Time of Eve 💭🫶

[@gachawangi7753]

Did your essay video about in this corner of the world got taken down?

[@BeyondGhibli]

It got blocked in a lot of countries for some reason, apologies.

[@gachawangi7753]

@@BeyondGhibli thank you for replying to my comment.

[@stephaniesews6603]

Oh no, I liked the video before I knew what the condition was this time! Oh well, then we will have that terrible future. ;)

[@pingpong5877]

It's all good until they take our jobs, then everyone will have to learn to code.

[@jacobegaca409]

Thatd be dope

[@nicolassantiago5581]

Another android? 2B? 9S? A2? I wish...

[@karstensingh343]

I need to see this uniquely terrible singing vision of the future!

[@pdahandyman]

🥰😍🤩😍🥰😍🤩

[@jinchuriki7022]

I want to be friends with androids. Thats it.

[@dante7228]

Time of Eve is not really appealing visualy, but I might give it a try anyway after your praise

[@Aurich88]

Had to stop watching the bit on Harmony because I was immediately sold and didn't want to watch a second more out of context.

[@BeyondGhibli]

That's what I love to hear!

[@NoidoDev]

If you liked "A Bit of Harmony" then don't make the mistake to try "Time of Eve". It's similar to a western movie or show, in terms of handling the topic and having tensions in there. It's awful. A better choice would be: Vivy (Fluorite Eye's Song), Prima Doll (subs only, maybe even unreleased in the West), and Planetarian (Movie). The first two are basically also musicals with robot girls. Also, don't look up Planetarian on KZbin, since there's a video with a heavy spoiler in the title.

[@XavierSalverda]

So time of eve is just a better film adaption of Isaac Asimov's irobot them Hollywood could produce because its not trying to make it an action movie / comedy.

[@flavorgod]

Unfortunately AI will never have a soul and sentience. That a quality of living things and chemical reaction not code.

[@jacobegaca409]

How long til the simulation of those becomes indistinguishable

[@RoboticDragon]

I have to say modern anime does not look near as good as the older stuff does.

[@rickyspanky]

.

[@petermgruhn]

Sounds tediously contemporary and not interestingly timeless. Sounds like tech social fiction and not science fiction.