Bharat Mata Ki Jai: Panel Discussion

[@alopal3191]

When Shushil Pandit quoted "Janani Janma Bhoomishcha Swagadapi gareeyasi" the discourse was lifted to another level altogether

[@utkarshpandey6879]

Sushil pandit is an intellectual.

[@thrinethran2885]

So true . Would have stood up.to applaud.

[@zeaybaanoorie528]

@KBP agree 100%. Intolerant fundamental islamist idealogies are exclusive n violent against those who speak against it or raise a voice that doesn't agree with it.

[@BharathiyinBharatham]

KBP All this absurdity happens only in our country in the garb of secularism There are strong forces well funded and structured operating in various levels of political machinery and social strata promoting Anti India and Anti Hindu rhetoric The problem is as mentioned we have to unite and stand as Hindus and vociferously speak about these things which is happening here and there but it has to be major movement otherwise we will be extinct

[@vipinsharma2283]

@@utkarshpandey6879 क्यों बे अंग्रेज तुझे जानकारी है कि ये इंटेलेक्चुअल होता क्या है बे

[@malmalhi007]

Im here for Sushil Pandit.!!

[@vikramchahal9676]

Bharat Mata ki jai 🙏🇮🇳

[@malmalhi007]

@@vikramchahal9676 Jai Hind.

[@rajkiransalunkhe3931]

He should be given chance policy making team.

[@mohitvkarma332]

1000 salute to Swapan dasgupta, he is one of those who are real mirror of ideal media.

[@kishansingh-sk3we]

MR venkatesh nailed the debate... Apt reply to Tavleen singh's stupid remarks

[@MrDillbud]

Thank you Sri M R Venkatesh..& Sri Aravindanji : hahaha .. compare your foreign-funded toilets, gluttonously purchased by selling your souls with the millions of innocent toilet - less souls of " so called Swatantra Bhara "t ..who were forced to defecate out in the open and face rapists born of these very elite tavleen and burqa media.. the brain-less buddhijeevi tavleen deserves the snub.. so do all se(x)oculars like her..!"Lunatic" indeed ! who are you to " reduce " COWS , you murghi ki agnostic andi ! How dare you say " Reduce to Cows ? " First , you call the Hindus "Lunatic", and the, "fringe elements.".and now, you expose your own neechta, by attacking "Cows.". you beef-eater.. This very fringe Hindu warns you against eating the cow, for , it boomerangs on you and fills you with the poison of spreading hatred for Humanity. .. The Cow is more Humane than the so called pseudo secular, reptiles like you and your lutyen clan . tavleen foolish woman, you belong to the fascist ghandy dynastic regime..kya, 70 saal se kyon nahin kiya..de-colonization ..makkhiyaan maar rah the air-conditioned mansions me baitth ke ?????

[@caesar848]

Hindus.... Reclaim India, Reclaim it's glory, Reclaim it's soul.

[@zeaybaanoorie528]

Sandhya Jain has explained the problem of "Islam in India" very well and why it doesn't fit into India's spiritual, cultural and inclusive culture

[@MrDillbud]

This lady is Meenakshi Jain's sister and, who was her father..? Can anyone explain please !

[@anhadpartap5473]

@@MrDillbud ..What do you mean bro??

[@DattaMusics]

@@MrDillbud member of sitaram goel group

[@kanwarsingh2127]

India has no spiritual or inclusive culture.

[@saajithsaajith744]

Indonasia. No 1 vihecle tire name GHAJATHUNGAL = GANAPATHI. National air line GARUDA. National ship companey SAMUDHRA. LARGEST LIGHT & SOUND NAME " RAMAYANA" . keep in mind Indonasia world largest muslim nation

[@zeaybaanoorie528]

Yes 100%. Indonesia is the 1st muslim country that implemented Sharia law

[@saajithsaajith744]

@@zeaybaanoorie528 not at all. Bkos whole indonasia not impliment sharia. In my knowledage only ACHA Province only sharia. Perhaps JAVA TOO* Im not sure. Over all this s obeous that whole indonasia not sharia. By the way for ur information that indonasia is only nation that given money to pakstan . Indo pak war past. ( not kargil)

[@akshaysharma6669]

The remarks of MR Venkatesh were the most beautiful and profound in the entire debate

[@JrJ2016]

Cow prejudice explained: Cows allowed humans to be farmers settlers. Provided milk and food untill crop grows. Bull helped to grow corps. Without cow humans would have been hunters till date. Every part of cow is useful solid excreets as fuel liquid excreets as cleanser for farms and house.

[@deadskinrippers]

@Citizen Kolar I love pork chops. Phuq muhammed. I'll make him my 9yr old bitch

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

"No country institutionalizes a system that foments trouble for itself like India has " Sushil pandit takes the cake

[@suen3634]

Great discussion and thumbs up for MR Venkatesh.

[@varoonshekhar4023]

"No other country allows institutional systems to foment trouble against itself" Excellent, perceptive remark by Sushil Pandit.

[@greygrey9628]

If you are secular, then stop eating beef , respect the other religion .

[@jawadkhinzeer2133]

What religion needs respect ? Hindus r being threatened for 1400 Plus yrs, invaders thinks they r owners, Hindus must make it clear to Invaders, Either respect Indigenous community or leave this land.

[@MrDillbud]

@@jawadkhinzeer2133 , is this guy grey Grey attempting to say that secularism is a religion ?? I suppose, it's blind leading blind violent, inhumane ,stupid and mentally & morally sick ideology behind which, coward musals, commis, leftists. seculars, naxalis & kristus are hiding to attack Dharma.. gutless goons ! Respect is born within on the basis of the other person's character and moral fabric..not by demanding respect from the innocent and vulnerable by Force , Conversions and proxy warfare from behind the scenes. I doubt I understand what grey Grey is saying..

[@suheilpinto6964]

That is not what is called secularism. Secularism means you can't force people to adopt other religions practices. If you don't want to eat beef don't eat it. You have hate installed in you by the rss. The reason congress was supporting muslims in this country is because hindus out number muslims. And if ever there was a fight between hindus and muslims, muslims whom are humans just like you and i could be wiped out. You believe dalits and muslims who eat beef should be killed. My sister has married a hindu, my cousin has married a hindu too. They are ashamed of people like you. Let go of that ego of yours.

[@suheilpinto6964]

@@jawadkhinzeer2133 No it is you who think that the so called invaders think they are invaders. In 1947 india became a country. Which means there are no kings, queens mullas, priests,seers gurus ruling people. People of various religious beliefs voted a party to power based on democracy and not based on religion.

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

suheil pinto what do u smoke ? So congress supported muslims to prevent their annihilation. Mughals too killed hindus so that they dont outnumber muslims? So both Congress & mughals are secular as per your logic🙂 Y did the mughals like humayun ban cow slaughter ?

[@koul09876]

हिनदी भाषा में मिलता हें ईडिंया टी वी। अौर आज तक की मासाला खबर । लेकिन Intellectual debates and talks के लिय जाना पडता हैं जयपुर festival. या पोणडी festival.. अब संकट यह हें कि यह सारे समारोह होते हें अंगृेजी में ।

[@koul09876]

@乙乇ᗪㄖ几Ꮆ爪卂ㄖ I do not agree with English binding whole India.Neither in past nor now. I think it is s poken by very few.. South does not need Hindi. What we need is hindi intellectual debates and Tamil translation below in written. And vice versa . Technology can help. And main point is we need to intellectual debates to hinterlands of India. Where people have no time to listen to debates.

[@AshwaniKumar-gh1bx]

Bihariyo ka control kamm ho news pe to Accha debate mile.. Qnki Inhe chatpata pasand hai to news Bhi chatpati kar dete hain.

[@dixitjain]

Both MRV and Arvindan Neelakandan Sir made very strong points ..brilliant ..loved it

[@du_boy]

Great discussion! Thank you Republic tv!!

[@shwetasawant6782]

Why isnt Pushpendra Kulshreshti invited to these discussions hez an encyclopedia for such topics!

[@harishkiran3663]

Too hot to handle!

[@saptarshiroy8548]

danger admi hain vai..usko bulana tik nehi hain..thora jada right winger hain.

[@sahajkuldeep6348]

@@saptarshiroy8548 😂😂 Par jo bhi bolta hai sahi bolta hai...

[@vaibhavbhore]

@@saptarshiroy8548 he is not right winger. He is indic or civilization winger

[@MadhaviAggarwal]

Too good. Though I failed to understand what Tavleen wanted to say 🤔 no Hindus are not lunatic. Hats off to M R Venkatesh🙏

[@axbisw2]

Sickulasism the congressi days are over. This generation not going to give up anything which is not logical.

[@tanvimishra3303]

At 18:00 , he made a point... How Gods and Goddess are associated with different types of lands.. How ecological balance was maintained and self correction was taught, weaving religious beliefs with ecological balance.

[@iamsidthebest007]

Here for M R Venkatesh. This man is the wittiest, intelligent and a knowledgeable person. And please note he is an excellent Lawyer. 😊

[@subodhsinha6966]

I used to think Tavleen is an intelligent lady but feel sorry when she spoke about shushrut and Shiva . It is Lord Shiva who taught शल्य चिकित्सा. Shiva is the architect of Morden civilisation. She should not expect Modi to read her mind and speak.

[@unitiindiversity5627]

Awesome episode. Very original. Beautiful days for the nation, is yet to come.

[@caesar848]

Awesome discourse. We need Bjp for next 50 years atleast or maybe forever. Hindu rule. There 52 muslim countries and 12 Christian and 1 Jew. None for Indeginious religion of India.

[@ranjitsubrun7034]

Remove secularism from Indian constitution and make india a hindu rashtra jay hind in order to save Hindus and hindu identity jay shree ram 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@zoomzoom7444]

Hinduism is secular, accepting others.

[@ranjitsubrun7034]

@@zoomzoom7444 ha ha ha only time will tell you that

[@indianbot0077]

Sushil Pandit is crystal clear, that's why ppl love him

[@Sudhentertainment]

Sushil pandit ji grt job kya bola hain

[@sudeshyadav7841]

Very good sir,the best explanation about this matter,🙏🙏🙏plz Keep it up,we always with you VANDE MATRAM

[@rajendrasinghbutola9217]

As far as, I know, tavleen Singh has a Pakistani son, writing against India in NYT. This lady has loyalties somewhere else, she will speak in that way only.

[@ronaldpotter5878]

NT Pakistani son. He was born in India , raised in India. Meet his father only when he was 20 yrs old or more. But why he still has his late father's surname, I didnt get

[@anandsaini]

@@ronaldpotter5878 he was raised in London , check your facts

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

Venketesh has made an exquisitely nuanced point 🙂 Faultlines need to b kept alive

[@rakeshsarvabhotla4998]

Superb discussion. I liked all the points of all the panelists

[@lalitkumartiwari1847]

I am proud to be hindu

[@SuperAdobeFlash]

Have to say MRV pleasantly surprised me. Kudos to him . General was making no sense.

[@anaghadani7193]

Saffron Maverick

[@johnroe8517]

Good and honest discussion doing away with being politically correctness! We need honest and open discussions to let poison from the mind to come out and society can then take corrective measures.

[@0706suchi]

So correct that we as Bharatiyas, are superficially following ‘Bharat mata’. The only way we tend to respect our nation is by showing aggression. At least we should realize the correct name of our country Bharat, not India. इंडिया का मतलब है land of indigenous people who are illiterate and backward. Though we cannot really get rid of the name ‘India’, but at least we the natives can always address our motherland by its original and correct name. 🙏 देश का नाम ठीक से नहीं मालूम, ऐर लाइन का कहा से रखेंगे ?

[@brshah8232]

Standing ovation for Swapan Dasgupta and Aravindan Neelakandan for their logical, ethical, and crystal clear rebuttals to the stupidity of Tavleen. She talks of where we have failed, but then why has she failed so drastically with her puesdo-intellectual son Ashish Taseer?? He is the epitome of a decracinated Indian. Maybe she should clean house first before talking about the "lunatic Hindu fringe". Fact is that the Hindu fringe is one the world doesn't have to worry about. Let's compare apples to apples on true lunatic fringes across all communities...I'm sure she'll be silenced by her own ignorance. Best moment/Pure GOLD..."you can't compare my toilet to your living room and claim that your house is superior than mine"

[@dy4858]

south had concept of mother land way before its being used in freedom fight...e.g Kannadambe in karnataka was there before bande mataram used.But politics has defenetly devided north and south for superiority.

[@mrudulabhalke1848]

More than politics, British did, through hoax Aryan invasion theory

[@DattaMusics]

That is no surprise because Bharat Mata whatever these people say was a migration of the Goddess of Bengal into to the poem of bankim Chandra chattopadhyay during the 19th century !!!....and that is Maa Durga Maa Mahakali and so forth now who are the other cultures worship goddess Kashmir Kerala Tamil Nadu kannada ...... Goddess Mari !! Mother bhadrakali !!! Goddess Mahakali of Calcutta which was known as kali kshetra because the Shakti peeth of mahakal is in there !! All this !!!..... Now this was a very problematic thing that day I mean periyarist and British they said you are different from the others I still don't understand how that can happen when during the time of dussehra the Tamil people celebrate a goddess festival will people dress dress up as the Goddess and is it is a very quiet acceptable during the time of Diwali in other places we we celebrate maa Kali puja !! Now???? the whole problem with this whole discussion is we are trying to say that the Mother India concept of abanindranath Tagore or of bankim Chandra chattopadhyay was hanging Oblivion no it was because of centuries and centuries of shakta cultures in India in various parts !!!....it will Trace itself back to Canada it will Trace itself back to tamilnadu it will Trace itself back to Raja pratapaditya Raja lalitaditya it will Trace itself definitely back to Shivaji raje !!!.... When and how did it got divided that is something I never understood why is this mythology coming from the southern Indian culture which was influenced by veerashaiva tradition which was influenced by agastya Muni and Lord muruga suddenly became a culture which is outside of Hinduism outside of north outside of Bengal how did that happen???....we celebrate kartik puja in bardhaman it is very peculiar that only one district in the whole of Bengal celebrates kartik puja separately in a big way other places also do but that is big in there !!!...... So???.. this is the only question when did it get divided when did it came about that someone sitting in Bengal created abstract concept in Oblivion when that is not the case !!!....... And I am confessing all this being a Bengali myself !!!.....

[@udaysheorey1490]

Tavleen Singh, what a pseud. indeed.

[@karthikpolasani3038]

Just start decolonizing Indian education system.

[@lalitkumartiwari1847]

Bharat mata ki jai vande matram

[@lakhyajyotikonwar2952]

Admin pls upload all the discussions as soon as possible

[@jyotipanikar5788]

Wonderful debate

[@fact5832]

The toilet and living room example just nailed it 😁✌️

[@ajitabhmishra9738]

Tavleen Salmaan Taseer is a Misfit out here.

[@cosmicallyspeaking871]

One of the biggest sold-outs in my opinion. She should babysit her jihadi son, but then that will be the end of her.

[@SitaShank]

@@cosmicallyspeaking871 It is a wonder she didn't tag on arka to Goshala & Go Mata!

[@yushpi]

On a panel which is so one sided, at least some semblance of contrary opinion of some kind.

[@poonamabbi7448]

@@yushpi You mean the muslims & the christians? They DO NOT CONSIDER THESELVES INDIANS... They consider themselves to be the OWNERS OF INDIA & INDIANS (read Hindus) & it is THE WHO ARE CAUSING ALL THE PROBLEMS IN ALL PARTS OF THE WORLD. They create these caccophonic conditions & while we are trying to discuss these & "resolve" these, they conveniently swallow our lands & identity like a giant anaconda

[@KshitijSpeaks]

Mommy of the hideous Aatish Taseer hired by white idiots at Time.

[@div_shrimali]

tamil literature - hindu literature(in tamil) = nill....best line

[@toonalaya]

Excellent discussion

[@gauravkapoor111111]

nadda is not his name at the moment it has always been madam.

[@rajendraprasadjoshi950]

If one goes through 13th chapter will make clear the idea of Bharat Mata though one need to go through whole of the Bhagwat Gita for understanding the concept of Bharat Mata.

[@thebatman7192]

Bharat Mata Ki Jai!!!!

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

I had no idea tamils worship chandi . Arivandan insights are enlightening

[@godsown_7]

These festivals should happen on a larger scale. This needs to reach a larger audience. I have attended the jaipur literature Festival. Can't speak about the content but the scale is massive. More people should consume this and be motivated to read and research more. For the real truth is not usually the apparent one but it requires a little digging, slight effort and it's definitely worth it.

[@Dr.Sahil55996]

They didn't allow for once Sushil ji to complete his point. It's very saddening

[@OneWorldView]

The issue of inclusive and exclusive is very critical... Bharat Mata may carry reservations and thereby Netaji's slogan "Jai Hind" was more acceptable and appropriate to most segment of society. Hence a more considerate approach needs to be adopted.

[@JrJ2016]

Ignoring is the REAL problem

[@seeker6088]

OMG am I the only Muslim commenting here? Any way, Bharat Mata ki Jai. Jai Hind.

[@nareshbharwani4491]

The panel has one thing in common, they are afraid of calling a spade a spade, and here you need a person as Pushpendra to give credence to the debate.

[@sakarbarve4900]

MR, Aravindan, Sushil ✌🏻👏🏻👌🏻

[@soumikspath]

Had to stop at around 4.00 min mark.First speaker talking abt having same education system,didn't Amit Shah announce about reforms in education by doing away with 10+2 structure in school education and introducing a layered school structure similar to US with elemntary,high,middle school like divisions? If not then what exactly was that,and if so ,is everyone here not informed on such a basic change here?

[@caesar848]

45:33 Swapan 🔥

[@shreenarainmishra5299]

Shushil is the best and correct in the Indian nation as mother

[@RahulKumar-bh9hb]

Our Constitution has provisions which restricts...........the majority to not include our sacred books in any form in our educational institutions. Every religion sacred book should be in any form part of the study. Let the people decide what’s right or wrong........eventually they suffer the consequences.

[@caesar848]

North and South should see the common among us that is our religion, brotherhood and culture. Forget hate. I am from Delhi and I respect love south. They are better than us when it comes to religion and many things

[@TheKarstrasse]

Dear Fest Team, too many mike issues :(

[@Tintin-gv9ir]

First 3 years of our education should be about Indian culture and religion . Respect , discipline etc . Plus we should become a Hindu country just like Thailand is a Buddhist country . Indian culture and religion first

[@shyamkumar-or9ww]

Still the secular intellects are afraid of calling a spade a spade

[@sreenathachar3246]

"Janani Janma Bhoomishcha Swagadapi gareeyasi" is when told by Shushil Pandith,that means at that time forget Muslim Rulers,they where No Mads,with that cultured people they started Looting and same Looting continued by Europeans...................Thats why we respect culture of "Sanathana Darma"from the same time of Rama.

[@akhilnarayanan8946]

Even the debate and my comment is in English, so we know where we stand

[@saajithsaajith744]

Bharath matha ki jay...... " why oppose exist 1st place ???"

[@namboodiries9069]

Very good. Tavleenji said what most people wanted to articuate but....2.Janani janmabhoomi..is not from Valmiki Ramayana. It's from Hanumannataka...very old work...

[@bipinnadkarni]

"you cannot compare our toilets with your living rooms "......bwaahahahahahah

[@ak20107]

Kanchan appeared to have half knowledge and didn't get the depth of points made by Shri Sushil Pandit. He was no match to Sushil's calm reasoning.... wonder why he got selected as moderator.

[@greygrey9628]

Give tavleen a broom to sit on

[@sidd4603]

here for Sushil Pandit

[@Tintin-gv9ir]

Sushi Pandit is right . Our culture and Bharat mata is under threat from middle eastern cult

[@suchita52]

Each country portrays their own culture & philosophy which they adhere to to retain their identity. It’s only in India due to the long rule of British & 70 yrs more of the westernised congress culture that we Indians, whatever religion, have kept themselves deprived of their own culture....feeling ashamed of their culture .

[@Openplatformbackup]

Bura laga Gali deni thi ni di.. gussa bahut hai.

[@sharadbishnoi3794]

Both the tamilian roks👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤🚩🚩🚩🚩👏👏👏

[@mrkumar7181]

Why Rajiv Malhotra is not invited?

[@manojmishra3889]

What is Bharat Mata:::: The term is of the Sanskrit root bhr-, “to bear / to carry” (fire or agni ), with a literal meaning of “to be maintained”. This MATA is for goddess SATI whose 51 body parts fell on various places (Shakti peeth) in a landmass which defines akhand bharat.

[@MrDillbud]

the rod-wielder did not allow Sushil Panditji to complete his thought.

[@DeepikaAditya]

We now have Vistara Airlines that too thanks to Singapore Airlines

[@n.k.choudhary6328]

We are missing Rabish for his brain refurbishment

[@sandeeptripathi4142]

Tavleen eneded the discussion by saying we need to decolonize education and she said that in English and I am posting this comment also in English and we both want education in India to be decolonized 😂😂

[@आलोकगुप्ता-छ4ष]

इन राष्ट्रवादियों को भाषा का राष्ट्रवाद कब समझ में आएगा

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

I cant allow a lunatic to certify lunatics 😄

[@aksa9993]

boring discussion.. tuned out most of it!! 😑 only 10-15 mins of it were interesting enough in the latter half.... calling so many panelists for such a short duration of time.. these organisers just waste the time of the panelists as well as the viewers!! they had some really intelligent people here like sushil pandit and that south indian guy on the extreme left(first time i heard him.. n he was a breath of fresh air in this booooring discussion!!.. would like to hear more of him in future).. and some who just knew good english, having no connection to the ground reality..... and the host, a sickular guy.. i hope they dont appoint such people in future.. they really bring down the quality of discussion!!

[@subashpadhee7096]

Even before the economic globalization, we have never assimilated the idea of Bharat Mata because anything we adopt from our traditions will be in conflict with the peddling of Secularism by our leaders post independence. And that eventually lead us to pursue and elitist image and trying to become person of everywhere, without carrying the pride of our traditions.

[@kbmnair2182]

Bharat Mata ki Jai.

[@ramakrishnan4802]

தமிழ் கொற்றவை 🙏

[@Garrry]

Quran 98.6. Surely those who disbelieve (after the Clear Evidence has come to them) -from among the People of the Book and from among the polytheists- will be in the fire of Hell a seed of which unbelief bears, abiding therein. They are the worst of creatures.

[@urp5774]

The quote from the plagiarised book authored by the warlords, thugs, invaders, looters, and sex slave traders in the tribal Arabian dessert in 7th century only has nuisance value. The authors of this book who dreamt of ruling met with violent death by their own people. It is outdated and fake political doctrine and stands fully exposed in 21sr century.

[@sushmasingh8008]

Saying "Bharat Mata ki Jai" In Mr. Nadda's way which is very casual, is not necessary. Ms Tavleen is right.

[@Vishal270187]

Being support jihad is good which liberal support like tavleen.....Syed salludin was once liberal favorite Congress alliance in Kashmir now a global terrorist now.....but liberals are mum now......

[@xyzpr3106]

Hou dare you to say HINDU PRIME MINISTER

[@tanukabanerjee1731]

Sushil pandit missed out kalinga airlines . Thats Indian christening .

[@kamalraj6939]

what about dharti mata ?

[@vkp5775]

Tavleen Singh is good journalist , but very predictable ..sticking to fake prejudices

[@AnilKumar-hx5is]

Tavleen Singh is half pakistani, she has pakistani husband and has a son Aatish Taseer, that is why she has anti india sentiments

[@Ragameiste]

Tavleen is certainly secular by our new concept of secularism. She has a love son with a naPak diplomat and he now writes op eds in NY times and WPo against India. She certainly is a paragon of virtues and can extol on bharat mata.

[@zeaybaanoorie528]

Who and what is stopping this lunatic tovleen question the lunatic Islamist. Who is responsible for such lunatics to be on such panels

[@veenahatti7183]

i think She Is Also A Lunatic.

[@KhaneKiChapaas]

MR Venkatesh is the best here.