Ranking Every Chocolate Chip Cookie ft. Zach Kornfeld

[@babishculinaryuniverse]

Gatorwine episode is next I swear

[@Hohhot]

Every gaterade flavor with every wine under $12

[@ItsBooToYou]

SIR

[@soup_queen]

Will it be all of the gatorade flavors with the same wine, different wines with the same gatorade, or some combination of the two? What are the logistics of gatorwine? Will it be cheap wine, expensive wine, a little bit of both perhaps? Furthermore, will there be so much wine drinking that the level of inebriation is going to have an effect on the ranking of different gatorwines further down the line? There are many questions to be asked, many variables to be accounted for.

[@imnotgivingyoumyname810]

I think this was the first tasting episode that I genuinely wanted to take part in.

[@Foo007]

What’s the over/under on Charles Shaw paired with Glacier Freeze?

[@TocsTheWanderer]

Fun fact, Canola oil, also known as rapeseed oil, comes from a plant in the mustard family. That's why the cookie package says "mustard free".

[@kogumasmommy]

Now what about that shellfish

[@TocsTheWanderer]

@@kogumasmommy No idea

[@zacharyworr5754]

​@@TocsTheWanderersimple. People with shellfish allergies are usually also allergic to cockroaches.

[@goblin5494]

Why would they call it rapeseed

[@TocsTheWanderer]

@@goblin5494 It comes from the Latin word for turnip, which is "rapa". Turnips are also in the mustard family.

[@pensandshakers]

The Council is not pleased that this is not the promised Gatorwine video, Andrew. Do not make us take further action.

[@RicochetMayhem]

There will be dire consequences if he is unable to follow up on his promise of the Gatorwine ranking.

[@johnsmith-jq1uc]

We will rise up. We will fight. We will win.

[@FKATorp]

Maybe this was filmed a month ago and we'll get Gatorwine in a couple weeks

[@Senthiuz]

I need more Gatorwine songs. I also need the entirety of Fenway Park singing "Sweet Gatorwine"

[@Nilejavxip]

Also, I put forth a motion to lobby for a chocolate bar ranking next.

[@CriticalMonkey623]

As a Canadian it always makes me very happy to see the Canadian brands in these videos, especially when they do better than average.

[@swinkscalibur8506]

Seeing the Decadent made me nostalgic for my youth in the North.

[@rtyrsson]

I just returned from visiting my sister in Toronto. I ate Coffee Crisp and Ruffles All-Dressed for a week and damaged my kidneys with decidedly unholy quantities of Tim Horton's. I can occasionally find these things down here, but only very rarely. Nonetheless I should recover in time for my next visit so that I may abuse myself once again. To attempt the lingo of the younger generation in the US: "The snack game is on point."

[@sanriohamtori]

@@rtyrssonlol

[@yoursodumn]

Meanwhile, I am so happy I have American options and can ignore PC to buy Tate's instead

[@pjschmid2251]

I didn’t realize they were a Canadian brand. They are one of the house brands in Jewel Osco stores here in the Chicago area. That’s why it was so surprising to me that he sent to Canada to get them. Unfortunately, whoever shipped them decided to Savage them on the way.

[@cinnababy6331]

The story about chocolate chip cookies is actually false! The woman who made them (Ruth Wakefield) was a skilled baker and she more than likely was experimenting on purpose. Tasting History with Max Miller has a very interesting look into the past of the chocolate chip cookie

[@ShayRae1392]

Came here to say the same thing lol

[@PaulSkySwitzer]

Shout out to tasting history!

[@laurennsspencer]

I was really hoping somebody would point this out! Justice for Ruth Wakefield, her legacy was not an accident 🤍

[@alijane6675]

Research matters, and Max Miller does his. Ruth Wakefield ❤

[@paligga]

Max is awesome! Great channel!

[@GROTESQUEDISARRAY]

Hot chocolate would make for in an interesting ranked video given the winter months ahead

[@CeceW-oo8yd]

Swiss miss forever

[@GROTESQUEDISARRAY]

@@CeceW-oo8yd we'll see

[@AmaraJordanMusic]

Oh I like this idea.

[@sociopathmercenary]

Swiss Miss is solid but Ghirardelli is pretty awesome too. Nothing beats homemade tho

[@KrmtFrog98]

My son and I love watching these ranking videos together. Thank you for giving me another opportunity to bond with my 14-year-old. As a single mom, it means an awful lot. ♥️

[@babishculinaryuniverse]

That’s so nice to hear! My absolute pleasure, and sorry for swearing.

[@KrmtFrog98]

@@babishculinaryuniverse No way, that's part of the fun. 😉

[@MENDEL7530159]

Mustard allergies are bonkers. My nephew has one and mustard is in everything! The color is used to replace artificial colors and the umami taste of the seed is used super often in things you wouldn't even imagine. The worst part is that it's labeled "spices" on the ingredients list so it's mega hard to identify until it's too late.

[@meganforster8912]

PSA the “white stuff growing out of the chocolate” is referred to as “chocolate bloom” it’s perfectly safe just that the chocolate was improperly tempered and the milk sugars are migrating causing the color seen. No impact on flavor or quality just less appealing to the eye. Loved watching yalls panic over seeing it tho 😂😂😂

[@Aikano9]

It most definitely has a big impact on quality, flavor, and texture, way worse than normal chocolate

[@Konarcoffee]

That didn't look like bloom though, that had formed a weird flattened white layer instead of the the chocolate whitening in place like you'd see normally. And agree with other comment that bloomed chocolate absolutely tastes and feels different/worse on the tongue

[@ditdah]

That was most definitely not chocolate bloom (which I'm sure Andrew is familiar with.) Chocolate bloom isn't 3-dimensional; it wouldn't have been layered on top of the chocolate like that. That almost looked like the cookies got wet and some sugar crystalized or something... really odd, and I sure wouldn't have eaten them!

[@tony_25or6to4]

The cookies were probably heated. Maybe sat in the sun in the car when they were purchased.

[@loopholesloopy]

I duno if it was bloom but I don't think it was mold either, looked like an ingreadient had seeped out of the chocolate, maybe the milk fats? IDK

[@BattlesOver]

Canadian here, the president's choice cookies were indeed crushed from the overnight shipping. They're usually whole cookies and very delicious. Love from Canada!

[@MalachiGoldschmidt]

I kid you not, 10 minutes into the video I stopped, went out of my apartment, walked to the nearest grocery store and bought some cookies to watch it with

[@rileystewart3170]

This reminds me of how grocery stores noticed an increase in sales in the UK when British bake off is on, but not in flour and sugar, just premade cakes. Consider us influenced.

[@Konarcoffee]

Plain potato chip rankings did this to me, would never buy plain otherwise

[@cabk.4538]

Which brand did you choose tho

[@Grayald]

Meanwhile, 10 minutes and I stopped watching because of all the pointless, uninteresting babbling going on.

[@MalachiGoldschmidt]

@@cabk.4538 Well I actually live in Israel so we have different brands over here. I took something called "Soft Muffin Chewy Cookies" that have milk, dark and white chocolate chips in it. This is from the amazing dutch brand "Merba".

[@puff222001]

I actually AM allergic to mustard (specifically the branch of brassicaceae that includes horseradish, mustard, and wasabi). I'm so glad to know that my cookies are mustard free! :D

[@drauglynn]

I don't know if you saw TocstheWanderer's comment but they said "Fun fact, Canola oil, also known as rapeseed oil, comes from a plant in the mustard family. That's why the cookie package says "mustard free"." just in case

[@detectivegumshoe695]

As a Canadian I grew up with those President's Choice cookies - very happy to see them here (and that Babby liked them!)

[@MrChadsimoneaux]

🎶 It's not the best choice, it's Presidents choice!🎵

[@rerolley]

But are they the choice of the Prime Minister?

[@r0cki338]

What about dads cookies? the chocolate ring ones

[@2damnfunny]

I wish Dads still made their chocolate shortbread cookies.

[@PaulSkySwitzer]

🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦

[@morelikecheldorado]

Zach's "I like trying" comment really flew under the radar lol

[@mykat7088]

I believe I heard a single muffled chuckle from behind the camera😂

[@maheshwarr8794]

Gatorwine to wash it all down?

[@TetraSky]

I was thinking the same.

[@gasstationnachos9952]

He was a gatorwine, she said see you later wine.

[@balthazarcorporations5969]

YOU COULD’VE FOOLED ME 🔥💯🗣️

[@nicholasborrelli7544]

No....milk. Enough with the gatorwine

[@clearlyepic9958]

YES!! Gatorwine FTW!

[@Leapyean]

That white stuff is called bloom, and it is totally safe to eat. It is just the coca fats separating from suspension in the chocolate and 'blooming' out of the chocolate it happens naturally over time at room temperature. Other than making the chocolate taste a little 'flat' and looking bad it is fine. If the white is on the cookie part and not the chocolate then it would have been mold; but that was only on the chocolate, so bloom.

[@TenaciousP45]

Ruth Wakefield didn't make chocolate chip cookies by accident. she was a smart cookie that made a bunch of cookie recipes. Its a shame thats the story that survived history

[@hackjack1439]

Really? I live down the street from where the toll house factory was and i didnt even know! Wild

[@ForTheNoms]

She didn't create them though - we have newspaper advertisements from Olean, New York, as early as 1923 with chocolate chip cookies for sale, and that's 14 years before Wakefield supposedly invented them.

[@hackjack1439]

​@@ForTheNomsHi! Im trying to find anything about Olean NY and chocolate chip cookies anywhere and nothing has it? Could you direct me to your source?

[@spainandengland1308]

I’m surprised that Grandma’s cookies weren’t a part of this

[@AccAkut1987]

At Andrew's age, chances are his grannies aren't around anymore to bake him some (I'm his age, no grandparents left)

[@laurasingleton301]

@@AccAkut1987I think they meant the brand Grandma’s cookies… found in gas stations

[@keard558]

@@laurasingleton301those only t t as station and vending machine

[@FishareFriendsNotFood972]

The description 'shellfish free' on a chocolate chip cookie has terrifying implications......

[@rileynorris1283]

If it makes anyone feel better it normally means there's been no contact with anything that's been in contact at all with shellfish! Or no ingredients derived from anything derived from shellfish, I work with a lot of kids with super particular allergies and in severe cases even the slightest cross contamination at a factory can be a big deal! 15 or so years ago my grandma had an allergic reaction to an orange juice because it had been processed with a preservative derived from peanut oil!

[@PsiVolt]

I believe that's just for allergy purposes. Major factories will process multiple products, so there is chance for airborne cross-contamination. So for severe, severe shellfish allergies it could be an issue.

[@SarcasticData]

@@rileynorris1283 It's just odd to state an ingredient that shouldn't be in any cookie, isn't in the cookie. It has unsettling implications.

[@gamerhex7335]

​@@SarcasticData Not if you use your brain

[@Buzzzy-bee]

@@SarcasticDatanot really

[@Atalanta01]

I was raised on President's Choice cookies (Toronto). As a kid, I would have them for breakfast, toasted, and then spread with Country Crock butter 😅🤪. I haven't had them in decades but I would still give them a solid 9. And for a vegan, gluten-free cookie, I recommend "Sweets from the Earth Ultimate Chocolate Chip" cookie.

[@AmandaAlto]

"[Hershey's] only works in the context of a s'more - nowhere else!" YES! THIS!! I've had this exact thought several times this summer. The *only* reason why there is a package of Hershey bars in my kitchen is for making s'mores.

[@victreebel170]

You should still use a better chocolate. Even their own Symphony bars. Hershey's is garbage!

[@b.r.v.8609]

His pronunciation of s’more was wild, it was like “suh more” which I’ve never heard before

[@CatsPajamas23]

Try dropping a 1/4-1/2 oz piece into your coffee cup just before you pour the hot brew in. Wait a half a minute, stir.

[@rtyrsson]

IN a world in which so much chocolate from chocolatiers all over the world available there is no excuse to ever eat Hershey's... unless that Palmer's Halloween or Christmas garbage "chocolate" is the only option remaining. Considering its half wax, just light a chocolate scented candle and eat your crayons.

[@kylejahimiak5010]

Babish: "The flavor just tastes like, y'know, something trying to be a cookie to me" Try Guy Zach: "I like trying"

[@GTRDesperado]

Since he mentioned camping, he should do an MRE ranking episode. I also want to see a honey episode (and it must include Tupelo).

[@todorovicl800]

I think those wouldn't be possible, because MRE-s make you very constipated.

[@sawtoothchris24]

A collab with Steve1989?

[@saintsgambit]

@@sawtoothchris24 mmm. nice hiss.

[@lauramcmahon602]

Yesssssssssssss

[@GTRDesperado]

@@todorovicl800 I think that’s only the military ones. What you get at REI/Bass Pro/etc. shouldn’t have anything to make you constipated.

[@lindadorman2869]

Famous Amos cookies used to be delicious! They had coconut in the recipe and a lot more chocolate chips and pecan pieces. Rather than being crumbly, they had a nice crunch with just a bit of chew. Then they sold the company and changed the original recipe. Totally inedible in my humble opinion.

[@PFBM86]

Yeah I loved Famous Amos growing up, I haven't had them in a long time though and I didn't know they've apparently gone down toilet in quality so I was really confused when Andrew trashed them.

[@LonkinPork]

Seeing PC Decadent come out on top really warms my frozen Canadian heart 🍁

[@andrewscullion267]

Decadent cookies are fire

[@wavesofbabies]

They're the GOAT! At least when it comes to manufactured cookies.

[@Ebonarc]

I'm honestly surprised because I consider PC Decadent cookies to be nearly inedible.

[@LonkinPork]

@@Ebonarc nostalgia is as much of a flavor enhancer as salt is 💖

[@coreymcdonald7745]

PC Decadent cookies are amazing

[@shuhlinspinnuh6600]

34:26 Andrew not knowing what sugar bloom is has me cackling 😂

[@renzodaihannya8644]

We NEED a beef jerky tier list!

[@jtcav6484]

Dental floss tier list double feature

[@liltako3671]

Beef Jerky costs a fortune these days, he’d do that tier list with one arm, one leg, and half a kidney.

[@Vu1turEMaN]

Some random guy selling jerky at a local fair who says garlic jerky is his best seller is a 10/10. Everyone knows this.

[@dirtporcelain]

Old Trapper is the best store bought and Jack Links is vinyl siding

[@MineSpeak44]

Savage jerky needs to be in it

[@nicholasmilillomusic]

No *Entenmann's Chocolate Chip Cookies* is a crime.

[@kngalex]

For real, that's the one I was waiting for. Those boxes didn't last a day when I was a kid

[@karenz5112]

Tate's are definitely my fave. And, as a fellow NY'er, I'm surprised that you didn't put Entenmann's chocolate chip cookes in there.

[@KrisKrisKrissy]

Yes! Entenmann's and Mrs. Fields were 2 I'm used to seeing everywhere and was shocked didn't show up.

[@karenz5112]

@@KrisKrisKrissy I remember that the Entenmann's cookies used to have so much butter and chocolate that I would get heartburn if I ate too many of them. :)

[@danselzer]

Also here looking for Entenmens. Sadly missing the similar Freihoffers.

[@toriierriffic]

I think the disclaimer for shellfish in the cookie is from the salt! sea salt can sometimes have trace amounts of shellfish

[@ElijsDima]

Maybe time to rank every olive. Not oil... olive.

[@freddy04123]

But also not EVOO, or VOO, just regular Olive Oil.

[@thestormageddn]

They'd go great with some wine... GATORWINE!

[@rileystewart3170]

He only compares things that are the same so far. So it’d be like 30 brands of black olive, not kalamata vs castelvetrano or whatever

[@lexistential]

@@rileystewart3170 his pasta one was all kinds of pasta

[@stephan17341]

Yes like nicoise olive too! It’s a very distinct olive

[@dvezha]

I think the only legitimately tasty packaged cookie is the Oreo. Never disappoints in any iteration

[@applegal3058]

Sadly, I'd take a little bite and throw the rest out. As someone who cooks and bakes at home, I find store-bought cookies to be too sweet and fake tasting. Perhaps if I had no other choice, and I was hungry, then maybe I'd do store-bought chocolate cookies...

[@hollystiener16]

@@applegal3058 @dvezha is referring to only packaged cookies and not comparing it to home baked.

[@ShinoSarna]

1:46 That's actually science. Most of the flavor is in the smell/aroma, and stuff being wet actually improves sense of smell (that's why things seem to smell more intense after a rain). So when dunked, you do end up intensifying the cookies own flavor.

[@danielfuerstman3690]

While I fear for Babish’s health, these rating videos are the best thing on KZbin bar none.

[@jimbubbatube]

You should rank microwave popcorn, even though the smell will probably linger in the kitchen for a month. Just don’t burn it.

[@victreebel170]

Microwave popcorn is garbage. The bags have BPA in them too. Don't buy it!

[@John_P._Buryiak]

Somebody forgot that the Entenmann's cookies are on the Entenmann's end cap and not with the other cookies. Can't believe you did a chocolate chip cookie taste test without including Entenmann's.

[@CyclingChefDiane]

As a canadian.... I hate chips ahoy... PC decadent are my nolstagic cookie. Glad to see they hold up.

[@ViRoseLaBianca]

Andrew giggling flusteredly at Zach is adorbs. I would also be giggling flusterdly at Zach, he’s a cutie

[@zwoope]

I don't eat vegan cookies because they're more expensive and worse, brother. Generic oreos are $4 max. They did the math on this.

[@HumphreyHorsehead]

"I deprive myself of joy" we already know you're a vegan, no need to be redundant.

[@iweargoocci]

babish please keep making these videos where its more of your personality and the banter with the cast, ranked and botched are my two favorite shows you put out

[@katrinalarsen9871]

It means a lot to have vegan acknowledgement in these videos, especially without being super weird about it. I wasn't familiar with Zach, he was a great guest and I'll have to check out his stuff. Throwing in my vote for canned soup rankings!

[@Alakazam024]

I am so glad that someone else finds the chewy chips ahoy worse than regular ones. It has been my hill to die on and I have felt like the only one who preferred the OG.

[@tycrabapple9282]

I think that's the common opinion tbh

[@valentinescookies.]

they DEFINITELY changed the recipe. i remember liking the chewy ones more than the original years ago

[@LindseyLouWho]

I always compared the taste of the Chips Ahoy Chewy to Play-doh, even as a kid. Those Pillsbury soft baked give the same flavor.

[@fadnama]

They taste like chemicals to to me 🤮

[@bflaves123]

Use to love the chewy and preferred them over the original. Tried chewy for the first time in years a few months ago and almost puked. They're so gross to me now lol

[@ezioauditore4061]

Some ideas for future episodes. Plain chocolate bars, BBQ sauces - some are regional so they'd have to be shipped, Yogurt, Chocolate Ice Cream, Hot Sauces.

[@meenakshiilango2956]

im so happy to be alive i love you andy ive been so sad and these ranked videos light up my days

[@ghostinthesnow4060]

Hang in there❤ I've been in dark places and it gets a lot better. Be kind to yourself❤

[@ellieboa]

Hugs 🩷

[@thisisspartacus]

Andrew you gotta rank the ready to bake chocolate chip cookie batters in those refrigerated tubes next.

[@lemons2394]

I was surprised that the NYC public school and vending machine staple Linden’s weren’t ranked.

[@fhsargevrod1301]

I love the videos and how your able to just seem high on life and just bring people joy your a huge inspiration and watching your video before you had your face in them is one of the things that got me started cooking at like 6-7 and now i just finished a college culinary class and have watched and watch your channel evolve while my cooking skills have evolved along the way

[@SkelyGeekin]

RIP Famous Amos

[@NaomiSlverflame]

Been a long time since I remember reading about them, but the original maker (Wallace Amos) of Famous Amos was sort of cheated out of his ownership in the early '80s. The guy had a different cookie brand eventually, local to Hawaii (The Cookie Kahuna). *edit. folded in 2018, which I didn't know.

[@jbum]

I had the original Famous Amos cookies, which were sold out of Bloomingdales in NYC in the 1970s. Really great generous cookie with hints of coconut. Nothing like the processed dreck in the vending machine.

[@Kelscheroni]

Might I suggest for an upcoming episode: ranking different chicken/vegetable/beef broths.

[@Klueran]

I usually dislike cooking channels doing ranking vids (cough Weissman cough) but the chaotic energy Andrew brings sells it for me

[@lateknightucd]

Absolutely this.

[@ShyShinigami8]

Josh has made me hate his videos

[@chrilborn4138]

Andrew has a way more likeable personality!

[@BiologicalEngineer]

I miss old josh :(

[@pleepler]

Andrew isn't yelling at us and isn't forcing the "correct" tools and techniques down our throat (no Josh, I won't buy a Kitchen Aid, stop being silly)

[@lukesodomin6711]

Nothing hits better than coming home from a hard day of work and watching one of these

[@KrisKrisKrissy]

You're in NY and ranking chocolate chip cookies, so where was Mrs. Fields?

[@rainzerdesu]

Maybe it's cookies you can buy in a grocery/supermarket. Mrs Fields you gotta go to a Mrs Fields store.

[@KrisKrisKrissy]

@@rainzerdesu Nope, I've always gotten them from checkout lines in grocery. Readily available in stores all throughout NY. Didn't even know there WAS a store for years

[@rainzerdesu]

@@KrisKrisKrissy Name me a major grocery chain that carries Mrs Fields in every store. There isn't one. Maybe your specific store has it but no major grocery store lists it as a product they stock.

[@rileysimmons9886]

​@@rainzerdesuI've absolutely seen them at a number of scores in NY and Mass. Had no clue there were Mrs. Fields outlet locations

[@rainzerdesu]

@@rileysimmons9886 So name them. The biggest supermarket chains in NY, Mass, or nationwide do not list Mrs Fields as an item they have in stock. I'm not saying either of you are lying, i'm saying that having 3 grocery stores in the boonies isn't a widely available product. Even on A-Zon, you're buying from Mrs Fields as the only option

[@krystalbaremore7627]

Maybe an episode on store bought cold brews? I never know which one to get.

[@novat97]

No Entenmann's is insane

[@michealpersicko9531]

also no lindens is either since they're both NY brands

[@liquidypoo]

After a moment of thinking, my roommate and I came to the conclusion that the next ranking could be colas. Pepsi, Coke, RC, and all the ones I'm sure exist that I'm just simply unaware of

[@tatersalad76]

Tate's is my favorite crunchy cookie. But as a soft cookie enjoyer, I've accepted that nothing will scratch that itch quite like fresh homemade

[@lauraslyricallife]

The cookies with the "white stuff" on the chocolate, most likely means the chocolate had gone through major temperature changes and bloomed. Safe to eat, not pretty to look at. Also, I know this is a chocolate chip cookie episode, but oreos are the best vegan cookie.

[@ShinoSarna]

I don't know about other European countries, but in Poland chocolate chip cookies are extremely rare (and usually imports from USA). Most common cookies here are usually butter cookies with jam, while in stores we usually get either jaffa cakes or sandwich cookies.

[@AccAkut1987]

There's those Danish cookie selections that existed since the beginning of times, and those always have some with chocolate in them. But yeah jam is more common. And chocolate chip cookies are often called "American Style"

[@ShinoSarna]

​@@AccAkut1987 The Danish cookies are popular everywhere. Rarely actually to be eaten, but across the world moms keep sewing utensils and threads in empty cans :P

[@krys42091]

The Zach crossover was dope lol

[@joshvanhorn2377]

I can’t wait for the upcoming Gatorwine video! So excited

[@Nilejavxip]

The council's incessant lobbying hath proven fruitful, for our requests for Gatorwine have been answered. But we mustn't grow hasty. Rea has yet to release the Gatorwine video. We must continue to implore him to give it to us.

[@mermaid_Gaming]

Man I’m sick right now and seeing a brand new ranking video just brings a smile to my face

[@threese6]

You are very wise. From Nova Scotia, Canada here. We LOVE President's Choice Chocolate Chip cookies. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@elisazouza]

yall got babish bad vegan cookies....like

[@vortexofweird]

WHERE IS ENTENMANN'S??

[@keard558]

In a display case at the end of the aisle

[@masterjedi8072]

A perfect video to watch while baking chocolate chip cookies for my family.

[@polaromonas]

1:25 Wait, you WEREN'T going to do the dunk test, for choc chip cookies?

[@Rattrap007]

You need to do pretzels. Different brands and styles. Bavarian, twists, mini twists, rods, window pane style, etc.

[@GuessImNotClever]

My grandparents ALWAYS had the PC brand decadent cookies on hand.....like they ran out. They immediately bought more.

[@bubblebeamm]

Video 4 of asking for every cambells soup can

[@spoonraker]

I hope you go back to doing the rankings blind. It really added another dimension to it, not only because you ranked more objectively, but also I enjoyed the "please don't be Lays please don't be Lays" type of moments.

[@therealestjo]

Please rank every kind of vanilla yogurt

[@Kogobean]

as a Canadian i approve of the ranking the PC cookies got, if i'm going to get store bought cookies i go for those.

[@EnderDragonGamerz02]

Chip ahoy are a forever childhood memory cookie

[@advillan]

100% agree with you. They are a favorite childhood cookie. Ironically wife hates chips ahoy due to a childhood experience

[@pigeonfog]

34:50 That's called bloom. It's either the sugar or cocoa butter crystalizing from the chocolate. It's entirely safe.

[@Nilejavxip]

The council's patience grows thin, Rea. Don't test us, for your life hangs in the balance. Give us the Gatorwine ranking.

[@brandons7888]

The best chocolate chip cookies are always the ones you make yourself

[@tinacraven2782]

I myself love Famous Amos!

[@mzdiamondlover]

Honestly, I’m thoroughly enjoying this series!

[@HeresJohnnyDee]

You had a whole vegan section and no Uncle Ed's cookies??? Sabotaged that whole section!

[@2222themoon]

Uncle Eddie’s would’ve swept

[@HeresJohnnyDee]

@@2222themoon truly the goat

[@Over_Toasted]

They got all the bad vegan cookies

[@HeresJohnnyDee]

@@Over_Toasted honestly that’s what I was saying too when I was watching it

[@lightnessisloud]

dude they pick the worst vegan brands and then go "vegan food sucks!" like bruh

[@Szznt]

I want to see Babish rank pickled jalapenos. Don't know why that was the first thing that came to my head after watching a video on cookies, but it did and now I want it.

[@SaiyanHeretic]

I can only assume Entenmann's were disqualified from consideration because they would have thrown off the curve.

[@Zayphar]

The crystalization of the Mountauk cookies is called 'Chocolate Bloom'. It is still safe to eat, but the taste and texture might be 'off'.

[@cbalparda]

After you’ve fulfilled your gatorwine responsibilities, I’d love a pickle episode.

[@kaylagraham8225]

I love Zach, this was so funny and yall meshed well together

[@agn728]

These are quickly becoming my favorite series ♥

[@waynehaley2409]

@babish. I love your content Please never stop. Thanks for not stopping prior. Thanks for giving hope against depression.

[@Ashes228]

Today is the day i will try the glorious Gatorwine for the first time, wish me luck folks.

[@way9883]

34:53 I think that's the oil from the chocolate chips bloomed out, not mold

[@anasevi9456]

3:10 they must have changed the ingredients since I was a kid, because while far from tasting home baked, or even bakery baked; Chewy Chips Ahoy tasted a LOT less processed than the original in the 1990s-2000s,

[@cjones0210]

i feel like these need to end with Andy making the ultimate recipe that corrects all of the issues that were apparent in the store bought items

[@ShinoSarna]

Gatorwine episode idea: tasting every boxed wine, and for each test include drinking it straight, and drinking it as Gatorwine.

[@AccAkut1987]

and the day after, best place for a hangover remedy top 40

[@Nooticus]

This is genuinely the best new show on KZbin right now

[@Luminocite]

I’m guessing that if it was a general vegan cookie ranking, Oreo would be the best out there

[@kasperstenbom]

These videos are fantastic. Please do continue with these 😍

[@RicochetMayhem]

The council is growing more and more impatient. If you are unable to provide the Gatorwine ranking that the council has requested, there will be grave consequences, Andrew.

[@Nilejavxip]

Worry not, for the council is ready, and willing to strike with force if our demands aren't met.

[@king_laws]

I support all council actions to deliver our point

[@David-co5oo]

the WineGator hasn't been fed for quite a while

[@MichaelQ-iv7pt]

I am once again asking for a Mayonnaise ranking (preferably a blind bracket tournament?)

[@talibthompson774]

why am I absolutely living for this series...

The way I waited for them to pull out Cookie Crisp cereal 😂

[@s3n0raw3s0meness]

Gator wine should be a must on this series