GODTEAR REVIEW - Is this my Game of 2020?

[@dub4148]

I got every set to paint, they seem like a good size for dnd....ended up loving this game. Now my friend group has massive battles every week

[@asdrubael1985]

Excellent presentation and review of a FANTASTIC boardgame!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Thank you!

[@asdrubael1985]

@@BlackJackLegacy you are welcome mate but it's the truth.. I'm glad I've snatched nearly everything i could find from my local retailers! I got only one game under my belt but i see the potential of it.. it kicks @ss!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I took part in an event a few months ago and absolutely loved it - it’s a fantastic game.

[@asdrubael1985]

@@BlackJackLegacy yeah captured me instantly

[@SuperDuperHappyTime]

I’ve played it, it’s a pretty good game. The way they ended Guild Ball, I won’t be buying or promoting a game from Steamforged Games that is just ‘pretty good’. They had major stock issues; Several of the original teams were not available for years on anywhere but eBay. They knowingly left the game incomplete (several teams will never see their minor teams). And their communication was so poor and spotty, most of the playerbase believes they were not just hostile, but actively blamed the players for a lack of support in the end. Sorry, but I just see Godtear ending as abruptly the next time a good excuse rears it’s head.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

All I can say mate is we all make our choices and as long as you’re happy then that’s all that matters. I wasn’t involved with Guild Ball and as you may have seen on my video about competitive gaming I see the situation differently but maybe as I don’t really have strong ties with the game or the company. What happened with Guild Ball won’t stop me playing or supporting a game I enjoy and if it ends I’ll still have all of the products I’ll have bought to keep playing it.

[@derekgarcia3069]

I wasn't involved with Guild Ball, so i can't speak to that. As far as the idea of SFG killing support of Godtear, that won't change the game I have. SFG can stop releasing characters tomorrow, and I still own a fantastic game. It's like when GW killed WH Fantasy; all of those players could still play the game for years, unless you can't play a game that you can't buy new things for?? Now, if you play competitively that's it's own thing with it's own challenges, but I also have zero interesting in structured, competitive play.

[@SuperDuperHappyTime]

BlackJack Legacy What I mean to say is, I’m not salty it ended, but the way it ended has soured me on the company for now. It’s not a “I’ll never buy from them again.” But if they want my money, there’s some things that will have to happen first. (Finishing the missing teams, getting behind the player’s community-run effort, Kickstarter so people can finish their collections, just a few ideas).

[@BlackJackLegacy]

That’s my point really - I think I saw the announcement differently as I wasn’t part of that community and so I’ve no reason to feel hurt by it. To me it felt like some folks took it the wrong way (in my opinion) and that seemed to get spread as fact. As in all big announcements there’s always more to it than meets the eye but none of that stops Godtear from being potentially my game of the year.

[@scoutingtheweb]

This sounds excellent I didn’t see those campaign bits on the website

[@joebaker5581]

I was looking for a simple game to play when my buddy brings his kid oner to play with mine. It looks quick, easy, and most of all durable.

[@craigbrown04]

Great view Andy! I attended the launch event back in December, played the game and picked it up straight away. I was very impressed with how simple it was but the depth as well. I need to get it off the shelf again and find someone to play with!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I wanted to go but sadly it clashed with family commitments. I wish I had now as I’d have realised how good it was back then!

[@Nethezbet]

8 months later I still have trouble finding players, even when I offer up just using my things in a draft lol. Oh well.

[@derdoc6507]

My thoughts exactly, BlackJack! I have two copies of every warband as mirror matches are possible. God, what a game!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I'm 100% hooked. I just bought a KS edition from someone to fill out my options so can't wait to get more games in.

[@williamjones7718]

That lore is minimalist but satisfying. Interested. I'll look at this further.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I think it’ll grow over time but it’s nice there’s a reason for these battles.

[@Chopperkelly73]

Nicely done Andy, great editing and presentation 👍 tempted...

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Thanks mate. Honestly mate this was so much better than I’d expected from what little I knew. I can’t stop putting extra champions in my online basket!

[@derekgarcia3069]

Great review, for a widely under-appreciated game. I was worried that it was going to be DoA as no one was talking about it after the KS delivered, but SFG seems to have a steady release schedule going. Also, unlike Guild Ball, as there are no set factions/teams, every Champion is viable for everyone, which is great from a marketing perspective.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I was super surprised that there was so little talk about it online and I thought the worst about it but I couldn’t have been more wrong. I agree with the no set faction thing too - it means every new release is available for everyone and not just one new release for one team.

[@scoutingtheweb]

P

[@scoutingtheweb]

was considering dipping into warhammer underworlds again mainly for playing rivals decks at home but this seems better, also has a better over theme for minis for me

[@dankennedy7549]

Great video Andy, I was tempted by the starter boxes last year when Jus had them in at the bunker. The models looked great and price seemed good. I still wouldn't mind picking it up but I just don't think I'd have anyone to play it with

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Getting opponents is always a consideration for any game.

[@joakimgustafsson500]

Great video! I have bought this game and played it a few times and I really like it. Heard before that it should be even better with more warbands and you really confirm that in this video so now I got to buy more. Didn't know it had a campaign which makes it even more interesting, at least for me. Thanks lot for this review!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

You’re welcome mate. I never realised about the campaign either so thought it was important to mention as it might be a deciding factor for some folks.

[@moosemoosington]

Seems quick and easy to get to the table. I do like being able to reference cards without having to keep checking back in the books. I feel like it’s quite a similar game to WH Underworlds if maybe a bit more complex.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

It’s actually very different to WH Underworlds - that was the mistake I made before I played it too. Whilst I think WHU is good I don’t like the fact it’s essentially a card game whereas this is a much more tactical miniatures game. I’d say Godtear was the more straight forward one to play - WHU gets a little confusing for newer players in the mid round phase or playing and drawing cards. This is one of those game that after one round you just know how to play.

[@moosemoosington]

BlackJack Legacy it seemed more complex in your vid but yeah the card side of things is difficult to master in WHU for sure

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Try exposing how to play WHU and review it in 12 mins! WHI would be a lot more confusing. As an example there’s no need to make a 5 rules folks get wrong video for this game!

[@moosemoosington]

BlackJack Legacy haha

[@1jasup]

I would like to see them release terrain expansions and/or environmental hazards in the future.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I’m personally not sure it needs it but expansions to the campaigns are planned and I think that’s where we’ll see some fun twists happening which is awesome.

[@simonparfitt1820]

Great video again. Definately peaked my interest with this one. Seems simple enough but also a good level of tactics.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

The game is all about strategy and tactics. The dice give that element of randomness that keeps a game fun but even the mid turn things like placing objective hexes is super tactical. It’s a great game.

[@smolle8906]

great game i have painted the 2 base starter boxes and some expansions.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I’m looking forward to painting mine. I wanted to keep them untouched for the video but that’s done now!

[@lordmaiden]

Thank you for your review. It's nice to see that what your initial thoughts of the game were versus what you think after playing it and it really speaks for a game if it manages to change your opinion. I have played a few games and i do agree with you. it's most likely best to start small and build up.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Yeah I’m always open to having my mind changed and I’m glad I got the opportunity to give it a try.

[@lordmaiden]

@@BlackJackLegacy same here, i'm open to try things. even things i don't like until i know i don't like it.

[@thedorkydoodlesden]

How am I just hearing about this game? I LOVE skirmish games!

[@goreshadetube]

Thanks for the video. This seems like a great set of rules. Almost everything I’ve read about this has been positive. It’s a little upsetting it hasn’t gotten more love. Games can be like music, the best stuff isn’t always the most popular. I’m going to try playing on Tabletopia.

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Glad it was helpful! The lack of noise put me off too however I'm so glad I got the chance to try it. I've now bought almost everything for this game and will begin painting them tonight.

[@goreshadetube]

I’ve just found out that not only are there local players but they had a tournament last month! Trying to get one of them for a demo game.

[@RedRoseWargaming]

Great video, Andy. You've motivated us to check it out!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Cheers Anna. It just plays so well and for all the reasons I love Warcry I get a lot of the same feel from this too. Super simple rules, cards with what I can do right in front of me, more time spent playing than referencing rules and fun.

[@benja6902]

I was drawn to these minis - they look great! I champion any game that may usurp the reign of GW - go Godtear!

[@BlackJackLegacy]

This is a great game and I've gone all in with it. The minis are great quality too for single piece plastic.

[@henrymendes5617]

Looks interesting. Great review 👍

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Thanks! 👍

[@lit_wick]

How do you feel about it now, two years later?

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Still love the game. The lockdowns held it back but it’s growing again now. I recently took part in an event and won it and there’s more Godtear stuff on my channel recently too. Great game - kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6HNaYBshM2arbM

[@arielsanchez465]

After three years I'm really burned by Underworlds. This looks like a very good alternative.

[@dirkd6908]

When they make a sci-fi version (like Dark Age..?) I'll be interested. Too many fantasy games out there.

[@marcolai9735]

Wow!! 🤩 This game really surprised you!! If I didn’t have Super Fantasy Brawl I would have definitely given this a go. If steamforged wants to send me a few items, I’ll definitely give it a go though :)

[@BlackJackLegacy]

It really wasn't what I expected. Super easy to learn but tonnes of depth in the strategy.

[@arthurmensing3869]

The game looks really cool. Does it have a solo mode? Thanks. Love the channel. Do you have an email address to ask otherquestions?

[@BlackJackLegacy]

Hi Arthur - it doesn’t have a solo mode although in a squeeze you could just play both sides. Thank you for the kind words. My email is [e-mail].

[@DatOldeBiker]

Thank you Andy, Godtear looks to be an interesting and rewarding game. I would certainly play and see how I like it. :>)

[@BlackJackLegacy]

I find it really scratches the itch of the things I like in games.

[@cronkitepercussion]

This game needs 3d terrain. Period.