Blindfolded Thomas Lennon Isn't Quite Sure If He's Got Milk

[@josephblumenberg6574]

Now I want to see them do a game called "Is It An Opossum?" 😂

[@ethanmckinney203]

As a variant of "Is It a Duck"?

[@dustyburwell592]

The disbelief on Taylor’s face when Marcella was rubbing herself down was priceless.

[@wirelesmike73]

Everything about this was pure comedy GOLD! The "3 fingers is a lot.", the opossum scare and the only fans, and the televised milk bath... all just floored me. But, Taylor laughing at Sarah freaking out over Marcella fiddling with the table was one of the funniest things I've seen on here. Damn, that was good. You just know that backstage is fun on this show, sometimes. This one had to be one of those times.

[@MarcellaArguello]

We had a blast!!!

[@wirelesmike73]

@@MarcellaArguello And it shows! Y'all were awesome! Easily one of the best episodes of the whole series. You Rock!💙

[@jenniferziegenfuss3719]

​@MarcellaArguello you were the MOST chaotic good person ever and a menace in the best way. That 🥛 vs 💧 was top tier.

[@rainbomg]

Everyone absolutely nailed it in this segment. Marcella is an absolute menace and I love her. I think this is the hardest I’ve ever laughed at this show

[@MarcellaArguello]

😋

[@jv-lk7bc]

@@MarcellaArguello is that you?! not allowed around anyone blindfolded ever again.

[@williamalexander7481]

Yes

[@wirelesmike73]

There's a huge difference between people trying to be funny for the camera, and people who are just naturally, genuinely funny, simply being themselves. These people are just genuinely funny people. There is no "try", it's just like breathing to them. Such a good panel, and a great episode. I could easily see these three doing a series together.

[@DutchWimo]

Marcella is always the most chaotic panelist 🤣

[@rainbomg]

She guests on a podcast I listen to every couple months and those are my fave episodes. I love her so much

[@DutchWimo]

@@rainbomgWhat’s the podcast?

[@MarcellaArguello]

Tee hee

[@Blissfulbizz]

​@@rainbomgtell ussssss we love Marcella

[@rainbomg]

@@DutchWimo it’s the daily zeitgeist and Lovett or leave it. They are both frequent and news focused and it may be pretty weird to listen to old episodes but she’s an absolute riot and I always audibly say “yaaaaay” when she’s on. Apple Podcasts app has a thing where you can search the person I think!

[@thedrizzle619]

I love marcellas commitment to the bit lol

[@Bluesayshello1]

Dialed it up to 11!!!!! She’s amazing

[@MarcellaArguello]

🤡🤡🤡

[@ahr355]

😂 I'll watch anything with Thomas Lennon.

[@Vtarngpb]

Yaaaas!😊

[@myrojyn]

Even Unfrosted?

[@augusts1]

This was unhinged in the best way possible!

[@AdrianColley]

3:40 "That is not funny!" _cut to_ Taylor reduced by laughter to the fetal position

[@kylelichter7]

“If my fingers were wet and I couldn’t see it I would be freaked out too” is a sentence that has never been uttered until this segment 😂😂😂😂😂

[@AdrianColley]

#hapaxlegomenon Look it up.

[@kylelichter7]

@@AdrianColley not gonna lie, my dude, I’m a little scared to

[@solvseus]

@@kylelichter7 Ok, hear me out...

[@jv-lk7bc]

@@solvseus play nice even the comments on this thing are getting a out of hand.

[@aliengranpa]

It's a pretty accurate sentence too if you think about it

[@kate_6436]

I love Taylor crouching down hahah

[@jv-lk7bc]

helpless

[@fireoflife2018]

This was the funniest thing, I have ever seen. If you ask me why I could not tell you but I fell out of my chair when she made those noises on the table. 🤣

[@MarcellaArguello]

🤪

[@almogdov]

it's almost like Marcella needs to be a permanent guest like the Whose line panel lol

[@Blissfulbizz]

this!

[@williamalexander7481]

Yes!

[@_mr_deedz]

There is no way in hell the writers could have imagined this game of milk or not milk being so gut-crushingly funny…😂😂😂

[@MarcellaArguello]

Certainly felt like an impossible task

[@magdalenadrysdale4582]

Only this group of guests could make this segment so hilarious!

[@sbtl.s]

Best panelist chemistry by far

[@eat_pray_porg8450]

"DON'T DO THAT! I peed a little bit." This was just pure comedy all around.

[@kyletownsend8028]

Easily the greatest episode of the this show and I've watched every one. Incredible.

[@rainbomg]

SAME! Same same same what a pinnacle of panelists

[@BlanBonco]

Slowly capturing the Japanese game show market

[@CB-pf5lb]

"They're bottles now, whoa." why was that so funny

[@incognitim]

Low-key the best line of an epic segment! 💯🤣

[@marksasahara1115]

Marcella! HFS! She's nuts! Comedy Gold! The opossum bit? Taylor dying laughing! One of the best segments!

[@lashadi1445]

This is truly an artform of late-night television 💫❤

[@ethanmckinney203]

This segment was insane and hilarious, but Taylor collapsing from laughter was the cherry on top!

[@peerblickdicht8401]

Splendid! Love when such a simple idea/challenge gets to go so wild

[@ReallyBigBadAndy76]

This trio of guests were fantastic together.

[@SteveZ1]

That was fu*&king funny. Hardest I have laughed since A/M started. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😁😁🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@AdrianColley]

And it's such a simple premise! It had _no right_ to be this funny.

[@shannonardo]

“Three fingers, wow! That’s a lot!” *”Is it??”*

[@JChaim]

This segment is unhinged and I love it

[@RequiemofaMadman]

I love Taylor and this show.

[@sailfast2005]

I haven't laughed this hard in a long time. Wow... what a great panel. Thomas always brings it. Marcella brings it harder. Wow.

[@nikknnen]

I'm literally covering my face in shock 🤣🤣 I want to be Marcella

[@MarcellaArguello]

😊

[@Blissfulbizz]

thats what u get for giving them cuervo followed by bowls of milk lmao 😂

[@MarcellaArguello]

EXACTLY

[@Tonyhouse1168]

Weird; not the first time I’ve heard “stop! Let me touch it!!”

[@ninavee7061]

gotta be the hardest i've laughed while watching this show. this panel is SOOOO GOOD. unhinged in all the best ways

[@DawnoftheDance4477]

So is this opossum 😂

[@GDletterwriter]

It's so much more fun with panelists who aren't afraid to be crazy funny. 😅

[@wirelesmike73]

Especially when those people are actually funny. These three are genuinely f--king hilarious.

[@jv-lk7bc]

Taylor you're going to have to start putting warning labels on these. had to stop it for minute to wait till laughing fit eased off enough to breathe. best AM clip yet hands down. its a menace!

[@victorb5]

Man when the guests are used to the format and commit is so amazing. Hope they keep coming back!

[@dxs_nightwolff]

These 3 are explosive together!

[@williamalexander7481]

Im starting to love Marcella😂

[@MarcellaArguello]

STARTING?!!?

[@Skye_Writer]

Tom and Marcella teaming up to freak out Sarah was funny enough, but then seeing Taylor having lost it so hard she was nearly on the floor was the cherry on the cake.

[@alexanderhancock525]

Almost every episode I'm like, "This is the best one yet." But this might be the best one yet.

[@aliengranpa]

It's always great when Taylor loses her shit, but I've never seen her actually hit the floor before! This was pure gold

[@ConstructiveCriticHD]

Marcella is the best 😅🤣

[@MarcellaArguello]

*Marcella!!!! And thank you

[@sir_vix]

crying laughing. This episode was possessed by the spirit of Chris Gethard.

[@luminousbit]

The absolute best episode yet. How does this show keep getting better?!?!?!

[@MariaBareiss]

omg, I just laughed so hard I literally exhaled all the air in my lungs!

[@hander929]

lol Marcella es severa gusana y me encanta! ojalá vuelva pronto. CAOS! Honestly, iconic.

[@acgeewhiz]

This might be one of my favorite clips, lol. Probably one of Taylor's as well.

[@joguestin]

Thomas Lennon is an improv legend

[@yzolakitchi]

And now we need a blindfolded KETCHUP or MUSTARD please!

[@NoneTheAneh]

Ok... The next level of Taylor laughing would be rolling on the floor...

[@nannyalberte]

For the love of god, this trio must be a recurring trio of panelist. I can be pleased with once a month :) (and then they all separately appearing the other weeks of said month, of course)

[@franimal86]

I’m always down to watch the scientific method in action

[@rlud304]

You should probably learn what that even is🤦🏻‍♀️😆

[@uninvincibleete]

i can't believe you didn't use cuervo for the liquids segment

[@AdrianColley]

I keep coming back to this absolute work of art.

[@riverdaleedited]

the way their heads went down at the same time

[@esc8engn]

i for real loled. thank you all.

[@myrojyn]

This shiw has the vibe of Colbert is letting Taylor throw a house party when hes gone

[@alhypo]

I feel like After Midnight has a lot of dairy-based segments for a show hosted by Taylor who is famously lactose intolerant

[@Ryanneey]

This was the best episode so far 😅

[@ssofft]

this was S Tier!

[@jakobervorhood]

I love how this show descends increasingly into chaos

[@Kelarys]

Tom thought he had brought the chaos, and Marcella decided to put him in his place. But the possum bit was extraordinary from all 3 guests

[@bjswope8797]

That just kept getting more erratic. How!?

[@nikandthepartz]

Marcella I love you

[@MarcellaArguello]

I think you’re okay.

[@andrewbaker5493]

Who cares about the game, when Sarah is up I fell out of my chair laughing.

[@aliengranpa]

The way she handled the bottles was low key sexy.

[@jacoblf]

i have to pause the playback because i need to breathe.

[@carriemyers1804]

Thomas Lennon could be a permanent guest.

[@pierfrancescocosta6336]

This is just stupidity on full display... and it's awesome! 😂

[@glass.hammer]

I know I’m two weeks behind, but I’m certain this is the only episode that actually brought tears to my eyes. No one can match Marcella’s freak.

[@ThoughtsonThoughtsandFeelings]

Writers get a 10/10 for this one: Excellent excellent task

[@claudia.e]

What did I just watch? This was hilarious.

[@pedxing]

an absolute fever dream! =)

[@kirkh914]

I love this show and this episode was the hardest I ever laughed!

[@jv-lk7bc]

"I am a mother!"

[@jv-lk7bc]

wouldn't be as funny if my mother hadn't used that line a couple times during my childhood..

[@jess_ismore]

The comics are playing their games and apparently Taylor's game is how many times can you say Cuervo in one episode? Hopefully it's pay per mention.

[@jorget.924]

I would like to thank Thomas Lennon for saying OPPOSUM. #pedantic #AuDHD

[@justinmckean]

Whelp. Now I worship Marcella Arguello.

[@duseylicious]

Ok this show is finding its strengths now. 🤘🏼

[@0o0ification]

Scientific evidence that milk is comic catnip 😂

[@MirElla-tq9ne]

Okay but why do i find Thomas so adorable??

[@posthocprior]

OMG. That was so funny.

[@benchiaase]

Sarah Sarah Sarah!

[@benfred8]

This show could go on tour. But it could also go on for hours.

[@toniviskari417]

I don't think they can do a segment like this again as how the hell do you top this one?

[@petecoogan]

Taylor, you have laughed harder. It was that episode with the sports caster guy

[@jdrano2215]

Strangely enough, I'm having milk and cookies while watching this.... Yea me🎉

[@Startemup]

Thomas is wild

[@ClancyNacht]

Marcella forever!!

[@MarcellaArguello]

👹

[@StarmanStarman]

That's not the hardest you laughed on the show Taylor, remember the kid on the rail at the ostrich race?

[@FlorianFahrenberger]

Oh yes, I'd love to see that clip again. Do you happen to remember what it was? Or maybe who the guests were?

[@StarmanStarman]

@@FlorianFahrenberger the title of the vid is 'Taylor Tomlinson absolutely loses it over comedians reacting to viral videos'

[@FlorianFahrenberger]

@@StarmanStarman Thanks so much! I actually found it, searching for "After Midnight Kid Ostrich" very much does the trick, almost like the company owning KZbin knows a thing or two about searches. 😅 And yes, it's very much worth a rewatch.

[@threepiecefishandchips]

DADDEH, CAN I STAND BY THE RAIL?!?!?

[@Tonyhouse1168]

DADDY! WHY DID MOMMY LEAVE US, DADDY!!?!?!?

[@deannacook1106]

🙋🏽‍♀️ I want your pink blazer too

[@PaulSDoize]

#TaylorTomlinson #AfterMidnight #Comedy Did you see #TaylorTomlinson @ 3:41 and @ 3:53? My absolute favorite part of any episode of #AfterMidnight is when she laughs this hard because the panelists did something that funny and she has to wipe away her tears of happiness like she did @ 3:59 & 5:36!!! THANK YOU AGAIN #TaylorTomlinson!!!

[@Palidine4M0O]

WHY CANT I TIP THIS VIDEO?

[@davidliskey3553]

So, something goes off the rails everytime Thomas is on?

[@justaguy12345]

Thomas is the definition of Understands The Assignment.

[@Elmerphant]

I'm literally DED BEST EVER

[@ThatScissorsGuy777]

If you want milk sure to voice actor of Paper from RPS? 😚

[@orangefeelrelaxingmusic898]

Thank goodness Thomas was there…🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@marfaxa]

Cuervo Broadcasting System has really gotten blatant with their ads.