Boiled And Steamed Alive By His Neighbor - Horror On Fulton And Pearl - The Story Of Kyle McGarity

In December of 2002, a driven, well liked young man from Ohio lost his life on the streets of New York City, in what was thought to be a horrible accident. As investigations unfolded, it would seem there was much more to this story.

[@aliviahenderson338]

So sad. The narrator and owner of this channel did a great job of describing Kyle as a person who lived and not just as a victim. What a terrible and torturous death he suffered.

[@melissamarioth9554]

Agree

[@bridgettemallory6868]

I so agree he's not so blah he brings a more gentler side to the tragedy the victim losing there lives

[@maishahhendrix]

There has to be some award you are eligible for. You never cease to amaze me with the manner in which you navigate these horrific stories with compassion and respect. Keep doing what you are doing. Thanks for being the voice for those who never had a chance. 🙏🏽

[@EvilIntentions]

Thank you so much for that compliment. I really appreciate it!

[@ridiboo7738]

Well said.

[@margaritachevere2033]

Thank you for your dedication I enjoy your page I was missing you already nd I was strolling through utube nd there you was with a new story continue what you do these ppl who are no longer alive nd don't have a voice of their own are not forgotten through you you are their voices nd I appreciate that nd so do their love ones god bless you 🙏

[@laurametheny1008]

Lovely🙏🏼🌹🤍

[@mimiwins1]

Yes - he is an incredible narrator, eloquent and respectful

[@rosied.f.8309]

As a Native New Yorker from the Bronx, I have to say Thank You for humanizing these cases. You have a kind heart and are not only empathetic to these terrible crimes, but sympathetic to those involved and their families. Traits that somehow, over the years, have been lost to some. I wish you much success in your podcast endeavors and continued blessings for your future

[@SandraAlexander-xi5lb]

Yes. He is a very respectful, decent, informative, and kind person. He is to be commended and admired. Phenomenal work.

[@EvilIntentions]

Thank you guys so much for the kind words!

[@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617]

Melrose is in the building.. what part of BX are you from..If u don't mind me asking

[@rosied.f.8309]

@@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617 Morrisainia...163rd btwn Trinity and Tinton Aves.

[@rosied.f.8309]

@@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617 Morrisainia

[@Megog]

I was a paramedic in downtown Manhattan for 24 years. I was working that night, and I can say for certain as an eyewitness that there was no vent stack covering that or any of the several other manholes ConEd had opened in the area that night, and the steam was so thick that I couldn't even tell where it was coming from. The open manholes didn't even have sawhorse barricades around them. They started appearing piecemeal between the time of the incident and sunrise that morning. I don't know about the rest, but the vent stack story is just ConEd covering their a**es to protect themselves from a potential lawsuit.

[@TheScotian82]

and there it is.

[@foreverlovely14]

Oh my God I was wondering because I wondered if the person who put him there somehow moved the topper off and then forced him into it fully intentionally and that's how I found myself on this video, trying to understand

[@Alejandro-u7q7c]

Man with so many eye witnesses how could they just sweep it under the rug?

[@jrivera123z]

I worked for con Edison for 32 years and I was there the night this happened the stack was knocked down so was the horses I know I put the ladder in the steam hole and Yanko and myself placed the harness around the gentleman to remove him from the steam hole. Look at the photo I’m the con. Edison worker on the left. We were told it was a fight over the girl by bros detective. fire department or EMS are not allowed to enter any Con ed structures.

[@foreverlovely14]

@@jrivera123z oh my God thank you for all the dangerous work you do, you must be very brave

[@RockyRoadJY]

Amen, RIP Kyle. How awful. Keith got away with murder. It seems to me that no manhole should ever be left unattended when there is boiling water beneath. Water boils at 212F, that water was 300F. That poor man, what an horrific way to die.

[@marynehra502]

Beyond awful 😖

[@bradsanders407]

Yeah I can't believe they just put that stupid little stack over the hole and called it good. Having a background in construction, I can tell you anything painted orange and white is like a magnet for some people to come and mess with. So it's very possible if not outright expected that someone would one day come and remove the stack and leave a manhole with boiling water below unprotected. Should have been a grate at the very least if they couldn't have kept the original cover on it.

[@kimmieh8419]

I can't even imagine the pain he was in. Condolences to his loved ones and may Kyle RIP🙏

[@myfirstnamemylastname2994]

If I were a victim like that and went straight to heaven where I was welcomed with open arms, I would be filled with questions rather than relieved and overjoyed. I would ask "Where were YOU when I was screaming for mercy???" ... When someone close the manhole cover? What were you doing when you saw that happen, or knew---as of course you did because you know everything-- about to happen to me?? Nothing happens in this universe without Your permission and approval. Why did you let that happen to me, if You and your Son love me!!??"

[@Texaslife98]

@@myfirstnamemylastname2994This is the most heartbreaking comment

[@jamieharris2633]

Ive had a steam burn on my finger and i know how bad that hurts i cannot imagine what he went thru. This one made my stomach hurt.

[@sweetmissypetuniawilson9206]

I burned my eyeball with a curling iron! One of the worst, off the charts, pain in my life! And I've fallen off a cliff and been hit head on, on the highway! 👀

[@sweetmissypetuniawilson9206]

Actually the burn to my chest, when I was a waitress, was pretty bad too! Fresh hot coffee! I've got a broken toe, since falling on the ice in January, and I'd much rather deal with that than another burn!

[@career5690]

I had a burn on my finger because of the toaster.

[@misszee007]

I just got burned from cooking oil. I didn’t wash it off and it slowly cooked my skin for 2 hours until I ran more water on it and neosporin. I can still feel the pain and can only on a small scale feel how Kyle felt, to be boiled alive for hours is an awful way to go.

[@marynehra502]

Absolutely horrendous,pain on another level ​@@misszee007

[@katekat1064]

The gentleman narrating the stories has a comforting voice even while delivering something horrible.

[@roberthamlin7168]

THERE are some very evil people out in society. You have to be careful and keep your head on alert.

[@TS-1267]

... Indubitably So Old Bean 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 So Don't Vote For ONE In a Few Months... VOTE 🔵🔵🔵 INSTEAD 😜 17:38

[@DewberryJackson]

But they only target vulnerabe and easy targets not strong people who practice their 2nd ammendmant

[@TS-1267]

@@roberthamlin7168 .... Then VOTE BLUE 🔵 For a Fresh Start and New Beginnings.... Greetings from Saturn 🪐

[@YourLoyalHighness87]

Of all the witnesses, the one that said don’t let them tell you anything else seems like he knows exactly what he saw and heard

[@bradsanders407]

Yeah but all the eye witnesses told a different story. So one says "don't let them tell you different" is cause to declare his story the correct one? Statements like that are usually said after a lie to sell the lie.

[@RoganBits]

@@bradsanders407 Can see it going both ways. Agree with you though; sometimes said by liars; but it's also said by people who are telling the truth, but also feel like they won't be believed. When I had my identity stolen the cops told me I was lying to them because I wouldn't make much eye contact. I just don't make eye contact; probably on spectrum, but it cost me 20,000; and they legit refused to look at the evidence as fact; and instead based their decision on me making eye contact. Do you know how ridiculous that is when you're telling the truth? It sucks, and there's more to that story, they did worse, but point is they based their conclusion not on the bank statements and video evidence, but on eye contact.... The kicker? It's pretty well known people who make eye contact tend to be lying. According to one study, liars showed more eye contact deliberately than truthtellers, whereas gaze aversion did not differ between truth-tellers and lie-tellers. It's why you can't take one identifier and make any conclusion. Need clusters; and you can't have your mind made up before looking at the clusters. Even then; abnormalities exist; and you actually need a baseline for each person you look into.

[@ultraviolettas]

a real new yorker

[@eonianomega]

@@bradsanders407 Different stories but what they all have in common is a fight between the two with Keith as the aggressor.

[@avriel9527]

​@@eonianomega 💯% Ad unless he admits what happened and sincerely REPENTS - he will soon face the ultimate JUDGE!!

[@sherribunn9136]

So....this man was never charged? Not even for manslaughter? How horrific. God bless his family 😢

[@davemccage7918]

Never trust someone named Kevin, and stay 100 yards away from anyone named Keith!

[@Townie7177]

​@davemccage7918 tf are you talking about

[@mattskustomkreations]

Or negligent homicide… something?!

[@koelael2660]

Hopefully this story can be updated with a picture of Kyle, so he can be more properly remembered. I appreciate your great storytelling.

[@dianeandrzejak2221]

I was actually born & raised in Holland, Ohio & I remember when this happened. I personally didn’t know him, but I heard that his family believed that it was murder. Holland is a small community & news travels fast! The whole community was heartbroken. As always, you did a fantastic job covering this unfortunate case. Thank you for sharing it with the rest of the world!

[@LoloO42]

This case should definitely be reopened. What ever happened to the girlfriend? Surely, at some point, she must have realized how dangerous Keith is. Maybe she'll talk now.

[@davemccage7918]

I’ve never met a Keith that wasn’t a dirtbag, that’s an actual fact. I’m sure there’s a decent Keith out there somewhere, but he hasn’t crossed my path.

[@Townie7177]

​@@davemccage7918I know a few nice Keith's

[@mike04574]

they're married and living in florida. Guess that's why she never testified

[@Alejandro-u7q7c]

​@@mike04574Damn, they're perfect for each other then. How can anyone live happily after causing something like that. And keep in mind that we bump shoulders with people like that all the time, without knowing the type of monsters they are.

[@Alejandro-u7q7c]

​@@davemccage7918Every Keith I've ever had contact with hasn't passed the vibe check. Not sure if that actually means anything though.

[@GanjaLady]

I love the beginning where you say "get to know these people before the grief". It is so true we are different people once we have lost a son,brother,nephew 😢😢 and we will never be the same person again 💔 thankyou for your empathy and love ❤️

[@landofthelivingskies3318]

Good lord there is nothing more painful then a steam burn. Like you said, it doesn't damage the nerve endings like a burn does. I can't imagine how Kyle suffered. Rip Kyle.

[@kingsqueen2180]

O0😊😊😊

[@tomthompson2309]

Absolutely horrific way to go. Damn

[@AnneQuiet]

My native New Yorker here in the Bronx gotta say, you're a gem for humanizing the victims. Because I listen to so much true crime podcasts, I've become detached from most of them but you made me feel heartbroken for Kyle. Thank you for reminding me that these are real and everyday people who have gone through something awful, life-changing, and sometimes life-ending.

[@BKLYN_CT]

It's very heartbreaking what this man went through. I don't understand with so many witnesses that man is out there living his life. I hope he can't live with himself and has nightmares every night.. Maybe with you bringing this story out and shedding light on it something good will come out of it There's a God and he sees and hears everything. Thank you

[@EvilIntentions]

Truly hope so. Thank you for that!

[@JME1186]

You speak for victims and their families better than just about every other creator I’ve ever seen. I salute you for the fact you tell stories about us and our people. If you read the comments each video I’m sure you’ve seen at least one direct, personal connection between the story and some commenter’s life. That is as raw as it gets and since every story doesn’t get the exposure it may deserve, the fact you give voice to the voiceless is commendable. Salute brother, rooting for you in all ways. 💯

[@sunnystormy4973]

-definetly ... !-

[@twodots9403]

That poor, poor man - words honestly fail me at how much pain he must have endured. Horrific.

[@Kizzabell]

Some people die in such horrific ways. Its so unfair 😭

[@kimgrace1855]

How could something so horrible happen to this beautiful natured guy, and to have no justice for his killing. 😭💔 Thank you for sharing this with us. Love and Respect to you. ❤

[@stephcarlofc]

The way you show compassion for the victims in your videos should be taught in courses around the world!! You channel is how a True Crime channel should be. Showing care and compassion for the victims. RIP Kyle McGarity. You will not be forgotten!!

[@surfergirl2943]

You do a phenomenal job of covering these stories . You come from a place of compassion but also facts. I very much appreciate your style and your preface . This is one of the best channels I’ve seen in a long time. Keep up the amazing work .

[@EvilIntentions]

Thank you so much!

[@dompbrown5293]

I second and third what surfergirl said!!🙋🏾‍♀️🙏🏾💜💙🫶🏾

[@wisdomseeker3362]

I second, third and fourth his excellence.

[@surfergirl2943]

@@dompbrown5293 haha right !! 👏🏼☺️

[@surfergirl2943]

@@wisdomseeker3362 👏🏼👏🏼☺️😂

[@khoskins6533]

Great way of covering this story. You did an excellent job telling everyone who Kyle was. You tell your stories with such passion. Thank you for sharing the truth about what really happen to this young man.

[@hulagirlhere]

Your kindness and integrity covering these cases keeps me coming back! Well, and the voice 🌺

[@lenevee4925]

I'm so sorry for what happened to Kyle and my heart goes out to his family. Keith was definitely not a friend; he is a murderer who should've been charged and sent to prison. The police did a poor job on this case.

[@lataneyawilliams6156]

This is why we have to be careful and don't trust people around us! That is a horrible mystery story! Keep up! 👍 Thank you

[@nogooddeedgoesunpunishedng3814]

Exactly! This is why I am a loner. I don't hang out with anyone, because I don't trust anyone. This is definitely a painful story to hear. That horrific human being got away with this brutal murder.

[@bradsanders407]

So move into solitude so you don't suffer the 1 in a quadrillion chance your buddy throws you down a manhole which has boiling waist deep water? That's rational.

[@Queenofdacastle]

Doesn’t sound like a mystery to me sounds like he threw the man in there clearly from witness accounts

[@77cpolissaint]

You need to be on network tv 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@abdulhouser]

That part!

[@EvilIntentions]

In time! Lol thank you for the kind words!

[@abdulhouser]

@@EvilIntentions Seriously, you would rival John Walsh on America's Most Wanted! Being that this is the age of social media, your show gets more attention than his anyway!

[@battlestarnomore]

Network tv ruins your soul.

[@YAH-1]

​@@battlestarnomore Agreed 👍🏾

[@josephjohnson5757]

I can't believe the guy got away with it! That's unbelievable, and a true injustice for him and his family! Oh and the story done by that show did a terrible job of explaining the whole story. I believe you did a great job explaining who he was and exactly what took place that night, another great video on your part!

[@Lynn-zx3th]

Kyle sounds like such a great guy! As someone who had a tragedy happen in my immediate family & I lost multiple family members due to violence by one of them. I gotta say your attention & respect you pay to the victims and their family is truly something I wish all true crime KZbinrs would do. Thank you for being so respectful.

[@ICE-vj2xz]

I dont understand WHY someone couldnt make a loop hole on the end of a rope and send it down so Kyle could have put it around him and then been lifted out??? How horrific that poor kid must have felt when NOONE WAS HELPING HIM!! Help was there but noonee offered any kind of solution and just listened to this kids CRIES OF HELP for so many hours!

[@madjack8893]

Exactly omg

[@Floydian4everr]

That's because the people that heard him were all new yorkers that didn't want to "get involved" aka couldn't be bothered to because of how self centered they are there. They think everyone around the world thinks the only city in the US is NYC. Little do they know how quick the rest of Americans are to NOT claim them. Sure, 911 came and suddenly no one could be more American than new yorkers but just listen to gilgo beach serial killer's neighbors complaining about police searching the killer's house and you get a much clearer picture of how newyorkers really are.

[@TheRetroWoman80]

Thank you for always correcting any inaccuracies you find while researching your materials. Dude had deadly insecurities. With how much I absorb true crime, I'm actually surprised he did not serve his girlfriend the same fate as Kyle. Just crazy. He should have done time.

[@blazefairchild465]

Thank you for bringing us Kyles story. Why is there no photo of him , there must HighSchool photos is this what you meant by changing names ? This is a very sad story.

[@LoloO42]

Probably out of respect for his family. It was stated that they asked the press not to use his image. To no avail.

[@resarm5007]

His family asked for privacy. No pictures. And my understanding is the author of the book that was spoken about in the beginning...she was the one who did post mortems and changed names of the people she did autopsies on, for her book. That's how they got referred to as different names. Both Kyle and his murderer were given aliases for the book and then were referred to by those names elsewhere when people spoke about them. It really is VERY SIMPLE. They want to protect people's privacy by changing names and NOT get sued!

[@koelael2660]

@@LoloO42wait, so the press DID use his photos? Was it when he was alive?

[@mike04574]

there's a photo of him on his findagrave

[@amypanddirtytoo1926]

There's too many cases like this. Where cops make snap judgements and don't bother really digging into what happened because it's the easiest way to close a case. The ones who didn't get murdered were drunk, therefore Kyle must have been too. The fact that newspapers will just run with false info tainting cases and cementing that further in investigators' minds whether they want to admit that or not. Funny how all the witnesses that night had the same story, a story that was different from Keith's, but the people that re supposed to protect us just chose to take Keith's side as gospel because....why? He said it three times in a row? If that's all it takes to get away with murder......... Sorry. This case is jusr personal to me. No, I did not know Kyle, but I had a friend exactly like him that was murdered by his GF when she was "drunk" and "didn't remember". Nevermind the fact that she would literally pull knives on him, threaten him with a shotgun, come after us if we were at their house hanging out and someone said something she took waaayyyyy out of proportion. She knew what she was doing, she did it all the time, but it was easier to believe that she was this poor little girl that just got drunk and didn't remember. She stood over him and watched him bleed out.

[@dompbrown5293]

Wowwwwwww!! I’m so sorry that happened to your friend and trust that girl will get her karma!! That ain’t right!! My prayers are with you and his family and friends and any and everyone affected!! Just heartbreaking!!💔 💔🙏🏾

[@amypanddirtytoo1926]

@dompbrown5293 Thanks, appreciate it. She only got 4 years. And it happened almost 20 years ago so even without good behavior she's long released. His name was Jeremy Kosner and it happened in Fairmont, West Virginia. Her name is Amber something. I think it starts with an O and has a Z in it, but tbch I dgaf about her enough to remember her last name. He was always so nice and gentle. Funny. Fun to be around. Always let me in his home when I was with an a hole and was trying to get away. Even tho my bf was his friend and was just the gf of his friend, you know? He was just such a good human being. And Amber was always very much not. Even if she wasn't drunk, she was miserable and no one liked her. I had already left WV by the time of his murder, but I got a call from my ex telling me "Hey. So Kosner died." And the first words out of my mouth were "Amber killed him, didn't she?" Sorry for rambling to a stranger on the internet, this case just brought up memories........

[@SugarandSarcasm]

My condolences ❤

[@BotheredGuest]

​@@amypanddirtytoo1926 that's terrible I'm sorry that happened to your friend. It happens way too often.

[@loopygurl2]

Thank you for covering this and to give Kyle his respect he deserves.

[@alisonp3398]

I live in Jersey and have been to Manhattan many times. I never thought about the steam rising from the manhole covers. Can anyone tell me what the purpose of having boiling water in these channels under the streets? Also, thank you for covering this story, Kyle seemed like a nice young man. I’ve only been following you for a few months since your channel popped up on my home page, but I’m enjoying your content and your voice and tone are perfect for these types of stories. Thank you for bringing them to our attention. ❤

[@DestructiveLioness]

The steam is mainly for heating and cooling buildings throughout Manhattan. It also provides the humidity for museums.

[@sweetzmamakitchen7815]

It’s a steam manhole and when it rains water gets in them. Some manholes have stagnant water thats been in there for years. Although it does have water in them the rain and other factors add to the amount that is in the manholes. I hope I explained that for you. ❤

[@alisonp3398]

@@sweetzmamakitchen7815 thank you very much for the explanation. It’s amazing I’ve never thought of what it was until I saw this video, yet I’ve seen it many times. 🙏

[@alisonp3398]

@@DestructiveLioness thank you so much for responding to my question. I truly appreciate your time 🙏

[@Kris.with.a.K]

𝗝𝗢𝗦𝗘! You are the most empathetically respectful storyteller in this entire genre. And, I should know, with the insane number of TC channels I sub to. Many creators put forth an honorable effort in highlighting the victim. But, you, Jose, have truly mastered the art of leaving the consumer with a clear picture of the WHOLE LIFE of the victim. Keep up the phenomenal job. You are absolutely ensuring these precious souls aren't forgotten. Much love to you! ❤❤❤❤❤

[@jessicacossin6282]

Your voice is soothing. Although I'd never want to end up on your channel, you give these victims a platform that is dignified & humane. Thank you for that.

[@Jammo1978]

This is one of the worst deaths I've heard of in one of these KZbin videos and I watch them everyday 😮RIP hope you're at peace now

[@bagemupbeauty7191]

I’ve been living in this area for a few years and violence is rarely covered by the media in this area i don’t know why (murders,suicides) it’s always swept under the rug 😒

[@susanwilliams4953]

Heartbreaking terror Kyle endured. (Injustice) May he rest peacefully 🕊.

[@marianeuman5741]

Thank you for kindness, humanity and respect you have for Kyle. Especially when there has been misinformation and disrespectful actions thrown around this story.

[@jerkofalltrades5430]

Kieth got away with murder, he should rot in prison.

[@sandraboglio7149]

Thank you for sharing Kyle's story. This was a tough one to watch even without a picture of him. RIP Kyle 🙏

[@chi-townlowend1812]

New York is like my 2nd home and it never fails to amaze me how different it is from other places.

[@dalerimoller272]

I was wondering if or when you’d cover this story. Thank you for sharing this, I’ve never been able to find out much about the poor man who died. Such a horrifying way to go. God rest his soul.

[@CarolAnne-wl6zu]

Why isnt keith serving a LONG SENTENCE IN PRISON!!!??????

[@peachiep2734]

I'm so glad you humanized him. I heard about this horrific event but this is the first channel that tells the backstory and Kyle would have been proud of how you focused on his life and accomplishments... Although Kyle's killer escaped the justice system there's a thing called KARMA that always spin's the bin. Thank you for showing this kindness to his family and friends.

[@mareemadill4643]

These stories are so heartbreaking but Jose tells them respectfully and gets the message across congrats

[@kims7150]

You deliver with such respect when you speak of the victims.

[@ZombieQueen819]

Thank you for your loving words and the love of other people 🥰🥰

[@LaDonaLynnGainey]

I have personally read and watched how the media makes vague statements alluding the community to facts and details of an event where the media downplays the seriousness surrounding the story. YOUR video for this young man cut down so many trees, showing us the true forest. Thank you!

[@oliverhatesgoogle9657]

A wicked world, misery machine, AND evil intentions all uploading today??? WOOHOO!

[@MichelleTurnz]

Those are my top 3

[@kaleahcollins4567]

Mines as well

[@aleayh]

I love evil intentions, and misery machine. I watched them the moment they upload.❤

[@jessicalawton1]

​@aleayh have you ever watched Monsters? The creator/narrator, Jiles, has a really great voice too. Love his story telling as well. 😊

[@muchtested]

@@aleayh You might also like AFC Podcast. I heard about them from the Misery Machine.

[@maquillamelily212]

What a horrible way to die. Rip Kyle 😢

[@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617]

There once was a time when seeing,hearing, reading about something like this shocked me, being a naïve kid back then I really thought there was a level cap on the evil humans are capable of..by time I hit 16 that faith in humanity had almost completely eroded..23 years later misanthropy is something I'll never completely rid myself of and though I've known about this for years, as pretty much always Jose finds details I never heard of, no matter how familiar i am with the story, as always I appreciate u taking the time to make these videos for us man and for bringing to light to many victims who are forgotten or who have never received the recognition they deserve and u always give them respect that always rings sincere to me unlike the countless others that place Money and Fame above Respect For The Victims

[@rosied.f.8309]

Morrisainia

[@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617]

@@rosied.f.8309 oh ok about a mile north ..join me in hoping humanity will one day grow the fuck up.. we've come a long way but I fear we have significantly further than that to go

[@sabrinasjourney]

​​@@antoniokastrocarlisledemel6617keep waiting, we've been doing this for centuries

[@truesavings1988]

Omg that is so horrifying. Poor man.

[@echoone1972]

I really admire the way you make things right for the victims in your narration. Kyle sounded like a really nice guy who befriended someone unworthy of his friendship.

[@asilzednanreh309]

What a sad story. May he rest in peace. You are such an amazing story teller. The details and history you include make your channel one of my favorites

[@EvilIntentions]

Thank you for that!

[@Tiggeez]

Thank you for showing us Kyle as a human with dreams and people that loved him. The perpetrator/s are usually given a spotlight with a backstory 🤦🏻‍♀️ Thanks ❤

[@pinkwakabeagle]

The charges were dropped? WTF ---- Keith had to have family in the NYPD

[@stephanieshowers2656]

First-time viewer, and I must say you did an amazing and respectful job in covering this young mans story! I can not believe how they just dropped this case, and i feel for his poor family. I truly hope they pick up his case again. I honestly hope the family files a few lawsuits against the state, police, street department, and whoever else for slander, misinformation, and whatever else they can think of. It may not go anywhere, but I've learned the more heat you put on these departments, the better chance of them actually doing more, Then maybe his case would be solved and the family will finally get what they actually want justice..

[@ttislandgirl3260]

You can hear the care, interests, kindness, and heartfilled love you speak about each and every episode. Keep up the phenomenal job. ❤coming from Trinidad 🇹🇹

[@RR-wf2ff]

Truly appreciate the caring, considerate and respectful articulation... Gracias Senor Ortiz...

[@kathyjones5085]

Thank you for covering this tragic story in a respectful manner. With every video you narrate I can hear in the way you describe the case that you have empathy, compassion and respect for every one involved. This case was especially sad. Thank you again.

[@jeff-be3sm]

Your narration is well written. The King's English is being abused, people using words that they can't define. I appreciate your narration.

[@theresaconstantini7446]

You did a excellent job with this story. Thanks for personalizing the victim and telling his story. I think his family would appreciate it

[@wisdomseeker3362]

You are a great writer, editor and narrator. I've been subscribed to you for about a year now. Keep going ...you have a bunch of fans !🎉

[@phaedrapage4217]

You always do such a great job of focusing on the victims and not just whatever horrible situation ended their lives.

[@kbsinsanewrld]

I remember hearing about this story on another channel a while back, but not to such great length and detail. We got to learn who Kyle was as a person. That he wasn't just another victim of a horrible crime. Thank you!

[@rosario204100]

You’re a great man ,keeping theyre memories alive.Eye opening and very informative. Thanks ❤💪🏼🎈

[@violetfemme411]

I recently stumbled upon your channel and have been enjoying it very much. You don't sensationize but also don't sugarcoat. I appreciate the work it takes to produce such informative content 💜

[@tarasherman2714]

Excellent coverage, compassion & insite into this victim's life and case. Keep up the good work. This has quickly become my favorite true crime channel - a fellow NYer

[@nreynoldspaint2011]

How many awards have you received??? And how many more just from the channel? The coverage of this story and every other story depicted on the channel are informative, historical, and so very respectful of the victim(s) and their families. I mean, I could go ON and ON about the quality, content perfectly matched with the length of the videos. You are THE very best. Awards are coming your way, Jose!! You are amazing.

[@EvilIntentions]

Thank you for the kind words. I truly appreciate it! Thank you for being here.

[@TSC-hr7ir]

RIP 🙏🌹✝️ KYLE MCGARITY ❤ Not Forgotten always Loved

[@LadyValkyri]

Thank you for always treating the people behind these cases with care and respect. I love you for that. Hugs

[@debbarringer1967]

Thank you for another great and compassionate narration. I love the way you give a bit of history about the places and the people. The cases you cover are very brutal and terrible but you always tell them with the respect they deserve. That is why this is one of my favorite channels.✌

[@kellyc6380]

My prayers are with Kyles family and friends 🙏 I’m so sorry you went through this

[@traciemartin3785]

Thank you for sharing stories that some have never heard of before. Many of the videos you've shown are stories that are new to me & I've never heard, not even in the media. May God continue to bless you, yours & your channel to always succeed. 😊🙏🏾

[@Lina5]

I heard that story though it was a version, it traumatized me. They said it took over 10-15 minutes to die. I appreciate how humane your channel is. Because real stories regardless how horrific they are shouldn’t be heard as if a fictional horror hollywood movie. I will now on remember Kyle tor the heroic soul he was, by saving that dog and dying trying to protect people from themselves. RiP

[@Wanda-b6c]

I was born (1964) and raised in New York City. 88th and 1st in Manhattan. I would walk to school every day while I was in grammar school a block away. Once I started high school, it was a little bit further. 84th and Park Avenue. So I would walk past the subway grates. There was always steam coming up and out of them. It never crossed my mind how or why steam was coming out. It was just a New York thing. Listening to this horrifying story, I finally realize how much the underground sewers and subway are menacing. I’ve never heard a story like this. I’ve been out of NYC for close to 40 years California now And now I worry about my Mom, brother, family and friends who are still there. Who in NYC would ever have to worry about this happening? Amongst other issues…. 😢

[@ONEACCORD-r4f]

I have been for you to drop. Thank you for such a amazing content!😍

[@daisydargan9336]

just found this channel by accident, but wow you are such an amazing narrator. First time ive heard of this tragic story. keep up the quality work

[@thickgoddess1835]

This one was tough. Just the thought of having to go like that in such a grueling way is wild. Wow!! Great video. Prayers to his family❤

[@MiaMia1n0nly]

My heart and prayers go out to his family, friends, and loved ones. Rest in peace Kyle 🤍

[@nancytoothaker3224]

Well done, you've got a talent for focusing on the humanity and communities that are involved in these stories and not the gory details. The scriptwriting is excellent and so is the timbre and pace of the voiceover.

[@mersaidesmiller-breland9472]

Another detail and compassionate piece . You are amazing in your craft I hope you get more recognition. This story is extremely heart breaking and painful. I really wish justice was served . Keith and his girlfriend will have to live with this for the remainder of their lives , knowing what actually happened and not speaking up . My deepest condolences to the family 🙏🏾

[@bebecatanzaro9362]

You’re a gifted narrator, and your story was very well done and respectful of the victims loved ones.

[@Voila1999]

How am i just finding this channel. Ive always taken stories like these to heart and really learned a lot from them. Thank you for your presentation.

[@lanazon4045]

I remember this being on the cover of Newsday 😢 so sad!! -but Thank God you made this documentation and called out the indiscrepancies

[@kgotabody13]

No notification! Thank goodness u popped up in my algorithm! ❤

[@FLyGRRLtOOFLy]

You did an excellent job with this. I left NYC in '96, so I didn't think I would know who this was about. But I remembered this instantly after I played it and said, " The Crown Heights riots." I was a kid. Thank you for filling us in on the outcome. Peace and blessings to those involved. 🙌🏽🙏🏽

[@rebeccaperna5140]

So glad I came across this channel. You are one of my favorites! Keep being the voice for these almost lost NYC souls

[@ladydragon5526]

The only channel and the only video that i'm interested in waiting four and watching even more Thank you again for the love you show for the victims and their families Thank you for creating content with such professionalism It's refreshing to see a contact creator who actually is concerned about their content as opposed to sponsors,likes, or subscribers.. And unlike some other content creator you are deserving of all and more❤❤❤

[@diana6772]

You sure did give me a description of a beautiful man who met his untimely death. Rest In Peace young man!!

[@melissamarioth9554]

Thank you for telling the true story behind this horrible death of this gentleman ❤so sorry to his family 😢😢

[@lislliamriegns]

You have become my favorite KZbinr. Your extreme intricate style of introducing each story not only makes the history of each neighborhood a glimpse view of what once was but gives a real time stamp of what exactly took place. Each story has great inside details and what an amazing way of taking us back and present to what each situation felt. I'm grateful for these stories cause most of them I was not only a kid but I remember them with vivid memories. Especially the 1993 massacre in el barrio which was my neighbors family. Thank you because it seems as if time passes and a lot forget but those of us who love our beloved jungle will never ❤❤❤❤

[@phoenixjnyc]

You do such a terrific job telling the stories. Thank you for sharing his story. RIP Kyle

[@beth244]

Toledo ohio is my home town thank you for the kind and Thorough info about Toledo. also I have watched some of the videos about the cases you cover, I must say you speak with compassion, empathy and sincerity.

[@sharonwhite6126]

Sweet. A bedtime story for me. People wonder how i can do that but it relaxes me before sleep. Could listen to your voice all day. Such a sad sory today. Added to my own sad news. My cancer has spread again. Been a rough week. Thanks for letting me forget for a while though ❤

[@Laurenlee64237]

Sameee … sleep well ❤

[@Chell3y_b]

I’m praying for strength, healing, hope, love, courage, light and fight for you🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@ashleymiles7025]

praying for your strength and healing🙏

[@DonnaGarner-qi7ej]

You always show the upmost respect for the victims in your podcast thank you

[@stacyward4309]

I fell into a round sewer in the middle of my street when I was 6 when the lid flipped. Luckily I quickly put my arms out and was able to hold myself up until my father came running out and pulled me out. I have NEVER stepped on a round sewer lid since 😅😅