Breaking the Cycle: Hate Speech in Pakistani Education | Zeeba Hashmi and Dr. A. H. Nayyar

Join us as we inspect the heart of Pakistani education to confront a pressing issue: hate speech.
Let’s explore its roots, impact and the urgent need for change in order to pave the way for a more inclusive and tolerant educational landscape in the country.
About the Speaker:
Founder of Ibtidah for Education, Zeeba Hashmi is an education research consultant. She has covered and identified barriers to education of marginalized groups and presented papers, case-studies and fact-finding mission reports for different human rights and semi-government organizations.

[@darkstar2871]

Its sad that so less people are there to listen this talk. Pakistan is really going through dark phases.

[@mairajamil001]

0:00 Intro of guests 2:10 Intro to topic 5:50 Zeeba Hashmi - Journey 11:38 Psychological Effects of Hate Speech 17:55 Using Hate Speech as Unification 23:54 Major themes of Hate Speech in Pakistan’s curriculum 26:02 Why prejudiced towards Hindus specifically? 31:14 Document of (Napta? )admitting extremism in curriculum 34:27 Justification of Pakistan’s Existence 38:30 Effects of 1971 42:30 Inclusivity 44:44 Audience Questions / Comments 48:15 Audience: Religious/Sect Discrimination 51:11 Audience: Hate Speech Formula & Solution 1:01:25 Audience Questions:State’s intentions 1:02:29 Audience comment: Social Consciousness of Hate Speech 1:06:14 Audience comment: Experience of a Poli-Sci teacher 1:12:56 Audience comment : Emotional Intelligence 1:18:40 Audience Comment

[@Tug748]

Dear Pakistani brothers & sisters, Aap mano ya na mano. Pakistan ki es halat ka jimmedar aapke diplomates, senior officers, bureacrats, professors, political leaders and Padhe-Likhe old people hai. Ye aaj bhi pak army ke agenda ko support karte hai. Pak army ka agenda hai ki apne country ki awam ko majhabi churan dete rahna hai, school syllabus, media and moulvio ko sath leker (hindu, yahudi, America, kafir hate). Pak army ka yahi tarika hai country mai apne hisab se rule kerne ka jisme wo fake news, videos and dahshatgard tanjim ko promote kerte hai and political interference kerte hai. Sarkar se fund lete hai and Logo mai dar ka mahol paida kerte hai.

[@sanjaybhu0542]

Let me tell u in a simple words its an en born error of Pakistan creation i.e. the hatred doctrine Two nation theory....as an Indian we are thankful to Mr Jinnah for doing that, it has turned out to b a blessing for us😂

[@2010anilshukla]

Absolutely brilliant- but I suspect it will be heard more in India than in Pakistan. As always.

[@neeraj439]

Kuch na ho sakta Pakistan ka... It gets corrupted to the core 😂

[@AlishbaRizviModel]

The issue with this country is this country itself.... How can you expect to build an inclusive society when the country itself was born out of an exclusionary idea?

[@amaa5980]

Don't use India or Hindutva for example. If you don't have even basic knowledge of it, first ask someone who knows about it. invite Kushal Mehra from the Cārvāka podcast

[@ultimateuv]

Chal Maan lete he India me bhi Hindu Muslim conflict h ,,lekin tum hindustan ki ek bhi school text book nahi bata sakte jisme Muslim religion ko demise kiya gaya ho ya religion ko kuch bola ho jabki mein Pakistan ke Kai saare example de sakta hu jaha school ke baccho ki textbook me hindu aur Hindu religion ke baare me me bakwas aur hate padaya jaata h ,,,uska kya ??? Agr India me hindu muslim klme koi conflict hotah to muslim bhi uska jawab deta h ,,aur Hindu side ko kitna nuksaan hota h but Pakistan me koi hindu apne upr hue julm ka jawab de sake ,,iske baar me soch bhi nahi sakta ,,,apni barabi mat kiya karo India se😒😒

[@subramayamrvr8774]

The concepts of kafir momin ummat jihad etc are divisive for society.

[@PR-pu7pv]

Good subject by blackhole Modern education is leading towards prosperity,humanity and human development. But speakers are under external pressure so they are not speaking freely 😊 not elaborating religious education of hate and war..

[@syed1559]

In 70s before General Zia ul Haq in the so called liberal Pakistan, I was in primary school. My parents fearing discrimination told me not tell anyone that you are a Shia. I remembered a teacher telling me that Iran is not Muslim country. The text books openly labelling Hindus as scheming and cunning.

[@abdurrehman9940]

The guest speaker is very clear about the subject and elaborated quite effectively. An informative and enlightening session.

[@DollarBill1981]

Separation of church and state in Pakistan is a prerequisite for social, political, intellectual, and economic progress. This means we must discard the existing obsolete constitution and throw it away into the dustbin of history. A new constitution on secular principles should be made and adopted. But religious extremists, who are politically very powerful, will oppose any effort toward making Pakistan a secular and progressive state for the simple reason that their monopoly over Islam will come to an end. Hence things will get worse and Pakistan will continue moving into the abyss of moral depravity. Sadly, we cannot be sanguine about the future of Pakistan as long as the state defines itself as a religious state.

[@SaeedSiddiqui-j5p]

Secular state mean by law. Doesn’t matter 100% people bias on base of religion race or color.

[@kpdwivedi1672]

The sense of superiority : is ESSENTIALLY is IN- depth INFIRIORITY. a barbarians sense of superiority that he is always right and KAFIR is always wrong. Out of 56 muslim countries, not one has designed/developed a mobile, a car, computer-related software. Does any one has has to say anything more. Most economies survive on oil. Only UAE has developed some good trading system, a very sensible thing to do.

[@krishnavishwakarma1969]

True.. Thats why we should also, deny this Superiority acculturation based hindutva ideology.. and support living being equality based secularism

[@ravindramorey5433]

Hate speech against each other religion race, community is wide spread phenomenon in most of the countries in World but only Pakistan has the distinction of putting it into school curriculum. That is the difference. In India in every school their is a pledge which is also on the front page of many subject books. Just read it.

[@ejazahmed8752]

Very interested discussion . I learn a lot from this plate form. Thank you so much.

[@user-jz6pq4zx3e]

It's just a nutter house. No fixing it.

[@AlphaVlogs-do2hg]

Zeeba madam is looking Gorgeous

[@anujay81]

Very poor attendance 😢

[@subramayamrvr8774]

Please teach your true history culture traditions civilization and DNA.

[@wahtsfgsgwwwsxq]

The idea of `self` by design lives in conflict and creates divisions. - Jiddu Krishnamurthy

[@ramananvenkataraman4594]

Spot on sir. All suffering ,I repeat, all suffering hvtheir roots in the ignorant belief of separate self. There is no separate self

[@amjadhussain2648]

Brilliant session...

[@zahiralishah455]

🌹👍🌹👌🌹🙏🌹

[@user-jn7wv8lw2w]

Good effort,

[@drajayatri]

Nice talk

[@Kenkalsi]

1:19:53 stop bro

[@shivampatil23]

Pakistani & HINDUTVA 😂😂

[@kuk3543]

Now there is same situation in India. We India also like to become a next Pakistan 😂😂😂😂

[@kpdwivedi1672]

For a change, very sensible discussion and articulate one. Every country will have some issues but Govt instead of being referee takes sides with confidence. Low attendance is unfortunate.

[@Kenkalsi]

1:09:10 she is right.