Priest Answers Questions from Protestants

SOCIAL MEDIA
Newsletter: breakinginthehabit.org/newsle...
Facebook: goo.gl/UoeKWy
Instagram: goo.gl/ShMbhH
Podcast: feeds.libsyn.com/511948/rss
INTERESTED IN BECOMING A FRIAR?
United States: goo.gl/MXKb2R
Find your Vocation Director: goo.gl/2Jc52z
SUPPORT THE MISSION
Order my books: amzn.to/386QDpR
Donate Monthly: goo.gl/UrrwNC
One-time gifts: shorturl.at/4CwgV
MUSIC
Epidemicsound.com

[@MuazCannabissativaMCMXCIV]

After 3 years of RCIA, I am going to be baptised with 6 brothers and sisters together next saturday. Please pray for us too 🙏

[@MuazCannabissativaMCMXCIV]

I want to add we are all sons and daughters of Muslims. In Turkey there's no other choice unfortunately but we are regrowing in numbers. Anatolia is the first location where Christianity blossomed, history is repeating itself. Next year more Muslim converts are going to be baptised.

[@humongousd]

praying for you right now!

[@immigrantveteran7340]

God bless🙏✝️🙏

[@johnyang1420]

Welcome home!!!

[@jvdavlim]

🙏🏽

[@TheConfessor]

I went through RCIA at 40.I was baptized Catholic, but not raised in the faith at all. I chose it for myself as an adult after a decade of research. The local parish priest asked me what I knew of the Catholic faith. I told him I'd read the Bible, much of the Catechism, as well as many of the works by Bishop Robert Barron, Peter Kreeft, and your own books Friar Cole, as well as the works of early church fathers and modern figures like Archbishop Fulton Sheen. They were shocked. "So... you just want to be Catholic?" My RCIA process was very accelerated because of this. I was able to show that I understood the faith and what it means to be Catholic. I need the strength of the Church and Christ in my life. I work two jobs, live in an isolated area, and am raising a special needs child that requires 24/7 care. It would have been IMPOSSIBLE for me to be Confirmed if I had to go through the entire formal RCIA process and it is such a wonderful gift that I was given the opportunity and grace to be Confirmed in Christ.

[@RonSwanson2024]

My conversion was very similar to OP, however I chose to spend an entire year in RCIA simply because I enjoyed the process. Between the OP and myself, I hope other candidates/catechumens will recognize that the Church is more flexible than you might imagine.

[@salusindomino]

read Peter Kwasnieski

[@growtocycle6992]

The communion point falls down if give it even a moments thought. The Catholics have so many different states of sin, different beliefs, absence of sacraments and many don't even believe in the real presence! Yet they all enter into the same comminution, because it's about accepting Christ! Not about us "getting it right"!

[@anthonyw2931]

wow. God be with you, always.

[@scarletmunchkin]

I joined the church at Easter after many decades of trying to. Its my home. My home sweet home.

[@BigHossHackworth]

I’m not a Christian but a coworker of mine that I respect quite a bit is catholic. He represents y’all well.

[@LittleWaffle]

It's so cool that you watch this channel even if you're not a Christian. I like your attitude ❤

[@alexabihabib8215]

Thanks for your open mind and for watching videos like this even if they aren’t from your worldview and tradition. We could all learn from such an example. May God bless you and your coworker

[@johnyang1420]

Join us! Take RCIA!

[@CybermanKing]

I hope whoever your coworker is will continue to pray for you and offer you support in all your trials.

[@maaxt]

I feel more joyful in my faith with every one of your videos, Father.

[@antoniosanjurjo8442]

Just did confirmation in May and so very happy to be Catholic. I give thanks to God for bringing me to his church.

[@jerryglisson8068]

Praise God

[@antoniosanjurjo8442]

@@jerryglisson8068 Praise him indeed.

[@LittleWaffle]

Welcome to the family ❤️

[@sneaky.23]

@@antoniosanjurjo8442 Yeah, welcome, we hope you will live a better life.

[@Redwarfa]

Where is confirmation mentioned in the bible

[@jaedynruli]

Id love a video 'answering questions from ex-catholics'

[@leoyuri8938]

There are no "ex-Catholics". There are Catholics and non-Catholics. Those who once called themselves Catholics, but today no longer call themselves Catholics, never were, in fact.

[@russellmiles2861]

Id love a answer questions from the Bible such as why was Genesis 18 22 changed, why referred to 10 Commandments when there is no list of 10 Commandments in the Bible - there are over 600, Mark 4 & 5 have tales of Jesus eventful crossing of a sea and then miracle of feeding 5000 (twice) - this is a rendition of Moses crossing red sea and miracle of mana from heaven not an historical account - if it were why were the disciples so lame as to wonder how to feed the 5000 the second time. I don't know, perhaps just like the first time. St Paul says he learnt of the Eurusist from revalation not by any oral tradition - so the Last Supper seems like a narrative invention. And many more. Why evade these elementary matters in the Bible. And in John Lazarus is suppose to be immortal - why can't we ask him about these things.

[@marvahoeckelman2539]

A big question I would want to ask them is, why did you leave?? I would like. To see if my observation in the past would be confirmed. That observation is that most of the time they leave because of another human and not because of faith questions or their relationship with God.

[@kevinkelly2162]

Like 'how can you be a member of any organisation let alone a church that has so far paid out $3 billion to victims of it's priests?'

[@davidsandrock7826]

@@russellmiles2861 Exodus 34:28 (KJV) And he was there with the LORD forty days and forty nights; he did neither eat bread, nor drink water. And he wrote upon the tables the words of the covenant, *the ten commandments.* Deuteronomy 10:4 (KJV) And he wrote on the tables, according to the first writing, *the ten commandments,* which the LORD spake unto you in the mount out of the midst of the fire in the day of the assembly: and the LORD gave them unto me.

[@cy7025]

Hello Fr. Casey. I would like to share our story with you concerning our wedding (40 years ago). I was raised Methodist (baptized) and my husband Catholic. We were married in the Methodist church. My husband received a Dispensation from the Canonical Form of Marriage, Matrimonial Dispensation, and signed a Declaration and Promise for the Catholic Party. Approved by the Tribunal of the diocese we were married. Both our children were baptized, received First Holy Communion, and were confirmed in the Catholic Church. 20 years after our wedding I went through the RCIA process and was confirmed Catholic on Holy Saturday 2003.☺

[@amytheoptimist]

The best line of the entire video is: "Priests have terrible memories. Do you really think we're holding on to this stuff?" LOL, I love it! Thanks for the fantastic content, as always, Fr. Casey!

[@crusadertobias]

“The Eucharist is the sacrament of love: it signifies love, it produces love. The Eucharist is the consummation of the whole spiritual life.” - St. Thomas Aquinas

[@8shizzle]

Was Thomas Aquinas with Jesus from the beginning to the end ? Was he an apostle ? Of course not . Why listen to him ?

[@cizzorzsonandy9773]

Sh you weren’t an apostle, we don’t want to hear what you have to say shhhhhhhh

[@franekcinhcak4040]

I once heard a story from a priest that had a vision during mass. He said that he felt as his soul left his body and was taken to the place where the Eucharist is stored (I dont know the name, it's tabernakulum in Polish) and he saw a marriage bed inside.

[@m_d1905]

​@@franekcinhcak4040 The English word is tabernacle. Not terribly different from the Polish at least to my eyes.

[@russellmiles2861]

@@8shizzle St Thomas Aquinas has a significant fan base. He also justified heretics being executed, hated women, Jews. His flawed reasoning for God actually logically proves Marcionist was right. What's not to like.

[@TheMarkJoergensen]

This will probably get lost in the comments, but thank you. You’ve helped solidify me in my faith and helped me beginning on my journey towards Christianity. Thank you. I guess my story matches most people who grew up secular in the west, a lot of edgy young adult atheism to spiritual wandering to faith. Thanks for explaining and spreading God’s love. It really helps me with my own doubts and reservations.

[@jwilsonhandmadeknives2760]

your comment is not lost, and neither are you. welcome home.

[@procerusgigas]

I am just now taking that path, rediscovered Jesus recently. Still have a lot of questions and doubts, but I did make the first step.

[@jeremiahong248]

​@@procerusgigas you might like to check out Catholic Answers website or KZbin as well as ex Protestant pastors who became Catholics. They have produced vast apologetics materials.

[@shellyannstokes]

I left the church at 19 and came back in my late 20s. I had a ton of questions. My advice is stay close to God. If you are truly searching he will show up. It happened to me. He will tend to show up in a way that you understand and he knows you. 20+ years later I’m so grateful I never walked away from him. I’ll be praying for you both. It’s good to ask questions. Oh maybe too you might want to look into a spiritual director if you become Catholic. They can help answer questions and guide you. Know you are a beloved child of God and May he guide you on your Journey 🙏🏼🙏🏼😃❣️

[@mitchellosmer1293]

@@shellyannstokes quote-----I left the church at 19 and came back in my late 20s. I had a ton of questions. My advice is stay close to God. If you are truly searching he will show up. It happened to me. He will tend to show up in a way that you understand and he knows you. 20+ years later I’m so grateful I never walked away from him... unquote Then maybe you can answer my questions. WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD RESTED on the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD BLESSED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD SANCTIFIED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD NAMED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD DECLARED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK as HIS HOLY DAY to make that day special??? Book, chapter and verse!!!!

[@fatesrequiem]

Layperson here but I wanted to touch upon “How do parishioners have the courage to make confession and continue to go to church?” 1) Faith. In the seal of confession and the power of the sacrament 2) Confession is a gift. I have walked out of confession with a complete weight removed from my shoulders that I did not even realize I was carrying. I have felt that lift from me and been moved nearly to tears of gratitude for the grace of the Lord. It’s different than simply “talking to God” because you have to GIVE of yourself. You have to approach with humility and openly verbalize your faults and sins. You have to make your ego, pride, and shame into sacrifice to the Lord, and for that sacrifice you receive absolution.

[@LittleWaffle]

Well said ❤

[@Griff_Files]

I did RCIA for around 3 months having been a protestant all my life. My RCIA instructor spent a fair amount of time questioning me on my beliefs, my understanding of the Catholic beliefs and helping to discern any conflicts I may not realize that I had. She ensured I was comfortable in my knowledge as we studied the Catechism, every step along the way making sure I understood the finer details. Then she asked me shortly before Easter if I was ready to join, she was being entirely sincere and reminded me that it had to be my choice for timing and that the priest could simply get the bishop to come down when I was ready if Easter was too soon - however, I was ready and able to join that Easter. It was something I had wanted for years and I was still surprised at my emotions on the big day of my initiation. I knew it was a huge deal, but I underestimated how much it would elate my heart, I nearly choked up when the priest had me read aloud my commitment.

[@beautyamongashes8378]

As a life-long Lutheran whose grandfathers are both pastors, thank you… this was really helpful!

[@bradyconant5125]

Thank you for your video! As a protestant myself, it's nice to hear directly from a catholic vs learning about catholicism from other protestants. It's been eye-opening!

[@Kevin_Beach]

Saints are our friends in high places.

[@johnbrowne2170]

Saints in the Bible were believers, living people who wrote each other. The RCC perverted the word.

[@Kevin_Beach]

@@johnbrowne2170. No. First of all, ALL the apostolic churches - the Catholic Church, the Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Churches, and the Assyrian Church of the East - all have the same usage of the word "saint" or its equivalent in different languages. "Saint" (From the Latin word "Sanctus") simply means "Holy". When we refer to somebody as a saint, we mean that they are recognised as holy. Hence, The "Holy apostle Paul" can be sensibly referred to as "Saint Paul". There are about 15 uses of the word "saints" in various epistles of Paul in the New Testament. For example, in 1 Corinthians 1:2 there is the phrase (in Greek) "... kletois (h)agios". which means "called to be holy". That is how the NT usage started: Church members were referred to as people whom Christ had called or summoned to be holy. In some later passages, the phrase was abbreviated to simply "... (h)agios". It is a misunderstanding to interpret these usages as meaning that "saints" was just another word for "believers". It carried the sense of a vocation to holiness, which (let's face it) not all believers seem to have fully followed. Those who have, we call Saints.

[@blaisemacpherson7637]

And they are just cool. The medals. The feast days. The patrons. I don't know your birthday but if I know your name I'm likely to call you in your feast day.

[@Kevin_Beach]

@@blaisemacpherson7637. [Grin} Well, the feast day of St Kevin (Caoímhín) is on 3rd June - yesterday. He was an Irish monk-hermit, who lived in the mountains of County Wicklow, Ireland. I've seen and prayed at his hermitage.

[@blaisemacpherson7637]

@@Kevin_Beach good timing then. I tricked everyone into celebration my fear day by having my son the day before. My son was born Feb 2. Also Blaise isn't my baptized saint my mom actually changed my name (not legally) when I was like 9 long story but I've always celebrated been Feb 3.

[@willpollock980]

We don't actually pray *to* saints. We ask them to pray for us. Its a difference I think is very important to stress. The second commandment and all.

[@CubeInspector]

No, we very much do. Stop letting Protestants who don't know what pray even means make you feel bad about the Faith. Pray literally means go petition, or to request. We are praying to them, to pray to God for us. Protestants confuse it with worship because they don't truly worship God. They offer no sacrifice. I'm not sure what "thou shalt not use the name of the Lord thy God in vain" has to do with this either. You seem to be referencing the protester 10 commandments, whish theor 2nd is part of the actual 1st. And doesn't apply because we don't believe saints have any powers themselves.

[@wlinden]

To misquote Chesterton, democracy objects to a man being disenfranchised by accident of birth. Christianity objects to him being disenfranchised by accident of death.

[@emmib1388]

how do you speak with them if the are no longer on this earth? Humans in Heaven or Hell cannot know what is going on here on Earth...so how do they get your message?

[@vanson311]

Dear Father Casey, I am proud to be a catholic because my father was the one who led a life just like an atheist , that means he hardly ever would go to Church , but I still remember once I was sick , he prayed to God and this impacted me profoundly. My grandparents , they do not know much about what is written in the Bible but they set a good example to me. I had not confessed for 16 years but I received the Eucharist without knowing that I did not deserve to have Jesus in me, now I would go to Priest for making confession every month and I feel like I am the best version of myself in Jesus Christ. God bless you Father

[@denisealfaro915]

Amén 🙏 what a wonderful story. I live in Silverspring Maryland and my kids where disciples of brother Casey. The Catholic Church is the fullness of faith, we have everything.

[@vanson311]

@@denisealfaro915 Amen

[@mitchellosmer1293]

@@denisealfaro915 quote----The Catholic Church is the fullness of faith, we have everything.. unquote Nope--But do you have the truth???? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD RESTED on the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD BLESSED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD SANCTIFIED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD NAMED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD DECLARED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK as HIS HOLY DAY to make that day special??? Book, chapter and verse!!!!

[@xaxierxerxes4563]

​@@mitchellosmer1293where is the word bible in the bible? Where is the passage everything should be in the bible? where is the passage bible is the ultimate authority for 40 k up denomination? Where is the passage that everyone can create a church or denomination in the bible? Where is the passage that everyone can read and interpret privately the bible? Where in the bible that you can correct the teachings of the catholic church? Where is your doctrinal and scriptural authority in the bible?

[@mitchellosmer1293]

@@xaxierxerxes4563 quote---where is the word bible in the bible?.. unquote IT IS obvious you do NOT know the meaning of :bible". Definitions from Oxford Languages · Learn more Bi·ble /ˈbīb(ə)l/ noun 1. the Christian scriptures, consisting of the Old and New Testaments. "verses from the Bible" Similar: the (Holy) Scriptures Holy Writ the Good Book the Book of Books New English Bible King James Bible Authorized Version Revised Version Good News Bible Jerusalem Bible Geneva Bible Gideon Bible -----A collection of authoritative writings. -----quote----Where is the passage everything should be in the bible?. unquote ****Hebrews 4:12 Indeed, the word of God is living and effective, sharper than any two-edged sword, penetrating even between soul and spirit, joints and marrow, and able to discern reflections and thoughts of the heart), or seen implicitly through its lens. *** Deuteronomy 17:14-20 states that we “shall not turn away from God’s Word, not to the right or the left”. ***Psalm 1:2 and Joshua 1:7-8 says that “the righteous person dwells on the Word of the Lord day and night”. ***Deuteronomy 8:3 states that “we do not live on bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God”. ***Proverbs 30:5-6 states: 5 Every word of God proves true; he is a shield to those who take refuge in him. 6 Do not add to his words, lest he rebuke you and you be found a liar. - -----I will ask you, which NO ONE has replied to: Who's other writings does GOD tell us to accept as the truth??? QUOTE FROM the BIBLE!!!!) Remember these words from Jesus: John 14:6 NIV - Jesus answered, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. Since HE IS THE TRUTH, then when a church preaches their version of the truth, who is the truth??? Jesus or the "Church"??? >>>>>>>> Sola Scriptura, or “God’s Word alone,” maintains that the Bible is the highest source of authority in a Christian’s life, the final court of appeal (though not the only authority: the Bible itself mentions governmental and other authorities). Sola fide, or “faith alone,” affirms that justification-being made right with God-comes only through faith in Jesus. Sola gratia, or “grace alone,” says sinners are saved as an unearned gift of God’s grace, “not as a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Eph 2:8-9). Sola Christo (“solus Christus”), or “Christ alone,” emphasizes the exclusivity of Jesus’ role in salvation: “No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). And soli Deo gloria, or “to the glory of God alone,” says that the purpose of creation, salvation, and everything-including our goal as Christians-is the glory of God, “that God may be all in all” (1 Cor 15:28). I can certainly understand why the roman Catholic does not agree with scripture . It would have to get rid of some , not all , some doctrines that are totally false. Let me add this; let's say a man presents to you an old parchment dated at 30AD. On that parchment states Mary IS NOT the mother of Jesus. Accept as true? Why or why not??? Same parchment states Jesus is NOT the Messiah. You accept as true???? Why or why not? Same parchmant says Jesus is NOT the son of God. You accept as truth??Why or why NOT??? My point' Just because it is written, DOES NOT MAKE IT TRUE!! What wil you use to prove those statements are false?? The word of men??? Why not the WORD of God??? >>>> quote----Where is the passage that everyone can read and interpret privately the bible? ... unquote Where in the passage that the Catholic church has authority to read and interpret the bible??? ---quote----Where in the bible that you can correct the teachings of the catholic church? .. unquote God!!! 2 Timothy 3:16 All Scripture is inspired by God and is useful to teach us what is true and to make us realize what is wrong in our lives. It corrects us when we are wrong and teaches us to do what is right. ---quote----Where is your doctrinal and scriptural authority in the bible?... unquote Where is your doctrinal and scriptural authority in the bible?

[@BillTxn]

Interesting point about RCIA and committed non-Catholic Christians. When my wife and I were preparing for marriage ten years ago, she was Protestant and had lived a very Christian life. She elected to go through RCIA (no alternative was suggested) and learned much about the church, partly because our parish has a vibrant and effective RCIA program that she fully embraced. Today she is a lay leader in two liturgical ministries as we joyfully serve our parish community.

[@nicktheolive7133]

you got me to start my rcia father, 1 year ago. after 25 years of protestanism. completed and here i am back here, about to bring another friend to join this year's rcia.

[@LittleWaffle]

Wouhouuuu! You're doing great, so happy for you and your friend. I wish you both all the best ❤

[@mitchellosmer1293]

WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD RESTED on the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD BLESSED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD SANCTIFIED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD NAMED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK to make that day special??? WHERE in the Bible does it say GOD DECLARED the FIRST DAY of the WEEK as HIS HOLY DAY to make that day special??? Book, chapter and verse!!!!

[@Vhk11]

Regarding confession, it is hard to allow yourself to be vulnerable in front of a priest, but as humans, it makes a huge difference to verbally express your sins to the representative of God. When I think about how great God is, I cannot look at him in the eye. When I think about how much he loves me, I break down in tears.

[@theholyminion_]

I started to see the discomfort I feel, and ‘embarrassment’ or shyness of opening up and being vulnerable like that in front of a priest as part of the penance for the sins I'm confessing. That and the whole garbage man analogy helped me out (just like a garbage disposal man just takes the trash out without going through it, so too the priest is just throwing out the trash into the ocean of God’s mercy)

[@Redwarfa]

That is why you pray to jesus who was a man and was tempted

[@theholyminion_]

@@Redwarfa you do both. In James 5:16, it says, “Therefore, confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another so that you may be healed.” In John 20:23, Jesus breathes on the apostles and says, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them.” When you’re sick as well as praying for healing, you go to a doctor and get medicine. When you need therapy, as well as casting your cares on the Lord, you also talk things through with a therapist. So too, when you have sinned in as much as you talk to Jesus about it, you also go to the sacrament of reconciliation that Jesus himself instituted. 🙂

[@Redwarfa]

@@theholyminion_ no Jesus said :no one comes to the father but through me I don't need my sins forgiven by a man,not when I can go straight to god.only Jesus can forgive

[@Redwarfa]

@@theholyminion_ we do pray for one another but we do not pray to the dead Who are the saints in the new testament?

[@matthewlucas3905]

I am glad you brought all of this up. My local parish is currently about to lose their Priest (retirement) and was not willing to put me through RCIA until a new Priest is appointed. The next closest Parish is only 15 minutes away, and the Priest spoke with the friend that has led me to want to convert. The Priest has assessed me and will only be doing a small course with me over the course of the next few weeks for my confirmation. Please pray for me in this time. Let’s become one Church ❤

[@user-hi6zn2bd2l]

(?!) I don’t understand how/why they would deny a sacrament (in my observation, usually someone other than the priest does the RCIA, so it seems like they could start).

[@rdowdy]

Thank you, Friar Casey. Too many videos on this topic turn out to be "Catholic beats up Protestant strawman". There was none of that here. You seem to understand the concerns Protestants have, and did a great job of showing that the Catholic viewpoint is reasonable too, without ever implying Protestants are dumb for ever seeing it differently. This is the sort of thing that is needed to promote greater understanding between Christians.

[@user-uj8xi9ww3p]

Catholics see all Protestants as their “separated” Christian brethren within the Body of Christ. That is not always the reverse and I suspect many think we believe that as well.

[@duanewoodson9804]

That still means JESUS never selected any Protestant to become and Apostle. So a Protestant is not able to partake in the Eucharist that is present in the Catholic Church. There were no Protestant present at Pentecost. JESUS never told Martin Luther to start the reformation!

[@foodforthought8308]

​@duanewoodson9804 let's have some humility. These are really complex issues.

[@duanewoodson9804]

@@foodforthought8308 Really modern person. Are you really saying that these modern times are more complex as compared to creation of the world. This is so sad. we modern people have all the comforts of electricity and shelter and refrigerators and gasoline cars and airplanes and army and you think we have it harder than our ancestors.

[@foodforthought8308]

@@duanewoodson9804 I'm talking about humility between Christians.

[@wjtruax]

Thank you, Fr. Casey, for this great presentation! I am an older convert (technically “reconciled”) to the Church last year after 40+ years as a devout Protestant. My journey to Rome took almost three years - the first two of which included intense research and internal spiritual struggle. When the Holy Spirit finally convicted me of my need to become Catholic, I was “ready.” I didn’t want to wait to participate in the Eucharist. However, a major part of my move to Rome was a final acceptance of ecclesiastical authority - submission to more than my own opinions. Our local priest significantly truncated my RCIA requirement and actually asked me to consider teaching a Catholic apologetics class after Confirmation (which I’ve done). Just today, after our morning prayer time, I was going through parts of Lumen Gentium with my wife who is still Anglican. In layman’s terms, I see the Catholic view of other Christian traditions in terms of professional baseball, or soccer (football) outside North America. Catholicism is the “Major Leagues” or the “Premier League.” Other traditions are still professional expressions of the sport, but at lower (“minor leagues” or “developmental league”) level. You could be the most skilled player in the world in that particular sport, but if you remain in the lower levels, you simply can never experience the fullness of the highest level of the sport. I like analogies, but they all fall short in some fashion, so I do not claim it to be perfect, but hope it is somehow useful. Grace & peace.

[@dat_boy_v]

The comment section is a living catholic community. I’m proud to be catholic. Thanks a lot Padre. Your channel has been the best discovery of the year to me

[@sixAdam22]

I was born and raised catholic by my parents and grandparents… I was baptized and did my 1st holy communion, but never got my confirmation done… at the age of 29, my mother and father converted to the baptized church. I was pretty heartbroken about it ..I felt like everything I believed in was a lie .. I knew in my heart that I had keep my faith in the church.. and I did.. that same year I got confirmed at St. Joseph’s Catholic Church .. I did so because I wanted to show my parents that I will kept my faith in the Catholic Church.. I don’t ever regret my decision.. I love my catholic faith ..

[@emmib1388]

you love your faith -- but do you love Jesus? Do you have a relationship with Him?

[@RacoonsAreJustForbiddenCats]

I’ve been watching your videos for almost 1-2 years now. Initially I started watching for the faith based comedy approach you seem to be able to give off (useless catholic facts, etc). Informative but funny. I want you to know I’m seriously considering Catholicism over my Protestantism.

[@kaizer4506]

I haven’t seen your stuff before but I really appreciate how concisely and compassionately you answered these questions

[@user-ym9mv4df3n]

You're great! Keep up the good work.

[@ARhere]

Your answer to the question in 7:57 made me laugh. “No, but sort of yes…”

[@richterbelmont04]

My biggest problem with Catholicism is the doctrine of papal infallibility. How can someone be viewed as infallible when he obviously isn't?

[@winstoncottage344]

Honestly, just look up the phrase online - even somewhere like Wikipedia and you will have a much clearer understanding of what it means and how and when it applies. It is not a blanket coverage of everything the Pope says or does, it is quite specific in its intent and execution.

[@richterbelmont04]

@@winstoncottage344 He already answered my question in one of his newer videos, still, thank you

[@josiahstewart8276]

Thank you Father. As a current Protestant, this was amazing.

[@Iris-bn1xw]

As an Anglican, this was very clarifying. I am not converting to Catholicism but love to know more like this!

[@ThomasBoyd-tx1yt]

Awesome. Brilliant content. God bless you Father Casey 🙏🙏🙏.

[@michaelblair5566]

I was a Protestant from 1972 until 1986. I completed RCIA in 1987 and have been a server, from 1987-1991 then since 2022.

[@CE24164]

I love this video because it helped me and gave me the material to talk to my protestant friend about some of this stuff when she asks! Thank you, Father!

[@LuisSanchez-dy5vl]

WOOO I love this! thank you for such amazing education!

[@samanthaduggan9002]

Excellent. Some really great answers. Especially that last one about being flexible about conversions of other Christians and not making people jump through unnecessary hoops!

[@wackypacky6917]

This is a copy of my original question from the community post; Hi Fr. Casey! Before I begin, I would like to preference that while these questions are a bit loaded, they don’t come from a malicious place, rather out of genuine curiosity. I’d also like to thank you for helping me deepen my love for the Eucharist! 1. If you seek to unite all churches, how would female protestant clergy members be addressed? 2. I’ve read in a pastoral letter (Diocese of Arlington) that says that while Catholics should strive to love and walk along with transgender people, they shouldn’t use preferred pronouns or names. How can you begin to build a bridge between two people when one feels their very identity is being assaulted?

[@BreakingInTheHabit]

1. This is not a possibility within the Catholic Church, as the issue has been deemed settled by John Paul II. 2. There is a lot we still need to learn. We need to walk and listen, but I don't think there is any room to budge from the Catholic side on the nature of the human person or the relationship between gender and sex.

[@Laurelin70]

But why they feel that?

[@TheMichaelMonroeDoctrine]

My new sound bite is asking people if they’re Christians or Protestants, because usually they ask if I’m Christian or Catholic.

[@oliviaedejer6126]

God bless Fr.

[@ssgsorrels]

I was baptized Catholic this year, from being unbaptized my whole life. But it took me calling my local diocese to actually get a church to respond. I do like that being Catholic takes work, but it'd be nice if it was at least easier to find somewhere to get started

[@benevenuto9794]

so well done Father. Thank you. Each question and answer would be a great super-bowl commercial.

[@BreakingInTheHabit]

You got 30 million dollars I can borrow?

[@JackRosetta]

​@@BreakingInTheHabit FATHER, WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, DO YOU REALLY THINK YOUR HALF-HONEST VIDEOS IMPRESS OUR LORD? Maybe it makes your freemason friends giggle when they bow to allah the dragon. FOR THE GOOD OF YOUR SOUL I BEG YOU TO TURN YOUR LIFE AROUND AND ACTUALLY SERVE GOD WITH YOUR WHOLE HEART

[@johnanthony8053]

I am so glad the private revelations was mentioned! And I hope my Catholics and protestants know about this! Because it was very comforting for me even as a catholic when I was questioning my faith to know what not devoting to certain “saints stuff” does not make me less of a catholic or those “saints stuff” does not define who I am as a catholic. And to be a catholic, I just need to believe in every word of the creed which I believe most Protestants do as well. That’s all, the catholic faith is that simple. Of course, after knowing that this is the right faith and right church for me, it is easier (still difficult at times) to go with different devotions. I also believe that most Protestant’s should think about the Eucharist and other dogmas of the church when questioning their own faith instead of the easy argument about Mary or devotions to saints that even me as a catholic think about. I would never leave the church because that’s where the source and summit of my faith is. I would never want to part from the Eucharist. And I hope more Protestants would explore reasons to join the catholic faith that their faith cannot provide or lack (e.g. Eucharist, the flaws of sola script) instead of reasons not to join the faith. I believe this is the work of the devil and attack on the Catholic Church and Eucharist.

[@setremnevets]

As an evangelical, thank you for content like this. So many of my evangelical brothers and sisters have very rough views on our Catholic brethren. Videos like this bring clarity and good conversation.

[@christinebullard2884]

I'm not Catholic. I've believed sola scriptura .(please forgive my spelling.) What you said about the many years previous to the Bible being available has caused me to reconsider. Never ever thought I'd say that!

[@winstoncottage344]

The Church begat the Bible, not the other way around...

[@CubeInspector]

Remember, Christ left a Church who gave us a Bible, He didn't leave a Bible that gave us a Church. The fact is Christ established a Church and Gabe that Church the authority to bind and loose (Matthew 16: 18-19) and the authority to teach. 2 Thessalonians 2: 14 tells us that we have to hold to traditions that have been taught [by the Church], whether by word or epistle. John likewise speaks of teaching more beyond what he wrote in his epistles. The Bible never gives us a table of contents it was up to the Church guided by the Holy Ghost to do that (ironically Protestants removed books, added words, and fumbled the translations giving entirely new meanings to verses) The fact there are 8 arch protestant sects each with different interpretations is pretty condemning of Sola scriptura And most condemning of all, there is not 1 verse that says it in all of scripture.

[@BeardnScars]

I left the church after being a catechist and seeing the Marian order in the curriculum and how they wanted us to teach the divinity and her apparitions in Portugal one day. I had just started reading the Gospels and the letters from Paul before this and there were too many inconsistencies between what the Bible said about false teachings and the church wanting me to go through with teaching about this. I chose the Scripture over this earthly position of honor as a Catechist. On my way out after quitting there was a lady in the hallway brushing off the golden artifacts on a table that would be hung up. It was like the final confirmation that I was doing the right thing. Yeah gold everywhere, but teaching BS.

[@ChaosOmnimon]

I was baptized lutheran; my mom is a baptist, and my dad is a non-practicing lutheran. I went to church when I was younger with my paternal grandparents but stopped going when they stopped. My journey began sometime during my sophomore year of university. My choir director from high school reached out and asked if I wanted to sing with his church choir; I said sure and sang on Palm Sunday ~2014. Slowly, I came to understand the Catholic faith. This took years of on and off singing with the choir. I was confirmed (Saint Robert Bellarmine) and received First Communion on the Sunday of the Most Holy Trinity this past year. I didn't go through RCIA/OCIA, father and deacon were super helpful. When I truly started to pray and reflect on coming home, the story of the prodigal son kept recurring. If one is ready to come home, they will, and we should not ridicule or chastise, for we were once like the hedonistic son. If someone does look down upon you for not being Catholic from cradle, remind them of the prodigal son and what the father did.

[@LittleWaffle]

Pretty cool video ! As a Catholic, I'm always curious to learn more about how other Christians express their faith, what we agree on, where we diverge, and how to help each other grow closer to God. Thank you for the work you do here ❤

[@michaelaugusto2538]

As an Anglican (Anglo catholic), I really appreciate how you answered the questions involving Anglicans. You didn't bash us like the social media comments tend to but displayed respectful and humble disagreement. Of course I understand we have our differences on our views of Anglican orders, but nonetheless there is a relationship to be had with each other. Even if it's not full communion. God bless you Father!

[@CubeInspector]

You guys "ordain" women ypu have no Holy Orders. The relationship is pretty of come home and renounce your errors.

[@michaelaugusto2538]

@@CubeInspector yes some of Anglicanism commits this error. Most Anglicans globally are located in Africa and are quite conservative, including not ordaining women. There's been plenty of ecumenical dialogue between sects of Anglicanism and the Roman Catholic Church, and that is not how the conversations went. So please keep running your mouth.

[@connors3356]

You should do questions from me, the watermelon wolf. Question mumber 1: What is the IRS question number 2: why is the irs auditing me question 3: what cereal is better mini wheats or mega wheats

[@ahbeng888]

Love your comments on RCIA/OCIA Fr Casey. I am glad I wasn’t received into full communion via a Latin Rite parish as I would have been forced to go through the entirety of RCIA even though I had been a Christian for three decades at that point in time. Instead via the Ordinariate, my priest had a chat with me over a number of weeks to determine what I already knew about the faith and what I already had assented to in Catholic doctrine and we then planned for the appropriate week for me to be received into the Church. All that was required of me was to ensure that I had my first confession before that Sunday.

[@AncientNovelist]

I grew up Lutheran and converted on June 3, 1985, without going through RCIA. I was overseas from 1983-85 (Peace Corps, Togo, West Africa) and corresponded monthly with the associate pastor at the Catholic Church I had been attending since late 1982. When I returned stateside, I had already exchanged several hundred pages of correspondence with the priest and he welcomed me into the Church days after my return. I've never looked back. I enjoy the morning and evening office every day and I've written over 120 hymns and authored 7 novels which are heavy in Catholic thought. There's so little difference anymore between Lutherans and Catholics.

[@diamondlou1]

What are the names of your novels? Always looking for good Catholic writing.

[@crush42mash6]

Always love your respectful demeanor, of course I subscribe along time ago Thank you, father for always speaking and answering our questions

[@Joelexmachina]

Beautifully Put. Keep up the good work😊

[@JackRosetta]

NAME ME A SINGLE PROTESTANT CHURCH NOT BUILT BY MAGICIANS!!!

[@davemiller6055]

Fr. Casey, can you explain the Catholic view of, and relationship to: 1) The Eastern Orthodox Church 2) The Oriental Orthodox Church 3) The Church Of The East 4) The Old Catholics

[@user-uj8xi9ww3p]

We see them as Authentic Apostolic Churches but not in Union with the Universal (or Catholic) magisterium of the Church all in Union with the Successor to Peter (or the Pope). Most people when they think Catholic, they think Roman. however, the Universal (Catholic) Church has 23 different rites (or Apostolic) Churches in Union. Only one of this rites is “Roman”

[@CubeInspector]

1. Schismatic heretics 2. Schismatic heretics 3. Schismatic heretics 4. Schismatic heretics. We don't have a relationship with any of them beyond welcoming them to return to communion with Christ's Church and renounce their various heresies.

[@sinkorswimstars]

I was a willing convert to catholicism. Coming from a Dutch reformed background, Calvinist, I was familiar with many theological concepts, albeit, I was not well informed on catholic church history or practice. I reached out to 4-5 parishes, some which referred me back to my local one, which didn't respond to my attempts to join RCIA. Finally one parish in the neighbouring city, fairly large in size, accepted me into RCIA. I was able to join this past Easter, thankfully! But I felt I was spiritually and mentally ready for confirmation before the Vigil. I will say, I did learn alot through the RCIA process, although most in the class were very unfamiliar with even the basic teachings of Christianity. I was able to form a fantastic friendship with the associate parish priest, who unfortunately is now moving parishes next month... Do I regret RCIA? No. Would I have appreciated a process that didn't take a year when I felt I was willing and ready to join in communion with the church? Absolutely. I think I was ready about 3 months into the 7 month RCIA program. I do know the schedule is demanding for priests, where the parishes are large, and there are few priests to go around. Open it up to the to married priests, similar to the Eastern Orthodox church. Tradition of the early church fathers taught that St Peter travelled with his wife.

[@jeremiahong248]

@sinkorswimstars. In my country the RCIA process is 1 year 😊

[@rick984]

7 months wasted months of your life.

[@whatsup3270]

It is generally a lifelong practice so if you missed 20, 30, or 40 years 12- one-hour classes was too much?

[@jeremiahong248]

@@rick984 only the devil will say that

[@TheArbiterOfTruth]

I’ve been in church since I was born (I’m 33 this year) I’ve studied scripture most of my life. This year is the first time I’ve heard the word “Eucharist”

[@user-mn2ju7tv8f]

What’s the name of the channel with the friars reacting…..I can’t find it for some reason.

[@mistermattmoose]

another great video, fr. casey! and i think it is very, very important for different christian faiths to find common ground. i'm 61 years old and remember hearing on the tv news and reading in the newspapers about the war in ireland between the catholics and the protestants. being a kid at the time, it confused me and didn't make sense. i would look around my neighborhood and see that 1/2 of my friends were catholic such as myself, and half were protestant. 1/2 of my relatives were protestant as well. and nobody cared. you either went to the public school or the catholic school. period. big deal. and people in ireland were killing each other based on their religion? that was crazy. thank God it's just a distant memory now.

[@Laurelin70]

Well, that's what happens when religion is contaminated by politics. Those "catholics" and "protestants" were not fighting because of their religion, but because of their allegiance: catholics' to their fatherland and protestants to their kings/queens, who happened to be English and not Irish.

[@charlier711]

Interesting point. I just got home from Belfast where my son went to school for a semester. Peace has prevailed now for many years, but I learned the "Troubles" had much more to do with allegiances to the UK (Unionists) vs those who wanted a completely independent Ireland. It was never over theological differences. Most of the citizens get along fine regardless of if they are Catholic and Anglican Protestant.

[@maximbodnariuc8748]

A video in which you explain the differences between Roman Catholic and, for example, Byzantine Catholic would be more then welcomed. God bless!

[@senzaiishiki.]

Does anyone know what happened to Upon Friar Review?

[@jeremymaffei4034]

can Cupid sense? Concupiscence?? FATHER!! What is this word?😂😂😂I love your videos, please, keep up the great work, and know that I am praying for you. Love from Fort Smith, Arkansas. God bless. 6:45

[@MM-te5iq]

Me and my husband was Catholic and later he moved out from the church to a non denomination faith . I fumbled to follow his faith to have unity in our life after getting a lot confused later I prayed to god one night to guide me and I got a vision which cleared me well on the right path . I will leave anything in this world to follow Jesus and Catholic faith. Love my husband and praying for his return back to faith as god wants me to show love and kindness as ultimately that is the essence of Christianity

[@fabio_0]

God is really sending a light for people to seek salvation through this father, God bless you.

[@anaguerra6645]

Thanks for your answers, fr Casey.

[@ThinkTwice2222]

Would've liked to see a debate instead of a QA... FYI we're not a democracy... We're a constitutional republic

[@BreakingInTheHabit]

It's a really weird distinction to make. Constitutional republic is a type of democracy.

[@pamelamays4186]

I'm not Catholic, however, I do enjoy listening to your content. It's very informative and educational.

[@bbygrlpt2]

My mom raised us Catholic and we trully see how that has made us stronger as adults now. I think when were kids or teens we dont realize yet how our faith will help us get thru the most difficult times in our lives. One of my sisters is Evangelical and one of my best friends too but we all get along great bc we share that love for our Lord and Savior. I want to teach my future kids the Christian faith too to prepare them for life bc everyone will need that faith and Gods love sooner or later.

[@ThinkTwice2222]

We'd happily accept you into the Baptist Church as well 😄

[@jaredolojan9719]

“We stand on the shoulders of the Apostles” *just waiting for an orthodox response video*

[@BreakingInTheHabit]

Both the Catholic and Orthodox Church share the same origin. We began to split a few hundred years afterwards, but neither one has a greater claim to originality than the other.

[@websiteckron8591]

I was raised catholic, but I really understand the full meaning of faith until my friend a Buddhist converted to the catholic church. After 13 years together we finally married. So through my husband and his questions I grew deeper in faith and the sacraments. Deo gratias.

[@gerardmcgorian7070]

Talking about ecumenism, at Yale in the 1970s, we Catholic students used to take "evening classes" - for which I "think" we got half a credit - taught by various Catholic religious who were based on campus or at the Divinity School. I took courses as varied as Sacramental Theology (taught by a Sister of Mercy, no less!), and the Documents of the Second Vatican Council, taught by a super Dominican Friar. I also took a very rigorous Systematic Theology course. The textbook? John Macquarrie's "Principles of Christian Theology." You won't need to be told that only a Jesuit would use a text by a Scottish Anglican priest to teach Roman Catholic systematic theology! But it worked! 🙂

[@rexlion4510]

you are correct on the communion question. As a former cradle Catholic, now in an Anglican parish, I would never try to receive the Eucharist in a Catholic Church. It would be highly inappropriate. A person receiving the Catholic communion is bound to aver by his "amen" that he believes that he is partaking of "the whole Christ" including His soul, divinity, and physical flesh and blood, and that the substance of bread is no longer present, so it is worthy of worship (despite the persistence of the _image_ of bread, one of its "accidents"). Since I believe that Jesus is present Sacramentally, spiritually, and symbolically, _but not corporally (physically),_ and since I no longer believe it is proper to render adoration (worship) toward an image (in this case, the image of a bread wafer), it would be improper for me to receive the Catholic communion. I hope this helps expand on the answer given.

[@winstoncottage344]

Idolatry, in Judaism and Christianity, is the worship of someone or something other than God as though it were God. The first of the biblical Ten Commandments prohibits idolatry. So by that definition in the Anglican Church you practice idolatry in the Eucharist, whereas in the Catholic Church, we believe that the Bread and Wine ARE God as promised to us in the words of Jesus himself: this is my Body, this is my Blood. Therefore there is no idolatry at all. The Hosts are not an image, they just ARE...

[@rexlion4510]

@@winstoncottage344 You wrote a false definition of idolatry. Idolatry is defined by the First Commandment which forbids it. Read Exodus 20 one more time; you will not find your false definition there. Exo 20:4,5 "Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them..." Is the host a 'graven' (man-made) image? Yes. May we direct our worship toward it? No, it is forbidden. Lev 26:1 "Ye shall make you no idols nor graven image, neither rear you up a standing image, neither shall ye set up any image of stone in your land, to bow down unto it: for I am the LORD your God." Is the hose in the monstrance a 'standing image'? Yes. Okay to worship? No, it is forbidden! The Israelites created a calf of gold, declared it to be Almighty God, and worshiped it. As punishment, Moses had the calf ground up and made the people ingest the gold. The Roman Catholics create wafers of bread, declare them to be Almighty God, raise them up in monstrances and worship them. Then they ingest them. See the similarity? By RC Tradition, RCs violate God's commandment to not make a likeness of Him and to not offer worship toward man-made images. If you say that "Bread and Wine ARE God", you are saying that God is bread and wine (if A=B then B=A) and your statement is heretical under the CCC. 🤪 But I know what you meant to say. It makes no difference that you believe the substances of bread and wine cease to be bread and wine, because the _images_ of bread and wine (the "accidents") still persist and the First Commandment forbids you to direct worship toward _images._ Incidentally, Anglicans do not direct worship toward their Eucharist, because they know it would be idolatrous behavior to worship the wafers.

[@beapussman8499]

My favorite confessional memory is Fr. McManus asking, "is that you B? Can you get me the football score?"

[@bryanwolfe9350]

I was a lifelong Baptist, 40+ years, and I converted this year, went through RCIA, which I really enjoyed. So very happy with my conversion. The Holy Spirit called me to the Church, and opened my mind and heart, it was great to learn the truth of the Church Jesus established. Best decision of my life. In my experience and observation, Protestants are edging further away from Gods truth, endless divisions, adaption of worldly views on homosexuality, false teaching, rampant divorces/scandals involving preachers, etc, is a really big problem.

[@kaizer4506]

Having grown up with a Catholic father and a Lutheran mother, I’m very grateful for the unique perspective I got seeing both sides. Despite all of us attending Lutheran schools, all my siblings are Catholic. I still wouldn’t recommend this situation, because it has affected my mother. She attends her own church with her side of the family, but her husband and most of her children are usually not with her. I pray she will convert one day and know that we love her and certainly do not look down on her faith

[@m_d1905]

My family was the opposite. My father, Lutheran and my mother, Catholic. I went to the Catholic Church with my mom's parents. I did visit the Lutheran Church a couple times. Being a kid, I couldn't really tell the difference. The difference for my situation is my dad did not attend church. He did watch Robert Schuler most Sundays. He didn't read the Bible much but had some good insights about it.

[@nettie4450]

Father Casey, I know this doesn't pertain to this video, but I have a question..I have started going to Adoration and feel kind of lost with the hymns and the litany at the end ..is there a resource that you suggest to learn them or should I just muddle through til I learn them? I am already Catholic..Just trying to deepen my relationship with Jesus. Thank you for any help you can give me

[@markpolo97]

Different parishes will have different litanies after Adoration and before Benediction. Possibly even a selection that are used at various times/days. The hymn "Tantum Ergo Sacramentum" is pretty universal, but there are dozens of common arrangements that are used in various places. In the English-speaking world, the Divine Praises are pretty common after Benediction. These may be prayed by all, or in a call and response style. Maybe ask your local priest if there is a booklet that he uses for those prayers.

[@non452]

Hilarious when he welcomed the Protestants to help reform the Catholic Church 😂

[@BreakingInTheHabit]

Would you rather them stay away and work against us? It’s concerning that welcoming people back and listening to their concerns is laughable.

[@non452]

@@BreakingInTheHabit um no? I was just pointing out the irony that Protestants originally existed because people were trying to reform the Catholic and then out of that led to a split. So you asking them to help out reform is kinda funny from an ironic view. *added context* I’ve been raised Protestant so the above statement is my basic understanding of what happened, it’s possible I could be wrong given that I’ve never really looked too in depth into that period. Also my joke wasn’t that serious, if we were physically interacting I would’ve said it in a soft tone with a light chuckle. I don’t mean to actually mock you or the Catholic Church, in all seriousness I have no problem with you trying to bring Protestant back/welcoming them in.

[@USDebtCrisis]

One of the best explanations I've heard for the Immaculate conception is as follows: Angel Gabriel calls her κεχαριτωμένη in Luke 1:28 kecharitōmenē. This Greek word has no exact translation in Latin, nor English. It is a conjugation, extension of three words: χαριτω (charitoo) "Grace", μένη (mene) (passive participle) and κε (ke) (prefix of χαριτω which means it is in perfect tense). The angel is not telling her she is receiving grace (much less "favor" as some translations say) in that particular moment, but that she is (passive participle) made graceful, fully, in past present and future (perfect tense). It's a quality of her being. She is blessed among all women. In vulgar latin translations it was usually translated as gratia plena/full of grace. This word Kecharitomene had never been used in Greek literature before this moment and wouldn't be used again until the 5th century. The author of Luke coined the term and meant it literally. Remember that "Grace" is undeserved divine help, gifted for free by God to someone so that person can better respond to His calls. Having such an absolute divine help, in past present and future implies no sin whatsoever, otherwise it would not have been truly gratia plena.

[@markelmore66]

Respectfully, That perfect tense should be rendered “has received grace (a completed aspect) or “favor” from God. No future is implied. Mary needed a savior too - no human can save themself. Jesus died and paid our sin debt - including Mary’s (Romans 3:23 and Romans 3:10 - 12). Πάντες means EVERYONE and the Greek of Romans 3:10 is very emphatic about there not being one apart from Christ who is righteous.

[@foodforthought8308]

​@markelmore66 I think Both Catholics and Protestants agree that Mary needed a Savior

[@sheriA7082]

How, though? If, according to catholics, she was sinless. Sin is what separates us from God. If she was sinless, ​therefore not separated from God, then she wouldn't have needed a savior. @foodforthought8308

[@markelmore66]

@@foodforthought8308 by the way, did you ever work for “No Such Agency”? There was a gentleman who wrote “food for thought” weekly encouragements that I used to enjoy reading. Was that you perchance?

[@generalyousif3640]

I wonder if we can do with Orthodox even tho it may be harder

[@elijahzetye7582]

it would be crazy trinitarian theology

[@S..527]

I am curious about your view on protestant communion. I’m reformed so we believe in “spiritual” presence instead of transubstantiation. Do catholics believe that when reformed churches have communion they are truely feasting on the body of christ? In other words, is christ truely present in reformed communion according to catholics?

[@CubeInspector]

No He isn't. Only a validly ordained priest can consecrate the Eucharist.

[@biggerdoofus]

I hope you don't mind a question that's more a tangent. When you got to the part about marriage, I started wondering. What is the church's view regarding the usage of the word "marriage" for secular unions and for secular purposes (such as taxes)?

[@whatsup3270]

Taxes? Non-Catholics marriages are called, in writings, a Natural Marriage. The difference is they are not recorded as a sacrament in the Catholic Church.

[@WilliamSwartzendruber]

I think you handled the Anglican Eucharist question really well. (No comment on Lutheran Eucharist because I'm not Lutheran.)

[@LittleWaffle]

I was searching the comments for non-catholics opinion, thanks a lot for your feedback 😊

[@bingkaramihan7516]

Thank you Father Casey for another information that widens our understanding about Catholic faith ❤

[@vincewarde]

OK, here's a question from a fan who is also an evangelical minister: Yes, tradition does indeed precede the writing of the New Testament, HOWEVER we see that tradition incorporated into the New Testament. Prior to the New Testament books and letters being composed various creeds - which were easily memorized - were used to instruct a largely, but by no means entirely illiterate group of converts. Many of these early creeds were quoted in the New Testament: 1 Cor 15:3-7 1 Cor 11:23-26 Rom 4:25 Rom 10:9 Phil 2:6-11 1 Tim 2:5-6 1 Pet 3:18 Rom 1:3-4 1 Tim 3:16 1 Tim 6:12 2 Tim 2:8 2 Tim 2:11-13 Thus we have a very good idea of what the very early church was teaching pre-60AD or so. Therefore, I think that to say that tradition preceded Scripture can be somewhat misleading. These creeds were in a sense Scripture, and were treated as such, from the time they were first taught shortly after the resurrection. I think it would be more accurate to say that tradition and NT Scripture began at the same time. As a member of a Wesleyan denomination, I do indeed hold that tradition has great value, but that it must always be subject to Scripture. Your thoughts Father Cole? 🙂🙂🙂

[@CubeInspector]

We have the continuous teachings of the Church from the Fathers to today. Not one of them would agree with the protestant idea

[@amyschmier8090]

I loved this!!!

[@Dragon-xq4ki]

Father casey ! What do you think about the Jehovah Witnesses. They came to my house and say that Jesus is not God. ?

[@CE24164]

Run! Lol but not

[@clipPRmusic]

Jehovah’s Witnesses aren’t Christians for multiple reasons.

[@CosmicDalmatian]

They aren't Christian

[@JackieDaytona1776]

I'd love to hear his answer to this! If the Jehovah Witnesses are NOT a cult I'd interested in learning how they're not. The more I learn about them the more they sound like victims of oppression to me. Happy to be wrong about that, though.

[@thefacelessquestion3333]

They're alot "better" than some denominations these days.

[@greydaze234]

I know the comment was about raising kids in a family with a Catholic and Protestant parent, but some perspective from a Catholic raised with Catholic and atheist parents (not left the Church, but never raised with any religion): it wasn’t all that confusing as a kid. My atheist dad taught me my faith is a choice, a choice I must make every day of my life. My Catholic mom taught me it’s important to respect people of all beliefs, even if we don’t agree. And I learned to look for Christ in every person I meet, whether Christian or not.

[@russellmiles2861]

Thank you for your comment: Ive mentioned a few times that I had married pretty Irish lass. I willingly agreed to raise children in the Faith - one does such out of love. I did so after their mother died much to young. I buried one son to forms and customs of the church. Oh my son's visited my father's church, local synagogue on a scout excursion and mosque on other occasions. My sons have made choices in life. But that had a basis to ponder such. They also had the love and care from various women in my life. They can recite the Nicene creed with ease - something I noticed many Catholics can't. They are upright and community minded - both gone into politics - taking after my father, not me. I'm proud. Their mother would have been proud.

[@marks1347]

Thank you

[@charlier711]

Thanks Fr C. I've taken to sending your videos to my sons who have stepped away from the church - I'm hoping its only temporary. Also, prayers out to Fr. Patrick. Hope he is managing ok.

[@rikralph]

4:41 Lmao very subtle jab at the protestants their Fr. Casey.

[@thelifeofcole8755]

Definitely

[@Gramma_Holly]

It would be helpful if Bishops made it clearer to parishes that RCIA isn't always required. I don't want to say it was a waste of time, but it was a very long and unnecessary process for me. And, I'm just glad now I'm Catholic.

[@miss__k]

You're Doing a great job Father❤ i just want to tell these preaching, particularly about the church teachings and traditions should reach every single catholic in the world. Along with the daily sermon in the mass. The church should teach people how to defend the church against false accusations. One who doesn't know how to answer protestants Questions are the ones who goes astray from the church. People should be made clear about everything in the church, both the scripture and the Tradition. Only the people who don't know them are the ones who gets converted to Protestanism leaving the true church behind.

[@MadeleineKuhl]

Hey mate My church pastor seemed Abit low in faith and Catholic media Stab stab. I’m recovering from a brain injury making my Aplasia (speech difficulties $ really bad. I liked the pretzel jokes along chosen watching for hope and love in Jesus. I tried to talk this but clearly didn’t come out coherent. Are you able to send him or alllow these joyful messages that you have shared, Love you all Bless you Got bless you all

[@doobat708]

Three years ago, we had a kid in classes to prepare for Confirmation. Her dad was raised Catholic, her mum Protestant, and she got to choose. Our workgroup has one part of the team dedicated to talk parallel talks with the parents, while the kids receive catechesis. The mum decided she wanted to convert, and received basically one-on-one catechesis. The number of catechumens is so low for now, our parish doesn't really do a whole RCIA programme, but perhaps we will again, in future. If someone's interested in converting but can't find a local enough parish doing RCIA, I suggest contacting the priest and asking if the do the same thing our parish does.

[@SoleaGalilei]

I loved your answer to the question about saints. I'd never thought about it as a reinforcement of the importance of the church as a community and a family, but it makes so much sense.

[@user-un5xj1wl6p]

A practical question just came to mind, does Eastern orthodox (say serbian or russian) is in communion with our Roman catholic church?

[@Seanain_O_hEarchai]

They have some valid sacraments and apostolic succession, but are not in communion.

[@russellmiles2861]

In 1965 they Roman Catholic church's then Pope and the Patriarch of Constantinople (Istanbul) kinda made up over excummincating each other on the 10th century CE. Then again the Roman Catholic church recently appointed a Patriarch to Jerusalem: there has been one there since 3rd century at least, but maintain by Orthodox church. Now there are two - they are friendly rivals. But as the RCC has south America it is winning easily.

[@user-uu8bs8tg1k]

I'm not a Catholic, I'm a born again Christ follower. Follow Jesus only not a church.

[@SirRaiuKoren]

The biggest yellow flag for me in Catholicism is the insistence that the Catholic church is the one true church, with the only justification being "Because it's been that way for a long time." _Lots_ of things are very old, like Zoroastrianism. That doesn't mean they are correct. _Lots_ of traditions are passed down for many generations, like Columbian trade slavery. That doesn't mean they are righteous. Traditions can be corrupted and used for malfeasance very easily, and not all traditions are valid. The Gnostic tradition is roughly as old as what is now called the Catholic tradition, and has just as many claims to Jesus' succession. Catholics would debate the legitimacy of those claims, and the Gnostics would debate the same of the Catholics. As these traditions have mutually exclusive beliefs, they can't both be correct. So, when the Catholic church appeals to tradition as a justification, it begs the question. "Our tradition is correct because our tradition says our tradition is correct." It's circular. I haven't heard an argument that validates Catholic tradition above others except that (a) it is old, which does not imply correctness, and (b) it succeeds the apostles, which other traditions can claim. I mean, even the Protestants can claim they come from the succession of the apostles by appealing to their Catholic lineage pre-Reformation.

[@ryanfreeman4492]

I am a christian though not a catholic, I can relate to your objection here. Where I don't exactly have personal faith in the catholic church, I certainly agree with the catholic church as being the true church as in the original apostolic church. The funny thing is though that your objection actually sounds like you're proving their case for them because where it is true zoroastrianism is older it is obviously not the true faith of God, which IS a point for the catholic church! They agree with you on that. In a sense with much respect as one who thought the same way as you did, This objection really shows that that you are agreeing with them and you're mad at them for it as i was once. Truth is not a matter of what came first, as your objection claims, but is rather what was revealed objectively on a historical basis to be right and what is verifiable and that I as a protestant know zoroastrianism came before Christianity but know its not true because history reveals this objectively. This is precisely your point and their point. It's not just that their church is older, it's that it is the historical church that developed from the apostles, to the fathers of the church into the institution of the home of Christianity becoming the pillar and foundation of western society. The gnostic claims where they arose shortly after the emergence of the apostolic church, the gnostics were against the apostles and even their gospels were written a century later containing contradictions of the apostolic faith. Clearly you don't believe just because it's old means it's true, it's about what is verifiable but as the catholic church itself claims and is verifiable its not that its just the oldest, it's that it goes back to the apostles and therefore Jesus Christ himself! Hope that helps and God be with you

[@srich7503]

History shows us that Jesus didn't leave us a bible, - the apostles didn't tell us which books belong in the bible, - the church fathers never agreed on the 27 books of the NT through the 4th century, - not only did they not agree but their individual lists of would-be NT canons were GROWING during this time, growing in numbers of hundreds of “inspired” NT writings. Therefore, if it wasn't the Catholic/Orthodox church that compiled the 27 books of the NT in the 5th century with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and preserved it by laboriously hand copying them over and over throughout the centuries before the invention of the printing press, the “rule of faith” for many, please tell us who did? And if this church no longer exists today, what good is the text which came forth from her if she couldn't sustain herself? Therefore the Bible to ALL Christians comes from the tradition of the Catholic church

[@roberterwine7650]

I was a catholic until my teens then I read a history book and later became Pentecostal

[@srich7503]

Why a history book? What happened to the Bible? History shows us that Jesus didn't leave us a bible, - the apostles didn't tell us which books belong in the bible, - the church fathers never agreed on the 27 books of the NT through the 4th century, - not only did they not agree but their individual lists of would-be NT canons were GROWING during this time, growing in numbers of hundreds of “inspired” NT writings. Therefore, if it wasn't the Catholic/Orthodox church that compiled the 27 books of the NT in the 5th century with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and preserved it by laboriously hand copying them over and over throughout the centuries before the invention of the printing press, the “rule of faith” for many, please tell us who did? And if this church no longer exists today, what good is the text which came forth from her if she couldn't sustain herself?

[@roberterwine7650]

@@srich7503 it has nothing to do with canon or text . you avoided what I said rather cleverly. the early roman church would be horrified at what their church has become , do you even read secular history and see what the church of rome did over the last 1000 years ? that is history not bashing or being 'anti catholic' would you want to associate yourself with that organization ?

[@srich7503]

@@roberterwine7650 Yes i absolutely do because i, like those in the church, am a sinner myself, which is why i posted what i posted about the church, “that organization” which has NOTHING to do with the practices of her adherents. But if you ever do find “that organization” without sinners please report back and i will be the 1st to convert. 👍🏻 EDIT: well, that is, if that would have me, the sinner. 🤷🏽‍♂️