British guitarist analyses Paul McCartney's first solo effort with The Beatles!

[@yesterdayproductions1019]

That Tenor Voice, smooth guitar playing & look was fabulous, especially standing up there and doing it all by himself. Just absolutely outstanding.

[@StewMandoo]

Yes

[@lauriekane4686]

When George introduces the song, you can tell by the audience's reaction, that they don't know this song. Can you imagine how different the world was? To live in a world without this song? I can not. The Beatles changed our world. And their music will live forever. It is eternally embedded in our very DNA.

[@1SeanBond]

That's a awesome comment and thought wow so true! I always wondered what would of happened if the Plane never crashed on Feb 3 1959 with Buddy Holly & the Big Bopper ,aka J.P Richardson & Richie Valens...

[@Farsider3955]

@@1SeanBond - 🤔..... is that you Mr. McClean ?

[@LednacekZ]

Didnt they make a movie about this last year?

[@arlenmargolin1650]

@@1SeanBond and what if the car never crashed and the hair was never lost and Sergeant pepper never happened and the whole business of what did happen happened what a crazy world we would have what a crazy world we did have what a crazy world

[@keithworsfold2689]

1Sean Bond Don't get wrong, I would have loved it if Buddy had lived, what great stuff he would of produced, he did so much in such short career.But I still think the Beatles would have made it, Chuck, Little Richard and the Everlys didn't die but they influenced the Beatles.

[@Zholobov1]

This was in fact THE FIRST live performance of "Yesterday" in public (the Ed Sullivan's came a week later), and don't forget that the LP "Help!", which featured this song, hadn't yet arrived also. So those girls who were present on the set of Blackpool Night Out TV show, witnessed the moment in History. No one was prepared for this. You can hear how the audience becomes unusually quiet during the performance. You can see how nervous Paul McCartney is. And what a relief that must have been for him in the end! He certainly passed the audition.

[@charlesanderson32]

Such a soft and Pleasing Voice. Marvelous Songwriter!

[@donnacolwell3988]

Many years ago one of my older brothers was learning to play the guitar. He would often play from a Beatles song book. My younger brother and I would sing along to the songs as he played. "Yesterday" was my favorite song that we sang with him. My older brother passed away unexpectedly this past February. I can't hear this song without thinking of my brother and the incredible diversity of music he exposed me to in my youth. Thank you dear brother for the gift of music.

[@mightyV444]

@Donna Colwell - Sorry to hear about your sad loss, Donna. Beautiful how Music has been helping to keep his memory alive 😌

[@denisemaxwell51]

So sorry about your brother, im glad you shared the wonder memories

[@TheDresen12]

heartbreaking comment !!! I really feel for you Donna

[@antoinettewitt2098]

Sorry for your loss. My deepest condolences. Music & Memories may help you through this difficult time.

[@arlenmargolin1650]

I think that's why music is the medium that it is and the powerful one at that I think the power of music is that it becomes a timestamp in our minds every note lineage whatever it was or whatever you were going through at the time and it tends to mark that time emotionally spiritually even physically

[@catnc1]

Paul is so nervous! He wasn't used to being out on stage alone. He did great though. The girls actually shut up and listened for a change.

[@jodeeb.6496]

Correct however John had said a very hurtful comment immediately before Paul did this performance. Info from docs found here on UTUBE.

[@d.b.4201]

@@jodeeb.6496 I believe it! Doesn’t surprise me at all!

[@amandas.6745]

He rushed it a tiny little bit 😌

[@Stacey721]

Beautiful Paul singing and performing a beautiful song. ❤

[@Slydeil]

Another aspect of the performance is that Paul doesn't look at his fretting hand. Even though he was nervous, he sang and played it perfectly whilst focussed on looking at the audience. A truly supreme musician, songwriter and performer.

[@robovac3557]

He clearly does. Several times.

[@bendagostino2217]

It's all open chords in the first position. You dont need to look at your hand.

[@laurencetyson7395]

​@@robovac3557I noticed it too. I've seen several videos here on KZbin that clearly show McCartney looking down at the neck of his guitar.

[@robovac3557]

@@laurencetyson7395 Just another comment left by someone who doesn't actually watch the video.

[@laurencetyson7395]

@@robovac3557 I've just looked at the video again. I counted at least five times where he looks down at the neck of his guitar.

[@dngdnf4862]

6.28 dont forget ringo starr was also a songwriter in the band. i dont know how many songs he wrote, but he wrote my fav ringo song, Octopus's Garden.

[@jackthebassman1]

Once again Paul’s vocals are superb, among the very best in pop history.

[@laural.enright4780]

Your face while you're watching that illustrates the absolute charm of the Beatles. You were transfixed by it as so many people are when they watch a Beatles performance. They really were extraordinary.

[@laural.enright4780]

BTW: I would pay to watch you sing Scrambled Eggs. :)

[@909Twodogs]

Phil, as usual you are such a delight to watch and listen to. Keep it up from Australia.

[@christenejackman]

What's so cool is that Paul was so steeped in writing songs, he was composing in his sleep. He says he woke up one morning with this melody. He dreamed it. What a classic! I remember seeing the Beatles on Ed Sullivan as a little girl. Never forgot it. Fell in love with the Beatles. I was not a screamer, but I remember thinking I would die if I never got a chance to see Paul McCartney. :) Now, it's a bucket list thing: coffee (or tea) with Paul McCartney, talkin' music.

[@cstarv]

Best band ever, they changed music and changed the world. Amazing songs that are so different from the last one, they had so much talent. I was very young when I saw their first Ed Sullivan show. Still remember it, especially my father laughing at the screaming from the girls.

[@venderstrat]

And for my next song, I'd like to sing 'Long Tall Sally'. He's a freak of nature.

[@toddubow2599]

Paul is just magical. No other way to explain it.

[@allenf.5907]

That's why it's really NOT a pop song - it is magical and other-worldly.

[@glamgal7106]

I saw Paul in concert in 2011. Though I sat up in the "boonies," there were large video screens of him. He was indeed magical in his 3 hour performance with 3 encores and no intermission. To this day, no other performer has had this effect on me in a live performance: Paul actually had me crying when he sang "Worlds Away" which he dedicated to John--it reminded me of my late sister who died of unnatural causes. Apparently I haven't been the only crier during his concerts. In an interview, Paul acknowledged his noticing fans crying at his concerts. Though he understood that music has the ability to do that, he'd said something to the effect of, "I know you're [going through something], but if you don't stop crying, I'll start crying too." I think that showed sensitivity on Paul's part.

[@Plorzie]

In my humble opinion, which doesn’t count for much Paul is the greatest rock star ever, he set standards for future rockers and in my opinion his Super Bowl performance is the greatest halftime performance ever. I don’t believe with all the recognition he does get that it is enough. Opinions are like bellybuttons everyone has one, or whatever.

[@toddubow2599]

@@Plorzie absolutely agree.

[@thesilvershining]

@@Plorzie I agree!

[@ianlaker9161]

Wow. Suddenly (almost) no screaming. Masterful performance from a genius.

[@stingfan16ify]

My favorite song of all time!!! It's both sad and beautiful.

[@TheDivayenta]

One of the most beautiful songs EVER written. Paul is a musical genius. He was even a little nervous there. 💕

[@arlenmargolin1650]

I think this is what gives the McCartney's such a powerful legacy between both of them there's a lot of genius flipped around

[@arlenmargolin1650]

@mark jagger d

[@arlenmargolin1650]

@mark jagger I'm talking about the two McCartney's that compiled would become that part of the Beatles and then the words of Billy Campbell who wrote an almost 700-page book of how he took the job over after 1967 in his own words you can find out what really happened with The Beatles although a lot of people choose not to read the book but of course ignorance is something that cannot be battled and ignorance is the thing that keeps us from the truth yes there were two Paul McCartney's and both of them together made for one hell of a legacy I would never ever put down the legacy of Paul McCartney be it the early one or the late one they both compromise one hell of a career

[@michaelangelo2739]

Fil no one does this better than you. You remain so positive and your joy just radiates. God bless you my friend. Peace, Michael Angelo

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@mitchlong8077]

I remember watching the Beatles on the Ed Sullivan Show on February 9, 1964, with my family....giggling and sort of "mocking" them, but cautiously intrigued at the same time. Little did I know that, within a year from that time, I would be COMPLETELY WON OVER, and it seemed that the entire "civilized" world came along with me!!! My dad, who grew up playing western songs on an acoustic large-body Gretsch (much like Harrison's) and singing barbershop, went out and bought "Something New" (the original "Hard Day's Night" album). I and my sisters loved it, but my dad listened to it more than WE DID!!! You have to remember that The Beatles represented a "changing of the musical guard" to my dad's post-WWII generation; but EVEN HE recognized that they had talent as writers and performers. THAT'S HOW POWERFUL an influence they became....to multiple generations!!!

[@patriciasnyder6915]

If I remember correctly, Bing Crosby said something similar about Elvis Presley. Elvis changed the direction and started a new era of music at that time. The Beatles did the same thing.

[@mitchlong8077]

@@patriciasnyder6915 That's probably true. Although, I wouldn't put Elvis in the same category as the Beatles- -at least as far as their respective "musicianship" was concerned. Elvis was "iconic", no question about that. But he certainly was NOT the musician the Beatles were. Elvis performed; the Beatles did virtually everything else: composed, played, sang, and performed (some of that with "Alittle Help From Their Friends" (i.e., George Martin)😉

[@patriciasnyder6915]

@@mitchlong8077 I was just repeating what I read. I don’t know when Bing made that comment in relation to when Elvis and the Beatles came on to the scene.

[@2cozmick25]

The stones hit in October I was 12 and between the two groups, well the world actually did change

[@lonniethomas2649]

Something New was the first record I ever owned! We watched the Ed Sullivan debut and my parents were a bit skeptical, but after we all went to see A Hard Day’s Night they were sold!

[@marcjohnson4385]

I seem to remember that Paul said he was a little nervous because it was the 1st time he was alone and not with the other Beatles

[@allenf.5907]

Opportunity knocks.

[@sodoffbaldrick3038]

Sitting in a darkened arena, hundreds of us singing this along with Paul, many with tears in our eyes, is magical. I've been lucky enough to experience this three times, and the joy and nostalgia it brings never changes.

[@thesilvershining]

I think the massive success of “Yesterday” really helped Paul gain the confidence to keep writing to his own unique musical personality. He branched off in a different direction than John, with John focusing more on the personal side of songwriting and Paul on the universal human experience. Paul’s music becomes personal for the listener in whatever way they need, which is similar to classical music. In classical music it’s the music itself which evokes strong emotion and conveys more feeling than any lyric ever could. I also think that’s why I adore his instrumental tracks from Wings, McCartney, McCartney II, Standing Stone, etc… they’re just brilliant. I also think “Yesterday” helped Paul fully embrace the power of mature empathy and sensitivity which led to songs like “Here, There and Everywhere”, “Eleanor Rigby”, “Fool on the Hill”, “Let it Be”, “Hey Jude”… all five being in my Top 10 Beatles songs. I love and admire all the Beatles of course but Paul knew how to go straight to my heart 😉

[@cathyf.2672]

So true. Great comment about how Paul and John branched out in different directions.

[@lizmurphy5994]

This is an extraordinary song. Beautiful and gentle to listen to. Full of meaning and emotion yet, acoustic guitar and singing tracks have had less commercial success than other music styles. I think that makes Paul's composition even more remarkable. To cut through, even today shows the genius of Paul. As long as the world has music, 'Yesterday' will be played and loved.

[@eh-i1841]

I remember this particular performance,and the impact of Paul’s voice,and this beautiful song.I was about 13,and it’s all I wanted to hear,for days after.Just gorgeous.

[@lonniethomas2649]

I watched at age 8 and got a weird feeling in my stomach that I later realized was butterflies and that Paul was my first crush! 😍🥰

[@chipurBillWhite]

Nice, Fil. You’ve gotten so good at what you do. Technically accurate, pleasantly presented. Thank you.

[@JoanVioletStretch]

Kudos for playing this original version of this live performance by Paul McCartney...introduced by George. I remember it so well and young as I was recognized its brilliance. My father was an exceptional ballad singer and didnt like the rock n roll bands popping up, but was converted and was softened my this performance, saying, these Beatles did a good job of this song and that lad can sing...after that he listened more to the Beatles and even the Animals and the Stones...liking some of Mick Jaggers classy ballads and Eric Burdons Rising Sun. This performance Paul should be proud of as its legendary.

[@dalem8332]

Brilliant. I've been a Paul McCartney fan since l was a child. LOVED the Beatles and have followed Paul's brilliant solo career. Had the pleasure of seeing him live in the late 80s Flowers In The Dirt tour. Incredible 3 hours of hit after hit. He's been one of the soundtracks of my life. Brilliant Singer Songwriter musical genius. This is a great performance. Great to go back in time to the early days. Excellent analysis and demo Fil. Thanks!🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦🇨🇦

[@leeann4743]

Isn't it amazing that simple chord inversions can have such a major impact on the flow and feeling of a song...? Beautifully done, Fil. As always :)

[@ThisTrainIsLost]

This song, that strikes harder with every passing year of the lifespan countdown clock, has been part of a personal mystery for decades. “Yesterday” and “Michelle,” along with a batch of snapshot memories, make up a picture from the early/mid 60’s that I can’t prove is true. Real memories? Things I’d read? Dream images with a Beatles soundtrack? I honestly don’t know but that part of my past has no solidity. For a few years I was “dreaming my life away” (thanks, John). It’s no gain but at the least I think that I know how Merlin felt, frozen betwixt life and death, inside of the Crystal Cave.… Yet again, I thank you very much for the time spent filming this analysis. I always come away with more than I brought in.

[@eileendobbs8574]

I'm glad the girls screaming was at a minimum so you could actually hear the singing.

[@kennethlatham3133]

This was from the "Blackpool" concert, I believe, from around April of '66. They were nearing the end of their last ever tour, the final date being @ Candlestick Park in San Francisco, August 29. 1966. This Blackpool concert is worth looking for here on KZbin, I guess they just "declassified" it, for lack of a better word. There's less screaming and hormonal agony coming from the audience DURING each track; you can actually HEAR THE BAND sing and play, and they are magnificent. The instrumental amplification is a bit more advanced, which helps them rock better. I suspect this short era contains a lot more nuggets like this, though the disastrous Philippines tour took a lot of lift from their spirits.

[@johnp515]

@@kennethlatham3133 The date was August 1st 1965, a few days before they left for America and performed on The Ed Sullivan Show (singing the same set) and then playing the famous Shea Stadium Concert. The reason the screams are not as intense is because the Blackpool Show was a televised variety show, thus not a purely Beatle audience..

[@plantfeeder6677]

They were caught offguard. They didn't know the song. Glad they finally stfu for once.

[@beatlemaniacwaltdisneyfan4753]

@@johnp515 is because the girls were caught off guard they were clueless. By then the beatles had lots of male audience especially since this song

[@Farsider3955]

Once again.... fantastic video. After watching your analysis I just had to go back and watch Paul’s performance again with even greater appreciation. And you are correct, the subtle complexity of this “simple” song is astonishing. There’s an obvious reason why this beautiful song is covered so often, and yet.... I’m reasonably sure there is at least an equal number if not thousands more professional singer/guitarists like myself who have passed on attempting to cover this song. It’s next to impossible to perform to this level of near-perfection with a little magic sprinkled on top. I think I’ll go back and watch this performance at least one more time. Thanks again for doing this video.

[@lynndow3185]

AHAHAAA!!! Hearing you SING the "scrambled eggs and legs" version was worth the price of admission! I have only ever seen that written. Thanks, Fil!

[@jennrat513]

😂👍

[@twotime777]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/kF7Ye4FqqcSdgs0 check this out if you wanna see Paul sing it. I think this is the right video haha

[@LouieLouie3]

This song is timeless.

[@OverlandOne]

I grew up in the 60's listening to the Beatles playing on the radio and, on my older brother's record player. when I think back, I find it incredible that a talent like Paul McCartney ran into a bloke by the name of John Lennon, and they got a guitarist named George Harrison along with a drummer named Ringo Starr. How does this happen? I have played in many bands over the years but...what are the odds these people all met each other, got along enough to form a band, and gave us these great songs? Certainly once in a lifetime I think...at least from my perspective. People that judge them now claiming...well...they were not that great, do not take into account the context of the music scene at that time. NO ONE was doing what they were doing and suddenly, EVERYONE was trying to copy them to be the "next" Beatles. To me, it was like the "Perfect Storm" of music. Toss in George Martin's genius and you have a sound people like me still enjoy all these years later. That is the test of great music in my opinion.

[@StoryeTime]

Yes that is the magic of life and that's why such bands are special, it takes a lot of parameters for all this to happen and make such a band happen and that goes for all the bands we love.

[@dncviorel]

"How does this happen"? Well, when you're Theodor Adorno it's not that complicated. :)))) But nevertheless, the guys were fairly decent on stage, so kudos to Brian Epstein for finding them. :)))

[@robanks3895]

It's hard to believe there are people who think they were not that great when you consider The Beatles extensive music catalogue and the fantastic songs they wrote in their studio years. How many bands today could possible achieve the same level of music in just 10 years!

[@StevieZero]

@@robanks3895 Any band with talent

[@MsAppassionata]

@@StevieZero Oh yeah? Like who?

[@sjderemerwi]

One of the greatest “lament” songs I know of, very expressive while short and sweet, and readily applied to the ear and mind of nearly any listener and thusly tailored to an individual personal experience.

[@dr.buzzvonjellar8862]

A perfect song, performed with care and honesty.

[@2323msg]

Fil, your McCartney voice is really beautiful..✨✨

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@MsAppassionata]

@@wingsofpegasus I’d like to second that. You have a nice singing voice as well as your guitar playing skills.

[@WildflowerNJ1]

Now this song...this performance.....I fell in love with this man. Such a beautiful song. Still in love with this man.....met Paul November 13, 2006 at Virgin Records in Times Square NYC. 500 fans sat all night just to shake his hand....I thanked him for his music and my sister...who was behind me.....said a big smile came to his face. 'No, luv......thank you. What would I be without you.' I floated up that escalator.

[@katethomas5712]

I love this story. You must have felt fantastic. It's great that he appreciates his fans

[@WildflowerNJ1]

@@katethomas5712 he does....he made me feel like I was the only person in that room......

[@katethomas5712]

@@WildflowerNJ1 What a great memory to have. Paul is so special and sweet.

[@thesilvershining]

Oh my gosh I’m so happy for you. I could never meet Paul, I’d stutter for a full ten seconds and then faint. My musical hero ♥️

[@jackmcdouglas4126]

This song may sound easy when we’re listening to it, but playing all the chords changes and singing this complex melody is no small task. Actually there were billions of covers of this song, but nobody could ever come close to Paul’s original version. His voice is soft, sugar coated, elastic and his timbre is extremelly pleasant. This is a music masterpiece that only his creator can properly reproduce.

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

I prefer the Seekers' Version

[@helenjohnson7583]

Paul looks so young and sounds (for lack of a better word) unrelaxed. Bet he was relieved when that spot was over!

[@DrDespicable]

Well, he was only 22 or 23, when this was shot - and even when you're used to playing with a band, it can be intimidating when the rest of the band isn't right behind you on stage!

[@MsAppassionata]

What you said brings back memories. I played this song (on violin) as part of a string quartet for my junior high school graduation.

[@brucestanley9656]

He didn't once look at his fretting hand! Off the hook! Thanks for reviewing this.

[@eternalme6077]

Damn Fil.....I've forgotten just how wonderful your Vocals are, the way you did that little diddy with the scrambled eggs was spot on! I'd love to see you Wail on those Drums back there. I also play many different instruments being I've been in bands in my day. You've probably played bass on some of your Vids and I've not seen them, I'd love to see them as well. Another Great Analysis for my All Time Favorite BAND.......🎸💚

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@TheDresen12]

It's just one of the most iconic songs of all time ... considering those lyrics comming from a man who was just in his early twenties at the time, is unbelievable !!!

[@jamescoughlan8193]

Wow I had never seen that clip before, great introduction from George and wow paul just being paul a legend. Such a great band

[@jimpaquette8007]

In the dictionary under the word LEGEND is a picture of Paul McCartney! He is the GOAT!

[@mmccartney6579]

The most covered song in all of music history. Great review, yet again, Fil!! Cheers, mate!! :)

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@philtimms6808]

How fantastic were the Beatles - one of a kind! Thanks Fil - I really appreciate you bringing all these artists to us.

[@norobbery]

Thank you for this; The Beatles were just like no other that's ever walked down the pike. I love George introducing Paul as if it's in a small pub. He enjoins the audience in the newness of it all and makes them feel at home while they're witnessing history, that we would only come to realize later. God Bless You and Long live The Beatles.

[@michaelserby7697]

Paul McCartney is a great talent 🇬🇧 ♥️

[@petrslivinski7481]

Wow this brings back some great memories of the mid 60s and the Beatles landed here in NY and played at Shea Stadium. They carved themselves a place in history that will live for many, many years. Always enjoyed the Beatles and their music. Paul McCartney is a phenomenal singer/songwriter and the song Yesterday is one of many songs that became a huge hit single! Thanks for talking about Paul McCartney.

[@melissakhalar1842]

"Join me do There’s a lot of eggs for me and you I’ve got ham and cheese and bacon too So go get two and join me do" ... I didn't know about the original lyrics and I must say I had to chuckle.

[@allenf.5907]

Fil, what is under-looked about this song is the time and meter within it. It is more than a haunting melody with beautiful chords and a head-scratching lyric for this young a man to write after eating his breakfast! We all know the story of his waking up to the melody and good fortune did knock to have a piano right there at the Asher home to begin writing this piece of music. I will never classify it as a pop song. It's the seven bar verses (who used that feel before?) to allow for the emphasis on the words yesterday and suddenly and create a philosophical feel to it (no pun intended) that give the mournful and soulful feeling. It all adds to the beauty and poignancy that the song is delivering and its perfection. It IS one of those songs where some kind of divine intervention had to have been occurring. Then the chorus goes into a duple meter feel (2/4 or 2/2) and lead sheets never indicate this yet you can sure feel it almost as if it's a different song all together. Your chord analysis is wonderful of it also - in that it could be many different chords or voicings within it. The Beatles were breaking ranks from what is a typical tin-pan alley song and bringing a VERY classical yet turning toward experimental forms of music. You can't dance to Yesterday or make out to the song but you can surely appreciate a brilliant piece of music that will stand the test of time. Your face tells the story of reverence while the song is being performed. Oh, and we can't forget George Martin's scoring and the playing of the strings minus any vibrato. Further - wasn't it recorded on the same day as I'm Down? This band could defy logic. Artists of a very high degree.

[@loosilu]

And I'm Down has the same singer! Insane.

[@dannypgrizzle]

While this is represented as McCartney’s first “solo” recording, the real inspiring thing here is the arrangement, and more specifically how rivalry and ego were secondary ro whatever was best for the song. Everything I know about good taste emanates from the Beatles. You can see it everywhere in everything they do from the very beginning. Another example: in the black & white A Hard Day’s Night, in the song “And I Love Her” with the full band, George delivers a signature riff and then... he stops playing, standing the guitar on his knee as the song continues. How many bands write or arrange music with this kind of restraint? Because sometimes, less is more.

[@pinky69207]

I just re-watched that scene to refresh my memory. You’re right. Great restraint.

[@19.sciencetechnology30]

Just as an interesting side note regarding some, but not all of George Harrisons contributions to some of the Beatles songs, I believe that it was george who composed that guitar solo in "and I love her," and the lead solo in the song "I saw her standing there" and also the idea and suggestion for the sitar in lennons song "Norwegian wood".

[@braemtes23]

@@19.sciencetechnology30 George definitely did the solo in "And I Love Her". I heard Paul talking about how amazing it was and how it took the song to a higher level (paraphrasing here).

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

@@19.sciencetechnology30 George composed the four notes intro to And I love her.

[@norobbery]

@@jeffreykaufmann2867 I wish modern top 40 would practice some restraints, but I don't see it happening (and that includes pop and country); I'll believe it when I hear it and not before.

[@michellewilsdon294]

Oh yes, I do believe in Yesterday--cried so much as I played the grooves off the 45. As you said a true and complex lasting melodic composition. Rock ! \m/

[@MrKockabilly]

"Yesterday" could easily be the pound for pound king of songs, so lean and mean, "simple" but heavy.

[@tjvanpopta]

This was the tv show ' Blackpool night out' from the ABC theatre Blackpool August 1- 1965. Also known as one of their best live shows. This was 2 weeks before the famous Shea stadium concert.

[@jrwsaranac]

The melody is absolutely gorgeous. Nice analysis, too!

[@kenmcfann8128]

The Beatles appeared on American television on February 9th, 1964, my 10th birthday and it changed my life, love peace ✌️ and a wonderful life to you all ✌️

[@linxMuppet]

He is the single greatest song writer our planet has produced...period

[@TheLadsBandLive]

Apologies if it’s already been mentioned but Yesterday initially came to Paul in a dream of The Rolling Stones performing the song. Also, I love how spot-on Paul is in this video with replicating all the nuances of the studio version of the guitar while singing pitch perfect. He makes it look effortless.

[@johnmccarthy-behindtheveil]

Most covered song of all time. Amazing.

[@suehollar2578]

I honestly never knew about the scrambled eggs lyrics, or if I heard them I tried to forget them! I was nice watching Paul perform live and being able to hear him.

[@pinball1970]

@sue Macca woke up with it in his head and sang it to everyone to make sure he had not just absorbed it from somewhere.

[@grievousangelic]

I've been a Paul girl since I was five. This is such a beautiful performance. Thanks for analyzing this! (I'd love to hear your analysis of "Ferry Cross the Mersey" in tribute to Gerry Marsden.)

[@DebbieJohnson-n2m]

Imagine writing this touching and tender song at so young an age and it becoming the treasure that it is as it spans time and situations and ages. All people’s find themselves in the lyrics and haunting melody in this classic and timeless Perfection. What a gift Paul gave our world. THE MAN IS SUCH A HUMBLE GENIUS✨✨✨

[@jamesleung8679]

The late George Martin once said that Paul McCartney was the best bassist, a brilliant guitarist, a first rate drummer and a competent piano player. Enough said ?

[@Nerkin610]

I’d say he’s one of the best bassists, phenomenal guitarist, hell of a piano player and unbelievable vocalist. Average drummer though. If you listen to his isolated drumming, you hear that it’s actually sloppy and almost random at times. Quite mediocre. It’s whatever though. Paul can make sweet music on whatever instrument is handed to him. He’s a Renaissance man.

[@MsAppassionata]

@@Nerkin610 I’ve heard that he can play over 40 musical instruments.

[@scottandrewbrass1931]

​@@MsAppassionataName them then.

[@scottandrewbrass1931]

He's a terrible drummer.And he plays banana fingers piano.😅

[@MsAppassionata]

@@scottandrewbrass1931 🙄🙄🙄 Oh, I see. Another edge lord. Bye 🤡

[@TorToroPorco]

I think I would die a content man knowing I had written but this one song. Pure magic.

[@markvonwisco7369]

Paul had such a pure voice back then!

[@quicktastic]

Women also scream when I sing, just for different reasons.

[@Altanon]

I say, "Yeah, I have a hell of a voice; when I start singing, folks feel like they're in hell."

[@quicktastic]

@@Altanon 😂

[@debishaw9355]

Lol

[@annwalsh1804]

🤣🤣🤣 aaaaaaaaaghhhhh!!

[@quicktastic]

@@annwalsh1804 😥😞

[@michaelmilner6831]

Hey Fil. For the record, I absolutely loathe autotune. I was a teenager in the 70's, and I went more concerts them I could probably remember, and the passion and feeling and even the imperfections of the lead singers' voice, was my favorite thing about live music.

[@garywalsh3487]

Profoundly talented writer-musician-singer.

[@pamnichols7877]

What a British treasure! I’ll be in love with Sir Paul and the Beatles until the end of time! You must get your charm from the Sir Paul! I long for Yesterday. ❤️

[@lordjs9726]

I'm glad you didn't have much negative to say about this. The song is wonderful and Paul is a genius.

[@Morticia1313]

Such a beautiful song.The Beatles were magic.The likes of , I doubt we will ever see again. Every one of their albums is a masterpiece. I've seen Paul several times & he is such a professional. Over 3 hours playing some of the greatest songs ever written without taking a break or a sip of water, "because it's rude" We didn't really get to see the extent of George's talent until he went solo, not to say he didn't write some amazing songs with the Beatles. 🎸🤘🩵

[@shatner99]

Yes! You did it. So happy. Phil singing from the roof top to KZbins: Don't take it down...don't take it down...

[@Updavidedattention]

Thank you Fil - The link is the description was disabled but we can enjoy it thanks to you, so this is the only video of this, first Paul’s live performance of the song that’s a cultural landmark of the 20th century.

[@jessicachapman2227]

I think it still holds the Guinness Book of Records title as the most recorded song in history. ❤️

[@randythompson1957]

Phil , you have more musical information an any search engine on the internet. Love your channel. I wish I could have learned from you years ago. Please keep up the great work. And I hope the New Year is a great one for you .

[@1SeanBond]

Awesome comment Cheers!

[@lawrencetaylor4101]

I've said the same thing many times. Fil has a great way of explaining music theory.

[@garygoodrich7495]

I believe this is the most recorded song ever in music history. More artists from all over the world have recorded this. Paul said this song "fell out of bed" Meaning he woke up with the melody in his head. If only I could get half the quality of ear worms he gets. Anyway, he's mentioned in interviews that he was embarrassed to play this for "the boys" for the first time. After all, "we were a rock band." So glad you worked past that initial apprehension, Paul.

[@MikeJohnson-oz7uk]

Great song. If you watch the full video after the other 3 come back on, John says tongue in cheek: "Thank you Ringo, that was wonderful!"

[@souplady9676]

I was lucky enough to see this performance when it first aired and immediately fell in love with the song.( As a 16 year old I already was in love with Paul) What a happy time. Thank you for this.

[@wingsofpegasus]

Cool!

[@Heywood.Jablome]

The thing guitar players appreciate about the Beatles is the level of difficulty and complexity of the chords and progressions! Yet, the songs sound "simple" with all the great hooks. AND to top all this incredible expertise off, they are only 20 years old, and playing things that had never been played before! And playing so tight with others, at such a young age. Just wow! Not even counting the incredible stand alone vocal talents. Just the ultimate band by every possible measure. This unique talent and musical direction lit a fuse that blew the musical world and musianship into outer space! I've not heard any of our greatest guitar players and songwriters from the 60's-70's that don't immediately credit the Beatles sound with igniting their fire to perform. Beatles really can't be underestimated. ROCK!

[@edjo487]

Wow! Can you imagine being there and hearing this “new” song? That was a gift to hear live. When writing a song, it evolves and those original words really needed to! Lol. Sometimes you can pull a Peter Frampton and write all your hits in one day, but that does not happen often of course. This is a song that will stay with humanity to the bitter end. It is simply brilliant! Also, great instruction. This is a tricky song if you do not know the tuning and strumming pattern. Very well done!

[@pocopico7409]

Great review of “Yesterday,” Fil. I thought you did a great job and I really thank you for doing it. I remember watching this song played live for the first time. It was one of those songs that immediately became super special to all that heard it, and you knew immediately it was going to be a massive hit. And the most amazing thing is that Paul said this melody just came to him in his sleep. He played the melody for the others, asking them if they had ever heard it, and nobody had. He was sure he must’ve heard it somewhere else, and he didn’t want to be accused of plagiarizing it, but it wasn’t familiar to anyone he played it for. Only then did he know that it really was his song. Can you imagine? Talk about a gift from God! 😊 You talked about how many other people have recorded the song or played it. One of my very favorite instrumental versions was by Jose Feliciano on his album called, “Fireworks“. Try to listen to it. It’s absolutely the most beautiful thing. Listen to it in solitude and it goes straight to the heart. His rendition came out 51 years ago and it’s still the most beautiful version I’ve ever heard.

[@paulkeah-tighii7046]

9yrs old watching Ed Sullivan when the Beatles came on,I was amazed, still listening to Beatles 😎

[@cannonball666]

"Scrambled eggs" was odd in the original "Yesterday" song, but so was "I Wanna Hold Your Ham"

[@MrThedonhead]

I’m pretty sure with a pine like it want to hold your “ they knew the word would be hand

[@kingrobert1st]

Don't forget "All my Washing."

[@slavaukraini404]

And who could forget Attracts Me Like A Cauliflower? It is something John taught the others, word substitution until the right words come. McCartney said it wasn't something he did often, but definitely did on Yesterday as the melody came to him originally but not the words.

[@michaelnorris7353]

To me this is a really hard song to sing and make believable. Paul does it effortlessly.

[@petersmith7126]

When you think that Paul was only 22 when he wrote this masterpiece makes it all the more remarkable, aand you couod easily say the same for all the great songs he and John put out prior to this.

[@BarbarraBay]

Nice vocals by Paul - talented lad

[@charleyfolkes]

That’s a great story about the scrambled eggs! He was out here to do Stagecoach, but hadn’t quite played enough so did a quick hit at a local place, Pappy and Harriet’s .. They announced tickets and in 10 minutes 250 people had already queued up ! Thanks for the great show !

[@eh-i1841]

Little fun fact.When George says ‘tonight,Opportunity Knocks’,he is imitating a tv show,of the same name.Hughie Green was the host,and he turned out to be Paula Yates’ father.She of course was Bob Geldof’s wife,and Michael Hutchence’s partner.

[@yuuya2111]

Well the thing about Yesterday was that, even when I heard that song for the 1st time ever I found it nostalgic and familiar... And it was like, when I was 8 or 9! I am a non-musician but your analysis is a joy to listen to! Thank you to much.

[@ronnie237]

Listen to You’ve got to hide your love away, Beatles.

[@pinball1970]

It's a while since I heard this. Easy to forget it's a masterpiece

[@youssefkasim7556]

George is just too funny, he’s my favorite Beatle. Keep it up man.

[@stan_doucet]

The Beatles sure did alright for starting out as a tavern band. Yep, them boys did go far with songs like this.

[@jessegreen6138]

I never noticed that Paul was playing a right handed guitar for this song. So unless he restrung it. He would have been playing it upside down. Like Jimmy Hendrix did. I have been a big Beatles fan since 1965 and never noticed this. It's to bad Eric Clapton wasn't able to give Jimmy the left handed guitar he had bought for him. Thanks Fil.

[@mightyV444]

@Jesse Green - *Jimi 😉 And yes, you're right and Paul is playing a restrung right-handed guitar. Happy New Year! 😀🍀

[@astronoybrasil7990]

Happy New Year, Friend! All the best It is impossible not to love The Beatles... They were the biggest group of all time... We still need them these days.

[@wingsofpegasus]

Happy New Year to you too!

[@astronoybrasil7990]

Thanks, Mate!

[@kathleenmckeithen118]

I would love to see you analyze Paul singing "Till There Was You". As far as I am concerned Paul did the best job (George's gorgeous guitar accompanying Paul) singing this beautiful classic song than anyone I've ever heard sing it. I believe it was performed on state for the Queen some time in the 1960's.