British guitarist analyses Simon & Garfunkel live in 1981!

[@gejuje]

Imagine having just two voices and an acoustic guitar, and be able to make half a million people go completely quiet, and just listen. That`s a talent very few people have

[@rebeccav9969]

I believe these 2 could accomplish the same feat a'capella!!!

[@golden.lights.twinkle2329]

They weren't completely quiet, didn't you hear the claps and shouts throughout the song?

[@paulajanson8053]

@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 Really? Lighten up

[@MaryEavey-dc3sk]

not all that many and those people were under various influences of the chemical kind. by the end of the song it was pretty darn quiet.@@golden.lights.twinkle2329

[@JR-pr8jb]

"Hello darkness, my old friend." In my 70's I still get goosebumps.

[@christinelamb1167]

Yes!

[@Beckiner67]

And me ❤️

[@Knards]

One of the most beautiful songs in history. Unpretentious, telling a story and sung in beautiful harmony

[@bilbobaggins4710]

His name is Fil 😀

[@hoponpop3330]

That performance was live in front of a crowd of over 500,000 people in Central Park I was mesmerized from start to finish . Art ‘s solo of Bridge of Troubled Water is one of the greatest live vocal performances of all time.

[@albertschepis]

The 25th Anniversary R&R Hall of Fame concert performance (Oct 2009) was as if not more exceptional.

[@jeffferguson899]

I love how they harmonize like no one else and yet you can still hear their individual voices

[@TheDivayenta]

No auto tune, fireworks,- just pure voices , harmonies and poetry. Paul Simon won the Gershwin Songwriting Award.

[@killyourtelevision3742]

Modern pop music is garbage compared to this classic

[@vitahealth.2372]

Karen Nyere I hate Breakups.

[@candicescott7176]

Carl Sandburg, the American poet laureate of the first half of the 20th c., said Paul Simon was the greatest poet of the second half.

[@pcs56]

I think Paul actually said during the show they wanted fireworks, but they wouldn't let them have them. :0)=)

[@kens32052]

And no cellphones.

[@jonathanbartron3658]

Your analysis is, as usual, diamond cutter sharp and on point. You've got a good head on your shoulders, an internet rarity. It's a pleasure to watch.

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@texasstardust6010]

.... Yes indeed, I completely agree.... I found this channel quite by accident and what fun and just amazing to watch Phil do this. 🙂😊💛

[@bettyjane6684]

Yes yes yes!!!

[@katiezee2]

@@texasstardust6010 ..me too, I stumbled on this channel yesterday and can't even remember how.. but happy I did ...

[@waynej2608]

Erudite.

[@sodoffbaldrick3038]

Art can literally sing like this with one hand behind his back...or in a pocket..like he isn't even trying! Amazing!

[@carolwilliams2439]

Yes, Ruth, as he did in this same concert while performing Bridge Over Troubled Water so effortlessly!

[@albertschepis]

Well, he knows how to really sing and not just belt something out. It takes some restraint and control.

[@EgbertWilliams]

I've heard Paul say that Art was given a producing credit early on so the imbalance in their contributions didn't seem so stark. Fair enough, but I've always thought his delicate, crystalline vocals already played a huge part in bringing Simon's amazing lyrics to life. It's not said enough, but Garfunkel was a great singer with a real depth of feeling that needn't be bolstered by paper tributes.

[@Historian212]

Agree. And I love the solo work he did afterwards.

[@bcal4877]

Also not said enough, Paul Simon always seemed like a gigantic douche. Even if it’s true, he’s just that dick that REALLY needed to say it. Best friends with Chevy Chase....kind of says it all...

[@2batgirl]

Part of the reason they were always so popular was the harmonies they did together. And why is it always little Napoleon that needs recognition?

[@patriciaalvareztostado8170]

They were the perfect combination, we know that Päul Simon is a musical genius, but without the voice of GArfunkel they wouldnt have the same meaning and that touch that he give the theyer songs, I love a lot of the solo songs of Paul Simon, but with the songs of Simon and Garfunkel Paul singing that songs dosent sound as good,

[@deed.3230]

Oh yes, it was definitely a team effort:)

[@garyshaffer1409]

Hearing this as a child all those years ago...the feel and the power was huge yet delicate. We all got it and we never forgot it.

[@SnaFubar_24]

I discovered this song in a record shop at 14yrs a year or two after its release and It was for many years my favorite tune. I still get chills as I listen to the lyrics, they mean and meant a lot to me.

[@adrianconley5811]

Perfect

[@darlatidwell9995]

Unison. Beautifully remembered always.

[@albertschepis]

Aptly put!

[@nicestrat]

Paul Simon, man.....dude is an incredible songwriter, singer, musician, producer, etc. Art complimented his voice with his harmony. I'm lucky to have walked the Earth the same time as these two humans. I've seen them both perform "live" together and apart. Never a disappointment! Thanks Fil!

[@catherinehammer8637]

I’ve always loved Simon and Garfunkel, but Garfunkel’s angelic voice always gives me goosebumps, and brings tears to my eyes.

[@davidstevenson6817]

and Paul Simon wrote it … it can’t be sung, if it hasn’t been written!

[@Gd10034]

I was at this show in Central Park. It was just soooo great. The secret recipe for pleasing a large or huge crowd--lots of great songs, all hits (very tough to do) and great musicianship. Their voices blend perfectly; Simon is generally an 'earthy' singer with a pleasant texture. Garfunkel's voice is either strong or gentle and really cuts through regardless of what modality he's in. It doesn't get any better than this and they don't make'em like that anymore. When the video cuts to the people in the crowd you can see that it was largely a 30ish to 20's crowd who were teens or in college or even grammer school when the songs were first out there. So until this concert happened, the songs, firmly set as milestones in the past, but performed ever so perfectly in that moment, gave a generation and a half a huge lesson in (for lack of better words) nostalgia's impact, while we were still quite young. I doubt anybody there ever imagined that they would be seeing this somewhere down the road in their lifetime. It was an unforgettable autumn night in the city with about 500,00 other folks and this pin drop moment is an excellent choice for a review.

[@aka.Mr.French]

I was there, too (age 28 at the time). Magical. Almost didn't go, figuring it'd be a madhouse (which it was); was working late in downtown Manhattan with a friend when it started, and after a few minutes of hearing it on the radio, we looked at each other, said "fuck it," closed up shop and headed to Central Park. I still recall hearing "Slipslidin' Away" drifting through the air as we approached the Great Lawn. You're so right -- an unforgettable autumn night in the city with a half-million people who WERE listening, united in the moment.

[@patriciapalmer3899]

I was there too! Such a gift to have been there. I was 19 & a college freshman who took the train from Poughkeepsie, NY. Magical night. Was also lucky enough to attend Paul’s solo concert in the park. Some of the most amazing musical experiences of my life were at those shows! Can’t wait to get back to concerts in 2021! Thank you Fil as always for your spot-on analysis. 🌹✌🏻❤️🙏🏻

[@Gd10034]

@@patriciapalmer3899 It still pops into my my mind how immense the size of the audience was; I was in the back looking over a sea of heads . One could never ever come close to imagining what it actually looked like, as it was completely unreal just sitting there.

[@cazgerald9471]

It's hard to overstate the cultural significance of The Concert in Central Park. Not only did it reunite the two, but it brought their songs back into public consciousness. Plus they are New Yorkers through and through, NYC was really hurting at the time, and in some ways this was the beginning of the city's turnaround.

[@jamesedwards2237]

You are absolutely right, these two guys managed to really feed off the audience, and vice versa!

[@supasoulproductions]

Best close harmonies since The Everly Brothers! I love how the audience goes off when they hear the line '10,000 people maybe more'. They're like hey, that's us. lol

[@cardboardheadguy7814]

The show was over half a million

[@katherinem.4414]

I think he is talking about now too, read my post. It seems like it may have been a true prophecy, the vision that was planted in his brain. Part of it was about texting, some about idol worship and I think it tells that people about cancel culture, partly because they don’t want to learn from history.

[@katherinem.4414]

The vision describes it as us buried in our phones too much in cyberspace, texting too much, buying too much online, and not listening to the words of prophets, so we don’t waste our time on earth. Idol worshipping. Can’t remember what else.

[@Historian212]

@@katherinem.4414 It's nice that you can relate to the song, but as for the original: no, no one intuited such things as texting, the internet, personal computer screens, or "cancel culture" then. It was about the hypocrisy of those in power at the time who talked a lot, but said nothing of value or meaning in the face of the problems of poverty, racism, war, and pollution that were ripping the country apart. It's a protest against the BS of people who refused to face what America had become; who drowned out real conversation and attempts at dialogue with BS, with advertising, with lies, etc. "The words of the prophets" refers to the graffiti that covered the subways and tenements of cities like NY, which testified to the misery of people trapped in poverty, and cried out for justice. The importance of the biblical prophets is that they called kings and other leaders to justice, and chastised them for their hypocrisy; they spoke truth to power. That's what Paul Simon was referring to.

[@katherinem.4414]

@@Historian212 Who knows?? That is just how I saw it, and one other person did. I do not doubt that people have visions, prophets have proven it, even in detail, because things come true later on. I have heard that young and old men have had visions and dreams of visions, and the scriptures say so. There are also near death experiences. And I hear that women too have some of those. I look for symbolism, because that’s sometimes how the Lord works. He talks in parables because that’s how people understand best. Whether this dream was a real vision or not, I don’t know, but I think that too much of phone and other device use is a form of idol worshipping. I believe that we need to be doing better things once we use our devices for what we need, and how we can communicate with others, or assist them with things they ask for. That is all. Many of us believe differently. I assume that in a way what you said could be true, but it all gets a bit complicated for me to think that way anymore, after my insomnia, sleep apnea and excess stress caused part of my brain problems. I seek for easy and simple to understand, and we have been told by a church leader that the gospel of Jesus Christ is simple, and that by small and simple things are great things brought to pass, just like the helm of a ship, kept guided through the waves, can guide it, no matter how big. I assume that things you say may or may not be true. You are blessed to be able to think through things, and I have lost that ability to a degree. Plus I have been living with family who knows nothing about psychology....so it seems, so we have not had any decent conversations using those abilities, trying to work things out. Not so good for me, I have always liked psychology, but that is what I have had to put up with.

[@varshvarsh9486]

"People writing songs that voices never shared" 100% best lyric ever written.

[@SeanCleverly]

Look out on the audience, this is a moment that transcends time and even the performers themselves. When the audience is so enraptured, they have gone beyond transfixed, they have become part of the performance, part of the experience. I have no doubt that every single person there that night remembers every note, every word and probably still feels the warmth of the breeze on their faces as they think back and smile. Truly brilliant!

[@patriciapalmer3899]

I was there, and you’re correct. Some of the most joyful musical moments of my life were at this concert AND Paul’s solo concert in the Park. I’m a blessed fan. 🌹✌🏻

[@Historian212]

My brother was there. He said it was truly amazing.

[@robertewalt7789]

My wife and I were there, too. Best music performance I ever saw!

[@dalem8332]

Paul Simon is a genius song writer. A wordsmith. Able to paint pictures with his music and lyrics. Excellence! ♥️ Add Art Garfunkels sweet phenomenal beautiful voice with Pauls in sweet harmony and you get a thing of absolute beauty. Perfection♥️ A legendary duo. Simply AWESOME. Such a great body of fantastic music! Thanks Fil! A Great Review and analysis! 😎🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦

[@stephenowens8763]

Crowd actually listens. Sounds of respect.

[@raindeerprojekt4119]

That must be a great feeling...

[@kathyirvine6719]

I hate we don't have music like this anymore, our culture has went down so much. Love these guys!!! Thanks Fil!

[@bekind6763]

Kathy Irvine Have you heard the cover by Disturbed?

[@jettrainbow]

@@bekind6763 Yeah and it's trash.

[@EattheApple666]

Just because its not on the radio doesn't mean its not out there. I never heard bands I like on the radio but that doesn't''t mean it doesn't exist. You just need to look for it.

[@JC-yb3zb]

@@EattheApple666 Agreed.

[@bekind6763]

@@jettrainbow I respect your opinion! Peace!

[@larryclark4297]

When Paul Simon heard Disturbed do The sound of silence he downloaded it onto his phone he was so impressed a song that was wrote in 1965 is still good today #1 Simon and Garfunkel wrote this after Kennedy was Assassinated in Texas

[@Vinniegret]

One guitar, 2 beautiful voices in impeccable harmony. Magic for more than 50 years.

[@dawnmazarati3301]

One of the most haunting, beautiful songs ever written in my opinion ❤ Simon and Garfunkle are magical.

[@jopisano67]

Still a man hears what he wants to hear And disregards the rest. When I left my home and my family I was no more than a boy In the company of strangers In the quiet of the railway station Running scared, Laying low, seeking out the poorer quarters Where the ragged people go Looking for the places Only they would know The poetry here described is one of the best written and so true to this day. Backed up with a beautiful melody. One of my favorites.

[@sjwillis1137]

They were the poets of their day . A bit like Joni Mitchell, but more out on the street maybe .

[@texasstardust6010]

..... I know that they were both sooooo gifted and talented, but , Art Garfunkel has been/ always was my favourite if this duo ..... basically. . .... The voice of an Angel, to me..... And such songwriting skills, and composition. I truly believe that not since the Everly Brothers., has there been a Duo quite like them. .. I don't think there ever will be.

[@waynej2608]

@@sjwillis1137 Laura Nyro. 💙

[@m.l.b.2908]

I just can't overstate how much I love The Boxer.

[@damialle]

A beautiful melody, powerful lyrics and brilliant harmony. Back in the days when many songs, even those on the top 100 chart, often spoke to us, delivered a message and challenged us to think. I miss those days, and Simon and Garfunkel were masters at their craft. Thanks Fil for sharing this great classic.

[@barbaradownie3265]

THEIR VOICES COMPLIMENT EACH OTHER SO WELL 😍😍😍

[@danielfronc4304]

And they complement them very well, too!😀🎵

[@barbaradownie3265]

Daniel Fronc 💖

[@swinetrek]

Pardon!? I couldn't hear properly because you were shouting.

[@jwichman9]

I first learned this song in my second grade music class. I had a very young music teacher who taught us all the current music. Lets take a moment to appreciate all the great teachers in our lives..

[@pcs56]

Man this song is so beautiful.

[@RawOlympia]

The true poets of that gentle Greenwich Village scene ~ oh, thank you, Fil!

[@dos-fslady3140]

Fil -- How do you remember such astounding detail and talk so knowledgeably about such a wide range of artists -- along with technical info, backstory, history of the artist, etc. -- without the benefit of notes? You remind me of every favorite teacher I've ever had -- and I was lucky to have plenty. You are easy to listen to, and everything you say ties together in a cohesive manner, and is riveting. Respect!

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks for the kind words!

[@LazyDonna]

They have such a rich sound you could think that there are more than two voices. Just amazingly beautiful.

[@bradleybriscoe6108]

This is an undeniable classic, in the truest sense of the word. Some of my friends and associates say it's too meloncholy, but I take comfort in songs like this. This song was written 10 years before I was even born. Thanks to my late father for turning me on too timeless and excellent music like this. Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel are true American Masters, nevermind American, they are true artist in the first order!

[@robertewalt7789]

Your father made an important contribution. I hope my son agrees.

[@bimmergeezer]

I love your analysis so very much. You bring a new, higher level of appreciation of wonderful music! Thank you Fil.

[@kay-jf7wj]

So true...

[@tuRbo-_-crOw]

Paul Simon became everything to me. This song in particular. I began to understand the power of poetry in verse. This and 59th street bridge song. I have my poetry to protect me. \m/

[@davedecker1725]

It's laughter and loving I disdain!!

[@juantailor]

And to think he always said writing lyrics was the hardest part

[@KayEl58]

I am a Rock was my teenage theme tune. I am an island, I have my books and my poetry to protect me. I remember Art Garfunkel laughing at it and calling it Simon's paranoid song or something like that.

[@hesavedawretchlikeme6902]

Simon and Garfunkel never ages. They are timeless, and the songs reach across all generations. With the beauty of their harmony in vocals, the story which they tell...

[@hesavedawretchlikeme6902]

I add Phil...failed to mention your broad perspective and exposure of so many other musical artists in such humility. Thank you.

[@SeviNoHeart]

More relevant today in 2021 than when it was written, in the 60's.

[@normalee8702]

spot on Fil...this song is a masterpiece

[@bekind6763]

Norma Lee I agree 👍

[@killyourtelevision3742]

This classic vs. Modern pop music. oh, guess who wins. (Silence)

[@lauriekane4686]

The Graduate was on TV last night! I hadn't seen it in years. The songs of Simon and Garfunkel played such a huge and important role in this iconic film, especially The Sound Of Silence. What a coincidence that you did this analysis tonight! Great as usual, Fil!!

[@lawrencetaylor4101]

The future is plastic. Someone should have killed that guy. Plastic is going to kill us.

[@xyz2121]

One of my favourite movies of all time. And you are right, their music is essential and irreplacable in the film.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

One of the best soundtracks. It is of the moment and forever.

[@sjwillis1137]

Totally . Love that film too .

[@colinsellers9714]

Yes, brilliant film, inspired casting, and Simon & Garfunkel's music seems to match the emotions in the film perfectly. Also, coincidentally, it features the original recordings of April Come She Will and Scarborough Fair, both mentioned by Fil here, lovely finger-picking by Paul.

[@usermo]

Just love their voices together America is a song I really liked by them. Thanks fil

[@lesknight4541]

One of their great songs of messages for that time, and it still hits home

[@redwoods7370]

They made gorgeous, sublime music together. It's a tragedy that their friendship did not survive. I will always be grateful to them. The soundtrack of my teenage years. So many memories! Thank you FIl!

[@Wisdomofautumn]

Fil, you knocked it out of the Park tonight! Such a timeless (and timely) song. The harmonies, lyrics, and beauty of a well composed song. Art Garfunkel always had a sweet and powerful voice. Paul Simon’s guitar playing was so masterful. I could see them playing this song on a corner in NYC somewhere. Wow! You analysis, as always, is much appreciated! Cheers Fil, Rock!!!!!!!

[@cocolossal69]

Paul Simon was the reason I wanted to play guitar. He writes the most beautiful melodies and I love the way he plays. Such a gorgeous sound. He will always be at the pinnacle of songwriters for me. This was a great video, thankyou 💕

[@pookatim]

Paul Simon's songs are poetry. They stand on their own even without music.

[@berulan8463]

Phil: "The greatest songwriters make you think." I totally agree but want to go one step further, they take your thoughts and connect them with your feelings. And that's a whole new dimension.

[@xyz2121]

A sublime performance. Perfect harmonies rendering one of the most poetic songs ever written. They will never be surpassed as a performing duo.

[@seabreeze8894]

Simon and Garfunkel had so many beautiful hits and with such gorgeous harmonies, they were definitely one of my favorites groups. Like you said, the connection is hard to explain or describe. Mesmerizing, captivating, poetry lyrically and musically. Thank you, Fil, for your excellent analysis, as always, and also for your research and sharing the historical and technical information you discovered. 👍

[@marilyncook2706]

I ran across one of your reactions by accident and immediately subscribed. I'm sure I've listened to Bobby Hatfield's Unchained Melody a hundred times or more. Hearing your comments helped me understand why that song affects me so deeply. I appreciate your comments here,also. I have a deeper understanding of the song and an increased appreciation. Thanks.

[@wingsofpegasus]

No problem and thanks!

[@romarobbins270]

I still cry when I hear them do Bridge Over Troubled Waters. They were such a good duo.

[@tm1830]

I’ve always loved this song and how they swap harmonies throughout.

[@debrakish9659]

They didn't swap harmonies in this song. Art sang the melody and only Paul sang harmony here.

[@barbaradownie3265]

FIL YOU ARE SO GIFTED IN MUSIC AND EXPLAINING IT THANK YOU 💖💖💖

[@cherylann9781]

Art Garfunkel had the voice of an angel and Paul was a song writing genius. Art has brought me to tears with Bridge Over Troubled Waters. Well, I guess they both did, Simon's lyrics and Art unbelievable vocal. Transcendent. I was lucky enough to see them in concert at Dodger Stadium and I can honestly say it was one of the best nights of my life, a definite tick off my bucket list.

[@shanemccormick6072]

For Emily Wherever I May find her. Art Garfunkel kills it

[@chefrobert987]

I said, "Wherever" for 50 yrs...but it's "Whenever"...I prefer the former😆😙

[@waynej2608]

Dangling Conversation.

[@Bachconcertos]

I was there at the age of 21 old - it was a free concert in Central Park -;so amazing millions of people and the sweet rich harmonies of Simon & Garfunkel filled the park & surrounding city.

[@KayEl58]

What a masterpiece. I was fortunate enough to see them perform twice, both times in Wembley, in the early and mid 1980's. I remember a TV interview with Paul Simon, I think it was with Michael Parkinson back in the late 1970's. He said he'd disappeared, taken a year or so off from performing and recording, in order to improve his guitar playing. He'd taken lessons and spent lots of time improving his technique. I was impressed that at the height of his fame he'd take the time and make the effort to do that. As a writer he's unparalleled, as good as Dylan but less vague and so he's able to connect more easily and with more people. There's only one guitar and two voices here yet sound wise there are no gaps, no empty space, it's something of an auditory miracle. In this particular song I always thought Paul Simon's voice was telling the story from a human level, while Art Garfunkel's vocals, which are more etherial, were giving us the message from a spiritual point of view. This is one of the best of your analysis videos. Thanks so much 😊

[@shadowsflame_4007]

I love these guys!! They have written some of the most profound lyrics ever written as evidenced by this song. Their music definitely moves me to tears! Great pick!

[@dragonmummy1]

Mark Culley Simon wrote some of the most profound lyrics ever written.

[@stephenmaniloff8493]

Paul Simon wrote both the words and Music..l🎼🎧

[@poodlegirl55]

Listening to your analysis is riveting. I am 65 so I remember when their records came out. I think I wore them all out. I love the Disturbed version too, this song is timeless.

[@bryanmyers1435]

Hey Fil, it shouldn't get blocked since your usage is for educational purposes and not for your own profit. But, you know how that goes. 😉 You always give the artist their respect. ROCK!✌❤

[@Wellch]

Bryan Myers claim the Fair Use claim for educational use.

[@bryanmyers1435]

@@Wellch you got it!

[@lawrencetaylor4101]

Exactly. Fil has a reputation now of being a great humanitarian PR machine for any musician. The only ones that can be angry with Fil are lawyers and accountants, which is another way of saying the Music Industry.

[@bilbobaggins4710]

@@lawrencetaylor4101 Fil??? Hahahaha what kind of name is that 😀

[@lynnarthur1411]

This video brought tears and nostalgia. Paul Simon's immense talent is moving and timeless. Thanks for the great analysis ♥️

[@kasperkjrsgaard1447]

In many ways this can be compared with “The Righteous Brothers” “You Lost That Loving Feeling” you gave us last week. Two harmonies, two great voices, a song thats building up and a damn good song. And a duo with it’s glitches.

[@victoriateague9012]

How real this song is today. 2023 unsettling and tragic.

[@dianefiske-foy4717]

Simon and Garfunkel is a duo that I love listening to. They are excellent 👏🏻🎤🎤🌟🌟❤️‼️

[@johnlowther4927]

“Fat Charlie the Archangel, sloped into the room”... I can see that guy... summoned out of thin air. Paul is a master poet. Paul and Art’s duo work helped a generation through turbulent times (troubled waters) and still inspires, settles, provokes, reassures... Thanks, Fil, for breakin’ it all down in your thoughtful, engaging way. It’s always a pleasure to spend time with you.

[@Historian212]

To the point about the crowd cheering, they cheered particularly at two points during the song: when the lyric is about seeing "10,000 people maybe more," they were cheering because they were gathered in a huge crowd there. There were actually over 500,000 people gathered in Central Park for that free reunion concert (proceeds from the movie/video and album went to benefit the park) -- a reunion that fans had been hoping for, ever since the two parted in 1970. The second point at which a cheer went up was when the lyric mentioned the "subway walls," which at that time were filled with graffiti that New Yorkers knew very well. The city had pretty much gone bankrupt in the mid-70s, due to runaway inflation in the U.S. and the Republican president's belligerence toward NYC. The much-beloved park -- as well as the subways and other infrastructure -- had fallen into disrepair. So New Yorkers identified with the subways and tenements, especially because they knew that Simon and Garfunkel had both grown up in the city, so they're hometown guys who also love it. So while there are definitely performance nuances, situational factors played a part in the crowd's response, too. BTW my brother was there that night. For us, S&G's music evokes a particularly intense moment in time that all comes back when we hear it. Nice research you did on the history of S&G and that song. It's great that the lyrics are still so relevant today; and, like all great art, can be applied to times and situations other than the original one. But be careful about saying "more relevant." You really can't compare the two times like that. It was very relevant in the 60s, because it addressed the hypocrisy of people who *were* speaking verbally, but weren't saying anything worth hearing, because of social conventions, or because they were trying to avoid the important issues of the day (poverty, racism, war, pollution, etc). Of course those are still issues today (alas), but part of the reason the song became so popular at the time was that people were crying out for justice -- "the words of the prophets" -- and were being ignored, or drowned out by BS. And that was the sound of silence. Thanks for featuring this song and performance. I enjoy your videos, you really dig into the details. BTW I love Art Garfunkel's solo work, too, he's done some beautiful songs.

[@ipsurvivor]

GreAt Lyrics, melody, mood, ambiance, harmonies, guitar accompaniment second to the none... And they’re incredible live...

[@MelindadelosSantos]

I hope they’re still friends, and let old bygones be bygones. 😊

[@icanfartloud]

You hear about them performing together?...then you'll know. Of course, they're getting old

[@KayEl58]

@@icanfartloud But it seems the older they get the more bitter they become. Every time I hear them interview they can't help but make a snarkey remark about each other 😔

[@Shred_The_Weapon]

That’s not necessarily old man’s bitterness. It’s part of the culture from which they came.

[@joycejohnson7164]

Yeah, how'd he get so smart?!

[@mikenorton632]

I saw paul interview where he was asked about the "feud" paul smiled and said there's no feud. They grew up together and art has been his best friend as long as he can remember.

[@vivian4949]

Another older musician I loved even though I've only known one of his songs is "Norman Greenbaum (Spirit in the Sky)", for us older folk emotional music was and still is EVERYTHING.

[@lawrencetaylor4101]

I have days where I'll listen to it over and over. I played it for my daughters and their friends, they really think it's cool. And then I tell them about being in the generation fighting Viet Nam, and for the only time we succeeded in stopping a war.

[@vivian4949]

@@lawrencetaylor4101 ........ 🌈 💖 💎 🎼 🎵 🎶 🎹 🎷 🎸

[@ernestogonzales4882]

Simons harmony was all to allow Garfunkel shine!! What a voice he had!

[@barbaradownie3265]

PEOPLE WHO CAN WRITE MUSIC AND NOVELS HAVE AN AWESOME GIFT

[@pureforce469]

Barbara Downie and when try doing it this well it is an extremely rare gift...it actually makes me sad that I don’t have any musical talent, truly it haunts me because I revere it and appreciate it so damn much. Maybe there will be a next life where I am gifted.

[@barbaradownie3265]

Tom zxzu I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE SAYING. STAY INVOLVED IN WHAT YOU LOVE TO DO. SOMETIMES IT'S ALL A MATTER OF TIMING. 💖

[@DAS1962]

Greetings from Australia - this concert was such a huge gloabl event. There were viewing parties, it was truly special. As usual the analysis is so spot on, taking into account the context. Paul SImon's legacy will be as one of the great US lyricists of the last 60 years - he has extended what is known as the Great American Songbook.

[@lynneclarke6265]

Yes, I remember watching it o n TV

[@carolinej3661]

Art Garfunkel's voice was angelic on this! And this might be the most profound and beautiful song of the entire 20th Century - Paul Simon was a genius!

[@stephenbaron5681]

The Central Park free concert was incredible, it was a heavily overcast day with a light drizzle. We feared it might rain, but just as the show started sunshine broke through and lite up a stage prop of a NYC water tower. 500 thousand people cheered and the heavenly sounds of Simon and Garfunkel filled the evening air and the rest is history.

[@carlswenson5538]

This song performance, the great Central Park Reunion concert, hearkens back to the original recording. Just two part harmony and guitar. The 'hit' version had percussion and electric guitars added later, much to Paul's consternation. Rhymin' Simon lyrics at his best. Their early stuff was all about social observation, isolation. miscommunication and loneliness. Paul or Art, not sure which, talked about sitting around practicing two part vocals while looking at each other mouths, just to nail it right. Paul was enamored by the Everly Brothers impeccable two part harmonies and tried to recreate it. Paul, a natural lefty, broke his left hand and had to re-learn guitar fingering. VERY under-rated guitarist. Paul has been writing songs and changing with times and taste for 50+ years and succeeding where many other people have failed. (Many don't know that 'Red Rubber Ball', a big hit for the Cyrcle, was co-written by Paul while in England). These guys are my favorite duo of all time. In case you can't tell. lol Rock on Fil!

[@mrsaturdaynightspecial3055]

I love those guys but Paul is a mid-core guitarist at best.

[@Sg4809]

Like a red rubber ball....

[@cubsrps]

Art was the one talking about how they would practice face to face. Watching the placement of their tongues, so that they could match up exactly.

[@rebekkad.2092]

These two were a phenomenon that will never be recreated again. They shaped the 60s and 70s. Thanks for doing a video on them.

[@debbeborders5762]

This is an incredibly important song. This duo is incredibly important as well.

[@baggerchicforever2687]

The magical time of Art and Simon. ..does it get any better than this. ..this is poetry coming to life. ..the songs of Simon and Garfunkel are timeless. .this song is haunting yet peaceful at the same time. .

[@susanowens8614]

I loved this song back then. I love your critiques on all the artists you evaluate. They are spot on! Still love when you commented on the "Disturbed" cover of Sound of Silence ♡

[@jamesedwards2237]

The harmonies between the two is just simply amazingly wonderful.

[@patricklee780]

Many of Simon and Garfunkel's songs got a huge boost when their songs were introduced in the movie "The Graduate". After that I was hooked on their music.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Patrick Lee I had a special connection to Mrs. Robinson. My mother’s mother was a drama queen and a predator. My mother was plagued by her mother’s faux pas and indiscretion. Great movie and it too has stood the test of time.

[@patricklee780]

@@catherinelynnfraser2001 Yes great movie and the sound track was very appropriate.

[@marcintime]

Beautfiul song. Paul closed his Brussels concert with this number, winding it up by playing harmonics - magical.

[@michaelprozonic]

500,000 people in attendance…all being quiet. Proceeds donated to park redevelopment. “People talking without speaking” was not a forecast of texting. It was about the human connection when you are near someone, feeling the same tings. You don’t need to speak, you just understand the emotional connection

[@tboudreau5239]

Lucky to grow up with this. FABOULOS!!! Not a cryer but this made me cry then and now..

[@cclarke9301]

T Boudreau I feel the same. So fortunate to have seen them in concert in the ‘60’s and many other fantastic groups. What a time!

[@THUNDERWORX]

I think these guys could read the same sentence and it would be in harmony. Great review!!!

[@glenkepic3208]

I was just a wee lad of 8 or 9 ('66?) when family bought the single. Seemed dark which is why we all loved it,

[@karencogs1]

Best harmonizers ever! One of my favorite songs!

[@brianmusson2789]

Have listened to this song sing it came out in the 60s. I was still at school. Still love it especially this marvellous live performance from these two. My generation was so lucky to have artists like this an many others to entertain us. Songs and performances like this should go on from generation to generation as they are so good .

[@CrystalShaman]

Synchronicity- I just watched this very video a few days ago!!...Such harmony they have together ❤...Golden...Legendary...Never duplicated...Thank you for sharing Fil...🙏💜

[@KRAZEEIZATION]

In 1982 I was at my uncles house and he had a VCR and recorded that 1981 concert from the TV. I watched it every time I went there and there was also a Beach Boys documentary and lots of other videos by 60s acts like The Kinks, Joe Cocker, etc. That tape gave me a Rock N Roll introduction at 13 that had me begging for more! That Central Park concert is brilliant and America is one of the best performances on it. The band are incredible too, with Steve Gadd, Rob Mounsey, Anthony Jackson, Richard Tee, Grady Tate, etc. I own the concert on DVD now and it’s still great.

[@chamed27]

I always close my eyes (unless I'm driving 🙀) while listening to this song. It's so soothing...especially if I've had a particularly stressful day..

[@hollypinkley7936]

This song has remained in my Top 10 all-time favorites!!!!! I loved it when it came out & even sang this on stage when I sang for the USO shows!!

[@trinkab]

Love your passion for this! Paul Simon is one of my favorite singer/songwriters. Their 60's songs (they broke up on 1970) and Paul's solo works were ubiquitous in my childhood, Diamonds on the Soles of her Shoes is one of my faves off of Graceland. Pentatonix also has a beautiful version of this, just FYI.

[@aggienodari453]

Fantastic Fil, I never would have connected they way we interact today. "People talk without speaking"

[@Wellch]

Aggie Nodari get rid of your IPhone and vocally talk!

[@aggienodari453]

Lol! I do! I was referring to the meaning of the song. I should have been more clear.

[@PeteFolksinger]

Paul Simon is also a profound poet. The emotion in his lyrics is stellar even before you consider the musicology of the whole package. BTW this is the first song I learned to finger pick, around age 12.

[@karenreardon5398]

Yes... Simon & Garfunkel are incomparable. Thank you Fil.

[@PC-dc1kv]

What angelic voices. ❤️

[@16Alain]

This is the first time I see you so serious, so "into" the words and music...

[@16Alain]

Thank you for the heart Fil.

[@lawrencetaylor4101]

His face shows his respect. As well as his eyes.

[@16Alain]

@@lawrencetaylor4101 I do completely agree with your comment. I just meant that Fil was "completely into it" like in "sucked into it". It was a very positive comment.

[@brianmusson1827]

How lucky to have been around at the same time as this marvellous duo. I saw them together in London at their last reunion and was blown away by their performance. Shame they are at odds with each other. Still a great performance and a great reaction .

[@dvictorbrown]

Leonard Cohen did a reading of this particular composition wherein he quoted the time, date and place that this song was written. Listening to the lyrics without music is moving. LIstening to this poem with music is transcendant. Again, Phil.....your analysis is amazing.

[@Sg4809]

I'm 35, and still say, this is real music and talent and it's a shame we don't hear anything like it anymore, thank goodness for my parents being music lovers and the oldies station growing up

[@billfurman1494]

S&G, if I may call them such, are in reality humble and down to Earth. "I've never been much of a careerist" Art once said. How inspiring!