Great pod. Really enjoyed this. Keep up the great work!
@johngarveyire9 ай бұрын
Good fun, still got some time to go, Hansen will be back and go up the rankings, Captain? Finn? , surprised POM doesnt pop up somewhere, I think some close decisions will be decided on bringing some beef/enforcers. I think the Lions will do it.
@ThomasBarthoulot9 ай бұрын
Have people completely forgotten about Mack Hansen just because he was out of the 6 Nations ?
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Or maybe there are just better wingers than him? You could say the exact same about Darcy Graham. Ireland are the best team, but it doesn’t mean that individually every player they have is the best of the home nations.
@barrydunne80969 ай бұрын
I think he'd get in there if it wasn't for Duhan the tripod.
@Coverdrive509 ай бұрын
I’m always so confused by the amount of people that just go for the Ireland front row. Ireland are an amazing team BUT, they aren’t actually a massively dominant scrummaging side. Joe Schmidt would look at the Ireland/Leinster front row as a potential area to gain an edge over the lions at scrum time
@johnmc38629 ай бұрын
They are all in the Farrell system which is a big plus. Cant argue with Sheehan.
@timslade58089 ай бұрын
Totally agree, we haven’t a dominant scrum against most of the top tier teams in years. Problem is Genge isn’t that much better than Porter and neither is Schoeman. Could be an argument for Fagerson over Furlong but Taidgh is better in the loose. No argument over hooker surely?
@amantedellopera16819 ай бұрын
Ireland had the second heaviest pack at world cup and heaviest/biggest back row
@Frankabagnale339 ай бұрын
They can be hit and miss, that’s true. Especially Porter.
@FR-je9bw9 ай бұрын
Correct. Surely we have a better scrummaging tighthead out there than Furlong who is living on past glories.
@josephharrington71299 ай бұрын
That was really fun. Surprised the Irish team features so much in the starting 15 (am Ireland supporter). But hard to argue. Mostly other nations have not had prominent players, esp in the front row. Back row looks awesome with so many good options. I am most excited by Russell/Aki/Tuipulotu myself as a combo. Would be a nightmare to defend against. Let’s see what another 12 months delivers.
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Tuipulotu tends to play at 12. So you’d have to shift Aki to 13 or play Tuipulotu there. He’s such a good centre though. Scotland lack quality in certain areas (especially the forwards) but imo our depth in the centres is insane. Redpath and McDowall are really good too, but can hardly get a sniff due to the Tuipulotu/Jones partnership.
@oinkanddiefreakman9 ай бұрын
11 Irish 2 English and 2 Scottish. Which Lions XV has had the most players from one nation? Has it ever been just 2 nations represented? Tried googling but got nowhere 😅
@Karma-qt4ji9 ай бұрын
Put another way... 8 Irish, 3 New Zealand, 2 English, 1 Scottish and 1 South African. That makes it 24 years since the last home grown team was selected. Kind of defeats the object
@somersetfan19 ай бұрын
You'd think 2001, when England were pretty dominant, but it was still only 8
@barrydunne80969 ай бұрын
I think 12 Welsh started the 3rd test in 2013, or maybe was 10. I should know as I was there but just remember being so disgusted that BOD was dropped.
@lapisstone32439 ай бұрын
Couple of British couple of Irish and Southern hemisphere lions!
@JosephFallon9 ай бұрын
So much fun - love the format ! Would be a surprise if AF doesn't bring Hansen over FW
@flatulentpaul9 ай бұрын
4. Itoje 5. McCarthy 6. Beirne 7.Doris 8.Earl is the most balanced loose 5 for me. VdF well off his wpoty form at the moment
@richcastle67969 ай бұрын
Martin over McCarthy for me but agree otherwise
@harryjudge81539 ай бұрын
Earl at 7 doris 8 tbh
@barryryan149 ай бұрын
Berine has played 6 twice in 5 years for club, country, and including the Lion's. He's played 100s of games at lock. He said he's a lock. Just because he can play there and there's a narrative about it doenst mean he should. He should be the 1st pick at lock for the Lion's.
@GeorgeChrist-z8u9 ай бұрын
That's the thing ..Next 6N none of those may be on top of game . .More Scottish and Welsh , who lost 20 players recently. And a few of their better players like Jac Morgan , Liam Williams.Lake etc to help , Ireland best win GS next season and England close 2nd . Or thar team is miles off . I suppose when you recruit heavily from southern hemisphere with no blood connection to country , maybe BL tours will be renamed Britain Ireland and Southern hemisphere baas baas
@countycricklewood9 ай бұрын
Itoje????? 😅
@adrianhall45479 ай бұрын
Decent side, but I always think that it's better to pick teams with balanced "units". The back row has worked out well but the locks are a bit off. I'd prefer a mobile lock (Itoje or Beirne) with one of the heavies to start. Beirne is the better player but I'd start with the better lineout man (Itoje ? )and have the other on the bench.
@paulb42989 ай бұрын
Yeah I'm sure the team will be picked on balance and combinations. But I don't think to you can venture to far from that team
@Mikeup1048 ай бұрын
Cant wait to watch the IRISH and british lions tour. Should be a o'hellava time
@SMacCuUladh9 ай бұрын
Mack Hansen is low on the pick list here probably because he was injured and didn't feature in the 6N this year so out of people's minds.
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Exact same with Darcy Graham then. He was in insane form before his injury and was one of, if not Scotlands best player.
@davidwalker2402Ай бұрын
Think this will change after the 6 nations , but all in all looks like a good enough team to beat the aussies .
@rhymeocerous9 ай бұрын
Tadhg Beirne is basically an all round brilliant rugby player
@daviddeane9 ай бұрын
9 from one club in the starting 15? I guess Bath in in the 90's of Llanelli in the 70's were the only other clubs to get even close to that level of domination. Leinster have so many competitive advantages.
@rustyfeatherstone939 ай бұрын
Generally a very good squad - don't think there can be too many complaints. Guaranteed that this won't even he half right by the time of the first test though!
@ZveeboАй бұрын
This is very funny 8 months on 😂 The assumption people had that Ireland and England would totally dominate. So complacent lol The actual Lions team won’t look anything like this.
@AustinLambe-t5jАй бұрын
Leinster Lions?
@patrickmccutcheon93619 ай бұрын
I suspect that in the end there will not be 11 Irish guys. Amazing that 10 of those are from Leinster. Has one club ever had more than five in a starting Lions XV.Partly to have a degree of balance, partly because I expect a few more England players and partly because some will be injured.
@corny1659 ай бұрын
Some of the English lads will properly step into the limelight in the next 12 months too. I'm thinking Martin and Feyi-Waboso.
@JohnWilliams-fk3hb3 ай бұрын
How Jack Willis is not mentioned at 7 for me is criminal. He's by far the best 7 in the NH right now. Earl 6 Willis 7 Doris 8
@amantedellopera16816 күн бұрын
Your joking,van de flier is easily the best,time and time again he never lets either leinster or ireland down,never injured and can and ofte plays all 80 mins
@Foxtonked9 ай бұрын
English bias very strong here (Im english)
@patrickchilds29878 ай бұрын
Bias 😂😂 Earl and Itoje? Please explain
@amantedellopera16816 күн бұрын
Its not your fault 😅😅😅😅
@bolton1219 ай бұрын
It will be interesting to see if Farell is brave enough to pick most of the Irish team. I think he'll try and limit himself to 9 or so
@ColmOConnor19 ай бұрын
9 Leinster players in the starting 15. That would be some kind of record, plus Beirne, who was also Leinster academy (messed up losing that one)
@gerwynmiller9 ай бұрын
Choosing a flanker is always hard but you have to have Tommy reffell
@Simwil339 ай бұрын
I can assure you that you don't
@eamonlyons80699 ай бұрын
Squad yes but XXIII No.
@flatulentpaul9 ай бұрын
Genge not Lions standard
@neillfotheringham211Ай бұрын
Irish front row,Beirne and a.n.other 2nd row(maybe Itoje on bench).VDF at 7,Doris must be 8,so still need a 6. 9,10,11,12 all fine. I would go Jones 13. VDM at 14 a possible but not set in stone. And yes Keenan 15. Schoeman and Fagerson on bench. And please,no Farrell on this tour(too many better options)
@dublin73 ай бұрын
In all honesty the above list is close to a carbon copy of who I'd bring on tour. I have 17 Irish, 10 English, 7 Scots and 3 Welsh - 37 Total. LH: Andrew Porter (Ireland), Ellis Genge (England), Pierre Schoeman (Scotland) HKR: Dan Sheehan (Ireland), Jamie George (England), Dewi Lake (Wales) TH: Tadhg Furlong (Ireland), Zander Fagerson (Scotland), Archie Griffin (Wales) LK Maro Itoje ( England), Tadhg Beirne (Ireland), Joe McCarthy (Ireland), George Martin (England), James Ryan (Ireland), Will Rowlands (Wales) BS FLKR Courtney Lawes (England), Jack Conan (Ireland) OS FLKR Josh Van Der Flier (Ireland), Jack Willis (England) N8 Caelan Doris (c) (Ireland), Ben Earl ( England) SH Jamison Gibson-Park (Ireland), Alex Mitchell (England), Conor Murray (Ireland) FH Finn Russell (Scotland), Owen Farrell (England), Jack Crowley (Ireland) LW James Lowe (Ireland), Duhan Van Der Merve (Scotland) IC Bundee Aki (Ireland), Sione Tuipulotu (Scotland) OC Garry Ringrose (Ireland), Huw Jones (Scotland) RW Immanuel Feyi-Waboso (England), Mack Hansen (Ireland) FB Hugo Keenan (Ireland), Blair Kinghorn (Scotland)
@grahammusto77599 ай бұрын
Cannot really argue with the votes. Ireland deserve a strong representation as they have been a settled team. However, we all know someone on this list is going to miss out due to injuries. Sad but true.
@paulb42989 ай бұрын
I agree with all of it tbh. A lot of lads are nailed on tbf
@JohnWilliams-fk3hb3 ай бұрын
Doris my captain and that side isnt far away. Arguments dor McCarthy,M smith ,Tuiplolutu Blair kinghorn and thats about it. Plus Jack wills at 7
@Garryo1777Ай бұрын
Irish squad with a few token other nations players to play mid week games.A few English players only playing in France will make the team.
@RobbieTaylor-f8q7 ай бұрын
I like that team.
@paulb42989 ай бұрын
Finn russell is such a legend. Hes world class wirh the attitude of a teenager 🤣
@creekyknee8 ай бұрын
And the intelligence of a baby....
@DavidParry-zq6sl9 ай бұрын
Jack Willis deserves a place and at 10 give me Crowley on the bench he can cover 15
@EdwardCorryАй бұрын
So can Marcus Smith
@ronnyjohnson7399 ай бұрын
I would take that team to oz with a lot of confidence in a 3-0 white wash
@surge86019 ай бұрын
obviously haven't seen aus since the rwc, but I'd take the current Welsh side for a 3-0 white wash.
@unleashedmystery9 ай бұрын
Irelands squad just changed to red Jerseys for 2025
@FJM9929 ай бұрын
Elliot Daly getting 0.1% for a wing spot, yet Borthwick keeps picking him 😂
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
He has the remaining 99.9% confidence in him 😅
@AllInTheGame019 ай бұрын
Wouldn't rule out Anthony Watson as a starting or bench Back 3 option in a year's time!
@rustyfeatherstone939 ай бұрын
the best all round winger in B&I in the professional era.
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Maybe a bench option as he can cover a few positions but there are at least five better wingers than him and several better full backs. I’d imagine he would be third choice for England at full back (behind Furbank/Steward). Then you add in Keenan and Kinghorn in to the equation. So he’s probably fifth choice at best at fullback. On the wing then Lowe, Hansen, VDM, Graham and (by then) Feyi-Waboso are ahead of him. All of those guys are out and our wingers too- where as Watson is between a winger and a fullback.
@RazorMouth9 ай бұрын
Can we change the name to the Irish and British Lions? 👀🤣
@justinstephenson93609 ай бұрын
That was fun. A few changes I would make Dan will turn out to be a better choice at hooker in a years time but he does need that extra year Blindside flanker is interesting because it depends what you want. I always like having a tall blindside who can act as a genuine 3rd line out threat. IMO Itoje will play there with Martin going into second row but both Baird and Doris are great options and if Lawes is still playing at the necessary standard he would beat both out. Alternatively if you have a 7 or 8 who is also a line out threat then maybe going for a more dynamic blindside is a better combo - step forward Earl. Openside really depends on how Tom Curry comes back from injury. If he is back to his best he plays and because he is real line out pest that gives more options to change the back row. If not then Morgan was a standout in a poor Welsh team (pretty much the only Welsh player to get a sniff of being in Lions squad although there are some youngster for whom this is a tour too early) Personally I do not trust Russell at FH, if the pack is struggling he tries too hard. I suspect Farrell will get the nod but I really like the look of both Crowley and Finn Smith. Other than that I think the voters were very astute
@bernieob95779 ай бұрын
Farrell Russell on the bench
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Finn is better than Farrell in literally every facet of the game- attack, defence, passing, kicking from hand and probably even dead ball kicking now (or at least it’s closest in this area). The only edge you can give to Farrell is that he’s won more trophies than Russell, but in terms of who is better than Russell wins in pretty much every area.
@silvercfox73669 ай бұрын
Looks spot on to me 😊
@finlaybarlow77119 ай бұрын
definitely a majority English vote
@Johan-rg3vo9 ай бұрын
Can't have lions test team with no Welsh ..
@boluadebowale73419 ай бұрын
I mean there is zero you would acctually consider good enough, maybe as training depth, but not a single one of them either by their current playing standard are anywhere near the 23 if we want to win the series.
@HibeeMcbee9 ай бұрын
We had enough years with no Scots and nobody cared. The Welsh aren’t good enough.
@barryryan149 ай бұрын
You can if other players are better. Wales are at a historic low so I get why there will likely be no Welsh in the starting 15.
@corny1659 ай бұрын
No Warren Gatland now so...
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Why not? Scotland barely got a player in the squad for years cos we were crap, now it’s Wales turn. Not one of their players would get near the starting 15.
@StopTheRot9 ай бұрын
Clearly just us English voting for this one! Mitchell ahead of White and Tomos Williams?!!!
@joeboonmusic40049 ай бұрын
Hardly, considering how many Irish players there are... and I'd have Mitchell over Williams for sure, your'e right about White though.
@raffaeletroiano18719 ай бұрын
The Irish and Irish lions
@nickrad69669 ай бұрын
The Irish and southern hemisphere mercenary Lions
@andrewharris18379 ай бұрын
No surprises there.we al just done Farrell's job for him😅
@Smudger_83.26 күн бұрын
ollie Lawrence
@Driver26169 ай бұрын
Dark horse for the number 10 jersey, Ross Byrne. Watch this space…!
@pr3nd09 ай бұрын
I’d play Marcus Smith over Byrne
@Johan-rg3vo9 ай бұрын
Doris is 8 not 6
@corny1659 ай бұрын
I'd make room for him and Earl. They're both magnificent.
@misterkunnyfunt9 ай бұрын
Essientially the ireland team with a couple of cameos. Hard to argue with it.
@Stephno869 ай бұрын
I know there is a lot of Irish in it already...but i would have McCarthy over Itoje...
@James-ih4gzАй бұрын
Probably at best be only two or 3 welsh a lot of Irish English ane few Scots. Scotland are unproven when it comes to winning championships internationally they haven't won anything significant since 1999. The Calcutta cup is great all that but doesn't have I think the importance a championship win or grand slam win would have. If Scotland won the six nations this year then I could see a pile of Scots get in until then I think be majority english and Irish with few Scots and Welsh
@smudgersmith26509 ай бұрын
I think Courtney will be the number 6 and also as captain, Tommy Freeman will also go.
@Damomasts9 ай бұрын
Henshaw isn't a 13, he's much better at 12. Good to come off the bench. DvDM is dogshit, IFW is far more effective. That's the only change I'd make.
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Haha yeah I’m sure you can accurately judge a guy based off four appearances for his country and one try 😂😂 If you wanna go down that route, he has scored in 25% of his international matches, and VDM has scored in 66% of his (with a much bigger sample size).
@julian2211039 ай бұрын
Not a Taff to be seen, and I don't think they could argue with that!
@surge86019 ай бұрын
Tomos Williams, Jac Morgan (if he gets his RWC form), Tommy Reffell. Maybe Wainwright. That's it, honestly.
@amantedellopera16819 ай бұрын
Farell should be nowhere near that team,a yellow/red card machine.im irish fan but id have smith ahead of him,its not the springboks or all blacks we are playing
@davidwalker24029 ай бұрын
Nah smith will never be the player Farrell is I think this was seen a couple of weeks ago when Farrell wiped the floor with him. Lions are tough and smith is weak in many departments Fiji just ran straight over him…
@patrickchilds29879 ай бұрын
Whilst it is extremely unlikely that Farrell will tour bases on that he wouldn't have played any international rugby That would be the reason for not selecting him rather than this view of his as a card machine. Certainly I don't think Farrell would be 1st or possibly 2nd choise #10 but if he were to go I think he would be an asset as cover but mainly as a squad member. Listening to how the previous lions players spoke of him and his contribution in the last tour as part of yhe leadership group and also in how he helped prepare the test sides when he wasn't playing. Again I don't think he will tour but I would pleasantly surprised if he did
@dulls84759 ай бұрын
15 Ben Earls for me.
@elliotharris39659 ай бұрын
unstoppable
@countycricklewood9 ай бұрын
Should be Irish/Scottish led
@timetherington-judge37199 ай бұрын
Ben Earl on the bench? That would be a crime
@MACCA040518 күн бұрын
BEN EARLE ON THE TOUR WOULD BE A CRIME
@fin-ed6oj9 ай бұрын
Huw Jones is twice the player that Garry Ringrose is
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Yep. Just a case of picking whoever players for the better team. Same with Porter ahead of Schoeman.
@DaSkonk9 ай бұрын
He is in his eye, give over!
@Stevenbfg6 ай бұрын
Yet Ringrose has outplayed him every time they came face to face LMAO.
@rjrrjrrjr239 ай бұрын
Morgan looks to have hugely benefitted from missing the 6 Nations - doubt he could have done any better than Reffell did. Morgan is promising but neither he nor Tommy Turnover come close to the Test 23 and either lucky to even be on the tour for me especially with the likes of Tom Curry and Jack Wills back in the picture
@barrydunne80969 ай бұрын
I think I'd go Doris, Earl and Conan in my back row. And probably Henshaw over Ringrose at 13. Other than that I'd agree with the team.
@davidlaffan88879 ай бұрын
As long as it starts with Peter O Mahoney as Captain
@Stevenbfg6 ай бұрын
POM was basically dropped from the 2nd test against South Africa. His day is done I think.
@amantedellopera16816 күн бұрын
😅😅😅😅not a hope
@billybones61379 ай бұрын
That was my team except for Martin at 6.
@barrydunne80969 ай бұрын
Poor Wales 😏🤪🤣
@imac97899 ай бұрын
Itoje is a penalty machine won't be in the running in a year. Fagerson on the bench likewise an absolute liability
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Same with Andrew Porter at prop then?
@patrickchilds29879 ай бұрын
Perhaps 3 years ago he was giving away penalty's. Certainly not this year or last year. Are you using game stats or guessing ? Ironically I remember some posters saying that before the last lions tour and he was one of the stars. Is your penalty count your main criteria for selection ? Andrew Porter had one of the highest penalty counts in the 6 Nations so are you excluding him from the Lions on that basis despite probably being the best loose head available?
@johnstrac9 ай бұрын
Itoje's a show pony.
@dashingeduardosuarez9 ай бұрын
I was surprised by this too. Thought Baird was the better choice.
@patrickchilds29878 ай бұрын
Love reading when some fans will use their emotional feeling to gauge the performance and imact of an elite rugby player like Itoje and proclaim his as a show pony thinking that over rules stats and pact What is controversial about selecting Itoje ? An experienced and back in playing form. His lineoit stats are excellent as is his work in the loose and defence. Like Bernie his disruption and jackling is excellent. Bernie is also an excellent player and I would be happy with either. Is one noticeably ahead of the other , without stats it is hard to compare. In the last game they met you could argue Itoje dominated. Ultimately it will be Andy Farrell and his team who will Ultimately select which players tours and thankfully they will judge what the players offer rather than who some fans prefer
@LindsayBest9 ай бұрын
I wouldn't even take Russell he is more trouble than he is worth. Scotland have there best team for years but always fail to deliver when it matters and l think Russell is part of the problem.
@creekyknee8 ай бұрын
Agreed.
@ElBauldo64Ай бұрын
You don't watch a lot of rugby then?
@GeorgeChrist-z8u9 ай бұрын
Why bother . In 2012 for 2013 tour. Everybody had majority English . Woodward I think had all Eng /Ire with only 2 or 3 Welsh and zero Scots in 15. FF 2013 6 Nations and it.changed ..tommy Refell Wainwright and if playing as in world cup Jac Morgan ...the most destructive hooked from bench ould be Dewi Lake . .BUT as a follower of lion tours since 77 . I don't know where lions can get new fans from as . Ireland and England have many Southern hemisphere players . .with zero UK bloodline . I stopped leaving for tours when Ben Te'o toured. .started getting ridiculous. Vunipola , Faletau etc who were born in SH but schooled in UK.. .we're a diff thing all together...Te' o landed , posed in IRELAND shirt then played for England . Jesus possibility of starting more player with no Britain or Ireland qualification. Then next tour could change nations and play for S Africa etc against lions. .I think 1 player from each 4 home nations, without strong bloodline to BI or Ire should be maximum. And good bet those 4 would be in test 15 . So even then over a quarter of team will be SH players . Possibility of resembling SH baas baas , rather than lions going on tours. .real possibility of being outnumbered by foreign born than home
@philmus1Ай бұрын
Rubbish, some really one eyed selections
@marktucker79769 ай бұрын
Lawrence at 13 Ringrose not even in the Irish side
@CaptainFantastic-m3r9 ай бұрын
For now. Injuries and fitness issues. Would agree that Lawrence at 13 would be epic. That man is an absolute menace and I feel is so underrated.
@DaSkonk9 ай бұрын
Only because he was injured. Otherwise, he usually starts and runs the defence. He's a Rolls-Royce of a player and should definitely be on that tour and in that team, if fit.
@daireharlin1819 ай бұрын
Russel shouldnt be on the team. Supposedly one of the best 10s ever. He has won nothing. Too focused on himself
@Demondoink19 ай бұрын
Look at Baths improvement this season and then reconsider your position. He hasn’t won much cos he plays for Scotland. It’s like when Parisse was at Italy- a world class player in a poor team. Granted Scotland are a bit better than that Italian side, but they are still not on the same level as the likes of Ireland and France.
@creekyknee8 ай бұрын
Too right, he is simply not clever or good enough.
@THEMRblackboy7thst9 ай бұрын
ben earl for me is a number 8. Strong, agile, quick, powefull