RDR2 Moments The Developers Didn’t Think Through 1

[@shikishimaOW]

the train killed more people in a few seconds than John at the entirety of the prolouge

[@LightningNation]

They got mashed

[@PapaJ608]

epilogue *

[@datmufuca3347]

I’m close i’mm cllloseesee

[@calvinwilder6512]

Epilogue

[@logger22]

I don’t think John killed anyone in the prologue

[@KleinerTimmy9]

The thing they thought through the least is that killing Charlotte's stalker gives you negative honour

[@fxntxsyyy]

same with if you kill arthurs assaulter. i think they shouldve made a few exceptions to the "kill a stranger=negative honor" rule.

[@boidzerg1380]

​@@fxntxsyyy There are a few exceptions. I don't think I've ever gotten negative honor when killing a character that was openly racist.

[@fxntxsyyy]

@@boidzerg1380 well yeah, you also dont lose honor if you kill the aberdeens i believe. i shouldve said a few more exceptions*.

[@blu4390]

@@fxntxsyyyyou don’t lose honor if you kill him AFTER he assaults you, if you do it before then you lose honor which is weird

[@LonghornsLegend]

​@Matasiete1850 yup they are basing it off the knowledge arthur has at that time. Kind of like how if you kill any of the people who kidnap you, like the Aberdeen's during dinner it's negative honor because Arthur technically didn't or shouldn't know their intent yet

[@ravianperez6512]

He killed everyone on board like Omni man

[@Vozars]

dang it i was about to say that💀

[@krishnarjunar2724]

Invincible was the train

[@swaghettimemeballs4420]

Too soon man, too soon!

[@chubbschubbs2x]

What I was thinking 😂😂😂

[@DionyYT]

same @@Vozars

[@yusufsafi7707]

doing anything bad to charlotte feels like a sin

[@morthurarrgan]

So true I felt so bad for Charlotte mostly because she trusted Arthur.

[@Fetidaf]

The player should probably go to jail for that…

[@morthurarrgan]

The Women’s Rights lady on the other hand….

[@RSAgility]

@@morthurarrganIt was a perfect mission in a game mostly played by people like you. Triggered over women's rights, because if women can choose, it won't be you.😂

[@warmcanadain7649]

Imagine how it would feel is someone taught you how to live then kidnaps you

[@Bobby.2tyy]

I think the blind man’s cane was intentional he probably found it and took it

[@YoonSooSuh]

I'm just about to comment that. I think the OP is mentally challenged and think about that.

[@user-vn6ki6gs8w]

​@@YoonSooSuhYou call him mentally challenged and you can't even word properly

[@Pebphiz]

@@YoonSooSuh Why are they using nicely polished walking sticks as garden posts?

[@luckybynn5788]

I like the idea that he wandered into someone's garden and ran into a stick, realized it was loose, and said "This is a perfect walking stick!" and pulled it out and left with it.

[@TheRedRaven_]

Nah I think they just got lazy, I think it’s obvious it’s just a repeated model, no variation so it looks out of place. Imagine if every tree or branch looked the same.

[@wiichoyt]

something else to add, if you tie an npc and leave him on another npc's horse, he will not react in any way and no one will say anything to him for carrying a kidnapped person, not even the police.

[@fael.ferraz]

LOL So weird XD

[@emmanuel3981]

hahahah I found out thiis yesterday xd

[@ashefauxe3369]

"It's not MY fault they're tied up on my horse."

[@memoryloss4327]

Man, so they just hate Arthur >:(

[@Gage-bk7cn]

Thats probably more of a coding "issue" than an oversight

[@TalkingHands308]

Don't know why, but the videos of animals randomly attacking during cut scenes always crack me up.

[@Aganie.]

The trapper talking like nothing cracked me up, shtty hunter 😂

[@WebOfTwilight]

If that’s the way he treats good paying customers I’m not so sure I want to be a customer anymore. 😳

[@conformistbastard9842]

Bc it's funny? Lol

[@Handhandme]

*Arthur getting mauled by wolves* Trapper: You ever been to Johannesburg?

[@broits3am]

I love how as the stalker is literally describing charlotte as she is literally tied up and squirming in his tent

[@Aganie.]

Plot twist: Hes a nice guy

[@Just_A_Guy_Here.]

I'm your 200th liker here & bye.

[@broits3am]

@@Just_A_Guy_Here. thank you for liking I never expected to reach more then 200 likes

[@omglol8425]

@@Aganie.he’s too shy to talk to her

[@jayhill2193]

i hate when the wolf thing happens. Happened to me the first time I visited the trap setter, but the wolves ripped him to bits. After that he gave me crap everytime as if I had done anything to him, so in return I had to actually do things to him, which caused a vicious cycle of animosity.

[@mike954]

I tried shooting the wolf that was attacking him, autoaim targeted the trapper I didn't notice that cause the wolf was on top of him and I ended up accidentally killing the trapper.

[@andrewlowden322]

same but with cougar out near pronghorn ranch. Trapper refused to serve me for a while

[@Dmkls]

Moi c'était chez l'ermite la femme ermite jetait à 2 pas de la cabane il on foncer direct sur moi du coup bah ni une ni deux il mon trop chauffer jetai en mode tranquilou j'me baladais et la direct un carnage j'ai plus de yeux ja pris la machette et je me suis fait plaisir il ne restait plus qu'une infinie marrée de sang dans la cabane de cette idiote. Pareil la grotte du diable j'ai jamais cherché à dialoguer avec des gens de type plante verte. Lui jlai buter. L'homme loup lui c un rigolo le mec il fait le ouf et direct quand tu le course il s'barre

[@tiltedgear7565]

Bear for me

[@DarkPoetDCLXVI]

in my case anything can trigger animosity, xD

[@yuhaye3986]

The pick-pocketer and Arthur were just doing a social experiment

[@omglol8425]

Tailor wins 100 dollars for being a real one

[@yuhaye3986]

@@omglol8425 *John Quiñones walks in*

[@thinkeightsix]

He's not a werewolf. He was a man raised by wolves.

[@jacqulineball2284]

He's not a man raised by wolves either. He studied them, then became a part of them. I think he started off in a job or did it as a hobby, but he kept a journal about it. You can pick it up in his cave once you've killed him. and the wolves. Read that, will tell you exactly what the story is. I haven't read it in years, so can't quite recall it.

[@ep6808]

@@jacqulineball2284 it's his childhood journal. He came from a wealthy and proper family, and his father would take him hunting a lot. He hated it, was always distracted by the beauty of nature, and killing made him cry. His father beat him over it. At one point he read a book about a boy who runs away and lives in nature, which inspired him. When his father beat him again, he ran away at night, and was catching fish for food. In the last paragraph he wrote about finding a den of pups, and one licking his hand, before the pen's ink ran out

[@frocat5163]

That wolf attack at the Trapper hit close to home. A few weeks ago, I was headed to the Trapper near Black Bone Forest and kept hearing a grizzly bear. I couldn't find the thing, so I hopped off my horse and started selling furs. I hear Arthur say, "Get back!" which really confused me. All of a sudden, I was getting mauled with no weapons in hand. I was able to break free and kill the bear...at which point the Trapper decided I had committed a crime and ran off to report me to the law.

[@ashefauxe3369]

The bear was his wife :'(

[@Aganie.]

*Every pelt is a little different, because every bear attack is a little different*

[@felixvillegas8642]

@@Aganie. You find them no were alse...

[@Hyperstimulation]

Oh… Back so soon?

[@NinjaEdits14]

Arthur just taking Charlotte to the stalker 😂 3:28 Also the stranger: u got a girl mister? Arthur: yeah I got it here!

[@Морскаявода-т2м]

I read: I got it three!

[@JvanEdits]

I had three once

[@YodaClips]

​@@JvanEditsno

[@JvanEdits]

@@YodaClips jvanno?

[@zonesquestiloveunderworld]

I read: I read: I got it three!

[@Vozars]

I think the trains are coded to just stop moving when crashing into each other, but with mods the trains just go insane like that

[@placeholder7852]

Yeah it's not the game's fault if something can only be achieved thru mods

[@coxnevin]

I did it on ps4

[@Vozars]

@@coxnevin prob a glitch then cuz normally the trains just stop

[@coxnevin]

@@Vozars it was probably the specific train, it was one of the random encounter trains.

[@Nordic_Mechanic]

@@Vozars Also did in on xbox one. There was 2 trains, one slightly faster than the other and it caught up . I spent a lot of time on the train, online. Happened twice

[@dragoryuu9506]

Also R* gives you second holster in a main mission only for it to disappear in every cutscene.

[@HeyMomonia]

Yeah i actually only realized that today And you don't even have an option to remove the second holster

[@Spliffy8]

i just did the first marko dragic mission and my off hand holster was shown

[@blakecacini8016]

Because they know it looks ugly as hell.

[@PatienceKiss]

Imagine the horror of sitting in the back of the train watching a ghost train quickly phase through the cabins mulching people as if it still had mass

[@davidwas77]

*arthur holding girl* "You got a girl mister?" "Eh, not anymore."

[@-yeme-]

if you kill/loot the guy who picks your pocket, he has a lot of money on him. it scales with how much youre carrying, so if you have, say, a few thousand, he will steal a few hundred, when you loot him you get several hundred back, way more than he took. same for the one in van horn.

[@ericbelander2319]

Can loot this particular npc by hogtying?

[@MiniNinja62]

@@ericbelander2319 Yeah you can, I think he stole like 300 from me and I ended up getting 800 from him after I hogtied him

[@frocat5163]

Can confirm. The one in Van Horn got me a while back when I was carrying around $15,200. After looting him, I had just over $16,000, meaning he had around $800 more than he stole from me. Good times.

[@aleatoriokkk3001]

was robbed in saint dennis, i had like 6 thousand dollars and after getting my money back i knocked him and looted like 3 thousand more

[@Just_A_Guy_Here.]

I'm your 100th liker here & bye.

[@edwinmaki6817]

At around 5:19, the EXACT moment you shot the werewolf, an ad popped in and I thought it was part of the video for an embarrassing long time

[@sweatybattlefrontplayer715]

lol what was the ad about?

[@Krenisphia]

The phantom train plowing through all the passengers is just wicked. Wickedly awesome.

[@goldensoul1842]

Say what you want about this game, but the story was severely flawed. Unless he was super human, how did Uncle survive all those years with Lumbago? It's very serious you know.

[@spiderbull274]

Such a slow an painful death 😢, he was torchured all these years😢.

[@Superkuldn]

And he managed to survive even more time in Rdr 1. What kind of a human being would be able to do that?

[@NJkidGamingRoom]

That's the 1 shot kid, put some respect on Uncle's name

[@buttered__toast_2899]

Because he channeled the power of Lumbago

[@kushtakathenomad8385]

@@Superkuldn It wasn't actually the bullets taking Uncle, it was Lumbago claiming him after all the slow and painful years of torture it caused.

[@runpullfourskinz6796]

As someone who's witnessed multiple train collisions, that's totally accurate.

[@brookeraquel2151]

what kinda life you live to be witnessing multiple train crashs😂

[@thetf8142]

The fact that the developers didn’t think we’d shoot Micah straight in the head at the end of the game is hilarious Micah will literally walk off 6 shots straight to his head and then just shrug his shoulders and collapse 😂

[@miguelpatino3856]

They also didn't think you'd throw a stick of dynamite at Micha while he's behind cover. Either that or Micha is somehow immune to explosives lol

[@strawhousepig]

I thought I'd do a big brain move and take the old soldier that thinks the war is still on to the fort where he could re-join them and they could tell him it's over. Got wanted for kidnapping instead.

[@katrina917]

This game feels incomplete sometimes. Like how the boats don't have anyone on them, and just sink when you reach the boundary

[@jacksepticeye_fan084]

Bc it is incomplete there's an entire chunk of the story that got removed abt Arthur going to New Austin at some point

[@EluciaDeLuteIma]

2:18 I hate how this game hand holds you into doing things. Staying and fighting is very possible, but rockstar doesn't allow it.

[@KNAFHLCJPT7A8EU3]

Rockstar: this game will be based by players choice. Players will be free to do the missions on their way. 2:16 Rockstar: No no, you aint suppose to do that.

[@Jeromebeckam]

they never said that

[@dustinpowell6507]

The rockstar way

[@BeTheDogYT]

The mission ended because you are supposed to stay next to Monroe and Charles, not because you kill all the men. The point of the mission is to escape. How tragic it must be to play the story as intended

[@catwithevilintentions2632]

​@Sushiette They promised the ability to explore the map, not explore the map while you're actively partaking in the story. This is literally just not your style of game, you should go play Skyrim or something.

[@Nordic_Mechanic]

follow the darn yellow line, kill the red dots. Over and over and over

[@Lone_Coyote]

4:56 thay cut was so funny man LMAO.

[@blackknightz5036]

There are stupid moments when you are clearly in the right yet you are still punished for it, losing honor or having a bounty on your head etc..........For example i walked into Van Horn saloon without messing with anyone, just head onto the bar for a drink then suddenly one guy started insulting me and started a fistfight, his friends joined in too, after beating their asses the other guys came over and fight me, one guy pulled a gun on me and started shooting which caused the entire saloon to open fire on me and lead to a gunfight with the entire town, i lost a shit ton of honor because of that.

[@ordellwinnfield7228]

Classic Van Horn trap! Going into this shithole's saloon for a whiskey always ends up with the street full of corpses..

[@NihilistCrab]

@@ordellwinnfield7228 Strangely I never had much trouble in the saloon there. There was the one time I dropped a spare fish I couldn't be bothered dragging to a trapper/butcher in front of some people gathered round a fire who started shooting at me. Just like the saying goes; "Give a man a fish and you'll have to shoot half a town in self defence."

[@marinablack181]

All you have to do is ride around st denis greeting everyone for 5 minutes to get back full honor

[@jesussaves21]

Agreed

[@RG.Ace87]

I feel the developers meant to do that with the old man’s cane, shows he’s to poor to even buy a cane and get see a store to get one so he used whatever he could find

[@Phyaflates]

8:37 Dudes fate was sealed...

[@nick_laze4930]

"what's your problem? I didn't do nothing" Well he's right

[@fox5animations790]

8:11 arthor gets sent to the backrooms

[@Matt..S]

Arthur got his honor back. It wasn't about the damn money.

[@lilhedgehog8576]

2:14 bro I’ve never seen somebody fail a mission because they were too good. That is hilarious!

[@lilhedgehog8576]

2:08 he’s just standing there! 😂😂

[@oilybat3269]

Also the wooden sign in Rhodes that says “no vacancy” because the hotel is eternally occupied

[@zone._9199]

7:45 *Arthur being mauled to death* Trapper: "You been up to the northwest of Annesburg?"

[@doctormahrio5226]

That first clip....Omni Man would be Proud

[@Vincifier]

On the Bounty mission for mark johnson, if you go a different way you dont have to run into his men, but he does break free from ropes still.

[@googleviI]

Thumbnail clips starts @7:00

[@ausername1972]

3:52 So you got a girl, mister?

[@nerdtom4513]

Arthur: "Eh... not anymore" Says that while carrying the literal woman the pervert is talking about💀

[@lilhedgehog8576]

2:49 oh shit bro got a cane farm. And I’m not talking about sugarcane !

[@Ripper_Indoraptor]

0:11 Arthur yelling: "stop right now or you're dead!" *Him glitching through the other train and driving over all the people in it who didn't even run away*

[@billyyank1916]

If I got killed by a wolf while buying something from the trapper, I don't think I could pick the game back up in at least a couple weeks.

[@Ic3h0rnEt14]

Love the outro! "Okay, I'll catch you later then."

[@luckybynn5788]

It should be a good video when I'm not even 10 seconds in and Arthur just casually Omni-man's a train.

[@mrdarksky5746]

😂 no kidding, it literally reminded me of that scene

[@Leo-99-99]

1:05 Let's just say Arthur felt the thief's hand in his pocket.

[@thisguy165]

8:39 MICHEAL! DONT LEAVE ME HERE!

[@2BigFooted]

Hundreds of hours in this game, loads of easter egg video's, i never knew there was a werewolf in this game!

[@Shadowswolf9666]

So Theatre one can be explained easily. Its the same as having no money but being able to turn in debts as Arthur, except in this case John (getting ready to propose in this mission) obviously planned how much money he would need and kept it off limits for any other purchase. Kinda like paying electric bill with last 130 dollars.

[@zionsmith2944]

Those trains “colliding” reminded me of that scene from invincible

[@johnpurdy3336]

That scene was BRUTAL 💀

[@ColliCub]

It would’ve been a cool design choice when observing the garden stakes and seeing that it’s same as the blind man’s cane, you can clearly see that one is missing.

[@MrBlack252]

Considering everything they did think of I think it's ok if a few nonsensical things, half of which are only possible through mods, are littered about.

[@luboskoondrejo9050]

7:21 same happened with bear

[@fleetwoodsoup7443]

I remember my broke ass in my first playthrough having that same encounter over and over in saint denis 😭😭

[@titoluro512]

THERES ONE YOU MISSED Bounty Hunters attacking you when going to charlotte's house, they will enter, shoot while on a cinematic and when you wake up on the bed they will now make damage to you.

[@abhijeetkundu7123]

In Rockstar games, trains are always unstoppable

[@Zack-sy5vo]

What’s the outfit for Arthur here? 1:14

[@BrandonDuckett]

Train went full Omni man on the other train.

[@nicklasveva]

What's amazing to me is the fact that people are finding new details and missed details to this day.

[@danmcgladdery1813]

Mercilessly bullies John for being mauled by a pack of wolves. Gets killed by a wolf 😂

[@L33M_0]

7:55 I’ve had a bear attack me once trying to buy garments

[@thetwistedsamurai]

It’s weird how on the first one, the train stops, so it clearly can sense the other train. They just didn’t add collision or anything lmao

[@saskiamalminen]

i got attacked by a bear at the trapper and got a bounty for disturbing the peace

[@PastaMaster115]

Oh my god. Bringing her to the stalker just changes the whole context of his dialogue lol

[@BlackNoir-y8j]

Bro invincibled the whole train

[@chrissavage1449]

Arthur straight up Omni-Manned that first train😳

[@highX-911]

The train said: sorry but this not scripted

[@TopHat_Drago]

The amount of lost honor you got from the first one is crazy

[@Ravvox]

Good to see that Rockstar left at least 10 glitches in the game. A game without glitches ain't a proper game

[@thingyithink]

“What’s your problem, I didn’t do nothing!” he was telling the truth

[@lucwijngaard8413]

"You got a girl mister?" "Yeah, right here on my shoulder!"

[@landon8590]

HAHAHA THE WOLVES PART

[@Onyx_-gq9si]

So... You got a girl mister? Yeah, she's just on my shoulder

[@thirdbrother4018]

7:10 "Common human go get yourself some warm wolf skin I dare you."

[@adyndickey4211]

WE GOING TO THE LAW MAN STATION WITH THIS ONE💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@PureMotivationPower]

Wait there is a goddamn werewolf. Bro you add so much that 99% people never see but dont think of 2 trains collapsing

[@caidenmceachern354]

That train collision gave me ptsd. THINK MARK!!!

[@Priyankaagoswami781]

The robber stole abigail's only fans account

[@santa_fighter]

man the robber in saint denis if he rob you with money you can get it back and if you rob him he has 600-900 by himself

[@reddragon4176]

0:10 Merryweather Fleet's Here Bro!

[@blurredwolf2339]

2:42 nah they're all just stolen from the poor guy

[@towardsthetruth1603]

Gta v - Invincible Train Rdr 2 - Invincible Train with no more passengers.

[@Tubeite]

Your average triple A game experience.

[@williamhayashi2190]

There are no cougars in missions.

[@nailstrabbit4895]

2:06 bro was flabbergasted

[@crickaless]

When he said he didn’t do nothing he was telling the truth

[@raggedybun]

The trapper, during the wolf attack: 🧍

[@meetthedawg]

"You got a girl, mister?" Yeah in my hands.

[@Neoheim.]

2:12 did you give Arthur Morgan the gun that John Wick uses?

[@Lunar_TV]

Bro casually became an urban legend at the end at the

[@LyraleiYT]

4:56 he deserved that for being a dumb npc/ ai

[@dardosalinas4426]

0:00 Arthur talking to the train. Train:i need to transport them!!!. Arthur:No Arthur: maybe this time you ill learn.

[@halftimex25]

The werewolf one should be in a mythbusters episode. i saw him a few times but could never track him down. dude just vanished in the woods and no trails would be following him. Was getting annoyed because i could never catch the dude.

[@disguisedNightfall]

The girl just died after arthur punch her 8:23

[@Greeanerbeans77]

Ig the blind man’s been to rhodes

[@Shadowswolf9666]

Man out here being Omniman with the trains right now 😭😭😭

[@callumrangan1061]

Well to be fair for the Charlotte one, the devs probably didn't expect you to be able to remember where the stalker was, if he spawned, or you to be that much of an asshole

[@Grassgrassgras]

wasn’t an asshole thing to do took he straight up to her stalker so she could watch him out a bullet in between his eyes front row seats g

[@CodPatrol]

@@Grassgrassgras yeah kill whoever you want when Arthur has done worse things the whole game

[@NeverOhVer]

The train thing is just Invincible.