Brothers (English Version) - Vic Mignogna

[@Dextroyfuller]

"What's gone is forever lost / Now all we can do is live." Last line strikes like an arrow to the heart.

[@CragusMaximus]

T_T IT's so painstakingly true and that's what hurts. :/

[@markusmlo8693]

i got hit by an Feel arrow and its now stuck

[@andrewmichael4238]

sames

[@Pichi-lv6yx]

It hurts even more when you realize that Al is singing the last line...

[@JayWalkerOnline]

+Dextroyfuller It really does.

[@sianerb9360]

It's a terrible day for rain...

[@epicjoyfulcreations4580]

+the_geeky_sandwich you need to learn to "bury" the past

[@emmigummi2895]

Don't do this.

[@emmaroberts2030]

What do u mean? It's not raining.

[@emmigummi2895]

DONT DO DIS

[@emmaroberts2030]

Sorry...

[@wyrmur727]

I will always wish I had never seen the series before. That way I could see it all over again for the first time and remember the feeling I'd gotten from it, because no matter how many times I watch it, it's not as magical as it was when I first saw it

[@allora5449]

You and me both. :) Still love the series to death though no matter how many times I've seen it!

[@DinoDays703]

teamleobaby same one of the few series that's makes me want to erase my memory and see it again.

[@natsudragneelmusic3188]

THE_NATE_PROJECT I wish could watch the original.😢🐉🐘

[@cicero2548]

I feel the same way about the mangas now I finished them yesterday.

[@psyhense]

The magic is still here, you just have to remember how to see it

[@rachelgiallella4121]

I think I like the Englishversion mainly because Vic is Ed's VA so its like Ed is singing it And that just brings on more feels

[@impelcrato9258]

+Keiko Kitten it is the VA of Ed singing it

[@HeartlessDragonX]

+Keiko Kitten Personally I prefer the Russian version but this one affects me more... probably because I can understand what he's saying.

[@iMonikah]

+kian raissian He knows? That's what he said.

[@sketchieakechi]

+Keiko Kitten IKR

[@TheAlkochochlik]

+Keiko Kitten I am NOT saying that this version is bad, but in the original song the second part was supposed to be sung by Alphonse (I guess) and it had more sense.

[@mewfangirl1052]

This is my only complaint about Brotherhood. That they didn't use this song.

[@aysa2817]

I Agree with this statment

[@TheRagingNative]

+Mew FanGirl THANK YOU I prefer Brotherhood in every way but having this in it would have broken my heart in all the right ways

[@biscuitismc]

Also, there was no mini skirt scene

[@aysa2817]

+Biscuit Is "I LOVE DOGS!"

[@CassiePaff]

+Mackenzie Macdonald Dogs embody loyalty they follow their master's commands above all else! Be a jerk to them and they don't complain and they never once beg for a paycheck! Trust me Fuery they're the great servants of man! Loyal canine how we salute Thee

[@ave_r_ie]

I... I'm not crying... winry just hit me with a wrench

[@Warrior_of_Symbolica]

same bruh

[@goldenwest4944]

Same here brother

[@ExceptionalOneStandAlone]

Same

[@AuthorJakeAStrife]

Winry must have hit me with a wrench a lot of times since the 2000s...

[@unknownperson5455]

Sniffel sniffel I just peeled an onion shut up

[@GangstaKenny10]

There’s no such thing as a painless lesson. They just don’t exist. Sacrifices are necessary. You can’t gain anything without losing something first. Although, if you can endure that pain and walk away from it, you’ll find you now have a heart strong enough to overcome any obstacle - a heart made fullmetal. -Edward Elric FMAB Episode 64 Journey's End.

[@jayayay]

+GangstaKenny10 Omg, that is like my freaking favorite quote eva

[@TigerW0lf]

😭 We must never forget the lessons learned from hardship

[@WordNoble]

"Nap time!" brotherhood part 3, god damn it Alphonse your great.

[@fightingmedialounge519]

What about talking that wasnt to painful to learn

[@JediAcolyte94]

+Patrick Allen Montgomery When does Alphonse say Nap time?

[@pirateguykarl]

Vic is a dedicated man! He truly loves the roles he plays.

[@katythekawaiigirl2527]

Tara Burris he really does put his heart and spirt in his roles

[@stronglabyrinth1772]

yes yes.. tamaki is his favorite according to him

[@katecoman521]

Jumin Han actually as of recently, Ed is his favorite but Tamaki is a very close second. I got this information from the panels uploaded to KZbin

[@findme-1036]

@@stronglabyrinth1772 nope he love ed more.

[@suhani2795]

@@debisboy too soon

[@RAP24842]

It would have been nice if Alphonse's voice actor sang the second part

[@Leighton7989]

Fun fact: Vic invited Al's VA to sing it with him, but at the time, Al's VA was still a child/teenager and had school etc., so he couldn't.

[@the_polar_bears_got_me]

+LN770 THAT WOULD HAVE AWESOME THOUGHT XC

[@tvmcrusher]

when something being awesome becomes more important than it being correct that is when fundamentalism is born

[@Leighton7989]

Jesse 'that's far from the truth' then 'that's partially true' -- which is it?

[@Leighton7989]

But that doesn't make sense. Something can't be far from the truth while also being partially true.

[@MasterJennaMcLain]

I love this song. It's like a dialogue between Ed and Al, with Ed's words for the first half and Al's for the second. It's so beautiful.

[@crystalkamits-rivera913]

I agree! This is a great song, but is it just me or he sounds like Edward too?

[@crystalkamits-rivera913]

NVM!! O_o LOL!!! OMG! Vic Mignogna is the English voice actor for Edward. Gotta love google! LOL

[@edwardelric2316]

Crystal Kamits Shocking though that he also voices Broly from Dragon Ball Z.

[@MasterJennaMcLain]

Edward Elric You HAD to bring DBZ into FMA. They are completely different anime. Please leave DBZ where it belongs, no need to bring other anime into this.

[@edwardelric2316]

MasterJennaMcLain Calm down there kiddo I was just giving out information. Also there's no rule that says I have to talk about the song or about what other people are commenting. So you'll just have to get over it and move on like everyone else. -.-

[@EXPLOSIONanimeTV]

Dude can sing, dude can act. What more could you ask for XD so lovely

[@thehavoccompany-a3]

Let a man have his beliefs. He is not nearly as bad compared to many other people out there.

[@tasha5419]

AMEN!

[@Ekraelum]

I finished the series (2003) today. Came here to cry.

[@-MissMochi-]

have you seen the conqueror of shambala

[@Ekraelum]

Wolf Spirit Yes I did, and I really loved it. But I still cried with the end. xD

[@-MissMochi-]

+Seychermanium the 2003 had such bittersweet endings!!

[@Ekraelum]

Wolf Spirit Indeed!

[@paz5655]

I saw the original first, then watched brotherhood. Such a great story.

[@SkyPikachu1]

Vic is just a perfect voice actor

[@frostfire2679]

Just dont call him short or he will rip of your legs and stick them to your head...

[@simply.supernova]

Sup Colonel? :D

[@Sunshroom_02]

I agree Vic is a perfect voice actor. W.^

[@eckat5]

Awwe... Mustang likes Ed's voice -let's all dwell in the touching moment-

[@Sunshroom_02]

Emily Katherine -dwelling-

[@EternalSkyDreamer]

;-; FEELMETAL ALCHEMIST.

[@stolen_stardust]

feelmeetal alcheemeest I'm so sorry but that's just fun to say Oh god I've completely ruined everything i'm so sorry

[@EternalSkyDreamer]

+Pikagal 31 no ;^; THIS IS GENIUS bless u person xDD

[@stolen_stardust]

xAtha-chan hOORAY I'M NOT BEING SHAMED FOR THIS ;w;

[@andrewmichael4238]

it's FullMetal Alchemist . Get it right

[@EternalSkyDreamer]

+maka albarn it's called puns my friend, we're all aware it's fullmetal alchemist xD

[@nezuo3687]

“So where do we go from here?” “And how to forget and forgive.” “What’s gone is forever lost,” “Now all we can do is live.” That is exactly how I felt when I finished the series...

[@Hadi.ClashRoyale]

Fr

[@QueenCreeps]

Vic Mignogna can sing?! HOLY CRAP, HE SOUNDS AMAZING :D

[@sheanartisthunty]

he's got multiple songs out 😍😍😍

[@alphablazer9750]

My favorite is DBZ Kai opening

[@mikoajgabor8117]

One piece opening :D

[@stronglabyrinth1772]

he does tamakis character song tooo

[@Mitch7297]

also Dragon soul dragonball z kai

[@lizbizwiz1238]

I feel that this song is just for siblings in general and just tugs at my heartstrings, especially as the oldest of three.

[@tenshishimura]

Definitely.

[@victormanuelcorpeno1095]

Always has been

[@sweetcinnamonpnchkin]

Never thought of it that way and now, as the oldest, I’m crying.

[@CyberEJ]

Wow. It hits so much harder when you know the words

[@DeadlyCyanide1]

He made up his own words for this song. He did it for shits and giggles but dear god it hits hard.

[@RK-ew6wv]

No the original lyrics are in Russian.

[@Dixxi91]

Strongly recommend you look for the translation of the Russian lyrics. Read the lines in English text while listening to the Russian song. That hits me the hardest. And the Russian singers are magnificent. I just came here now because someone told me there was an English version and I had never heard it before.

[@danteastral9665]

BRACE YOURSELVES THE FEELS ARE UPON US

[@baeleilloyd28]

...too late. *dies from overload of Feels*

[@danteastral9665]

Orion Heartling NOOO

[@queenoftears03]

Orion Heartling NOOO!!!

[@dameonpie]

Orion Heartling NOOO!!! WHY ORION YOU WERE SON YOUNG YOU HAD YOUR LIFE AHEAD OF YOU ohhh his wallet -walks away with his wallet-

[@NoBodyToDanceWithMe]

Orion Heartling NOOOOOOO!!!!! wait, did that guy just take a dead man's wallet? wtf man? no respect for the dead?!

[@Jaknaboi]

I love how this songs reads as a conversation between edward and alphonse, one regretting his pride, the other reassuring him they share the blame and that they need to move on. I get chills every time i listen to it.

[@MyArmorFlo]

I think it's even more beautiful that Vic (Ed's voice) sings even the part that was meant to be about Alphonse. Like this, you realize Al's voice, his body, was taken away from him, and Ed is weeping through what he would say. No, I'm not crying, I swear---

[@SnorriSnibble]

Well, I have not seen FMA, but this piece of music is beautiful. I'm crying.

[@rustyshackleford932]

+Snorri Snibble Watch it. It's totally worth it.

[@SheenaMalfoy]

+Snorri Snibble You totally need to watch it. Brotherhood too.

[@HeartlessDragonX]

+Snorri Snibble If you watch it (you should) you'll cry more.

[@weegle.]

+Snorri Snibble HOW DARE U NOT WATCH FMA!!! DO IT! DO IT NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@SnorriSnibble]

Nah, I'm not that into anime. No matter how good the story may be.

[@jennifercooke1094]

Hot damn ed can sing!

[@zoepatrick8603]

Actually Vic Mignogna can sing ;3

[@emoimo4171]

... He was a professional singer before he became a voice actor.

[@jennifercooke1094]

Oooooooooh, okay.

[@nekochiyu5060]

That...That explains a lot

[@jessicachoun4886]

Sure .....

[@sombreset9792]

Brotherhood is not about the two brothers in particular as much as 03. There’s a large cast in BH, and the focus is much more vast, and has a certain type of optimism that 03 trades for its specific brand of tragedy. This song is much more appropriate for 03’s identity in particular, with the two brothers only having each other through all their suffering, and largely still keeps this show (which is also great just like BH) in the minds of FMA fans. I’m glad 03 got this special song, and that it is EXCLUSIVE to the experience of 03.

[@doubleflores8350]

Couldn’t have said it better myself.

[@ameliaclauss4053]

Feelmetal alchemist.

[@andrewmichael4238]

FullMetal Alchemist! GET IT RIGHT!

[@ameliaclauss4053]

+maka albarn I know. i'm calling it feelmetal alchemist because the story is filled with feels.

[@andrewmichael4238]

+Amelia Clauss ooooooohhhhhhhhh, ok. I'm stupidly oblivious, lol

[@Adrii_aciid]

I like that

[@laweda1218]

jaja word... word all of the feels

[@cryptidworthy]

It's like a scene from a Disney movie. That's how perfect Vic's voice is.

[@mariekano9730]

Yes!!

[@sova1235]

"What's gone is forever lost. Now all we can do is live." this sentence gives me chills.i can just imagine Ed and Al, not knowing what to do, being lost and just having to accept what happened to them, trying to find a solution and still living their lives i can't put the feeling into words, just them being like:"brother... what do we do now?" in a very sad and hurt tone, it makes me cry when i think about this sentence and what they must've been thinking and going through

[@Merisu_Sheep]

I couldn't believe this was sung by Edward Elric [Vic Mignogna] he sang this so wonderful. I wish they could've got Al [ether actor] to sing is part

[@wumboace5410]

He didn't wanna but you can see short little videos of them singing it together

[@CrescentMoonDancer15]

There is one where a youtuber sung for Al's part and OMG they sound so much like Alphonse it's not even funny. It's really good

[@Merisu_Sheep]

CrescentMoonDancer15 could you send me a link pretty please to that video

[@CrescentMoonDancer15]

Sayaka♥ Ichigo♥ Kamishiro [SIK] There you go! Hope you like it, I sure did! :3

[@Merisu_Sheep]

CrescentMoonDancer15 Oh I'm sorry but I don't see the link

[@Soul_Resonance]

Vic is such an amazing singer 😃

[@CrystalTheHedgehog]

Agreed

[@danishdarkstar3250]

As an older brother who messed up big time this song kills me, when I realised what I've done it was already too late and now all I can do is live carrying the burden till I die or maybe the burden won't end if there's a hell.

[@sageof6pandas233]

Powerful message

[@Madison-fc5pn]

Omg I haven't even seen the show yet and I cried..

[@oliverisboring6041]

Cat Cake72 At first I didn't want to watch it then I saw the video 'dont call Ed short' and I regret nothing. 10/10 anime

[@emilyg8076]

Watch it, though beware feels MAY/WILL SLAP YOU IN THE FACE. I'm just saying...

[@uee9543]

If you want to watch it watch the original 26 episodes first then watch all brotherhood episodes, everyone agrees that the first 10 episodes of brotherhood aren't as good in introducing characters

[@vince0f331]

Cat Cake72 go watch the first fma

[@n.atalia23]

Lmao good luck when you watch it then

[@acacacacacacaccaca7666]

The scene were the lieutenant is carrying ed after he passed out from fighting to exhaustion and she tells Roy he is only a boy to which Roy replies he stopped being a boy when he joined the army still hits harder than any death I have ever seen in an anime. Goes to show you don't need to kill a character to have a deeply emotional moment

[@dandelion9543]

The last line though... " Whats gone is forever lost, now all we can do is live " This is just so true and heartbreaking... Beautiful song : )

[@CJCroen1393]

... (Grabs Ed, hugs him and cries) It wasn't your fault, Ed...what happened to Trisha, to Al, to Nina...none of it was your fault...oh Ed...Ed...T_T

[@parhy4562]

Who the hell is Trisha.

[@MrScherpie]

Parhy Lolzilla his mother

[@parhy4562]

Leander Scherpereel Oh, well I'm a fuckin idiot.

[@madisonfife4403]

Who's nina

[@MrScherpie]

Natalie Herbert the girl turned into a chimaera by her dad... she died soon after

[@pancakemaxx4377]

"Whats gone is forever lost,now all we can do is live" Thats basically the show in a nutshell

[@banditkeith6479]

Well yes but actually no. The gate is infinite life that everyone passes through and enter a new world. The homuculus are humans and have souls which is why they have their memories slowly coming back to them.

[@legendaryash5805]

Never before has a translated song made me cry this much! i blame this entirely on Vic's voice acting(singing) skills...

[@DeadlyCyanide1]

He wrote the words for shits and giggles, Its not translated as far as i know.

[@omegaman255]

That is correct. This is Vic's own cover of the song.

[@EvlutnTrnrDaisy]

@@omegaman255 To both of you^ After researching the song, the lyrics here aren't a direct translation but seem instead to take inspiration from the translated Russian. Here's a link. lyrics.fandom.com/wiki/Fullmetal_Alchemist:Bratja

[@callmebaby7246]

When I'm sad I listen to this song and it always cheers me up... but it makes me cry more... lol

[@bethanyschnieder3482]

I agree with you when I'm so sad and i feel like i have no hope this song helps me to be strong and i feel at peace :)

[@achimnoeul_]

I believe no anime can ever show the pure love of two siblings for each other like fma/fmab. They went through it all tgth, carried the pain tgth, fought along with eo, sacrificed themselves for eo, cried for eo... Asides the great philosophy this anime has, the pure love & brotherhood of Ed & Al is what makes me really emotional 😭😭😭

[@mightymoon6791]

I think Fma:B didnt managed to show us Ed and Al's pure brotherhood and make me care about them getting their bodies back while Fma did it

[@crossoverqueen1775]

Imagine if whenever Ed just wants to feel sad and just, not keep it all inside, he sings this to himself. Even after getting their bodies back, he'll find himself humming or slightly singing this to himself and he breaks down because he doesn't want to go back to those times... Damn, now I made myself sad.

[@alchemistofsteel8099]

I think it weird that Ed and Al consider this to be the best time of there life

[@4angstyzukosproductions186]

I WANT A FULL METAL MUSICAL NOW

[@victorenciso3580]

So a disney version of fullmetal alchemist?

[@KanekiKen-cc2nr]

Me too

[@lookatthiscutekittyc2903]

There is a Death Note musical so I suppose it shouldn't be impossible to get a Full Metal one...

[@AshtonMonitor]

'Full Metal Musical' makes me think of a musical filled entirely with metal music.

[@andrewcarmichael2371]

And Roy Mustang Song is him beatboxing.

[@armin5767]

Why FMA dub is so good ? 60% - everyone else 40% - Vic alone this is probably my 10000th time listening to this, tysm for uploading this - this song lives forever.

[@mikechicago6200]

Man be is not only a great actor, voice actor but also a lovely singer he is trulyey one of the best and i love his work....Funimation screwed him and we lost an icon!

[@flame1220]

IKR. Vic is an awesome person and someone had to ruin his reputation..

[@salvatoredali4384]

@@flame1220 It wasn't just "someone". Over 12 people who knew him personally/professionally testified to their own experiences with Vic.

[@salvatoredali4384]

@@seramagirl Its a 10 month old comment man, don't worry about it.

[@GoGasgano]

@@salvatoredali4384 So 12 competitors lied to get a leg up in the anime VA market, what’s your point?

[@gotalotofpencils]

I got to meet Vic! He sang this to us, and it was one of the best moments of my entire life!!!

[@zachlindsay6672]

kewl beans

[@Ryan-mech-muffin]

that's lit!

[@user-ug7rd9bi9x]

Is it weird I'm fangirling and crying at the same time while listening to this....

[@siennanewbold1366]

Bean Does Art same!!!

[@delaneyford2106]

We need this song more than ever now regarding what's happening with Vic. I love him so much and he has played such an important role in my childhood. #IStandWithVic

[@rickrijks4560]

Agreed, Vic is a good person, if the accusations were true, wouldn't there be proof since a long time by now? Pardon my French, but I call bullshit, I say Vic is innocent. I ALWAYS got the feeling Mignogna is a good, loving person. To those who don't like Vic, fuck you.

[@elyxircreations1003]

Wait whats going on with Vic

[@jack688]

@@elyxircreations1003 He was accused by Monica Rial of sexual assault. Something that she alleges happened years ago, yet decides to speak up about it, just when the new broly movie comes out. A few other VA's jumped on the bandwagon (Sean Schimmel and Chris Sabbot the voices of goku and vegeta, both dislike vic and like monica, big shock there) and essentially destroyed his carrier. They removed his name from the movie (the highest selling animated film at that time i believe) and he lost everything. He was drug through the mud and it almost killed him. However, with some help from some online supporters, he has found some justice and started going to panels and cons with outstanding support. Also, there was NO evidence at all supporting her claim, but like most things, if the word rape is thrown up, companies will drop you in a heartbeat. Sadly i dont believe he has done any animated films since this all happened, but he has alot of support and fans, and many of us side with Vic. Which started the hastag IStandWithVic. There is a long log of video depositions for the case, but sadly i dont think anything really came of it. He had his day in court, and i dont believe he was found guilty, but they also did not punish Monica in any way. She still is doing VA work while his life was ruined and lost years of work because of her. The wonderful world of guilty until proven innocent and the court of public opinion, isent it a great thing? -_-

[@elyxircreations1003]

@@jack688 omg that horrible. Vic was always my favorite VA since he has a gentle soul. I read up on it and honestly was in disbelief about the accusations as a sexual assault victim myself I felt betrayed but I still chose not to believe it. Now that you went into detail though, my worries are erased. I hope he can get back on his feet

[@jack688]

@@elyxircreations1003 He apparently is doing not too bad. He has talked about some VA plans in the future, and he still has alot of supporters. I have watched the story from the beginning, and obviously i cannot know if he is truely guilty or not. However, what i can say is, his story has remained the same, hers has changed. She has been caught in lies, Vic has not. Her boyfriend Ron posted page after page (something like 30 pages) of tweets, slandering Vic, yet claimed someone hacked his twitter and they posted it. Vic said it himself, he is not perfect, or a angle, but he did not ever do anything that was non consensual with anyone. Other thing, Vic never responded to any of these allegations and attacks, he stayed calm and acted like an adult, while Monica and Ron have relied on the court of public opinion and spreading rumors to harm Vic.

[@sketchieakechi]

SOUNDS LIKE ED SINGING IT *CRIES* FEELMETAL ALCHEMIST

[@zoepatrick8603]

Vic Mignogna plays Ed that's probably why

[@sketchieakechi]

Zobo Patrick I know lol

[@spectraltala6362]

IMAGINE IF ED SANG THIS TO AL

[@the_polar_bears_got_me]

+Star “Ember” UniversePines 😭😭😭😭

[@findme-1036]

@@spectraltala6362 but this song indeed Edward guilts to his lovely brother Al.

[@autistic-echo]

The 147 people who disliked this video are completely insane.

[@moonphoenixprime8760]

tell me about it i like this song

[@ShaymonMizu]

Kenzie Lumbra I know I don't know why anyone would be such a fool to dislike this. FMA and this song is awesome.

[@ShaymonMizu]

Are you talking to me cause I forgot what I said

[@bholanathhembram7366]

I'm guessing that KZbin automatically put dislikes on famous videos, Otherwise there should be no dislikes on this beautiful song.

[@Ryan-mech-muffin]

probably humonculi

[@galvatronus1139]

Vic is just all around an amazing person. So talented, funny, and seems to really enjoy his life.

[@ゆぅか-i8n]

Here I am. 10 years later after this video was released and trust me, the feels in this are still there

[@nikkimel56]

vic mignogna did an excellent job! I imagined ed singing this song while listening to it! ♡

[@mossboi2669]

I think this song was actually for Fullmetal alchemist and the voice actor for Al was even invited t sing as well.

[@kurai0kami541]

If you listen to the background music in the anime, you will hear the Japanese version playing softly from time to time, usually close to the end of an episode

[@senmonkashonen5875]

"What's gone is forever lost now all we can do is live", literally the mindset of curing depression

[@maikamaikamaikamaika]

who's cutting 'em onions? ;-;

[@DatNguyen-jz9ur]

IT'S THOSE FUCKING ONION NINJAS, I SWEAR TO GOD!!!

[@lealalchemical470]

Damn onion ninjas

[@gamewizerd01]

Maika Mikaela Mother nature picked a terrible time to start raining. 😢

[@3Austin16]

Maika Mikaela i am does evil laugh* kneel before me XD

[@DiceFTW273]

Sloth. He was told to dash by people listening to this song, cutting onions. He complained that "it was a pain" but was too lazy to argue.

[@haya2337]

Everytime I hear this song I can not help but shed tears, FMA was a great anime. Taught me lots of lessons. It's the best anime I've ever watched. FMA lives on forever in each of our hearts.

[@8RedSpades6]

Vic Mignogna has an amazing voice

[@ChibiChild626]

"now all we can do is live"

[@edwardelric7429]

Chibi Child only thing we can do

[@ToshisGarden]

Let it be remembered that Vic got his career ruined because he cared too much. God bless the man, and I hope he's able to get the compensation he deserves.

[@kaylan4856]

Wait- What happened?-

[@Otomeweeb]

@@kaylan4856 falsley accused of sexual harrassment and got no justice

[@cross-zevol4056]

@@Otomeweeb And hearing that song, even though it's FMA themed, it makes me sad for Vic, he deserves love and support, and that last verse, it makes a day terrible for rain #IStandWithVic

[@thundergoblin2828]

Does he still act?

[@cross-zevol4056]

@@thundergoblin2828 I'm sorry, but no, he hasn't been casted currently in future anime of this new decade, so he's currently doing livestreams every Tuesday night on Unlocked, an app where you talk to actors of your favorites, and he still goes to conventions that still love him, so pray to the Lord himself that Vic Mignogna stays strong, for all us loving fans who look up to him and respect him like a father in their eyes #WeStandForVic

[@sparklingglitterlucky9629]

I still come back to this so many years later and ughhh, I love this song. Wish Brotherhood had this

[@osama_a8119]

Me too

[@FitForRivals125]

What's gone now is lost makes me think of Ciel Phantomhive's line "Once something is truly lost, it can never be found." or somethin' like that.

[@saniharuo]

"I'm afraid when something is truly lost, one can never get it back again."

[@FitForRivals125]

Oh...thanks~! ^^

[@saniharuo]

x3

[@FitForRivals125]

i love Ciel.

[@saniharuo]

Same here bro.

[@Thepateisgreat]

I’m listening to this song detoxing from heavy fentanyl use on my own at home. Use that I’ve been stuck in for the last 2 years or so. Pray for me

[@crownedclown49]

How you doing ? I hope you get better

[@AshN-nf9wb]

Hope you are doing better my late fiance and his brother used as well and as well myself a bit after he passed. This song reminds me of them for they lost their mother back in 2017 to an overdose. Hope things get better stay strong. I love FMA and he did as well. 💔❤️

[@blackjack1295]

Vic Mignogna, is absolutely... AMAZING. This song proves it even more

[@27Izabelle]

this is so heartbreaking...the tears are inevitable at this point

[@xerith42]

There was a moment when I listened to the song this time where I forgot who Vic even was. This wasn't a voice actor doing a cover of a piece of music for a show he worked in, it was Edward Elric singing to his brother.

[@Bsruj]

Love this. Its one of those songs which give me goosebumps anytime. I feel like any pain is much less than what Ed and Al faced. Its so consoling and makes sure I keep moving forward no matter what happens.

[@adararelgnel2695]

This song, and his voice, Ed's voice, take me way back. woah. I was really sad back then :(

[@BananaChicken21]

No fair, sky. I'm the one who feels like crying.

[@biscuitismc]

Time to go cry in a corner for half of my life. So sad ;~;

[@shaylariggins6135]

Vic is such an amazing person :) He has a great voice and he's my favorite anime characters of all time (Ed and Tamaki)

[@lucario765g]

#IStandWithVic He doesn’t deserve this pain at all

[@susanstanley4242]

Yeah he done nothing it is stupid all the nice people are being shit on it is stupid # STAND WITH VIG and throw out kick vig people like that where ever fans don't deserve to be ever called fans of vig again I hate Jessie AND I HATE JAMIE MARCHI AND I HATE MONICA RIAL

[@reibean9542]

susan stanley, Vic wouldn’t say he hated them... tbh I’m conflicted by the two sides but I know that Vic really is a good person, he may have just misspoke some things.

[@susanstanley4242]

@@reibean9542 I didn't say he said that geez anyways Cort case is on the 14th so we will find out then

[@DavidMartinez-ce3lp]

No he does not. Some may have completely abandoned him, but not us. Never

[@susanstanley4242]

@@DavidMartinez-ce3lp that is right I like the way u r talking no I am not a boy but I like boys okay that bitchy stab backing bitch . Oh yeah u should watch sheild hero it's like this but Monika and Jamie marchi is the boys and Jessie is mine if u don't know what I am talking a bout just watch it and u will see

[@rhysp.2920]

Also I'm not crying, my eyes are cosplaying Equius.

[@sannyqua3687]

original. I like it.

[@rhysp.2920]

+Sannyqua :3 Thanks XD

[@sannyqua3687]

xDDDDDD

[@CrescentMoonDancer15]

There is one where a youtuber sung for Al's part and OMG they sound so much like Alphonse it's not even funny. It's really good

[@sannyqua3687]

Name?

[@kji794]

Thanks to an amv did I discover this amazing series back in 2013. I was so amazed by the story, the music, the sadness and valuable lessons it brought. I was so into anime during this time, and I remember there was a manga/anime store a few minutes from my house. I rented the DVD version from here and practically forced my mom to watch the original Fullmetal alchemist series with me. It was such a simpler time for my family then. Now my mother has cancer and it's seems our financial situation only spirals down. I sometimes feel as if Fullmetal alchemist was preparing me for some tough times. Being that the main theme seemed to revolve around loss.

[@sexyishtar8537]

as soon as I listened to the first line I had to stop for a minute and cry to myself. Edward singing this (Vic Mignogna) made it much more emotional

[@MarissaScalero]

My mom and I just finished watching the original FMA. She hated anime 10 years ago when FMA first came out and she FINALLY watched it with me all these years later. We just finished watching the entire anime tonight and she loved it. She said that she finally got me and my sister's love for the show and is slowly understanding our love for anime. I made her love FMA after 10 years, and I'm so happy I got the chance to finally share it.

[@AnnaKnight]

I'm sitting on the school bus listening to this and trying so hard not to cry T^T

[@CatsRul85]

It's like ten times more awesome when the one who is sining it is in fact EDWARD ELRIC!

[@edwardelric2818]

Ah you found out!

[@maedaaaayy]

:O ITS THAT CUTIE!! :D

[@maedaaaayy]

:O ITS THAT CUTIE!! :D

[@kw7588]

You can just see Ed singing this with Al in the background wishing he could cry, and Ed can't see him.

[@maksimkalmykov33]

these are exact 'unsingable' lyrics : 1 Forgive me younger brother! I have wronged you imensely. It is futile to attempt to return That, which the earth took. 2 He who knows the laws of existence Would be able to help me find the answer. I made a grave mistake. There is no remedy for death. 3 Darling, gentle mother! We loved you so much. But all of our efforts Were in vain. 4 I seduced you With the wonderful image Of our family being back together. My brother, it is all my fault. 5 Don't cry, don't be sad, older brother! You are not the only one to blame. We share the same path, And we will pay the same price. 6 I have nothing to blame you for, And I am not angry with you. Heavy is our sin Of craving ultimate power. 7 Darling, gentle mother! We loved you so much. But all of our efforts Were in vain. 8 I was seduced myself By the wonderful image Of our family being back together. It is all my fault. 9 But what shall we do, how should we go on? How do we fix and forget everything? It is futile to attempt to return That, which the earth took.

[@meherchowdhury9156]

Oh my Gawd.

[@Sousuke15]

Holy shit that was even more deep

[@maksimkalmykov33]

+Sousuke15 yep... I'm russian, so i can unerstand and translate for you all the lyrics

[@eugenemedvedev5264]

+Максим Калмыков That's about as close as you can get to a perfect translation, nicely done. Sure, the Russian version is still better, but what can you do.

[@maksimkalmykov33]

Eugene Medvedev thanx =0

[@couragew6260]

Remember! This is the same guy that sang Dragon Soul from DBZ. He’s also a really nice guy. Edit: his name is Vic Mignogna for anyone curious. He is also the original voice for Qrow from Rwby and Broly from DBZ. He’s currently going through legal issues for “rape.” I actually did research on this and as far as consistency goes, I think he’s actually innocent due to his history as a very, and I mean a VERY good person (it’s honestly shocking). Also, it’s pretty coincidental that these allegations showed up EXACTLY before he was about to get a big promotion that the current “rape” victim could have also gotten if Vic wasn’t around. This 4 hour interview should help any newcomers get a grasp on Vic’s character kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYeudHx4h8mlmNk

[@sageof6pandas233]

Jesus

[@warriorofthegrandline2y618]

He didn’t win unfortunately

[@couragew6260]

@@warriorofthegrandline2y618 His Lawsuit was never taken to court, and some people liked to jump the gun and assume, “it’s official now that Vic is guilty” (it isn’t official at all). Vic took it more seriously and said that he wasn’t even given a chance to defend himself and that to deny him that right is like going to a ball game, locking the Home Team in a basement, and saying, “Guess we win the game!”

[@warriorofthegrandline2y618]

@@couragew6260 not me obviously But it’s not a loss either so No I’m still sad about it

[@kyriacoskeravnos7228]

How can someone dislike this??? This is easily one of the most beautiful songs i've ever heard. So powerfull, filled with love and meaningful lyrics. The melody is a pleasure to my ears. Simply breathtaking. FMA will always hold a special place in my heart as my favourite TV series in of all time.

[@vamplovebot]

Oh my god O,O This just makes me respect Vic Mignogna even more not only as a voice actor but also as a person. He seems like such a kind-hearted and bubbly person, yet his voice acting skills are amazing, he can play so many different characters with so many different personalities different from his.

[@briellewilbourne9236]

a couple years ago i played this song every time i had a panic attack. didn’t know i would still be relying purely on anime to keep up my serotonin. also the part where his voice crackles when he says “i led you with hopeless dreams” is ughhhh😹

[@ragerasengan7997]

Thank you for sharing this... This anime has stayed with me for so many year. Hearing this touches my heart.

[@JaydevRaol]

This is such a meaningful and thematically appropriate song. Beautiful!

[@HorrorFangirl34]

Wow, he's got a wonderful singing voice and those lyrics hit really hard right into the feels :(

[@mayeenmdtasin8584]

I lost my grandfather last week. He was my everything. The last 2 lines hit me really hard and I can't help but agree with what it said.

[@teddythekingofbears]

After all the drama and bullshit with Vic's lawsuit and allegations, I decided to come here, and god it made me feel more sympathetic for Vic. 😭

[@Kawaii_Nami]

This will always be one of my most favorite songs. It's beautiful.

[@SenetTheSnek]

So where do we go from here And how to forget and forgive.... Wow it's hitting too close now... #istandwithvic

[@sweetcinnamonpnchkin]

And he chose to forgive.

[@theparlor3753]

Vic is the best voice actor ever.

[@AWlpsSHOW36]

This song is beautiful and emotional! I didn't know Vic can sing! He is so good and beautiful!

[@zaragachizanparo4948]

I hope Vic one day is able to make a comeback in voice acting. He's got a good singing voice and I thought he did great as Qrow in RWBY. Maybe one day...one day...

[@alexasayles6436]

To think, that ths is how they ACTUALLY feel. They don't show this much feeling in the anime... this is absolutely beautiful :)

[@AustinoDLG]

It's so interesting to hear the voice of Edward Elric, almost like a musical. This is still awesome.

[@StattStatt]

I will never be able to look at any character voiced by Vic the same way again. And I do not care in the slightest since this is simply so beautiful. Holy mother of god, biggest of kudos to you Vic.

[@pancakeboi6797]

I met Vic at comic con! He was so sweet😊

[@gypsysnowwolf2313]

I don't have a brother, but a younger sister. I still cry when I see Ed and Al's mother die. Made me think of my mother and her sister who lost their mother when they were very young. My mom was 9 and her sister was 6. They both followed their father's footsteps and became teachers too. I miss my grandfather so much, he passed 10/1/18. 😔

[@Unreal_Ra]

How am I only discovering this now?? Its amazing! Love Vic.

[@joelbond7440]

Mignogna has a really nice singing voice.

[@aliammar160]

I never watched Anime....but after watching it......I realised i was such a fool....FMAB Is a perfect anime....story ...characters....all are beautiful

[@beowolf7460]

This song is better than many mainstream songs period!!!!

[@thelastjedi3259]

have you ever once heard one of those songs and go back to it everyday after you find out about it to listen to it again?

[@luckybishoparchs3412]

yes, I did that exact same thing, lol