Bruichladdich Port Charlotte 10 Year Old Vs Caol Ila 10 Year Old (Round 3)

[@kellywellington7122]

Heh...I'm basically averse to Islay peateds. So, when my Talisker Storm tapped out, I replaced it with a Port Charlotte 10. I thought I'd end up feeding it to my friends, but, of course, I had to sample it. Then, I had to resample it. My friends were similarly impressed. I've been sampling it repeatedly and it's almost gone. I'm gonna have to refill with another.

[@WhiskeyStraightAl]

Loving this series Erik, particularly your breakdown of the expressions and your rationale in determining the victors. Brilliantly informative.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

Thank you very much!

[@cliffnorman178]

Another superb comparison video. Great that a very available whisky beat a limited whisky. Look forward to the next comparison.

[@gregwilde1119]

Just bought a PC 10 based on your reviews over a few videos. Been quite a while since I bought a peated scotch. Thanks again for what you do.

[@silverlochwhiskyreviews6157]

Very cool ... loved the knock down videos. I like PC a lot. I also enjoyed the Caol Ila 12 few years ago ... that bottle went down fast! Looking forward to the next round!

[@budj13]

Thanks for all your work putting these together, Erik. I'm really enjoying them. I love the "three chord song" and Pee Wee references-- very expressive. Lots of great information and insights.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

Thanks for watching. The Mike Tyson Vs. Pee Wee Herman clip only lasts a second but it took me about 30 minutes to make. But it adds another layer of comedy.

[@jamesburgoyne7861]

Spot on with this series Erik. I must get another PC 10.

[@un.uomo.assetato]

Erik, wish to thank You very much for entertaining us in lockdown's time with all these videos. Should be a lot of work, but it's very appreciate. Slangevar 🥃🥃

[@Koby616]

I have port Charlotte 10 which isn't open yet. But this video makes me wanna try it right now. I don't like to have many bottles open 😅

[@jeffcoole741]

Great series, and love the intro and special effects! I’ve got to get a bottle of the Port Charlotte 10yr. I’ve only had the non-age stated version, which is still pretty good.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

Thanks for watching!

[@Richie.Z]

Let's get ready to RUMBLLLLLLLLLLE! Love it!

[@samclark6048]

Great show Erik, I've not had the coal isla 10 yet, however was sniffing my empty of the port Charlotte throughout this. The cork is still vibrant and doling out a peat punch after close to 5 months empty! Gotta get some more

[@pfalzgraf7527]

I am SO looking forward to this wildcard battle! These comparisons are great! I said it before - but I say it again in slightly different words: Keep doing what you did before, but mix it up from time to time with these competitions: they are a lot of fun! Also, they come close to what I like to do when I drink Whisky (or Rum for that matter): have two on the table and compare them.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

Thanks! I'll probably d more comparrison videos after the Islay Marathon but I will keep them all core range whiskies that are readily available.

[@pfalzgraf7527]

@@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies Thanks, I like the idea!

[@steveno7058]

Got a bottle of cask strength Caol Ila 11 from Total for $50 from Berry Brothers at Total. Amazing deal. 55% ABV, NCF, NAC.

[@flying_hussar3034]

I love Uigeadail and its my favourite peated. I thought Laphroaig QC was my second but after having a chance to try PC10 few times I would risk statement it beats QC and is up there with Ugi now. However I've never had chance to compare them side by side. I tried couple indie Caol Ila and they were good but didn't provide the same depth of experience even though they were cask strengths.

[@foodquig]

No wonder I'm a big Port Charlotte fan... Great side by side, Erik!

[@kresimirjelcic576]

Erik, while watching your review I was typing that PC is behaving like Mike Tyson in these matchups and knocking out everyone...and than you mentioned Mike😂😂😂😂

[@travisloewen6191]

Hoping it's a Bowmore Tempest. I really enjoy the batch 6 my fried has.

[@samwasserman1837]

I can't get enough port charlotte 10

[@paulfitzpatrick6202]

I recently bought the port Charlotte 10 and its absolutely wonderful. Tonight I have been nippin on the Ardbeg weebeast. That having been said I think Eric has the better buzz. Lol. Time for some port charlotte. Maybe I can catch up.

[@davidowen2834]

Fascinating. Love this series 👍. Another Islay 10 🤔. Maybe a bowmore (devils cask, tempest ). Laga 10 ??? Find out in the next round. 😁

[@jimmunger8658]

That pretty much went like I thought it would keep punching Bruichladdich

[@clarenceboddicker7708]

Nice. I will buy the PC10.

[@jackthepickledhound]

Ok !!! Mercy! I call Uncle!! I'll grab a bottle. Seems to be with $15 more than our beloved Ardbeg 10

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

You won't regret it!

[@clintondeabreu8565]

Real shame the Talisker 10 wasn’t put into the comparison, would of been a great addition.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

Stay tuned! I’ll be reviewing the Talisker 10 as part of my Peated Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky series and may do a comparison video if I think it’s a good match for an Islay whisky.

[@benkinobi9529]

let's roll! hahah greetings from germany

[@999YCM]

There's a Caol Ila 10?

[@999YCM]

Ah right!

[@russell3733]

Another Islay 10 year old? Well, Lagavulin recently brought out a 10 yo for travel retail, there’s probably a number of Bowmore 10s out there (e.g. the "Tempest" at cask strength) and there may well be a special bottling or two of Kilchoman at the age of 10. But I don’t know of a standard Bunna 10yo that would fit the bill (and you’re not going to use any independent bottlers, are you?). So, Erik, you’re going to keep us in suspense for a few more days? Okay - good things come to those who wait. Great to see that the Port Charlotte 10yo is still doing so well in this challenge so far. Cheers.

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

I am posting a round per day Friday through Monday so you won't have to wait long. I've been posting about 5 videos per week which has been a lot of work and I am still working 9 hour days during the week. But, there are a lot of people stuck at home so I am providing more content!

[@jackthepickledhound]

Thanks Erik. Did Kilchoman present with a 10 year????

[@lcpholman]

Gotta be the Lag 10

[@FastHatTrick]

Sorry, I disagree with your choice of the 10 for Caol, you should have gone with the 12, which is readily available. People watch this to explore new Whiskeys, and take your notes and run down to the store to explore further. I want to know how the 12 compares, not the impossible to get 10 year limited run. Save that for Rare Whiskey Fridays....

[@ErikWaitWhiskyStudies]

This is a competition of 10 year old whiskies. Not 10 and 12 year old whiskies. I’ll be reviewing the Caol Ila 12 soon.