Can Science Find God? feat. Stephen Meyer and Michael Shermer

[@nine4burnitall]

is bryan gonna be the spot for deep theological debates? 😂 never saw it coming but i’m here for it

[@juniperjennifer]

Agreed

[@macromicrodragon]

Ditto! I quite enjoy Bryans way of communicating, he’s a well spoken person to talk to especially about theology.

[@wagz72]

BCS>TFATK

[@tonymaurice4157]

Abiogenesis fails

[@jeffpickens4467]

Yea 100%

[@vahe.sargsyan]

I have immense respect towards Dr. Shermer. Always respectful, yet solid and humble in his arguments. Dr. Meyer, no words. Extremely important scholar and a trailblaizer in his field. Brian Callen, an intellectual man who happens to be a genius comedian. Thank you so much for this conversation. Truly remarcable!

[@garintj1547]

God bless you, sir

[@bboynewsboy991]

Dishonest in his arguments. Although not as blatant as Hitchen's.

[@stevebanning902]

Shermer is a con man lol he went to jail for fraud

[@br.m]

The intro song is one hell of an intro song.

[@syn4588]

lol Bryan an intellectual?

[@mn7669]

Callen is so caustic and disorganized in this interview. Thankfully Meyer's articulate insights and the depth to his ideas are more than enough to sustain this conversation. We need more Meyer...

[@BuddyBudenstein]

The entire interview he was interrupting to interject milktoast buzzwords you find on an intro to philosophy vocab study guide. He derailed highly polished points on both sides.

[@cmax4488]

Agreed. I honestly believe when he has guests on his show, he should chill out and mostly allow them to speak amongst themselves. His interruptions were not even funny and his timing was horrible. Strange considering he's a comedian.

[@Cj99861]

@@BuddyBudensteinwhile I agree. I think it works decent for bringing the conversation back to a place a layman or even novice can access.

[@Cj99861]

@@BuddyBudensteinotherwise these conversations, the average listener will be so lost in jargon they might not even follow along. I typically enjoy unmoderated open dialogue though personally.

[@nomadicrecovery1586]

Called literally proved Stephen’s point as he tries to deny it There’s no over arching mind in the economy??? No There’s MANY One or many the economy does NOT simply appear. It’s a result of minds Holy crap what a fool

[@brianthompson5521]

The more I hear Meyer the more I want to hear from Meyer!!!

[@jerrylong6238]

The more I hear Meyer, the more my a**hole wants to chew tobacco, so I can s**t it out.

[@joshuapanicker3327]

Stephen Meyer is truly the GOAT

[@Lerian_V]

A grand GOAT

[@rustyosgood5667]

No he is not...sorry to burst ya dumb bubble: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d5zZYYeQfp5ra7c

[@APRENDERDESENHANDO]

He's certainly one of the Greatest Grifters of All Times 😉

[@killerbee6484]

​@@APRENDERDESENHANDOCope harder

[@markjosemanders9778]

a whole lot of nothing and a lot of nonsense and a lot of false claims which he can't prove! is all nothing more than worthless!

[@gregorypierquet6321]

Meyer is such a great communicator of some difficult concepts. The return of the God hypothesis is more than a book title, but, as we know, science progresses one funeral at a time.

[@JevinTappero]

God is...

[@jackwatt8988]

@@JevinTappero an inane fantasy

[@edgaralansmithee8638]

@@jackwatt8988So all the matter and energy that is the universe (or even multiverse) has no possible explanation?

[@brandonmacey964]

​@@jackwatt8988that inane fantasy is shared by most of your fellow homo Sapiens. Just deal with what biology gives you. Your fellow apes are religious and you are religiously devoted to team "atheist"

[@harryf1ashman]

Like WLC he operates on a different level. His ability to relate these ideas to the layman is almost inspired. Qudos to Shermer for acting as the perfect foil in this debate while keeping it civil. There is nothing worse than listening to the likes of Krauss or Atkins who refuse to acknowledge that the sceptic is owed an explanation and not just opinions based on personal prejudice. This kind of intellectual laziness is all too common among atheists.

[@anthonycostello6055]

Bryan has the enthusiasm of a 1st year philosophy student. It is fun to watch. I hope to see more of these kinds of discussion; and, for the most part, Bryan is on the right track!

[@artax7664]

Very true, but he definitely needs to learn how to get to a point and stay on topic 😂 he is a bit scatterbrained.

[@joshuastephenward5316]

There was a time when religion was outdated and science showed up on the seen telling religion to do it's homework. Now we are living in a time where the script has flipped and both are better for it. Religion now has need of finishing it's reformation in our better understanding of genuine spiritual experience.

[@seller559]

I’m a Christian and I really enjoyed this. Excellent guests 👍

[@CameronFanSite]

I'm a Christian and Michael Shermer is a relic with rocks for brains. Stephen Meyer has BTFO'd that prissy old man with these arguments before but Shermer's too dumb to either comprehend them or is so dishonest he keeps tossing out these tired old counterarguments even though he knows they're nonsense. Probably the former, to be honest.

[@jasonm2506]

Evolve

[@33Cigarettes]

@@jasonm2506 **tips fedora**

[@matthewparlato5626]

At minute 6::30 Shermer literally debunks his own Philosophy about moral Objectivism...the whole Embodied Cognition movement is based on Heidegger and Dreyfuss, who are calling upon the recognition of Decartes Error in his infamous Subjective OBJECTIVE duality...and that error is not a mere woke thing... it's your problem Michael. You don't have an Objective morality because objective is a false dichotomy. We are in and of the is world just as we are in and of our bodies....like the Christians and their incarnation preoccupation nailed explicitly btw. Geez and he's a "smart guy"

[@seller559]

@@jasonm2506 No

[@johnsonvids2010]

Meyer had a superior scientific rebuttal to any of Shermer’s statements. Well done Meyer. 👏 And “Signature in the Cell” is still one of my favorite books. 👍

[@imanilim6632]

Meyer is a conman from Discovery Institute

[@johnsonvids2010]

@@imanilim6632 how did you come to the conclusion that he’s a conman?

[@ZebecZT]

@@imanilim6632genetic fallacy, doesn’t matter where he’s from or what he represents, what matters is what makes more sense, and its quite obvious.

[@dapperdondaddaakalegba1698]

Meyer is a Christian with a Christian agenda.

[@jessebryant9233]

@@imanilim6632 1. What do you mean by that? 2. What is your evidence for that?

[@zac3392]

Apparently comedians are the last line of defense for having good faith debates and conversations. El Gato, this episode was just as uplifting as those eyelids…

[@WhereTwoWaysMet]

I would put Stephen Meyer in the room with ANYONE on matters of science! He’s the man!!! God created the Heavens and the Earth, and EVERYTHING that in them is! PERIOD!!!!!!!

[@MariaPerez-uv8mm]

Amen 🙏

[@Sooner_Smith]

Callen has really surprised me with these interviews. He does a really good job asking questions and letting them discuss.

[@Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n]

Joe rogan better take notes

[@stefanallard3084]

Rogan would be proud

[@coachmarc2002]

Totally agree.

[@plutoloco2378]

All Rogan cares about anymore is trans debates and wokenesss. It’s boring.

[@stefanallard3084]

@@plutoloco2378 cutting of the sexual organs of kids in a massive scale is pretty serious

[@anthonyreed480]

Meyer was instrumental in bringing me back to faith. His book "Signature in the Cell" is a great read.

[@thedynamicsolo4232]

Let the mockers mock Anthony. Once you read "return to the God hypothesis" you will be supported and affirmed. I am almost finished with it and there is really only one answer to "Where did it all come from?". The science is validating our Great Creator every year.

[@elikunkel4381]

@@monk4258 Have you read "Signature in the Cell"?

[@Erik_Danley]

Before any of us mocks someone or their views, we need to honestly assess. Yes Meyer is fantastic, a great debater, and an incredibly talented and brilliant man. God bless him

[@anthonyreed480]

@@monk4258 Compared to "The Blind Watchmaker" and other New Atheist drivel that appeals to adolescents, yes, it was relatively easy for Meyer to dismantle their banal piffle.

[@anthonyreed480]

@elikunkel4381 Of course he hasn't lol. Or, rather, he couldn't.

[@mattdonnelly1972]

Wow, a comedian just provided probably the best short discussion on these topics that I've ever heard. No joke. Well done, sir.

[@mycrazylife408]

you need to watch more podcasts with stephen myers then

[@hongkongman852]

Bryan I love this new direction you are going in. Your intelletual interest combined with your humor is unmatched.

[@davidbryant2450]

As a Christian, I love the grace Meyer continually extends to the grumpy Shermer, who constantly exhibits that he is completely closed minded to theism regardless of how rational it seems. Meyer is constantly exhibiting love and I wish all Christians, especially those on the public stage of ideas, would exhibit. Myself included.

[@jamespenny9482]

I'm most of the way through the video and I kinda like Shermer, he's polite, patient, and personable, but his arguments are very weak. But yeah, I also see the closed-mindedness, which is so common among atheistic scientists. They seem to assume as a given that God does not exist and therefore any evidence that points to His existence is explained away, but with very poor arguments and speculations.

[@jakebaldwin7172]

​@@jamespenny9482i think anyone who truly believes, understands someone who is clearly fighting off the belief because it is outside of their ability to grasp. When I finally came to belief, I wasn't relieved or excited, I was terrified. The idea of actually coming before God in judgment is paralyzing. These materialists often cannot unpack the infinite series of implications that would follow them admitting to the existence of an all powerful creator. I have empathy for that, because in my life when I've been the most arrogant and dismissive, it is when I'm burying something that I'm afraid of.

[@LJrock101]

Dr. Meyer is on another level. 😮

[@VeridicusMaximus]

Yeah, right above snake oil salesman.

[@lonzo61]

@@VeridicusMaximus ZING! BAM! BOOM!!!!!

[@jerrylong6238]

Correct, he is another level of ignorant stupidity for sure. He is the epitome of stupidity and seems to be proud of it too. I guess the way he sees it is being the best at anything (even ignorant stupidity) is much better than not being the best at anything at all. Religion destroys people's ability to use any common sense or critical thinking skills. I mean the Buybull God says for you to lean not on your own understanding, but on the wisdom of God, because man's wisdom is foolishness to God and no man can understand the mind of God. And for that I truly thank Zeus from the bottom of my ackey breaky heart.

[@SirKabawl]

This is such a great episode for those with an open mind to watch and just listen to two gentlemen discuss their many hours of life (work) on the question of, how did this all begin? Thank you for your discussion, fellas. Keep it up, Callen!

[@cnault3244]

The video is titled "Can Science Find God? ". What is the scientific definition they provide for god?

[@thedude5740]

​@@cnault3244to me the definition would be, the driving force behind the creation of everything that can or cannot be experienced with the senses. That force or energy is frequencies. Everything in the universe is a frequency or combination of frequencies holding their shape like a whirlpool in a stream... "God" is a fractal pattern endlessly expressing itself throughout the universe. You are the word made flesh. Science that backs this claim. The amazing resonance experiment & Star in a Jar

[@atmanbrahman1872]

Stephen Meyer is a genius.

[@ishmael_03]

That he is. I love how he uses arguments from atheism, agnosticism, big bang theory, materialism and every other ideology that doesn't believe in God against them. 😁 His use of math and science is just the cherry on top. 😁

[@bicstic8]

No, he isn't. He is making all the same arguments that have been dismantled prior to him thinking of them. He is using mental linguistic gymnastics that make him sound amazing, but same old arguments that fall short.

[@atmanbrahman1872]

@@bicstic8 never saw anything dismantled. just atheotards unable to come to grips with reality.

[@Jasterouge]

If science can find God, why are there no scientific studies or peer reviewed scientific journals providing evidence for the existence of God?

[@atmanbrahman1872]

@Jasterouge for the same reason you don't find the proof of plant photosynthesis in a neuroscience journal. The proof for the existence of God are in philosophy and theology journals.

[@katlehomahlophe6513]

I can listen to Stephen Meyer the whole day. The man is knowledgeable. A discussion with him is informative.

[@patrickl8943]

I feel the same way about Michael Shermer😂

[@gjjk84]

“You give it a name not because you understand what the force is but because it’s a name for what the thing does, and we don’t really know what it is in its essence.” That’s a perfect explanation of God.

[@markrutledge5855]

I wish Bryan would stop interrupting these two guys and let them interact more with each other. I am Theist but I really to wanted to hear more from Michael Shermer. I respect Shermer even if I don't always agree with him.

[@tpaulhimes]

I agree. I don’t like it when people are talking over each other, making understanding them impossible.

[@oldschoolsaint]

I’ve listened to tons of this sort of debate. Meyers, by far, makes more sense than all others combined.

[@jaydenwilson9522]

@muneebiqbal5584 it's funny because modern atheism is more adherent to doctrine and dogma than the vatican church of old, to the point where they indoctrinate students with disinformation and lead to stifling of free thought for scientific ideas... not to mention they worship the gods of randomness (newtonian dynamics), nothingness (big bang) and meaninglessness...... the next Einstein will most definitely not come from academia or the west...

[@franzpaul6244]

you should consider Dr. James Tour on the origin of life. he had a great podcast with Steven Meyer about 2 years ago...

[@jeffclark2675]

​@@franzpaul6244yes! Steven was a guest on Dr James tour's podcast... Absolutely enthralling discussion

[@franzpaul6244]

@@jeffclark2675 Dr. Meyers has a 4 part discussion scheduled with Dr. Tour on the origin of life and the first 2 have been published so far. those 2 together are an absolute must watch...

[@LuciferAlmighty]

I don't find the con man more convincing

[@Reeseballin8]

So dope you did this Bryan. Would love more of these. Also I’m a huge fan of Stephen. The guy is revolutionary in science

[@imanilim6632]

Meyer is a conman from Discovery Institute

[@edus777]

Nobody in the DI is revolutionary in science, only radical creationists.

[@boxelder9167]

Stephen Meyer has obviously done his homework. He’s also humble enough to know the limitations of human knowledge.

[@pjaworek6793]

Is it humble or is it part of the scam. You can't understand this, so you need me to tell you what to think.

[@seraph6758]

“You can’t understand this”.. 🤣 so tell me...?! 🤦‍♂️Lmao!

[@Thrawnmulus]

He's done enough to sound like he knows what he's saying. Unfortunately he still advocates for creationism, he just likes to call it intelligent design.

[@bllla]

@@Thrawnmulus Not just creationism. young earth creationism!

[@barrygraham205]

Do your homework. Meyer does not advocate young earth creationism.

[@johnnyboy6707]

Great, respectful discussion. I’ve been an agnostic about the existence of a creator being for as long as I can remember. I’ve never really been into philosophy, or science for that matter..but as of late I’ve been really developing an interest in both. This Meyer guy really impressed me; eloquent and really intelligent. I found his arguments pretty compelling. Will be checking out more of his stuff!! Thanks for having him on.

[@BbBb-sd2bs]

Really?!?!? im 4 min in and hes already talking about intelligent design and "codeing" in cells.. this is run of the mill apologetics..

[@johnnyboy6707]

@@BbBb-sd2bs I don’t really care if it’s considered “Run of the mill apologetics,” or anything else - I judge his arguments by the weight I think they carry. This was sort of the first time I’ve ever heard these arguments articulated this way, and I don’t think they’re so easily dismissed…they’re making a good bit of sense to me.

[@danielgiordano3238]

I’ve heard similar topics brought up in apologetics, but to your point, Meyer makes these points in a way I’ve never heard articulated before. Very compelling and he clearly has solid scientific grounding (one of his big differentiators)

[@jamespenny9482]

I agree with you. You may also like Hugh Ross, he's terrific and very humble and respectful of others with opposing views.

[@RK79KR]

@@BbBb-sd2bs Haha, 4 minutes in and you're an expert. Please. Be less close minded, it's silly.

[@shawnbydalek4153]

This was an awesome discussion, Bryan, thanks for hosting it. Stephen Meyer is such a bright guy and a great scholar, and Michael Shermer is so bright and well spoken as well. I love getting to hear their takes on the big issues, and seeing them discuss these things together was so cool. Stephen had some great takes in this.

[@giorgirazmadze5102]

That was a great discussion! Meyer sounded persuasive to me! Michael is also a great person. Well done to both of them and Bryan of course!

[@gregariousguru]

Nobody has more faith than idea that sophisticated, complex, prescriptive and directive information comes from star dust....nobody!

[@MichaelJComedy]

Bryan, I’ve been a fan since the TMP days. I’m an ICU Travel Nurse with 10+ years in the job. I would be honored to be a guest on your pod for even a quick chat. Keep up the good work!

[@bradleynewall7541]

The fraze I've heard time and time again, since the covid days.... "Trust the science man !"

[@davepurcell1318]

Great to see Stephen here, I’ve followed all his stuff and when I first discovered ID over a decade ago I was totally blown away it completely made sense. If more people could look at this more closely instead of going on auto believe with neo evolution theory they would find meaning

[@petepottieski6673]

Aron Ra... Truth teacher!

[@Luke-pc5rb]

Return of the God Hypothesis is a great read.

[@markuse3472]

Dr. Meyer and Dr. Lennox are my favorites. There are others, too, but these two are my to-go-to for proving creation and God. And no, one does not need to be a Dr., or PHD, not even a college grad or associate D., reason and evidence is all that's needed, which is why "Dr." Hovind makes many great points.

[@afzaldogar2452]

Meyer is phenomenally intelligent & learned individual I have ever listened

[@raginglunatik8979]

His logic is based on fallacies. Hes starting off with morals not being objective, fine tuning of the universe, intelligent design etc. Even Bryan is on a higher intellectual level.

[@seraph6758]

We don’t need to have problems with how other people think. That is the whole problem with society today. Stop caring to control what people think, let them have their lessons. It’s NOT FOR YOU TO KNOW HOW OTHERS SHOULD BE. 🤷‍♂️🤦‍♂️ One love.

[@raginglunatik8979]

@@seraph6758 People are allowed to have opinions. However, when those opinions are harmful to others it is absolutely a problem. On behalf of all the abused children who are forced into religion by their parents, and taught that they are broken and will be tortured for eternity if they dont worship an imaginary being, you are wrong. You are demonstrably wrong. Furthermore, moral standards are pretty important in society. While laws should never be the moral guideline since slavery was once legal etc its imperative that some line be drawn. We dont let serial killers do what they do because who are you to tell them they cant be who they want to be.

[@seraph6758]

@@raginglunatik8979 Now you need to be real, and not ephemeral, opinions don't hurt. No, I'm not religious by the way, NOT that you have established a grasp on the subject, at all.

[@Dilly972]

@@raginglunatik8979 You complain of the parents who brow beat their children due to the parents faith, what of the children who are coerced into sex changes and hormone therapy because of their spiritually dead parents? The understanding that life is designed and design is an absolute like Stephen Myers argues for, does not require a religious God. It does however offer a level of understanding (about life) that in the case of the trans issue would show the way to have a life of peace happiness and joy is to fit into the design of life and encourage the children to do that rather than the trauma misery and pain that the trans community eventually land in. Ideas have consequences, religious as well as non religious. Lets not pretend that doing away with God as a concept does not come with some pretty serious issues.

[@nickgroves-dv9zj]

Meyer is the boss

[@maximuspike]

Please have Dr. James Tour on your program

[@33Cigarettes]

That would be good.

[@pjaworek6793]

Ugh, what a moron, when he talks about abiogenesis. It's despicable to see educated chemists lying to people that magic or alchemy is real in this day in age when he knows damn well he's misleading people.

[@ianhastie5785]

I’m a Christian and i have a really hard time with Tour. Has a really hard time with difficult questions. Always seems to have his points built on sand.

[@Relies-t5v]

@@ianhastie5785 you didnt say anything specific, James Tour is world-renown and he simplystates what common says says in most of his stuff, like that life always comes from life (the law of biogenesis), and that abiogenesis is impossible, which is obviously true and what we see in reality

[@Spasaymoostard]

@@Relies-t5vhe’s a petulant man who has more pride than sense. Abiogenesis has more scientific backing than god. It may not be a proven theory yet, but there is strong evidence for it.

[@Anthony_Marquis]

While I found the interview deeply interesting and entertaining, and while I definitely agreed with Dr. Stephen Meyer more, I felt kind of bad for Shermer. I felt bad for him because it seemed like most of the video he had to debate both Meyer AND Callen. That must've felt frustrating for him. What patience and grace! Really interesting interview!

[@leepretorius4869]

Stephen Meyer’s testimony resonates with me

[@hankhooper1637]

Love Meyer! Brilliant mind. I really like his friendly approach and grasp of everything. Shermer seems like one of the better skeptics. Also, friendly in manner.

[@YeshuaHamashiak]

HALLELUJAH!!!!!! STEPHEN KILLED IT!!!! ALL PRAISE BE TO OUR GOD IN JESUS MIGHTY NAME. AMEN.

[@jasonm2506]

Twit

[@pjaworek6793]

Duh. No point, just like Stephen

[@Northertba]

Incredible interview. Myers really is a true scientist and incredible witness for the truth in the Bible and Jesus from a solid scientific perspective. Him and John lennox are leading the world into a new enlightenment period.

[@Tehownilator]

Is it just me or are the arguments for Christianity and religion way stronger nowadays than they were 10 years ago? I love the point Brian made about what Jesus did and who he was. That’s what made me say I’m a Christian; not the bible thumping stuff. Actually what made me go all the way was the fact that I realized I was embarrassed to say that I was Christian. When I realized how petty that inclination was, I felt obliged to call myself Christian just as a matter of principle. If other people hear me say I’m Christian, and assume a bunch of different beliefs on my behalf, that’s on them and not me. People will always misunderstand, often deliberately, what you mean. And in a sense is it true that I’m Christian? Yes; I think Jesus was the greatest man to ever live by far, and he didn’t even have a job or a wife or a house or a business and he wasn’t a politician. The guy was a phenom the likes of which the earth has not known before or since. You can see that clearly without any miracles or supernatural stuff.

[@Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n]

Like Myers said naturalism is itself a metaphysical outlook

[@pjaworek6793]

​@@Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n not so. Meta means beyond. Natural is what is the base reality. There is no beyong reality. Wake up

[@King_Conan]

10 years ago, Intelligent Design was very active in their debates and new ways to explain their viewpoints. All the great arguments were alive and well 10 years ago, and prior. I think many ppl didn't recognize this because the new atheism was very fashionable at the time. But now we live in a world in which traditional religion declined and now we are subjected to completely irrational social justice type ideologies, which has made people recognize the failures and limitations of atheism and are therefore more open to God again.

[@Tehownilator]

@PraiseTheLord777-nb3il this isn’t helping anyone. Anybody who would read a quote read off by wrote is a fool.

[@josephbrown9685]

@@King_Conan That is excellently explained. I think you’re right. I actually got caught up in the whole “new atheism” movement for a while but then ended up coming back to Christianity. It’s not the only reason, but the insanity that has ensued by removing God from modern society has contributed to my feeling of having made the right decision.

[@jamespenny9482]

Fist time on your channel Bryan and I gotta say, you are a great interviewer: direct, lay it all on the table, no agenda, just searching for truth!

[@TheJusticeCole]

Brendan might lose his mind when this channel surpasses Thicccboy in subscribers

[@leedsdrumacademy]

Yep. And I'm here for it.

[@DPER4]

He'll start hating on bryan guaranteed

[@Grandiloquent786]

Amazing discussion. Bry actually made some very poignant points throughout and was asking the right questions. I loved this

[@nathanwaibel454]

Poignant means sad.

[@Mr_everything10]

@@nathanwaibel454 😂

[@seraph6758]

...three thumbs up... 🤷‍♂️

[@goodshorts]

As a Christian, young earth creationist none the less, I appreciate Michael's demeanor in this video. Great video and thank you.

[@kidheyful]

Young earth creationist? …wow

[@goodshorts]

@@kidheyful yes, your point?

[@kidheyful]

@@goodshorts you’re silly and believe stupid things?

[@exiledskunk5046]

​@@goodshortsits just unusual to see someone say they are a young earth creationist. Im not but I don't really care enough to argue against it. I'm close to becoming Christian i guess. Grew up in a Christian home, went materialist atheist during my late teens and early twenties and realised it was internally contradictory over the last few years and coming back to Christianity (eastern orthodoxy)

[@Spectre4913]

​@@goodshortsI find you people hilarious. Right up there with flat earthers in there wilful ignorance of the world around them.

[@promisesrkept]

Bryan, thank you for providing this content. In a culture that seems to be moving in a more atheistic direction this has introduced both excitement and hope into the conversation. I left this discussion impressed by all three of you. We are now entering an age of technology in which these types of free expressions of thought are less censored. The previous guardians of truth imposing one version of scientific theory on an unsuspecting public may be over. Stephen Meyer deserves a seat at the most prestigious tables of debate and discussion. He has the potential to be highly influential. I eagerly anticipate the day when he will be welcomed.

[@isaacfileger3307]

Stoked to see more and more people do this stuff. ❤️

[@solidtank7957]

The algorithms did me a solid recommendation on this, fan of Bryan since TMP. Exceptional podcast, i thank you. Familiar with Shermer and thought he was great here, and Meyer is someone I am very happy to be introduced to.

[@joshuaroach1834]

Flowers bro. Ole Wrinks bringing all the wisdom lately. I’d love to see a weekly installment of this show.

[@juniperjennifer]

Our wrinks is really growing. Proud of you Bryan.

[@matthewparlato5626]

At minute 6::30 Shermer literally debunks his own Philosophy about moral Objectivism...the whole Embodied Cognition movement is based on Heidegger and Dreyfuss, who are calling upon the recognition of Descartes Error in his infamous Subjective OBJECTIVE duality...and that error is not a mere woke thing... it's your problem Michael. You don't have an Objective morality because objective is a false dichotomy. We are in and of this world just as we are in and of our bodies....like the Christians and their incarnation preoccupation nailed explicitly btw. Geez and he's a "smart guy"

[@juniperjennifer]

@@matthewparlato5626 preoccupied with God is time we’ll spent.

[@Anneheed]

I’m so glad to see this finally hit more mainstream platforms. Super interesting discussion!

[@danielbrowniel]

I recently had a really really wild spiritual experience and now I am perplexed as to why God would show some people these things, but not all? Perhaps some people wouldn't talk about their experiences like I am about to? Basically a few months ago I was laying in bed, my back hurt, I was thinking about rolling over to get in a less painful position.. Out of nowhere I felt a hand come over my left shoulder and set down on my chest. (where did it come from? How did I know it was there, when I couldn't see it?? DONT KNOW) When this hand layed down on me it was like my entire body and soul was absolutely loaded with pure joy. It was so unbelievably intense and so completely overwhelming that I almost couldn't handle it and I was beyond intimidated within the 3 seconds that this hand was on me. So after 3 seconds or so, the hand lifted and the moment it lifted, as a knee jerk reaction I just blurted, "thankyou!" like a reversed gasp, mumbling thankyou. Idk how that came out of my mouth when I didn't even have time to put together why this was happening. So, it turns out I'm not the only person that has experienced something like this, I yesterday, met a man from South Africa who is also a Christian and had an experience where he felt that wild/ intense joy.. It is so unearthly, and alien a feeling to have any emotion as strong as this.. and to have it be injected into your being faster than a drug, faster than electricity, it was like light. It was like breathing for the first time ever without ever knowing that you could breathe. I spent decades being a Christian and never experiencing anything to that magnitude and the only reason I think God doesn't do this,, is because it has an effect of depressing you. You want what you cannot have, something that satisfying should be as available to me as the air I breathe. So for me, going from just 3 seconds of whatever that was, being near God? Going from that, back to work/ everyday life is depressing, it is spiritually suffocating, it makes me realize our world is much closer to hell than heaven.

[@1847bdr]

The mind brings everything into existence through the breath and word! The Holy Trinity!

[@stueve]

I'd love to see Stephen Meyer on Rogan.

[@bryantalexander2359]

Agreed

[@AndrewC4]

Loved it, indeed. Props to Bryan for probably being the push to get Dr. Meyer on JRE

[@franzpaul6244]

you are an oracle...

[@heidiooohs]

Good news. Latest Rogan podcast is with Meyer

[@franzpaul6244]

@@heidiooohs yup- hopefully he soon follows with James Tour...

[@MarkMetternichPhotographyLLC]

What a beautiful civil discourse. So refreshing without the typical ego that is so pronounced in many other discourses from very different perspectives. One of the best conversations I’ve heard on the subject with humility. Thank you for this wonderful podcast.

[@salomonligthelm14]

I love this Bryan, you are really digging at the heart of things with this line of questioning…

[@AgainstTheGrain1991]

Shermer didn’t bring anything new to the table, just the typical questions we all have while meyers brought very informative answers that wowed everyone

[@johnnygallardo76]

I love that Bryan Callen is interested in this and is not afraid to ask the meaning of certain words phrases of things these guys say I'm learning more this way.

[@juniperjennifer]

He is fearless while not afraid being in fear. 🇺🇸

[@mickey_rose]

Whoa. Didn’t expect this! Good job Callen! Keep it up!

[@phillipschwabe2085]

Bryan is the man for finding men like Stephen Myers and Dr Tour!

[@kidheyful]

De tour is an idiot outside of his specific field

[@TheSaiyanRace]

Wow, you got Dr Stephen Meyer! I love his work, and I have 2 of his books. Darwin's Doubt and Signature in the cell. WLC and now Dr. Meyer, Awesome Bryan!

[@invaderzim1265]

At the 01:18:50 mark, did Dr. Stephen Meyer revealed the name of this mathematician yet? I'm curious.

[@AlmaTlust]

I really like the respect and appreciation they show for each other, even though they disagree on things. We need more of that in our culture of despise and hatred for anything that doesn't agree with our narrow minds...

[@jacobogutierrezsanchez]

It is very interesting Dr. Meyer's position that the existence of God is a question of science.

[@Spectre4913]

Everything is a question of science. That's just common sense, not very interesting or revolutionary.

[@sczoot6285]

There's a clear delineation between what people define today as "science" and what actual science is. Knowledge of absolute laws is absolutely a thing despite what is spoken of here and needs to be taken seriously, as the abandonment of such understanding leads to entire fields of "science" for lack of a better term that are predicated on false axioms thereby invalidating the field of study.

[@ultramarinechaplain88]

Stephen meyer was on shermers podcast before and that was one of the best discussions ive heard... Now they are in one room?? 1 hour zoomed by quick

[@Scarhandz]

I wish i could like it twice, i can't... so instead, i'll say this. Bryan, you have all the gifts to stand out in this field. Your whole life has led to this (imo) please keep your ADHD ass with it coz its a real gold mine of influence that will grow with consistency, a change i selfishly want, is to see you take on the best of your "peers" in this genre.. i hope you consider that comments are your community without a forum. Most mean well and want you to succeed. Haters gon hate, but even some of those have to admit, this is great conversation. More please. Great questions, respectful, no interrupting. I just think its too fascinating to exist at all, that its so bizzare, there has to be a reason for it all... A God of some kind, or we are in the "Matrix" that we wake out of when we die, only to discover that, just 5 minutes have passed, in the place where we are ACTUALLY from... In a future world where you can live a whole life while waiting for your spouse to shop, lol.

[@CaptainFights]

"A little philosophy inclineth man's mind to atheism, but depth in philosophy bringeth men's minds about to religion." - Sir Francis Bacon

[@careywaldie6735]

Hold on a second! People talking about great questions without yelling and name calling? What year is this?

[@Si_Mondo]

These are men from a different generation.

[@jessejones3423]

Stephen Meyer is a GENIUS I,'ve got all his 3 books Darwin's Doubt, Signature in Cell and Return of the God Hypothesis. Must read books

[@WrinkledPlatypus]

What's interesting to me about Michael Shermer is that he explicitly believes in anthropogenic climate change, seems like the easiest thing to be skeptical of.

[@sbjrcourses7961]

I could listen to Meyer and Shermer all day long!

[@charliek2893]

Love Stephen Meyer!

[@adamsmith-wi3qg]

Shermer described the atheists' position perfectly around the 37min mark - "I don't want to believe in things that have to be believed in to be true" If he's married I hope his wife doesn't see this interview 😂 otherwise he better have a good answer prepared for the next time she asks him if he loves her

[@rcmysm9123]

Not only that, but he literally has to believe what he is saying.

[@brianmeen2158]

@@rcmysm9123I like Schermer but he’s not a strong debater

[@cejotajunior3151]

I loved it kkkkkkkkkk

[@joshmeyers372]

He also has to believe in the accuracy of all knowledge taught to him that formed his worldview. Point being / no one escapes belief

[@AustinDpOwers89]

He has to believe his own senses and mind are accurately perceiving the world at all times.

[@blackswan7568]

1:27:27 was my main takeaway from this episode. Asking these big questions and debating them is what makes life worth living (at least in the Socratic sense). Skeptics and atheists need guys like Stephen Meyer to pique their brains and help them stay open-minded, while theists and religious folks need guys like Michael Shermer to help them think critically about their beliefs. That's why I'm grateful to both men for agreeing to this talk. This, my friends, is how we get closer to Truth.

[@angusdesire]

That was brilliant. Meyer is my intellectual hero but hats off to Mr Shermer, I disagree but what a a good man. Bryan Callan is excellent, first time I have seen him, great mediator. Well done all of you.

[@crustyMilk]

It's nice to see Bryan making an attempt. And his guests showed good patience.

[@rageoid]

He's getting great guests. The human experience is by nature limited by our perceptive abilities. The longing for understanding produces all kinds of ideas and human mind observations, which may or may not be true, we will never really "know," since the limits of our perception define our existence ultimately. Great discussion to get one thinking about the universe as we perceive it !

[@33Cigarettes]

This was an excellent episode, and a great example of the cordiality that there should be in discussions like these. Internet theists and atheists should take notes.

[@peteranthonyofthefamilybir18]

I love GOD..! ref: as in.. ● Gift ● Orientated ● Dividends 👇 The narrative about a all-seeing, revengeful, absent-minded, DEITY with A PENIS..? NOT so much...!!!

[@lonzo61]

I am a nonbeliever, and I assure you I felt no compulsion to "take notes".

[@Scarhandz]

Thank you Bryan Callen, im so happy you went back to this more intelletual and funny podcast, up & running better than ever. I was one of the tens, if not hundreds of listeners to the o.g audio podcast haha, and am also a die hard tmp guy. You are killin it!, the numbers are growing with these fantastic guests. Michael Shermer's podcast is the sh*t too.

[@alopez78]

Mind blown starting @ 1:18:30. I can't even articulate why. Thank you for making these types of videos.

[@tylerfoley2859]

Let your guest get one in bro 👍🏼🇺🇸

[@francoisschneegans8881]

You have to give it to Bryan, a comedian, to be able to stir such a philosophical theological debate this way. Amazing discussion guys!

[@MrRickkramer]

Science can’t find God, but those who seek God will surely find Him.

[@bobbyboywonder12]

Tried. Didn’t find him.

[@brianthompson5521]

Bryan has a very philosophical and deeply probing mind!

[@JP-dx8xt]

This just keeps getting better! The content is 💯 B!

[@patrickkrueger8768]

It’s called the image of God , as is our mind over our processes, so is Gods mind over His processes, where we get to commune with such minds.

[@RogerZerne]

I find Mike to be a truly intelligent and likable guy and I have a lot of respect for him, but Steve is far more convincing.

[@jamespenny9482]

My sentiments exactly!

[@ASHsor]

Gullibility

[@mcjiggy8821]

Just an amazing Podcast! Thanks to all three of you!

[@JCNewsom]

I’m a Christian so I am aware of my bias. I’ve read three of Myer’s books and I don’t think most responses to his arguments are fair nor are they adequate. But again, I realize my bias. I very-much doubt however that anyone truly is without bias. One of the things I find frustrating is that many of the skeptic types act as if they are objective and have no deeper reasoning behind their beliefs than reason itself. Religious people are always encouraged to examine their assumptions and this is not something practiced most times by the other side. I have listened to Michael on several occasions and I will say that he is at least respectful towards those he disagrees with which is a rare find with many in this conversation. Great discussion.

[@pjaworek6793]

Aware of your bias. How is that possible if you believe something completely; you're convinced of something and biased towards any information that could disprove your belief. You're not aware of the bias that when loosened would dissolve your belief. That's what a bias does, blinds you. Religious people are in no way ever encouraged to doubt their beliefs. Prove it, let's hear one religious person telling people to be skeptical. Nuts!

[@noiceman]

@@pjaworek6793 "Religious people are in no way ever encouraged to doubt their beliefs. Prove it, let's hear one religious person telling people to be skeptical." As a former militant atheist of 20 years and now an Orthodox Christian, I have to say you have no idea what you're talking about. There are countless examples in the New Testament describing the Apostles as being doubtful of Christ and Christ telling them that it is natural to doubt. Moreover, most of the people on the interwebs encouraging people to be skeptical of the government or mainstream media are conservative Christians. To argue that "religious" people don't tell people to be skeptical is intellectually dishonest and demonstrably incorrect.

[@reenie6738]

@@pjaworek6793we are all biased. But if you become aware of your bias you are no longer blinded. Your eyes are open and you will be less likely to let your bias dominate your ability to critically think and be able to entertain other views in good faith and even be open to good arguments that may change your views.

[@jamesclab1]

Thank you gentlemen for sitting down together!!

[@AleInBywater]

Michael is a very likable sceptic, and very respectfull and knowledgeable. Stephen is incredible and knowledgeable beyond comprehension😃 Very intelligent man. Host: "have you heard of it?", talking about one random book he has read from Newton, Stephen: "Yeah, ive studied this stuff."😂🤩 He has read most of the stuff there is on the matters at hands, at least all the big names. Scholar with capital S.

[@AleInBywater]

@Muneeb Iqbal And? What are you trying to express?

[@michaelnapper4565]

Man, this was such a good listen. I wish it were longer. I think we are thirsty for not only truth, but also intellectual dialog. Damn our mainstream media.

[@darrellanderson6650]

We are all in this crazy thing together. Good to hear some civil discussion.

[@MichaelMcDonald-lu3et]

Dr Meyer is a next level debater on this topic.

[@josephKillinas]

This was fantastic! Keep doing episodes like this!

[@petethepeg2]

Soooo refreshing to see this congenial meeting of minds with diametrically opposed world views and the presenter right in the middle . This way we can all be stimulated in equal measure without having to take a hostile one sided view . As Stephen meyer said , the battle line laid out by Richard Dawkins is a very elegant and convenient way to sum up the materilist world view. Also Kudos to michael Shermer . I found him more amenable in this conversatiuon than usual and could take on board his views and arguments with less resistance . In a way they all represent the world views that the world holds . I`ve saved this to watch again . Thanks! PS Full declareation ,i`m a believer but love to know what makes folk tick. I did an arts degree at university many years ago and my own twin brother went down the science road . He has become an Emeritus Professor at a top university. he consequently has become a child of Richard Dawkins in his scientific world view . Our world views clash mightily and we both get very aerated with each other . But i`m fascinated that we were both bought up with same friends and girlfriends and education, love etc and yet ended up with diametrically oppsed worl views. This podcast sums this all up nicely . Peace !

[@chrissimmons3213]

Stephen Meyer is the man

[@Francoisdp82]

Oh wow. Thanks for having this conversation.

[@withoutlimits16]

Damn this Stephen guy came prepared