BukhariGate Part 1: Sahih Bukhari is NOT so Sahih -Mufti Abu Layth

In this video, Mufti Abu Layth investigates widely held misconceptions regarding the authenticity and authorship of the Bukhari hadith collection we have today. Part 1.

[@shovon100]

The Quran Revels to us that the distorter of the previous scriptures are none other than the scholars

[@cubbman79cubster37]

Well said Mufti, this topic has been plaguing my mind for years

[@shovon100]

Bukhari's book can be considered as historical record, I think. - which cannot be called as authentic but people can use it to get knowledge about history with analyze and self judgement.

[@shovon100]

No one dare to take a step like what you have done. if are doing that for the respect of our Allah, prophet, Quran honestly, inshallah Allah will be with you. when we talk to any general muslims who is little practicing, they dont even want to accept that sahih bukhari book has errors.

[@khanG-gq9hc]

A very thought provoking video! Thank u for making us open our eyes. May Allah preserve Mufti Abu Layth

[@tmk5]

Absolutely right too much believe in Hadith books esp Bukhari and Muslim particularly the problematic Ahadith created Qur'an only type of people. If we adopt a middle position like Abu Hanifa and Imam Malik rs, most problems can be diminished.

[@douglassurridge]

As a side note according Jewish law any genital deformity would have disqualified Musa (as) from service as A Prophet.

[@douglassurridge]

@Always Ahmed Leviticus 21:16-23 [by extension this also applies to Moses and Aaron (as).] 16The Lord said to Moses, 17“Say to Aaron: ‘For the generations to come none of your descendants who has a defect may come near to offer the food of his God. 18No man who has any defect may come near: no man who is blind or lame, disfigured or deformed;19no man with a crippled foot or hand,20or who is a hunchback or a dwarf, or who has any eye defect, or who has festering or running sores or damaged testicles. 21No descendant of Aaron the priest who has any defect is to come near to present the food offerings to the Lord. He has a defect; he must not come near to offer the food of his God.22He may eat the most holy food of his God, as well as the holy food; 23yet because of his defect, he must not go near the curtain or approach the altar, and so desecrate my sanctuary. I am the Lord, who makes them holy.’ ”

[@everfreshlove]

Great stuff! Real eye opener. Thanks for breaking the spell of divinity of Bokhari shereef. Sigh of relief! Alhumdulilah. Keep critiquing anything and everything that brings bad name to Islam and the Holy prophet (peace be upon him). Jazakallah!

[@stochasticxalid9853]

Assalamualaikom Bro. You are my hero. Thanks for your amazing work. Wa assalam

[@nothing0870]

So this guy is a deviant. ALLAH bless him with a long life for keeping it real. Excellent content, very educational.

[@ricosalb]

Could you make a graphic illustration of the faults in the chains that you emphasize?

[@sayfali2623]

salafis worship bukhari almost

[@notadane]

Salaam Mufti - I appreciate the effort that went into this research. But why are you showing the text on a reversed camera? :D

[@pashtun631]

Someone please list the hadiths in the comment section!

[@mrtaz4340]

Of course Bukhari was a human being so he wasn't 100 percent correct and perfect. He made mistakes like we all do.

[@doncotti_certi4ever]

Keep speaking the Haqq brother

[@155stw]

Mufti Saab, the english translation, Volume 7, Book 63, Number 182 , says "Give me yourself (in marriage) as a gift.". Is the " "(in marriage)" there in the Arabic?

[@farukashraf5626]

I believe that all hadith, including those of the other Imams, should be revised by a complete hadith commision to re-check each and every narration on the principles of accepting and rejecting hadith according to the medhabs. To start of this dream-team hadith commission, the team should include Mufti abu layth, Dr Shabir Ally, Shayk Atabek Shukurov and someone who is an expert in only "tafseer of the Quran" to constantly reflect on any narration and rejection/acceptance of narrations, if it goes against/along the Quran. This person should not know to much about hadith to narrow his scope of thought trough Quran only (the gate keeper of the commission). I would also appoint a projectmanager / scrummaster who does not involve himself with any theological aspect, but only organizational/commisionary tasks. Scrum methodoloy would be perfect for such a project! what a dream... May Allah have mercy on us all and make our good dreams and wishes come true.

[@AbuBakr-Siddiq]

Great job mufti Saab. And ty for being sensible this time👍

[@tsgillespiejr]

"These are the best chicken nuggets in the entire world." Hyperbole. It's a thing. Apparently a lot of "scholars" in our history never got that memo (I guess it wasn't in a book).

[@1rozi]

Wonderful work.🙏🏾👏🏿🇯🇲

[@heartofodds]

We get frog-boiled by the schemers. Hindrances we can attach pride and identity to. University professors do it all the time. Their devotion is to reputation rather than truth, perhaps.

[@349h4]

The rasor blade on the necklace, is it Occam's rasor? 😉

[@saeedabdullah3356]

I really enjoyed and learned from this lecture but when you quoted Fatima Zara (as) not speaking to Abu Bakr well this is True and we’ll know in the traditions passed down from The Amal Of Medina and AhulBayt

[@learnzz9255]

Where are the time stamps in description? Why did you leave them out

[@zohebalikhan7404]

Thank you for highlighting this problem. Jazakhallah

[@kimabunuh6762]

Do you admit that bukhari also reports that the prophet saw Aisha presented to him in a dream, and that he then said that if it was from Allah then it would happen (this is the meaning not directly translated)?

[@zohebalikhan7404]

Can I ask where you did you scholarship course?

[@pashtun631]

Mufti you destroyed it in your first ten min!!!!! Alhamdulillah

[@abdullatif9581]

Thank you mufti

[@anthonyhead3330]

I believe that based on the tone in Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 that they’re going to Adopt what you’re teaching me being a Revert and being attacked by my Christian family appreciate your wisdom I always said The month of Ramadan the Muslim’s are at its best. 30 days of The Holy Koran and very minimal Hadiths. I love Allahu Ta’alaa and Muhammad sas and the Blessed Noble Quran those three quotes in the Hadiths can stay 1. Refer back to the book of Allah and 2. That Muhammad didn’t want anything written about him. And 3. Muhammad sas said three generations after him there will be no more, there will come a people GROSS and OBESE in their manner and ways, they will give a verdict without being Asked. I enjoy learning the Surahs in The Book of Allah and when I read it compared to trying to understand Hadith has a Spiritual difference Allahu Akbar JazakAllahu Khayran

[@MrMShake]

Mufti which book is more authentic or reliable between Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim?

[@jackpitaji]

1:03:30 tell me hadis no some one I want to confirm it.

[@cogitoergosum5414]

Brother have you read dan gibson assumption that mecca is actually the city of petra ?

[@yasiralkhabees1488]

Ibrahim g Petra is in Jordan

[@adamahmadbey714]

suggestion to mufti. shias are using you for their motive. They have nothing to do with what are your thoughts. They just want to weak the narrative of khulfa rashideen. To promote their khurafat. mufti must think about it just to balance the things a bit. They need dose from you.

[@tmk5]

You like very nice not drinking soda and not LOLs.

[@JUSLOFI]

Tariq Maqsood Khan it’s not soda... it’s RED BULL!

[@zemzemyahya3967]

Hadith? Right now there are more than 37 Qurans containing more than 5,000 variations. hahaha