Butterscotch Pie

[@WyseGuide]

You can print the recipe here: www.wyseguide.com/butterscotch-pie/

[@amiedavis5257]

I don't know if you've ever tried this or not, but butterscotch pie on a pecan shortbread crust. This is a must try and you've no idea what you're missing. I put a sweetened cream cheese layer between the shortbread and the pudding.

[@DuckDuck42]

My mom LOVES butterscotch pie, so I know what I'm doing for her this Mother's Day!

[@PrototypeDyna]

Is your mother by chance named Toriel haha.

[@michellebartel]

Gorgeous pie...yummy!

[@lenap2906]

I have been PRAYING and searching for this butterscotch pie recipe for a long time my great aunt used to make it when I was a little girl. She is gone now and no one knew the recipe, I remembered some of the ingredients but not all. Your looks quite similar, I can't wait to try it out. Thank you Wyse and BLESS YOU. I just came across your video and I also subscribed and ready to watch them all.

[@melissaparks5947]

You make everything look so Good 😀

[@pamelacorsi]

Wow! That looks like the best pie ever!

[@amberluttrelll8359]

I totally need this in my life. I love your channel

[@terryperri2916]

I love how much you love your pie. You sold me. I have to make it in the morning!

[@lanaspires7578]

I just love that your baking on a cold snowy day… Makes it’s feel warm and comfy!! ❤️

[@robfohl]

Love your recipes Caleb..

[@mattgeiger9988]

I remember my grandfather bringing home Amish pies near Christmas, my favorite was butterscotch pie from Ohio. It was something like heaven.

[@music292929]

Turned out 10/10! Delicious! Thanks so much for sharing!

[@dianasinclair8807]

I made this pie for my sister last year and everyone loved it~ Today, she had some dental surgery, so I am making just the pudding component to see her through recuperation. I adore your kitchen: it's lovely

[@paulaszymczak8771]

I love meringue too! 😍

[@flourchylde]

Tomorrow is Sunday and this pie will be happening in my kitchen. Thanks, Kaleb.

[@marymauldin3229]

My Mother use to make what she called a brown Carmel pie. Everyone loved it.

[@zapsoda4984]

love this video! reading through other recipes was so daunting, i appreciate how you show every step up close

[@abby-a]

Thank you so much for putting the ingredients and the measurements in the description box, its really helpful when cooking 🧡

[@nancyjohnson5810]

OMGosh your making me droll as your eating this! This is by far the best recipe that I have seen on KZbin! Thanks for sharing and I cannot wait to try this. Awesome and I love your bubbly humorous personality. Your just so fun to watch. Oh I must subscribe now Thanks again Wyse Guide

[@jodysweetg5344]

I totally love you. Your ideas, tips, recipes, i always feel like we are in a room together and your talking directly to me. Awesome.

[@shellylbarrett]

I’m making that. Butterscotch is my favorite

[@cindythibaut3337]

Oh my gosh this is my favorite pie ever! Love it! Love your kitchen too. The windows above the sink with a beautiful scenery. ❤

[@berthalandry4903]

Hello thanks for all your recipes I love them I done your meatloaf 2 days ago every one loves it and we’re 8 5 kids and 3 adults and it’s so healthy compared to the one i was doing i would definitely do it again and and the butterscotch pie and pumpkin is my favorite and I am going to try this thank you so much you’re assume love your videos take care and stay safe 💜

[@cherylcosgrove511]

Omg amazing!!

[@Peachy7-k9h]

You are the best. The look on your face is priceless after eating your first bite of pie. Love this! 😁

[@karlawilson4828]

Love butterscotch pie! An Easter tradition in our family

[@PeaceintheWorld2025]

Omg yummmmmy!!!! 💗💗💗💗💗💗

[@mg5635]

I just made your pie recipe! It was so delicious! Never had butterscotch pie and I love butterscotch! I’m a new fan of Swiss meringue as well. Thank you Wyse 🤗 I also love the way you teach. Issaquah, WA 🇺🇸

[@colleenhopp8861]

My mom made this and I forgot how much I loved it. Now I have to make one.

[@sherylmangold5]

I love your recipes and I like how you are about flavor because that is what it is all about hello

[@diannplatt-roberts8692]

Hubby would love this. Me, I'm a pumpkin pie lady. Have a great week.

[@lauragrandgenett]

That looks heavenly to me? Thanks!

[@lauragrandgenett]

I gotta make this!! Thanks so much!

[@jnorth9702]

Thank you for sharing. I’m trying this one

[@jayneward6649]

Oh wow, that looks amazing & so yummy ❤ ❤❤❤

[@MaryM454]

I also want my pudding home made nothing else. Used to find butterscotch pie on nearly every restaurant dessert menu and in almost all café dessert cases. I haven't made butterscotch pudding in a long time but just had to get to work on some right away. I thought I lost it though, the liquefied sugar when I added in the liquid ingredients mixed together caused the sugar to crystalize and I had a perfect sugar candy at the bottom of my pan, thankfully it melted and blended in just fine before it was time for the butter and vanilla. The egg white I saved for a lemon meringue pie I am going to make latter this week... for a bigger meringue on the pie. Cannot wait to do the meringue your way. Thanks so much!

[@tamiernesti1796]

I made this today and it is so delicious! And my pie crust, using your recipe as well, was the best I’ve ever made. Thank you! FYI, you left out the addition of the vanilla and salt to the pudding in the written instructions.

[@kristinz5081]

Your videos are such a joy to watch!

[@ejmedina7065]

Wow Kaleb, yum, yum sure looks delicious!! Thank you

[@robertasolomon7052]

Your. ARE. A Great. Cook

[@thechubbyhubby1650]

I NEED this butterscotch pie in my life!! I’m going to make it just because it’s Tuesday. Your pie looks so good, it could be used as currency in the 3rd world!!!! Xoxo

[@phillipsmom6252]

Yummy 👍😀💜

[@HomeGrownCountryGirl]

Looks delicious, Kaleb! Hail IOWA!

[@heatherwallace1607]

I can't wait to make this. Looks so good. I was trying to find something different in a butter scotch pie. The sugar caramelized I think is really going to change it up. I love your positive personality too. You make it fun.

[@michelesylvis9061]

❤ineed the recipe on the butterscotch pie

[@anitraahrens905]

That looks sooooo good!

[@rally618]

I went to Amish Country today and had amazing butterscotch creme pie and wanted to make one. This isn't a creme pie Wooooh Baby that looks Delish 🤪😯 Love anything butterscotch!!!!

[@abby-a]

Thank you so so so much for making this recipe alot of ppl say that this pie is delicious and I haven't tried it

[@Jennjen1985]

Omg I love this... and you're so 😋 🧁 sweet I'm glad I found you 💗 💛 I can't wait to try. Thank you ❤️ 😍

[@leeanndusci9511]

Butterscotch is my favorite. Will definitely be trying this recipe

[@mosesjonathan1240]

Instablaster.

[@Jeannified]

This looks insanely delicious! I am definitely gonna try this!

[@deniseb2571]

Uhg looks so good!! 😋

[@lisafair8168]

Very entertaining!!!!😃😃😃

[@janetspiteri5043]

I really love your channel!!! ❤🎉🎉

[@jot4336]

I love butterscotch! I'm going to put this on my list to make when I'm on vacation ❤💕

[@liarprincessxblindprinceni7067]

toriel liked this

[@kibidango272]

"I wanna leave a lil bit more for myself" hahaha! relatable!

[@shundakm]

Your recipes and tips are very helpful and great, you should do a cookbook, seriously. I’d love that and to own one also Kaleb

[@roberthicks5704]

Yummmm. Looks wonderful. :)

[@joannerobinson9023]

No words yummy 😋

[@sharonlatour6230]

SQUEEEAAALLLLLLL!!!!!!! OMGGGGGGGGGGGEEEEEEEEEEE!!!! I am going to make this pie

[@michelesylvis9061]

Recipd for pie thankyou

[@ivytasha5434]

This looks amazing. I can’t wait to try it! I love your videos! ☺️🥧

[@sweetdeb100]

I love so many of your recipes. I made your butterscotch pie and your pie crust. The butterscotch pie is sooo yummy. The pie crust turned out ok but it shrunk down about in the pie plate. Just by chance do you have any idea what I did wrong? Thank you Sir for sharing all of your great videos with us God bless you and loving family. ❤️

[@marygonzales5957]

Auh chicken Noodle I got to try this I sure do! Thank you!

[@bizzerktheboy3319]

Ok i Heart you! You are outstanding im an instant fan

[@eapuplampu5749]

I'm making this ❤

[@nidhavellir]

Adorable

[@callioscope]

❤ the idea of a Swiss meringue. For the longest time I thought I hated meringue … until I started making SMBC, and then pavlovas. The texture difference between mostly uncooked meringue and fully cooked meringue is like night and day. My husband loves butterscotch pudding, but cannot eat gluten. Can I sub cornstarch or some other starch, or even some xanthan gum? Because we can get a GF pie crust and I could make this pie.

[@zackthecharizard9139]

Toriel wants to join this.

[@anounimouse]

This MUST be Deliciousness!!! I've never seen Kaleb taste more than a single bite of anything - he couldn't restrain himself from tasting throughout!!! (posted in Mar 2024)

[@gloriagibney3085]

Show us how to make the pie crust... Please 🙏❤️

[@derekmorrison4191]

Yum🤤

[@ianscianablo8507]

Hi Caleb. Any baking pie crust recipes for CREAM BASED pie? Do you egg wash? Do you dock it? Still using your butter/lard crust. Thank you!

[@marygonzales5957]

I get a kick out of you you make feel like I am with in your kitchen. Ha ha!! I bet that pie is good!

[@messybunsoap6712]

You are too cute! This looks delish! Tfs

[@wendystone9591]

This is the first video of yours that I've watched. You're so inspiring and I'm making this pie as soon as I can! Thanks for the great recipe!

[@gojewla]

I like flour as a thickening agent much better than corn starch in many cases. I think gravy is MUCH better if you start with a roux.

[@marygonzales5957]

Wow that's a fancy machine. Real nice meringue. Is marshmallow like !? Raw whites?

[@adrang1003]

Hey, happy thanksgiving, thank you for the recipe. My daughter has made this a few times but for some reason the consistency is not firm enough. What do you think she may be doing wrong. She has followed the instructions but for some reason it’s not firm enough.

[@HaydenStudios]

This is probably the first butterscotch pie video I've ever seen that doesn't acknowledge Undertale.

[@frankvelazqiez2961]

GOAT Strikes again.

[@flourchylde]

So I made the pudding exactly as directed. I was a little worried when the melted sugar hardened as I poured in the milk but it all melted exactly as you said it would. However, I was a little disappointed in the flavor which was not butterscotchy enough. The consistency was perfect. Any thoughts?

[@WyseGuide]

Hello!!! So glad the consistency was good! If the flavor didn’t seem strong enough did you take the sugar to a dark amber color in the beginning? The darker the sugar the more flavor? That is what I would try!

[@flourchylde]

@@WyseGuide , thanks, Kaleb. I will give it another go and let the sugar go darker. I was so afraid of burning it the first time. I love, love , love your videos. I think I made just about every one of your Christmas recipes in December, all with spectacular results.

[@leahwilson130]

I made it today and it was delicious. But I thought it tasted more like caramel than butterscotch. It was very good.

[@PrototypeDyna]

Toriel would be proud

[@BigMoneysLife]

Anytime my mom has made pudding, she still gets the skin on the top when she covers it. What is she doing wrong?

[@nelliehedrick3147]

Do you take it to church pot lucks ??

[@louisecroft1914]

👍🤟

[@hummingbird275]

I don’t see a pie crust recipe. ❓❓❓

[@bonnyborland7438]

Can you please send the exact amount of each ingredient. You don’t give us the measurements so how do we know how much to put in ???

[@WyseGuide]

Hello! The recipes are in the video description and also on my website! Wyseguide.com

[@AnOrdinaryDude13]

So this is what Toriel had been making

[@Growstrong1]

Why wouldn't you eat more than one bite??

[@marygonzales5957]

Oops I panicked!! Your browning meringue!!! Duh!!! I have never tasted this pie before!!!

[@Nanna2five]

If i want this as a pudding not a pie, would i put less flour..

[@natalieeubank4533]

Flour helps it thicken you would leave the flour measurement

[@victoriawolfe686]

Okay see we need a kitchen tour. Because inset cabinet doors. Drool.

[@kathycrone1258]

Watched you yesterday. You didn't give measurements as you went. Would love to make your recipes. Sorry a waste of my time to watch with no measurements. You seem so good.

[@SisterShirley]

Kathy Crone, the recipe is on his website.

[@Merasus]

* So... butterscotch or cinnamon?

[@AverageNoL]

Butterscotch

[@eldin14]

So glad i saw this...seen others but your tips n tricks are Wonderful!! I am making this one and sharing!!!

[@WatersBreedlove]

Thanks! But where did you find that Big Blue Bottle¡🫨🤯🥹😍!