By the way, are YOU a GOOD PERSON? | Harvard Moral Dilemma

[@dom-xt9pt]

**reads title** **chuckles a bit** “No.”

[@thenuggernaut9084]

-Stephen, 2019

[@renithink7900]

Honestly tho XD

[@imjustdonehaha.1813]

Dhom yep me and Stephen and crazys

[@pomf5207]

its just a shadowy gru face and the words "no"

[@luciussakura5031]

SAME

[@-itzizumi-uwu4995]

Moral lesson of the video: Don't take a nap at the hospital

[@muchdeadsheep8038]

Exactly I'm never trusting doctors again

[@uhuh5963]

Ded

[@mylucidadventures6540]

I mean ask the 5 and see if any of them are willing to donate they all have different problems so Likly one of them will say to themself I'm gonna die anyway least I can do is save these 4 people. That's what I would do in that situation

[@lorekeeper685]

Doctors are not allowed to do that tbh

[@mylucidadventures6540]

@@lorekeeper685 ya but this is if you could get away with Anthony

[@crispybanana2328]

"By the way, are you a good person?" Why's Hosuh here? Of course he is

[@foof5695]

Yeah man hosuh is so innocent and cute

[@gemopunzalan8173]

@@foof5695 i know!!!!

[@anooska888]

@@foof5695 ikr!!!

[@jacksonbrown1372]

Ya

[@gaiacticcbacon]

Crispy Banana HE?!?!?!?!?!

[@fridasophiaaaa]

If you just need a simple push, then he's not that fat KILLED ME

[@barbara174]

love your profile picture lmao

[@fridasophiaaaa]

@@barbara174 LMAOOOO i love yours

[@barbara174]

@@fridasophiaaaa pls i love finding stays in random videos lmaooo

[@fridasophiaaaa]

@@barbara174 I knaurrr, it feels like we're a big fandom now lmao

[@barbara174]

@@fridasophiaaaa exactly LOLL

[@yoonseomg9693]

"then i wouldn't stop at this murder, i'd keep going!" Stephen- 2017

[@sianeds]

YoonseOmg *2020* Edit: I got 5 likes thank you so much its the most i’ve ever got on anything!

[@cheesethehoonter2955]

Sian Billington no *9999*

[@imjustdonehaha.1813]

YoonseOmg i agree

[@leafu8154]

Same.

[@sianeds]

Ender King303 no it’s *1136343416643437275445765657474783878911177*

[@corn8561]

The real question is: WHY TF DOES A HEALTHY GUY TAKE A NAP IN THE HOSPITAL

[@tarnyowl6068]

He’s suffering from plot convince syndrome

[@crom5906]

Mandatory check ups are a thing for specific jobs. Also some illnesses you only start to actually notice when it's too late. So even people who think they're perfectly fine get check ups because they might have a serious illness.

[@Silvianyay]

You know how long it takes for doctors to actually get to your room it takes them like a hour you could take a nap in that time

[@corn8561]

@@Silvianyay lol

[@genericname3470]

He could be waiting for a family member or friend who is getting checked out..

[@howltertrash6143]

1:12 if it is KKK, I would keep going STRAIGHT

[@novarayne9388]

6 3 6

[@hawksleysmith565]

could i go straighter?

[@linachorus2001]

What kind of KKK is it the Philippine KKK that is for making people have hope or the other one?

[@teaqap9943]

@@linachorus2001 probably the other one

[@STwins-kg3gy]

@@linachorus2001 yea I think so

[@KingSaysHello]

So, in my psychology class, we’re learning about how humans develop ethics and morals. Let me just say I quite literally jumped out of my seat when I saw we were watching a DanPlan video as one of the videos for class.

[@taniellemalloch694]

luckyy

[@Siidan-ii]

How

[@KingSaysHello]

@@Siidan-ii wdym how

[@user-tcf.orv.tsctir]

(ㅇㅁㅇ!)

[@pokevs2919]

​@@KingSaysHellohow do humans do that?

[@Kanna.o_o]

by the way can you survive stephen?

[@tibetgms]

Only shaggy with 50 %

[@toiletpaper790]

No, no one can

[@Userrook]

@@tibetgms not the meme

[@uknowwho4067]

Yes yes yes

[@deborahiraheta-gonzalez3499]

....if I come prepared.....

[@mb-pp8yz]

Moral of the story: don't be fat because everyone will want to sacrifice you

[@helpmeimakitkat]

Well I'm gonna die. Edit: I left for three months, what the heck?

[@CobiExter]

same

[@acutedog162]

I would kill the five people people on the track. They can learn not to be on a train track, in heaven.

[@lilcinnamonroll9577]

@@acutedog162 yo thats what i was kinda thinking like why are you on the tracks why don't you see a trolley is about to hit you. Like don't be stupid and you'll stay safe... but whatever

[@puffy2930]

Me that actually is but doesn't eat a lot now for so reason and only ate a little bit of food today: *So anyway-*

[@cffee3288]

So The trolley cart situation at the start I have an answer *why the hell would there be workers on an active trolley cart rail*

[@samgoode2274]

Blueberry Cheesecake I have an answer: I would not switch the track and would drive right over the five ppl, killing all 5 of them. Then I would stop the train after some distance and run back to the 5 guys. Hopefully the 1 guy from the other track would have come over to try and help the 5 ppl, and as I approach him, I look as if I’m scared and crying. Then when I’m close enough, I’ll stab and kill him. Then I’ll repetitively stab all 6 of them over and over as they cry out in pain begging me for mercy. Then I’ll finish all of them off, so they can’t come for revenge. This is assuming I could get away with everything.

[@whatintheactualkentuckyfri6603]

@@samgoode2274 edgy but I totally agree with you

[@superiorbeing8805]

@@samgoode2274 Do you need help??

[@constellious]

@@superiorbeing8805 It was a joke

[@shadybean3875]

Cøffee Cup u dumped morals down the drain

[@ACECLAN9000]

“If I am to chose between one evil and another, then I prefer not to choose at all”

[@ACECLAN9000]

Chris Qiu shhhhhh🤫

[@icewolfwolfie173]

@Chris Qiu that's what he wants.. See as many die

[@righthandstep5]

​@@icewolfwolfie173morality doesn't need your permission to justify it.

[@bleuming7199]

"This is Canada.. WHERE ARE ALL THE OTHER DOCTORS?!"

[@money_funny08]

I know!

[@sigridliiio1627]

In hawaii.

[@beatriz894]

I was shook(y)

[@sleepingforest4048]

We laugh now but....

[@dawnunger3446]

yeah here in canada we have tons of doctors!

[@blackbeast9920]

Stephen: 1 persons life is less valuable then 5 persons lives Also stephen: how dare you value that 5 lives over 1 life

[@chriscunningham8807]

We don't knowmwjerher the healthy guy's organs will be accepted by the people, needing a donor. To kill one person andmchqnce six deaths seems too risky. Kill one of the people needing an organ donor and give their organs to the other four people would be the most ethical and viable decision. The healthiest person or the sickest person in the group is now the big dilemma?

[@izzyfizzym]

True

[@CuzDino]

For the train one/ride I'd flip the the thing on the side and hit all 6 at the same time... I'm just kidding, dont kill me FBI

[@hylachusphobiae]

spelling please

[@kai3522]

ikr

[@aurianemalvesin9524]

4:23 "Lawsuit"! The only thing between Stephen and mass murder XD

[@THRILLMANblog1111]

Haha so true!!!

[@robert8192]

I was laughing so hard at 4:21 "You can get away with everything." and the responce was "Well, I wouldnt stop with just one murder.. I would keep going.." That had me rolling in hysterics...

[@eudoravia7082]

He instantly became my fave guy 😂 he’s so real 🤣

[@francies6175]

The real question how is the one without a heart alive

[@keks1491]

Maybe his heart is just almost "dead"

[@adamteashaw9441]

The true answer is that the one who needs the heart is dead, and you can transplant their organs

[@ake9454]

The one without the heart needs a transplant to get a different one, he still has a heart but he needs a better one to stay alive

[@PhoenixMilk]

Yeah and the one without a kidney can survive u only need one kidney to survive XD oof

[@adamteashaw9441]

@@PhoenixMilk you could have one kidney destroyed and one damaged enough to be failing, so he could have actually needed a kidney

[@Andionschannel]

I love this contrast of funny chatting and serious and intelligent brainstorming in your videos. Paired with the cartoon style it makes them so entertaining!

[@lindensalter6713]

I couldn't agree more. I'm now addicted to it. I might need help.

[@phoneservice10]

Andion I subbed can you sub back

[@asher_delphi976]

Yeah totally.... Definitely being selfless

[@andrew-paulclements1502]

The correct answer is tokyo drift the trolly to kill all 6

[@Furo6448]

Andrew Clements this man gets it

[@TravisBone14]

Just move the one guy over

[@natesal5037]

Andrew Clements go for that Sextupile kill streak

[@andrew-paulclements1502]

Deja Vu!

[@elainad6728]

Andrew Clements Or you could yell at them to get out of the way if you have time.

[@aldenstromberg7273]

I think that the biggest difference in the situations is that there is always an objectively better choice to save the 5 people over the 1, but in the doctor and fat guy situations, you would be making someone else's decision. If it is set in stone that you must make the decision, you can relatively guiltlessly sacrifice the one, but if the one still has agency, it feels wrong to choose for them.

[@BioTheHuman]

How can ethics be objective? Objective on which basis? Also, when you turn to kill the one person and save the other 5 you're doing the same thing as when you would push the fat guy or harvesting the organs, how can you not see it? what's different? Only because there is a machine between you and the victim? The point is that you're the one controlling the machine.

[@Orphim]

There's the logical answer I was looking for. The difference on a lot of these is the agency of the decision. If either of your choices means someone dies but only you can make that decision, it's easy to sacrifice the one for the many. However, if you choose to make someone make the sacrifice when they should have the option to make it themselves, it's no longer an unavoidable action on your part. They had the agency to make their own decision. The fat guy could choose to sacrifice himself to stop the trolley. The healthy patient could be informed and choose to give up their organs. You don't have the right to make that choice for them. With the trolley though and you having to choose to switch the rails, only you can make the choice and someone dies either way, so the correct decision morally would be the one for the many, because you had the agency to make a move and save more lives.

[@bahnankhayre9534]

But aren’t you just doing the same thing aren’t you taking the agency from the one person and basically forcing them to sacrifice themselves for the 5 people

[@Orphim]

@@bahnankhayre9534 That's something of a fair argument, but they are not even in the position to make the choice at that moment. It's really more of an explanation of the situation and why one is more easily seen as morally bad and the other is not seen that way so easily to most people.

[@bluejaysilverscythe7776]

Everyone came here with the knowledge that Stephen was probably not a good person.

[@Victoriai-y2m]

I like to think he kills with purpose, if he killed at all You know, killing bullies, KKK members, whatever else. An antihero like Deadpool, kinda Sorry if it makes no sense :D English is not my first language

[@fuzzeh5001]

@@Victoriai-y2m I think it's very clear Stephen is a good person in general. It's just his internet persona is an aggressive and rabid psychopathic killing machine 😂 and the Stephen he is in the videos also would kill people for no real reason

[@Victoriai-y2m]

@@fuzzeh5001 oh, no worries; i understand that's stephens persona, but i mean just in his own portrayal, haha

[@thatoneravenclaw417]

@@fuzzeh5001 oml... Fuzzeh!

[@evermoreonline3537]

It’s basic knowledge, like call 911 for emergencies, which way is left and right, and Stephen isn’t a good person.

[@moonkurai8188]

Moral of the story: Am I a good person? Well yes,but actually no

[@watermelon2485]

*mega twist*

[@TinosHut]

@@watermelon2485 are you sure or not?

[@watermelon2485]

@@TinosHut yes but actually no

[@minoreror9961]

No

[@leonardocarrillo865]

Good guess, but actually no

[@janreiafrica]

4:26 "Well then I won't stop at this murder, I'll keep going" Wise words from a Psychopath

[@shadowplayed6189]

Janrei Africa what anime???

[@weeb-senpai3919]

Mirai Nikki (Future Diary)

[@艾雯丽]

*Yuno Gasai would like to know your location.

[@tartaglia.]

Armin Arlert once said: “I don't like the terms "good person" or "bad person" because it is impossible to be entirely good to everyone. To some, you are a good person, while to others, you are a bad person.” So therefore, we are all neither good nor bad people.

[@kovici7226]

You’re not as bad as your worst decisions.

[@citriccat142]

its all abt perspective. There is no true good or evil, its just the way you see things vs others see things. At least thats what I think

[@kovici7226]

@@citriccat142 everyone has a different moral compass 👍

[@sitrinist2842]

thats a stupid thing to say. just because some people view you as bad or good doesn't mean you are bad or good because of their perspective of you. you are bad or good based on your actions

[@user-Mahhabat]

Next question: 6 patients come in your way that we’re hit by a trolley Hmm what a coincidence

[@headintheclouds01]

Ikr

[@renithink7900]

0.0bWow I never thought of that XD

[@PxndaCakes]

I guess that fat guy didn't stop the trolley...

[@ShiningDarknes]

@@PxndaCakes That was my reaction. Especially with the one being critically injured. Guess he didn't stop the trolley AND he didn't die AND the 5 guys didn't die so...the previous situation worked out way better than I could have hoped...granted they only _technically_ "survived" only to be left in a state where they still might die but hey, guess we are getting asked these questions by the devil, hear that guy loves technicalities.

[@wingardiumlachancla9078]

I immediately thought of it, I laughed so hard xDD

[@ioo5522]

“Are you a good person?” - No. Edit: uh..the f#ck?..likes? What? °-° YES! FINALLY :’)

[@farhiyaabdi1378]

Im a good person Or im i 😈😈😈😈😈

[@yoyoyoyoidk8849]

No I am not sorry but I already started killing 🤔😄

[@evelynem209]

I’m more like a wolf in sheep’s clothing lol

[@rvqqxl1626]

“This is Canada..! wHerE aRe thE othErs dOctOrS!?” *lmao* 😂

[@ςααδα]

Lol

[@bripollard1287]

not in america that’s for damn sure😂

[@unknownbutracistanimator171]

lol tru for real lmao

[@AloysiusWaffle]

In America WHERE ARE THE OTHER 99999999 PATIENTS

[@alastorbutwithagun]

Yeah where are they >:(

[@jonl7855]

I had a class in university in Japan during study abroad, and it was literally reading and talking over these exact situations, and talking through it in groups and in front of the class, then the professor would discuss the author's philosophy and the 'answers' to these questions. Brought back memories. Thanks for the vid. Funny enough this video actually came out before I even went to the class, so in an alternate reality I could have seen this first, and went into the class already enlightened.

[@paperbagcomedychannel7492]

Hosuh: this is Canada, where are the other doctors Me: *Social distancing is more important*

[@paperbagcomedychannel7492]

Ok

[@TheRabbitInTheTwoTonneHat]

I could bring corona back to 2017

[@wisconsin50]

@@TheRabbitInTheTwoTonneHat prankavirus

[@afakkafa7009]

One doctor per hospital LOL

[@fluffystuff500]

Wait, if I have time to turn, don't the workers have time to move?

[@rscenicc29]

no.no they wont

[@Jun-cz9cv]

They must be stupid to not hear a loud freaking train running their way.

[@rscenicc29]

But.....they dont know where its gonna go

[@MaddieThePancake]

@Klint AC I don't care, if a trolley is coming my way, I'm getting off the track regardless of whether or not it turns

[@paloma2674]

No, because in the original situation, the workers are all wearing earmuffs and can't hear the trolley coming.

[@cold.raviolis]

A teacher once asked us the first question the other way around. So you're driving towards the one person but plot twist: the one person is someone you know and like.

[@smolson8471]

That's a good twist. It makes you think even more about your values.

[@airez3765]

Have her die and retrieve the body AHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHSHSHSHAHSHAHA #Necrophilia

[@allyarendt4886]

My teacher said that the girl was your child lol

[@you_gullible_fucc]

I'm going with 5 people then. Call me selfish but every human has to be selfish at some point

[@Kana_108_]

I save the one i love rather than 5 guys i don't know.

[@_heh]

my teacher played this video in class yesterday, i havent watched danplan in years and man i miss hoshuh and stephen

[@ellapaet7655]

But the real question is... why? Are they idiots? Why are they working on a active trolley rail?

[@masterduck1676]

As I said before, Daniel makes up unrealistic events because he enjoys messing with people's minds

[@blakeevin9936]

This wasn't made by Daniel it was a professor

[@sharifbrown3567]

@@masterduck1676 if you don't know about the trolly problem you're too young for KZbin.

[@masterduck1676]

@@blakeevin9936 so . . . ? Daniel chose to put it in the video

[@masterduck1676]

@@sharifbrown3567 Who said I didn't know about it?

[@The_Knife_Pie]

Dan- lets say you can get away with everything. Stephen- Well then i wouldn't stop with that murder. Stephen is a closet pyscho

[@aldric2252]

The_ Knife_Pie "new video - are you a psychopath?"

[@nobody-rw9cc]

He is just socially conscious; if you can get away with anything... you would find a sick fantasy to live out as well. its the beast nature; if there is no consequence to you then there is no need for moral action. fallout for instance You can kill everyone and steal everything its just a game there's no real consequences. To not do a single bad thing in that game is a lot harder then being as evil as can be.

[@jeremossy9768]

The_ Knife_Pie yeah me too XD

[@Labanmad]

The_ Knife_Pie Gadget

[@dabossman5650]

The_ Knife_Pie he is in all of them lol

[@kakashihatake6176]

Casually taking a dude organs during a check-up

[@no-vw9ib]

@Braedon Collins shut up

[@KTam853]

Monica Granger it’s just a simple correction

[@KTam853]

Well he was asleep so idk he may wake up

[@thegoon9876]

oops

[@WiseTree547]

I know right

[@cryfier]

You really see how his friends try to avoid these difficult questions by humor

[@siringc]

1:27 If he's fat enough to stop a train I doubt he'll be living long anyways. PS: I doubt he would be able to be pushed over either PPS: How is the floor not broken?

[@alastorbutwithagun]

yeah, and also, why was he just watching people die? he's most likely a psychopath and would probably kill people, therefore, push him, stop the trolley, also end his suffering.

[@alastorbutwithagun]

@SCP 682 well obviously he's not trying very hard because they should be able to hear him

[@goldenstripes3296]

@@alastorbutwithagun well going by that logic, why wouldn't you shout to the workers instead of immediately thinking of killing another person for the sake of many? Why should one unhealthy man be disregarded so much that his only use is to be a sacrifice for others?

[@erikamayday1602]

I’m confused ._.

[@latenightbingewatchers]

I think you could turn horizontal and hit everyone with the train carts

[@dazaiosamu8103]

Hi, just rewatching my memories before danplan isn’t the same ever again

[@yunazzyuu1417]

Same here my dude 😔👊💔

[@Kazoo_Itchy]

Same

[@n3ko800]

Same

[@solomonirvin2387]

Same ☹️

[@kollops]

Same bruh but we have to hear daniels side

[@lemondrop1969]

there is a reason why the answer changes. when you are contemplating taking a turn choosing to kill one person or going straight and killing 5, your choices are exactly that being personally responsible for 1 death or for 5. On the other hand, when you are pushing the fat guy onto the track you are choosing between being responsible for one death or zero. Yes, 5 people are going to die if you don't push the guy but those 5 deaths are not your responsibility and no one is gonna question you why you didn't push the guy to save the 5. At the end of the day, it is not an ethical dilemma, it is simply a question of what are you willing to be responsible for? There is also the fact that working on the tracks the 5 workmen have consented to the inherent risks associated with the work and the one being push did no such thing.

[@Slitherr]

@David Winehouse you're not responsible, because if you were to not change the tracks then you wouldn't have proactively done an action that killed someone but if you do change the tracks then you are proactively doing something that will kill someone. So, in my opinion it boils down to whether or not you believe that the ends justify the means, because if you do, then killing is is favored when it will save more lives, but if you don't, then killing is wrong regardless of how many lives it will save

[@somebody579]

Just scream to those 5 people to move.

[@pooltable1339]

Also with the organ transplant one, the options change. In the first question if you do nothing all 6 die so you have to choose the lesser of two evils, but in the second one if you do nothing only 5 will die and if you save them one will die. This makes it harder to answer because in both cases you have be directly responsible for murder.

[@pazecs]

@@pooltable1339 In the first question if you do nothing not all 6 people die? Only the five that were on the tracks which the trolly was going towards.

[@vukkulvar9769]

The difference between the first and second problem : 1 situation you act on the cart, 1 situation you act on the person.

[@Phoenixishh]

0:03 that sounds like the beginning of the supernatural outro

[@oshahott2532]

"Let's be serious, here." _Organ Bucket_

[@Cupids_love666]

I can't like I have to keep the 666 likes

[@rys2147]

"either turn right and kill 1 or stay straight and kill 5" Animator draws the turn as left 0:50

[@stock7416]

Housa why 😂😂😂

[@sephtis3658]

@@stock7416 ITS HOSUH.

[@imvic99yearsago62]

Kill 5 because the 1 person is working alone and if i will the first one of the 5 then the others will run

[@imvic99yearsago62]

@Pure_Steve _1153 let the other four die because they weren't helping the human on the right! (๑و•̀ω•́)

[@sephtis3658]

@が 大好きビクトリア 和 アニメ *kill them all*

[@flysmite1507]

"Are you a good person?" me: "I eat cereal with a fork" everyone: "Are you Satan?"

[@milvanis]

Flysmite how the fuck do you eat cereal with a fork

[@KingOpenReview]

That comment is emotional abuse.

[@Jinx-iw6zb]

I eat cereal with bare hands

[@potatocat8589]

Flysmite same then I drink the milk with a spoon

[@stevendunn8897]

I eat cereal with a fork as well, dry cereal with a glass of milk.

[@wtf8178]

"No matter how good of a person you are, you are the villain in atleast someones life. So get yourself together and atleast be a good villain"

[@HellishSpoon]

3:50 Simple Just take the organs from one of those 5 guys You can save 4 people And the other one would have died any way. Bam

[@arcticshocked]

Damn, nice one.

[@GoEatSoyEgg]

damn u smort

[@resedatan2200]

HELL SPOONtheJojoMain i

[@kathrinagleeson9227]

Thats what i was thinking

[@zixuanren6737]

Smart!

[@topcomment8170]

Him: Life is never black and white Me: Exactly it's rainbow.. UNLIKE THE BLOOD IN THIS VIDEO

[@xxmarblesoudaxx3564]

ooooh gottem

[@leafu8154]

The Blood In this Video Brightens my Mind.

[@halley6903]

FUN EXTENSION! : what if the 1 person on the train tracks was a loved one, would you still save the 5 ?

[@firegodess_nullz]

REEEEEEE NOW IT'S HARDER

[@halley6903]

Fire Godess 👉😎👉

[@1helluvakiller352]

I'd still run over the 5 either way, honestly.

[@chari19]

That was also in the book

[@kbob115gaming6]

Its easy their strangers they probably won't save me so why save them so I would save the loved one (if I had one)

[@dayanafidalgo8953]

I'm shocked by how smart you guys are. Really! Deep thoughts... I really loved it. Brilliant minds!

[@daydreamstudios1606]

"This is Canada, where are all the other doctors?"

[@xaviergalloway7025]

They are drinking maple syrup at Waffle House.

[@cloudieo]

@@xaviergalloway7025 Lmao

[@blazewolf5495]

Lol

[@senkusupremacy3828]

They are busy with all the others using the free health care to their advantage. Its the sad canadian truth

[@brianmcm1398]

The question is answered in the first 3 words

[@cookiesandcream626]

“A-Ah!” Daniel - 2017 “Speaking of cannibalism!” Hosuh - 2017 “Lawsuits coming your way!” Stephen - 2017

[@creature8911]

😂😂😂

[@robloxnub943]

:|

[@Obcordata]

"Then I wouldn't stop there and kill more."

[@SwaggerJoyce]

*shows Yuno pictures*

[@Cookie-tw9by]

I find it funny that he says murder rather than something else

[@gse547]

this is the same way the terrorist think of us when we go to their country and kill their love ones.

[@lightryuzaki3974]

Me too..bcoz its hypothetical questions.

[@jeweluzumaki3233]

Lovey Dub 😂😂 I burst out laughing when I heard that

[@koharumi1]

0:16 I would do multi-track drifting and do my best to get a strike. You know the quote "got to get them all"

[@justplainweird2727]

When rewatching danplan videos like this one is just hard to believe that all this time you thought housuh Stephen and Daniel were such good friends but now Stephen is leaving because for so long he felt under appreciated

[@isabellejoestar2455]

Stephen began wanting to leave Danplan around the beginnings of 2019. This was 3 years ago.

[@hassanaiham2333]

Stop commenting I know it's sad but it not nice talking about it in danplan's channel

[@whatdoyouwant4548]

@@hassanaiham2333 but the thing is that's what this channel was mainly built up on, its what people remember the channel to be about, so of course people are going to talk about it where they feel it belongs - on their old videos.

[@catssassin137]

*1:00* i would kill the 5. If i kill the 1, i wont get xp and and no combos 😂

[@deletedbecauseofhate-9971]

cat ssassin, ikr, you have to kill somebody, might aswell kill 5 while you’re at it.

[@raivynnrealalvarez1352]

Ye plus you'll get more drops,its a win win

[@CupheadCoolkid]

Wow

[@coastylzeast5665]

Multikill, Bloodthirsty, carepackage ready mark it where you want it

[@Sutaokami]

Don't forget about the xp multiplier for combos

[@justacameraman4900]

Heres how im currently thinking of it. What ways more on your soul? the act of saving lives, or the act of taking lives. in one your not saving nor are you killing, in the other you are saving and killing.

[@thegentleman2419]

as the king of Wakanda put it "victory at the expense of the innocent is no victory at all"

[@daca8395]

Every war ever...

[@sagumosageyo943]

The needs of the many...

[@ramenstuffyt6783]

Why is there a guy for a checkup in an organ donors office?

[@shl3bl3_25]

Thay said hes in the next room

[@rantingsfromateenagerspers499]

@@shl3bl3_25 That would be in the organ donor wings than. He still shouldn't be there

[@flames4856]

Where were all the other doctors tho? Thats what I‘m thinking...

[@Meiaiscool]

Maybe he had a surgery with this and he came up for a checkup so they could see if everything is right after the surgery

[@asamiastra6292]

Stephen: I’m a philosophical thinker Hosuh: who are you and what did you do to Stephen

[@user-anonyzous]

The explanation to the trolley problem, the first scenario is more favorable to change since it means saving five in result of killing one. The second is not favorable however since it is like killing one while indirectly saving five.

[@sydneynahoo6887]

*"Well then I wouldnt stop at this murder I'd keep going"*

[@limonkowyludz1328]

I know it might sound weird but if you do something this crazy (murder) then why don’t you just kill some more? You’re going to jail and ruining your life anyway so why not?

[@Vary180]

i laughed so hard at that

[@len4129]

@@limonkowyludz1328 because if you do you'll most likely have a longer sentence in jail.

[@caitlyn_tkoj4935]

This is probably really weird but my answer to the question at 3:50, assuming that the patients organs are healthy except for 1, is: I would take the patient with the highest chance of death and take their organs and save the other patients. Cuz that person was already dying and they would technically be saving 4 others. Plus if they were dying the family would probably be prepared for the worst case scenario.

[@jeremybrown8654]

Caitlyn Alba OMG WOW thats really smart

[@lucaselmer6982]

Thats a good point

[@minimuhfuckinduck2283]

Their organs are fucked though

[@HomeworkH8]

Smart

[@kashinimeyo]

That probably wouldn't work though. The one with the highest probability of death that is in need of an organ transplant would be suffering from complete organ failure spurred by his or her other organ failing. In my mind, I assume the one in need of the organ the most, the pancreas patient, isn't as easily sustained on medical support like the others. That's why pancreatic cancer is so deadily, because it spreads easily but so many other bodily systems rely on the pancreas. Tbh, I would *ask* The pancreatic patient if he or she was willing to kick the bucket because of how difficult it is for he or she to survive because of it before any of the other organs suffered. But that's just my own assumptions, I'm not a medical professional. Your hands are still tied no matter what, you cannot commit murder no matter how good your intentions are in order to save another life. Assisted suicide is another thing, but straight out murder of a patient who did not consent to their demise is illegal. The family can file for malpractice and wrongful death which will result in your license being revoked and possibly wind you up in jail.

[@novastardust1200]

I know I'm late to comment, but on the organ one, I'd probably not take the organs, partially because we don't know if blood types will match. I mean, if the one healthy guy has the most incompatible blood type, then he can't save all of the others anyway.

[@SpookyTim16]

My philosophy professor had a pretty good explination as to why the answers differ. In the first case, you don't have the intention to kill. For example in the trolley dilemma: if by some coincidence the one worker manages to jump away, we'd all be glad for that. While in the second case, we want the fat man to die if we push him.

[@high.on.methanol]

"The bigger question is how to kill all 6 of them" The Good Place: Micheal (A demon)

[@bade7]

AYYY THE GOOD PLACE! GOAT

[@renadaniels3843]

Finally, I was waiting for this one😂😂😂💀💀💀

[@roximoldovan1]

all 7 of them actually if you count yourself

[@isaultra3405]

Explain the reference, source ???

[@nola9957]

@@isaultra3405 tv show called the good place

[@ilikepancakes512]

6:49 i mean there’s 2,000 of you guys video posted: 2017 current year: 2019 *has over a million subs*

[@sir_xenorion]

Why is your pic He-man beating his meat, evidently

[@peanut9807]

And I say heeyyaaayyaaayayay heeeyaayaay. I say hey! What's going on!

[@Bee-dj1fw]

XD

[@bibou4664]

And now in 2023 there are more than 2 million subscribers

[@whyhellothere6855]

Why don’t the workers just walk off the rail? Are they blind? EDIT: Okay maybe they’re underground with walls around them but c’mon at least try to hardcore parkour out of there amirite

[@mladen7641]

Did you see them having any eyes?

[@zaffearnight7827]

Calico Bunny yeah. That's a good one. Probably maybe....? IDK.

[@whyhellothere6855]

Goran Prvulovic good point

[@GnarledStaff]

They are working. Possibly with ear protection. They are not lounging around looking at a the toad but looking at what they are working on.

[@whyhellothere6855]

Geordin Soucie but a train usually always has lights, they have to at least see those

[@0CaptainZer0]

Trolley problem solved: Horn. People will hear it and move, if they don't hear it because headphones, oh well.

[@beanie.s1844]

1. Kill 1 2. Scream “run” 3. Save the 5 4. Do nothing I’m fringing insane

[@katytaylor81]

4

[@grim3512]

4...

[@Randomperson-no2xg]

I think the same thing

[@fishl3gsyt345]

BÉANIE .s 1

[@sei8932]

5. Profit

[@amicho3167]

Dan: He teaches that life is never black or white. Me: Then it’s gray..

[@audenuhl9179]

Ami Cho gay or gray?

[@Hububba]

Ami Cho that’s racist

[@amicho3167]

Wth you guys it's just a joke XD

[@revesnee]

nigga

[@Karma-zp7pb]

Fifty shades of it to be exact

[@AngelGirlCryBaby]

Your content is so lighthearted and funny, yet gets serious and takes up some really morbid stuff. Smash that together with a great and personal cartoon style and boom, great content!!! Please keep this up guys so I ACTUALLY have something good in my feed for once :3

[@blooeagle5118]

2:30 No, I don't believe it does. Just because you didn't act in the best interests of the five workers by sacrificing the fat guy, it doesn't make you a morally nasty person, it makes you rather normal. What kind of person is willing to throw just about anyone ONTO the tracks to save a group of people. By doing so you are taking his life. It is classified as murder, or maybe even vehicular manslaughter. It has a designation. However, if you DON'T act, you are still morally justified. What kind of person can stop a trolley car or a train? Probably superman, but we are just mere people. In fact, I think that in a real scenario one would be too shocked by the visuals to even consider murdering the person beside him. Anyways, you cannot otherwise stop the train unless you commit murder. Even if you did consider it an option, you are perfectly justified if you don't act.

[@danielleboyer5844]

Here's my question. Why did a train depart from the station in the track with construction on it in the first place. If the driver even started the train he would have known this and is intentionally murdering the construction workers.

[@Scarfacex1]

It's hypothetical

[@richardescobar9306]

Kitty Kitty Cat the workers and conductor were both unaware this was happening and it was like a normal day for them

[@williamazazelmiseria519]

Richard Does gaming why would a conductor depart on a broken rail road lol

[@easiestpeasiet]

Bad management

[@SweetSinger789]

There's another situation where 5 people are tied up on the rail tracks and if you diverted the tracks to the other path there was a construction worker/another man tied up.

[@worldglitch9919]

I'm not a good person ( 4:27 ) I agree with Stephen on most things, such as this

[@ghostlavender9873]

Same here

[@vermyn_vern5315]

I almost always agree with Stephen

[@blake7110]

Same

[@leeharper8513]

I swear as soon as it was "you can get away with anything" my brain went like: "oh so let me do this and save 5 over 1."

[@noah-ns7lu]

Daniel: are you a good person Me: No Im a disappointment

[@zeniashanze1882]

Me: I'm the baaaad guy. DUH!

[@sephtis3658]

@@zeniashanze1882 Stop.

[@rainbowdragon9721]

"exactly"

[@puroboi9591]

Noah ok lazarbeam

[@trigonometry9775]

Sees thumbnail:... Me:well Steven won't be competing

[@Niveous23]

the answer is: it depends. that drives philosophers NUTS. For so called lovers of wisdom context is not as 'cool' as an underlying morality.

[@britishpigeon838]

Yeah . My job is teaching philosophy. This type of thing is HELL

[@Ray-hk1zm]

I think that the problem is that everyone thinks of these as theoretical. Maybe, THEORETICALLY, I'd push the fat man over. But I could never do it in real life. If I was standing there, looking at this situation, I would never ever do it.

[@vincentliu4588]

Also if one is missing a heart he's already dead so take the organs from him

[@samanthadegroot7749]

Vincent Liu he isn't missing a heart, his heart just isn't working right. it still is keeping him alive but its not gonna be working for long.

[@seassweep]

exactly

[@nekole_luna1351]

Dude have you watched docter shows, his heart is severlu damaged not dead to point where its not beating damage

[@JeppeBeier]

The heart isn't what determines if you are dead or not. That's the brain. You are only dead after all brain activity stops.

[@spartansquid5931]

yes but if your heart stops there is a pretty good chance you're fucked.

[@blackbirdredwing8182]

5:17 Shaggy is getting heated with a pitchfork on the left there.

[@jonathancortez2125]

Andrew Emmanouil yes im not the only one that noticed lmao

[@SPORTZIES]

XD yas

[@koreansruinedmylifeu4741]

im not alone XD

[@Erik-fy9dy]

Are you sure?

[@rolichanel4085]

THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT

[@theoneapplejam9622]

1: *I would pull my window down and scream "MOVVVVEEEEE"* 2: *umm............* 3: *uhh......I-......I'd quit my job :)* 4: *stillll quiting

[@aprilbennett4161]

1) Sound the horn like a madman, switch to the right track, and hope the singular man gets off the track in time. Either way, the men on the tracks are supposed to be vigilant. You don't get a job working on tracks without that being drilled in. 2) No. A single fat man would NOT stop a train. I'd be more interested in screaming at the folks to get off the damned tracks, anyway. 3) Mildly-injured people wouldn't die if I focus on the man in critical condition. Nurses, trainees, etc... can take care of the significantly less-injured patients, with a trusted nurse in charge. I'm taking some nurses to perform surgery on the one first. 4) NOTHING. You don't just take organs from a random guy. I don't know his blood type, or anything. Organ rejection will kill the patients, nevermind incidents like accidently giving someone an organ containing malignant tumors, or something. Killing everyone is hardly beneficial.

[@JayAreAitch]

Saying shit like "sound the horn" is just dodging the question and deliberately trying to avoid the reasoning behind it.

[@bigman5823]

there would be a horn on the trolley car they're saying "sound the horn" because they're using it as a warning, if you actually think about what they're saying instead of blindly going against them you'd see that they're being completely smart with their choices

[@JayAreAitch]

bytesize and friends Yeah I know what a horn is. But that's not the point of the moral dilemma.

[@bigman5823]

They're trying to save everyone

[@JayAreAitch]

bytesize and friends You can't. That's the point.

[@sleyaraze8916]

"so you'd sacrifice yourself to save others?" *Me, who just wanted to die* 👌

[@blank3881]

Same

[@hellbreaker1745]

Same

[@miniko_artsy]

Same tho :(

[@c0sm0chess9]

hope you guys are doing well now... Alive I mean...

[@TripleLLe]

@@c0sm0chess9 yeah.. I hope you guys doing well...

[@lndn1365]

"Who Are You, And What Have You Done With Stephen"

[@trinityy-7]

if everyone was already in the bad position, save the 5, if not, save the one. putting an innocent bystander to die is worse than having someone already on the rails die

[@mamavenena]

i would’ve gladly thrown myself on track-

[@imashadow699]

Can Your Body *Stop The TRAIN* , tho 😅? (Your Sacrifice Means Nothing, If The Train Didn't Stop And Killed The 5 Workers Anyway)

[@user-ko3by9sp1r]

@@imashadow699 lol I'm useless even if i offer my whole life

[@imashadow699]

@@user-ko3by9sp1r Exactly 🤣 (No, I'm Serious... You Can Do Much Effort If You Stay Alive, Like Blocking The Way With Something Rock Solid UNLIKE HUMAN'S BODY ,, even Throwing Bunch Of Any Kind Of Metals Will Probably Make Little Difference Rather Than "Just A Bunch Of Meat" 😅)

[@aquabitxh9770]

Stop bringing triggering topics on KZbin.

[@hrf6548]

I don't wanna ruin the 69 likes ↁ_ↁ

[@myenasub1730]

For the last case, you can sacrifice one person who need the organ transplant, and give his organs to the other 4 patients, which you will not need to kill that healthy guy.

[@imashadow699]

Or... I'll Just Tell All Of Them To Seek Their Own Organs... My Job Is Transplant, not "Organs Seeker" 😅

[@himikohenson3861]

You most likely couldn't, though. The odds of any 4 random people being a perfect match for the organs of any one other person are astronomically low. Organs need matches or else they'll be rejected; the closer the match, the better. You can't just throw any random organ into any random person.

[@ZomboidMania]

that is genius

[@Ebamber3]

The dilemma arises again though, why do you have the right to choose which of the 5 lives and who dies?

[@ZomboidMania]

@@Ebamber3 well 4 lives is much more valuable then 1, of course if that 1 guy is a person who is working to beat cancer then ihis life is more valuable based on all the lives he could save in the future

[@aidarich3712]

For the Frist one, *JUST WARN THE WORKERS*

[@aceofparts938]

Cant your going very fast in highly protected trolly. You think your gonna pop your head out and yell about a Trolly that the people can CLEARLY see....

[@aidarich3712]

@@aceofparts938 true

[@aidarich3712]

@@aceofparts938 but it didn't really say it was protected

[@aceofparts938]

It's a trolly.

[@aidarich3712]

@@aceofparts938 ok, you have a point

[@avamtippery5686]

Usually, there are 2 variations of this situation. 1. There are 5 people working on the tracks and a train is about to hit them. 2. There are 5 people TIED TO the tracks and the train is about to hit them. You might ask "Well, what difference does it make? They're still 5 people who's lives are on the line." That's true, but in the first situation, they're STUPID people. Trains aren't invisible and they aren't silent. If you can't get off the tracks when the train's coming through, maybe... it's best if...

[@Canextro]

1. Don't push fat guy. The workers should have known the dangers of their work place. They weren't paying attention and some guy on the side shouldn't be sacrifices for the irresponsibility of 5 others. 2. Without consent, taking another person's organs from someone completely healthy isn't right. It sucks, but at the very least, the patients needing a transplant were already thinking that they wouldn't make it. These surgeries are a big deal. What would the family of a completely healthy dude think if he just randomly died out of the blue with 5 organs missing? It would hit much harder than someone who was unlucky enough to have a bad organ.

[@neifz4113]

Canextro Good point

[@Adam-gg1rq]

Canextro all you have to do is yell for the one person to move and motion the trolley driver to go to the other side

[@ChuChild]

Steven's my favorite character out of these but tbh.. I would never go to the hospital with Steven.. or lean over a train track near him.......................................................... Or anything that could result in my death. Ok, bye.

[@peteclark6495]

what fool would bring STEVEN to a moral dilemma?

[@_antisocialmedia6377]

It's Stephen

[@kitwarrior4life124]

Daniel.

[@hahahhad8193]

Hosuh.

[@God_3712]

In that situation I think if I was the bystander, I would honestly just try to scream at everyone to get out of the way. Like. That's all I can do. And panic and cry afterwards

[@SeriousGuy]

Imagine the news the day after and then take your decision. "Man turns trolly to kill a woman" or "Five men died by a trolly", see now the situation is so different. Same with the fat person. "Man pushed a man into a track to be killed by a trolly." or "Five men died by a trolly", see here if you sacrifice the fat person for the greater good, society just sees you as a murderer. You can try justifying your acts that you saved five people instead, but the newspapers the media and the public will most probably not agree with you, cause you're basically a murderer. But the doctor situation is different. No matter what you do, the society will never blame the doctor, they'll always blame the cause. Like if you fail to treat a gunshot of a soldier, the people will blame the war, not you. So you should of course, help the five mildly injured people, and bonus points if you kill the other one secretly to end his suffering. The second doctor situation is a little different. You're saving five ill people, by killing one healthy person. Now Dan says that I'll get away with it, so I'll hack and slash the healthy person and help the five people ASAP. But if this is a real solution and I can be caught, then I'm not going to do anything, I'll just give that healthy person a checkup and bonus points if you kill the five people to end their sufferings. I can justify this decision by telling you that the fact that I'm out of organs is not my fault, it's the fault of the institution I'm working in. The news will say "Five men died because of no spare organs, Donate Now." And you can donate your organs like after you death right? And so many people die like every time, so this news is actually encouraging them to donate their organs. This is actually for the greater good. So it you leave the five patients to die, millions of patients in the future can live. Wow what a happy note to end this comment with. Thanks for reading and let me know if you agree with my points or not.

[@CheesyNivs]

you thought about this

[@officerari]

True, I agree with those points

[@Zeyox96]

Though why wouldn't you be able to use the organs of the one who needs a heart transplant? I mean he's otherwise healthy isn't he? And he was going to die anyway.

[@roadworkahead4744]

Wow I feel smarter already and school hasn't even started yet, I agree. Then if you bring the possibility that you know the one person changes everything, as well as the status. Say one is in charge of supervising the workers, or a friend of yours.

[@deaddinosaur4856]

Finally a moral person that while i dont fully agree with everything he said he sure as hell had an explanation to his thoughts that arent well i dont know kinda stupid.

[@OhRlyNao]

- [RANT: don't read if you don't want to] - Some of these moral dilemmas don't make sense. For instance, if I can see people about to be hit by a train, I can also warn them and they should hear me or the train as sound travels farther than the eyes can see. Plus, even if a healthy patient was available to have their organs transplanted, the possibility of their genetics matching all five patients is nigh impossible.... like, what? Not to mention the reason people ask questions like: "what if those five were murderers and the one was a doctor" is because we have a sense of right and wrong and we value those we deem innocent based on those presuppositions. I honestly don't think things are as morally grey as people suggest, most times people just tend to take a mathematical perspective and assume more lives equates to a better result. The real question moral 'dilemmas' ask is how willing are you to take on guilt and to commit crimes

[@charificusii8618]

ok yeah but calm down

[@OhRlyNao]

@@charificusii8618 I wrote that 7 months ago. I just wanted to comment on the video because I liked the channel so much. I was calm.

[@natsuki515]

Can't we just back off the car?

[@valsayshi1166]

My like was the 70th.

[@sallymorgan2802]

no i agree with you.

[@epicoperator6556]

I really expected Stephen to say that he’d keep the trolly going to kill as many people as possible

[@Gojxd]

"imagine you could get away with anything" stephen: then i wouldn't stop there, i would keep going

[@samanthadegroot7749]

the difference between the first and second is that in the first you have to kill one, you have no choice. kill one or kill five is your only option. in the second one its not your problem, you don't have to kill anyone at all so you can just be a bistander. i don't think its the people that you think about whebn answering ths question, its what's best for you.

[@smolson8471]

Huh, that's definitely something to consider

[@JeppeBeier]

I wouldn't deliberately change rails, if it would kill someone else. I don't value the 5 people over the 1, or the 1 over the 5. Swapping lanes would make me a murderer, where staying the course would make me a bystander.

[@milvanis]

Jeppe Beier how Would letting you get 5 people killed make you a bystander but changing the rails to save those 5 but kill 1 make you a murderer

[@JeppeBeier]

Milan Vissers because it wasn't my fault they were there, and the one person's life isn't worth less than the five

[@milvanis]

Jeppe Beier even if you think that the 5 are worth just as much as 1 it also isnt your fault that he is there so switching either wont make you a murderer or your a murderer no matter what

[@chickenychickens07]

The organ transplant doctor question,my answers: I won’t care about anyone, organ transplant needs suitable blood type or it will fail, the patients will also die

[@dracomalfoy9108]

Exactly what I was thinking!

[@waldimirabreu8525]

but this is an hypothetical situation were they will live

[@someone_random0144]

How are people living without a heart and lungs?

[@youshalllove227]

I was also thinking about that.

[@christiemarie8748]

Yes!

[@nanik4913]

Trolly car situation is actually kill 5 strangers or kill one person you know (like family or spouse)

[@amask4360]

There are multiple variations of it.

[@whydoievenbothertoputthish2199]

Definetly kill 5 strangers and in 5 diffrent ways makes it harder for the cops to track you down an close relative seems more suspicious also space the killings out over time so they dont connect the murders with eachother

[@user-ib3dj1he5x]

Nani K i'd split the cart in half and kill them all

[@hello-oh5bk]

On the first one I'd pick to go for the 5, reason being that if its 5 people they'll probably all try to run away, if the 5 see the 1 they might try to help him possibly killing them aswell

[@nicolruiz8810]

what if no ones paying attention though or like the question said they're construction workers and possibly have really loud machines on

[@oldcheese9996]

This is why everyone hates moral philosophy professors (Please tell me someone gets this)

[@masterduck1676]

I get it.

[@SoupMansSoup13]

I live it

[@getsomementalhelp8090]

Welcome back to the *good place*

[@Julia-qd7bg]

I have a stomachache

[@welllfed]

B R U H