CAMILA CABELLO GIVES BS APOLOGY FOR INSENSITIVE COMMENTS | Reaction

[@alex19leal]

The way that they treated Normani was absolutely uncalled for and disgusting I was gathering a couple of then but it's not surprising at all.

[@Alibern7]

Alex Leal ikr Camila fans got mad at Normani because Normani described Camila as Cute and Quirky

[@bryanalstoncoxing]

Camila didn’t make any meaningful attempt to stop the behavior either. They still call her Normonkey to this day and have consistently cyberbullied her with racism for years but nothing from Camila

[@mariafelix6774]

First of all camilla is not racist and yall should really learn south american history because latinos have the same exact right to say nigga. Second normani and the other members treated her terrible just because of the fact that they was jealuos of her success. Did yall see the performance were they diss her with that puppet on stage.

[@Divestedpinoyasawa]

Maria Felix Maria what happened? You must’ve been there when she was being treated badly by the other group members, plz share. 🤣🤣🤣FOH, with that bullish.

[@breezybabe0019]

Maria Felix i swear camello fans are the dumbest fans ever...🤦🏾‍♀️

[@shilohcara9479]

I'm Black, Beautiful, And Proud. Point Blank Period.

[@miannyvonne]

_PERIOD_

[@mariafelix6774]

Who called black ugly nobody.

[@shilohcara9479]

@Andreya Thank you for that lol. Black people have been seen as "Ugly" for years

[@shilohcara9479]

@@mariafelix6774 Okay so I guess you've never heard of Black Face or Jim Crow

[@shilohcara9479]

@@isuzuke ok and???

[@amxiirah]

I don’t like the fact that people who aren’t black is accepting her apology. She didn’t offend you she offended people of color. I don’t wanna hear no one saying they forgive her unless they’re a person of color. I said wtf I said.

[@salma1491]

True

[@brittanib242]

@Big Stepper doesn't matter how old she was tho, she still said it and more than likely STILL feels that way so she gets no sympathy from me🙄

[@amxiirah]

Brittany B Exactly

[@drinkwaternotalcohol]

She also said racist things about Asians and sexual abuse ppl. Disgusting.

[@drinkwaternotalcohol]

Big Stepper so? She grew up in America, where they teach u racism is bad. Hell im 15 myself and I knew for years that it’s wrong. I know there’s such thing as dark humor but they fact that her page seemed dedicated to racist stereotypes just seems......... eh. Also we r allowed to feel offended. Ppl take things differently. If someone were to call u an insulting word, u would probably feel offended but I won’t cuz they never called me that. But how would u like it if I said “ur making it a big deal” when ur clearly hurt? Ppl have feelings. Also the change between the a and er in the n word makes no difference. It’s still offensive. Even though I’m black, I hate the use of the word out of anyone’s mouth. It should’ve died back then. But it makes since apparently for blacks to use it. And if u can’t see that then... u need more education.

[@kareem4205]

We need to uplift and support Normani

[@shilohcara9479]

I do already, she's a great singer. I try to send as much love as possible, I feel like others should do the same.

[@ivansentosa7699]

She just cant sing..thank you next

[@maricarvelasco5792]

Kareem 🤮

[@JinxSAW]

I do support her but tbh she’s can’t sing tho..

[@emilyspector2728]

Normani has REAL TALENT....that girl can sing and dance....and CIARA...But she helps me get motivated to get my ass to the gym. Love watching her videos and her performance at the awards was PHENOMENAL!!!

[@Snozberry24]

Camilla has always come across as fake and disinguine to me. Like she tries extra hard to embody the bubbly, cute relatable roll. The way she stood in the background when Normani was getting bullied was foul. Folks need to stop putting their irrelevant two cents in and stating how she needs to be forgiven when the offensive things she said doesn't pertain to them. Therefore, shut up. All this she's changed bullshit. When a person shows you who they are the first time, believe them.

[@Snozberry24]

@@David.lovesU cause you were in the room with Michael as he was molesting those kids and know what happened 🙄🙄🙄. And Michael was universal and had fans of all ethnic backgrounds from around the world that believed he was innocent. It wasn't just the black community that supported him. Michael influenced more then just the black community 🙄🙄🙄 The entire black community didn't support Chris brown, there are many of those that didn't. His career was never the same after the Rihanna incident. Kendrick Lamar is black, Camilla isn't. Kendrick saying the N word versus a non black person using it the way she did is NOT the same. Please stop, you're reaching 🙂

[@Snozberry24]

@@David.lovesU y'all justify certain black people using the n word as an excuse for everyone else who's non black to be able to say it however they please "But Kendrick says it too, blacks say it tooooo"...ok, and...is Camilla black? Last time I checked she wasn't...having the occasional black dancer and featuring rappers in a few of her songs doesn't count. Therefore, shhhhh!

[@christaljonan8701]

@@David.lovesU You sound like a bigot. Please be quiet and go educate yourself before making anymore simple minded comments.

[@Snozberry24]

@@David.lovesU that word has never ALMOST been gone. Lol according to who? YOU!???? I can assure you thats not the case, as I'm sure you already know and are simply talking out of your ass. How about this, don't worry about what other black people are using the N word, it doesn't concern you if you aren't black.

[@benjaminlaw1819]

Love that quote

[@ljb5163]

15 is old enough to know what basic morals are. That’s not ignorance, it’s hatred.

[@ljb5163]

DARIEN Ford I was not racist at 15. Were you?

[@jedayeyo]

LJ B I’m 16 and there are so many kids in my grade who say the N word. I would never do that, but they say it because their friends all do it and they probably don’t know any better. Not insinuating that it is acceptable, but that possibly could have been the case for her. She grew up in Miami which has a majority of Hispanic population. Believe me when I say a lot of Hispanics say the N word, so she was most likely influenced by that. The important part is that she realized what she was doing is wrong and stopped doing it (as far as we know).

[@ljb5163]

Loser_McGee Her using the N word was the least bad thing she did. She explicitly used it in a way to degrade black people. Intent matters and it’s clear that she had something against black people. All I’m saying is that “she didn’t know any better and learned” is BS. She knew and was racist. She did not once use the word in an endearing way between friends (publicly). It’s always been derogatory. I just don’t get the excuses people are making for this behavior. Maybe she changed but don’t excuse her past as ignorance.

[@jedayeyo]

LJ B I’m not making excuses, sorry you thought that way. The people she grew up with did the same thing, they used the N word in an insulting way. She did it too, probably not realizing that it was bad. She grew up in an area where almost everyone said it. Think of it as your friends start saying something, eventually you will do it too. Early teens are really impressionable and most will do anything to fit in, that’s why most kids in my high-school all say it without realizing the consequences. In no means am I saying it excuses her behavior, or the behavior of my peers, but what’s the point in hating on them once they’ve stopped doing it and realized how horrible it is? It’s been so many years and she’s done so many good things since then, and has even supported various movements such as Black Lives Matter. TLDR: What she did was horrible, and I’m not trying to make up excuses for her behalf. But putting so much hatred onto someone for something they did as an impressionable and immature 15 year old is no better. She grew up in a racist community and the most likely scenario was that she simply didn’t know how bad it was. The important thing is that she grew up, realized what she did was bad, changed her ways and started to support the black community, and now is asking for forgiveness.

[@Vmadisonh14]

as you can see in my profile picture I'm white and I grew up in Alabama and Missouri. down south so many parents are racist, and kids grow up to be what their parents are. mine are not but they are hardcore republicans. she is Cuban so her parents might have wanted her to think the same way they did at the time. At 15, you don't know if you wanna listen and follow your parents' beliefs or go your own way. My best friend is black and I make soooo many damn jokes about her liking chicken and watermelon. but I live in Alabama so its racist, even though my best friend is black. I promise she has black friends she jokes with and can do it without the fear of being attacked but people who can't take a joke. some of the things she said were kinda over the top but she didn't actually mean it. you think she would have posted it if she knew she would have to have dealt with all this stupid drama. she just did it as a joke. you don't know right from wrong if you have no one to tell you.

[@krystenholman8152]

It’s funny how every group but the people she said horrible things about forgives her and says it’s not a big deal when you’re race isn’t the one being disrespected 😂😂

[@krystenholman8152]

2012 was only 7 years ago and I was 12 and knew better then to write racist shit and it’s not one comment like most caught being racist it’s multiple occasions so FOR ME I feel it was half ass and it was consistently something she did at 15 which if you don’t know not to write racist shit at 15 I question your upbringing and like I said it’s always the people it’s not against telling to get over it

[@krystenholman8152]

Thai Ya Long also I don’t know her enough to hate her and actually felt bad for her when she left the group because I felt she was treated badly and I didn’t know about the racist shit she said about people who look like ME which is disappointing because when I start to get in to certain people their caught being racist towards people who look like ME and I should support them ?????

[@gabrielmichael3701]

Thai Ya Long just no

[@drinkwaternotalcohol]

Thai Ya Long it’s not that we want her to commit suicide. We don’t want harm. A eye for an eye and the world goes blind but ppl r finally seeing how racist she was or is. It doesn’t matter if she apologized or if it was from 2012. I’m several years younger than her and I know that’s messed up. Especially since she grew up in America. Don’t they teach you about racism? Yet there it goes. I know kids my age like to say dark humor and shit but there’s a point where it needs to stop. Especially in jokes that include stereotypes about race. They stem from racist ideologies. It’s up to all those ppl who felt offended by her remarks whether to forgive her “apology” or not. U shouldn’t feel offended if ppl decide not to forgive her. Bc words hurt. If someone said something hurtful to me, u think I would still be around them? Hell no. It doesn’t matter if they apologize. And her apology doesn’t mean anything to me bc I don’t even know her personally or her personality. Idk if she still feels this way about blacks and Asians. I’m turning an blind eye. Y’all can do what u want but don’t u dare tell ppl how they should feel. Ppl take things differently, u should know that.

[@LGSN96]

@@krystenholman8152 7 years is a long time, not sure why you're saying "only" like it was yesterday. I hardly think the same as I did a year ago.

[@diogoalexandree]

The people “forgiving” her aren’t even the ones she hurt. Stop supporting artists that only care about their public image. This girl would not have sent out an apology if her actions didn’t have such big consequences on her career! Open your eyes please.

[@teanasworld]

Sandcastles exactlyyyyy

[@joshj2862]

Sandcastles nobodies “hurt” they’re just offended.

[@diogoalexandree]

Cloud Sipper As a mixed person myself I was hurt by her comments. And I guarantee you Normani was hurt as well.

[@diogoalexandree]

Do Na Go on Twitter for 10 seconds and you’ll know.

[@mariafelix6774]

Well iam a black latina and yall should really learn south american history because latinos have the same exact right to say nigga.

[@ver0_]

Im 15 and I already know the history of black people but go off camila . try and save your career

[@whydoihavesubs6644]

Her career is fine. That shit was like 4 years ago

[@DGBETCH]

@tejano151 try again

[@ivansentosa7699]

@Ray S. zach is a hyocrite af towards camila

[@SarahYusra-s7l]

She’s been flopping for years now

[@poppyyppop]

The saddest part about this is the people that are defending her

[@lucaswallo8127]

She should be defended. Sharing memes AS A 15 YEAR OLD back in a far less overly sensitive time is not relevant to the present day whatsoever.

[@diogoalexandree]

Wal Luc no, please stop. She apologized for herself, not for the people she hurt. She never mentioned hurting black people, she was doing damage control. Fuck her.

[@denzelmckenzie2171]

Wal Luc using “nigger” was never okay at any point in time of her lifespan stop...overly sensitive or not. You must feel the way she does.

[@poppyyppop]

David I not really you should stop generalizing

[@kaishapage2443]

@@lucaswallo8127 u need help.

[@Kuro_Dante]

She's cuban not surprised. If you're from fl you already know 😆

[@Kuro_Dante]

@Ray S. She reps her cuban side way more.

[@simplyjay0748]

Aye FL gang 😂

[@jeremyjdl713]

Cubans are notorious in the Latino community for hating Mexicans and Central Americans. They are also one of the few Latino communities that voted for Tяump in droves. What they fail to realize is that Mexicans are Native Americans. Northern Mexicans particularly are genetically identical to the Native Americans of the southwestern US. Ppl forget from Texas to Cali used to be Mexico. Polk forced war against Mexico knowing he would annex land afterward. He wanted the US to stretch from the Atlantic to the pacific and Mexico was in the way. A quote from Ulysses S. Grant about Polks war on Mexico: “I do not think there was ever a more wicked war than that waged by the United States on Mexico.” He said this bc he knew the war wasn’t about anything Mexico had done illegally it was simply so the US could take Mexican land.

[@Kuro_Dante]

@@jeremyjdl713 Everything you stated are facts. The funny thing about everything is that cubans were once in a similar situation as the mexicans. In the 70s/80s they faced discrimination and prejudice, from American's in miami.

[@mariafelix6774]

@@Kuro_Dante uumm most of the cuban population is mix or black, and latinos can say nigga learn south american history.

[@michideartist2219]

Before you fans destroy ypur keyboards and defend your sides I wanted everybody to AT LEAST try to fit yourself to black people's shoes. Society is hard for them and I couldn't even imagine in a place somewhere where we're not welcome and we would feel so insulated every now and then. I'm not a black person but I ha e a lot of friends who are black people and sometimes would often open up why some people just wouldn't accept or take the joke so effortlessly, a joke can sometimes trigger to a point it's not a joke anymore. I wish well for Camila and I do HOPE she really did develop to be a better person and try to be at least considerate to ALL RACE. To be fair we are all equal. This world was made for EVERYBODY, so don't feel so obnoxious especially if your race is more accepted and use that privileges into disadvantages. I ask everybody to love one another. I pray that Camila will be sincere enough because she cares about equality and not because she get caught. I believe in the goodness of people and I hope she really is sorry. To the people to takes sides without a doubt please put yourselves into other's shoes before you jump in sides. To all unique races, you all belong and has a place in this world, you have a purpose and YOU ALL ARE LOVED. Spread the love everyone. For those who got hurt especially because of this issue I will send virtual hug and will pray that love will win inside you to make you feel better.

[@Pulser43]

Amen Praise Jesus

[@bibliotecas69]

Why tf was my comment deleted

[@ivyreid7]

Michi De Artist I need you to really step aside and stay with Camilla in the corner

[@shay409]

Chile she don’t give a fuck lol look at the bs apology she gave

[@kiara-yd5vv]

amen

[@mellothefellow2905]

I'm not buying her apologize

[@minanina1829]

No one is

[@minanina1829]

@Buttered Lumps yesss that's exactly what I was thinking about 🙌🙌

[@Jess-ew3tm]

@Buttered Lumps so we basically cancelling Eminem for his anti black women song even tho he made a whole album damn near defending black america??? And are we cancelling justin bieber and anyone else who has apologized? We gotta cancel Shawn mendez too at this point

[@slowedaudios1990]

No one is, i don't need her apoligy Like nooo....

[@ItzLionxss]

Jess girl I canceled all of them and no one care about Justin crackhead self anymore .I stopped listening to Shawn after this black lady asked him about being racist and he said that people should move on from things and I never liked Eminem anyways

[@enyaaa7921]

She’s only 22, her teenage years weren’t that long ago. She’s always come off as fake to me anyway.

[@MrGoodman174]

She isn't even that pretty. Take her ass out.

[@anonimperson9749]

@@MrGoodman174 calm ur ass

[@MrGoodman174]

@@anonimperson9749 make me bish

[@anonimperson9749]

@@MrGoodman174 Why so upset? Hit a nerve?

[@Vistapro97]

Camila had 45.1 followers on Instagram the day the news broke, now she has 45.4. It’s pretty obvious this isn’t going to have a huge impact on her career. Comments on KZbin aren’t going to cancel her. Normani hasn’t gained any followers since the news. Here what I think: LETS SUPPORT NORMANI PEOPLE, SHE NEEDS SUPPORT. Camila isn’t going anywhere but let’s put this energy into uplifting Normani!

[@arryzlo7664]

Well why the heck do you think this stuff resurfaced from YEARS ago?? Because people feel like they have to pull down Camila and push up Normani. I agree, what she said was disgusting and unforgivable, but that shouldn’t be held against you your whole life. I support Normani, but Camila hasn’t acted like this ever since so I also support Camila. Also, I find it interesting that this resurfaced from a Normani fan around the time Camila’s album came out. how convenient. Anyways that’s just my view on this subject, and it obviously differs from most others. Have a nice day! 😁

[@SarahYusra-s7l]

But she’s been flopping ever sense and I’m glad

[@SarahYusra-s7l]

Yes, so she said horrible things and she’s racist. It doesn’t change anything just because you were young and how would you call Normani a nigger It was years ago and it just can’t be forgotten because how you feel and it is gonna be dangled overhead because she did something wrong

[@Kylietmusic]

I’m black. I feel uncomfortable saying the N word and hearing it come out of anyone’s mouth. I refuse to support the people who represent this country by tearing down a race. Like she said... this country was developed upon hate and racism.

[@aiden8111]

it's so sad that camila's fans are so easily influenced by camila being racist that they say stuff like that to normani. the fans she has currently still call normani names like normonkey and photoshop photos of her. the even have the audacity to tag her in it.

[@LamarTheeDean]

jennieult exactly but if we say some shit the world ends

[@certifiedcoffeebean]

Normani didn’t even do anything wrong, all she did was compliment Camila. I swear some stans are so sensitive. And even if Normani had said or done something against Camila, that doesn’t make it okay for people to be racist.

[@mirandabullard4809]

How she has fans 😂😂😂 canola oil one good song havana 😂😂😂

[@Ggj2715]

You know what this is so sad like wtf is different just because our colors or nationality is different you say these words like why i don’t even understand we are humans we should treat each other in a respectful way like what if u just treat others with some respect or no we want you to just shut the fuck up and stop hurting and making fun of others this world would be beautiful without racism, crimes ...

[@Notmyancestors]

GG, I agree I really wish people would think before they open their ignorant mouths. Instead of making fun of someone get to know them as an individual and not a race. Those comments that she said whether she said them 7 years ago or 7 minutes ago doesn't matter to me, she still said them. When I made a terrible mistake I owned up to it, I didn't wait until I was caught red handed before I apologize for what I had done. I wish that she didn't say what she said it's really sad.

[@kiara-yd5vv]

ikr that's what i've been saying a long time ago

[@mariafelix6774]

@@Notmyancestors yeah you should also learn south american history because black and non black latinos were also called niggas and enslaved by the white spaniards and portugues who colonized the south. Then when latinos first imigrated to north america they were called niggas by the white americans and non black latinos were called brown niggas. How is she racist just for saying nigga.🤦🏽‍♀️ p.s iam black and latina.

[@aiai9571]

@@mariafelix6774 Yeah "negros". Even in my country Somalia they call them "Jareer" which means "nappy hair" but in a rude way. My parents comfortably say it but i don't as its a racial slur. I only say it when talking about hair texture but never calling that to a person since its not nice.

[@wwmexd4451]

GIRL BYEEEEEE, I'm 17 and when I was in elementary I already knew about racism. People so evil and twisted.

[@s.c.6989]

I’m black and I don’t really care about her comments. She just another racist person, or was one. Either way, it doesn’t matter, to me. Sorry everyone who was offended by her

[@Deafkn1ght]

Same her bro. Just another day in paradise for us black folks out here in America

[@TkRyujin]

Same but when the fans made things about normani getting lynched that was unacceptable

[@arryzlo7664]

TekkenKingMari Yes, that was unacceptable, but you shouldn’t hold that against her when her fans did that. She doesn’t have control over everything her fans do, like any other celebrity.

[@celine9174]

@@arryzlo7664 Well she has a responsibility to put her fans in oder as she has a lot of power over them, especially due to the extremities to which they bullie normani although she didn't cause her the pain she contributed to it

[@arryzlo7664]

Celine Magnusen I guess I don’t understand why a person should be responsible for what millions of people do..

[@Snax27]

My sister is one of the her lil fans who defend her and I honestly don't know how to make her understand its wrong

[@shyguyx1219]

Patrick is she really young? Cuz if so then that makes sense. Kids tend to support things solely based on the fact that they like it. She’ll understand as she gets older

[@Snax27]

She's 20 years old And we're not from the US so I get that she doesn't fully grasp how horrible the shit Camilla posted is but I tried to educate her about it ,and no use.

[@morganc2834]

I understand how wrong it was for Camila to post those things, but she was a teenager. Don't tell me you did everything right when you were a teenager? She was also surrounded by people who were racist which made an imprint on her. I have been a fan for quite a while and know that Camila has no room for genuine hate in her heart, she has proven that she has changed. She made an apology back then and now. She deserves another chance. She is not a bad person she just made bad decisions. I understand how upset people are but what else can Camila do? She made an apology twice and has proven how changed she is.

[@shay409]

Morgan Conley shut that shit up that’s complete bs she’s racist and that’s that!

[@kaseygale2747]

Kiya i do agree that that was messed up, but I just think that people should accept her apology and move on. Camila is not the only celeb that has ted something racist many others have yet she is majorly dragged? Unfair to me

[@Sunny-zw3hh]

You were 15/16 what to you mean you didn't know about the history lmao shut up and apologize properly

[@morganc2834]

What else does she need to say?? We all did stupid things in our past, she just had tons of eyes on her. I have been a fan for a while and know that Camila has no room in her heart for genuine hate. She is a loving person and has shown how much she has changed since then. I understand how people can be upset, but we all need another chance. What else does she need to say as a proper apology??

[@shay409]

Morgan Conley being racist is not normal for a teenager shut up.

[@morganc2834]

@@shay409 You are right, it isn't normal to be a racist teen, but it is normal to say stupid things as a teenager that you regret.

[@shay409]

Morgan Conley yeah but she didn’t say stupid things.. she said racist things so🤷🏽‍♀️

[@AHSghost]

Kiya that she regrets

[@harundaniel7705]

I'm sorry but at 15, you should already know from right and wrong regardless of your upbringing. How is she gonna act like she didn't know the meaning behind the "n" word when violence/racism towards the black community in the US is so prevalent. That's like me (an Afghan living in Australia) not knowing about the sufferings of the indigenous Aboriginal / Torres strait islanders have gone through in history and in the present. Her reasoning / excuse for her behaviour back in the day is bullshit. I was a fan and now I don't even wanna hear her name again. And on a side note, Normani is literally what an artist should be, the girl can dance, sing, stage presence be on point and her music doesn't sound generic like most singers these days.

[@tristanfeinauer]

Chicken is okay, I prefer steak or ribs.

[@planetofi5hii]

I'm 16 and I have never once used a racial slur nor insulted a person due to their race. Stop excusing her because of her age. Stop letting people off when they need to be held accountable. This happened less than 10 years ago. She was brought up with these insensitive racial stereotypes and I know for sure they haven't completely gone from her mind yet.

[@user-uj7sd4dk7p]

Her fans over here trying to say she was 12 and didn't understand what it meant. She was 15/16 and by the amount of times she posted about black people she had to have known what it meant. If it was one post of the watermelon chicken gif than yeah, maybe. But it wasn't she knew what it was and is only sorry because she got caught.

[@AJDaEnvoy]

OOF it’s crazy how her fans defend her like that. As if you’re a little kid at 15. Of course she was a kid but she knew better

[@lucaswallo8127]

@@MikeyJae777 People just need to get less sensitive imo. Wdym by she needs to get it together? Those were posted several years ago. Digging up old shit is just annoying.

[@ogd5757]

What happened to the Hispanics getting the N word pass?

[@czs7624]

Denzel Mckenzie but at the same time the group (5th harmony) were bullying her, so I guess it makes it equal

[@LGSN96]

I never liked her, still don't care much for her but this was 7 YEARS ago. God forgive we actually evolve as a person..

[@nicoletakyi]

It’s really sad that people are defending her , like yes she was 15/16 years old but she obviously went to school and learned that racial slurs are bad and can have consequences. She also called Normani the n-word and let her fans bully and made a whole tumbler page saying disgusting things about black people and Asian people, the apology was so full of bs, first of all she didn’t even make it clear who and what she is apologizing for? Like if we didn’t know what she had done , we could have thought this apology was for something else. Like 🙄🙄🙄 and PLEASE IF YOUR NOT BLACK DON’T TELL BLACK PEOPLE HOW AND WHAT TO FEEL , STOP SAYING WE SHOULD MOVE FORWARD.

[@kyriecoleman9447]

Exactly

[@SarahBaby83]

people can grow tho

[@castillocastillo9188]

Those messages are fake, normani's fans made this in 2016. Also normani never defended camila for insults xenophobic of her fans lol

[@aboutthat1440]

Of course you would try and defend that racist skank. Like her FOS fans. Vile demonic people.

[@xiondavis6594]

About That they were fake. anyways since y’all mad n upset she is still the most streamed artist in the world. since all this is happening more ppl are listening to her so anyways stream romance for clear skin

[@donovangreenwood4737]

I'm 16 and I know better

[@MrGoodman174]

Your parents raised you well.

[@nolovelost4020]

And then I get criticized and called a racist because I openly don't support white celebrities. Can you blame me?!?! 😂😂

[@SainteDenali]

The best thing we can do is give Normani our love and support.

[@MySweetAriane]

She's kind of a weirdo. Why would she even be into posting things like that? It's strange. I wonder if the men she has dated or people that are her friends look at her differently now

[@johndawhale3197]

I was actually her boyfriend in a dream I had one time... I look at her differently now though.

[@1029teddybear]

Damn..I never knew Camilla was racist. I'm white and this is not okay ever. I have a different view of Camilla now. I'm sorry whoever she offended.

[@kindly_jaded]

Here’s the thing. She never said those things about Normani. Fans of hers will know that those were photoshopped years ago to make Camila look bad, and they get brought up everytime it’s time to drag Camila. She DID say very racially insensitive things in the past, and that isn’t okay. But it’s a simple fact that she said those things 7 years ago. 7 years ago, I was a stupid teenager who said ignorant stuff too. We’re all products of our environment, and it’s evident that Camila has grown since then and makes an effort to include POC in her art, and speak up on important topics. Hold people accountable for what they do, but don’t keep them from growing and changing their behavior.

[@dremkitten4764]

I mean, she is Cuban. What did y'all expect?

[@redblue4127]

Lols he was 16. Unless she literally lived under a rock or was homeschooled by racists, there is no excuse. That wasn't no childhood heat of the moment BS. I guarantee you that at 22, she still holds the same beliefs. That was a string of character elaborating, overtly racist actions. AT SIXTEEN. Are you fucking kidding me? 2 years later and it's a wrap. She even said that shit about her team mates while she was in fifth harmony and essentially endorsed her fans organizing a racist hate mob against her team mate. Give me a break.

[@medylemaproductions]

I don't understand why she is using her age as an excuse to say that she didn't know better because that's dumb really really really dumb. At 15 I knew the difference between right and wrong

[@clarita.clarita.47]

I’m dark skinned I will never forgive her but I do accept her apology ( since she did have the dignity to say that she said those hurtful words and did apologize for them ) , however the age doesn’t matter at 15 u are wise enough to tell what is right or not to say in my opinion . I also don’t like the fact that once she got called she apologized. However I can’t say she didn’t change . She might’ve been a racist which she was , but right now she doesn’t seem like it and supports all groups of people . But I can’t say it’s that easy to just forget what she said and move on ,many are saying we forgive u Camila no i don’t really forgive u but i do accept your apology and maybe in the future I might forgive her .

[@arryzlo7664]

I appreciate your honesty and I wish everybody has the same mentality as you! Have a nice day/night 😁

[@kindly_jaded]

It’s kinda weird how Normani fans used this situation (which wasn’t about her) as an opportunity to make it about her. Those screenshots were faked by 5H fans who wanted to make Camila look bad, look into it. Camila and Normani have been civil for the past 2 years, and have said nothing but kind things about each other. It’s so weird.

[@neamhdhlisteanach6720]

theres a difference between making a racial joke (which is still wrong) and then making multiple racial jokes and even directing it towards someone you actually know. disgusting

[@extrememakeoverfan]

Thank you for saying that you don’t think all white people are like this. 15 is too young to know better? Took you until 22 to do better? No. The truth is that just because people aren’t saying racist things doesn’t mean they don’t think them. Very very sad.

[@StillND]

20 dislikes are Camila fans.

[@StillND]

@@David.lovesU I don't forgive racists. And it ain't no damn "mistake." She did it multiple times and at 15, you know right from wrong. So don't tell black ppl that they should forgive these racists, because when someone says something disrespectful about the Holocaust or 9/11, you don't tell them to forgive. Why should we? We aren't obligated to forgive anyone.

[@mertmitm]

If she had said it like 1 time or so, I would've believed her that she regrets it and that she thinks it's inappropriate. But her entire online presence was about black people and degrading them which to me seems very disturbed and actually racist.

[@shay409]

It’s so sad that normani had to be in that group with her :( praying for her

[@itsnotaiiden]

she has had a racist past but now in 2020 i think she has changed for the better. she’s protested for black lives matter and supported black lives and equality in her nbts tour.

[@lol6294]

as a white person saying the n word is horrible but multiple times? that’s gone wayyyyyyyy too far

[@mirandabullard4809]

I am done with her. I never did those things I was not stupid.

[@moranaime5751]

In France, I studied there for a while, the racism against Asians is a LOT and they just brush it off and tell you that u don’t have a sense of humor. For black people, it’s there but for black womans it’s worse but not like in the US tho it’s way less it’s more old people that are like that. That’s what I observed, I can’t talk for black people cause I didn’t experienced it but I can talk for Asians

[@yassoras205]

Jugemu JugemuGokō-no surikireKaijarisuigyo-no Asians are very racist

[@moranaime5751]

Yassora S aight

[@lanababy3660]

@Yassora S Are you gonna ignore the fact that Asians aren't the only ones with a tendency of being racist? I'm not saying that all Asians are not racist but there are a few who are and a few that aren't. But if you're going to comment about how racist an ethnicity is you might as well include Africans, Hispanics, and Caucasians. Anyone can be racist, it just comes from how people think in particular matters, you on another hand seem very small minded with your surroundings and the information you are withholding/putting on the internet.

[@Jess-ew3tm]

Which is why it blows my mind when Asians themselves are racist 💀 we should be sticking together wth

[@Light0486]

@@lanababy3660 wait what? I know what you're trying to say after your first question...but that question doesn't make sense...he said ppl were racist AGAINST Asians, not

[@Ashluv085]

And it seems like shes not going to say anything else about it. Shes just gonna move right along from this. Like nothing happened. And like that apology was actually good.

[@Ashluv085]

@@Lisa-iz7fr 🙄

[@ivarthirlwall]

If she wasn't a artist no one would ever be so hard on her... She is just under a microscope... And being judged by people who don't know her.... We are HUMAN.... We all make mistakes, we are all learning.... I hate that she gets this awful hate because she is famous

[@moskimoon]

if yall going to have this unforgiving energy towards camila, keep the same energy for jeffree star, justin bieber, post malone, lil pump, sixnine, kevin hart, dave chapelle, chris brown, hailey baldwin

[@claudiaparada3300]

I’m glad people are talking about this

[@vj9055]

"Once i became ware of the history...." Please girl I can tell she failed her classes. Even having black friends, they will tell you what offends them. There's no excuse. I think she felt insecure bc the black singers were better. Camilla never sang good the rest did and probably she attacked Normani's skin color

[@Hey_Its_Tiff]

How in the hell have you lived in this country your entire life and only find out the meaning behind the word AFTER you’re caught using it? Girl bye.

[@killulgybixxes7137]

I’m so shocked, she seemed so innocent and nice.

[@Riddimsofcreation]

They are OBSESSED with us 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I will believe the apology when I see her sacrifice herself for one of us

[@jai22udhdbdjdjdud]

You know about those fake history books chief💪. You know who you are and I love it!

[@Fuffuwu]

Omg I didn’t know about the Normani part! Dang Camila fans were tripping! and the fact Camila couldn’t say “hey can you not be mean to my band member” just hurts me even more 😔

[@dgaller06]

I wanna see Camila really apologize, not do that beauty guru notepad apology on Instagram and Twitter. I wanna see her actually make a video, address the issues and apologize.

[@VanessaBarrios1119206]

I want to say this because I don't understand several things. I know what she said when she was younger was very bad, it was disrespectful and she apologized before and now, she comes back to the light and she apologizes again and I guess that is going to chase her forever, but I don't understand the point, people will never forgive her? never? so what is the point of her apologizing all the time ... I live surrounded by racism, homophobia, classism, misogyny and I can hear it even in my family and I really believe in the possibility that ignorant people learn and change, it is not what do we all want ? or we just want to destroy a person, without generating any impact, we just want to see it fall and that's it?. Think about that.

[@breezybabe0019]

Vanessa Barrios if u r not black pls don't tell us who to forgive and who to not, thanks!🚶🏽‍♀️

[@cimsim597]

This is the main problem, she can apologize 1000x but it means nothing without 1 sincere apology. 1) The format she uses to relay the apology is subpar (we should have at least seen her face or shown effort by physically writing something or typing it in a formal structure), but we can forgive it in the age of technology. 2) the language things she did were hurtful and were intended to be disrepectful, but she contradicted herself and said she meant no harm. She needs to own up to her mistake without sugarcoating it to make herself seem better. 3) She blames her behavior on her youth, but it wasnt like she was 11 when she said this, she was 15...when discussing blatant racism, that is not young. Age as an excuse for racism ends after you become a teen, let alone being halfway though teenaged years. 4) She never specifies what she did. We all know that scenario with an adult making a little kid apologize and when the kid says "im sorry" and the adult follows with "for...". Even little kids know that an apology comes with an admission of what you did wrong. She only apologizes for the "hurtful things she has said and done". That is generic AF. What did she do? what did she say? what was she young ad ignorant about? That is the main problem. But also, to do these things as a young adult (not a small child), she was in a point of her life to know better and for many who have been hurt personally by things like this, it is unforgivable. Thousands of black ppl have been murdered with the last word they heard being n*gger and she had the audacity to use that word (not misusing it as a term of endearment but using it as an insult at that, with the R, towards someone she knows...), some are not gonna let that go and that is their fully justified choice. We're not required to forgive one's past, especially when given an underwhelming apology.

[@breezybabe0019]

Issac Madrid wasn't talking to u suh 🙄

[@VanessaBarrios1119206]

@@breezybabe0019 You cant see my photo? Im fucking black, a latina Black .Girl, where I am from, I always have to see racism, people call our hair "Pelo malo" (bad hair), they call us ugly and much more, even in my family, my grandmother is white and she has always been very racist with my mother and me, just for being black. our own race discriminates, they even feel offended, they think that being black but having too dark skin is being ugly ... My point is, I live in a country where machismo, racism, classism It's culture and I have to educate my friends, my family and many people, every day and for that I have to forgive them too. I am from the Colombian Caribbean btw.

[@VanessaBarrios1119206]

@@cimsim597 I agree with you on almost everything, but that's why I keep asking you why to make her apologize 100 times and more, if you will never really forgive her. At this point she can do and say many things and people will never be happy with what she's saying. So let's avoid giving moral classes when we all know that we have screwed up when we were younger, the difference is that we are not famous for everyone to know and make a trend on twitter about our names. My point is, every time you "Canceled" someone famous, the reality is that nothing happens, the person apologizes and returns to work

[@ashaarredondo1824]

When u wanna be black... but don't want to face the racial discrimination that comes w/ it. Sick of fake people ✌🏾🙄

[@fayelienalien]

people who say that they didnt know the history of the word is bullshit. Im not even from America and I was taught American history before i was even a teenager. smh

[@thetydeeshow]

Idc I forgive her 💯

[@mindofafangirl2224]

an objective explanation of the normani story (from the pov of a black fan who saw it happening at the time): as concise as I could make it so pls read! normani's horrific ordeal on twitter happened when fifth harmony (5h) first started to fall apart and the fandom (harmonizers) started to become fragmented. it was the start of the end for 5h, with the other four (ot4) all appearing to turn against camila out of jealousy and resentment of her solo projects. harmonizers split into camila fans (camilizers) vs ot4 stans. the reason why camilizers were upset about mani's description of camila was because when she described the other three girls, she had something nice to say about them straight away. she called ally her 'little ray of sunshine', lauren her 'counsellor/therapist and best friend' and dinah 'the turnt queen....so much fun'. people simply called normani out on it as proof that ot4 hated camila and didn't consider her as a friend or want her in the band. they were genuine fans, upset and confused about the future of their favourite band. the problem lay in the fact that there were already a lot of racist harmonizers who would go to meet and greets (m&gs) and hug all the girls except mani, or not want her in their m&g pics. they saw the drama as an opportunity to launch their hate campaign, and they pounced. it had nothing to do with camila. yes she made a lot of hateful and insensitive comments/posts, but even though the band hadn't been together too long the other girls already displayed a dislike for her as she was the "favourite" when they were on x factor and quickly became friends with the taylor swift squad. camila was being immature and lashing out, but people forget she wasn't the one photoshopping mani's head onto gorillas or people being lynched. she said herself that she did not consider the people who hurt her friend like that her fans and she tried to put a stop to it; but it wasn't her battle. it's just another tragic reality of an ongoing battle in the us and uk. it's sad but it's true. it was highly problematic of empressive (nothing new there) to put the two stories together as though they were part of the same thing. one was about a racially motivated attack on an innocent, beautiful, strong black woman whom people were intimidated by and proceeded to drive off of twitter with their abuse. the other was simply a pathetic attempt to take away from the fact that camila decided to own up to her past mistakes for which she has already publicly apologised on two occasions, by making fun of her latest genuine apology. if you know camila, you know that's just how she communicates because she has such a way with words. when she rambles, she's speaking from the heart. clearly kinda like me haha.

[@mindofafangirl2224]

@SunKissed Melanin this isn't even a quarter of the story. i just think people need to move on considering she's already addressed it and she was a child at the time. i'm 17 and some of my classmate still act that ignorant! besides, i bet there are a ton of black celebs who have done inappropriate things before that you've conveniently brushed off for the sake of "solidarity". look how long it took for r kelly to get what he deserved....

[@mindofafangirl2224]

@The alien in your backyard you're right tbh. all of them were in the wrong bc the dynamic of the band was always toxic. camila had this coming, but it's turning out the exact same way it did before when they drove her out of the group. everything the girls did to her is being completely overlooked.

[@mindofafangirl2224]

@SunKissed Melanin actuallyyyyy, the only member of the group who didn't do a solo project / collab with another artist is normani. all the girls had the opportunity to do things separate from the group. that's why mani ws on dwts fgs. and yeah the plan was always for mila to go solo, but it was never meant to happen that soon. we were supposed to get at least one more ot5 album but the girls made it too toxic for mila to continue with them. they made up a ton of lies and did everything they could to make her look bad to the point where she developed depression and ocd so....

[@mindofafangirl2224]

SunKissed Melanin no that’s what they wanted you to believe. they stopped inviting camila places and her friends felt bad

[@mindofafangirl2224]

SunKissed Melanin and ally did a side project before camila left

[@jaylenc4946]

“watermelon is disgusting” PERIOD!

[@beka6275]

But she apologized... What else can she do, if she ignores the situation yall will get mad, if she apologizes y'all will get mad, what can she do for y'all to just stop attacking her

[@itsuplike9947]

Reap the consequences of her actions.. move

[@KP-dt9ol]

Camila was acting like she didn’t know what slavery was....at 15...we learned this every year in social studies stop playing

[@Dree03]

Dang I was over here feeling bad for her thinking everyone in the group was just doing her wrong. I didn’t know Normani was in 5th harmony tho

[@blackisbeautiful9318]

They probably kicked Camilla out of fifth harmony thats why she left i bet.

[@moskimoon]

the facebook message was fake, she didnt go by camila till she was on xfactor and her facebook is karla cabello

[@rebeccasilva7528]

She apologized 3 times in different years. And is helping so much people that in the past she hurt. The fact that we can make a mistake, learn and do better makes us humans. People are too good at judging people in the past without see what they are in the [present] 2019. It’s bad, yes. But we all learn. The fact that in the react even she’s apologizing you said that “nobody’s care” prove a lot of point. If we didn’t care, we would never be watching videos about this. You can learn and search of what she’s doing and who she is now, Camila is a good person and a support of any people. You guys just choose the wrong battle for fight.

[@rebeccasilva7528]

Little Normani Yes, I hope so too. She is such a good person that talks about people that need. I hope we all get though this and things got better

[@nothingbutintroverted4372]

Listen i agree with you but when you said 'non black Americans are racist as fuck' i have to call bs i have heard plenty of stories of black Americans being racist as well racism doesn't discriminate based on race ironically

[@hyunjinstan5534]

Girl, girl, girl. Dee is not buying that shit.

[@joshj2862]

Are you guys kidding me? Y’all don’t say shit when the Hispanic kids at school say the n word but since it’s a celebrity it’s a big deal. I don’t think anybody should say the n word but the hypocrisy is real.

[@patriciawoolfolk3515]

I saw a thing where it said she knew what those words meant bc one it was in 2012 which is when the black lives matter thing startes so she HAD to know wtf that shit meant

[@yxngd7201]

I'm 22 I knew at 15 what the n word means so u can throw that apology in the trash

[@msveeip]

If she posted or said one thing...it would be different. Homegirl WENT IN!!!! You learned the history(even if it was one chapter) in school...STOP IT.

[@youtubemanswagroy212]

i lauphed at the basketball chicken pic😂😂😂

[@tlnaml]

she has the nerve to have john 3:16 on her backround photo. smh.

[@Noa......]

What about it?

[@SuperChiko]

She said sorry for that tweet

[@jonathangrant5176]

By fifteen your old enough to know racist comments are wrong she wasn't 9 and accidentally retweeted someone's else comments she repeatedly made those comments once is a mistake three or four times

[@castillocastillo9188]

Why do people talk about what Camila did years ago when she was not famous and they don't talk about the foundations towards African children that Camila helps? mature please

[@castillocastillo9188]

@SunKissed Melanin the obsession 😂😂😂😂

[@castillocastillo9188]

@SunKissed Melanin you are in all her videos lol

[@xfrenchii]

Florida people aren’t surprised... and that’s facts.

[@itsjadeyuwu]

Here's the thing. I disagree with what she said and did and I'm ashamed of her for saying those things. However, I'd like to see how she acts and what she does in the future, and then we'll be able to tell if she's really sorry.

[@iloveyou202]

I used to be a fifth harmony fan and I never liked her she was always hating on the others and was always letting ppl talk shit bout Normani

[@Uil7686]

the netherlands is like this too to some extend, as one of the leaders in slavery back in the day and a lot of black people from colonies living in the Netherlands nowadays, there is a lot of systemic racism. They also made pictures of black female politician Sylvana Simons getting lynched just because she spoke out against the racist blackface tradition annually in the country. We're all in this together across the globe...

[@kiasman0114]

To be fair latins in Miami have been saying nigga forever. Listen to Pitbulls first albums. I know I grew up saying it and most of my friends were black

[@lorivera94]

I mean, that was 9 years ago (or 7 years ago). But I agree, racism is unacceptable, especially when it is more than once being bright out against blacks (who I love and support btw). She made more than one racial slur back then when she was a teenager. I believe mistakes happen and we learn from them. Which means I believe she learned from her mistakes and she learned from them. Her fans on other hand, some of them are loyal and respectful, but then some of them are fake with stupidity (when they said racial slurs to Normani, they probably were acting like her fans and still wanted to go too far). She apologized to Normani 2 years ago (which is what we wanted), and then she apologized over and over for her past racial comments from 2012 like she did today (but, it doesn't seem like it's enough). I know the black community is angry about this (and probably not having it with her past remarks), but I do believe people do change and learn from a bunch of horrible mistakes (while some just don't change at all). She wrote a lot about herself, mainly because she wanted to specific (even when she didn't really say the parts of it, but most of us should take a hint). I just hope, since (supposedly) she truly is sorry for her racial past (because she apologized again), and the black community can take the time, to know that her apology was to them and was never a fake. I know it's hard for a few to accept an apology, (because not all of us are forgiving like nothing), the one thing, I don't want to see, is us being divided, and hating each other, when our past mistakes (even the worst ones), don't define who we are, in our future (unlike Donald Trump is still being a racist putting fear into all of us for being united). Thank you 🙏

[@cimsim597]

I'm gonna say something that ppl aren't gonna hop on to until another couple of years, but pls don't minimize racism by saying the word racial. It was a racist past, clearly. Doing racist things continuously makes a person a racIST, not racIAL. There is a scale of how racist a person can be and she isn't Trump level, but being racist doesn't have to be overt and clownish. Saying someone is or is being racist isn't necessarily an insult, its a fact thereof, like calling someone rude. Not every person who does something rude is characteristically rude but if you engage in rude behavior often enough it becomes quite evident that you are simply rude. Saying racial allows ppl to shrug off the weight of their actions. It makes the perpetrator feel better about their actions when the truth is that it was racist and ppl are afraid to make the perpetrator feel bad. We can only conquer racism once ppl understand what it is. Racial (adjective) is used if we are simply talking about race (noun), if racism (noun) is involved the adjective is racist. Switching these adj's out is misleading and incorrect. Sometimes we have to own up to things and carry a weight we don't want to hold, but that's what right. Let's not use plays on language to prevent ppl from owning up to their mistakes.

[@kari5765]

Why is people bringing old shit up tho.

[@AngelHxze]

But it's like at what point are people forgiven for the stupid shit they do? It's been 7 entire fucking years lmao- she was FIFTEEN. She is now TWENTY TWO. I'm sure there are countless of things y'all have done 7 years ago or at the age of 15 that you wouldn't want people holding against you if you know that you've grown from that time. It's just popping up for us but this happened nearly a decade ago for her. But if it's not something really recent, I don't get why people are mad at the shit. Kids are dumb and do dumb things. Can you not be a former anything? If we held people to their standards of 7+ years ago in the spotlight, a lot of y'all would be in deep shit lol. I wouldn't even apologize for this; but then again, they wouldn't care because I'm black.

[@iangrant9958]

Shawn and Camila belong together. They both have a racist past and they both gave weak ass apologies.

[@letitbe1977]

7:50 Were you rapping or what? I didn't understand at first and thought I was buggin' lmfao 😂😂

[@royjyvo]

For all we know her team wrote that!

[@liv_fornow8316]

15 is old enough to not be stupid 🙄

[@aeiresslumpkin4866]

As a black person in today’s society, I frankly don’t care. I get these comments are very offensive and insensitive is an understatement, but It’s in the past. Some people can feel however they want about this situation, and that’s completely justified, but I’m not going to waste my time being mad over something said 7+ years ago. Everyone said dumb things at that age because that was just the normal and “cool” thing to do. So as society is progressing, people are becoming more aware of these issues and how wrong it is. I understand it but that doesn’t mean it’s right. So I understand and recognize people’s right to be fucking pissed, because this is not a laughing matter. But I personally just can’t waste my time and energy on something like this. And to those saying her apology isn’t genuine...maybe it is, maybe it isn’t but frankly it doesn’t matter because nothing is going to change. She may loose a few followers and her sales may decline by a minute percentage, but in the end, the people who like her music will continue to buy albums and this whole situation will be forgotten.

[@jonathangrant5176]

Going by that logic someone can kill someone or rob someone but because they're fifteen they didnt understand so its ok

[@swampmermaid3081]

Influencer with racist past: "I was uneducated and ignorant back then. 😔" Swarthes of white fans who are actually uneducated and ignorant: "Omg! All is forgiven! No need to apologize." Everyone affected by the infuencer's racism: "Uh... excuse me?" I don't think it's talked about enough about how these fans are equally damaging with their immediacy to forgive their fave's bigotry. It's infuriating. Just because someone "apologizes" doesn't make it right. And if someone showed bigotry/racism before, they more than likely still retain the same bigoted/racist ways to an extent (even after trying to change/distance themselves from their past behavior) but are more tactful with handling it by not letting everyone else know about it. I wished these celebs were actually held accountable.

[@Toxic-bg3wj]

I am a 15 year old white man, and I do not believe she is very sorry for her actions. As I am not a person of color, my feeling towards this doesn't really matter. But the fact she said she was young and immature? I am years younger than her, and I know what is racist and isn't. She can do all she can, but she knows what she did and apologized, even tho when people try to make aplogizes they use big words and make the speech long to act like they are sorry. IMO i don't think she is sorry.

[@feedgotcha]

Lmao she was wilding at 15 😂

[@Tarikkb]

Yes racism has no age and it doesnt change things but what changes things is time and it’s been 7 years she cleary learned from her mistakes, cuz she didnt do or said anything racist since 2012 and back then ppl didnt really discussed racism it was a topic, but it wasnt mainstream, media didnt shed light on it, so it is likely, that she didnt knew how hurtful and heavy the word actually is, y’all cab forgive jefree which used that word in his early 20’s and why does cardi b has a pass she isnt black, but you cant forgive someone who learned from their mistake? Smh

[@Tarikkb]

Phoenix Rize are u aware of the fact that ppl can abd will change as they grow up , especially from their teen years

[@robvegetadam]

Theo fam at 15 everyone knew it’s a scummy thing to make racist comments like that on social media stop acting like it was the 1950’s and no one knew what racism was

[@StillND]

It's not a mistake if you keep doing it intentionally multiple times.

[@nicoletakyi]

Shed light ? Clearly she went to school and she knew that it was racist every 15/16 year old knows what racial slurs are , and Cardi B is half Trinidadian so she is half black so why even compare her to Camilla ?

[@gracetrack4291]

Theo ok so that happened in 2012. The racist comments against Normani were years after that. If Camila truly changed she would have defended Normani since it was Her fans that were attacking Normani. All Camila said was “spread love not hate.” Ally and Lauren were the ones that actually defended Normani when it wasn’t even their fans attacking her

[@keishacarlies5172]

15 years old?! She was in high school they teach rascism. I understand 13 and younger

[@AnnieLiuMusic]

it's not just the language?? she's apologizing only for the language but you can see through her posts it's a lot deeper rooted than just "careless use of words"