Can a Novice Blacksmith Forge a Hammer Without My Help?

[@dragonrace43]

Jamie needs a maker's mark for all the new things he's gonna forge

[@ibrahim-sj2cr]

Jamie needs a destroying mark

[@MadmanJnr]

JS for Jamie's Sheet...

[@blazingeek]

Not until he becomes a master

[@Rsama60]

I was about to comment the same.

[@Zogg1281]

I was thinking exactly the same thing!!

[@derekbushey595]

You can't be around a craftsman like Alec without picking up some skills of your own.

[@aserta]

Osmosis learning.

[@LittleGreyWolfForge]

Yep

[@russelali8697]

A day with a good teacher is better than a thousand days of study

[@kz.irudimen]

He should have Yogo try to forge a hammer then

[@bramweinreder2346]

Just by watching his channel (and others), I've been sort of able to give advice on the Baliscissors (butterfly scissors) project. Probably not great advice, but I do get a feeling why the scissor halves warp unpredictably after machining and grinding in the bevel. Alec too learned from the best, and following his channel (and That Works) gives a great insight into basic metallurgy without having to follow engineering courses. I'm not sure I could do half as well as Jamie though, but I do love the process of crafting and manufacturing.

[@thatonneguy]

Keep in mind we don't wanna lose Jamie to him creating his own successful youtube channel and blacksmithing workshop. Seems oddly specific, but I feel like there's something to it.

[@TomYourmombadil]

… then I would have TWO partners who created their own successful KZbin channel and blacksmithing workshop. Which isn’t a lot, but it’s weird that it happened twice.

[@joshuagibson2520]

Let's hope. You can't be someone's minion forever. Gotta go out on your own at some point.

[@magoshighlands4074]

He could always Cask Of Amantiado Alec then he doesn't even need to make his own channel

[@FoxDog1080]

Reminds me of Blitz and Intern

[@USMCRabbit]

Jamie's refusal to call the punch and drift by their actual names and instead calling them "small hole maker" and "big hole maker" is hilarious.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.

[@alecrabedeau4788]

I 👏 am 👏 here 👏 for 👏 the 👏 Alec 👏 and 👏 Jamie 👏 content! 👍

[@PARIAH8877]

Love seeing Jamie get more involved in the videos, from added commentary to full on forging, its great!

[@KiryokuYT]

This is a *perfect* example of the interaction between a *true* teacher and a student. Guiding, giving subtle hints, while still allowing them to make mistakes that they can recover from.

[@Zuul88]

That's how proper Coaching works :)

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.....

[@scotadam]

I would take a series where you take one or more people and teach them various blacksmithing skills, starting from something simplistic to more complicated things. Way to go Jamie.

[@ItsAnArtform]

when he first started his youtube channel. he us to teach people. You can see him making all them tools with a class in his very old clips. Alec even live streamed for awhile. shame he stopped them.

[@piraterubberduck6056]

The collabs where he teaches blacksmithing were great. It would be nice to have more of them again.

[@alanhersch4617]

@@ItsAnArtform Just a theory, but I would bet covid had a huge factor on this. I was working in a makers shop before covid, and once the pandemic hit, not only did we get WAYY less commissions, but being around people in close proximity was a risk factor so we decided to shut down.

[@Temp0raryName]

Awesome idea. A lot of us would love the chance to do something like that and Jamie is the perfect stand in, for us to see how that might turn out for us! Next: Alex vs Jamie!

[@booshmcfadden7638]

Alex will spend 8 videos fixing mistakes; Jamie would make one video.

[@OperationDarkside]

But in 2 categories, where the other is an expert in

[@tobyforrest3877]

Whose Alex? : )

[@Temp0raryName]

@@tobyforrest3877 Alec's slightly cooler cousin Alex Typo. ;-)

[@Kfed1995]

You gotta get Jamie to make a makers mark for all the stuff he’s been making recently I love all this stuff you guys have been working on. Keep on the amazing work :)

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@panopticemu]

ngl I really love alec's teaching style here... always asking the right questions to get Jamie to come to the right answer

[@JPWildlife]

You should do a series going through the ABANA (Artist Blacksmith Association of North America) curriculum, perhaps with some useful tips along the way for aspiring smiths. Enjoyed the video!

[@everking3767]

I love how you and Jamie are teaching each other new skills--caving vs. smithing.

[@phillipstrauss6269]

Man. You two are the most iconic duo 9n the internet. Seeing Jamie try out new skills is very exciting

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@randyphillips8803]

Well done, gents! Jamie taught you about caving, and you have him swinging a hammer at hot steel. Love it!

[@lordofgraphite]

really appreciated the balance of letting Jaimie work it out but dropping hints. much more fun to watch, as opposed to a strict version. was really wholesome and gratifying to see Jaimie learn and Alec thrive as a teacher. if you'd just shown me the hammer id never believe it was some ones first.

[@MadWiking]

Oooooh what a glorious episode! Technical input, learning to be had, from billet to finished product in one episode! I LOVE IT !!!! Thank you Jamie and Alec!! Best regards from Norway!

[@ewan3900]

I wish I had a friend like you Alec. I've just found your channel and it's helping me through an incredibly tough time so thank you and keep up the great work.

[@QYXP]

Apprentice Jamie should be an entire series!!!

[@mr.wambller5240]

Man I loved the old tool forging videos. Like when he made a beautiful damascus Japanese hammer .Alec should make some unique beautiful tools . I always loved how Illia from that makes has an engraved and enlayed hammer.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.

[@rikardhakansson]

I think you gave him just the right amount of tips. Not letting him ruin anything and making sure he's safe. Great job to the both of you!

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@lukasgropl2166]

Man I just love this. Brings me back to my beginning days, and the days I teach my friends to strike and forge on their own. You two are the best.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@scotadam]

Soooo... does this mean we get to have a video of Alec editing a video and Jamie watching on? :)

[@michaelcherokee8906]

You want a video of editing? Wouldnt that just inevitably result in an infinite regression of videos of editing of videos of editing of videos of editing...?

[@everettbruckerhoff6029]

@@michaelcherokee8906 editception

[@NearFall2Pin]

Bringing this channel back to its roots!!! I remember all the videos of you teaching classes and seeing this again was incredible!! Fantastic job

[@jlush444]

I love all the recent content with Jamie. He’s quality. Great job here too. 👌👌👌

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@petracoresage8288]

My absolute favorite video. Showing a friend how to make something is integral to the spirit of blacksmithing.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.

[@thegreatsaxtonian]

Kinda wish there was a bit more to this vid, Alec pointing out where Jamie went right, where he can improve, breaking down the features and effects Jamie got on his hammer because of how he worked it, and what Alec would have done to make it better

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@freqenc]

Passion, Pressure, and Personal pride. Those are my points of success. Got to love what you do, supply and demand, and if you won't buy it, most others won't either.

[@ogi22]

This clip shows it very clear how big difference does it make to start from a scratch and knowing nothing and how you perform when you watched someone doing that work (and document it) for some time. Comfort with tools, catching hints, knowing the process... It takes time and practice. He had his time watching, just needs a bit of time feeling how it's done. And it goes fast. Really good job. And i wish my first hammer would be as good :)

[@Freeman-Dl70]

I just acquired a forge. When I return home, my blacksmithing journey can finally begin. Nice hammer Jamie, my first will be an old sledge hammer, transformed into a rounding hammer.

[@clifbradley]

We get the Alec version 2.0 again? Yes

[@alecsteele8]

me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@dustiestspade339]

I think the way I learned to hole punch is continue on one side till the thinnest side cools faster then switch back and forth till it gives. Its fun when you get a nice and toasty biscuit in the sock

[@alecsteele8]

me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@blakemckee2304]

It's great to see videos like this where yall are actually forging we need to see Jamie make a maker's mark now.

[@MrMk1mexico]

After watching this channel for years, this would be one of the best videos. Simple, to the point and entertaining. Great work boys.

[@davidvalenzuela3144]

Absolutely love it when a trade is learned and passed on. Ggs both of you.

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@ericatkinson1217]

As a teacher, I completely understand the desire to just do it for the studnet. BUT YOU CAN'T! That is how people learn by doing and gentle guidance. Well Done Both of you.

[@heyimamaker]

Remember when Alec was making videos in a tiny dark workshop? How far he has come! Awesome work my friend!

[@nateolmsted22]

An interesting short would be a bunch of clips of hammer swings counting how many strikes it takes to forge a hammer or whatever. Oooor a challenge between to smiths where they "bid" how few of strikes it'll take to make something

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@frankierzucekjr]

I gotta say, this one was a lot of fun to watch. Seeing the precision and power behind Alecs strikes with that sledge was really impressive. Also Jamie I thought you did an awesome job and did very well for your first time. I'd love to have this opportunity to learn from Alec and work beside him. Very cool, well done guys. Great episode

[@EdwinWiles]

Loved this! I've missed your teaching videos, and this is a fantastic idea. Someone who has seen the whole process up close attempting to perform the creative task themselves. A great confidence builder for other new blacksmiths, that still ... drives home ... the point that sooner or later you need someone to help you. Even if they are gravitationally challenged. 😀

[@JohnDoe-fm8tr]

I love seeing you guys teach each other about your respective hobbies, like jamie shows you how to cave, you show him how to forge, so cute 💜

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉...

[@samtuttle4103]

Kudos on the editing, makes it a very entertaining watch

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@amelienabet1861]

Alec being so proud of Jamie is the cutest. Great job Jamie!!!

[@valentinmakes]

I like the videos with both of you, the interaction and dynamic is fun to watch.

[@alexthomson4720]

That’s amazing! Congratulations Jamie! Makes me want to learn to forge! Definitely looks more approachable 🎉

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉..

[@BraxxJuventa]

Thanks for filming Alec and Jamie. 👍😁

[@Neecola88]

Suggestion: It would be awesome if on the end of the video if you show hammer being used on hot metal, how it does, the balance some commentary would be nice :) Awesome job both of you this was very nice and friendly as any learning should be :)

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@timothymoore7890]

Jamie dropping things reminded me of the Alec Steele drinking game from the live stream days

[@MrJport1]

Really enjoyed this one. Jaime seemed a bit apprehensive initially, however, by the end he really made a nice looking piece. I enjoyed the format, teaching, but only hinting at the next step.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.....me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.....

[@JacobCanote]

You two are precious. A joy to see.

[@AvanaVana]

I like the way you’ve got Jamie in front of the camera for more than just bits. Though I like the bits too. Nice job, Jamie!

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.....

[@gilbertmckown6161]

This is a fun idea! Grab some who has only watch videos and hasn't forged at all and get them to forge stuff with no help whatsoever! You should do more of this it is so much fun.

[@alecsteele8]

me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉....

[@rider68-12]

Jamie needs to starting making those in the UK. He is quite good at that. It really looks good

[@glennbayley5863]

Congratulations Jamie brilliant job🎉 watching you and Alex make that rounding hammer ⚒️ you can understand why they cost so match 👍🇬🇧

[@Unabonger420]

I rather like watching Alec teaching. It's a wonderful side of him.

[@edwartschwarz7136]

This is the best of alac , i like the energy!

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@victor-antonioali378]

Thank you for making a video that's not a series. Yo your one of my top five KZbinrs, but if I gotta watch more than two episodes for the end result I'm not sticking around. Thanks for the shot stop. 👍🏼

[@MrTalictaiedala]

Nice one men! It speaks volumes about promoting from inside the business...

[@xxPenjoxx]

I bloody loved this episode! What a brilliant job Jamie did. 👏

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉...

[@Jordan-ws6jy]

This was a great video! Not surprised how well Jamie did though, not just because of being around and part of Alex's antics but Jamie is pretty on to it anyways.

[@alfiegoldsworthy7132]

I have to say, very impressed with Jamie's work, well done👏

[@jarrodsmith256]

LOVE this video! Always enjoy hearing the thought-process/problem-solving skills put to use.

[@danieldavis3761]

I think everyone, at some point in life questions why they chose the profession they work in. I think Jamie has discovered why he didn’t choose to be a blacksmith, but big props to him for going through that!

[@samfletcher93]

Another idea could be Jamie's blind trials. Jamie describes a project to Alec and sets a time limit. Alec creates and at the end, Jamie's drawing is revealed and Alecs finished article is compared to Jamie's drawing/ concept to see how closely it matches.

[@timosavelkouls4043]

Great video!! Would love to see Jamie make more !

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@daltonhaglund949]

It's free smithing lessons is what it is! Love your stuff! Good work, guys, and keep it up!

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.

[@savageriptide1294]

This is truly amazing! This makes me want to make my own,but I Sadler don’t have any forging equipment😢

[@savageriptide1294]

Sadly*

[@codybates2419]

This was a great video. Back to what got a lot of us introduced and interested in the channel.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@MackenzieForge]

It's always fun to see Jamie learning good techniques in tool making.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉.....

[@MediocreHexPeddler]

That's a fine hammer. I love the rough look on the side faces.

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉...

[@LuinTathren]

I love Alec and Will together, but Alec and Jamie is awesome!

[@itsjohannawren]

Definitely need more Jamie-making-things content.

[@MxEuphemia]

Great video guys! Have Jamie make an axe next?

[@thibni_]

I must admit Alec! Seeing you work alongside someone else REALLY brings out the energetic Alec from when I discovered you years ago. I missed him 🥰 It's wonderful to see you filled with excitement over working the metal again AND filming! 😅 Hihi! PS; Jamie! Great work on that Hammer buddy! 😁👌

[@thibni_]

Reported for fake account 🙄. Been a fan long enough to call this bullshit. Stupid people who try and scam others. Ugh. Keep up the good work, Alec! 👌

[@Drayvenblaze]

very well done. I'm surprised that Jamie didn't put his own touchmark on it.

[@JokerInk-CustomBuilds]

It is nice to see some of the onscreen cooperation between to guys doing projects. And allways fun to see ppl learning. Way to go jamie. You should make a nice display plate of wood and hang it at home. Beautiful and a good memory to have on the wall! -And it is one of those things your future guests would ask about and that would be a good conversation piece. :)

[@boskone]

See, now I want to see a video of Jaime doing Alec stuff, shot and edited by Alec.

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@theponkster]

Great job Jamie and Alec - most enjoyable to watch along.

[@leviathan7477]

I love how Alec can’t help but teach!

[@foxymady]

Hey.. Jamie should do from start to finish.. including the grinding, tempering and handle. 😁 Great job!

[@guffels]

good video idea, been loving the channel recently. There have been some really unique ideas yall have come up with.

[@granitesand78]

Dang man. That’s glorious. Nice job dude. I’d be so proud.

[@JonathanChute]

It would be interesting to have a bunch of these challenge series where Jamie makes random items and then Alec makes one on his own and then they are compared to see where Jamie could improve.

[@MichaelMaven83]

Your next project should be to make the Subtle Knife from His Dark Materials. In the TV Series they depict it as being 4 sided with 2 sides having a oil stain pattern (patina) and the other 2 being a high polished stainless steel

[@moletrap2640]

You guys worked very well together. Good idea for the video.

[@ThatGuy-ou4ev]

Hi Alec, here we are again. Just make and finish a freaking katar already.

[@murrayhayter9731]

Jamie is the best side kick I’ve seen so far🤙

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉

[@musicalcomputernerd6474]

Hey if Jamie can’t forge something without Alec’s help after editing all the videos Alec puts out, then none of us can. I feel like I’ve watched enough hours of Alec that I could be a blacksmith and I plan on doing it whenever I get my own place.

[@nickkowal6537]

Jamie's been learning from Alex with the dropping of the hot steel!

[@TheSponge77]

From one Jamie to another...well done sir...Next object to make...a torch...that would be magic😁

[@charlesroughton7306]

Since Jamie has now made his first hammer, he should come up with a touch mark to add!

[@alecsteele8]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉...

[@otterconnor942]

Blacksmithing with Jamie is a good idea

[@bretthildebrandt9250]

Great job Jamie. You have great teacher. On another subject. I have a challenge idea for you. I saw another guy forge a steel frying pan. So, I wondered what a damascus frying pan would look like ? Just a thought.

[@alecsteele8]

me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@codymccabe7157]

How about a series of videos of you making tools but how it’s changed since your first few videos. How your techniques have changed or stayed the same. Style changes. Etc.

[@Wayne1977]

Hey Alec, How about making some nice pans, Skillets & utensils for your new home? 👍

[@AndrewCartwright304]

DM me 👆👆👆 Thanks for watching and commenting I have got some rewards for you🎉🎉🎉......

[@smashallpots1428]

alec really is a great instructor

[@wilfredosantiago7143]

Jamie you need your own stamp 👍

[@jimcorbett3764]

Now Jamie just needs to get Alec behind the camera to make a full video!

[@TheRealWulfderay]

JAMIE! Well impressed! You need a maker's mark for your hammer!

[@joacimLiam]

Great idea! Please do more of these in the future