Can Earth Have Rings?

Hello and welcome to What Da Math!
In this video, we will talk about if Earth could ever have rings?
Patreon page:
www.patreon.com/user?u=231819...
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Other videos here: • Universe Sandbox 2
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath
The video introduction made by Daniel Bates
His KZbin channel with more of his work is here: / mroutrochannel
The new music theme made by Bogdan Bratis
Check out his work here: www.bratis.uk/

[@EpicRobotoMan]

Earth actually does have rings. Made of satellite debris.

[@cesarconcepcionjr.8770]

Ha ha.

[@Jana-ho9mu]

EpicRobotoMan Films bam, there you have it everyone

[@prasunpahari]

Right

[@eamonnsiocain6454]

EpicRobotoMan Films : LOL!

[@Enzi_Meteori_902]

Lol 😂

[@codykillir10]

The moon was having one heck of a party. 2:43

[@nelsonflores5674]

party overdoze

[@57xa29]

Lol u guys r do funny 😂

[@cosmicepic4288]

Hahaha yey it was hehehehehehe he he heehe

[@57xa29]

Oh no the moon had a party overdose and exploded

[@randomguy-jd8su]

lol

[@ElektrikPichuZ]

Seeing all the water on Earth drain completely was scary

[@gabichri]

Will happen in about 1 billion years.. :(

[@samsmith6370]

★ Cuddlepuff ★ don't worry, at 4:16 you can see a little bit of water just north of the islands... At least not all humans will die of dehydration. Yay...

[@THEARDUOUSMOTH]

the water did not drain it evaporated because of the Huge tidal Stresses that the moon/Dwarf planet caused

[@Swixels]

★ Cuddlepuff ★ i

[@BFDIfan-ef3pu]

★ Cuddlepuff

[@darksavage596]

2:44 The moon is having a party?

[@WeskerZombieWanker]

the rings on uranus look nice

[@thedeadliestrobloxia]

I haven't watched your videos in a while, and the new intro is bae.

[@AIDR999]

LOVE THE NEW INTRO!!!

[@vovacat1797]

Hey, Anton, is it possible that one day geostationary orbit becomes so overcrowded that it becomes a visible artificial ring? A thin one, at least?

[@hassanbeydoun7866]

god liked saturn so he put a ring on it

[@tizoro3]

Hassan Beydoun This is a stupid comment. Saturn isn't the only planet with rings

[@Aidancordell]

jacksepticeye reference

[@aaronparaiso9677]

God didn't like earth so he didn't put a ring around it and walked out centuries ago.

[@lasersummit7895]

This is totally WRONG,Saturn was NOT a single lady!

[@TGOM22]

Hassan Beydoun god like the earth mars jupiter saturn uranus neptune makemake haumea snd eris so he put some moons around them

[@CesareVesdani]

Yes. It is possible for the Earth to have rings if the Moon orbited too close to the Earth. If the Moon orbited too close to the Earth, that would trigger the Roche limit that would pull and stretch the Moon causing tidal effects inside it, and then the Earth strong gravitational pull would rip the Moon apart creating rings from the Moon's debris. This would create a ring system just like it did with Saturn. Saturn also had a moon that orbited too close to it and it got ripped apart by the Roche limit.

[@zool201975]

there could have eben a period that has seen this effect occur. the moon has been quite a bit closer billions of years ago. but unfortunately that also is more then enough time to remove any asteroid belts for being between two masses that are on cosmic terms not that different in size.

[@Mellowlyte]

Cesare Vesdani Wouldn't some of the fragments of the moon hit earth and wipe out life on a massive scale starting another time period after the quaternary

[@maroonmochi3426]

Cesare Vesdani But the sun will control our tidal forces considering the Moon isn't there. and Tidal forces will be as much larger than before

[@carnation7079]

In real life, it's probably impossible. Scientists have proved that the moon is slowly going away from Earth. But don't worry, it will probably escape Earth when we're dead.

[@aleksandarmitkoski9997]

That is an if, but the moon orbits far away so it is imposible

[@CollisionSkunk]

anton's channel is growing I'm soo proud

[@Mario-jl1el]

when the moon meets you're eye, like a big pizza pie, that's a morrrrrrrray. Then, an eel jumps out and he takes a bite at your snout! That's a morrrrrrrray!

[@terigonUSAS12]

LOL

[@demi172]

Mario do you know your in videogames

[@kendrabarber483]

Awesome What Da Math intro I love it use it for your new videos

[@sciblastofficial9833]

I love the new intro

[@sciblastofficial9833]

0:21

[@blacklotus3965]

Blow up the secret moon bases and make some rings to block the sun. Hell yeah.

[@Raptorman0205]

1:36 fucking RIP the Mediterranean Sea

[@ismaeljimenez6562]

Raptormann0205 that was the Caribbean

[@AndreiVlasov]

Very interesting! Thank you! What space simulator do you use in this video?

[@Nashtonatronics]

Many many of these rings, uhh. Already exited our solar...*awkward Silence*.

[@adamrussell7060]

Great Video! How long would it take the icy rings too melt? and how long would it take the rocky rings to dissipate?

[@thatguy716]

love the new intro

[@tranzitsinvancouver6745]

Love the new intro :D

[@theprolificnetwork4670]

Topic request: Can you run a model to see how the third gas giant got tossed out of the solar system and where it could possibly be since theres gravitational evidence out in the Kuiper belt.

[@shindinder]

youtube compression ruined the rings

[@cutinup99]

THANK YOU for pronouncing Uranus properly!!!!!!

[@lewisallrightsreserved7879]

The Earth already has plenty of rings around it, onion rings, phones ring, the ring of fire, Ringo (not a ring, but he sure likes them, ..."and Ringo was his name-O"), for Flat Earthers there is the ice ring, for Fat Earthers there are very large adjustable rings called belts and smaller ones which we eat to become a Fat Earther called donuts, ring tones, Ring Dings (much tastier than Yodels because of their round shape which is what you resemble when you eat too many), ring around the collar, bath tub rings, "The Ring" (film), Saturn's rings are usually at 30ish? p.s.i., I can't speak for any other car make, film projectors have rings with teeth called sprockets, and of course there is the asteroid belt which got ginormous from Jupiter eating too many Dingo sized and larger asteroids called meatballs when an ancient alien round table and their entourage from Saturn's moon Europa's underground ocean used to go bowling on Wednesday nights, also and always formerly known as Prince Spaghetti day and Boogie Knights.

[@scikclan5524]

Lewis Allrightsreserved wtf

[@cacher5841]

i smell wikipedia

[@ReniPlays_]

Lewis Allrightsreserved sorry, stop lieing, get out of here.

[@literallyartemis]

So could I assume it's entirely possible that the rings of various planets could have at one point been celestial bodies torn apart by the Roche limit? I might have that somewhat (or entirely) wrong, but it seems reasonable. EDIT: I asked this before watching the entire video.

[@cowcannon8883]

I Earth did have rings space travel would be more dangerous because tiny space rocks.

[@veganarchistcommunist3051]

cowcannon There's already a massive amount of junk out their that makes space travel dangerous. In the case of having rings, you could probably just fly around them.

[@ReniPlays_]

Sorry, but your a liar.

[@geraldstahlman7036]

Just a few more satellites and we will have bath tub ring!

[@SawyBawy]

I think I'm going to get this game now

[@nolongerinuse-vm7yp]

Haumea and rhea also has rings and Mars used to have a debris ring

[@Derek12783]

Anton: What happens if Pluto was were Earth was and terraform pluto

[@redfox-zj5mn]

he changed what DA math intro

[@yobel_i]

i think i like the older what da math? intro

[@vnmiranda]

But did Earth USED to have a ring? Also we have our own pearsonal asteroid that is about to make our rings meet 48 Doris

[@pumpkin8211]

i like the new intro

[@johncgibson4720]

Love it.

[@mirukimilky3216]

if human try to explode moon, it will.

[@Yeetnbone]

Nice new intro

[@ilikeutubeful]

Out of curiosity, Anton, do you think it's possible that the Earth Trojans at the Lagrange Points, as well as the occasional "second moon" that passes in our neighborhood, may be the remains of Proto-Earth's primordial ring system?

[@mrprofessordoctor303]

Not gonna lie those rings look stable

[@dezraq1984]

take us to alpha centauri and build a habitable earth like planet and see if it can exist there under the crazy gravitational conditions it would endure being part of a triple star system.

[@heal0152]

Earth probably already has very not visible rings made out of spaceship parts.

[@ReniPlays_]

@Kitty Kat first of all, theres no rings around earth, but theres human made objects orbiting earth. [First of all becuz of the youtube algorithm

[@fryhfryh]

Thank you for the video/ How's this program called?

[@fryhfryh]

And... does asteroids shards crashes themselves with another shards in planets with rings? the fact you mentioned the ISS made me thought what would we do if our planet had rings.. in that case we would've built something like ISS in a shard? (besides it could be dangerous travel to)

[@fryhfryh]

Thank you, do you know any similar program but more oriented to exploration and information? I remember that I used to play one many years ago, that one for example had the names of the craters in moon etc..

[@jonahobrien8211]

Mr. フライ Space engine?

[@madman026]

we had rings :) they was absorbed you breathe them in every day :) Earth probably did have temporary rings in the past after asteroid impacts or cometary flybys, but Earth doesn’t have rings today.

[@sulphuric_glue4468]

Funky new intro

[@sarandippity2645]

What if it were debris from other planets!I've often thought that our asteroid belt was actually old planes/planet that had been destroyed!..

[@renaibrown5587]

planes?

[@bigshrekhorner]

Renai Brown He/She means planets. He/She just spelled it wrong

[@adrigor4461]

9:55 you put Moon in geosync orbit :)

[@christmassnow3465]

How long would take for space junk from previous missions to clear?

[@ropegasus6458]

If im jupiter I will bring a asteroid & Earth Will crush the Asteroid & NOW EARTH HAS A RING ○

[@novagd7520]

Saturn's little cousin...

[@moodybarf7854]

What is the APP you are using?

[@thrakerzad5874]

we should build a second moon to confuse people

[@k4li365]

Idk, can it?

[@Edzhjus]

8:40 What if Theia had lifeforms before collision? 💫🙄

[@jairogers5876]

Only gas giants have rings around it. Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune.

[@coleemane7k]

Jai Rogers no my dad wife has a ring

[@dezraq1984]

our moon is so unnatural in comparison to other moons throughout the cosmos. I would'nt be suprised if a previous ancient earth civilization once existed on earth and mars and the moon was built in the perfect place and at the perfect size and distance it is to have the stabilizing effect that it does on earth.

[@numberjackfiutro7412]

There's no law of physics stopping terrestrial planets like Earth from having rings, in deed, Earth may have had rings in the distant past, but it probably went into making Luna, our moon. I don't think that rings would be very stable around a planet as close to a star like the sun as Earth or the other terrestrial planets in our solar system, at least, not stable long term. That said, it would be cool for Earth to have an orbital ring that makes space travel cheaper and easier, Issac Arthur has a video or two on such artificial rings.

[@cosmonaut6443]

If my computer can run kerbol space program do you think it could run this

[@gta5gamerv906]

Can we actually get a object big like ceres in our orbit...

[@sheungyinng4670]

Nice new intro,but I like the old one more

[@ichiroudesu_.]

Sheung Yin Ng I Agree because the old one seemed more simple and more "mathematic"

[@sheungyinng4670]

Lol

[@Jancias]

If universe is a simulation.. Does Universe Sandbox 2 is a simulator of a simulator?

[@michaelcavicchio5618]

Nice video👍🏻

[@castrator8057]

Why doesn't the Roche Limit affect artificial satellites around Earth or other planets? And more importantly why doesn't it affect things on the surface?

[@THEARDUOUSMOTH]

because artificial satellites are not made of the stuff that a small moon or an asteroid will be made from

[@soratsuki469]

Vaperisor because artificial satellites are held together by force, not mass

[@castrator8057]

The SpyCrap what force?

[@xavierrodriguez2463]

Gravitational Gradient a large object like the moon would have higher gravity on one side then the other so as It got closer the gradient would get larger and tear the moon apart. Artificial satellites are so small that the gravitational difference is not enough to tear it apart.

[@voideyegaming3115]

The Roche Limit will usually affect large objects, and perhaps the earth does not have a gravitational pull strong enough to tear smaller things apart.

[@Arvi79k]

Are near earth objects remaining pieces of earths rings?

[@jmm1233]

yes it can if made the moon into rings , the moon is the big vacuum cleaner

[@lunarguest]

Anton, can life exist in a red dwarf binary system?

[@NonoJpeg]

earth had rings before the moon (luna) was created

[@KazuBells]

What if all of the planets rotated clockwise like Venus or what if our sun rotated clockwise?

[@WildVke]

I thought they already decided that the Earth did have rings?

[@essakkymuthu9760]

it had rings

[@plir2128]

Anton Petrov says: Hello Wonderful person! viewer: murderer

[@kordellcurl7559]

What would happen if 2 asteroids crashed into each other in between earth and the moon; would that create rings

[@alamira.9635]

kordell curl I don't think so but that's a good question

[@Mernom]

Two asteroids crashing into each other is less likely then you winning the lottary 10 times in a row, especialy if it's outside of the asteroid belt.

[@gamercoolcraft4208]

No because it will create another moon and the size will be bigger except tiny rocks from the asteroids might hit earth or moon

[@theprolificnetwork4670]

I take this channel with a grain of salt

[@whatdamath]

Free Reign Network as you should everything in life

[@theprolificnetwork4670]

Anton Petrov Greetings my scientific Comrade: I love your topics but can I ask you to please take your time and think it through because it's so all over the place and science is very precise so is math. How about this, maybe start with the model simulation in play, see if it works and then after we watch it not work explain why instead of jumping all over the place starting stopping and stuff because watching the model work or falter is going to create questions that the viewer wants to be answered and that's your opportunity instead of creating an idea interrupting yourself and the model as it's in process. What software is that because it's fascinating Id be awesome if Neil DeGrasse Tyson had the same idea or even Carl Sagan himself because I'm really interested in your Concepts but it's just like you're playing too much so that's why I have to take it with a grain of salt. Planets in each other's orbits because they clear their orbit and that's why orbits can't be stable and planets orbit each other Titan is like an exception to the rule and look at Triton.

[@ufodeath]

Any planet worth its mass can have rings!!

[@SkiesAboveTravel1080]

THOSE ARE SATURN RINGS , EARTH RINGS CAN ONLY LOOK LIKE URAUS OR NEPTUNE!!!! THIS IS A RARE VIDEO !!!!

[@aljuvialle]

@Anton, What's about our own junk we throw into space every year? How this junk is affect to the science?

[@theevildrdeez]

With this being tested, almost wonder what would happen if we sent allot of satellites, to spread a curtain like veil to cool down Venus with micro eclipses, or what would happen if Venus had a moon?

[@carlramirez35]

How come, say, Saturn's rings have very little eccentricity, and are all in practically the same plane?

[@TPerm-hj4sf]

Well anton the rings are still stable

[@swaspwasp8487]

can you do a video where you put ALL 80 moons around every planet(so every planet would have IO and every other moon)

[@mrjayjay124]

What is the intro song?

[@NetLockGaming]

Is it me or did the explosion animation change?

[@jonahobrien8211]

CARS_PLAYS_MC It did, they updated the game recently

[@zivo4652]

Yes

[@Orion12113]

I understand that the moon would rip the rings apart but what if the moon turned into the rings and was ripped apart.

[@arcanegianterinokripperino9945]

its not impossible even with all planets... you just have to make everything perfect and it would be working

[@YTRulesFromNM]

Uranus has dark rings?

[@BoltonBolt]

your intro is cool!!!😀

[@tomcat2687]

were did you get that

[@Sky-lm2no]

Yes, our planet has rings of satellites

[@ReniPlays_]

Sky Emerald, Sorry, But never lie ever again.

[@ricardothomsen8408]

because earth was never married.... luck him

[@everetteparks4624]

Not sure if you have any questions

[@chanimetron3948]

thr is another way to form rings bcuz of roche limit.

[@malcolmhardwick4258]

How come the moon did not fall apart when it was closer to Earth in its formation ?

[@6Fiona6_P_6]

The reason? It's because you can't run rings around our planet. It's so awesome, it doesn't need them. Take that Saturn... ⚛️

[@TheYellowFlyingFish]

Why would the icy rings evaporate/melt, isn't it really cold (well below 0) in that region?

[@arcanegianterinokripperino9945]

in space you can find no temperature, if you place an object in space, this object has temperature, but not space itself Ice in the inner solar system (mercury to mars) is impossible due to the sun heating the ice or other stuff (dirt/rock) near the ice up, thats why there are gasgiants (Jupiter Saturn Uranus Neptune) in the outer solar system, because there even IF the sun light reaches the surface, the average temperature for the surface is -240 if not lower, because the sun light is just too weak to heat anything up

[@togrulhuseynli7600]

Anton! Y no space engine???

[@ryancarrethers2504]

Maybe 🌎 has rings

[@everetteparks4624]

i not sure if you have any questions

[@WMPotomacfan27]

Intro song?

[@voxie247]

Hello Anton

[@spiderdijo7]

If Jesus liked it he should have put a ring on it