Can we keep dogs at home in islam Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem

[@user-kc6ni3fk6w]

This is why I made a promise to myself to help animal shelters take care of dogs that can't have homes because I know as a Muslim I won't be able to give a dog the life of a cat and that saddened me so I said I'll take care of their well-being instead. More than one pup will be taken care of for the sake of Allah with food, warm blankets and whatever else animal shelters need. Being Muslim means being soft not hard at heart

[@einstein3448]

Don't keep Chuwawa it can be eaten by cat. ~me

[@SomethingaboutScreens]

🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂

[@abulkalam2671]

🤣😅🤣

[@KarungiSheillah]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@maryamm28]

chihuahua*

[@ClipCoyote]

This animal unlike any other is renown for its loyalty to its keeper, will readily sacrifice its life to protect the safety and honor of that keeper, protects the home, your children, and your livestock. They are a blessing from God and nothing less. Showing kindness to an animal is an act of charity. In my eyes this balances out every time you feed your dog. As much as I respect Islam i know in my heart dogs are a gift from God, and with a goid one protecting you, your angel can rest easy.

[@geertwilders3675]

Do what Allah and his prophet say dont follow ur feelings that will destroy you, whatever they say we accept it, case closed done!!!

[@RealDawg0]

​@@geertwilders3675 sure, blindly accept everything in the hadith, even though there's no proof that they are the words of prophet Muhammad

[@eriklarson4082]

God of Islam is a false god.

[@roxanne2749]

​@@RealDawg0 Their are good evidence to support they are from Prophet Muhammad. But, anyways kinds of you are hopeless anyways.

[@famepearsonpinadancy]

every dog is a guard dog once they are family its in its nature to protect its master

[@allgood6760]

I agree 🐕

[@haysnairte4]

Meanwhile Golden Retriever : every human is a friend

[@Hamzah.315]

There are verses in the Quran that mention the dog/dogs. I can search for them and send here.

[@famepearsonpinadancy]

@@Hamzah.315 Muhammad pbuh himself prayed in the presence of dogs and many of his cousins and companions, who were the first Muslims, owned dogs; the Mosque of the Prophet in Medina allowed dogs to frolic about in Muhammad's time and for several centuries afterwards.

[@famepearsonpinadancy]

@@Hamzah.315 also dogs are one of the animals stated to be able to see jinn and spirits

[@aji7393]

This hurts me a lot, my dog is the sweetest creation I’ve ever came across. Doesn’t judge, loves us unconditionally. Wish my religion didn’t prohibit them 😫

[@solarman6648]

Islam is only for those who use common sense. You can have a dog, just maintain its hygiene as you do yours. Please don't make Islam look more weird and intolerant than it already is. Ameen. salaam.

[@TheTruth51517]

Quran does not prohibit keeping dogs at all. Rest easy knowing you are doing no wrong by keeping a dog as a pet. Quran is the only source of guidance and not hadeeth. Don’t listen to these ignorant mufti’s who play god; it is not for them to decide whether keeping a dog as a pet is haraam or not. Follow the Quran only and most of your anxieties related to our religion will be solved. Peace

[@WeirdBulldog]

None of this is true, stop listening to this dogs are prohibited crap and use common sense. Back then during the days of prophet Muhammad dogs weren't vaccinated and clean like they are today, they use to live in the the wiled or outside (they didn't have streets, so can't really say they lived in the street but you get the idea) they were looked down upon by our Muslim brothers as wild dirty and dangerous creatures and probably said to stay away from them to their children and families. Now with the cures we have and the vaccines they are completely normal.

[@shogun4637]

@@TheTruth51517 Brother its true quran is our ultimate guidance but not full on it's own. Quran shows us the bigger picture while the hadeeth fills in the smaller details. One cannot only follow the quran and leave the hadiths behind and vice versa. For example we are told in the quran that there are prayers. But not how to pray them. Withouth the hadith we wouldnt know how to pray. Therefore the hadith are just as important as the quran. Also Allah tells us to follow his words and his prophet(which is largely written in the hadiths). You cannot simply deny the hadiths importance for our religion. Have a good day

[@Contenthouseyt]

@@TheTruth51517 Astaghfiroullah, Allah in the Quran says obey me and obey the prophet Quran 64:8 , how do you know how to obey the prophet, how do you pray? How do you make abolution, it’s all in the Hadith wal3iyadou billah

[@geoffgoodall3839]

Thankfully i am a Christian and not subject to loosing points as far as Allah and his servants are concerned. I give thanks to God for all of creation.oneof those are our k9 freinds.They show pure unadulterated love for us,a loyalty beyond measure.when Muslim ideology compares you to a dog or an infidel stand proud and thank them because the love of a dog is a blessed thing

[@ADNANIITH]

I am handicapped i will adopt dog because i love traveling but also travelling alone is danger specially in India so i hope my rab does not decrease my good deeds

[@mehmetozatt9672]

Dogs have served humans for the last 30,000 years. There is no other animal with the loyalty and devotion to humans that dogs have. Their faithfulness and loyalty is an example even to humans. They save human lives in the military and police, they lay down their lives as search and rescue dogs, the make life bearable for countless blind and disabled people. We owe dogs an immense gratitude that we can never repay. It’s time to start treating them with compassion after all they have given us.

[@edgarmoule9825]

Yeah but we like dogs mainly for there personality, so what's gonna replace that?

[@bionquinn]

@@DeathDeliveryGuy no they aren't, horses would be terrible guide animals for the blind or support animals for the elderly. They don't smell well enough to find a missing person.

[@User80066]

You don't know more than Allah.

[@drnoorulain704]

Who asked you not to show compassion. Even if it's forbidden to keep them inside home. There are so many ahadith about caring for animals and being kind to them.

[@dr.doomofficial]

“If a man loves a dog, he is a good man. If a dog loves a man, he is a good man.”

[@AhmedMohamed-ml3kb]

This doesn’t make sense you are saying the the first sentence that the dog is a good man

[@dr.doomofficial]

@@AhmedMohamed-ml3kb Now ?

[@momi7461]

Jinko samajh nahi Aai Woh Pataal Lok Season dekhy

[@Brhamabull]

@@momi7461 Ab isko samajne ke liye hum ek poora season dekhe ? iss comment section tk aa gye . ..isse zayda velle nhi hum .

[@a4ya294]

@@AhmedMohamed-ml3kb bro u failed in English

[@theckra19]

I am always doing good things for people, but I do have a Maltipoo that lives inside my home. I love her very much. She protects me everywhere I go, including outside. Allah knows best and may I be forgiven for loving her so much and allowing her inside my home.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@badolgiringya5035]

This whole comment section is filled with brothers from Canada and America where they are trying to change Islam using liberalism. Islam is perfected so no matter how you try you CAN NOT **keep a dog inside the home The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Angels do not enter a house that has either a dog or a picture in it." (Sahih al-Bukhari 3322) and **keep a dog reasons other than hunting, guarding and security. Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "If someone keeps a dog neither for guarding livestock, nor for hunting, his good deeds will decrease (in reward) by two Qirats a day.' (Sahih al-Bukhari 5482) may ALLAH SWT guide us all

[@badolgiringya5035]

@soniasarwar7031 no you cant. But you can keep it in the out house for safety purposes or hunting.

[@AhmedHabiib-v8h]

Your wrong ​@@badolgiringya5035

[@savagebubbles5544]

Shihtzu are also good watch dogs. A friend of mine had a shihtzu and he made him a room outside his house and the dog always alarms them whenever a stranger came.

[@fai3379]

😍😍

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@almightybirdwatcher4986]

@@eliasziad7864very well said brother. Mashallah. You’re a bright individual. The Pakistanis repeatedly try to corrupt the name of our beliefs! With their creations and belief of books fabricated by man!

[@Bbarfo]

"The more I learn about people, the more I like my dog." Mark Twain.

[@Radec913]

Cringe. Prophet Mohammed peace and blessings on him >>>>> mark twain and a million dogs

[@sameerdev618]

@@Radec913 Then why Allah blessed the Seven sleepers and their Dog for accompanying the pious men?

[@YaseenAl-Gharabally]

​@sameerdev618 It was a guard dog. They didn't keep it in their home. They brought it to a cave, which is a public place.

[@dominikthespook]

@@Radec913 Imagine being so brainwashed by your fairy tale that you put the life of some desert ped***le above the life of a great artist and millions of innocent beings.

[@user-kc6ni3fk6w]

​@@Radec913you saying cringe and being harsh at heart isn't what Muslims do. Change your character

[@kallebyn8548]

Ooooohhhh I love this guy, already know the answer before clicking

[@absbi0000]

He's great! May Allah reward the Sheikh.

[@RIPer-rg2cz]

@@absbi0000 he was being sarcastic

[@sobanfarooq8288]

Why are you clicking then ?

[@thischhh971]

So you want him to change teachings as you like?😂 Everything is defined for a reason whether you see it or not

[@aboubakarb7906]

I’m a Muslim brother, I would love to adopt a Doberman. Very protective and smart breed. I work night shift at a hospital and I know this dog would be a good protector.

[@pluto3747]

For *legitimate* security reasons you can keep a dog

[@AA-iy4gm]

Only outside due to their saliva and other liquids, they lick and rub everything, and whatever they lick you have to wash 7 times, no amount of cleaning can keep up with amount of dirt a dog brings inside.

[@سفخصعليك]

You don't get a guard dog unless you live in a extremely dangerously neighborhood and crimes happen daily in it.

[@EvolutionMachinetoMan]

​@@pluto3747lol allah didn't say that😂

[@pluto3747]

@@EvolutionMachinetoMan the hell do you know little one

[@tariq2835]

I have a question what the dog must come in the house? Like a seeing a eye dog or a dog that assist the elderly. Also in many protection scenarios it’s necessary for the dog to have a way in the home to defend and ward off danger.

[@djevanoasikan2778]

I think that if you keep a dog for a legitimate purpose it is permissable but when keeping a dog just for the mere purpose of keeping and loving a dog

[@fayak911]

So what u mean, u can keep dogs as gaurds but not pets? Than how do u show them love and affection.? Dogs are outside however they must be loved and cared for if we need them to gaurd the homes as well.

[@luluah1198]

Keeping dogs in the home is Only a western thing, I’d argue primarily in the UK and USA . Now ppl are copying this behaviour . But it’s the norm to have a dog house and keep the dog outside in almost every other part of the world . When I was a very young child even in the uk it was normal to see dog kennels in neighbours gardens . Now apparently it’s “cruel”? My current neighbours are polish and they have a huge kennel, I believe they constructed it themselves not these commercial ones that are too small. This is clearly normal in their country so they’re doing so in the uk too. The dog doesn’t need to be Living in the home for you to interact with it and show it love and do obedience training

[@fai3379]

Havig a dog is means you have to give them food,hey foolish you think domestic dog search food from everwhere it is better to keep it as a stray dog,other things it must be vaccinated, And other things is dogs love his master ,although you dont love them,but cat s dont love although you love

[@fayak911]

@@fai3379 our country, we dont let them get food alone.they gaurd our homes, so its a duty to give them care, and food. Not let them find there own.

[@sdsfgsty]

I don't know about the hadith in this regard. But humans have owned a lot of animals for food and work for a long time. The story of " the Companions of the Cave" in the holy Quran highlights the friendship between man and dog.

[@lightshadernft8156]

@@sdsfgsty my bro you don't know the clear meanings

[@all-caps3927]

My grand parents have a dog, but they never ever let it inside the house and they are elderly living in America and gun violence there is an issue so I think the keeping of their dog is permissible

[@all-caps3927]

@Maryam Ali it is ok to keep the dog outside the house, but you shouldn’t own a dog for the wrong reasons : don’t own a dog for fun, own a dog if it helps mental health and well-being, own one for defence, but for no other reasons. If you own a dog for the right reasons then never ever touch it’s mouth or saliva as it is very unhygienic, never let it inside the house and always wash your hands after touching it

[@anandmishra2925]

Ha ha this means you are denying the authority of prophet muhammad you are denying prophet muhammad.

[@all-caps3927]

@@anandmishra2925 I’m not denying prophet Muhammed PBUH, making such assumptions is haram, they own it for the right reasons not because he’s a fluffy pet; they do everything to keep him out of the house and he never enters

[@Amexella]

@@anandmishra2925 saying that is haram and that is haram is a sin, please quickly repent to Allah swt

[@rahul21stcentury]

@@Amexella Angels dont enter a house which has a dog or a painting

[@bismahaider1504]

Well about this i think we should ask Allah because he knows better about everyones niyat so i think when i talk to Allah i feel a spark in myheart like Allah is listening to me and understanding me and i think asking Allah for permission to keep a dog is best that’s what I think because whenever i talk to Allah i feel like he answers my every question so if you think i am wrong you can tell me☺️

[@shaikfarah8061]

Thank u for telling this. I also want to have a dog so i will do the same ...will ask Allah to permit me and i believe that Allah is merciful so he will accept my prayer

[@bismahaider1504]

@@shaikfarah8061 yes indeed he is merciful and I fell like he will understand us maybe

[@auroobajaved]

Wow MashAllah brother so now u will ask Allah for disobeying Allah's command 😂 Now u will use Allah's mercy to disobey him MashAllah brother 😂

[@bismahaider1504]

And about mercy matter he gives mercy to whoever he wants no matter how much bad sinner he is

[@auroobajaved]

But bro u r not asking Allah's mercy for forgiving a sin instead u r asking for mercy for doing a sin and there's a huge difference in that so kindly dont do this May Allah give us hidayat 🥲

[@mali5591]

Al-salamu ‘alaykum and Ramadan Mubarak for you and your family and loved ones. I pray that Allah bestows upon you the gift of peace, balance and beauty, and that God guides you to the righteous path. Thank you for your message and inquiry. You asked specifically about the hadith attributed to the Prophet that angels will not enter a place or an abode where may exist. The report to which you refer typically states that angels will not enter a dwelling that has dogs or pictures. In most versions, the narration of the report is attributed to Abu Huraira, with a few versions attributed to others. I thought I should respond to your message because of the opportunity to address this specific narration. There are several important points to make here: 1) All the versions of this report claim that angels will not enter a dwelling that contains dogs or pictures. By the terms of this report, it would follow that angels would not enter a place that has passport pictures, or drivers’ licenses or any document that has a picture. This is blatantly unreasonable and this constitutes a serious substantive problem with this narration; 2) This report is rather inconsistent with the Qur’anic narrative on dogs, in which we are told in the chapter on the people of the cave that they were a particularly pious group of people and the subject of a great miracle and blessing from Allah. And yet, the Qur’an is careful to point out that the people of the cave were accompanied by a dog, and that both humans and the dog were the subject of God’s miracle and grace. It would be rather incongruous to claim that angels did not accompany the people of the cave because they had a dog, or at the very minimum, it would be extremely speculative to pretend that a blessed and pious people mentioned in the Qur’an were denied the presence of angels because of their dog; 3) More importantly, this hadith makes a claim as to a matter of ‘aqidah (an article of faith) because it addresses a question involving the absence or presence of angels who are in the world of ghayb (or the unseen). Yet this hadith was categorized by all scholars of hadith to address a question of adab (a question of etiquette or proper social conduct). A hadith that could be considered credible enough to inform a question involving adab cannot be considered effective in matters involving ‘aqidah. Put differently, adab hadith or hadith that arise from the category of social etiquette are too low on the totem pole of authenticity and weight and thus, cannot be counted as effective or of sufficient weight to affect a question that involves faith. Hadith that establish articles of faith or ‘aqidah are typically mutawatir (of cumulative transmission) and therefore, of high authenticity, while hadith of adab, such as the one in question, are typically ahad (of singular transmission) and of much lower authenticity. To believe the angels enter or abstain from entering any particular place is a very serious matter and can only be established or negated by either the Qur’an or hadith of the highest level of authenticity. Hadith of singular transmission, such as the one in question, cannot either affirm or deny a matter involving the celestial world of angels and the like; 4) It must be recognized then that when a hadith of singular transmission is declared to be sahih (or authentic) in Bukhari or Muslim or the other collections of hadith, all that means is that in the opinion of Bukhari or Muslim, there is a 51% chance, ie. a simple probability that the Prophet actually said what is attributed to him. A 51% chance is insufficient to affirm or deny matters of faith (‘aqidah), such as where angels dwell or do not dwell. What militates against this hadith is that many of the hadith that are demeaning to dogs or anti-pictures or anti-women have been attributed to Abu Huraira. Whether Abu Huraira narrated these hadiths or not is a very big question. But in all cases, scholars of usul (jurisprudence) know that this typology of hadith, ie. hadith involving pictures, women or dogs, and prayer, angels or purity, are suspect, which means that one cannot just simply quote them as if they establish a truth or a fact, or as if they are indicative of Allah’s will without careful analysis and reflection; 5) As I have stated elsewhere, historically, dogs were an important symbolic issue in the past. On the one hand, they represented loyalty, faithfulness and companionship, but on the other, dogs were a source of a vicious plague, ie. rabies, and were also used by despotic forces to hunt down and torture political dissenters and accused heretics. So, we know for instance that not just in the Islamic world but in the medieval world generally, dogs inspired wonderful literary works, but at the same time, figured prominently in literature as a source of illness, death and torment. In the Roman world and the Umayyad and Abbasid dynasties, political dissenters, after being executed, had their corpses hung with the corpse of a poor murdered dog. The reason the corpse of a dog was hung with the corpse of a political dissenter was that it was a way of insulting the corpse and claiming power and dominance over the tribe, family or clan of the dissenter. Interestingly, one of the major tribes that first supported the Umayyads and then later rebelled against them and supported the Abbasids were known as the tribe of Kelb (dog). My point here is that dogs featured symbolically in politics and social narratives. So, when we have a narration in which it is claimed that Abu Huraira claimed to have heard the Prophet say that angels will not enter a place that has dogs or pictures, we have an affirmative duty to inquire into the historical circumstance that might have put such a report into circulation. Interestingly, although medieval scholars were aware of the existence of this hadith, it was never relied upon in discourses on theology and faith until the modern age. This is largely the influence of the Wahhabi school, which does not draw a distinction between hadith of singular transmission versus hadith of cumulative transmission and similarly, does not differentiate between the strength of a hadith’s authenticity and its impact in questions of faith or otherwise; 6) It is a true tragedy that contemporary Muslims continue to rely on palpably unreasonable hadith such as the one in question. Quite simply, we should ask, why would angels not enter a place that has dogs? What singles out dogs as opposed to cockroaches, flies or mice? It is unquestioned in even the most conservative or Wahhabi schools that Muslims may own dogs for protection or hunting. So, are we to believe that angels will stay away from places simply because they have a guard dog on duty or because there is a hunting dog under a roof? Even the most Wahhabi of scholars have not dared to claim that angels will not enter a place that has a picture of the King or other members of the Royal Family. But yet, by the terms of this hadith, angels would have abandoned the entire earth because our earth is full of pictures everywhere, most obviously on the Internet on every personal computer. Are we to believe that because pictures on Facebook and selfies are zipping through the electronic atmosphere that angels will abandon Earth? 7) As I am sure you know, dogs are among God’s wonderful and beautiful creatures. We are taught that a prostitute was forgiven her sins because she saved the life of a dog, and we are taught that the people of the cave were selected by God for a great miracle, although as the Qur’an points out, they were in the company of a faithful and loving dog. What in these amazing and beautiful creatures would cause angels such aversion and disgust that they would stay away from a space that they occupy? I wish Muslims would use their intellects and hearts before they slander and vilify a great religion such as Islam, which is the truth that comes to us from God containing everything full of mercy, compassion and beauty. I am sure you agree that it does not sound merciful, compassionate or beautiful to claim that angels abandon a place where God’s creatures dwell, even if that creature is a mouse, a rat or a fly. It is my sincere belief that the reasons for this narrative are found in the creative symbolisms of history and in the political conflicts of the past (the same thing with many of the patriarchal hadith demeaning to women). And it is also my sincere belief that the Prophet (may peace and blessings be upon him) never uttered this hadith. I say this ever mindful that Allah knows best. Please ask God to forgive me my trespasses and bless us all. Wa al-salamu ‘alaykum, Shaykh Abou El Fadl

[@AlhamdulillahiRabbalalameen]

JazakAllahu khayrun sheikh. BarakAllahu feekum. Allahumma Ameen ya Rabb’Al Al’Ameen

[@anandmishra2925]

Ha ha now you are denying the authenticity of sahih hadith. And still you claim yourself Muslim. Only hadith contain information of prophet muhammad. So you are denying sunnah.

[@alijoon3266]

Well said

[@jamalraja9157]

Salamalakum brother. That's great you listed so many reasons for why dogs are great etc., but what's the real reason you're doing so? Is it to pander to the West and claim that Muslims are tolerant of dogs? One thing you did get right was that dogs were in fact the source of a great plague known as rabies and they do in fact need vaccinations to prevent the spread of these diseases till this very day. Aggressive breeds such as pitbulls are also the source of many serious injuries and even death among mail carriers and children. Dogs also have no hygiene, they shed fur, and drool their saliva everywhere. My uncle owns a German Shepard and his yard is literally a shit mine, and you have to watch your step every time you go to his house. Dogs are utterly disgusting creatures and most breeds don't even come from nature, but rather they're mutations.

[@TheTruth51517]

@@jamalraja9157 they say there is no cure for ignorance and you are as ignorant as they come..

[@rainerwinkler8635]

What if you have psychological problems and the dogs helps you in getting better?

[@osmananwar9365]

I think yes and obviously yes as well if you need to help for blind and can be a guide dog

[@mohdafzaldar1295]

Get a cat😁😁

[@poopbutt6241]

@@mohdafzaldar1295 cats are useless though

[@Wcnd]

Bist du Muslim ? Meddl off

[@rainerwinkler8635]

@@Wcnd Ich glaube an die Macht des Meddls

[@mehmetozatt9672]

This prejudice against dogs is responsible for a huge amount of animal suffering. Throughout Muslim countries dogs are abandoned on the street, poisoned and beaten by locals. This is all due to these hadiths and people thinking dogs are dirty and can’t live in homes. This thinking is wrong and unscientific. We now have vaccines and medications to protect against harmful diseases, and dogs can live safely within our homes. We need to change our thinking and be more compassionate towards these amazing animals who have served humans for thousands of years

[@LightPr1nce]

am pretty sure you should be getting good deeds for taking care of a animal

[@zaystarrrr]

Allah is enough to take care of an animal 🤣

[@shaam_arafath]

@@zaystarrrr a prostitute gave water to a dog and gates to heaven was opened for her and all her sins were forgiven . This is a hadeeth . Allah has given man free will . The will to do good deeds .

[@Djdfjjfnfnrjnfnf]

Yes it is but you cannot keep it inside the house

[@mohamadhakimkamaruddin1503]

If we thoroughly think about it...most of us have pets because we like them..thats why the pets doesn't cost cheap....we brag on breeds,cuteness etc, sometime because we r lonely..some really really love them..whole heartedly...lets really look into the intention...if we truly care for the animal...why dont just take care of it? All animals r cute...its a pure soul...even flies...islam doesnt tell u to treat haram animal like pig n dogs badly...why should we...we r forbid to ate pork...and to keep em as pet...thats it..if we work at a shelter taking care of these dogs..is it haram?? No u don't...but when their saliva or poops or urine touches u..u need to clean it properly as per islam guidance...but strictly, u can't have them as pet....next to my house got 20 stary dogs that me n my mother used to fed everyday n everytime..not just leftover...we cooked it for them...i even named some of them..are they my pets?..later...a neighbour came n poisoned them...he is not muslim..how do i know...the uncle came to me n proudly told me that he poisoned them....he said he do it for me..because the dog have been barking next to my house and saying that you muslim people dont like dog right......the f??? .bad assumption though..he even saw me feeding the dogs.n he had a dog..a short leg dog name mikey....so tell me...is the intention of having dogs as pet is pure as it is mentioned everywhere here? I dont know about that...up to you guys to think about it...i love dogs...doesnt mean i keep em as pets...i just be nice to them..as to all other animal...some even scared the shit out of me...so be respectful my friend..n furthermore when u kept them as pets...u locked them...u caged them..some would beat them...some even left them to die in a hot locked car without ventilation...so truly....how noble of these people who owned a pets to be taken as animal lover...if owning a pet doesnt reflect u as an animal lover...than what r u? Thats why i said...just as above...which is...eh.......

[@ejasahammed1681]

Buying a cat or dog is prohibited in islam

[@yasminejasmine4368]

So if I have land in a western country can I keep a dog outside but make his own house separate from our family home and not let him inside? He would be for security for us and the property

[@samali4327]

Yes

[@Lonystal]

yes you can keep the dog that way. In fact it's hasanat for you to aid and shelter, and be kind to animals. They're the creation of Allah aswell. Just don't keep the dog inside your house.

[@AlmaPerdida0.3]

I can’t even think about having a dog and can’t keep it with me where I stay 😢 I love dog and can’t imagine to have one like this 😢

[@JahannamHellfire]

We are all tired of what we see in the news every day; war in Syria and Yemen, genocide in Myanmar, occupation in Palestine, famine in Somalia - to name just a few. It is both mentally draining and depressing to see the current state of the Ummah. One might naturally feel somewhat helpless and wonder why it has come to this. Whilst we in the West live in relative peace and security, we all feel the pain of our brothers and sisters around the world. Of course, given how much we are shown in the news, many have become desensitised to many of these issues, and only awaken when a new or big incident occurs, over and above the day-to-day suffering and “normal” levels of injustice or violence. Our usual reaction of anger and sadness often ends with a shrug of the shoulders, blaming our corrupt leadership and intending to make duʿā’ for those suffering or to make a donation. Or perhaps that level of anger might last slightly longer so much so that we attend a few protests and write to our local MPs to make our views heard, before slowly but surely getting back to normality. Life must go on, and we can only do so much after all. In a famous ḥadīth, the Prophet (sall Allāhu ʿalayhi wa sallam) said: “The parable of the believers in their affection, mercy, and compassion for each other is that of a body. When any limb aches, the whole body reacts with sleeplessness and fever.”[1] These days our limbs are far beyond aching, yet the fortunate amongst us can only sustain the mentioned sleeplessness and fever for the shortest period of time. What then can we really do to make a difference?  Duʿā’, sadaqah, protests and writing to our local MPs should not be belittled; these are all important steps to take. In fact, some of these may be amongst the most effective and powerful tools at our disposal. But by taking a step back and looking at the bigger picture, we see that Muslim lands are largely weak and divided, and many are run by corrupt rulers seeking to secure their own power-base rather than establish justice. Thus, though sending money to those in need may help deal with some of their immediate concerns, we should wonder what difference we can make to the fix the larger problem at hand. With a bit of self-reflection, we might even find that instead of pointing the finger at our leadership, it should be ourselves we look at and blame! How so? Imagine a world in which the vast majority of Muslims practiced the very basics of the religion; ensuring their five daily obligatory prayers were maintained; the obligatory fasts and charity upheld; and major sins avoided. Imagine an Ummah whose members, seeking self-improvement, continuously looked at their own shortcomings, instead of dwelling on that of others, or on differences of opinion. Is it feasible that such a nation would suffer as it is does today? Absolutely not. Reflecting on the ḥadīth mentioned above, surely a sound and healthy body would overcome any aching limbs with ease. However if the body is neglected, it is only natural that more and more ailments will arise. We need to each realise that every single sin we commit as individuals adds to the wider problem; harming the figurative body in the ḥadīth. Every time one of us neglects an obligatory act, that in itself is likely to have a direct impact on the Ummah as a whole, because when all of these are added up, what are we left with? The answer is a nation collectively living in disobedience to the Creator, and hence deserving of the leadership we face today. Thus it is imperative that we, immediately and without procrastination, work on rectifying our own relationships with Allāh and improving ourselves, in order to safely expect the dramatic turnaround we all desire in the Ummah. Our leaders are only a product of the societies they come from; if we want just rulers, let us strive to be just ourselves. And the ultimate justice is being dutiful to Allāh, and living according to how He decreed we should live. Allāh says in the Qur’ān: “Indeed, Allāh will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves.”[2] If we are truly sincere in our desire to help our brothers and sisters in need around the world and see the status of the Ummah rise, we must take heed of Allah’s words and realise that we, as individuals, are very much part of the problem and can be very much part of the solution. Whatever our level of religious practice is, we all have faults and all need to work on ourselves. Striving to rectify our situations, or jihād, comes in many forms but begins with the basics of praying 5 times a day and abstaining from major sin, such as consuming alcohol, earning interest, back-biting, etc. Every time we are faced with a decision about whether to commit a particular act and we know it is displeasing to Allāh, let us remember that we are not only harming our own Hereafter, but also adding to the suffering of others in this world. Perhaps one may be comfortable being heedless over their own affairs, but will at least think twice when it comes to others and that which they see with their own eyes today. Amongst the simple acts we can do, and should all do, for our sakes and for the betterment of the Ummah are: • Maintain the obligatory acts (prayer, fasting, zakāh). • Abstain from all sins - major or “minor”, nothing displeasing to Allāh should be overlooked. • Rectify intentions; perform acts to please Allāh alone. • Work together, overlooking differences and coming together for greater good. Progress will not occur whilst we spend our time arguing and refuting each other over the secondary matters, whilst genocide and occupation is on-going against the Ummah. • Increase in time with the Qur’ān, in its recitation and reflection. • Constant duʿā’ for the betterment of all of our brothers and sisters, in this life and the next. • Leave that which does not concern us; think of the reality of the Day of Judgement when we will only worry about own scale of deeds, and thus look introspectively instead of judging others. I ask Allāh to protect us all from oppression; from being subject to it or from contributing towards it by our own shortcomings. Amīn.

[@imawake4532]

MashaAllah tabarack Allah, Jazackee Allah Kheer. I share your feelings, frustrations and heartache exactly! Our Ummah is suffering as our so called Muslim leaders turn their backs. It is up to each individual. We must speak up and speak out, and your words express this perfectly.

[@ld6607]

Sir. What about keeping dog in front of main gate? A bit far from house entrance.

[@shafuimcoming5151]

maybe ok

[@orchidalk7748]

Outside it’s fine

[@Rudeus_Greyrat.]

It outside. totally fine.

[@orcckaa]

Fine

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@bismahaider1504]

Being muslim is the best thing Allah gave me in my life

[@darshans926]

Damn the disrespect to ur parents 😭

[@bismahaider1504]

@@darshans926 it is the thing all Muslims are proud of if you can't respect any religion then don't disrespect it also😒

[@darshans926]

@@bismahaider1504 nah but you’re parents gave birth to you, they brought u do this world, but if you’re saying ur parents are god, that’s another thing🤷‍♂️

[@banosultan4113]

​@Darshan S allah comes before parents it's not wrong to say islam is the best thing that came into your life

[@muhamadq1744]

A person living in my house is bringing a dog and I dont want it! It will not be my pet but my siblings. But its happening because i have no authority. What do i do? Should i move to a homless shelter to keep my rewards from being taken away???

[@shariqinam8726]

Same question

[@muhamadq1744]

@@shariqinam8726 thankfully the dog was too much for my sibling to handle so it was returned to where it came! I am so glad there is no najis creature in my home.

[@koreanarham6591]

Suffering from the same prob. :) A puppy is inside my house 🙃, my siblings brought it

[@amritakesh]

@@koreanarham6591 yeah be happy and play with that Lil puppy

[@alimanzar9985]

same issue

[@AuditingBritain]

Get the Chihuahua a AK-47

[@lifer195]

Guard dog needs to be in the house to protect you if someone breaks in, no use if the the dog is in the garden.

[@deleted3443]

Dumbest Statement i have ever read

[@riyaansheikh7470]

Agreed

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@SAJEDMUNIR]

Jazak Allah kharun

[@LB-jw3ly]

As far as I know there is no Hadith nor Ayah that states a guard dog must be outside. I don’t know about in all places but in the US many if not most houses have a front yard and back yard that are usually fenced in, especially the back yard. If you keep your guard dog in the back yard someone will just enter in the front of the house. If the guard dog is in the house it doesn’t matter which way they enter.

[@anahash3221]

then keep 2 dogs one in the frontyard and other in the backyard😂 or else just read ayatul kursi u will be guarded with 70,000 angels if i am not wrong, may Almighty forgive me if i am wrong

[@anaana1378]

brother don’t listen to this , the quran don’t say anything about dogs being haram

[@anandmishra2925]

Ha ha so you are denying the hadith of prophet muhammad means you are denying the prophet muhammad yourself.

[@sahilshabir5057]

There's only one Hadith that subjects dogs should not be kept inside ....rest Quran does not prohibit the dogs if you keep him in your yard or lawn ....

[@TheTruth51517]

Quran does not prohibit keeping dogs at all. Rest easy knowing you are doing no wrong by keeping a dog as a pet. Quran is the only source of guidance and not hadeeth. Don’t listen to these ignorant mufti’s who play god; it is not for them to decide whether keeping a dog as a pet is haraam or not. Follow the Quran only and most of your anxieties related to our religion will be solved. Peace

[@Cent-130]

Now a days there lots of robberys in houses. women attacked by strangers . People live in isolated area remote locations where there is threat for families why dint we keep for protection?😢😢

[@MuhibAfridiWeapons]

I planned to purchase a German Shepherd 😭 and even I found a guy and we were negotiating about the prices, the GSD is a cute puppy two months old, the cutest, I can never imagine ever that a dog can be that cute, but this video broke my heart, I have three houses to live, sometimes I have tasks, meetings, etc at different places, but I cannot think of keeping it away from myself as I can’t think if someone can take more care of him other than me if even I purchase ( which now I don’t think 😣 ), there’s a serious complication in this matter but one thing I know, The Story of Ashab - e - Kahf, they had Dog with them, and it will go to Jannah. I need clear answer which may or may not convince my perspective.

[@senadzri]

The stories of Ashabul Kahf proves that Islam is not against dogs in total. First these pious young men don't own the dog, the dog followed them during their journey. And they let the dog guard the cave, which are not even a house. There's big difference, between necessity and hobby.

[@lightshadernft8156]

My bro how does the video break you're heart? Do youre heart not beat and jumps in the following the commandments of creator?

[@MuhibAfridiWeapons]

@@lightshadernft8156 Bro, I didn’t adopted the dog due to the reason islam is not allowing it for fun.

[@jidddd01999]

​@@MuhibAfridiWeaponsfor fun? Are you crazy dogs are noisy animals and shouldn't really be at home also they are considered dirty in the quran dogs are meant to be guard you can own one if you wanted to guard your house just make sure you keep it outside

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@RedFozFive]

A Chihuahua CAN be used as a guard dog. If an intruder comes into your home, your dog will alert you of the intruder so you can protect your family. This proves ANY dog can be used for security. Mashallah.

[@aboozayd00]

Masha Allah💛

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@jotarokujo9242]

People will be proud muslims because they dont have a dog, and then go and sell drugs. Brothers, no one can live a perfect life but you must avoid doing harm to your family and community.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@Geferulf_TAS]

Watching this as my black dog sleeps on my feet under my desk. Islam is ridiculous!

[@TheMotivationalVault]

Sir a street dog gave 8 puppies in my garden and the mother died within a week now the pups will die if i dont bring them in for food what should i do? They can only drink milk rightnow

[@ruheedabhat7442]

Pls ans this question

[@ayshamuhiyadheen2564]

Iam not a religious person. just wanna share my opinion with you. If you feel like you shouldn't keep them then you should give those puppies to some loving hands. I wouldn't suggest raising them for selfish protection when they are so affectionate. If you can't make them feel at home then you should give them away. if you give them as much as you should have done if it was a bunch of kitties then keep them for yourself Hope you made a wise decision. and hope my opinion gives you an answer

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@ayshamuhiyadheen2564]

@@eliasziad7864 That's what i was absolutely searching for. i agree with you a thousand times

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@superman-ed7vm]

Yes good deed is there. He feeds a life form made by the omnipotent. And second think he never spreads hatred.. So he won't be in debt

[@pakibro5791]

But you can’t keep a dog inside the house 🤷. To gain good deeds you can feed stray dogs

[@superman-ed7vm]

@@pakibro5791 is it said where.good things can be done in home also.not only I'm street. Both in street and home it will be done

[@pakibro5791]

@@superman-ed7vm but for a reason dogs cant be kept in homes. you can search on the internet what the dogs saliva contains and what it can do to humans if contacted with face. there is always logic behind every statement of Islam

[@superman-ed7vm]

@@pakibro5791 it's not because of any logic. May be log there. but faith is the matter. Okay.

[@pakibro5791]

@@superman-ed7vm i am not a knowledgeable scholar so i wont start a debate .peace. May Allah guide us all

[@MohdSaif-xc5ru]

Man, how many restrictions? Is breathing allowed or is it also haram?

[@mohammedkhan1038]

It can be eaten by a cat...

[@G_Singh222]

The cat can be eaten by the dog

[@Helmzer.an.the.homeless.hounds]

i guess my good deeds will be taken everyday then because I love my dogs and not anything will ever change that

[@niharikakasini7154]

Same here 😊😊😊

[@venkatkumar3640]

If an option of God(Allah) and dog were given for you, kick God with your left leg and embrace your dog and feel warmth of true love and affection.

[@orcckaa]

People are literally throwing away their religion for some measly dog. What a time to be alive!

[@Helmzer.an.the.homeless.hounds]

@@orcckaa my dog is the reason I still breathe I believe God knew what I needed to come to my life when i needed a real friend depression almost took me i stayed at my little place for 5 years i only seen my grandma a few times i only weighed 105, i cut everyone out of my life and i just waited for death to come but a dog came instead thank god because i love life now things are totally different for me today I love my god he is the one and only and I love my dog/best friend

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, 'This is haram, and that is halal,' ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@guesswho8767]

I really really like dogs, but I also understand that following my desires can cost me something I’m not willing to pay.

[@leninmao326]

A person who is ready to forgo his love for dogs for 72 prostitutes in hEaVeN should be the last to talk about desires.

[@guesswho8767]

@@leninmao326 whenever you hear ‘following desires’ it means to follow what suits you best only because you have a stake in it. Have a good day mr mao and may allah guide you to that which is pleasing to him, surely you must be a thinking man to end up here. I sincerely wish you the best

[@Brhamabull]

What the fck ? What kind of a person doesn't have a will power to pay whatever the cost is to achieve his / her desires ?

[@leninmao326]

@@Brhamabull I don’t know, a person who values his family over his lust ; basically a person that isn’t filth

[@guesswho8767]

@@Brhamabull do you know what the possible cost could be?

[@liebert109]

This is the problem if you rely your religion from a scholar.

[@naveedjukaku6254]

In a nutshell you can keep a guard dog

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@xavierdewinter919]

I have a situation, i own a Pet Husky dog who was given to me by someone i know and that person could not take care of it anymore. Knowing this person and the dog i agreed to take the dog in. I tought at the time it would be good since the dog can protect my house and i get to take care of the dog providing it a house and training. So i let the dog sleep outside as much as possible it has it own house in the yard BUT occasianlly comes in the house, this for when i have to take it outside or go for the park / training. Now im in a conversation with a girl who i would like to marry, she has no problems with the dog but keeps presisitng i dont need the dog. Knowing if i take it to the shelter they might put it down because Huskys are very stubborn and loyal to 1 person dogs. Im try to let them know the dog can sleep outside in its house, it will never come in the same room as where i pray. BUT on moments the dog does need to go trough the house because there is no alternative to take it out. What should i do, i feel like getting rid of the dog might be the end of the dogs life, there is no dog inside the property to stop potential thiefs. What options are there, because being good to a animal is also something valueable. I never in my life have i turned my back to a animal and this is not in my personality to do so. THe idea alone of taking it to the shelter while the dog is well fed, stable, happy and very protective over me because it likes me feels very wrong. That brings guilt feelings.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@Goldenstu]

What if the guard dog has been gravely injured protecting its home and must be cared for but cannot be done outside due to bad weather or another threat?

[@hasanjamalkhan689]

Its allowed to keepp dog in house just take care of hygiene

[@ludwigvoncocksucker3275]

my best friend is an arab muslim, ive known him since grade 5 and him and his family have and still have dogs today.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@hasanjamalkhan689 where are getting these reasons bro? please enlighten us acc to Islam not your whims and desires.

[@badolgiringya5035]

@@ludwigvoncocksucker3275 so? Arab Muslim doesnt automatically mean best of Muslims or the rep of Islam.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@sunnyr8434]

Sir, Please tell me in which chapter in the Koran, says that we cannot keep dogs?

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@zaystarrrr]

Umm what about a husky ? It's more of a wolf than a dog it doesn't pant or drool all over.

[@superdude5160]

😂😂😂

[@istagfar7705]

Nope.

[@annijalipatova914]

A husky is pure dog. Not wolf or anything except a dog. And having a wolf inside the house is cruel on the wolf.

[@waltheofthangbrand5005]

A husky, a malamute, are not more of a wolf than a dog they have been dogs for 10,000 years

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@shaisthaanjum773]

We got a Golden retriver not as a pet actually it was searching for a new home .. i planed to keep in front gate. But it is not at all possible. Because of hot weather it comes inside .... I don't understand how to pray . What are the cleaning measures to do... Other than this I am pregnant for 5 months for guarding purpose only my husband bought that .. pls guide me through the cleaning measures...

[@MindMelt-xo7mb]

You bought a golden retriever for guarding purpose? Its like trying to shoot with a flower😂

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@abdullahalqaq840]

What about a emotional support dog? I feel like that falls in under the category of a working dog. Is this ok?

[@abdullahalqaq840]

@@joea57 so is a support dog not ok?

[@getpoggeredon9877]

It’s ok for mental and physical health reasons bro

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, 'This is haram, and that is halal,' ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@faizaroble846]

Im so sad i always wanted a small cute little dog

[@robindranathrobindranath7191]

We Hindus worship our dogs . We love our Dogs .

[@qce18]

may Allah guide you

[@AbdallahSomali]

No surprise there mate, My Allah guide you

[@shofnaakthar3651]

@@AbdallahSomali yes no surprise, Hindus worship dogs, cows n elephants too. They don’t want Allah’s guidance Mu’min as their cows will guide them 😅

[@webbo9798]

@@qce18 May Allah guide my dog to eat bacon he loves my bacon butties. Yummy😋

[@dkhan3233]

Dogs are perfectly fine to keep in Islam that hadith is weak Theres hadith where the prophet made it so dogs would be fed and can drink water and roam free around masjid nabi

[@thischhh971]

That still doesn't tell us if dogs are are allowed to keep inside or not, And yes ofc you may feed and take care of them outside

[@ZainIsInPain]

Listening to this video, reading this comment section and reading other sources is so complicated. Some say it’s completely haram, others say it’s permissible as a guard dog, and some say it’s okay to have a dog as a pet. This issue is so complicated that I just won’t even risk it. I’m a cat person but it still sucks that this issue is so complicated that I can’t even consider having a dog. The worst part is my brother says that he’s gonna get a dog once he lives on his own but I don’t want him to risk being wrong, and he won’t change his mind. I just wish that someone would give us a clear answer and actually settle this. This is such a simple matter that for some reason involves huge conflicting statements.

[@aaqibbaloch02]

The video also clearly says that keeping a dog as a guard or as a hunter is allowed.

[@akamekonigsmann8435]

Honestly I want a dog so badly

[@bilalbhutta6881]

Video clearly answers the question, listen to it again.

[@AA-iy4gm]

No it says as a guard dog but only outside, that's an important part not to miss, it's a cleanliness issue.

[@anthonyderosa7730]

Put it this way None of the scholsrs can figure it out. Again, put it this way, the domesticated dogs of today are not the same as the dogs from those countries back then, First of all. Second. If the dog is well trained, groomed regularly. A clean intelligent animal, even if it is a sin,(which no one can figure out), if you admit yes this maybe sinful, you are not out of the fold of Islam.

[@L8start]

are your duas accepted during iftar if there is a dog in the house

[@Joepurple2317]

Muhammad himself prayed in the presence of dogs and many of his cousins and companions, who were the first Muslims, owned dogs; the Mosque of the Prophet in Medina allowed dogs to frolic about in Muhammad's time and for several centuries afterwards.

[@ElyziumPrime]

Some things might appear cute but God sees everything, if it's mentioned not to let dogs inside the homes... It's definitely for a benefit although hidden to our perception.

[@chainjail4834]

It sounds like Allah or Prophet Muhammad hate dogs. There's absolutely no reason to punish dogs like this and I hate dogs. But it doesn't seem fair because I've seen stray dogs and I feel bad for them.

[@ElyziumPrime]

@@chainjail4834 they are a creature with their own purpose but they simply don't belong in the house of the believers as pets. I think establishing a subconscious dislike for dogs is beneficial for the general population to avoid them in the homes. Hate would be one step too much though.

[@ماهر-ل1ط]

​@@ElyziumPrime stooopp

[@ElyziumPrime]

@@ماهر-ل1ط Stop what? Hey If you want I can show you dark things. Maybe that will provide you a nice perspective why dogs are not allowed in homes.

[@ماهر-ل1ط]

@@ElyziumPrime only Quran says what is haram. Do u really believe and angel don't come in an house where there are dogs ? Such a joke

[@jufrirayyan2584]

So keeping a dog as a guard is permissible? I have an elderly mother and this dog keeps her safe. It is a Bulldog and is a very good dog, well natured and heaven is at the feet of my mum. I will say and ask you to answer. “ Allah SWT permits this” Does anyone deny my mother being safer with a guard?

[@oueizaii976]

What about for blind ?

[@manlikeak]

That is obviously out of necessity so yes it would be permissible.

[@Zeninslays]

We can keep them outside right? Giving food to stray dog which comes to our food and stays forever. Is that haram? (Not allowing inside but he sleeps infront of our door) Outside

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@leen9662]

Al Salam Alykum, sisters and brothers please guide me as to what to do. I am muslim since birth however 2 years ago i was young and ignorant, aotho billah, and i did not listen to my mom when she tried to warn me about the islamic perspective of getting a dog. Now this Ramadan Al Hamdulillah i have gotten closer to Allah and i have started to look into the rulings about dogs in the houses We got her before as a guard dog but now she is a pet. Should i put her for adoption or keep her? In the country i am in the adoption system is very bad and most adopted animals are thrown in the streets after some time and then the government kills them. I don’t want to commit more sins by killing her and I don’t want to loose my good dead’s by keeping her what should i do?

[@jhondelion8044]

Walaikum salam brother or sister, sad to hear you are thinking about this... I too have a dog but I do not believe in this hadith because it's not strong. However, unfortunately this sheikh does not mention what does the Quran say about dogs. From surah Al kahf (the cave) chapter 18, it is mentioned that a dog was with the youths in the cave and the youths were turned over to the right and left during their sleep. I believe angels were present to turn the kids while they are asleep even with the presence of a dog. Thus I do not believe angels dont enter your house because it does not match the quran. I do however believe the hadith regarding the dogs can make you fear water which is true as this is the cause of rabies, but once they are vacinated for rabies then it should be fine since we have prevention for that now. You can watch this video too about it kzbin.info/www/bejne/hH21naqpi96foqc.

[@nazneenazeez1451]

I think you can keep it outside your home and avoid its saliva and touching its mouth.and love it the same .after all it allah ( swt ) creation ,so please do what's best for it .

[@fory820]

Hello. Please listen to "dogs are 100% halal in islam" from an islamic teacher, which I can't recall right now. And please don't throw her away like an object so she can suffer and get killed. Don't forget that every good dead towards a living creature is rewarded by Allah. I often see many Muslims being very cold toward dogs as if they were not Allah's creature. Allah knows best and I hope it's not too late for her.

[@nataliem4266]

Can I work at an animal shelter with dogs and cats?

[@Jajababsjsl]

Im not a muslim but im somewhere close to converting so im trying to learn what i not allowed to as a muslim. My question why can’t we have dogs cause mine actually made me a better person there is no human being on this planet (except my siblings, mom and grandma ofc) who has been good to me every single day he made me so much better I genuinely I can’t live without him so can someone explain what to expect if i may convert to islam

[@tanjiroushirogane690]

the thing is, Allah knows better.. Everything that is not permissible in Islam, it definitely has something in it which will be harmful.. So if u convert to Islam, u should abide by the rules and follow it in your daily life.. as such, dogs aren't permissible..

[@Stargazer9933]

We as Muslims are not allowed 🚫 to have a dog 🐕 in the home because Allah forbids it. As a Muslim, who practices Islam, one is expected to submit to the will of Allah.

[@fory820]

Hello. I'm a muslim and I love animals. One day I would love to rescue one dog and I keep looking for an answer so I can rest my mind. Please watch "dogs are 100% halal in Islam". May Allah guide us all.

[@mahmudchowdhury7557]

To get technical, the main cause for concern is cleanliness. Some owners do not clean its paws when a dog comes into the house or when a dog walks over it’s own pee. Many owners also do not properly clean their dog after they do 1 or 2. The other thing is that a dog will lick anything and then lick its owner in the face. Some owners allow this and do not clean their face right away before kissing their loved one.

[@Jajababsjsl]

@@mahmudchowdhury7557 thank you all for your answers. First of all i converted to islam not long after the comment. Second thing, my dog is a very small one, pees only on his mat but I understand why its haram i totally agree, however i converted i pray and i still have my dog knowing that it is a sin i cant just sell him like that so i will have to live with the consequences.

[@jonathanng138]

Protecting and feeding a dog is basically a good deed already so it cancels out

[@kookoonuthead5644]

Me who loves big dogs : 💃💃💃🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mister.9909]

What if a dog came to my house and stays outside and I feed it occasionally

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@marchionessamoretto7326]

Message to Muslims: the Dog is a creature of GOD, they are loyal and help the blind and they protect you against evil spirits. Get a Dog, they are family members, you won't regret it. Open your heart ❤️

[@CRYSTALLINE..200]

Am a Muslim and I like it your thought too.

[@patrickdixon7202]

You're promoting haram.

[@marchionessamoretto7326]

@@patrickdixon7202 Dogs are clean animals and love having a bath, unlike Cats who hate water.

[@sumyunguy6894]

Here’s a little comparison I did between my dog and mohamed. Hope you guys like it. My Dog. Mohamed Child rape No Yes Murder. No. Yes Necrophilia. No. Yes Cross dress. No. Yes Hatred. No. Yes Loyalty. Yes. No Kindness. Yes. No

[@guadalupesalguero3492]

This is so sickening. My friend in Jordan talks about the horrible cruelty the street dogs suffer at the hands of these religious people. My heart breaks to see this level of cruelty.

[@shiny2401]

I live in a Muslims country and yes. It's terrible. We have authorities who catches dogs and euthanize them. To make it worse, we even have a case where a civilian who tried to protect the strays was charged in court for obstruction - preventing the authorities from catching the dogs.

[@wsuy143]

That is not Islam. Islam teaches us to be kind to everyone including all animals. Those people are not religious if they hurt dogs. They are lost.

[@chainjail4834]

@@wsuy143 ok if Allah want us to be kind to animals, why he punish for keeping dog in the house? Not only that, dog gets the highest level of impurity. You can't answer these questions and even the top scholars can't, so is this a flaw or what?

[@wsuy143]

@@chainjail4834 dogs are not meant for our own pleasures to keep as pets. If we want dogs, it should be for either guarding the house or a shepherd for the farm. Allah rewarded a woman that fed a thirsty dog . She was granted Jannah ( heaven). If you want more information you can search on KZbin or Google and you can find more details.

[@wsuy143]

@@chainjail4834 also it's the dog's tongue that's impure. There are other animals too like the pig that is impure too. Not just dogs

[@sohailrahman2637]

dogs are the angels so that's why angel thinks there is no need to go there they have one already.

[@Dodgers-sw2uk]

Chihuahuas can still provide security even if they can’t win a fight. They wake you up so you can prepare for the intruder.

[@HectorVargas-c7j]

Where’s the Hadith? We’ve always been told if someone makes a statement as a fact it have to be written in the Quran

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@huzairriyazmahajan9499]

It can get eaten by a cat 😂. Mashallah the humour

[@Ok_Bye1]

You know what.. In Hinduism, in our great text named Mahabharat, there was a guy named Yudhishthir who went to heaven.. He started his journey with his brothers and on the way a dog followed them.. All his brothers got tired and said we can't carry on... But Yudhishthir walked on and do you know when he reached the gates of Heaven, it was him and the dog... The dog is the one which follows you what you do. And do you know why Islam prohibits Dog, it is because Islam is one of the religion created by Sankaracharya.. And that's why Muslims gave more focus on Shukr ( Friday in Hindi) .. Sankaracharya was the God of demons.. So he hates what people do to satisfy gods... That's why such thing is written in Quran

[@ayshamuhiyadheen2564]

Ok fine, I admit that I'm not a pure believer. I'm one of the person who believes to consider god is inside yourself that should be worshipped. Anyway getting to the point. god has told as to love every individual regardingless of its physical appearance (especially). And the presence of angel in a house is according to the good deed in there. Without the presence of a statue or dog a house can't be filled with angel. According to by personal regards dogs are the most caring and friendly animal in the entire universe. i can't believe it has the ability to chase away angel

[@roxanne2749]

“God is inside yourseIf" do you mean pantheism? Are you referring to pantheism here which suggests that everything is God? And yes God are the most loving and caring animaIs undoubtedly l too beIive that but can l ask something, how do you know what Angels like or not? I mean my sister in lsIam l am also a girI and l really care about u as we both are musIims so concerning about my sister is what l think is my duty have u ever contacted Angels and asked them hey u, yes u over there! Do u Iike me keeping Dogs or not? WiII u visit my house if l wiII keep these in my house? The Prophet (SAW) was someone who was directIy in contact with the divine and we have enough evidences to prove that which no other reIigious beIief can give. If you want then l wouId be so happy to share these evidences and proofs with you anr don't worry l wiII give u proofs other then scientific miracles Hidden in the pages of Quran. The vedios wiII give references of there source material and they wiII quote schoIars and historians nd the vedios wiII be academic. WouId u like to watch one of them my sister?

[@roxanne2749]

Btw, sister using your logics can l not say that pigs are also given the same status? And dogs beIive it or not spread diseases in the house (l can quote my sources to prove my point) sorry if l hurted u in any way l just want musIims to atIeast try to understand the lsIamic narrative as weII.

[@ayshamuhiyadheen2564]

@@roxanne2749 Brother, I AM NOT AGAINST MUSLIM BELIEF AND RITUALS! i was just saying my opinion about it. What if it is a pig or dog or cat or anything, it's just a living organisms that breathes like us. There is no need for forbidding a living thing or lead people to hate it. Brother, if we discriminate human skin colour,it is racist. right? If racism is sin then why isn't this? I hope brother understands.

[@ayshamuhiyadheen2564]

@@roxanne2749 And about spreading disease. Is it really a excuse to discriminate animals. Why would you say something like that? Even cats can do it. Even a micro oraganism that we can even see can cause disease. Brother, it's 21st century Edit: i feel like i sounds angry or argumental while re-reading it so sorry if it does same to you. I was just as said ,stating my opinion

[@roxanne2749]

@@ayshamuhiyadheen2564First of all l am a sister not brother nd btw, to correct you on your point that “We are in 21st century" this is basically an argument which has literally no meaning at all, musIims in middle ages were far far more advance then any other civilization but that doesn't mean they changed their own reIigion. And you cannot catch any illness from any human unless that human herself has some disease whike on the other hand there are dogs and pigs (as a musIim l am shocked that an another musIim supports keeping pigs) just tell me this are u a musIim or musIim just by ur birth?

[@zamzamwater8749]

I’m still gonna get a Pomeranian one day

[@rainerwinkler8635]

and by the way, I have no dog nor a picture of a dog, yet still no angels ever visited me. I personally dont know anyone who ever had an angel as a visitor, regardless whether they were dog owners or not. So its either not true or angels are frigging useless

[@taiyeebmuhtadi]

Angels are invisible

[@rainerwinkler8635]

@@taiyeebmuhtadi so how did you see one?

[@taiyeebmuhtadi]

@@rainerwinkler8635 never saw one, and probably never will

[@IGKingIII]

How about I keep as guard dog like German shepherd.

[@muzakkirnf7921]

There’s no single verse in holy book of Quran that’s says dog is haram. Hadith? Yes. But Hadith are records of the prophet’s life after his death. Which were narrated and translated by men. Which means they are many ways it can be tampered based on one’s perception of something. human errors happen. Islam is all about showing love and care for all living beings. And dogs are significant in the prophet’s era. They were used to hunt and stuff. If their saliva are impure, how come people can eat the food they catch? And how come cats are ok when their characteristics are similar to dogs? I’ve never heard of anyone getting sick or died from dogs saliva. Unless it’s rabies. Which doesn’t originate from dogs but bats. So….

[@venkatkumar3640]

You are absolutely wrong. Mohammad ordered the people of the city to kill all the dogs of the city. People killed almost fifty thousand dogs.

[@poopbutt6241]

@@venkatkumar3640 evil

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, 'This is haram, and that is halal,' ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@Ok-dw4gz]

Astagfirullah 😢I got us Siberian Husky or the purpose of guard when he grows up because there are thieves in the area where we lived but after watching this I feel so regretful because I have not making any good deeds 😢

[@adammoe2061]

All dogs are made for work. And naturally they are not made for home regardless of you’re companionship with animals they are still animals.

[@wamboiwamboh]

confiremed,,was looking to this clip i have been urguing with my friends about dogs in home😢😢😢😢

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@Mahesh-uy8jw]

I would rather have dogs at home than have a wife. Dogs are more faithful than human beings.

[@KarungiSheillah]

With loyalty and faithfulness I agree with u but a dog will not bear yo children, cook for u, satisfy u sexually, take care of yo home, do the chores etc it’s only a wife who will do all the mentioned above

[@CalllMeZack]

1:45 Chihuahuas can be eaten by cats?

[@mrumarGTA]

So keeping dog in the house removes righteous deeds. Wtf lol

[@G-O-A-T-E-D-guy]

Are you Muslim? Saying “wtf lol” to something that will have come from Islamic sources is pretty disrespectful. If you have nothing good to say, don’t make sin for yourself.

[@sobanfarooq8288]

Are you mocking hadith?

[@eliasziad7864]

@@sobanfarooq8288 Hadiths are satanic made up by Rabbi Bukhari's delusions.

[@logicalrealistic3139]

Some dogs are service dogs Dogs can help people suffering from.depressiom

[@girlwithkoka2603]

I have got a cat, but my kids and hubby wants to have a dog. However we have decided not to have a dog. Allah knows better.

[@Keenjannik]

Get a dog. And stop believing in fairy tales

[@venkatkumar3640]

Good sattire

[@bungeegum9286]

God bless you ❤️If your family has a garden I can recommend having ducks instead. I don't own any myself because it's not allowed where I live but they're kinda similar to dogs: distinct personalities, intelligent, funny, remembers their owners, etc. Plus, they lay eggs ;) And yes, ducks are willing to let you pet them. It might depend on the breed, though. Muscovy ducks are silent ducks, in case you fear their nosiness. But remember that it's cruel to only keep one since they're flock animals.

[@girlwithkoka2603]

@@bungeegum9286 Thank you :)

[@ThePowerofInspiration-ym7vr]

According to Javaid Ahmed Ghamidi, Angel Gabriel did not like a dog near Prophet when he came for revelation. Us humans do not have any revelations (wahi) from Allah

[@TheTruth51517]

Quran does not prohibit keeping dogs at all. Rest easy knowing you are doing no wrong by keeping a dog as a pet. Quran is the only source of guidance and not hadeeth. Don’t listen to these ignorant mufti’s who play god; it is not for them to decide whether keeping a dog as a pet is haraam or not. Follow the Quran only and most of your anxieties related to our religion will be solved. Peace

[@wissemaljazairi]

Throw away the guidance of the prophet and all your anxiety will go away? ... Your afterlife will also go away

[@TheTruth51517]

@@wissemaljazairi it is upto Allah to guide you and who are you to tell me my afterlife will be thrown away? We will both stand before Allah and our afterlife will be in his hands not yours. Brainwashed sheep..

[@ashokpatil4022]

Time immemorial, Dog has been mankind's best friend. Islam prohibits it, unfortunate.

[@itsinc4596]

bro i love dogs😭

[@Vibe_editz63]

Mee too

[@MetheShef]

I jst found a losst puppy.... Giving him shelter.. In my house... He stays in the poarch... But hearinng this.... Will jst accpept alllah has snd this puppy to me.. So that i can feed this needy and ear good deedsss.. Rasullahh has prohibited. 😢😢😢 yrrrr wht can i do

[@elenarossignoli]

SE TI PIACE IL CANE TIENILO TI DARA' TANTO AFFETTO. TUTTI GLI ANIMALI SONO CREATURE DI DIO, CHE LUI CI HA DONATO PER VIVERE E STARE MEGLIO. ABBI CURA DEL CANE NESSUNO TE LO PROIBISCE, AMA IL CANE E AMA DIO IL SUO CREATORE 🙏

[@sameerdev618]

Then why Allah blessed the Seven sleepers and their Dog for accompanying the pious men?

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is haram, and that is halal,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@eliasziad7864]

Dont listen to this man he is a Salafi propagandist.

[@tentimesful]

my dad was a programme(per land) director of Ugandas save the children and he had a big house with even banana tree... he did have a dog there for security reasons and the dog even captured a thief that wanted to steal his light out side and the dog put him to ground. well the dog is simple trained, if you aint with the boss which are my dad and the dog carer while the dog is in his dog house and the dog sniffs you, well if you meet that dog while no one around he will bite and put you to ground lol... so watch out there lol... but is it allowed to have a dog house for a dog while I saw there in uganda like 1000 small wooden huts in rows with people living in it... I think the dog house was bigger than those huts, just dont remember as I was very young...

[@ilmafatima4401]

What about rescuing a street dog? They get treated really badly outside!

[@user-ji3il6ce2o]

You can feed them but you can’t bring them inside your house

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. Also there are hadiths on rescuing stray dogs, giving them water, and for that alone the person has earned paradise. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@MRCroosingTootH]

But if i dont remember wrong, it is Said in the quran (please correct me if I’m wrong) no good deeds can be removed from bad deeds , but bad deeds can be removed from good deeds ?

[@MRCroosingTootH]

Verily, the good deeds remove the evil deeds (small sins). That is a reminder for the mindful.” (V.11:114). But I can’t find anything about bad deeds removing good deeds except for kufir

[@eliasziad7864]

Quran 16:116 "Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is haram, and that is halal,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed." Dogs are not haram at all, this was never mentioned in the Quran. Dogs were created as a companion to mankind. And those who spread such lies such as this man will have their punishment. The prophet PBUH is not allowed to prohibit or allow anything other than what Allah has revealed in the Quran. Thus the Prophet did not prohibit dogs and is just a fabrication of words put into the mouth of the Prophet PBUH by people with a malicious intent. They claim its because dogs are "impure" yet rats are in most Muslim homes, and rats are responsible for hundreds of millions of deaths throughout history.

[@MRCroosingTootH]

@@eliasziad7864 i know i have looked up everything there is and nothing about dogs says they are haram or forbidden, nothing remotely close in the Quran. I even was discussing this with all my Muslim brothers in the mosque and one day we had a lecturer an ulejma from Mecca who had studied Islam for 60 years. And I handed him a note about “does my dog that lives with me in my house break my wudu or makes my prayer invalid”. And he answered there is no such claim in the Quran, nothing says they are haram… and I swear to you the whole mosque was looking in chock except me hahahaa we was dying laughing. Even the Ulejmas companion said when we spoke further that “why do you even keep the dog, just remove it” and I said but is it haram or gives me bad deeds and he still aaid No even though he didn’t like dogs himself. Just use logic, WHY would a dog be haram or a bad thing. They can hunt, protect family, create happiness and exercise for you to move and go out. They know nothing but love. But I swear Muslims live in a bubble cause in their countries they can’t take care of dogs and consider them dirty. Even though it is them who is kicking them to the streets. My dog was cleaner than 99 percent of people I know. This is just ridiculous at this point that Muslims can’t agree on such an easy topic.

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that dogs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs in the house. The problem is with black magic. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.

[@marcinjakubowski2622]

Dark ages 🤦‍♂️

[@lifer195]

Why are you here troll

[@saqibishaq8756]

But what's the reason Islam is so logical they must provide reason for this

[@Dogsanscats]

In the early times of islam people had dogs either for herding/guarding/work OR people had dogs in the house to use for religious rituals or black magic. In the Persian empire and around, it was common to have a "housedog". This was a dog used for black magic. That is why islam has hadiths saying you can't have a dog in the house other than herding/ guarding/ work. These text not allowing dogs are about black magic. You can't keep a dog for black magic and rituals. That is what it means. The reason they did not specify "dog for black magic" was because that was the obvious. Why else did people have a "dog of the house" other then black magic? People do not specify what is common knowledge. And common knowledge was that digs in the house meant black magic and superstition. So they only specified the only other reasons that a minority of people had dogs: "Oh right, some people have a dog for guarding, herding or work in fields. Ok, that is allowed". There is nothing against dogs. Second, about the saliva, saliva is not considered impure acording to islam. Only: if a dog licks your plates or cups (that you eat of) then wash it 7 times. This has nothing to do with "impurity" it is just hygene especially in a time where there were stray/ wild dogs who could have rabiës. The Quran talks very positive about a dog who is one of the just youth. They hide together in a cave. In the time of the first muslims, dogs walked in and out of the mosque, nobody cleaned where the dogs had been, and people prayed when they were around. So you can keep any dog, just don't do black magic.