Can you guess the costume in 4 pictures? (YIAY

[@jackisanerd]

HOLY CRAP LOIS hat store.streamelements.com/jacksfilmscouncil/product/DY0_uhavTE2wzQRFDiaSDg

[@Ph1syc]

Where is the garfield movie frame-by-frame analysis jackothy, we need it

[@thedigiboi]

are you remememememememember?

[@Banana_D]

holy crap

[@asterisk5054]

go piss girl

[@cluckendip]

for a sec I thought the url said store.steampowered and i was like damn you managed to make a game out of a bad meme that's impressive :)

[@frijjfan]

my greatest achievement is having sent Jack down the homestuck sharpie bath rabbit hole

[@EmeraldKeys]

It's always a good jacksfilms video when he discovers some niche internet lore

[@sonikkuwerehog]

and the fact he guessed undertale first too 😭 he isnt even that far off

[@redtaileddolphin1875]

@@sonikkuwerehogthe fact undertale was made in andrew hussie’s basement never fails to baffle me

[@prageruwu69]

legend

[@sparklecat60]

jackfilm is a valid ancestor name and jack sfilms is a valid kid name

[@crowzur6055]

Jack not knowing which one is Rhett or Link is hilarious especially because he has been on the show a few times

[@rus.t]

Do tou think rhey are also confused which is jacks and which is films?

[@snowy4112]

I'm the same with kay and peele, watched so many of their skits, couldn't name who's who, I know ones called Jordan? I think, but don't know who is who

[@highdefinition450]

was it nit a joke lol oof i would be so embarrassed

[@JaraelMoonsilver]

I think he used that joke at his own Smosh funeral lol

[@SwimmingInSunlight]

I was listening to Rhett on Sad Boyz podcast, and I kept picturing Link's face whole time until they spoke of the Rhett stick and it clicked 😂

[@CaptainJ62]

“In just 4 pics” should absolutely become a new YIAY sub-series.

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@WhoTFIsBillybob]

Fr

[@I_eat_bugs666]

Honestly yeah

[@iburiedpaul]

no, because sooner or later it will just devolve into loss

[@crimsonlion100]

You know what, thats legitimately a really good idea with a lot of comedic potential.

[@ejaybugboythree]

Normally a joke this run into the ground would suck, but that stretch of like 5 Jack to The Future outfits and Jack absolutely dying fucking broke me. That was so insanely good. Holy shit.

[@RToast13]

I was really hoping there would be a break of like one different costume and then immediately back to just Jack to the Future

[@fishblanket12]

@@RToast13 me too because i submitted one and it wasnt included (im not mad about it!! im completely fine!!!!!!)

[@dexterwilliams2520]

This is what he did to us in that A Lightswitch bit he did in the What Turns You Off YIAY. It was the same answer over and over and somehow kept getting funnier the more he exposed how exactly the same his audience is, myself included.

[@noahspizza4003]

bro im literally crying hahaha

[@EEEEEEEE]

‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎E

[@summer7578]

I love how Jack got the Ace Attorney joke almost instantly, but the Homestuck reference took a while

[@jstarstudios7110]

He's just like me fr

[@tenidiotaodpizzy4603]

im pretty sure ace attorney is more known than homestuck

[@heathenised]

because ace attorney is fun while homestuck is garbage lol

[@somerandomcube]

@@heathenised homestuck is *fun* hot garbage though

[@calculoopy]

Its because he is literally Apollo justice (victim of forehead jokes)

[@BonseyJonsey]

Of course Jack is the kinda guy who saves all his old phones in one drawer

[@pocketpc_]

I was NOT ready for him to just have the World's First Phone with Tango on deck like that, ngl

[@MajiggerRose]

Fun fact about the "baby" gravestone. There was actually a time when gravestones would just be small headstones basically just saying "baby" because with the high infant mortality rate, babies often weren't given names at birth. ...I guess that wasn't a very fun fact, was it? :(

[@erikallen863]

Naw, it's cool, I laughed

[@MajiggerRose]

Technically, I usually see “Infant” and not “Baby” but it’s a similar enough idea that I thought I had to bring it up. I have seen “Baby Boy” and “Baby Girl” and I think I have seen a couple that said “Baby”, but it doesn’t seem as common. (Btw I’m just someone who likes walking through old cemeteries. I’m not a historian or expert by any means.)

[@Pukeprincess]

I mean you should have the right to bury miscarriages and still births, especially if people bury FISHHH

[@kiiimiko]

It's fun if you get free shoes from it!

[@sillypplproductions2]

I know in Christian societies babies sometimes didn't have their name revealed/given until their Baptism, which now that I think about it is likely related to that

[@kristym7149]

The editors putting Ian and Anthony over that bit about Jack not knowing Rhett vs Link was a highlight for me

[@goldenn819]

SAME

[@deadhorse9741]

Explain?

[@syahmikadira6832]

​@@deadhorse9741I know the joke is just simple but it could also go 2 ways. Ian & Anthony of Smosh are a similar KZbin duo who started off during the "classic" age of KZbin similar to Rhett & Link but also when Smosh's parent company Defy went under in 2018, Rhett & Link decided to buy out Smosh before they could be "auctioned out" to the next bidder.

[@MissCaraMint]

It was beautiful.

[@tweer64]

8:12 Fun fact: the creator of Undertale and Deltarune wrote music for Homestuck. The creator of Slender: The Eight Pages also wrote music for Homestuck.

[@arsonvamp]

toby also straight up developed a lot of undertale in andrew hussie’s basement which is still wild to me

[@yukaii0]

oh wow never heard of that slender part. it all comes back to homestuck eventually...

[@certifiablyRad]

he also wrote a homestuck mpreg album

[@Fleabagwashere]

@@certifiablyRad the baby is you...

[@certifiablyRad]

@@Fleabagwashere the worst part is that it actually sounds good

[@holliwawa]

The sharpie bath incident also vandalized the hotel room the cosplayer was sharing with a group if I remember correctly. Lmao

[@PaperPK368]

I'm pretty sure it was also confirmed a hoax

[@holliwawa]

@@PaperPK368 No waaaay say it ain’t so

[@strangevol5264]

It was, found that out in the Izzzyzzz video. It’s become a bit of a meme.

[@holliwawa]

@@strangevol5264 It’s still real to me damn it 💀

[@Ghs6]

ohh

[@danner253]

Thank you for that 'Isn't America basically the planet' reference, hands down the funniest joke she ever made

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@izzysauls7737]

Calling the troll horns “cat ears” made me cringe and then laugh for a good 5 minutes. Lov you Jack you old fart

[@Justapikachu577]

Nepeta would be proud

[@tzarg]

timestamp?

[@DeathnoteBB]

@@tzargBetween 0:00 and 17:45

[@Aven_colonthree]

nepeta

[@iburiedpaul]

nepeta

[@Topazzzzzz]

confronting people with homestuck in the year of the lord 2023 should be a criminal offense

[@monoteozin]

The update for Homestuck^2 came out like that month, so you could honestly bully any homestuck fan if that was their reason for it.

[@goobybro]

jack pay for my therapy after hearing him talk about h*mestuck challenge

[@prageruwu69]

him finding out about the homestuck sharpie bath story was hilarious

[@elle2104]

little else has been as thrilling today as watching jack learn of the homestuck sharpie alcohol bath in real time

[@Kreed360]

SEEING THE HOMESTUCK ONE IMMEDIATELY WRECKED ME. As a fan of homestuck for ages I just needed the sharpie and the bathtub to know exactly what was going on. That person REALLY thought they were clever in trying to DYE THEIR OWN SKIN GREY in i think it was a hotel bathroom or something for a convention. SO SLICK because they wanted to avoid the whole body paint all over mess and it just never occurred to them that INK POISONING EXISTS. Jeeez I can remember a thousand stories from Homestucks heyday that would be unbelievable. Like the person who had a metal bucket chucked at their head at a con. Or people passing around a metal bucket and communally spitting in it. Even ONLINE, the Homestuck forums seem you can find a forum threads that is THOUSANDS OF PAGES LONG and QUARANTINED TO PREVENT ADDITIONAL POSTS, then you will see a DOZEN THREADS JUST LIKE THAT ALSO QUARANTINED AT THOUSANDS OF PAGES and each of them are just DISCOURSE ABOUT _THE SAME _*_ONE_*_ CHARACTER_ .And that's just the top of the ice berg, the deliriously biznasty stuff requires you to start having REFERENTIAL CONTEXT and that is its own whole bucket of worms.

[@spencr.]

bro is a yapfest

[@Kreed360]

@@spencr.Better a yapfest than a yiffpest.

[@spencr.]

@@Kreed360 what the fuck

[@iburiedpaul]

@@Kreed360better death do us part than shit do us fart

[@Kreed360]

@@iburiedpaul You may piss the bride.

[@clulessidiotowo6651]

The fact that I recognized the bathtub and sharpie immediately scares me

[@aykrivwassup]

the "worst halloween costumes" tradition is broken 😢 this episode looks fun too tho!

[@polishka7529]

As long as the worst Christmas presents stands still, my faith in God will do too

[@EEEEEEEE]

‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎E

[@aykrivwassup]

Update: It was fun!

[@MxZanReacts]

Hearing Jack even refer to Homestuck in such a way is surreal lmfao

[@sylphofheart]

every time jack mentions homestuck i grow stronger

[@ajkcool]

you must not be very strong then

[@ailuromantic]

fellow nepeta pfp spotted

[@somerandomcube]

nepeta pfp, swaggy

[@westvirginiaglutenfreepepp7006]

He's never watched SpongeBob but he knows what Homestuck is

[@somerandomcube]

@@westvirginiaglutenfreepepp7006 i've never watched spongebob because my mom found it degrading but i do know probably wayy too much abkut homestuck for it not being my main fandom

[@DreamyFlowerz]

Jack learning about the sharpie bath was not what i expected from this video

[@talic-os5899]

I don't know about Bert and Ernie, but I know that Rhett and Link position themselves in the order of how their names is said. Same goes for Brazilian country singer duos. Rhett is always on the left (for the viewer) and Link on the right (for the viewer). If they change positions, they automatically change names.

[@Jaythephoenix428]

Do you guys memember Halloween😂

[@akabill6127]

Oil up ima be there in 5

[@Yourhandleneedstobeatleast]

​@@akabill6127🧍

[@MarBL23563]

​@@akabill6127🚶🚶🚶🚶

[@V1DE0B0Y]

No

[@emilyferguson3718]

Jack mentioning Powerpuff Girls and Dexter’s Lab being “before the next wave of Cartoon Network” as if they weren’t airing well into the early 2000s 😂

[@Rubensteinsrevenge]

yeah, I was like "did those air a decade later in my country?"

[@decomposedcorpse5186]

Early 2000s? I was born in 2004 and watched those cartoons as a kid, so more like early 2010s

[@starspawn507]

I think a Loss costume has to be a couple's costume (or involve a mannequin) - one to be the person standing there over the bed, the other to be the person in the bed. You could maybe bring additional people and props to recreate the whole comic, but just the last panel is enough for the joke to land I think.

[@naiba8948]

Fun fedora fact! It used to be the symbol for feminism, named after a feminist character in a play named Fedora who wore the style of hat first :)

[@summer7578]

That's a fun fact thank you

[@worldwidefunnyguy]

oh no.. now fedoras are associated with discord and reddit mods

[@jstarstudios7110]

I'M BRINGIN IT BACK

[@OstroGothic]

Love seeing the Izzzyzzz cameo for the Homestuck cosplayer video - great channel

[@BassicallyKiyash]

Yeah

[@BinglesP]

15:07 I love that I could tell that the voice for the 'laugh track' was not only a council member's, but specifically Marshall's

[@StefanyDjuba]

I love how, despite not shading sssniperwolf anymore (because she's psycho), Jack still does the bbbit

[@sillypplproductions2]

I just realized, the Rhett and Link/Ian and Anthony joke works on two levels bc R&L's company used to own Smosh for a bit there until I&A bought it back It's alllll connected

[@xXxM0nzt3r_V0m1TxXx]

I’m just glad Jack’s okay tbh

[@penguinoats4613]

Too bad this couldn't be released on time due to an…*extreme* trick or treater...

[@maverickREAL]

Oh, that's a mini YIAY idea: how do you tell Bert and Ernie apart? My answer: Bert is the top, Ernie is the bottom.

[@cooperhurst2639]

Rhett is the top, Link is the bottom

[@esmooth919]

🛑

[@CommanderFuckwit]

One’s named Bert, the other one’s named Ernie. That how I do it.

[@Meat974]

That’s what they want you to think.

[@SuperBuffalo007]

Ernie is the top because he has trapped his four friends in separate dimensions, encasing them in eternal torment forever.

[@Somathrace]

I’ve been watching Jack for 14 years now and it feels so good to finally be included in a YIAY.

[@VintageFenrir]

6:50 Do you not remember when he freaked out because Strongbad claimed that? He is very insistent that he wears long pants and doesn't understand how people could think otherwise

[@PaulWiele]

He's a long pants man, long pants long pants!

[@lillianward2810]

Thank you

[@casperwashere]

the fact that he called the homestuck horns cat ears is funny to me

[@abbyn2557]

For the Fantastic four costume, just don’t show up and claim you were being invisible woman

[@presidentalpaca]

it's such a shame jack's been missing out on classic spongebob and adventure time. theres a ton of overlap w his humor there imo, and they're both just very fun, very well made shows

[@temphlosion3950]

this yiay is genuinely one of the funniest in a while. broke me several times with laughter

[@freep3115]

Erin did amazing on the makeup! I thought you hired a professional for that costume when i saw it last month

[@StormtrooperInStilettos]

Jack at one point you'll just have to admit that Jack to the future is your greatest masterpiece

[@Mollish]

Hearing Jack say "Homestuck" in 2023 gave me such violent whiplash - I knew what the costume was going to be as soon as I saw the bathtub 😅

[@Pokefan220195]

I can imagine all those 7 Jack to the Future costumes standing at my front door, demanding candy while they all recite the ad in unison

[@zeebo30]

no only does homestarr need to be pantsless, but you need boots that go all the way to your crotch

[@freddiescott2715]

The Jack to the Future joke is one of my favourites because it comes up like every few months and then it goes and it never gets old

[@ineedcornholioformytp]

I’m glad jack is back after that long Yiayatus.

[@miraculousmoonsanddragons]

Is it bad I knew exactly what costume the Homestuck Sharpie Bath one was with just the first two pictures? Also you don't even need the speaker, just a cardboard cutout with objection on it! (As someone who went as Phoenix Wright)

[@abstrusepaladin]

I did not expect to see Jacksfilms to run across Izzzyzzz' channel

[@I_SWEAR_IM_NOT_LYING]

IF I HAD A NICKEL FOR EVERYTIME HOMESTUCK WAS IN JACKSFILMS RECENTLY ID HAVE TWO NICKELS AND THATS NOT A LOT BUT IT'S WEIRD IT HAPPENED TWICE

[@Aven_colonthree]

what was the other

[@I_SWEAR_IM_NOT_LYING]

@@Aven_colonthree Asking AI the most cringe questions uploaded 3 months ago

[@Aven_colonthree]

@@I_SWEAR_IM_NOT_LYING aight thanks

[@I_SWEAR_IM_NOT_LYING]

@@Aven_colonthree ofc

[@marxssweetass6118]

Seeing Jack talk about Homestuck was something I would've never expected to happen. Yet here we are

[@sillypplproductions2]

Yo unrelated but why's Kirby so cheeked up 😭

[@ajkcool]

@@sillypplproductions2 Ack-shul-lee 🤓👆it's not Kirby, it's Marx, read the username

[@sillypplproductions2]

@@ajkcool ah yes, of course, silly me Why is Marx so cheeked up 😭

[@iburiedpaul]

homestuck cant die. like ever. (unfortunately)

[@Purple_Trial]

@@iburiedpaulgood.

[@thyme-traveller]

The jack to the future costume marathon was spectacular

[@colorsbyflow]

the primal just horrifying dread i got from hearing jack talk about homestuck, which i try every day of my life to forget, only for that IMMEDIATELY followed by fucking "IS THIS LOSS??" is something i will never ever get over in my life

[@AJRION1]

I feel like this YIAY was too good to not be 2 hours long

[@wilhelmina3053]

I love Erin is the Funny One (she really is:)), I’m listening to it in order after accidentally listening to the last one and there’s so much dramatic irony with how often they talk about reaching episodes in the hundreds, even in the last episode u_u

[@CGYT_Gaming]

i love it when jacks content comes inside of me!

[@yourlocalchaosgoddess]

ay yo?

[@monoteozin]

And then he content'd all over

[@kyle.v.ressler]

Jack questioning his wife for watching Blues Clues be then immediately says he's only watched 4 episodes of Spongebob...

[@ultimateskillchain]

As someone who never stopped enjoying h*r and referencing it, I'm legit buzzing that it's making a comeback 😁 Also, that exact style of Hawaiian shirt is 100% ubiquitous here in Australia, at least in the north. In certain towns you have a 0% chance of going into any establishment on a weekend and not seeing at least one, most probably several, of these shirts

[@CoolerThanHot]

“I was gonna say can we bring back fedoras, but we’re they ever in?” They were with Feminists in 1882, during the woman’s suffrage movement.

[@Obi-WanGaming]

it's immensely painful that i know nothing about homestar runner outside of seeing it brought up every now and then but i knew exactly what the sharpie bath was immediately

[@pattykcake]

12:28 Oh my gosh after 5 years of submitting answers I can believe I finally made it onto YIAY! I wish I had captioned my costume “going as Ariana Grande’s boyfriend” to be topical but oh well I absolutely love SpongeBob and it is a timeless costume. Thank you council and thank you jacksfilms!

[@StarToastiez]

I love the Jack to the Future joke so much it's awesome

[@loghorn-feghorn]

Cmon Jack. Everyone knows Homestar is wearing long pants!

[@piupaupompompom]

long pants, strong bad! the longest pants! everybody everybody longest pants! long long long long long long pants!

[@Axqu7227]

Creepy pants all the time get some.

[@Shadowrunner123]

Homestar Runner *explicitly* explained he wears long pants that just look like they cover his shoes. Jacksfilm being a fake fan not even knowing the series got a Trogdor the board game, SMH.

[@BassicallyKiyash]

Seeing izzzyzzz's name in a jackfilms video was the best thing ever

[@wellhellogoodbye]

going from homestuck immediately to ctrl+alt+del is quite a funny transition

[@collicomet]

Little does Jack know I actually went as Jamiroquai for halloween

[@bleachyidioms]

so did i!!! i got so excited when it came up

[@michael-luce]

Woah never expected izzyzzz to get a shout out over here. Very weird to see those sides of KZbin collide

[@tzarg]

13:16 I don't, i've only ever heard of this homestar runner thing like a few months ago and now I'm hearing people act like everyone knows what it is and it's scaring me

[@azzierulz]

That costume is genuinely awesome even tho I don’t get the reference- fantastic job, Erin!

[@aykrivwassup]

9:03 - 9:09 Yes, on purpose. The troll characters have grey skin

[@pezzable]

I've officially done it. I've completely caught up on YIAY. Watched every single episode. Seen everything. I wanna die

[@brolicanklesanonymous]

Poor fedoras, forever mistaken for the much goofier trilby, while the real fedora looks mega fresh.

[@starrkitty1]

Jack and I must be like exactly the same age. I watched the same cartoons he did and missed the same ones, I used to pronounce meme “maymay“ unironically and I have (very) special place in my heart for Homestar Runner. I actually just visited their site the other day to see what those dudes are up to, if anything. My thought is that they need to not necessarily re brand, but have a huge come back, invade tick tock or something. Just so we can really culturally elevate this upcoming skibiddy toilet generation.

[@AlfSandvich]

3:27 "Ian and Anthony" 💀

[@MarquesAllenJones]

i have been stuck watching the last two episodes of YIAY over and over again bc they each recommend the other at the end. help.

[@FooPanda]

Leave

[@MasonBitByte]

Jack was after Johnny Bravo but before Dude, what would happen? and Destroy Build Destroy, what an interesting piece of history

[@StarBoundAngel]

I’ve heard about homestuck since I was an itty bitty and I still have no idea what it is. I’ve deep dived into the stupidest things and yet never Homestuck. At this point I’ve made it a part of my character to just be confused every time anything Homestuck comes up.

[@kingdingaling3376]

17:00 he’s got a fling smash to play every single day

[@lukes.3679]

Both of your Homestar Runner voices were genuinely good!

[@thesameguywhomaderoomlocked]

the homestuck sharpie bath thing is something we do not talk about.

[@nylarose2310]

Halloween is always in present tense if we want it to be. Belated content just extends the season, keeps christmas at bay

[@eves1es]

an izzzyzzz cameo wasn’t on my bingo card but I’m so glad it happened

[@ScorpionTamer]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who hasn't touched homestuck simply because it's so gosh darn long. It's also why I haven't watched One Piece, it's a commitment and I'm afraid of commitment.

[@Ph1syc]

I am dissapoined in the lack of a frame-by-frame analysis of the garfield movie.

[@maromania7]

Blues clues: Has the host say "I'm going off to college, but my little brother's going to play with you while I'm gone ok?" Johnisageek: Is this a multiverse?

[@MisterFribble]

16:49 suddenly I had flashbacks. I played that game a lot as a kid. I completely forgot it existed.

[@MinecrafterPictures]

8:59 Even distorted, hearing the YIAY outro theme is completely unforgettable

[@owen_the_oddball8907]

8:59 those are some good sounds

[@user-oh6uw9mu9u]

I was NOT expecting Captain Disillusion! Jack has a great taste in KZbinrs, as always!

[@BaconPinata]

4:08 if you’ve watched lasagna cat, you know this one immediately. 101:24 minutes of pure, uncut art.

[@ECTOBIOLOJIZZT]

OH MY GOD. IT’S HOMESTUCK. 😭😓 8:05

[@sonikkuwerehog]

He wasn’t even that far off when guessing Undertale when talking about Homestuck and he has no idea

[@Kenzie-Soup.n.Squash]

My brain just sent off so many alarm bells when he said that 😨😀

[@sonikkuwerehog]

@@Kenzie-Soup.n.Squash HEARING HIM MENTION UNDERTALE BY NAME IS HORRIFYING 😭

[@ceruleanModulator]

@@sonikkuwerehog at least virtually everyone knows about Undertale, hearing him mention HOMESTUCK was something else

[@digdug4451]

The Loss one works doubley. If you look at the general photo make up, it makes the classic | || I| |_

[@alchemyrecords657]

10:31 Oh jack, you sweet summer child

[@azzierulz]

THE SOUND AT 15:08 LMAOOO I WAS EXPECTING THE USUAL LAUGH TRACK

[@Cleanframe]

You only watched 4 episodes of SpongeBob and no Blues Clues. You can't blame Erin that she watched TV as a kid, LOL

[@imwithpluto]

Pinnacle Jacksfilms content ❤❤❤ going straight to my favorite playlist

[@SapphireCarbuncle009]

Jack to the future is Jack's version of EVO Moment 37: A moment he doesn't want to remember but his fans love to remind him of it

[@nerdyneedsalife8315]

Are you referencing Daigo not wanting to remember or Justin not wanting to remember? Because I think Justin takes it well even though that was at his expense

[@SuperBowlJeffyTV]

Glad to see hes back to making consistent content, doing good jack 👍