Can you guess the Hearthstone card? W/

[@Wooker]

"is it in wild" sure is a question of all time

[@bnsz8704]

It means not in standard but it does sound silly

[@Eighty_Ninety]

@@bnsz8704those aren’t the same, standard cards are also in wild so it could be a card in standard but he could still say yes to it being in wild

[@bnsz8704]

@@Eighty_Ninety but that’s what the question actually means. It should be said as “only in wild” though

[@criticaltipper7699]

@@Eighty_Ninetyyeah but would you really hear that question and say yes in good faith knowing what they mean behind the question

[@Dani_el_Duck]

Some standard cards are banned in wild so it's kind of a legit question

[@Oldmantic]

Trump would honestly be the perfect person to do this video with

[@Yazimo]

The very best, but I dont think the president plays HS.

[@tahagoven5227]

dude do you want a 4 hour video?

[@iPressure-]

@@tahagoven5227Yes, 100000% id like a 4 hour video of him snd trump playing this to like 10

[@projectx5154]

No he's a boomer, the video wouldn't get finished

[@eldunae922]

​@@Yazimoyeah, he only plays MTG with other ex presidents

[@Razmatschannel]

Rarran consistently narrows the cost down to only 1 cost, but still asks if it’s that cost

[@JumbleOfPeople]

That was fun to watch. :) 2 suggestions : 1 - When trying to determine the class, you can go by Mean Streets category. Example : "Is it one of the Jade classes?" (Rogue, Shaman, Druid) 2 - When facing Roffle in this game, the best pick is Plate Breaker. Whenever that card is brought up on his streams, he refuses to acknowledge its existence. I think his brain would just BSOD.

[@cruxofthesubject1402]

But then you would just be making up cards which is unfair

[@spaniardincanada8381]

I thought of that first tip too, very clever; though I'm a little lost about that second one, I don't think you're allowed to pick a card that isn't in Hearthstone.

[@QueenLuxAeterna]

​@@spaniardincanada8381Plate what? Picking custom cards is bs.

[@Alliclare]

@@QueenLuxAeternaPlatebreaker is from Rise of Dragons

[@QueenLuxAeterna]

@@Alliclare There is no such card in that expansion

[@adamstewart5664]

Rarran: Does it have another keyword on the card? Roffle: No Rarran: Is it Armored Warhorse? 💀

[@Bootiesxd]

This is one of the best HS videos ive seen in a long time. Much love to Rarran and Roffle

[@edwardsaintland4819]

The optimal strategy is to eliminate roughly half of the cards from the pool with each question. Since there’s 11 classes + neutral, you can narrow it down to one class with 4 questions max, know the mana cost and rarity with another 6 questions max. Asking 10 questions GUARANTEES the class, the mana cost and rarity of the card, you can then go through the collection to ask a few questions to easily get sub 15 questions each card. It can’t get you the card very quickly, but it can stop you from getting screwed by a series of unlucky specific questions and get 20+.

[@gabenwatching2746]

But is it fun?

[@AbleAsmitha]

​@@gabenwatching2746it is Skills is funny

[@aure2549]

Rarran is so bad he always ask something that he already knows. Like "is it less than 2 mana? Ok is it 1 mana ?" Like he eliminates every other possibilities but he stills need a confirmation

[@admosse]

@@aure2549 0 is less than 2 too, you know?

[@aure2549]

@@admosse but 0 is not an odd number

[@Flatfootsy]

Rarran picking THE most vague questions ever, on repeat lmfao

[@thefatman4671]

The edit at 6:19 just SLAYS me I rewound that so many times, I love this series.

[@bogdicool2461]

Thanks Rarran for bringing back the best content creator Roffle

[@MrDanders666]

Isn't "Did you pick the same card as me?" a yes or no question

[@JohnsGamingFun]

Thankfully it didn't make a difference but being coy about it wasn't cool

[@kihouou1295]

I think it came out as more a thought to himself than a question. Rarren probably should have asked for clarification but it’s edited so he probably did instead of assuming.

[@tomhoffs8209]

It didn't come off as a genuine question and if it was supposed to be Roffle could easily have insisted on the answer, no foul play there imo.

[@theparagonal]

​@@JohnsGamingFunThis is not worth caring about

[@Domineque333]

They were having fun. Don't think they cared about that. But technically yes lol

[@Opno]

The gigatroll picking Ancestral Healing again was incredible

[@PeterZaitcev]

Seing the previous game, Rarran 1st question should always be "Is it from the Core and/or Legacy set", and the 2nd should be "Is it from the Legacy set?"

[@Bobal27]

7:30 The pro move is to set two lists of five classes (Mage, Paladin, DH, Warlock, Priest; as an example for list 1), and ask if the class is in list 1.

[@quinnbell2388]

'did you just pick the same card?' was a valid yes or no question. 'Maybe' was not a yes or no answer

[@noahnyul4069]

2 amazing creators❤

[@dermegger7733]

Last week I was so confused about not having Murozond anymore for a wild Priest deck I was making. That card was in the core set for so long that I actually thought I had it.

[@bertchintus4103]

Picking the same card as Roffle right after was a dirty move lmaooo. Love these videos, plus love Roffle as a guest, lets go!

[@justinh826]

Honestly, the best first question for these seems to be "Was the card considered good?"

[@patrickgass787]

"might have discarded your brain from your head" ... savage

[@christopherbronson3275]

My dude got the G.O.A.T. of sassing his twitch chat in on this. LET'S GOOOOOOOOO

[@Aceries_]

The "why not?" was powerful.

[@balintszeles2519]

This was really fun. Hope to see more of these in the future!

[@МолчаливыйКлинок]

21:48 Technically right here Roffle had the right questions, and Rarran didn't answer it, so....

[@jowi6491]

Mathematically speaking this was a disaster

[@izaiahsundquist6877]

Rarran: Is it from Shaman? Roffle: Yes Rarran: is it an odd card? Roffle: No Me: Is it Genn Greymane?

[@nickjoseph77]

Always love seeing Roffle and Rarran team up for this stuff.

[@sephiroth8575]

Godlike combo. You need to get Roffle on here more often!

[@Val_1992]

I see Rarran does not learn on his previous mistakes with core set... :D One small suggestion from my side - it would be nice to have counter on screen with questions asked, it would make it more intense for viewers (unless viewers counts in their head, but I doubt it :) )

[@d1edserg]

Finally that happened again. My favourite hs content creators making some huge collab

[@ktownpunkjr.1946]

Love rarran style content, keeping the game in my mind even after all this time not playing!

[@johnny5731]

It would be nice to have a question counter

[@jokojabo]

No spoilers, but judging from the first question Rarran asks I know who's winning this challenge. Is there a single card that would answer 'no' to this?? 😂

[@KoopaKrump]

Well actually... I'm pretty sure there's a funny 1 drop draw card in priest thats banned from wild right now.

[@jokojabo]

@@KoopaKrump yeah after the comment was made I realized there are a few cards banned in wild. Doesn't make it a good question though 😅

[@Maddogs1]

Yeah he's really awful at the guessing segment

[@kennybrown8382]

it is great to see more roffle/rarran combos

[@slayerxeraxus6119]

scammed Roffle on the "Did you pick the same card" question it is a yes or no question

[@puszujtowera]

Take a shot each time Roffle says "no".

[@HampenBraender]

Rarran consistently asks questions he doesn't need to xD For example asking if it's a 4-cost when it's the only remaining option.

[@chudziak2704]

Yay Roffle again I was wondering when you will invite him again. Love his and your content. Keep it up!

[@Salacavalini]

I think a good question for hero powers would be "Does it have the capacity to deal damage to either player in any way, by itself?", which would cover Rogue, Druid, Hunter, Warlock, Death Knight and Demon Hunter.

[@jemsuper]

Roffle cant handle cost questions. Asks if its even, gets yes, removes 0 costs. Asks 5 or more, gets yes, asks if its 3, gets no. Filters 5 away

[@KuroroSama42]

Rarran: "Is it even? -Yes. Is it 6 or more mana? -No. Is it less than 4 mana? -No." Also Rarran: "Is it 4 mana?"

[@kaigelling7157]

These collabs go crazy

[@falseten1055]

Roffle: No 🗿

[@bernard832]

According to Druid questline, equipping a weapon does give your hero attack, so that would count for Rogue hero power.

[@wruthe2709]

Ngl the game should consider the total amount of questions asked. Roffle got majorly robbed there imo.

[@Paul_Nesteria]

15:40 nothing wrong, it wasn't a hint, because Roffle first asked, "does HP do damage" and then asked about gaining armor, and since druids HP BOTH do damage and gain armor, only one HP which fits condition left - warrior's one

[@voice7819]

Druid's HP doesn't do damage. It gives attack.

[@defn0tjake]

I think a decent question to narrow down classes would be to ask which faction a class's mercenary belongs to. Combine with alphabetically first/last (splitting between priest and pally), you have it narrowed down to 2-3 classes + maybe DK in just 2 questions

[@rowan4573]

I feel like a good question would be "Was the class Alliance or Horde during the Mercenaries story line" since that narrows it down to half the classes right away

[@SuperMetalmeltdown]

Well, that is not a "yes or no" question... or technically it is; You answer "no" if your class is Death Knight And yes if not

[@rowan4573]

@SuperMetalmeltdown right, I guess clarify the question to "Was the class part of the Alliance" that way if it's yes it could be 5 classes, no means 6 because of Death Knight Then you could ask something like "Did it come out during The Year of the Dragon or earlier" to root out Death Knight and Demon Hunter potentially

[@badcatgames783]

It is a good question.. That is, if know about the Mercenaries storyline.

[@rdemon97]

You can also ask is it warrior, warlock, shaman, DK or dh?

[@TheArbalah]

What in tarnation is mercenaries storyline? I bet most of the players like me have no idea and just skipped past this mode after couple tries

[@Crazimir]

This is an excellent game you've invented, Rarran. DO IT WITH THE LONG-HAIRED BAZAAR-PLAYER.

[@profdouglas1392]

Rogue hero power does not deal damage or give hero attack but it does summon something, which did not come up in this video but could matter in any sequels

[@yoanlul]

Congrats to Roffle for 100k subs!!!

[@DamianPereyraHs]

Rofle. ❤ Great guess to this show. 🎉 Thanks for the content Rarran!! 😊

[@vladimirefest4980]

Technically Roffle should've had at 21:49 when Rarran said maybe instead of yes.

[@williammartinsyay]

The gigatroll move picking Ancestral Healing again loooool

[@kilton2835]

Two of favorite Hearthstone creators!! I'd love to see Chump on an episode!

[@Grimfang999]

15:32 Druid gains armour but it couldnt be druid since the previous question was does the hero power deal damage which... well I guess it kind of does so should be a yes?

[@javyz6197]

”It’s even” ”Does it cost 6 or more” (No) ”Does it cost less than 4” (No) ”Does it cost 4” bruh come on man

[@Nehimsupacac]

Next time you should do: 1 question, 1 free guess. That way you add a little bit of fun by guessing totally random cards, and you dont have to feel bad wasting questions on a single card guess!

[@trokolisz3702]

I think a good class question would be: does your hero power allows you to remove a 1/1 opponent minion. That incluses dh, dk, mage, druid, rogue

[@quentind1924]

Well yes but no. You have less cards in DK/DH, and so if its a yes it only includes 5/11 classes, including the 2 classes with the least amount of cards. So asking with alphabetical order is better

[@Fledermausmann]

Aww Rarran, so dedicated to winning that he had to resort to cheap and dirty tricks :p

[@CanadianPianoMan]

Thinking about it there's some interesting optimizations. When you asked if the HP summoned something you asked if it was Paladin and then Shaman. Instead since you know there's only Shaman and DK left you could've asked if the card had overload which could (and would've) saved you a question.

[@Chaconcito96]

Activision: "Piracy is a discount" Thats a weird thing for a publisher to say.

[@TheIdiothead]

In my opinion I think that it’s completely fair for the answerer to interpret the question however they want. I think it’s up to the asker to be precise with their question. So for things like “was this card playable?” I think then the answerer determines what that means if the asker doesn’t specify.

[@Cuestrupaster]

I think one of the best ways to narrow down the classes is to ask if it's part of one of the Gadgetzan Gangs, because if it's yes, then you remove both DH and DK, and then you ask if it's from Jade/Goons/Kabal, if you get it right it's down to 3 classes, if you get it wrong it's 3 less classes...

[@SeleenShadowpaw]

Hmm. Usually in takes on 'what am I?' like this, to encourage clever questions, you usually only count the questions that were answered 'no' for the negative point count to determine who wins the round. That makes it less volatile for stuff like immediately trying to go way too deep and getting lucky, because you can take your time carefully eliminating 'spheres' of yes-questions to slowly narrow it down. It just all in all makes the game experience more consistent and allows you to be strategic, makes it less negatively stressful for players, and would in the end be more entertainment value i think :D

[@jellybean3384]

perfect way to include rogue in narrowing classes is saying "does the hero power give an opportunity of attack" instead

[@satibel]

Binary searching is a lot better than asking one by one, basically you want to split the cards into two approximately equal parts and repeat (e.g. mana cost 5 or more, then if yes, check for 7 or more, then you have a pretty good idea.)

[@potmasiero]

Love this format

[@TheTrekx]

I like how rarran always wastes his questions being too specific

[@Nightknight1992]

''does it heal'' immediately forgets

[@Gleveniel]

You could also ask more specific, combo questions '"is it a class minion card?" instead of splitting it into 2. It's riskier since saying no could mean that it's either a spell or a neutral minion.

[@zhaf]

Asking if the default hero an Orc-ish race is a good question because it can narrow down the classes to 4 (Hunter, Shaman, Warlock, Warrior) or eliminate them. Then you can ask question about the hero power to narrow down the class even more. Humans are 3 classes (Mage, Paladin, Priest). Elves are also 3 classes (Demon Hunter, Druid, Rogue).

[@taube17]

pls more with Roffle

[@TheSlick44y]

2 clever and handsome men

[@frak7190]

I truly believe roffle is good at this game because of his time working in software. He just understands algorithms and patterns on a higher level

[@frak7190]

Like one good example is the line of questioning "is it an even cost card" --> "is it it 6 or more mana" --> "Is it 4 mana" relegates all future picks to 2 or 0 cost cards

[@phillipjones1536]

them asking "is the main character of the class female" makes me think rouge, mage, and priest because i always think Tyrande is the default

[@miltonarijr]

I got a challenge for you: the IMPOSSIBLE SWAP HERO CHALLENGE, so turns out that there's 6 classes that have more than 2 hero cards, so my challenge is you have to play all of the heroes from the classes and win, you cannot win the game without playing all heroes

[@askmeagain43]

As bad as Rarran is at this, picking Ancestral Healing immediately after Roffle was a great move

[@hogg156]

I think an interesting question would be "does the hero power do something in increments of 2?" Aka, deal 2, heal 2, gain 2 armor, or summon with 2 health? That would limit it to Warlock, Hunter, Priest, Warrior, and Shaman - splitting the class options perfectly in half.

[@QueenLuxAeterna]

Summon with 2 health is pretty hard to think as "doing something un increments of 2" and even so, incorrect. There is the 1/1 totem.

[@hogg156]

It's a question that would need to be explained, but there have been a few explained questions so it should be fine. Shaman still has the ability to summon something with 2 health even with the 1/1, so I think it can be counted.

[@Imakunipwns]

This is obviously just for fun, but both contestants could save themselves a lot of questions by using binary search.

[@潘昀-s3b]

Rarren's tactic was just so awlful XD

[@cobaltbeau]

when you're running through the classes, you probably want to go binary search mode. Instead of guessing one at a time, guess "Is the name of the class before Priest, alphabetically speaking" (so priest or after gets a no) And then you divide the remaining possibilities in half from there until you want to guess something else.

[@GumshoeClassic]

I was sitting here for 20 Minutes trying to figure out what felt wrong with this video until I finally realized Roffle doesn't have a beard on the points tally.

[@harlanharrington4732]

Love this series

[@Stemtyke]

Any video w/ roffle is a good video

[@s0larpr0phet68]

This was so fun to watch🎉

[@supercereal1]

I think my favorite part of these videos is the comments trying to min-max the questions like complete monkeys

[@ssspikesss]

i like how rarran casually forgot how to play the game and what questions to ask since the last time 💀

[@onniturunen3719]

Love the kurtis connor shirt!

[@ernestcheung5467]

the third round wasn't just a 14q diff, rarren just folded and asked what is the card LOL

[@Keltolas]

after watching the first 4 minutes i thought the entire video is rarran trying to guess felsoul jailer

[@KuroroSama42]

18:05 Cheating?! How dare! The rogue equipping a weapon gives the hero attack. edit: Ah. You do address it. You're wrong, because when the weapon equips the hero also gets the number next to its portrait. I can understand the mistake, but there's definitely no gray area there. The hero's attack is the number next to the portrait.

[@WavemasterAshi]

This is the SECOND TIME he's gotten giga-jebaited with a Legacy card! Also, would you consider Druid to be a HP that does damage because of the +1 Attack, or does that specifically refer to Mage/Hunter/Warlock?

[@andredepadua8799]

The Druid's hero power doesn't do damage. The Druid himself, on the other hand...

[@SunbleachedAngel]

The hero power doesn't deal damage, no arguing about that

[@fragniz]

What I'm wondering is WHY is Stealer of Souls Legacy in Roffle's collection? Because it came out in Wailing Caverns, the Forged in the Barrens miniset. I had to look it up to see where it was from, because I was SO confused seeing Legacy on it, since it wasn't in the game's starting card pool, and I was pretty certain it wasn't a Core Set addition.

[@KuroroSama42]

On first thought at the "does damage" question, I was counting druid, rogue, mage, death knight, hunter, demon hunter and warlock. Basically, the hero power can cause damage somehow, via attack or anything. But when they mentioned "It's only 3 classes", I immediately understood. And unfortunately, both interpretation seem valid to me.

[@KuroroSama42]

@@SunbleachedAngel I disagree. There is some argument both ways. If you attack as a result of the hero power being used, then the hero power "did damage" via the intermediary of that attack. It's a very direct chain of causality. The paladin hero power doesn't "do damage", because the chain of causality ends up too far removed - and it's very possible the recruit doesn't even damage anything. Removal and whatnot.

[@mircasta]

A question you could use for class is the main class character alliance or horde or what gang it has.

[@DavidTG98]

18:04 Rarran straight up lying

[@psychoinferno4480]

i actually equip tyranda portrait for so long i forgot the default priest was anduin

[@mamakrida5546]

rarran he asked if you picked the same card on an ancestral healing its a yes/no question, you should've said yes it would have been the most brutal comeback

[@miguelgarduno4664]

I'd love to see you make a program like Master roulette of Yu-Gi-Oh where you open certain packs of an hearstone expansion to play with or master duel I think would be awesome

[@Herio7]

I would love to see some value brain like Kripps or Trump against Rarran's shenanigans

[@mathiasbrenner9442]

"You just picked the same card?" "Maybe" Thats not how you answer a Yes/No question 😜