Can You Trust Content Creators? Feat.

  Рет қаралды 24,830

The Trinket Mage

The Trinket Mage

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 306
@AzuriteCoast
@AzuriteCoast 24 күн бұрын
Elk's pic in this looks so nervous to have Maldhound on!
@yusheitslv100
@yusheitslv100 24 күн бұрын
Wolves do hunt deer.
@DinoDan1999
@DinoDan1999 24 күн бұрын
I mean I'd be the same way if a radioactive wolf was next to me
@annoyedhitsuji2865
@annoyedhitsuji2865 24 күн бұрын
😭
@thetyzonator
@thetyzonator 24 күн бұрын
Did you hear how elk melted when maldy called them cute? Ofc they're nervous
@psychedelicsewell
@psychedelicsewell 24 күн бұрын
Can I trust elk? With that mischievous picture? Devious. I think not.
@esergio
@esergio 24 күн бұрын
😂
@GrayVMhan
@GrayVMhan 24 күн бұрын
That's how I look holding a spell pierce hoping the next player taps out with something big
@MothCoveredRock
@MothCoveredRock 24 күн бұрын
I hope every guest eventually joins the cast
@thetrinketmage
@thetrinketmage 24 күн бұрын
then we eventually have like 30 people just yelling over each other
@Thoughtmage100
@Thoughtmage100 24 күн бұрын
​@@thetrinketmage Peak Discord call moment
@valeriosellan284
@valeriosellan284 24 күн бұрын
The council
@commanderpower99
@commanderpower99 23 күн бұрын
@@thetrinketmage average Reddit post
@xxhellspawnedxx
@xxhellspawnedxx 23 күн бұрын
​@@thetrinketmage You're saying that like it wouldn't be epic :P
@tranoscar1068
@tranoscar1068 24 күн бұрын
"one time i burned my hand on a hot lantern and i reacted to the pain..." and the second of silence after it caused me to burst out laughing elk is so fucking funny
@justass3001
@justass3001 24 күн бұрын
Elk’s humor seems to align with mine the most out of almost anyone else I’ve seen, it’s great
@yurisbest2892
@yurisbest2892 24 күн бұрын
“Can you trust content creators” idk I think trinket mage is trying to sell me on artifact decks 24/7
@ra_v2373
@ra_v2373 24 күн бұрын
One thing that I know is that we cannot trust Maldhound's inner thoughts on balance of green
@maldhound
@maldhound 24 күн бұрын
I'm very normal and can be trusted with the Lorax's home address
@jonjonhholt
@jonjonhholt 24 күн бұрын
Every blue players dream is to sign the foreclosure documents on the lorax’s house
@chasm9557
@chasm9557 23 күн бұрын
I feel like it would start with a bat to the kneecaps and end with you calling Tormod to see if he's willing to hide a body in his crypt.
@Hashbrown1682
@Hashbrown1682 22 күн бұрын
​@@maldhoundyou and i know damn well that you're the dude singing "how bad can i really be? "
@CharlesLeeRay812
@CharlesLeeRay812 24 күн бұрын
Slowly assembling the Avengers of Commander content.
@Kulreg777
@Kulreg777 24 күн бұрын
Oh man, I know hes a curmudgeon, but he's the people's champ, we need Demo (EDHDeckbuilding) in here!!
@CharlesLeeRay812
@CharlesLeeRay812 24 күн бұрын
@Kulreg777 I'd like to see him in an episode too. Also, the Nitpicking Nerds would be awesome.
@thatonefirekestral
@thatonefirekestral 24 күн бұрын
Can we get Crim?
@kementurh
@kementurh 24 күн бұрын
But not their pronouns. ​@@CharlesLeeRay812
@erickschusterdeoliveira2662
@erickschusterdeoliveira2662 24 күн бұрын
we need Better Commander in here, brother!
@kopakanuva566
@kopakanuva566 21 күн бұрын
I find it very interesting how a channel I really like, Playing With Power MTG, basically avoids all the pitfalls or creator games you went over. Their videos are super snappy and fast, with an excellent voice over that makes CEDH easy to follow. And since its CEDH theres always many explosive plays AND a lot of interaction without slowing down the video much, I highly recommend them! ☺️
@thetrinketmage
@thetrinketmage 21 күн бұрын
I think playing with power is the best gameplay channel out there!
@fakename3168
@fakename3168 24 күн бұрын
Maybe if we feed the dog it might stay
@alphanick4694
@alphanick4694 23 күн бұрын
We did get to keep the snail after all!
@imboredhowru1
@imboredhowru1 24 күн бұрын
Dream blunt rotation
@tyczynski
@tyczynski 24 күн бұрын
First an Elk, then a Snail and now a Hound? Trinket's zoo is expanding at an alarming rate!
@mac_antonio
@mac_antonio 24 күн бұрын
The awkward silence into “yeah I guess this is a good time to end” gets me every time😂
@hanschristopherson8056
@hanschristopherson8056 24 күн бұрын
Trinket mage, I’m so glad someone from outside the mtggoldfish meta brought up Richard’s just awful take on spot removal
@patches.742
@patches.742 23 күн бұрын
Yea I watch a lot of the goldfish content and he has the craziest commander takes out of anyone online I feel like
@simongpunkt
@simongpunkt 23 күн бұрын
​@@patches.742Wdym Path to Exile is genuinely a good card and not just ramp in aristocrats
@hijjak97
@hijjak97 23 күн бұрын
@@simongpunkt not sure aristocrats particularly likes exiling its own creatures
@1423big
@1423big 24 күн бұрын
I don't ❌trust content creators 🤓 because they keep telling 🫵🏻me run more REMOVAL 🔫and more STAX 🔪 pieces in my casual 👼🏻mtg decks. How dare them.😩 Yes, it makes the games more dynamic 🏃🏻‍♂️ and interesting 🔍... But we need to SMASH 👊🏻 face and BUILD 🏗️only MID-RANGE 📊 piles. 🥺
@MustangMike52
@MustangMike52 24 күн бұрын
Reject interaction embrace battlecruiser
@seanedgar164
@seanedgar164 24 күн бұрын
I don't trust trinket mage because he tells me to run cards I feel ruin games, to help my games 😂
@dnd402
@dnd402 24 күн бұрын
I don't ❌trust content creators 🤓 because they keep telling 🫵🏻me run more REMOVAL 🔫and more STAX 🔪 pieces in my casual 👼🏻mtg decks. How dare them.😩 Yes, it makes the games more dynamic 🏃🏻‍♂ and interesting 🔍... But we need to SMASH 👊🏻 face and BUILD 🏗only MID-RANGE 📊 piles. 🥺
@lracseroom8286
@lracseroom8286 24 күн бұрын
you understand that people have different taste in terms of what makes a good game of EDH than you, yeah? Just because you're a sweaty try hard who couldn't cut it in constructed and need to compensate by playing nothing but hyper optimized EDH decks doesn't make you better than anyone who enjoys midrange games over beers because their self-worth isn't tied to their deck's win ratio. If you're so obsessed with running optimized lists why not play cEDH? Or are you too much of a f'ing scrub for that too?
@fastpuppy2000
@fastpuppy2000 23 күн бұрын
@@lracseroom8286 b8
@fasterbuilder11
@fasterbuilder11 24 күн бұрын
MALDHOUND! On MAGIC MIRROR PODCAST!?!? What crazy universe is this?
@y9y-f9q
@y9y-f9q 24 күн бұрын
There's a handy tip for journalism which states: "Any headline ending with a question mark can be answered NO" and it applies here
@bluetf2622
@bluetf2622 24 күн бұрын
Be right back, gonna make a headline titled "Is life worth living?"
@alicetheaxolotl
@alicetheaxolotl 24 күн бұрын
@@bluetf2622 No
@Kyronex0
@Kyronex0 23 күн бұрын
As someone who's KZbin consumption is 90% while sitting at my desk at work, that "second screen" comment by Mald is 100% accurate
@Blacklodge_Willy
@Blacklodge_Willy 24 күн бұрын
I'd like to add, as far as content creators go, it seems easy to pick on the command zone as they're the biggest of them all (and most likely most influential), but to be fair there is A LOT of removal/ interaction in their gameplay videos.
@KeganKirby
@KeganKirby 24 күн бұрын
Ayyy my 4 favorite small(ish these days) mtg creators on one podcast? This must be a mirage
@SGashesNetwork
@SGashesNetwork 21 күн бұрын
I like your profile pic
@nhlindblom
@nhlindblom 24 күн бұрын
I really liked having Mald here it was kinda nice having a less structured episode and just some bs with the bros it was a relaxing time
@1423big
@1423big 24 күн бұрын
24:20 when they get to the topic of the podcast. ❤️ 56:30 QUESTION ZONE 🌀
@savannahlion3081
@savannahlion3081 22 күн бұрын
Thanks ! 🤘🦁🤘
@AlfaWolf777
@AlfaWolf777 23 күн бұрын
In response to the Idea that losing can be just as fun as winning, i just wanted to mention my favorite MTG memory of recent times. I was playing my Sovereign Okinec Ahau deck, and over the course of one turn, turned a few 2-6 power creatures into 40+ power flying tramplers. I swung for the win, only to be stopped by an Everybody Lives cast for free off of an As Fortold. I got knocked out shortly after that, but left that game incredibly satisfied.
@Melvin-rd3rr
@Melvin-rd3rr 24 күн бұрын
Finally have a 4 player pod. Y’all we are SO BACK.
@hanneskoehler6791
@hanneskoehler6791 24 күн бұрын
The less structured episodes with elks random chaos are what I love most about this podcast (love you elk
@kaloyankitanov6977
@kaloyankitanov6977 23 күн бұрын
46:42 when Trinket Mage said "and I think I'm dead for half of it" I honestly spilled my water
@imaginarymatter
@imaginarymatter 24 күн бұрын
This board state is getting large.
@alkemi9946
@alkemi9946 24 күн бұрын
Suddenly all of my favs on one podcast This is phenomenal, the banter is peak
@567thatoneguy
@567thatoneguy 24 күн бұрын
Best outro so far.
@bleep_bloop1
@bleep_bloop1 24 күн бұрын
Question Zone! - What factors affect how many colorless utility lands you run in a deck? What makes you draw the line on "too many" and what makes you feel like you could push your mana base more? Is the ideal that it only be so much that it almost never interferes with your game plan, or is that tradeoff sometimes worth the cost? For the amount of in-depth land discussion out there, I haven't heard that much about balancing colorless utility, so I'd love your guys' thoughts.
@AeonHeals
@AeonHeals 10 сағат бұрын
You can check Snail's Blame Game precon upgrade for that ^ ^
@waaaaaaah5135
@waaaaaaah5135 23 күн бұрын
With regards to first screen commander content, MTG Goldfish came to mind. I rarely watched their MTGO clashes, but the paper stuff has been amazing stuff that I usually try to watch instead of just listen. I think it comes to a combination of showing their faces as well as their boardstate, leaving in talking and joking around (instead of purely "I play this card and do this thing, pass"), the editing flourishes (small sound effects when they lose health, showing cards on screen, and of course -69 damage getting a "nice" 😎), and knowing when to cut away from shuffling.
@danielsokulski91
@danielsokulski91 22 күн бұрын
ok consider: commander gameplay show, but its fully animated. No ppl around the table, you just watch a tolarian professor, literal hound, Obi-Wan and a communist goblin duke it out in a full-on wizard battle. "oh i tap my llanowar elves for..." NO. You have a close up of an elf doing magic with their hands and summoning a wave of spores that destroys a spider nightmare from another realm that was charging on them.
@CthulhuBut2FeetTall
@CthulhuBut2FeetTall 24 күн бұрын
Maldhound was a delightful guest :)
@kyrios2773
@kyrios2773 24 күн бұрын
“We’re gonna fix you, brother”
@patches.742
@patches.742 23 күн бұрын
I think a big difference about playing removal being engaging during play vs not engaging while watching is that we lack knowledge about what’s in people’s hands. Atleast when you’re playing you know what’s in your hand. I think that’s something the command zone does well sometimes compared to other creators Knowing the meta you play in and what cards you usually have to play around (especially when it comes to having a consistent playgroup) is another layer of fun/complexity that I don’t think is captured anywhere in the content online
@pajurr
@pajurr 23 күн бұрын
Hey I finished the podcast ! Very uncentred, the middle part is interesting to be honest, i liked it. Also, I really do not think content creators are the reason why removal is hated. 2 things : 1- We are in a bubble. Do not think you are like other magic players, we are not the majority. The majority of players do not watch youtube videos about it, and like Wizards said, the vast majority of players play kitchen table magic. The vast majority of content about magic is in english. That's just one language, there are hundreds of them. 2- I play with family and friends that are bad players. My wife's cousin who just started playing, he proxied all her cards with Adventure Time art, so that she becomes interested in Magic. Well, she does not like removal. She has to play against a friend of his that plays no fun stax control "casts Armageddon because it is funny". Well she does not line removal, and has established commander as a format where everyone build their sandcastles on the beach. The winner has the prettiest sandcastle. Well then you have 2 strats for her, 1. Everyone builds something cool and then who has the prettiest. Or 2. Kick the others' sandcastles, and win by having the only one remaining. Aka stax+removal. = Players hating on removal and stax did not wait for youtube to exist. Anyway, that's all for me. Have a good day, from France
@greysonmiller9407
@greysonmiller9407 22 күн бұрын
We could have used this kind of video months earlier. My Salubrillian friend's hands are already wet with the blood of 2 Elkians, and we haven't seen our Trinketarian comrade in weeks.
@natelagrassa9337
@natelagrassa9337 23 күн бұрын
So at 32:12ish where hound talks about frequency of playing… definitely matters! I play maybe once a month for a few hours so when a deck doesn’t perform like it should ONE game I pack it up and grab a different one. I have 36 total and half of them are a year old and need testing so I need many games still for each one and I don’t have that time. So on point for that one! 👍👍🙌
@EmperorC3
@EmperorC3 24 күн бұрын
I like Blighted Woodland in mono-green control to help sneak in null elemental blast.
@FrostedFlakes-ux6dn
@FrostedFlakes-ux6dn 12 күн бұрын
this is one of the most nuanced discussions of removal ive heard online and i appreciate it so much. im in a situation where i run a good bit of removal in a pod that whines about removal and counterspells and doesnt run almost any. i thought they were just being childish in not wanting to cut a couple cards that kind of relate to their theme, but looking at it from the context of "thats how a lot of content creators play" and "well, seeing everyone's deck strategies and combos is more important than winning makes me unferstand it a little more. i still disagree and think thay people should play more removal because THATS what makes a game more interesting, but thank you for this insight
@TheCatHerder
@TheCatHerder 24 күн бұрын
I enjoyed the discussion on why people enjoy being theatrical when their deck pops off.
@slashspade
@slashspade 24 күн бұрын
Trinket mage is gathering up a zoo for us. Elk, Snail, Hound. Just need a few more animals!
@thetyzonator
@thetyzonator 24 күн бұрын
This podcast just keeps getting better and better
@stefanslehofer5315
@stefanslehofer5315 24 күн бұрын
Elk and Maldhound would be a great First Screen Commentary duo
@Sir_Pleasant
@Sir_Pleasant 19 күн бұрын
Best episode by far. The outro gets me every time XD. I would say you guys list too many cards to read out all of them, but just listing the key cards then putting an image of the others cards in passing would help.
@slashspade
@slashspade 24 күн бұрын
38:06 3 to the face is enough to throw most people off their game. I get it
@tra5hg0d81
@tra5hg0d81 22 күн бұрын
17:02 I build my decks around what song would be their theme song if they were pro wrestlers so that’s dope you see the cards similarly.
@drewswanberg6722
@drewswanberg6722 24 күн бұрын
Cardmarket is great at making their mtg content "First screen content". Carl does a great job.
@tartfruit801
@tartfruit801 24 күн бұрын
My current desert deck is my animar deck, it has, 3 protection spells and 3 ramp spells, 6 total inst/sorc The rest is just x spells, value pieces, and mana dorks, it's just fun seeing how many dice I can put on things. Games consist of me small beaning for a while, popping off on turn 6, killing someone out of nowhere, and then dying. But because I put 6 20/20's on the board, I have no complaints when it happens.
@jakiller7
@jakiller7 22 күн бұрын
Personally I find the combination of natural tangents from pre selected topics to be beneficial as it helps to flesh out the personalities and views on the game. Also second time shout out to niv mizzet supreme. Also Mald was handed the opportunity to capitalize on the fan fiction bit
@jcstaff1007
@jcstaff1007 24 күн бұрын
46:07 I can’t speak to games content creators have, but I can speak to games that I’ve played. And amongst friends we bm each other. Armageddon, we play Tergrid. Etc. We even let a player use dockside bc we’re friends and who cares? But online when I try to get in a game of Spelltable. Half the time it’s a big baby crying and ruining the game for everyone because that person got interacted with. I play decks that run 20-ish pieces of interaction (removal, wipes, protection, recursion). So i’m usually the one that says “no” to players popping off and getting ahead. That’s usually when the b*tching and moaning starts, “why are you targeting ME. Why don’t you target someone else’s thing? I’m NOT the threat.” For that reason I think OTHER players don’t run interaction bc there’s negative reinforcement for players to not run interaction and instead play more explosive cards that advance their boards because it’s more fun and leads to less “feel bads” and less annoying people crying over a literal card game. That’s my take. I don’t think it’s just players seeing content creators popping off and seeing fun plays being made. It’s more they don’t like feeling bad or hear someone complaining over a Generous Gift being played.
@BigBosssette
@BigBosssette 17 күн бұрын
"Play more explosive cards that advance their boards because it's more fun... " I feel like you literally explained why people don't play interaction right here. I am definitely someone that doesn't run as much interaction so I would be in the camp that you're talking about and I have to say as someone from that group yeah I definitely would not want to play against someone that has 20 pieces of interaction in their deck. It was mentioned in the video but a lot of people don't get to play a ton of games of magic and so they like to be able to do the thing their deck does. Obviously, I don't think people should be rude or anything to people that play a bunch of interaction, But I certainly wouldn't sit at the table for another round of magic with you. I think that if one fifth of your deck is interaction, then at that point a sub genre of your deck is basically not allowing other people to play their decks. And yeah that annoys people. So yeah I feel like you are trying to have your cake and eat it too. On one hand you want to play interaction and take the game seriously and you want a bunch of strangers to be cool with that. And that's just not an option. You can control that in your personal playgroup where it seems like you get to play all the cards that you want, but just like people that don't like interaction can't control what other people do, you as someone who likes a lot of interaction can't control how other people feel about interaction.
@jcstaff1007
@jcstaff1007 17 күн бұрын
@@BigBosssette So, a) i defined interaction as both PROTECTION, RECURSION, AND REMOVAL and WIPES all in the same category. So 1/5 of the deck being stuff that does something other than directly influence your gameplan doesn’t seem too far-fetched to me. B) you’re 100% entitled to your opinion that you wouldn’t have fun at a table with me, but i believe Magic is Magic BECAUSE you CAN interact with others. Making EDH into a race of who can get off the their strategy the fastest instead of balanced decks ready for anything and everything seems extremely boring and I PERSONALLY wouldn’t want to be playing against players like yourself. And im entitled to that opinion. C) ESPECIALLY IF YOU ONLY HAVE VERY LITTLE TIME TO PLAY MAGIC, i would include MORE INTERACTION. Why? So i can play the game. Someone out there is going to have a Dranith Magistrate that’s going to lock out my commander. So i need removal. Someone is going to board wipe, so I need protection. Someone is going to blow up my stuff, so i need recursion. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to have these basic necessities in your deck and i don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect you to be able to potentially play around it. I interact with you, you interact with me. Just like this comment. Or would you rather you scream into the void and no one to hear it? EDH is a social game BECAUSE its interactive. You CAN politic, you CAN make deals. Interacting with your opponent(s) is a dialogue. It’s a back and forth. I expect you to stop me. And i expect you to have things I want to stop. If you like the game to be 4 separate instances of Goldfishing (playing by your self) then go ahead and do so. But i think that’s just a sad way to be.
@BigBosssette
@BigBosssette 17 күн бұрын
Yep. That's fair. And I find your way of playing a sad way to be. I'm not saying you aren't entitled to your opinion. I just think that for every person who you you say is being a cry baby there are very aggressive people like you that think your way of playing is best. And people think that is equally vibe ruining and unfun to play against. I think you paint your opposition as the only kind of people that are annoying to play with at the table when people that play like you can also be unfun to play against given peoples tastes. I don't think interaction makes magic magic because many card games do this in different ways. I don't think you are playing TRUE magic any more or less than I'm playing magic. But comments from people who like to play like you seem to express that. That your way of playing is right and everyone else's is wrong. It is even expressed in this video of all the times people say "you can play how you want but..." And then basically advise people to play the game the way they think it should be played. We will obviously never see the game the same way or see what is fun the same way. The conversation just seems to be very one sided.
@Trufflegator
@Trufflegator 22 күн бұрын
Maldhound really hit the nail on the head. I play once a week, I wanna proactively do something cool
@lucyarisato6850
@lucyarisato6850 13 күн бұрын
I’m a simple woman. I see Maldhound, I click. (Genuinely a wonderful episode, glad to see more.)
@Temzilla2
@Temzilla2 22 күн бұрын
1:11:11 oh hey look funny timestamp, but currently my 7 favorite decks out of my 20 or so, are my 5 mono color decks (Gaffer life gain, Arcanis Omniscience, Drivnod big death triggers, MH3 Ashling mono red control, and Kosei Primal Surge), my Zhulodok colorless deck, and a 3 color Marneus Calgar clue deck that I could have absolutely made into a 4 color deck, in order to add all the juicy deep clue sea green clue generator cards, but cutting back to 3 colors evolved that deck into a secret commander Tezzeret, Master at the Bridge deck, where I try to play tezzeret out to dome everyone for 20+ damage. The mono color decks are really fun to build, I took apart my mono color decks to make the current 5, but I think at some point I might have more than 1 of each mono color deck kept together, the previous five were delney (as elk said, card advantage isn't so hard, I remember a game against a mono blue deck and a Greensleeves deck, and at one point I had more lands than the greensleeves player, and had a thinner library than the mono blue player.), Azami (a rediscovery of how busted wizards are, was semi-competitive), Sheoldred // The True Scriptures (tried to do all graveyard stuff, mill, reanimate, mass reanimate, cares about cards being milled, cares about cards in graveyard etc.), Calamity (This deck was fun but was like playing with an unloaded gun in the command zone, and sometimes you just didn't draw any bullets.), and Kodama/Gilanra (manually storm out and put the deck onto the battlefield).
@ianwhite7246
@ianwhite7246 19 күн бұрын
Kharn is actually so cool. I would make copies with him using delina and draw a grip when the tokens disappeared
@Joebob31100
@Joebob31100 20 күн бұрын
Question Zone: What do you guys do for work, and it paid more, would you buy more expensive cards? Also, I absolutely loved your Guest's point on modern Commander being closer to a board game night to a lot of the newer players. That feels like it 100% nailed the vibe to me of a lot of playgroups I see right now.
@Punkmation
@Punkmation 23 күн бұрын
I want to clip Elk saying "You have to pay 5 mana for it" through gritted teeth and play it every time someone asks me about a costy card
@surplusvalue5497
@surplusvalue5497 22 күн бұрын
This was an especially good episode. I don't watch his content but the dog man had some thoughtful and interesting takes.
@partlytwin6735
@partlytwin6735 23 күн бұрын
"cut it mid se-" Genius
@GIyphix_
@GIyphix_ 4 күн бұрын
This makes me wanna start a podcast group with my friends, this sparked many topics in my mind for many topics and things I haven’t heard necessarily brought up often.
@KumaSC2
@KumaSC2 24 күн бұрын
My two favorite mtg content creators in one podcast. Can't wait to listen to this on my way home!
@jonathanrichman2330
@jonathanrichman2330 24 күн бұрын
I think one aspect to the lack of removal in people’s decks is that they watch more commander content than they play. So people have the expectation of minimal to no single target removal when making their decks. I’ve played against too many people in LGS’ who got salty after their threat was removed then preceded to get irrationally emotional. My guess is that the viewing experience from content is centered around them and their enjoyment; so when they get interacted with, that illusion of what they expected to occur is shattered. People weren’t celebrating their genius use of Exquisite Blood + Sanguine Bond, we killed it on the stack or the second it hit the table then moved on. The experience shifted from one focused around them to one that is communal. I just hope more people actually play magic/commander since that is the best way to fix the issues with their decks.
@Kobold1650
@Kobold1650 24 күн бұрын
I play plenty of removal in my decks. It still doesn't feel good to have your stuff removed. I've personally took a player out for countering one of my spells, cause I have lethal, and you decided to draw attention to yourself.
@once.upon.a.time.
@once.upon.a.time. 23 күн бұрын
I'm fairly new to commander (and not particularly good, I just like getting to do stuff), and when I first started I had a lot of removal. Perhaps my playgroup is just extra salty but I ended up taking out most counters and removal and replacing them with bounces or swat stuff. And I try not to target anything until the player gets to use it at least once or something. However, that's just what I prefer because personally I don't really play to win, I just want to engage in shenanigans and see other people's decks do what they do. I have also seen people get very annoyed with removal and maybe I'm just too sensitive myself but I'd rather avoid all conflict haha
@jonathanrichman2330
@jonathanrichman2330 23 күн бұрын
@ My perspective on removal definitely changed over time. Initially I just took it as part of the game, but when I played Friday Night Magic with strangers, I started to remove it from my decks after people started to sometimes get confrontational about it. Nowadays I think they are some of the coolest plays in commander! 2 weeks ago a friend of mine played the 5 mana counterspell that creates thopters equal to the mana value of the spell countered, to counter my 11 mana value hydra that I was playing to win the game with some +1+1 counter moving shenanigans. So instead of me winning, he got 11 thopters which he made into 4/4s with Brudiclad and then with all my blockers, I exactly died to the last thopter token. Neither of us won the game, but I think I’m going to remember the play for a long time. I even made an Eluge deck afterwards that plays all of the silly high mana value counter spells to make my own hype moments like that in the future!
@once.upon.a.time.
@once.upon.a.time. 23 күн бұрын
@@jonathanrichman2330 that's interesting! So your solution to the salt would be to play higher cost removal that adds interaction or does something neat? I'll have to look into that more, thanks for the ideas 😄
@jonathanrichman2330
@jonathanrichman2330 23 күн бұрын
@ the nice part about niche removal spells is that they are usually super cheap since they were made for an old limited format! Like in my poison/proliferate deck, I use two counterspells that only work if the target is poisoned and I use Glen Elendra Archmage as a repeatable counterspell since I can give her +1/+1 counters to remove the -1/-1 counter so I can keep sacrificing her to stop really scary noncreature spells. I made a $50 budget Vishgraz deck with the theme of blinking. So some of the removal spells I chose are: Acidic Slime, Reclamation Sage, Knight of the Autumn, and Ravenous Chupacabra. The idea is that just getting the effect once is great, but occasionally being able to flicker them to remove another target is amazing! Modal spells like Knight of the Autumn are awesome since if I need to remove a pesky artifact or enchantment, I can do that on the first enters the battlefield, but if I need life gain or just want a bigger creature, I can choose the modes later! So modal removal spells that can also further your own game plan or take out a scary target are awesome spells to add to your deck!
@RavenHeartization
@RavenHeartization 23 күн бұрын
I am a believer in Richard from MTG goldfish, he actually plays a lot of removal but it's board wipes and land based affects, the more I play commander the stronger it feels. I genuinely think his more competitive decks would beat most of the hosts ones
@philoc7063
@philoc7063 24 күн бұрын
That outro was gold btw
@andresarancio6696
@andresarancio6696 23 күн бұрын
Interesting talk about the different metas. Something I realized over time that my LGS' meta is primarily driven by very content creator-inspired games, which brings a ton of issues when I sit with a responsible deck that has more than one counterspell and two removals (the average I see there). It is so normal for me to see someone play decks that ramp and draw cards into oblivion, but rarely manage to win effectively, or fold over to a single piece of interaction played correctly. Meanwhile I usually get side glances on any stormy deck that goes from zero to a million without playing any super well known card or without a lot of board presence On the topic of Magic becoming first screen content: Card Market does it. Their process of "interviews" in the middle of games helps a ton making interactive gameplay really matter
@jamesloder8652
@jamesloder8652 18 күн бұрын
I had no idea Snail was on another channel! Neat!
@paulhedges4625
@paulhedges4625 23 күн бұрын
I think your section about the difference in playgroups was quite interesting! I'm part of the group that rarely gets games of commander (sometimes zero a month) and so, when they do happen, the most important thing for me is to have everyone play the game. Our playgroup even enables this by allowing people to take as many free mulligans as they want (though we give people crap past mulligan three). Stax and full-on control are soft banned? In that those decks don't show up but are completely fine. But I and one of the friends in that group like playing very competitive Magic, where control, stax, aggro, and combo are all on the table. And since our commander games are much less intense and lean towards midrange-y value, we decided to just play modern/pioneer/canlander with each other. I will note that our commander games are interactive; everyone is playing boardwipes, targeted removal, graveyard hate, protection, and counterspells. Not nearly as much as a cEDH deck, of course, but it's there.
@jacobd1984
@jacobd1984 24 күн бұрын
100% that Niv fanfic involves multiple Niv-mizzets and they’re all hot to go
@Phoenix_9624
@Phoenix_9624 23 күн бұрын
yesterday, i was a couple of seconds into this video and i injured myself at work 😂😂, and now that im out of work for a couple of days, it gives me a great excuse to finish this video 😂😂, love your content woodland critters and bauble mage
@thetrinketmage
@thetrinketmage 23 күн бұрын
Sorry to hear that hopefully you’re alright!
@Phoenix_9624
@Phoenix_9624 23 күн бұрын
@ im all good, i ran over my foot with a loaded pallet jack, i went to the doctor and they said no fractures or anything, im just pretty banged up and they put me in a boot, but i appreciate the concern :)
@natelagrassa9337
@natelagrassa9337 23 күн бұрын
So one of my favorite decks is narset enlightened master, but I don’t play the infinite turn loops. It’s a whole deck revolving around possibility storm and super friends, and artifacts. But it locks people out and shuts down control decks. I love it. 😂😂😂
@curtissearle6462
@curtissearle6462 22 күн бұрын
Glad to welcome the 4th permanent member of the podcast Mald! Lol
@grip7777
@grip7777 23 күн бұрын
Great guest and fun pod, keep it up fellas!
@kirchofer1563
@kirchofer1563 24 күн бұрын
This is something to look forward too!!!
@nachoman9600
@nachoman9600 24 күн бұрын
I think I saw an example of main screen commander content done by Big Deck Energy. Granted it was shock collar commander, but it required more attention to detail from the viewer to understand the extra bit. And if you understand the ins and outs of triggers and rules, it's that much more satisfying to feel the tension of "will they remember that trigger."
@rhysbenson2061
@rhysbenson2061 23 күн бұрын
“We thought you were a react creator.” Maldhound: “I am a react creator, or rather, a react creator as they were meant to be.”
@Magical_Sound_Shower
@Magical_Sound_Shower 23 күн бұрын
Adding Slicer and/or Alexios are good ways to make Mogis better due to the fact they can’t be sacrificed and are good damaging threats.
@DJSoSadRN
@DJSoSadRN 23 күн бұрын
I made a 180-card cube out of the Foundations starter collect and took out goblin negotiation and I think you’ve convinced me to put it back in.
@_Carlos
@_Carlos 23 күн бұрын
You guys talking about Fiend hunter loops reminded me of one game I played, years ago when Lorwyn was standard, it was an elemental aggro deck, so "champion a creature" was relevant. I can't remember what I was playing against but I was losing, and didn't want a loss on my record, so I set up a 3 creature "champion a creature" loop with no other targets. We had to call over a judge because my opponent didn't understand why the game was a draw.
@dicedude1071
@dicedude1071 24 күн бұрын
Looking forward to next week's fanfic episode
@claytonwilde5750
@claytonwilde5750 22 күн бұрын
My favorite part of this episode was when Maldhound said “it’s malding time” and malded all over everyone
@shrinkydink9217
@shrinkydink9217 23 күн бұрын
Would love to see Deck Driver as a guest in the future! Your styles of content are like peas in a pod.
@kissenger8454
@kissenger8454 12 сағат бұрын
My favorite two casual decks rn are Mindskinner and Sovereign Okinec. Mindskinner doesn’t win games. I run a lot of interaction and protection my joy in that comes from people’s reaction to being milled and the ability to protect my game plan. The sovereign is nearly pure synergy but I run a lot of removal to get through. My joy in that one comes from making giant threats consistently
@jaceg810
@jaceg810 24 күн бұрын
Question Zone: What is your opinion on light staxx that incentivizes interaction, things like Ethersworn Canonist, deafening silence, Charitable Levy and Stone of Erech. Basically anything that limits options while not being desolation.
@DarkJusticeMetal
@DarkJusticeMetal 24 күн бұрын
Elk is giving me the "why are you playing this" eyes
@condorman6293
@condorman6293 24 күн бұрын
Please, please make the card art larger. The mirror shouldn't be taking up so much screen real estate. It's really hard for me to read the card text
@TheTicatic10
@TheTicatic10 24 күн бұрын
MOM CAN WE KEEP HIM TOO
@thetrinketmage
@thetrinketmage 24 күн бұрын
we can't do this with every guest! But he is welcome back whenever
@webbc99
@webbc99 22 күн бұрын
In defense of Richard - Up to you if you believe it or not, but he maintains (according to their podcasts) that his playstyle and approach to commander works even better outside of the Clash meta. In personally have adopted his approach and it works exceptionally well imo. Additionally, their ban list does ban some fast mana stuff, but the most recent bans were Field of the Dead and Glacial Chasm which are two Richard staples.
@freaklikeme211
@freaklikeme211 22 күн бұрын
Re: Making Gameplay interesting to watch I really enjoy watching the North 100 Showdowns because the actual thoughts and theoretical lines are just openly discussed. Maybe some form of commander content focussed on one player with their decisions and thoughts on the game is the way to make gameplay more engaging/interesting to watch.
@shmackydoo
@shmackydoo 24 күн бұрын
Awesome guest! Learned so much from him
@thembosupremepizza1827
@thembosupremepizza1827 24 күн бұрын
blighted woodland fits well in oops all explosive veg and teaches green players how to hold mana up
@thembosupremepizza1827
@thembosupremepizza1827 24 күн бұрын
HE MENTIONED RADHA LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOOO
@ethanglaeser9239
@ethanglaeser9239 24 күн бұрын
Just saying Mald, I would watch you make more "reaction" content about gameplay clips framed as a sports commentator. Draw on the screen with the yellow lines and circles like you're watching NFL replays, and act like the smallest things are hugely exciting.
@patches.742
@patches.742 23 күн бұрын
Yes I think this would be hilarious and somewhat innovative
@taa347
@taa347 22 күн бұрын
I loved this talk, it was great
@danielpaxton3560
@danielpaxton3560 21 күн бұрын
My Mogis slug deck also has some troubles, but imo, he’s fantastic in Neegan as it helps get more damage around or I get treasures.
@FroPlamondon
@FroPlamondon 24 күн бұрын
That outro was perfect
@BrutusAshes
@BrutusAshes 24 күн бұрын
59:17 a little secret, play these search lands in Flubs and play ancient greenwarden so you can constantly do it from your grave while pitching lands to your graveyard, you go to zero cards in hand and pick up a spell from the draw play that spell if it's good then do it again because when you play that spell you have no cards in hand so you pick up another card.
@BrutusAshes
@BrutusAshes 24 күн бұрын
My personal deck tech
@isidoreaerys8745
@isidoreaerys8745 23 күн бұрын
34:00 I think you guys are pretty jaded about This aspect. Think of it this way: if you’re in a race does it feel better if both players do their best and set a new world record… Or would you prefer game where player two Immediately trips player one who busts his ankle, and player three is just sitting at the starting line in a lawnchair with .22 caliber pistol. I get that you need answers because player four is building a teleportation machine at the starting line which will transport him immediately to the finish line in a completely predictable and boring way. But the rest is a matter of personal taste…personally , I enjoy games where both players Play good honest magic and use their removal items to sculpt the board and make the match more competitive rather than everyone playing 1 million farewells and cyclonic rifts Until finally someone limps past the finish line by being the most resilient or underhanded.
@33elk
@33elk 23 күн бұрын
We never mentioned farewell and cyc rift I think? (do correct me if im wrong) We're just generally talking about removal.
@yawg691
@yawg691 19 күн бұрын
Your comment really brings home to me how much I hate multiplayer Magic lol
@Hashbrown1682
@Hashbrown1682 22 күн бұрын
This Maldhound guy seems very interesting. I wonder what he thinks of which commander can and can't "get it"?
@aronarguello982
@aronarguello982 24 күн бұрын
I would love a commander gameplay vid between you four, using decks that are very much *not* great for content = )
@qazaq25
@qazaq25 24 күн бұрын
Regarding first screen commander gameplay videos I'd say the only one I reliably enjoy is "cEDH TV Gameplay". Between the games being shorter/edited being able to see all the hands and getting to hear each players thought patterns it feels far more compeling then others I've tried watching
@sparkierss3189
@sparkierss3189 24 күн бұрын
Blighted woodland is fun in patron of the orochi cause lands entering tapped mean absolutely nothing to them
@toromisher
@toromisher 22 күн бұрын
Asking if they watch Bleach into talking about laying a metaphorical path in front of you. I'm sad none of them got to appreciate that reference to Ichigo and Unohana going through the garganta. 10/10 reference and writing advice xD
Is Reliquary Tower Good? | Magic Mirror Podcast Episode 11 #mtg
55:39
The Trinket Mage
Рет қаралды 21 М.
The Biggest Mistakes You Can Make in Commander | Commander Clash Podcast 149
1:13:05
Support each other🤝
00:31
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 55 МЛН
It’s all not real
00:15
V.A. show / Магика
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
How many people are in the changing room? #devil #lilith #funny #shorts
00:39
UFC 310 : Рахмонов VS Мачадо Гэрри
05:00
Setanta Sports UFC
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
We React To Your Ragequit and Salt Stories | Commander Clash Podcast 135
1:03:15
MTGGoldfish Commander
Рет қаралды 78 М.
Hs player rates classic Foundations mtg cards
1:13:34
CovertGoBlue
Рет қаралды 101 М.
#EVERYTHINGISCONTENT: Let's Play Magic: The Gathering
2:14:11
Critical Role
Рет қаралды 224 М.
The Lessons that EDH-only Players Don't Learn
13:58
Salubrious Snail
Рет қаралды 125 М.
Ranking Every Color Pair in EDH | Magic Mirror Podcast Episode 15 #mtg
1:24:24
MTG Restricted List BREAKS Yu-Gi-Oh! Player
1:06:25
CovertGoBlue
Рет қаралды 153 М.
How to be the Archenemy | Magic Mirror Podcast Episode 7 #mtg
1:07:43
The Trinket Mage
Рет қаралды 23 М.
Roasting Each Other's Decks | Magic Mirror Podcast Episode 8 #mtg
1:24:33
The Trinket Mage
Рет қаралды 31 М.
Every Goomba Glitch in Super Mario 64
2:24:13
pannenkoek2012
Рет қаралды 522 М.
Support each other🤝
00:31
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 55 МЛН