2020 Peugeot 508 GT v Mazda 6 Atenza comparison: wagon showdown | CarAdvice

FULL STORY: www.caradvice.com.au/804632/2...
#Peugeot's back in the big-car game with its striking new 508 GT. But can the wagon variant beat one of the best load-luggers in the mainstream segment: the #Mazda6 Atenza?
-------------------------------------------------------------
CarAdvice.com is where Australians turn to for the most comprehensive independent reviews of new cars.
Our videos are created by expert and unbiased journalists who are passionate about their work. We have fun making these videos and we hope you enjoy them too.
We welcome the opportunity to answer your questions and encourage discussion. Don’t hesitate to ask us a question in the comments section.
Subscribe to #CarAdvice for your regular fix of automotive news, reviews and entertainment.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR KZbin CHANNEL HERE
kzbin.info_cente...
CONNECT WITH US
- / caradvice
- / caradvice
- / car_advice
JOIN OUR EMAIL NEWSLETTER
Get the latest news, reviews and videos fast-tracked to your inbox by registering for 'The Shortcut' here: www.caradvice.com.au/theshortc...

[@paulfromperth5713]

I bought the Peugeot wagon 6 weeks ago and I absolutely love it. People look at, the exterior and interior design are fantastic, the unusual driving position takes a bit of getting used and the steering wheel is amazing. Never thought I’d ever buy a Peugeot. But with a 5 year unlimited is warranty I had no choice. I was looking at the Mazda as well but it felt too out dated.

[@Drivecomau]

Thanks for your feedback! It is a very good looking car.

[@heinedenmark]

I'll take the Mazda any day. With the 2.2l diesel and the 6 speed manual.

[@rajg825]

Diesel is notoriously unreliable in the Mazda 6. Stand clear!

[@PeterCulka]

just bought a mazda 6. Have had my fair share of PSA Group vehicle troubles.

[@chriscoates5427]

I have a 2013 Mazda 6 GT wagon and had a Mazda 3 before. No problems with either car. Peugeot sells so few cars in Australia, a major concern would be spare parts availability. The Pug is a very nice looking vehicle, and good to see another wagon as an alternative to the ridiculous number of SUV's in the market.

[@aussie8114]

Mazda ✅

[@johnnjoroge6329]

Thanks for the review, it quite cuts out research work. I'd however love details on ground clearance and suspensions

[@Nonbelieverification]

According to European spec the Mazda 6 Sportwagon has 522 liters of trunk space (compared to your 506 liters). Always wonder how it is measured as there does not seem to be consensus for some models.

[@gregcoleman6670]

Is the reason the pug seats don't fold flat is that the head rests are all the way down? Raise them a little and they fall into the leg well rather than hit the seat??

[@bsct71]

lol. the Peugeot low steering wheel is great. less stress on your arms and easier to see the clocks. once you adapt your driving style it's better then everything else

[@lopezben3023]

, . NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. , , , , ,

[@hughventer2934]

7:52 what is that song?

[@kmuinde]

That peugeot beauty is unresistable, I will consider a used one in 5 years time

[@bigchief2331]

You wont have to wait that long. Peugeot depreciate more than 50% after just 2 years. Will be a great used car buy, hope some businesses buy them for their fleet so I can pick up a bargain at the auctions in 2-3 years time.

[@redwhite_040]

But the reliability is a thing though.The Mazda on the other hand will be still reliable after 100.000km.

[@kmuinde]

Back in the day we used to have very reliable peugeots 504 and 405 they were very popular in my country especially the 504

[@bigchief2331]

@@redwhite_040 No, it is not a 'thing' at all. Peugeot is actually right at the top when it comes to reliability, check the most recent UK report. It will be just as reliable as any car, provided you look after it and service on time. They had a patchy period but as of 2010 or so they've turned themselves around and invested millions in research and development, sourcing quality parts etc.

[@urabusliberty9258]

redwhite_040 my mums Peugeot lasted 18 years and for the last 7 years of its life it was abused and got rid of it because is would of cost more to fix than it’s worth it was only leaking injectors and it had 270.000 km

[@patriceelder1313]

I prefer a wagon over an SUV and yet in America one is limited to luxury wagons priced over $100,000! I love Mazda and the Atenza is just what I’m looking for. Is it possible to get one shipped to America?

[@glennbrown7241]

Interesting comparison. I really like the new Peugeot 508. But why no mega test; ŠKODA Superb, Volkswagen Passat, Ford Mondeo (in Wagon variants) etc. Seriously, 2 ads by 4:38sec!!!

[@lopezben3023]

º º NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. º º º

[@sticksman7819]

2 very nice looking cars.the Peugeot does look better with 19" alloys but I think I'd go for the Mazda.

[@france4me117]

Peugeot 508GT all the way ... I love mine and it's a head-turner and very good drive. Also in regards to the steering position due to the iCockpit design, it's not a problem as all you need to do is adjust the height of the steering and position the seat to your prepared height ... Also, to the point that a wagon is really designed for space and family and not judged to whether it's 2.6 or 1.6 for that matter. I had 4 Mazda's and yes for this, certainly Peugeot 508GT all the way ...

[@ln5747]

Nah, Pug is a pig with lipstick on.

[@kimmern999]

I have the liftback version of that 508. Gotta say, the wagon is just as mean looking. Well done by Peugeot.

[@Nicholas.T]

Rusty Galloway. I haven’t driven one, but personally I would think that it might be a bit underpowered, particularly for a $60,000 vehicle. Rusty, how are you finding it’s performance since owning it(the liftback version) ?

[@kimmern999]

@Nicholas T: I’m sorry to say that I live in Europe and have another spec that’s even more «underpowered». That said, the car feels very light and nimble for its size. It’s just a bit firmer than cars in its class too. I do like the ride quality very much. But as I said, I can’t give you any indicators on engine performance. I use mine as a family car. 🙂👍

[@selldivision]

Sam and Jez are a much better combo. Nice work. Can I have the Peugeot with the Mazda engine please?

[@Nicholas.T]

s d The perfect combination - the Peugeot with the Mazda engine!

[@matthewrafferty4117]

That Pug looks absolutely fantastic for a wagon. One question I have though is this car based on the ZB Commodore/Opel Insignia? The unloved Commodore at the current prices looks like unbeatable value with all the safety tech plenty of room and decent sized engines not to mention the availability of All Wheel Drive.

[@Nicholas.T]

Matthew Rafferty No Matthew, this car was in the design stage before Peugeot bought Opel off GM.

[@REPOMAN24722]

The commodore wagons are going for as low as 24k new now, no one is buying them, an absolute steal at that price.

[@tornado0925]

Mazda 6 all the way

[@F1Kamel_1992]

I reckon the Peugeot is the best looking estate but if you prefer reliability record the Mazda is the one to go for.

[@germie7666]

Horrific ad content in this review. Also, lots of talk on the engine outputs of the Peugeot but none on the 6. If it has the new turbo in it it’s arguable got more pull over taking advantage going up hills?

[@Drivecomau]

Thanks for the feedback. We'll ensure output details are more clear in future clips.

[@demihani5062]

What suburb is this? From around 8:55

[@Nicholas.T]

The new Sydney suburb of Breakfast Point on the Parramatta river near Mortlake. Now fully developed, construction commenced about 20 years ago on a former industrial site. A mixture of free standing houses, apartment towers, villas and town houses, it has a very lovely village atmosphere, with mostly American architectural style.

[@demihani5062]

Nicholas T ah, thank you!

[@angusludwig-mcdougall5431]

Too many ads in this review.

[@tbone5654]

10 years on and most the population still hasn't discovered free add blocker browser plugins. Humans are daft.

[@lopezben3023]

º º NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. º º º

[@AgsyMixChannel]

In terms of reliability then I would go for Mazda, end of story. 😁

[@romeotrinh6415]

So Mazda is cheaper Give you more

[@aydinbaltali]

Where is the mazda 6 engine?

[@aadi8568]

Mazda is the better buy, the reliability, the interior quality, the handling and those beautiful looks. It will definitely retain its value more than the unreliable pugeot.

[@xanthuumnihyr5319]

www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2019-uk-vehicle-dependability-study-0 Or maybe not

[@garnray8568]

BS.

[@gregburville3368]

Don't forget to mention the warranty and the five year servicing costs. BTW. Mazda.

[@REPOMAN24722]

They still have 6 months servicing? haha what a joke.

[@Antoineforum]

Peugeot is awesome 💎

[@lopezben3023]

, . NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. , , , , ,

[@Antoineforum]

@@lopezben3023 Please, again... Don't text when you're drunk

[@lopezben3023]

@@Antoineforum . . 😊 .

[@ramzi2669]

Peugot anytime

[@billkatsikanis5852]

Comprehensive testing indeed. By taking out a measuring tape. How about testers really put these family vehicles under typical family driving conditions. Try loading them up with luggage and throw 4 to five people in the car and take them for a drive. You'll then discover how the handling, suspension, fuel consumption and engine operate. A punesy 1.4 litre engine with 300Nm isn't going to cut it with me under full load.

[@markpaterson6024]

Agreed, I have seen so many so called “in depth” reviews that never go over 40 km/h around suburbs. If you only want to do that get an electric buggy! For me now passengers and weight is not a huge issue, I am looking for comfort, quiet, fuel efficiency and luxury options, like massaging & heated seats, decent sound system, climate control, adaptive cruise control, etc, etc. Not many mid sized wagons offer all that in one package these days for this price range.

[@craighill746]

Play Duran Duran on the audio.

[@peterjansen7854]

Picked up my mazda wagon 2023 in nov😆 european car in australia dont think so

[@jaylocke9574]

Too many adds. I got about 6 for this little review. Boo KZbin, boo!

[@lopezben3023]

º º NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. º º º

[@kylesoler4139]

Am I the only one who get's late 90's Mitsubishi Galant vibes from the 508?

[@nicogoris]

Mazda is de volvo of Japan. Sober but high quality. My peace of cake

[@Dan4096]

18" wheels more comfort, cheaper tyres. Function over form.

[@marksakowski9272]

And "PARTICULATE FILTER" that will get stuffed in 10,000 km!

[@lopezben3023]

º º NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. º º º

[@Dan4096]

@@marksakowski9272 what's your evidence for that?

[@markpaterson6024]

@@Dan4096 None I would guess. Some other dirty diesel vehicles had filter clogging issues, but with a high octane low emission fuel I would say the filters would be good for at least 100,000

[@charlesa1234]

as much as I love Mazda cars, the Peugeot’s interior and exterior look more premium like its a class above the Mazda6

[@litogor]

Those who prefer the Mazda are crazy! The Peugeot is much more beautiful and is better to drive -----> no fight possible ...

[@Drivecomau]

Thanks for the feedback!

[@germie7666]

Except the engine in the Mazda, if the Cx9 turbo, is better for hauling 4 people is better from most accounts. In saying that our old MY10 Mazda 6 Wagon with the 2.5L never struggled with four on board + dog + roof pod.

[@xanthuumnihyr5319]

@@germie7666 Depends on what you call "struggling". I don't see the pug nor the mazda struggling in that situation

[@xanthuumnihyr5319]

@@germie7666 Depends on what you call "struggling". I don't see the pug nor the mazda struggling in that situation

[@jeanneoone3593]

508 super

[@jeanpeup]

by far better engine, by far better reliability, look is more subjective but I also prefer the more classy and timeless design of the Mazda so not even a close contest in my book. The Peugeot is more "original" and has better infotainment but I don't really care about that.

[@garnray8568]

"the more classy and timeless design of the Mazda"...... LOL what a clown you are... The Peugeot 508 wipes the floor with that Mazda. So much better looking. You need to get to your head checked.

[@veselingramatikov]

Mazda is much better design first. Peugot is so over the top... also Mazda is the better car.

[@litogor]

You will not convince very few people because it is obvious that the Peugeot is a range above for the design ...

[@veselingramatikov]

@@litogor above ? Give me a break ..

[@bigchief2331]

Give me the Peugeot. They are absolutely killing it right now, all their cars are great. They have a premium feel about them and drive beautifully. Aussies need to wake up to themselves and stop buying Korean junk or Japanese cars with their claustrophobic interiors and dated tech, cheap interiors. For the same money you can get a beautiful Pug with brand pedigree, good looks, quality German (Bosch) and BMW/mini shared engines, traditional auto gearbox, functional and high-class interior and a drive that is unrivalled. Peugeot = quality.

[@markpaterson6024]

Dammit Chief! You got me sold! 😝 I am looking at a 508 GT Line wagon which will probably be my last car to purchase (I’m getting up there in years) Don’t like Mazda, Toyota, Hyundai, VW (not bad but shitty after sales if any) And I’m sick of the sight of SUV’s let alone own one.

[@ln5747]

The Pug is cheap once you spend some time in it. Had a few on rental with work and didn't like them. They're cheap under the surface.

[@bigchief2331]

@@ln5747 No it’s not. My 2015 308 is holding up beautifully. Everyone who gets in is amazed at the quality of the interior.

[@ln5747]

@@bigchief2331 incorrect statement, I wasn't (impressed). It is cheap once you spend time with Pugs.

[@bigchief2331]

@@ln5747 nope you’re wrong

[@methkeo3421]

I will happily take the Mazda thank you.

[@tonybennett638]

I think I may have actually talked to someone who almost bought a Peugeot... almost.

[@deaddoll1361]

So the Peugeot boot is “a few inches” wider? Australia adopted the metric system about 50 years ago, however some seem to have missed the memo. It’s bad enough that the US staunchly ignores the rest of the world, but if Australians are so overexposed to US video product that they’ve become confused as to their nationality, I suggest seeking immediate remedial therapy.

[@aindoria]

I am sorry all of you rest worlders are wrong.

[@bulentmakul4761]

Mazda ❤ jinba ittai, arigato mazda engineers

[@medroastt9888]

in country where I live that peugeot will cost 50% more than that mazda

[@macak321]

People saying that peugeot looks good... what are you smoking?

[@isaialeuila9327]

Mazda 6 it will age gracefully!!!

[@user-pj6bd3vm2o]

Just mazda

[@lopezben3023]

. .- . NOT, NOT, NOT ... Peuge-NOT. . .

[@scottthompson7009]

Or maybe buy a VW Passat or Skoda Superb for about 10k less

[@germie7666]

Scott Thompson I like those choices but the Mazda GT has most of the fruit and is several grand cheaper.

[@ln5747]

Not with DSG shit

[@anemite2]

Lol Mazda, Peugeot is on a whole new level in quality and technology, it rival with Audi, bmw and MB wagons not the wannabe Mazda

[@1ohtaf1]

Peugeots make the best coral reefs.

[@anemite2]

@@kseppi77 lol, been the 2nd most sold brand in Europe, the most demanding market IN THE WORLD and having multi awarded vehículos and engines worldwide really is a reflect of bad quality Lol try harder mazdeto😉

[@anemite2]

@@kseppi77 you could say the same as VW is also a group, and yet the most recognizable brand of PSA is peugeot still even if you count the cars sold by each invididual brand you will see how mazda stay wayyyyy behind any of the PSA brands, thats because europe in general is not easily impressed by the "wannabe "japanese mazda mazda is just a regular japanese brand compared to toyota or honda, which without trying to impress fools, they can achieve really good cars in general

[@anemite2]

@@kseppi77 funny enough, peugeot sell much more cars than mazda , also how many awards has mazda won, i know, zero, none of his cars are worth enough to be recognized, while peugeot has over 3 *car of the year* awards with recent vehicules and also it was their line of engines, the puretech who got the recognition from the experts and media for been excellent engines, while mazda is all about marketing about their skyactiv engines, which promise both perfomance and fuel consumption and deliver nothing really extraordinary, their 2.5 petrol engine has a good HP, but is practically the biggest 4 cil engine on the market so it couldnt make sense that it didnt as for the skyactive X, which promise diesel consumption with V6 power, also offer none of it mazda has put a lot of effort on selling illusions and fantasy , which actually they deliver, as some people think that their mazda 6 is on par with audis o BMV LOL

[@anemite2]

@@kseppi77 lol, is that so, because the puretech has been engine of the year for 4 years and the skyactiv afaik only win the technobest on 2019, and only because of the skyactiv X, cuz the petrol version is not even worth to mention lol As for your carrot award, funny that in the internet is only mention as a school awars Is pathetic to make up award to try to defend Mazda jajajajajaja The only time that Mazda won a car of the year prize was for the mx5 , unlike Peugeot that has already 6 cars under that award, so try harder my friend, cuz right now Mazda is nowhere the level of Peugeot, and both the sales, awards and media agreed with me😉

[@xyvhx]

The number of adds here are VERY annoying, thumbs down!

[@BB-mt2xb]

Mazda🤩💪🏻

[@markpaterson6024]

🤮

[@ronpower7790]

The interior designers of Peugeot most have been smoking pot a lot...otherwise I cant explain the ergonomic mess of their cockpit layout...for the sake of making it different.

[@markt1758]

who wants to be pragmatic? you will one day be sitting at the lights somewhere and a 508 will pull up next to you and that will be the point you will know you made the wrong choice

[@javigar133]

Why do compare Mazda with rubbish french made Cars? Different leagues

[@gregrobins5615]

Peugeot are premium, Mazda is just another European wannabe.

[@bulentmakul4761]

Javigar13 Thats the best comment ever 👏👏👏