Caraway Cookware vs Members Mark Dupe | In-depth Test and Review

[@suzanneb6608]

So far, all of the reviews I've read of long-term use of Caraway pans seem to go along with long-term reviews of almost all ceramic pans. They don't hold up with use. There are also reviews of 30-day usage that describe why the buyer chose to return and not keep the cookware. It was enough to turn me against Caraway and any other ceramic cookware. I'll stick with my Hexclad and stainless steel.

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Thank you for your input! I haven’t done anything with Hexclad. I do love my stainless steel. I would love for you to come back and see my long term review later!

[@NormaHernandez-ho1no]

❤ loved the video. Got my set today. Would love a video of the paperless paper towels.

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Will do!

[@julieboz5530]

I appreciate your review. I went ahead and ordered the Sam's club dupe set of fry pans based on your reviews. I didn't really need a whole set ( even though I wanted it lol)

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Hope you enjoy them, I know we did. come back and let me know your thoughts. Make sure you follow the instructions for prepping the pans. Most people dont realize they have to prep cermaic pans or cook too hot and could have a bad experience.

[@erikaunruh7010]

Great review, I loved that you used a heat gun to measure how well they held heat! By any chance, have you tried them both without oil? If so, would you say that they both remain non stick even if no oil is added?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

No I have not. I believe you still would have to add a little bit of oil or butter for it to not stick, BUT I can do another video and test it out! I’ll try to make it in the next few weeks.

[@daisymaldonado9202]

Love that you did this video!! Many of the other ones are unboxing. What do you think about the longevity of these??

[@TheWholesomeHome]

I love them so far! I haven’t had any issues. I did drop my small frying pan, so there is a chip in it, but that is my fault.

[@crayzidesi]

It’s November 2022, so you’ve had the sets for a while now. How is the dupe set holding up?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

7 months. I’m editing a video to upload about how they are holding up. Subscribe to find out 😉, but I will say you will not be disappointed.

[@JananiMuralidharanIyer]

@@TheWholesomeHome thanks for the quick response! looking forward to seeing what you have to share =)

[@DavisCrew1995]

Are the Sam’s club pans flat in middle?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

For the part that touches the stove top? Or inside where you cook?

[@jojorussell9336]

Did you season them before 1rst use?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Yes.

[@SamanthaH]

Would love to see the cloth paper towels

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Will do! I make them myself. Super easy and a money saver!

[@mattadulting]

Good job! The kids seemed to like the eggs too.

[@TheWholesomeHome]

They did!

[@davidzambrano9126]

Are the members mark nontoxic ?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

I believe so. Someone above posted the info.

[@mayra13r]

Does the handle get hot on the dupe?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Not for me. If you put it in the oven it would.

[@Pvbeachbum15]

is it possible caraway makes them for Sams?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

It is possible, but not the exact same. These are lighter. I know store brands are made by name brands, just theirs are the end of the mixture or beginning. The same I would apply for these pans. They are $30 off for Black Friday. 🙂

[@ezodyessey]

How about the fact that the members mark how's toxic.

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Not that I am aware of. It’s free of PFOAS and etc. can you explain?

[@er5bm]

Do any of the lids fit on the fry pan for the dupe ?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Hi! Unfortunately no, the lids are too small. I did have a lid that fit from a prior set. That is a downfall!

[@er5bm]

@@TheWholesomeHome How are they holding up now ? I ended up buying the dupe ones. The quality is so so. Arrived cratched on the inside and outside. Paint and the ceramic coating seems very thing and not so smooth around the inside edges. Have asked for a replacement. Hopefully those are better.

[@TheWholesomeHome]

@@er5bm oh no! Mine were not at all damaged like that when I received them. Yes, the the paint on the outside chipped, but I dropped mine. It didn’t chip easily though. I wonder if you received one that was returned? I hope the next one is better! Keep me posted!

[@TheWholesomeHome]

@@er5bm oh! And follow the instructions on how to prep them too.

[@er5bm]

@@TheWholesomeHome Thank you for responding. Will do once the replacement arrives. Hoping they last atleast 2-3 years.

[@KB-hs7vh]

Thanks for sharing your review!

[@TheWholesomeHome]

You are welcome!

[@fragsupreme8128]

Awesome video

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Thank you! Stay tuned for more!

[@da900smoove1]

What is this fascination with how easy a nonstick pot or pan is to clean after using as instructed with low to medium heat??? Nonstick cookware is not meant for cooking 97% of your meals in life or even 50%. I think that if people actually took the time to learn to cook more than 10-15 meals they would Grow and learn better results are possible with Quality Cookware of which there are many that are not nonstick

[@TheWholesomeHome]

True. I also have stainless steel, new and vintage cast iron, and multiple others types. This is my first time experimenting with ceramic coated, and wanted to share. I do have ceramic coated cast iron as well, but those are Dutch ovens 🙂 I love cooking, enjoy testing new products and recipes, and saving money. I did shoot a part of this video testing the eggs to my cast iron pan I use to make fried eggs, but cut it out to keep it shorter.

[@modernmarketinglegal]

Thanks for this! Do you have an Instagram?

[@TheWholesomeHome]

Yes. @stephnnnieee