Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco Review - BETTER Than Mancera Red Tobacco

[@garydc1057]

I first bought CH Mystery Tobacco (after sampling) over 12 months ago and to be honest, I was really hoping that no KZbin reviewer would ever make the piece you've just made! This is a phenomenal perfume that had exactly the same effect on me and I won't lie, I've spent parts of the summer gravitating towards it, having a sniff and almost longing for Autumn to arrive! If you smelled this as a sample, house name withheld, you'd instinctively know it's money. And it's worth every penny in my book.. Always, always get asked what I'm wearing when I wear this.

[@MP-ej9pw]

I've had mine for 2+ years and it has been my top tobacco fragrance since.

[@cubs531]

While I love your content, I'm never sad when the review is over because I get to listen to that sweet outro music. Got that John Mayer vibe. Really like this second channel!

[@extragentsscents]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@jcoleman924]

CH should give you 10% of sales because of the hype you are building to this. I ABSOLUTELY love Carlisle... so a decant will have to be purchased lol! Thanks for the review, man! Keep good.

[@DaveNYC]

Just got my decant. Wow. You are not wrong. Beautiful stuff. Definitely picking up a bottle for fall I had been wearing Le Labo Tabac 29 in the autumn but I am almost out and now that they released pricing for the City Exclusives event and I see they have completely lost their minds (100 ml $510 🤣😂🙄) this will make a fantastic successor. Thanks for the review!

[@clevonick216]

I have to check this out. Red tobacco is one of my favorite fall time fragrances.👍

[@anibalduarte4607]

Hey Ash, nice video! Could you please tell me wich one is better, ch mystery tobacco or mancera intense red tobacco?? I would love to read your opinion!

[@schari30]

I think CH private line is probably one of, if not the best designer private line, I've smelt. I will purchase pretty much anything with tobacco in it and Mystery Tobacco is a stunner. It's balanced, sophisticated and easy to wear. It is definitely more refined than Carlisle and Red Tobacco and yet the latter is still my favorite Tobacco frag to date. I personally love the rough, unapologetic edges of Red Tobacco and it's just my absolute fave. If you love Tobacco and tonka and don't mind the splurge, then you cannot go wrong with Mystery Tobacco.

[@MPerry-ox9qb]

Smells better than Red Tobacco & Carlisle? That’s a bold statement. I’ve gotta get my smeller on this.

[@NewName0]

Well? Did you?

[@Yjn75]

I've been suggesting a review of this from KZbin reviewers for ages and no one listens lol. It's so good yet so underrated.

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great review and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try it and have a blessed day

[@georgetito4820]

Sounds awesome, thanks Ash, haven't seen you this excited about a fragrance in a while...😃😃😃 Mystery tobacco makes up for a weak CH Man prive that always leaves you wanting more and more...🤪

[@cowboycrunchies]

Opposed to Bad Boy… Looks like Carolina Herrera has been a Good Girl! Great review Ash, need to check this one out for this Fall / Winter! 👍

[@MP-ej9pw]

Glad to see some love for this one. It has been my favorite tobacco scent for over two years. And just like you said it is better than Red Tobacco and Carlisle which are really good too. I also have the Nightfall Patchouli which is a great scent for patchouli and cinnamon lovers.

[@jingledubz3989]

Sounds legit, Ash! 🤘

[@Fuder95Ibra]

I ADORE RED TOBACCO, 1st 3 times i was confused but when you get into the scent, man its addictive !!

[@ivaylops]

It is better but it costs exactly FOUR times more than Red Tobacco in my country, so it's a NO for me. 🤷‍♂ I just can't justify the price, Mystery Tobacco is not THAT much better than Carlisle or RT.

[@GuiltyNoticer]

Yes.

[@jandrews4384]

I like RT way more than Carlisle, I am probably in the minority though

[@ilovefragrances5968]

Hey Ash, with the passing of Issey miyake do you think you could do a top ten list? I think it’s a under rated house that I really like.

[@TheFragranceChannel]

Hmm what about vs Side Effect?

[@shawnconley7248]

I'm interested in how this compares to Amouage Royal Tobacco.

[@diggyphil]

Would love to see you review and compare against Paris Corner Chariot Mysterious Tobacco

[@sbeliveau7809]

Charuto Mysterious Tobacco... yes, I would also appreciate a comparison. Exclusive Tabac from Maison Alhambra is also a clone and it's supposed to be good.

[@sadrsawi]

Please try to review Tobacco Rush from afnan

[@WireHedd]

I really like a lot of the vintage CH stuff like the original, Chic, Prive, 212 VIp and VIP Black and Under The Sea but haven't jibed with the lightning bolts. This looks and sounds like something I'm going to love as I love Carlisle and Herod as well as Red Tobacco so this is a must have now.

[@polopena3337]

Agreed but Bad Boy Le Parfum slaps its amazing.

[@V0ltron]

Not sure which I want more Vanille Havane Les Indemodables or Mystery Tobacco Carolina Herrera. What ya think, Ash?

[@pradeep_sekar]

Vanille Havane is the best quality wise.

[@lozdawes8761]

definitely one of my favourite 'tobacco' fragrances... very, very classy.

[@OlfactiveOverdose]

This is the same fragrance that you said it's like hey what's up I'm red tabbaco in ch bottle

[@fatima-5884]

Hello, I recently tested Mystery Tobacco and really liked it, could this be unisex, or strictly Masculine. Thank you

[@toksmachine69]

Watching in late December 2024! Not smelt this but Red Tobacco Intense is way smoother than the OG RT and this is double the price of the Intense version of Red Tobacco......🤔🤔

[@2GunsUpZ]

Hey Ash, have you tried Tabac Imperial Versace? I haven't seen anyone talk about it. Interested in seeing what Versace does with Tobacco.

[@jamesdyer1983]

Funny you should mention Tom Ford. Try D&G Velvet Amber Sun compared to Amber Absolute.

[@fr-marty]

Ash, I’ve hear several people praise this one, but it’s difficult to find where I live. How do you feel it compares to Dior Tobacolor?

[@Muhamedhatem-]

What about Oud Couture

[@native7876]

hermes h24 edp at macys now

[@scentedbyjota]

Have you tried arrakis because arrakis and red tobacco they're soooo similar its crazy to me try em ash i would love to see your opinion

[@jonsmith9728]

designer private blends should be considered niche... checkout diors tobacolor (i may of mis-spelled that lol) also probably my personal favorite of all my fragrences, niche included, would be chanels le lion, something about that stuff really rings home, i keep it for the winter though as i don't wish to clog up houses haha

[@imrananwar3980]

Please review LA MAIR Fabian

[@WSF176]

Ash do you happen do own Accident A La Vanille?

[@tasty_taco]

this has been in my aresnal for 3 or 4 years now and it is the one tobacco to rule them all. It was a EU exclusive years ago, not sure of the status now, which is why it was so hard to find and sample

[@Polyfusia]

What about Tiziana Terenzi Arrakis?

[@initdialog]

@Gents Is it better than Triumph of Bacchus?

[@ay_ay_ron2112]

Carlisle is a beast !!

[@tejanissimo]

Have you ever tried tabac tabou by Parfums D'Empire

[@perlarsen7944]

Lattafa Oud Mood Elixir is a clone of Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco perfume. Their scents are incredibly similar.

[@JoshCroft22]

To me carlisle smells way better and not that similar to me. Red tobacco and mystery tobacco are close. I own all 3. All 3 are amazing.

[@TheAntifluencer]

The better more grown up and refined Carlisle. In Top 5 Clubbing / Bars scents forever. 🥰

[@papascent6877]

gonna have to blind buy….dont tell my wife!

[@KT-dd2hw]

HAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHHAAHH

[@Papatroll]

Just messaged her, I’m not being part of your lies 😂

[@EDME86]

I feel you 😅

[@extragentsscents]

Your secret is safe with me

[@Hutcho18881]

Does he know your wife?

[@alexchavez3223]

Where else can I get it, the website doesn't let me get it

[@mazanek198585]

As good as Herod?

[@itscansnow]

U need to try exclusif tabac by maison alhambra.Its a clone of mystery tobacco

[@Detman101]

Just ordered that one this morning, can't wait to wear it!

[@iamshauncraggs]

Have you ever tried penhaligons halfeti Cedar? It reminds me of both Carlisle and red tobacco, just so much nicer!

[@sulaimanaljabari]

See you!

[@Gonzalo_K]

For me it's a little fruitier PdM Herod, almost the exact same fragrance, maybe better performance from the CH

[@Yjn75]

Red Tobacco has been reformulated! I just got a batch 2022 bottle and I confirm this. It now has an almost clear color (not dark Amber like before) and the performance is super nerfed! Just a heads up guys.

[@ahmetindere4726]

Sounds like a new batch that needs some aging.

[@Fuder95Ibra]

true, but i still like it tho

[@gimlow3946]

Me too dude , got a September 2022 batch. I feel your pain !

[@harvardblue2436]

Everywhere I look PDM is $300 plus … where kind I find it cheaper ??

[@Goldman-Khazar-Rothschild]

Aura fragrance

[@harvardblue2436]

@@Goldman-Khazar-Rothschild thanks 🙏🏾

[@justaddlight]

The strength of the magent alone might just make it worth it. 🤣 The satisfaction of confidently picking up a heavy bottle and lifting it over other fragrances is sumthin' else. 🤤 The world just feels RiGHT.

[@tker0212]

Sounds like another killer, wish my saks/nordstrom carried the line. They have TF, Bond, Creed, Kilian, and the saks just recently got PDM and MFK. BTW what makes this a fragrance you "wouldn't normally have reviewed on your main channel"? That was supposed to be the point of this channel.. I guess? I don't get why this review of one of your fav new fragrances would be out of place on the main channel. Just curious.

[@daniell5740]

His main channel mostly does top 10 and designer

[@joeyswaney8497]

Not for over 200... I don't care what you say... lol

[@weazul9593]

Day 6 of asking Ash to review Milton Lloyd fragrances

[@soulshaker23]

Who's buying a perfume for the logo?! Or for the packaging?!

[@GreyCrowe]

Oh so CH has time to make this gem, but they're too busy to make my dreams come true with a CH Prive PARFUM???!

[@turboshazed7370]

Foreal...

[@Dj.Alex-D]

Cant buy it in The Netherlands

[@ineedtochangemyname5803]

How does it compare to triumph of bacchus?

[@gmoney1961]

Carlisle? … there’s no tobacco in it so why the comparison. I could understand if it was Herod

[@MuddyGreenMonster]

Tobacco Intense Mega Collection is a fantastic clone of Mystery Tobacco. It's by Ard Al Zaafaran (the same brand that did the great Interlude clone). Only £15 in the UK. Joy Amin has a very good review of it on his channel.

[@achille5]

07

[@lifewithoutborders1348]

still a no...nothing Beast Mancera RED TOBACCO......Try Charuto Mysterious Tobacco..its cheap and very close to CH Mystery Tobacco

[@mamon99519]

Nope.

[@guerrillamainframe1223]

Who cares about the box and bottle dude

[@ivaylops]

Not me but A LOT of people do.

[@giovannisynthesis]

Hey did you have a fall out with Richard from Precious Liquid? I know you two worked on Royal Tobacco and you did a review on it but you never released that review. You also didn’t review his new Limited Edition release. 🥲