THE KING OF TOBACCO FRAGRANCES? MANCERA RED TOBACCO VS CAROLINA HERRERA MYSTERY TOBACCO REVIEW

[@sideeffect2]

Mystery Tobacco isn't a new release... totally agree with your comparison. I personally prefer Mystery Tobacco!

[@TroyD247Mall]

I actually don't do loud lol so yes i can see that.

[@Detman101]

Me too. I've just gotten my bottle of "Mystery Tobacco" and immediately had to order a second bottle. It's just amazing!! I have to FORCE myself to wear my other fragrances.... If I dont, I'll wear my "Mystery Tobacco" EVERY DAY ALL WEEK!!!

[@ramoneregal8317]

Mancera Red Tobacco is an awesome scent as you stated it's not rough it's just very complex and nuanced in the opening more so than Carlise and Mystery Tobacco.I have other great Tobaccos like Amouage Boundless,Pure Havane,Naxos,Enigma,Sweet Tobacco Spirits and more. This one is fantastic it transforms its warm spicy chocolatey vanillic smooth leathery smokey has a dark fruity cherried plummy accord.For this reason I believe this is the best Tobacco fragrance created.When you factor in the price its actually a steal this should cost around £200-300.Mancera needs to hone in their collection they have too many fragrances this does them a disservice.

[@TroyD247Mall]

Thank you for your feedback!

[@TrustedNose]

Red tobacco is so erratic and loud it can be off putting but it’s good value for money if that’s what you’re into

[@jstacks444]

Great review 👏 👌 as usual sir.... Still waiting on that Boadecia the Victorious Harmonious review.. that's going to be an interesting one

[@TroyD247Mall]

That one is locked and loaded

[@cyrilmadihlaba9179]

TroyD, interesting battle. Yes red tobacco is nuclear, Carolina Herra is mild and smooth to me. For attention Red Tobacco & for cosy or intimate moments Carolina Herra mystery tobacco. I own both but got mystery tobacco @ 25% discount, from South Africa 🇿🇦 Joburg South.

[@TroyD247Mall]

Thank you for your feedback!

[@Smoke_C]

Great video as usual. Clive Christian C is still my favourite pipe tobacco with saffron scent, hands down. The cinnamon in RT is over the top and makes it smell like cheap crap. A superior version of RT is Luxor by XJ IMO.

[@pharaohsanakht6839]

Red tobacco is awesome but only a couple of sprays it's strong 💪

[@sarmero8958]

I would love to see a comparison between mystery tobacco and Carlisle

[@PrimoKadro80s]

I love them both ❤️

[@tovlirami1711]

Thank you for the review 💜 Red tobacco is HEAVENLY

[@joakimlofberg8345]

You could add Argos Bachus to the list as well.

[@juansalaza7528]

You have trying guisada embassador intense

[@TroyD247Mall]

Juan you gotta send me samples if you can hahaha

[@JonMadd]

I know it's not officially listed as a note, but PdM's Carlisle is so similar to Mancera's RT except so much smoother. Would love to get my nose on Mystery Tobacco for a proper comparison.

[@JonMadd]

More importantly though, really like the passion, detail and conviction you have in your reviews. One of the best reviewers with consistency. 🔥🔥

[@mlisboalima]

What is Better, Mystery by CH or Tobacco and Vanilla by Tom Ford ?

[@d.s.6221]

I have to try Red Tobacco again. The first time I smelled it I was repulsed. I was at Saks in Manhattan and was testing manceras and RT MESSED ME UP! I asked the associate 'who would wear that??!!' lol Even tho I do enjoy strong fragrances (my absolute favorite fragrance is Overture Man) I dislike garishly loud fragrances. I never smelled MT but looks and sound really good. Currently my absolute favorite tobacco is Fumurie turque. The only other tobacco that's calling out for me is Sundowner. I just have so many fragrances that it becomes hard to justify at this point. Altho I REALLY want it. Lol. Good job, man..

[@polanialmoni6274]

How about fragrance world tobacco myth?

[@redkop1964]

Zaharoff signature tabac is where it’s at🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@sealedindictment]

weak no performance

[@jodee8831]

@@sealedindictment great scent profile... but yes the performance is lacking

[@redkop1964]

not on me bro 🔥

[@Robbyfrags90]

Mystery tobacco came out in 2016 way before Red Tobacco....so why do people compare the CH to the Mancera....shouldn't it be the other way around 😂

[@jamiesmith3600]

$180 for a bottle of water and honey, worst house in the entire world, Scam House was so excited to like this scent, smells like water and honey with a hint of vanilla sprayed 7 times, two on neck, once on both wrist and forehand, once on chest, went outside and in a building with lots of people, nobody said anything even after the dry down

[@barneypoloztas6778]

Carlisle > all

[@jameshorne3105]

I’ve owned both. Resold red tobacco, every woman in my life hates it, it’s a boxer dropper. On the other hand Mystery tobacco, you hit it on the head but you forgot to mention that along with it being one dimensional it’s also super refined, it’s for the people who are looking for the most simple refined high quality sweet piped tobacco without all the stupid shit. No fuss, no games.

[@daniell9268]

Tobac Dore true king

[@TroyD247Mall]

Different kingdoms out there :)