2024 Jaguar F-TYPE R v Lexus LC 500 Comparison | All hail the mighty V8!

[@rlstrad2059]

Jag F Type owner here…my six years with the car has resulted in no issues whatsoever….if you spend a bit of time on owner’s forums, you’ll see my experience is quite typical. Do agree the Lexus is gorgeous, but I’m quite happy with my F thanks very much.

[@chigasaki06]

I've been researching the F-type for some time. It seems reliable!

[@iSOBigD]

That's good to hear. I still want an F Type R, but I do think the LC500 looks quite nice, despite some of the exterior designs not quite matching, and despite the F Type's interior seeming less luxurious than I expected. In person, I found all surfaces to be hard like they're plastic bits wrapped in leather without much padding under it. Still though, overall just for the sound and looks, the 2016 AWD is my favorite affordable two seater.

[@SNORKYMEDIA]

wasnt there an issue with the original tune (ie pops and bangs all the time) destroying the cats - wasnt that why the later models are much quieter???

[@richardcollis5576]

They maybe true in oz, in the uk they are as regular as the three pronged suppository in the workshop.

[@philipwakeling2777]

I’m an Aussie that lives in the US. Back in 2021, I looked at both and decided on the F-Type R convertible (which I’m not sure is available in Oz). The Lexus is very nice, but the raw power of the Jag is intoxicating. So far in the 3 years I’ve owned it, the Jag has been trouble free and has only had its scheduled services (which are included for 5 years or 50k miles). I should add that I very much like Lexus and have a ‘22 LS500 luxury edition as well.

[@ZoltanF1LH]

The F-Type is one of the most reliable Jaguars and it also came second best in the reliability list in the sports car category in 2023... My 2016 V8 R has been super reliable so far 😁👍

[@Pedroaghyu]

Why compare a soft top and a hard top. Makes no sense

[@francescoferraris2340]

But can you make videos where you compare a luxurious GT and a bare-bones sports car?

[@BlackoutLC500]

Ausie are strange..

[@carsales]

We sure are!

[@TeaVR]

Shame you didn’t compare like for like. I’m pretty sure the coupe LC500 would give the Jaaaaaag a run for its money on a twisty road.

[@dlj1285]

@@TeaVR Now that’s funny…lol…Yeah, no

[@andradece_]

‘16 f type owner here.. 65K miles, no major issues. I did a lot of research on forums and stayed on top of maintenance intervals. Still look back at it every time I park😂

[@simplecarnivore]

Comparing the Lexus to the Jag is like comparing Filet mignon to a McDonald's hamburger.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@simplecarnivore Yeah Jaguar is a Filet mignon next to crapy hideous looking toyota who no one buys.

[@davidkeenan5989]

A welcome comparison, thanks. I would buy the Lexus if I had the money, for the overall.package. One must view the Lexus as a sporty GT - purchasers buying it as a sports car might be left wanting. I don't mind the Jag but would probably cross shop it with the 911.

[@pm512]

One big difference. That raggedy jag is going to spend 90% of his time in the shop. That Lexus is solid as a rock.

[@mofayer]

Yes. The real difference between the two is one you buy and the other you lease.

[@HarjotSG]

Completely wrong, I’ve owned one for 8 years and over 65k miles. Since 2021 every time I take it out, I redline it at least once and always drive in dynamic + paddles. Reliability is amazing long as you service it like every other car. Have had 1 problem over the years and it was a coolant leak during warranty. Sadly have coolant leak again but the new updated part will fix that issue permanently as i have seen on forums. The jag also sounds better than the LC (without me being bias). I love the exterior of the Lexus but it’s built for those who aren’t as driver focused and just want an elegant ride I feel. Thought of adding one to the collection but it’s just meh/a good ride. Transmission is horrible on it and Lexus has even said it themselves

[@stevielowe2853]

Spoken like someone who has never had a jag

[@odinikita4821]

oh really, well done for perpetuating 50 year old myths. i have a 2014 f type, nothing ever has gone wrong.

[@mofayer]

@@odinikita4821 50 yr old? My friend had 2010 xkr supercharged that had non stop problems, he got tired of fixing it, sold it at just 70k miles.

[@markbiggart1265]

The LC is not divisive in the slightest it’s stunning since the moment it was launched. Shame it’s not depreciated much.

[@hugohugo2832]

Huge depreciation in the UK

[@dlj1285]

In Canada I don’t believe that they have held their value all that well, not sure about other markets. That said, all these type of cars will hold and increase at some point once people want what they can no longer have.

[@philippezevenberg1332]

I mean it weant from 100k to 30k

[@SNORKYMEDIA]

@@philippezevenberg1332 ? not many for 30K, 50k maybe

[@richardcollis5576]

@@hugohugo2832 it just didn’t sell, which for some lucky buyer means rare to see on the roads. Huge depreciation???, clearly not at my local dealership in Ipswich

[@nicolasmikah4168]

This is not “plastic fake metal” !! It is brushed aluminum in the interior of the Lexus. Get your facts straight. What about mentioning the Jag’s infotainment screen that looks so dated. In regard to the touch pad of the older LC model, I got used to it and I do prefer the cleaner look of the dash over the new one. The only thing I wish my 2018 coupe has, is a front facing camera.

[@unions100]

I totally agree 100%. Lexus quality is top-notch.

[@dlj1285]

What a rude boy you are.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@nicolasmikah4168 Cope harder Toyota fanboy

[@simonbaj334]

Drove the Jag and the LC500 (coupe)... The Jag is a brutal unrefined animal. The Lexus is all class, smooth and silk. The interior of the Jag looks like it belongs in a Chinese car. Spare parts on the Jag like brake pads will make your bank manager rich.

[@michaeladabo2719]

Jag uses Peugeot engine

[@dlj1285]

Completely ridiculous comment…lol, my gawd, where do you people come from? Seriously.

[@zsb707]

@@michaeladabo2719 Dude, seriously?

[@Ze_Hans]

@@michaeladabo2719 🤡🤡🤡🤡💩

[@Ze_Hans]

@@simonbaj334 people still like the Jag more than this ugly looking vacuum cleaner toyota. What you gonna do about that eh?

[@jeffreyb.1657]

F-type awd v6 tuned to 475hp, better sound actually imho (1970's F1 sound). No issues at 65k miles. I put metal coolant tubes on it to prevent the one known issue. Used, F-types are amazing deals. Best deal on the market by far.

[@MichaelK7]

Only comments I see are people talking about the f types reliability as if they’ve ever owned an f type let alone even sit in one.

[@keithjackson4985]

I like that, Jag! The Lexus is pretty, but not in the same way as the Jaguar. How come we can't have Lexus quality with the Jags body?

[@ferrarikangaroo9271]

Great review! I still prefer the original design of the F-Type. I'd have the 2wd version too. Keep up the great content!

[@ckaparos]

The Jag V8 is awesome

[@williamfraser5593]

AMG GTS is faster on the track but the F Type R is a truly iconic British V8 roadster. I love mine.

[@jamespopovic9750]

Cold start on Jag in sport mode is epic.. very punchy car

[@Steve-gc5nt]

Both nice but only the Jag has soul.

[@RealityMauritius]

As people who do buy these sublime cars for the sheer pleasure of driving, the great styling and engines ... do you really think we're going to care about a heads-up display? I barely touch these things

[@TWHISPERER]

Jaguar F Type for this man.

[@supertaufiqr]

I always like the sound coming out of the F-Type 😍

[@grabir01]

Not me. I do not care for sounds of car parts failing .

[@Ze_Hans]

​@@grabir01Who even gives a fck about you. I do not care for reliability Im not broke. Lol.

[@Ze_Hans]

​@@grabir01No one care about your comment neither. Just like no one care for plexus😂

[@grabir01]

@@Ze_Hans I meant to say. I do not care for the sound of car parts falling off on to the road.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@grabir01 Sorry for breaking it for ya but there's no car part fAlLinG OfF oN tHe rOAD on Jaguar. You are just brainwashed with nonsense. Btw I dont think you could afford any of those 2, so I think you dont even belong in this conversation buddy😉

[@adamdavis9600]

Great job Scott, as ever a thorough review of the bits and pieces, and worthwhile driving insights.

[@eddieg6436]

For quality, and RELIABILITY it’s 100% the LEXUS.

[@dlj1285]

I always get a kick out of these types of comments. Supreme reliability is not necessarily a requirement in a purchase like this. Combined with other factors reasonable reliability could be good enough for someone depending on their goals. Modern day F-types are well worked out and quite reliable. They’re also much more aggressive, better handling, and powerful than the LC. They like to compare them but these things are for 2 very different buyers.

[@eddieg6436]

@@dlj1285 While I have money, I don’t have money to burn on constant maintenance. I still have my 35 year old Toyota MR-2 supercharged I got as my first car as a teenager, and would EASILY pick the LC500 for it’s Toyota/ Lexus reliability…..plus I MUCH PREFER it’s looks, and it’s far more RARE.

[@dlj1285]

@@eddieg6436 That’s good. You do you. I like the LC as well for what it is. Performance-wise these 2 cars are on different planets. That said, the LC is more than fast enough for the street. I’m a Toyota fan. I have 2, so you don’t have to convince me of how good they are for reliability. I just don’t care if I have perfect reliability for a dream car purchase. There are other things to consider in such a purchase beyond reliability. Despite what you say, the latest F-types are very developed cars with very few issues. I know this though experience (I know family and friends with them, and I own one myself), not because Bob’s friend Bill told Sally’s Uncle that they were unreliable in the 80s and 90s.

[@richardcollis5576]

@@dlj1285 I like to look back at cars, it’s just that most expensive brands prefer your wallet then how you look at them.

[@dlj1285]

@@richardcollis5576 Yes, expensive cars are expensive. They all are at the end of the day.

[@BradsHacks]

4:54 F-Type has regular cruise control and no adaptive cruise control.

[@DanielSadjadian]

Both have such lovely V8s, what's not to love 🔥

[@sandrider1406]

Well the Jaguar loves the repair shop. The Lexus loves the road.

[@Ze_Hans]

​@@sandrider1406and you love to eat 💩

[@hamsterbrigade]

Why didn't they use an LC500 coupe to compare? It's a dramatically different handling car with the rear steer and the coupe is much more rigid.

[@carsales]

This was covered in the video, but Lexus only had the Convertible in the city we needed to film in. You're right, the Coupe handles much better, but given the point of the video was as much to celebrate the engines as compare the cars, the Convertible worked fine.

[@richardcollis5576]

@@carsales then why do the comparison, wait until you’ve got access, otherwise this review will date harder then the aluminium trim comment.

[@blu_is500]

There's no replacement for displacement. 😍 Thanks for posting!

[@gregs8685]

Actually, there is. Forced induction.

[@gdubyadubya8961]

@@gregs8685actually there isn’t. Forced induction is exactly that…forced.

[@klowe007]

I'll be trading my Lexus RCF for the LC500 later this year. I considered the F-Type for a minute, but notice a lot them sitting in Lexus pre-owned lots. Both are beautiful rides, but having driven both the LC is way more comfortable. The LC is a GT car and gets amazing mpg on long trips for a V8. He should have reviewed the hard-top instead of the convertible. The hard-top with Dynamic Handling package is a better experience for comparison. The convertible is heavier and lacks some features due the roof mechanisms. Many folks in the car group have gone from the Jag to the Lexus for whatever reason.

[@freebo27]

No comparison, the Lexus is fugly, the Jag is gorgeous.

[@richardcollis5576]

Gorgeous na, Ian Callum did a better job with Aston

[@tc88888888]

Thr LC500 wins easily on looks alone.

[@stevielowe2853]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 sure , sure

[@chriss8417]

100 % 💪

[@tabrazerasul]

😂

[@Ze_Hans]

@@tc88888888 🤡🤡🤡

[@Ze_Hans]

@@tc88888888 🤡🤡🤡🤣🤣🤣

[@TheMarkyMarx]

Lexus should have remained a "Concept car" and not left the drawing board. The F-Type is a work of art.

[@ted6462]

The LC convertible is soft and not an ideal comparison. What you need is an LC500 coupe with the performance package.

[@stevielowe2853]

100% the jag

[@craigdavid6668]

Is rubbish. Just finished your sentence for you, you’re welcome.

[@stevielowe2853]

@craigdavid6668 I'm glad you put that it saves me saying that you are clueless. Now, people know you're welcome

[@stevielowe2853]

@@craigdavid6668 just say you can't afford it and stick to your Toyota 🤣🤣🤣

[@stringer-ik1pc]

​@@craigdavid6668stick to your mom's nissan micra 😂😂😂

[@MyGoogi]

are you comparing a coupe with a cabriolet?!!!!!!!!!!!!! the LC 500 sport plus coupe has no shaking and no wobble and is great to drive. An all wheel drive hard top coupe compared to a rear wheel drive soft top!!!!! again a biased comparison when it comes to japanese cars. people are used to it.

[@carsales]

This was covered in the video, but Lexus only had the Convertible in the city we needed to film in. You're right, the Coupe handles much better, but given the point of the video was as much to celebrate the engines as compare the cars, the Convertible worked fine.

[@esteemedenergy]

The Lexus is just a silly want-to-be sports car. The F-Type is a true performance car. Drive a LC500 and the very poor transmission shifting will frustrate you to no end.

[@Mik-xq2co]

The Lexus is a GT car and no one that knows this vehicle would try to say it’s a sports car.

[@peteri1984]

​@@Mik-xq2co Lexus is not even a Gt car. It is Camry coupe basically with Camry suspension components. Jag is unique full aluminum body. Google for regidity of two cars. Jag is vastly more advanced period.

[@francescoferraris2340]

When you make these videos, don't always put the 1500 kg boxes in front and behind the luxury GTs. They are 2 completely different machines. A super luxurious GT and a miserable little box!!!!

[@Ze_Hans]

@@francescoferraris2340One is a masculine drivers sportcar with raw V8 which casually obliterated every car in its class, other is leather trimed, slow pittyfull rebadged tOyOta. Btw your country cant even make an engine that will not entirely fall apart after 80 000km. Maserati, Fiat, Lancia,Alfa = junk, junk, junk. Italian car industry except Ferrari is laughing stock of the car world.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@francescoferraris2340 been quiet pasta man? 🤣

[@christopherward6809]

You're the only reviewer that I have heard describe the ride as "choppy" and why are you comparing a coupe to a convertible, of course it's going to have some cowl shake. I just took delivery of a 2024 LC coupe w/performance package and I disagree that the ride is what could be described as "choppy"

[@peteri1984]

Driving myself lc500, a total piece of junk with obsolete Toyota suspension.

[@richardcollis5576]

Hmmm a proper engineer reviewing these cars on a lift and I know which one will become a modern classic.

[@odinikita4821]

woke aussie car "reviewers" are crap.

[@chapacubraelderscrollsonli3491]

LOL don't compare Jaguar with toyota!

[@gregs8685]

I don’t care how good the Lexus is, it is hideous looking.

[@rideroll9609]

I love the look of it. It will never gets old after 50 years it will still look new.

[@wongyeukhei]

Truth is a V6 f type already have a similar performance as a LC500 .. with much lesser cash

[@STRENGTH444]

The F Type is the better sports car... Also worth noting the Lexus LC 500 owners are the most insufferable people ive come across, dont join that club.Every single comparison against any model and they use the weak arguement of reliability as its their only saving grace... two weeks later theyre complaining about build quality, its hillarious to watch

[@simonbaj334]

Yeah, sure buddy.... The Jag cost 100k more than the coupe and its got more power and a trash interior.

[@STRENGTH444]

@@simonbaj334 I found one 🤣 Let's be clear, these two cars are not in the same league, the F Type destroys the Lexus in driving, but you keep telling yourself it is when you are looking at your suede interior to make you feel better😉

[@dlj1285]

What I get a kick out of is how so many people feel the need to tear down another really nice car to validate their choice. It’s so childish. I absolutely adore the F-type R for its brutal vibe and performant nature. It suits me more than an LC in terms of what I’m looking for. That said, I still appreciate the LC for what it is, and I certainly recognize that it’s a really nice vehicle even though it would not be my first choice. Car enthusiasts, so many of them bring these sorts of silly and childish view points. It’s strange. Anyone would be lucky to own either one of these cars at the end of the day. The real kicker is that, in reality, most of the people making these silly childish comments probably can’t afford either. That’s the funny part.

[@dlj1285]

@@simonbaj334 Trash interior…lol, okay there…Both cars have really nice interiors…especially with the fully extended leather package in the Jag.. very nice place to spend time…Have you ever actually sat in one? Or are you basing it on internet videos and pictures…You have to sit in one to appreciate them… The seats in the Jag are actually more comfortable than those in the LC to me.

[@simonbaj334]

@@STRENGTH444 I don't have a small Weiner so i'm not worried about calling the RACV when the jag breaks down...

[@bearwarfare9464]

2024 Nissan GTR Nismo vs 2024 Lexus LC 500 Inspiration Series

[@JLU55]

Love! Both... 4-5 years ago a would have chosen the F-Type for the engine and exhaust. Today, not even close... LC500 By a Mile! On the engine sound alone.😅😂

[@kiwi335d]

Lexus LC500 build quality is on a much higher level than the Jaguar, or just about anything else for that matter. Jaguar still using low cost single piston sliding brake calipers, while Lexus are using six and four piston Brembo brake system. Lexus LC500 coupe would have been a better comparison.

[@chileshemubanga3594]

V8s,for the rumbly sounds🎉🎉🎉🔥🔥🔥🌡️

[@realRichHunting]

Jag at 50,000 miles = Broken and in the shop every month. Lexus at 50,000 miles = Barely broken in and daily driven.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@realRichHunting Interesting how Jaguar is being unreliable mostly to people who never owned anything better than a corolla. Keep glazing fella, my 2008 3.0 V6 XJ has 348k miles on the clock and still going strong. Cry me about it.

[@bigboymarket]

Make a Vid for the Alfa Giulia QV VS the LC500 or RC...

[@khkckhkc]

One is properly built by craftsmen in Japan, another one is thrown together from 10ft away by fat lazy workers in the Midlands.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@khkckhkc cry me a river about it, you cant afford any of those 2 anyways.

[@NeutronStar-r7r]

I’m thinking in 20 years time the Lexus will be going strong with no issues. The Jag will be long gone. The LC500 will be a classic for sure because its build quality is unrivalled.

[@Steve-gc5nt]

Really? Take a look at how many 20 year old Jaguars are for sale.

[@stringer-ik1pc]

Ever heard of the e-type ????

[@dlj1285]

Lol, I don’t think I’ve ever seen so many ridiculous comments on one video. Do actually think before you speak? Old Jaguars are a thing…Get a clue.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@NeutronStar-r7r Do you even realise that Toyota is nothing compared to the Jag. Years of history at Le Mans,E type, XJR 15-first carbon fibre body car and the first ever F1 derived street legal car,XJ220 fastest production car in 91', fastest 4 door sedan multiple times XJR, Project 8, aluminum minocoque construction, etc etc. What does toyota have? Ummm oh yea, sUpRaa and fancy sounding V10 that no one bought. Stay humble little guy.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@dlj1285 ignorant haters , mate. They hate BMW, Mercedes,Jag,Aston.. Anything more expensive that their crappy corolla.

[@jasonal1769]

Jaguar has great style, sound and capability. But it will also have a great relationship with the workshop. The LC500 coupe is the one to go for with the performance pack if you want reduced chassis flex and improved cornering capability. It is far from being a slow car, in fact quite the opposite. In buying one of these two cars price is definitely a consideration and I wouldn’t even consider the Jag from a reliability standpoint alone. But having said that long live the V8 and we should commend both manufacturers on a great achievement.

[@computerhelpcc]

Lexus 5.0 F motors make incredible induction sounds; at 3,700 rpm a sudden, deep baritone emanates and proves superior to muffler sounds. I manually shift GS F to 5k just to hear it again. F Type sports exhaust is hilariously fun. Neither is Porsche-grade at limit yet V8 motors are worth trade-off.

[@thecure3665]

I would get the lexus ❤

[@JJS432]

The Jaguar interior looks like Fisher Price was involved.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@JJS432 tiyota looks like shit

[@CharlesZupan]

Steering wheels on the wrong side

[@chriss8417]

Lexus all the way 💪

[@russellmurphy7109]

The Lexus isn’t stuck in ‘no man’s land’. It knows exactly what it is. A Grand Tourer of the highest order.

[@Ze_Hans]

Jag without a single tought over that horribly ugly vacuum cleaner looking toyota.😂

[@Alan41363]

lexus has performance worse than 430i's, F-Type R has true sportscar performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/qWPCn2uIfbNgfZI faster than R8 and Cayman GTS even F-type has handicapped with heavy V8 engine in front

[@jasonc6241992]

Stop using the convertible, it's the worst version of the LC

[@hugohugo2832]

Good film but peculiar testing coupe against convertible

[@malligrub2516]

The infotainment in that Jag is not "okay". Completely unacceptable for nearly 300K

[@daviddarmanin2188]

Jags have always been for people with lots of money to do repairs 😂 absolutely love the Lexus it’s beautiful

[@WilliamGelmi]

Every JAG is always in the shop getting fix. They got the worst reliability in the world.

[@dlj1285]

Here we go…Once again, absolutely uninformed and clueless. Do you feel better getting that garbage off your chest?

[@Ze_Hans]

@@WilliamGelmi never owned one pal

[@92Godzilla]

I’m sorry but the Lexus is hideous.

[@unions100]

Each to their own, but I’m sure millions would disagree with you. Period. The lc is a work of art , simple !!!

[@Ze_Hans]

@@unions100 You are simply extremely biased. Milions? Dude no one even buys that ugly toyota, no one even knows that LC exist 🤣 Just learn to cope. P E R I O D

[@sandrider1406]

Lexus every time ……….english sports cars are awful, unreliable, overpriced poorly engineered and hugely overrated.

[@stevielowe2853]

Spoken like a clueless 🤡

[@sandrider1406]

@@stevielowe2853 well well well, if feel your hurt, it’s only Jaguar owners who are the 🤡. Bought a lemon no doubt? 🤣🤣

[@stevielowe2853]

@sandrider1406 nope it was a great car 100% but hey clueless people like you are also entitled to their opinion 🤣🤡

[@chiefcomplaint1]

Just going based on performance and exterior appearance, the F type is way better looking than the Lexus. I don’t care that much about reliability when purchasing luxury sports cars. Let’s say Lexus reliability is 90% and Jaguar reliability is 80%, that’s a negligible difference. I’ve had no issues with my F type at all

[@grabir01]

Lexus will be reliable. The Jag. Well.. Its a status symbol of stupidity.

[@jasonc6241992]

Id give that award to Maserati

[@unions100]

The jag is a sports car. The Lexus is a grand tour car. yes’ I know it’s about the V8 engines, !! But’ come on’ at least get like for like not a soft top LC. The jags reliability and durability will never ever come close to the Lexus LC 500. The Lexus LC will become more desirable as years go as it already does because they are so rare. The jag looks common still nice to look at though. For me the Lexus LC has class, more room than the jag and the design is so futuristic, that is without shadow of doubt the winner ❤❤❤

[@pinkipipe]

Lexus ruined the car with those wheels …..

[@williamfraser5593]

meh

[@Euroretro86]

Not a good comparison. Should have been a coupe LC500. Lexus hand down 😂😂😂Lol

[@progressoful]

HANDS DOWN THE LEXUS THIS IS A NO BRAINER!

[@stringer-ik1pc]

The fact that africans and asians like lexus says it all. Jag is pure class.

[@carloscarter9429]

This comparison is not even close. That Jag is a repair shop queen, That Lex is a road king.

[@Ze_Hans]

@@carloscarter9429 And you cant afford neither... blacky.

[@chiefcomplaint1]

Mine has never been in the shop

[@Mufflerpatrick]

You just can' buy more ugliest car then the Lexus on a market🤮

[@Ze_Hans]

@@Mufflerpatrick literally, that ugly crap looks like a vacuum cleaner.🤣🤣