Case 65: Allison Baden-Clay

[@JulieLeach-n3m]

I love the thoroughness of your show and your voice is very soothing thank you.😢

[@jennklein1917]

What a waste of a talented, well travelled, beautiful, lovely girl. And a great mother to boot! 😢

[@Pebs_dandysworld_781]

I remember this case. Poor daughters 💔 I recently watched the 60 minutes documentary and like always you have so much more details. If anybody has listened to this I do recommend watching the 60 minutes Australia documentary. Watching the detective who had to repeatedly call her mobile and listen to her voice message then broke down in tears even years later because she wasn't found alive made me bawl also. He was obviously a strong man but had heart. Great detective work from the beginning RIP Allison

[@thecatatemyhomework]

15 years minimum. Another example of the despicable Australian criminal justice system

[@JulieLeach-n3m]

15 years in prison is like dog years and Gerard will I'm sure feel hard done by and too superior to be in prison (GOOD)

[@JulieLeach-n3m]

Also just. Just because he is up for parole does not mean he'll get it.

[@samlape]

No consequences for bad behavior in Australia. Definition of lowclass white trash country propped up by trillion dollar Perth Mines.

[@JulieMiller-of2dl]

Yes and they wonder why we currently have an epidemic of violence against women.

[@adeverger]

Excellent. I listen to your podcasts on cases that I have known about for years. You are extremely thorough. Thank you for focusing on the victims. John Newman and The Bodies in the Barrels are also excellent from you. I an so happy for this channel. I am American and we don't hear too much about what happens in Austrailia unless it is about Bindi Erwin. lol

[@JulieLeach-n3m]

😂😅😊

[@lancemckellar]

I have had the privilege of meeting Allison's family at the Strive to be Kind Day. Wonderful people!

[@Balrog-tf3bg]

I’m glad the high court upheld the original sentence but Australias justice system to victims of violent crimes is just sad for a first world country. Like in America we’re not perfect, but we’ll hand down death or life without parole without question for killers like this

[@princessinaworldofevil]

It is a testament to those police officers and community that they put forth that much effort ,dedication and love for this woman to try and bring her justice. All for a total stranger for most of them. What a wonderful group of human beings filled with love.

[@jenniferbailey5914]

Narcissists, when they become desperate, turn into sociopaths. Listening to her diary is like reading mine all these years later. Luckily I got away before it was too late. RIP Alison.

[@TomTheOwl68]

You don't just turn into a sociapath, you already are a sociapath and you can be a narcissistic sociapath. Mental health is patterns of behaviour that can escalate or de-escalate depending on the situation. The patterns are for the most part usually predictable. Too many people think they are qualified to diagnose mental health. If you are qualified then all good but leave it to the professionals otherwise. You may have experience but many symptoms of mental health illnesses and personality disorders overlap and you can not sit diagnosing people without the full knowledge of all of someone's mental health, and the other factors that contribute.

[@VladRadu-tq1pg]

ok mr shrink@@TomTheOwl68

[@stephenkelly7397]

"Rot in HELL" THE best years of my childhood years were being in the Boy Scouts. I pray he rots in HELL, forever. SCUMBAG.

[@alexajessop5590]

Great work from everyone.

[@Danigirl77777]

If you kill someone, you should not be eligible for parole in 15 years. What a joke! How can the sentence be called “life”? Hopefully, he won’t be out for a long, long time. Poor baby girls.

[@ishtarbabylon4869]

Crime of passion that’s why

[@kathleenbyrne1284]

​@@ishtarbabylon4869😢

[@stephenkelly7397]

My prayers go out to the daughters and all the family.God bless RIP ALISON.

[@melbournegirl7]

I liked the bit of Australian history at the start. Very interesting.

[@ishtarbabylon4869]

This is great but way too many adds! Not ideal to sleep to as I’m constantly having to skip the ads! Otherwise keep up the good work mate

[@Charles-oo8bq]

Absolutely. Every two minutes I have to reach over (without touching the screen wrong) and pass these adds. I liken it to eating a delicious cake but every other bite I chew a bug

[@johannah4785]

So would you pay to listen? All that work and investigating needs paying!

[@steff.7028]

I don't know why you don't have more subs!

[@joanneginever1890]

Have just finished indepth book on this case and watched numerous videos. Gerards sister Olivia was shadowing her brother from day one, keeping journalists from getting close to him, stopping him from speaking on occasions, no emotion at all re missing sister in law. She looked a nasty piece of work, and their parents too! I have no doubt they knew from the beginning that he'd killed Allison, and assisted in some way also re the body or other ways.

[@melmazing3993]

Yea, this family was way too insular. There's being close, and then there's being weird. Definitely unhealthy. Not surprisingly, it spawned a killer.

[@kerrieboyden570]

What’s the name of the book you read. I’d be interested in reading it as well.

[@joanneginever1890]

@@kerrieboyden570 The Murder of Allison Baden Clay by David Murray. Available Amazon for Kindle.

[@lancemckellar]

There is a Barbara Baden-Clay. She is weird.

[@sleepinglabradors]

This is an amazing podcast, great job. Would it be possible to add in the description section which Casefile podcast number was mentioned as a reference in the podcast? Please. I appreciate you guys make a mention to a previously covered podcast and the number, I feel like many don’t really do that and just say “on a previously covered show”. By the time I finish listening to the current one I forget which to go back to.

[@bluechurch776]

I can not believe these judges. Thank God the high court and the incredible community. Bless all of you! ❤

[@marktrezise7312]

RIP Allison

[@donnablack6280]

I was willing to be objective up to the point he said their lives had turned around and everything was looking up, which wiped out any reasons for his explanations of her suicide/running away.

[@paulabrown6840]

Men stop murdering women.

[@Levon2464]

Men die more at the hands of men. How about stop murdering anyone?

[@Shacktown110]

"The 0.001 percent of men that murder stop murdering men (80% of murder victims being men) and women." There, I fixed it for you Paula. 😊

[@JulieLeach-n3m]

I wonder how Mistress Toni feels knowing that the argument that killed Alison was over her and in court he said he never loved her and was going to leave her 😢

[@roslynweidemann9487]

I'm listening to this CREEP and he's and, am all over the place when answering the questions from the police. He's done something to her. He's murdered her and the police knew it

[@lachicafun]

I looked for an update and it looks like their oldest daughter Hannah graduated from Uni and Tony left Australia, changed her identity and lives in the UAE

[@lancemckellar]

I have met the daughters. A year ago all where students. Doing well.

[@robbiekeen9508]

I suggest reading comments at end...alot of spoilers

[@elizabethroberts6215]

………that first tv interview with Gerard, with his ‘crocodile tears’ was a red flag. His sister’s closeness to his back, & back left shoulder, during it was downright creepy………

[@juniorjohnson5961]

Really enjoy your channel - movement Watches are Junk !

[@genie674]

I knew when I first saw a photo of that man that he murdered his wife. He's a psychopath and I hope he doesn't get out in 15 years.

[@aanon5716]

i hope you dont serve on any juries with that ridiculous belief you can tell a psychopath by their looks.

[@iloveschicken6527]

@@aanon5716 , Sometimes you can. The eyes say a lot about someone. My own brothers eyes look empty. He shot and killed the 19 yr old mother of his baby last year. He got off murder one on the grounds of Insanity. Isn't that a cozy feeling?

[@genie674]

@@aanon5716 I've been told I would make an excellent juror by a professional person.

[@brantleyfoster021]

Genie Didn't he get a life sentence?

[@genie674]

@@brantleyfoster021 He got life but can apply for parole in 15 years. The laws are too weak here in Australia.

[@alexajessop5590]

Turning something very bad into something very good.

[@sheribrougham4863]

Who gives a shit if he killed her in a fit of rage. He never owned up to it. He lied, covered it up and still killed her. Thats murder. 😢

[@sheribrougham4863]

When your friends hate your mate listen to them. 😢

[@soyuzdavillan721]

This guy knows alot about the body that I can't remebeing released in the press 😂

[@VladRadu-tq1pg]

what a braindead comment

[@goodkopbadkop9054]

2:17

[@skitch1518]

thank u jesus

[@cherylmoore3349]

Interesting story disturbing 😳

[@nicoles8176]

What the hell this is about the case murder case of freaking commercial

[@KathleenCalhoun-em6ys]

He really screwed up his life and destroyed others.

[@marktrezise7312]

Sad.

[@soyuzdavillan721]

Just putting it out there mate ------> he didn't search "right to silence" he searched "pleading the 5th"... nice research once again

[@randomuser778]

No, you ignoramus. This occurred in Australia. They don't "plead the fifth," which references the US constitution's fifth amendment and wouldn't apply to anyone outside the United States.

[@soyuzdavillan721]

@@randomuser778 hey listen "you ignoramus" even though yes this is Australia and we don't have the same laws as the US I KNOW AS A FACT that he searched "pleading the 5th" because the cops searched his hard drive.... and want to know why I know that???? BECAUSE I DID JAIL WITH THE BLOKE. I was at Arthur Gorrie CC where he was in the same unit he was in December 2012 - June 2013 and I spoke with him on a very regular basis as you do when you're in a unit with 36 other crims. So before you go thinking you're smart and knowing everything remember there's always one out there that knows a bit more 😁

[@soyuzdavillan721]

@@randomuser778 yup good job gronk

[@nikimagelakis9085]

@@soyuzdavillan721 And you believe what he said😀

[@soyuzdavillan721]

@@nikimagelakis9085 I believe what I saw in his QP9's

[@brendajstevens3719]

👏👏👏

[@angels0auras]

😔🙏

[@helenoftroi9511]

The justice system is so unfair, 3 years, if I knew I could get 3 years for cold blooded murder....................hmmmmm🤔, does that punishment fit this crime? Ridiculous.

[@markflint2629]

15 years

[@ishtarbabylon4869]

You get less when it’s a crime of passion .. Ridiculous

[@TrashwareArt]

Jesus Christ I hate watches.

[@chicagogyrl4846]

3 Years??!! 😆😂

[@soyuzdavillan721]

Christ what's the go with background music mate???

[@VladRadu-tq1pg]

dude just fuck off and don t watch it

[@texastea5686]

I googled a pic of Toni the Whore.. . No joke, she looks like Dylan Mulvaney. Check it out for yourself!

[@AlbaFire]

You’re right 😮 I thought you’d be exaggerating just because of the case but she really does resemble Dylan!

[@pascalmariopathaw3283]

That's so true 😂

[@lancemckellar]

Toni the Whore had to leave Australia . She is now in Dubai.

[@nicoles8176]

What the fuck what the hell is this

[@abbie545]

That female cop is awful

[@boosqueezy2418]

know who you’re marrying!!!!!!