What's next for Syria after Assad's fall?

[@CaspianReport]

Stay better informed ground.news/caspian and access world-wide perspectives on global developments. Subscribe for 50% off unlimited access through my link.

[@Saimon1985]

Did you saw what is happening with the Druze in Hader and surrounding towns?

[@ricardolorrio8228]

your reports are the best info

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

Take the L white people🏳️‍🌈👱🏻‍♂️ and keep coping we don’t want your isms and anyone who replies shilling for whites doesn’t represent the majority and it is normal to give him/her likes because he wants to keep your interests in the region but in reality won’t happen

[@morrari690]

hahaha you just outted yourself. nooob

[@ExiledGypsy]

Who is going to finance the Assad soldiers going into Iraq? Will Iran finance them? For Iran even Iraq is proving too heavy unless the U.S. really leaves. None the less this Sunni/Shia divide in itself is not as bad as the Western media makes it out to be unless it is used by outsiders like the U.S. and the U.K. Left to themselves, I don't think there would be a divide. If Trump does really pull out, then Turkey will call the shots. Erdogan has dreams of the Ottoman empire, but the Arabs are now rich, and I doubt they want the Sultan back. The danger is between Turkey and Iran. Azerbaijan persecution of Arminian with the help of Turks and Israeli weapons are becoming bigger and bigger thorn in the Islamic Republic's side. During the Ottoman's Russia and Persia were too much for the Ottomans but now with Georgia, things are shaky for Iran and Russia. However, on the face of the Turks are against Israel but Erdogan himself would welcome Israel's help where-ever his personal ambitions are involved but how far is the population is prepared to follow him on that path and are they even aware of their current depth of co-operation? The Kurds might be finished in Syria, but they still have the oil rich northern Iraq with Iran over the border and the Kurds they are more Persians than Turk. Therefore if U.S. really leaves including from Iraq then Iran's influence will get stronger and if they can accommodate Turrey then Israel will have to back down. This is why I don't think that the U.S. will leave. They will create a new ISIL again and Trump will be convinced not to with Netanyahu singing in his ear. So, Iran has to accommodate Turkey somehow anyway or Erdogan will get involved against Iran and then the Islamic Republic will be in real trouble.

[@nelsoncheng2674]

Let’s hope this video won’t be outdated within 6 hours.

[@Abdullah-mh7eg]

it wont

[@okbuddysoyboy6940]

It already is. SDF has withdrawn from Deir Ez Zor

[@theobservationsreal3291]

Can't blame the man for speed of advance of the rebels that's out of his control

[@juanortiz8092]

The videos on this channel are timeless.

[@Badger_IV.]

NS created an Turkish embsarry. More will follow. They're actually creating a govroment and HTS's leader commanded his people to stay calm and dont start arguing with others

[@BjornMoren]

Strange that you didn't include Israel in this discussion. Has played a significant role in Syria and also will in the future.

[@azeturkmen]

next video..

[@fayaqun0]

Exactly! Israeli invasion of Syria hasn't been discussed.

[@Vetrarland]

Including the six Druze villages in southern Syria that have formally requested annexation by Israel, because of fears of persecution and insecurity following the collapse of the Assad regime and over the rise of extremist Islamist factions in Syria.

[@leoanthony79]

Hopefully to be covered in a future episode. It did deserve a passing mention I agree, especially in light of what's going on now.

[@hyhhy]

@@Vetrarland Southern Syrian Druze People's Republic, am I right?

[@Jeanclaudevandamme55]

comment section is absolutely grilling him, and i love it

[@lordofvurgun187]

Fr, I keep reading them for entertainment, it is such fun))

[@ecoideazventures6417]

I was about to say how dare you, but when i read all the comments, i am like even the great Caspian Shirvan can be biased!

[@yengidemir]

thats why kurds are losing, they spend their time spamming in internet instead of actual training

[@Jeanclaudevandamme55]

@ found the turkey

[@SineN0mine3]

Lol maybe it wasn't a great idea fo replace all of our actual journalists with random people on the internet who have no instutional oversight. You simply can't expect any random individual to be unbiased even if they make efforts to be. Traditional media still had problems with bias and bad research, but it was never as bad as the state we're in now without it.

[@UnicornPizza]

4:55 - “to look like the Syrian Zelensky” LMAO

[@jodawgsup]

epic lmoa!! XD

[@theosvult4857]

He really does look like Zelensky lol. I'm the trimmed beard, modern hairstyle & change of clothes really was intentional to appeal to Western nations

[@Omer1996E.C]

He's more than zelensky. He won over Russia

[@user-op8fg3ny3j]

​@@theosvult4857 lol, more like zelensky looks more Muslim since he opted for the rugged militant look with the beard that is very uncommon for weatern leaders

[@pcenero]

I mean, Che Guevara (and other non-tuxedo rebel leaders) did it first soooo

[@tahademir6069]

He made this video 13 years ago and waited for assad to fall. What a patience :)

[@uncledan2u]

True. 👍

[@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781]

Isis and hts didn't exist back then lol😂

[@impactEditHD]

@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 yes they did ...

[@tahademir6069]

@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 he has foreseen it

[@magivkmeister6166]

​@@impactEditHDNot by those names....

[@kolyafischer5822]

I love how the whole video is presenting itself as this unbiased neutral report, sponsored by ground news and stuff But when it comes to the SNA SDF conflict it’s just completely uncritically reproducing Turkish antikurdish propaganda… like lets not talk about SNA militants wearing ISIS Patches on their uniforms, killing injured people in hospitals, kidnapping women and the Turkish state celebrating this in national tv… „SDF is neither Syrian nor democratic“… of course the majority of people self governing themselves in the Syrian north east have been syrians for decades and sure „they are not holding elections, so they can’t be democratic“, let’s just ignore the fact that they are implementing a complex system of direct democracy of councils and delegates that you could argue is way more democratic than every western parliamentarian democracy… Just absurd how biased everything regarding Kurdish autonomy is addressed in these videos 😅

[@yeahokbuddy2510]

Because it’s Turkish propaganda

[@PekekeTerbiyecisi]

Another commie anarchist coping for the brainwashing he recieved by the mainstream media 5-10 years ago. Times have changed. Nobody buys this bs anymore. If you actually have any clue about the region you'd know nobody likes these THUGS that is SDF/ YPG/PKK.

[@felixdomingo3921]

The guy who runs this channel is Azerbaijani. I like this reporting for the most part, but videos like these is where his bias shows.

[@history_repeats8201]

No transparency, The Caspian Report is financed by the Azerbaijani and Turkish dictators

[@yeahokbuddy2510]

@@felixdomingo3921 he’s Azeri???? That makes so much sense now. Of course he’s gonna have bias. Also this guy is YOUNG which can also explain bias since he probably is still easily fooled by state media

[@dragosstanciu9866]

The Syrians better make sure they create a strong Judicial system, otherwise political and financial corruption will take control of the country.

[@LuciFeric137]

Like USA?

[@dragosstanciu9866]

@@LuciFeric137 Like well developed countries in Asia, like Japan, Taiwan, Singapore.

[@meteorknight999]

​​@@dragosstanciu9866you mentioned no developed countries anywhere Beside where do you see a country there ?need country to make judicial reform

[@mezjean5966]

Yeah Gl with that one. They immediately created the moral police force.

[@brocaraton]

They’re going to implement sharia.

[@MrBugmusic]

Not a single mention of israels involvement?

[@TheRealHungryHobo]

This is a video about war, Israel isn't doing war.

[@IbnWobbler]

@@TheRealHungryHobo rolling tanks into another countries sovereign territory is war if not, then Ukraine is not at war then.

[@Morso8]

He is Azerbaijani, he supports Israel

[@TheRealHungryHobo]

​@@IbnWobbler Just a bit of "pre-emptive defense", you know how it is "The new government that takes over could potentially be hostile to Israel, therefore we will bomb them and steal a bunch of their land, just to make sure they actually are hostile to us, and will retroactively justify our actions because 'they want to destroy us' totally normal, not war, self defense things." Also, totally not weird at all that The Times of Israel had an article that literally, using the actual german word, called for Israel to take more Lebensraum. Also, totally a coincidence that Bibi regularly uses maps of "Greater Israel" which shows literally all of their neighbors not existing/having much of their territory conqueered - and he brings them to international meetings and shows them off publicly. Also, since we touched on people stealing actions and rhetoric directly from 1940's Germany, I suggest you look up what Bibi says about the little moustache man and his historical atrocity - I literally can't quote him without automod eating my comment... Like I said, they're not doing war. It's beyond that.

[@tesserae-c2y]

No matter which side you are on, Israel has been conducting air strikes and occupied Syrian territory. That's the reality on the ground. Caspian is definitely biased in this video and is not presenting all the facts. This channel is def compromised.

[@benjaminedelman3523]

You can tell when a vid on Caspian report is affected by personal bias - *this is one of those videos*

[@nikolasmacedonites917]

It's not personal, he's an intel soft power project.

[@benji1we]

Sorry Caspian, but you rant on the SDF, lack of criticism of SNA, and failure to mention Israel's incursion almost at all really shows why you can't be listened to in issues affecting Turkey and Azerbaijan lol

[@ahmedhasan4966]

Because he is from Azerbaijan.

[@leobaghirli4630]

And why you think whatever SDF is aiming is legitimate and truthful. Since when terrorism is justified ?

[@envispojke]

​@@leobaghirli4630lol he said nothing of the sort. how are you so bad at arguing you need to make things up?

[@ÖSA-q4w]

does everybody have to toe the pentagon's line?

[@circuitbreaker8314]

He became a zionist shill long time ago

[@equalopportunityoffender1816]

Bro went mask off with the Erdogan propaganda on this one, should rename channel to RecepReport.

[@abhishekparmar6702]

yooo ahahaha nice!

[@exarder1377]

PKK supporter living in Europe spotted

[@equalopportunityoffender1816]

@@exarder1377 First half of that sentence is true, second isn't. Can barely say shit without KZbin auto deleting my comments.

[@equalopportunityoffender1816]

@@exarder1377 YT keeps auto deleting my comments, love that censorship. Don't live in Europe btw. First half is true though.

[@abhishekparmar6702]

@@exarder1377 i dont think you people understand, that we in fact are proud of it.

[@EverythingaboutKurdistan]

“The SDF is not democratic because they have never held elections” shows how little you know about them. The SDF operates under the ideology of Democratic Confederalism, which supports a more direct form of democracy. This system includes local elections for each region, local courts where people from different minorities gather, and democratic decision-making through voting-pure democracy! You also claim that SDF territory is not Kurdish simply because Arabs now live there, without even mentioning the Arab Belt Project. This project, initiated in the 1970s, forcibly relocated hundreds of thousands of Kurds, replacing them with Arabs in these areas. Finally, you allege that the SDF lacks local support and has been targeting civilians. These claims are entirely false and have been debunked. On Instagram, we’ve shown how Turkey, the SNA, and HTS have been releasing fake videos claiming to be from the PKK and YPG, spreading this misinformation online. Your so-called “unbiased research” in your videos is nothing but lies and propaganda against the Kurds. Every recent video of yours I’ve seen reflects this bias. Shame on you!

[@capncake8837]

Aren’t the Kurds still mainly concentrated in a few clusters along the border with Turkey? It stands to reason that the further away from those areas they go, the more non-Kurds they’d have under their rule.

[@EverythingaboutKurdistan]

@@capncake8837 read my comment again and then understand that what is today is mainly due to Assad’s project The Arab Belt during the 70s

[@JojoBojob]

@@capncake8837 "under their rule", the whole point of democratic confederalism is that those who live in a region rule said region. So there is no such things as "under their rule".

[@Con_Koumis]

The Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) control areas with a diverse population. According to a survey, approximately 68.7% of the SDF fighters are Arabs, while 17.2% are Kurds. The SDF itself estimates that 50-70% of its troops are Arabs and 30-50% are Kurds

[@davidhollenshead4892]

I decided to Unsubscribe of this biased video...

[@rayb8190]

Was a big watcher. However, the overwhelming Turkish bias the past few videos has become too much. Can’t even finish this one. You can keep licking Erdoğan’s boot my friend, but I’m out.

[@the-dark-matter]

Same!! Very sad, very few channels bring a geo-political aspects into any analysis. But this one has become too biased, especially when it comes to the middle east.

[@PekekeTerbiyecisi]

Maybe you're the biased one? Ever thought about that? Mainstream media has brainwashed you into believing these SDF/YPG/PKK thugs are some saints. GTFO nobody cares.

[@PekekeTerbiyecisi]

@@the-dark-matter Maybe it's you who is biased?

[@maxmichalik4938]

@PekekeTerbiyecisi Really? Did this video feel like it was presenting two sides of an issue and talking about the good and the bad in both sides? He had plenty of mixed things to say about the HTS, as well as most factions and people he talks about in other parts of the world. But name one negative thing he said about Turkey and the SNA in this video, or one positive thing he had to say about the SDF. Or do you honestly think that the SNA are perfect angels and that the SDF is as bad as ISIS?

[@history_repeats8201]

Same here I think most of the subscribers remaining are Erdogan's trolls

[@3lihabib831]

This feels like watching a video from the Turkish state TV that tries to portray itself as neutral lol.

[@SJA-mh2uz]

exactly it is.

[@gurkeschurke6667]

Ok, Racist.

[@thefarsear]

It's funny how CaspianReport stops being impartial when it gets to the Kurds... case of an enemy of your friends?

[@gurkeschurke6667]

It's funny how you people get hostile whenever Turkey is mentioned, seems a little weird doesn't it ?!

[@berkekadircelik6282]

You people just want every video to attack Turkey.

[@nikolasmacedonites917]

When it gets to the kurds, when it gets to Iran, when it gets to Greece to Russia... Generally whenever it gets to whatever Turkey's geopolitics don't like.

[@سعیداکبرزاده-غ7ه]

did Erdogan himself write the script of this video? :)))

[@tauceti8060]

No Bibi did

[@yurig2530]

@@tauceti8060 Bibi and Egdogan together. Biden was helping a bit, while not asleep.

[@Hangover-ry9bo]

The winners always do that, they draw new maps, pay historians to write and teach the new version.

[@OttomaniaGaming]

Why you guys crying? Already Turkey won on Syria, so script also on point

[@JohnTibbitt]

Sadly it looks like Turkey's the foreign power that won in Syria. They bet everything against Asad and he gone.

[@GrigoriosTzikas]

''SDF never held elections.'' No, the actually had elections in 2017.

[@Sheriffovic]

Sdf was lit pushed to rebrand by america because it’s tied to a terrorist group. Even American general called democratic as irony

[@EagerEggplant]

He didn't know because the Turkish government never mentioned it. 🙃

[@dataanalyst9343]

This wasnt a real election when 80 % boykotted the election.

[@iX067]

Cope terrori$ts.

[@sarpsarp5917]

It doesn’t change the fact that SDG is run by PKK.

[@uninstaller2860]

Calling Syrian Kurds non-Syrian has a genocidal ring to it

[@BBWahoo]

Israel approved

[@mdstate829]

Shirvan is from Azerbaijan so spouts whatever his turkish freinds say

[@erenyesil5897]

He's not talking about the Kurds living there, but the fighters of SDF, Although I can't say to what extent it's true or not

[@destinationlimbo378]

you mean how the kurds are killing and ruling over the native arabs?

[@mustafacoban6382]

Even SDF claim that fighters in SDF who not local will return back to Iraq. So by your logic, SDF is genocidal to Iraqi Kurds.

[@jkc2099]

No one knows what sharia law would mean? Come on, really?

[@Kenny-Alpha]

😂I know, right?

[@AbdullahKhan-s1t7p]

Yeah not really, will they follow a more relaxed traditional interpretation native to syria, or something that have imported from certain parts of the gulf? Will they follow something more similar to the Azharis or something belonging to Julanis old friends? I can tell you don't really know what you are talking about when it comes to the middle easts culture and history.

[@maxmichalik4938]

Apparently they want some kind of "Sharia Democracy". Saying that no one knows what that means is fair.

[@jkc2099]

@AbdullahKhan-s1t7p stonings, no rights for women, no education for girls. Such a backward religion. It's really so sad.

[@kaywanahmadi6468]

this video is so pro turkish. dude even did not try to spill some truth in to the video

[@VoornuVoornuwillem]

Reality hurts 😂

[@aramokurdo]

indeed

[@gre3nishsinx0Rgold4]

What's great about this channel is the analysis, the research, and all the info put into it, looking from the outside of it all. But recently, some videos have been questionable on its biased stance. It's so painful to watch the credibility die so slowly as if it's been bought out by someone with an agenda. Or an unwanted virus that afflicted many news channels turning them into a mouthpiece is also rotting away on this channel, too.

[@aramokurdo]

indeed i disliked and unsubscribed

[@Tsavttanem]

Azeri guy makes video with heavy Turkish bias what a surprise

[@OttomaniaGaming]

If truth is showing Turkey, it doesn’t matter what is his origin.

[@rojvankoc7252]

@@OttomaniaGamingit MATTERS big time kardes..

[@badgers0525]

Yeah a little disappointed. I usually find his videos to be pretty good but ig I just won’t watch any videos to do with Azerbaijan or Turkey bc they will just include heavy bias.

[@RandomGuy-df1oy]

What is that bias tell me? The whole world presents it on anti-turkish bias. What information on this video is wrong?

[@dora3743]

@@RandomGuy-df1oy for a start it intentionally tries to cast the AANES/Rojava as authoritarian and anti-democratic because it’s not a liberal, representative democracy, neglecting to mention the more grassroots, localised form of direct democracy they have instead.

[@michaelgonzales1845]

Biased video. He focused way way too much on the SDF and kept calling them PKK but almost nothing about the SNA. Guy's a Azeri and normally his stuff is good except when it has to do with Azerbaijan and Turkey. Nothing on the war crimes the SNA are committing. To his biased reporting it's all SDF/PKK with a laser focus.

[@3three3]

So hes unbiased until he speaks facts about the biases you have? The PKK are literally an international terror org LOL keep your own biases to yourself

[@Sheriffovic]

Bro, Usa lit agreed on that. There were American’s saying they told them: wod considers you as terrorist, you have to rebrand. And even they find it ironic to call “democratic”. Sounds American, and it has nothing to do with democracy that’s also American. All fits

[@delomohammed3431]

@@Sheriffovicis the Turkish backed SNA democratic? How about the illegal Palestinian settlements in afrin perpetrated by Turkey? Hmm 🤔

[@maxmichalik4938]

@@Sheriffovic The "world" that considers them terrorists are all the countries that have dealings with Turkey, who is a NATO member and a (very leaky) shield against immigrants and asylum seekers. Turkey literally held the NATO ascension of Sweden and Finland hostage with this subject.

[@astrodas1910]

SDF is PKK. Changing name doesn't change who you are.

[@DoctorFeisar]

Often you hear: "Middle east borders are just European lines on a map" While simultanious "Syrian teritorial integrety must be kept" I mean, pick a stance. Europe is full of smaller countries with a coherent social and cultural fabric. Why aren't the syrian 'minorities' (which range in the millions of people) entitled to this either? Blaming it on the Europeans (rightfully so) but now wishing to keep their drawn lines for maximal power feels unauthentic.

[@Sheriffovic]

What a simple way of thinking. Have you ever looked at human history ? West is just marketed as an angel, deep down it has devil roots that can suck you up. Of west never touched east, it would be prospering as it did in the past. But you tell me which one is easier to exploit, control? Educated, coherent country or divided, everyone is in war country ? Have you ever watched trump saying they could end isis so fast but american gov didn’t allow? Just for couple billionaire could sell weapon and buy cheap oil or even free oil from a country, how many countries got destroyed? Africa is richest continent in earth yet the poorest. You can not destroy a country, bomb their schools, hospitals and leave them uneducated, turn them each other and not expect it to grow ?

[@PekekeTerbiyecisi]

The problem is, people who want this "rojava" project which basically means Western Kurdistan. Wants the kurds to control alot of land which they aren't even a majority in but rather a minority just like how Assad was running Syria. It's not gonna happen again. The PKK knows this and try to save time with the Biden administration. But hopefully Trump is smart enough and removes the backing of the US for these thugs.

[@FNA27601]

Because if it splits into smaller countries then it'll just be easy pickings for any of the gazillion foreign powers that have tried to influence Syria. Also within all these lines of different people is still a mixture of the minorities so many people will have to be forced to migrate and that alone is a massive headache and overall a horrid thing to do. That all plus the fact that these borders are the internationally recognized borders of Syria so maintaining sovereignty is maintaining its territorial integrity.

[@maxmichalik4938]

@@FNA27601 They could have their own federation. The EU isn't easy pickings after all, despite being made of many small countries.

[@FNA27601]

@@maxmichalik4938 difference is the EU is huge and already had diffe governments and head of states that decided it would be better if they formed a union that would help integrate their economies and be a block. That means theyre a bunch of already soverign different states that cooperate with one another. Syria itself is considered a smaller country and with its ethnic diversity that means you'd be chopping up a bunch of smaller states within the overwhelmingly larger sunni arab state which will undoubtedly dominate this union and we'll just go back to square 1 or it just becomes an offshoot of the current Russian state.

[@dev.0122]

I never thought of it but it feels like Shravan hates Kurds, in multiple videos i have noticed how he singles out SDF and supports Turkey and authoritarian rulers. This was the case in war on Armenia by Azerbaijan. I have been following this channel for over 5 years now but this is the first time I realised the overt bias against Kurds, and Armenians.

[@Dz-rt9fk]

Oh he hates kurds alright, its been known for years.

[@abhishekparmar6702]

ive been following this for 7-ish yrs or more and yes i agree with you.

[@makaltun]

Same I swear to God. This was the time it has been most pronounced

[@Hakankirbas]

Caspian is telling the truth 🤓 but your use to propaganda news

[@projectixj9868]

Makes me wonder where Shirvan is from.

[@WyoSavage1976]

Kurds deserves a country of their own.

[@RandomGuy-df1oy]

No but Native Americans deserve the America. Europeans shall go back to Europe.

[@jonahkristiansen5301]

No

[@JojoBojob]

@@jonahkristiansen5301 yes

[@Sheriffovic]

Yes let’s give them from your country

[@beggarsarentchoosers]

lets start from your home ♥️

[@colinstu]

Holy crap... the propaganda in this one.

[@АлексейТихонов-н3ц]

the turkish glazing is insane 😭💀 (average azeri)

[@lordofvurgun187]

Cry, orc

[@ÖSA-q4w]

mudslinging is much more insane. look at the rest of the comments here and think of all the similar rants when YOU are reclaiming YOUR OWN land.

[@Chipotlerr]

I saw a crying ruski

[@maxmichalik4938]

​@@ÖSA-q4w Where are you from and what land are you currently reclaiming?

[@ÖSA-q4w]

@@maxmichalik4938 Azeri. Karabağ.

[@erfanSaydanzad]

The quality of your recent videos has significantly declined, and in this one, you appear biased and seem to side with Turkey.

[@tavenstrickert9658]

It didn't seem Turkish biased. It just stated the realities that turkey is a powerful player in this situation and that the other players in Syria are likely going to cooperate with turkey against the SDF. I would love to see an independent Kurdish state, but if this is the way things are lining up, it doesn't seem realistic to hope for that. That's not biased, that's just reality

[@OttomaniaGaming]

Your hatred blocking your visdom. It’s not channel’s mistake..

[@tavenstrickert9658]

@@OttomaniaGaming I don't really think it's hatred either. I mean we're all people that have biases every single one of us. Some of us see the situation in Syria and we want different factions to win different results. I don't think any of that is born out of hatred. Just born out of a legitimate desire to see something good as we understand. Good to be. But because we have our own biases, we can blame others for theirs unnecessarily when we don't like images and information were being presented with. That comes more out of ignorance than hatred.

[@lartts7483]

​@@OttomaniaGaming Okay "OttomaniaGaming"

[@DemonOfMirkwood]

What happens when you hear anything other than western imposed propaganda. Liberals dont even know YPG is marxist is pretty funny but they are somehow experts in MiddleEast.

[@viewerdescretionisadvised474]

was waiting for this video, always interesting to see the pro-Turkish anti-Kurdish pov and propaganda

[@Fuad_Guliyev1]

Do you ever know what propaganda means?

[@viewerdescretionisadvised474]

@ I think you meant to say "even" not "ever". Here is the definition of propaganda: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda

[@PekekeTerbiyecisi]

anti-Kurdish. Lol. Anyone that is cucking for PKK and trying to paint the picture as if the Kurds are equivalent to PKK is the real anti-Kurdish.

[@roberto2044]

@@Fuad_Guliyev1this video is the definition of that

[@tiyaxiaoqi7709]

It's unfortunate how Anti-Kurdish sentiment runs so deep within ethnic turks communities such as Azerbaijanis.

[@Samirustem]

There is so many kurds living in azerbaijan. We never treated them as low grade humans. Can you honestly tell me in europe you consider them equal to you? Or in america?

[@aykutuckan1665]

its unfortunate how prejudice against Turks runs so deep with people who has no grasp of reality of the subject outside social media outlets they pick and choose themselves.

[@mw8498]

There are probably less than 50,000 Kurds, citizens or immigrants, living in the USA.

[@angusmatheson8906]

​@@Samirustem Yes. Kurds are equals, absolutely

[@noahgolden-cv1pc]

Buddy, the average American and Western European doesn’t even know who the Kurds even are.

[@MrHoodey]

Lol you ignore every flaw of hts and more importantly the sna just to double down on the sdf. Your bias is pretty obvious.

[@3three3]

Seems like yours is obvious as well.

[@MrHoodey]

@3three3 cool dude 👍

[@thekidfromtheyvshow3328]

SDF sold syria so its not wrong lol

[@MrHoodey]

@@thekidfromtheyvshow3328 to whom? The oil thats so unprofitable no us company wants to invest?

[@thekidfromtheyvshow3328]

@@MrHoodeystop stealing the oil then lol

[@highelojungler]

a lot of pro-turkey bias in this video. I urge viewers to remember that when watching caspianreport these days.

[@Artanis5]

I guess truth has a pro-turkey bias then ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@simply420high]

“The Syrian Zelenskyy” 😂😂😂😂 @4:55

[@danirey425]

They even got the same shirt 😂, saw that and it's stuck in my head

[@dspserpico]

“Makeover into the Syrian Zelensky” That is way better than how I have been saying.

[@fabrifibraa]

lol legit

[@dimas3829]

well, unlike real Zelesnky, he is not clown-beggar, yet.

[@projectixj9868]

He DOES look just like it too. It's crazy. It's important to remember that the Koran spefifcially teaches that it is acceptable to ignore custom or even behavior in order to deceive the infidels.

[@matthewmiller6568]

​@@dimas3829 I'd rather have a beggar as president than one who would put their pride above the interests of the people.

[@太陽神-u1l]

@@dimas3829 russian bot is crying lol

[@ranja3378]

The Turkish glazing is strong with this one

[@bogeaqYT]

Pretty ironic the Turkish foreign minister complaining about international terrorists in the SDF. How many foreign Salafi terrorists did they let through their borders into Syria? I hope the SDF are able to negotiate peacefully with the new Syrian government, despite their understandable mistrust of Turkey. I’m not so sure the Americans will leave the SDF however. We all remember what happened when Trump tried to leave the first time? That spot is too advantageous for them to give up. I think they want to stay to cut off Syria from Iraq to prevent Iranian weapons from being smuggled to Hezbollah and Palestinian resistance.

[@sfy07]

😂 Man Hts and Sna fought with Iranians and Hizbollah. So dont worry about this. Situation changed. Turkiye and new Syrian goverment has ability to stop ISIS. Türkiye is 2. Biggest country of NATO and you can be sure it can stop ISIS better than SDG. So no need SDG there. Nobody buy it anymore

[@bogeaqYT]

@ My brother, I don’t give a F about the SDF. They hoard Syrian gas and wheat on behalf of the Americans. I’m just worried Turkey will use this as an excuse to go to murdertown on some Kurds. Furthermore, ISIS is not a threat. HTS/FSA/SNA are ISIS more or less. These fools change armed groups the way some people change Sneakers. The biggest threat to Syria is the one entity that is currently invading Syria and bombing them to hell: that piece of shit called Israel.

[@Hama8902]

@@sfy07 you forgot there no isis anymore, they are all in HTS and SNA so a Kurdish state is needed there as long as Syria is ruled by masked isis

[@aramokurdo]

thank god some see trough Turkish hilarious hypocracy!

[@Arya.Ahmad.Abdulrahman]

Let’s not forget that SNA also recruits previous ISIS members, in fact you see some raising their flag beside the SNA’s. Same goes for HTS. So SDF being linked to a terrorist organisation isn’t really the reason why it shouldn’t be a part of Syria as it’s not the only organisation in Syria.

[@RajenderSingh-ub4gg]

Turkish propaganda Chanel

[@СимонаВаршава]

Azeri propagand chanel.

[@joshumu]

The SDF is the military and a coalition of various groups like the mainly Kurdish YPG and all woman YPJ, the Assyrian MFS, and the Arab al-Sanadid Forces, among others. They have a high degree of autonomy and in at least some of the YPG/YPJ groups the rank and file soldiers elect their commanders with direct democracy. But the armed forces are not generally elected anywhere. The SDF is the military wing and subordinate to the Syrian Democratic Council, which very much has had elections, with higher offices, in theory, existing only to enact and coordinate decisions made by local assemblies. So to paint the SDF as anti-democratic is pretty disingenuous, especially in comparison to the other alternatives in the area.

[@Camelwrestler]

Well when you look at the treatment given to the NK war between Armenians and Azerbaijani you see where the channel’s loyalty lies.

[@OkayOcak]

Tell me why pkk terrorists that are known by their name and identity, found in sdf's military ? How can you be so naive or just expect us to be 😂 no no. Just cry more until you think that you are right.

[@berkekadircelik6282]

YPG is literally the offshoot of PKK. You just claimed they are a big part of SDF. PKK is a designated terrorist organization by the US and EU. But I guess it doesn't matter to you people

[@aramokurdo]

its just a Turkish propaganda video that's why they hate non Turks specially Kurds and democracy and humans!

[@aramokurdo]

@@OkayOcak youcan take out of your Turkish and Oyghur Terrorists out Of Syria then spit out words

[@Teapot_Steam]

the map from 07:00 is 85% accourate guys, its made by turkish influence that wanna make look kurds look as small as possible, there are 3-4 million kurds in Syria. dont take this map too serious.

[@meenyheany]

We can understand the numbers after US support leaves. In case things turns out as predicted in the video, we can say numbers reliable. Otherwise If there are 3-4 million Kurdish population local support will hold. Even in case most of the Kurds may not want to support a terror organization who shoots civillan which is worse than prior goverment.

[@dimas3829]

it's also important to note that this guy totally ignores Israel taking land on the southern east by moving their tanks forward, while they effectively destroyed what was left of Syrian fleet. I'm questioning if he is biased towards god chosen race.

[@OttomaniaGaming]

Just 2 millions kurds in 23 million country. That map completely true, you are wrong !

[@lazo_ozal]

also, that map is the result of the Arabization policy of the last regime. he also completely ignores the fact that while yes, the SDF has PKK roots, that maybe the PKK has roots in some real issue.

[@yengidemir]

10% of syrian 30M poplatuin simply means 3m kurds, he never said kurds are less than that

[@dora3743]

This was really disappointing for its one-sided coverage of the SDF.

[@spacetragedy]

Yeah god forbid soneone should critisize the sdf your quasi heroes then it instantly becones "one sided"

[@dora3743]

@spacetragedy god forbid one expects more from a channel that one has trusted to employ nuance

[@maxmichalik4938]

@@spacetragedy Well, he didn't say a single positive thing about them. Are you saying they are literally the devil? Hell, he had more positive things to say about the freaking Taliban (though he also did say a lot of negative things about the Taliban).

[@gurkeschurke6667]

You would't cover Hitler in a Positive way, because he happens to be Anti-Smoking.

[@aramokurdo]

@@spacetragedy tell that to you brainwashing anti Kurdish media

[@adenjzmribagbfd]

GLORY!!!I'm favored,$255k every 3weeks! I can now afford anything and also support God's work and the church.

[@Marcosteve-q7d]

Wow, congratulations on your financial breakthrough! Can you share more about the investment that's generating $255k every 3 weeks?

[@Fyff-x8c]

How do you make such monthly ?? I am a born Christian ✝️and sometimes I feel so down of myself because of low finance but I still believe in God❤️

[@StefanPichler-v4h]

Congratulation!! The scriptures clearly states there's going a transference of the riches of the heaven to the righteous.God keep blessing you

[@adenjzmribagbfd]

I give special thanks to Evelyn Vera,an instrument of God's goodness in my life. Her guidance and support have been invaluable.

[@adenjzmribagbfd]

To anyone seeking a financial breakthrough,I say:hold on to Faith,trust in God's promises,and believe in miracles!

[@koa89]

You can rightfully critize the SDF for a lot of things, but saying they've never held elections is just completly wrong. Villages vote for representatives in the local councils, these council have a say in the development of the AANES as a whole. You can even see this in practise (and the shortcomings of the SDF with it) as the Deir ez-Zor Council (democraticly elected representatives of the region) left the SDF recently.

[@notaPrimate]

This guy can’t remove his own Turkish bias from his videos

[@3three3]

Seems like you have an anti Turkish bias lol

[@Sheriffovic]

You are so biased by your personal feelings about turkey, it prevents you accepting the reality

[@notaPrimate]

@@Sheriffovic LMAÔ defining a country’s entire political standing as reality couldn’t prove my point further. Go home, man.

[@notaPrimate]

@@Sheriffovic Average TRT enjoyer

[@Sheriffovic]

@@notaPrimate Average brainwashed sheep

[@Ivanfbi]

All I see is anti Kurdish bias here...

[@3three3]

All I see are facts

[@aramokurdo]

indeed i disliked and unsubscribed

[@мувн-ш4ы]

well your beloved "Kurdish" fellows are committing terrorist activities in both Turkey and Syria.

[@mw8498]

Let me get this right, there are Turkish Kurds, Iranian Kurds, Iraqi Kurds, and Syrian Kurds but there can never be a united Kurdistan. Why is that?

[@chrisdziedzic2544]

For the same reason we're not allowed to question the colonial boundaries drawn across Africa, even though they rarely reflect ethnic or cultural realities.

[@projectixj9868]

Imperialistic meddling almost 100 years ago.

[@tarrasteno]

The Kurds and the Berbers ( Imazighen) are one of the fewest natives that don't have a state. The Kurds need to create a strong and independant state first ( ideally in Iraq). The union will come later

[@parasf2984]

Yes kurds need an independent state... support for Kurdistan from India❤

[@СимонаВаршава]

Because this is azeri turkish propagand chanel.

[@Max70022]

excellent transition into the sponsor of the video, well done

[@bear2551]

Your a turk dude.....

[@lostvarius]

Reported for misinformation and promoting terrorism ;)

[@willh1970]

To clarify: the SDF are not an offshoot of the PKK. They are a distinctly different group. The SDF do not want PKK in the NES region and have been walking a tightrope between this aim and also the natural support from some for the PKK. Its incorrect to say that the Syrian Arab population in NES are against the SDF, on the contrary the SDF comprises a large % of Arabs wiithin its ranks. Prior to the amazing events of the last few weeks the safest place to live in Syria was NES. Also to add that the cost of living within the NES region was significantly cheaper than both NWS and especially the GOS areas. The success of the NES region is something that could not be countenanced by the Turks so they have destroyed civilian infrastructure over and over and over again, in an attempt to make daily life so unbearable that the general Syrian population would turn against the SDF. This has never actually happened. I've no doubt that cities such as Deir ez Zor are more natural HTS supporters Raqqa, while definitely Arab, is not as clearly going that way. From what I've been told from Raqqa over the last couple of days their is still support for SDF, or at least the 'idea' of the SDF. To add: the Self Administration actually had planned to carry out a democratic election earlier this year but the USA instructed them not to do it, so it was shelved. I was asked to work on a project for the AANES, which never materialised, but I was given one specific mandate: 50% men - 50% women involvement. Unheard of in the middle east. I've spent over a decade in Iraq, Kurdistan and Syria and while what I've written above is correct there is a small window of opportunity for a peaceful transition. I hope that cool heads take over and all sides agree on concessions that work towards a peaceful Syrian future. Final point to note: the world bank figure is MILES out. $11+billion for reconstruction of the whole of Syria is a fraction of whats required. $100billion+ will be required. As I've suggested elsewhere a Marshall Plan for Syria is required, at those huge levels, in order to support the reconstruction. Peace for Syria.

[@z3k139]

Wow man, totally lost all rsspect for your channel. 0 credibility from now on. Overly pro Turkish.

[@carteor]

Pro turkish propaganda😂

[@spacetragedy]

Yeah sure if it doesn't suit your narrative it becones propaganda...

[@dutcheastindiacompany6939]

Biji Biji Kurdistan ♥️♥️

[@brookechang4942]

Coming from a Western perspective, "secularism = tyranny, Islamism = freedom" was a big eye-opener for me. That puts a lot of things in context that I didn't understand before.

[@DaveSmith-pm2yq]

Liberalism is so foreign in these places. For them it's a question of which flavor of tyranny .

[@ceasar8679]

Islamism will only bring ruins

[@morewi]

People were saying it decades ago. It's nothing new most westerners don't pay attention to the middle east

[@AntioneDouevre-pr8oc]

it's probably an overgeneralization, there are more liberal groups in the syrian opposition. The type of "secularism" in the middle east has always been a cover for a cult of personality or in the case of Assad minority ethnic rule. Secularism in a lot of middle eastern countries has historically meant dictators arresting religious people without due process in fear that they are opponents of the regime.

[@Dielonthug]

The culture over there is cooked

[@Kizhan_Ismail]

Pro-Turkish propaganda..👎👎👎👎

[@josif409]

So I guess this channel is more of the Turkish report

[@wildrecords5980]

Did Erdogan pay u to do this video? It must be a joke

[@spacetragedy]

Who paid you to autochirp your memmorized stale response? Youu numbskulls are alk the same if it's not what you want to hear it automaticaly becones biased or pro erdogan or pro Turkish..

[@sssleyer]

Kurdish people deserve their own state, the history and justice are on theri side. This definetly shoud include parts of Syria, Iraq, and Turkey. You are the son of the Ottoman responsible for the Armenian Genoside, enslaving of peoples for hundreds of years, religious presecutions. The truth is that Turkish are not native to the middle east. Please next video make about the warmonger Erdogan.. but I suspect you wont. So let me be very skeptical regarding your objectivity.

[@state140]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 go back to Iraq your people come from Iraq buzz off there

[@astrodas1910]

One can't just immigrate to a place and claim those lands. Ironic you didn't mention Iran, which is where they're from historically, until they immigrated. If they want a land they never had, they can invade and conquer for sure, just like any other country done. Nobody will give their lands freely. There is no Armenian genocide. They lived freely under Turkish rule for a thousand years. They weren't slaves or forced to change religion. You believe 1000 years of that would keep their identity? Armenians revolted with the back of Russia and sided with them during war; thus Ottomans deported them. Armenian Prime Minister acknowladges this but it's easier to throw "genocide" on unrelated topics. Also you should know that, Kurds done most of the fighting against Armenians.

[@alexandrosgialamidis430]

That's just Turkish propaganda

[@gordonreid5603]

Great reporting as usual. Please keep us updated.

[@mbaker2280]

So much turkish Propaganda in this video...

[@lostvarius]

Cool propaganda bro.

[@barzanjaff529]

Kurds are the only democratic force in this region and also the original people of this area who protected minorities for decades.

[@genkihoriguchi5612]

realy

[@Anonim-xc3su]

When was the last election of SDF?

[@Rozhonline69]

​@@Anonim-xc3suIt was created in 2015 in the middle of the war, it's literally never had time for an election, since the start they were in war with ISIS and now theyre being invaded by turkey

[@jonahkristiansen5301]

Hahahaha

[@Anonim-xc3su]

@@Rozhonline69If they didn't have time for election, how are they democratic?

[@EdinProfa]

This guy hates Kurds.

[@عابر-سبيل-ب]

well kurds them selves hate thos sdf it's very simple muslim = I hate any left nonsense

[@stin4173]

More like a Anti Kurdish PKK breakdown video. I'm looking more into what youre saying about their structure but you failed to highlight the turkish invasion of Afran and the Kurdish Enclaves located in the north west.

[@expLos1vEn]

anti kurdish about what? he only mentioned the media manipulation made by kurdish lobbies and naive leftists. they are not democratic, they are not syrian. even their name is misleading. if it is not about "the power play of the opportunist faction" but the freedom and survivability of the kurds then why are they suppressing the syrians with curfews? why are they trying to rule stubbornly an area that is not ethnically kurd and where they are not wanted? if it is about the stability of the region and the life quality of the people living under the sdf banner, why are they not listening to the calls of turkey? is it so hard to cut ties with a structure identified as terrorists even by the western countries? you see the map and still think that these so called freedom fighters are the things they are portrayed in the western media? oh, right. you are never gonna look more into the answers of these questions. you will never question the invasion of syria by the us even though having nothing to do with the region and why kurds are overextending. i love it when people who are not from this region know things.

[@birdsofkerala-in]

One thing I understood is that the channel don't like kurds and PKK. May be Azerbaijan likes Turkey very much...😅

[@FLLCI]

Whether channel like it or not, PKK is a terrorist organization identified worldwide. Why would someone like them?

[@bozturk7706]

Thank you for your honest breakdown of events and realist foresight, This was an amazing video Caspian Report! keep up the great work! 👏

[@turko6690]

completely agree! had to sub 👌😎

[@breitgebauterlad8068]

Says the 🐕 from central asia 😂

[@SadKitty90]

I almost never comment on videos but I feel I should in this case as a long term watcher. Been having a few issues with this channel, sponsors was one issue and misinformation on several videos was another but it was stuff that I could look over has simple mistakes. But immediately conflating SDF (which is made up of Arab tribes too) as PKK = instant unsub for me let alone leaving out how Turkey backed SNA are brutalising not only Kurds but Arabs too in areas they take over. The Kurdish issue is something that should be looked into by someone without a clear bias. It's not as simple as Turkey = Good / SDF = YPG = PKK = Bad. I don't trust CaspianReport to be objective in this subject.

[@spacetragedy]

Sdf's top leaders are all pkk, google it ther's loads of pics and videos, ther's even video of how us generals changed the nane if ypg/pkk to sdf to suit their geopolitical goals, the footsoldirs arab or kurd are just mostly forced conscripts, you all got brainwashed by your own western media and are now reacting cause somebody for once challenged your memorized narrative.

[@batuhancokmar7330]

Granted, SDF=PKK is oversimplification but not THAT inaccurate. Hear me out. PKK is founded 1978, just a year later, Ocalan moved the core of PKK's operations into Syria in 1979, stayed in Syria until his exile in 1998. So PKK had a strong presence there from the start. After Ocalan (leader of PKK) arrested in 1999, PKK restructured... KCK Kurdistan manifesto defined their state as 4 administrative divisions PKK, PYD, PÇDK, and PJAK for Turkish, Syrian, Iraqi and Iranian territories respectively. As per Kongra-Gel (their legistative branch) declaration, PKK's Syria arm was renamed to PYD as a seperate administrative division in 2005. Of these, PÇDK unofficially existed in 1990s, but after weakening of Saddam post Desert Storm allowed Turkey to directly intervene Kurdish civil war; Turkey and KDP Peshmergah fought againist PUK Peshmergah and PÇDK. We all now know how it all ended up; Turkey HELPED formation of Kurdish autonomous region in Iraq, but PÇDK is crushed and exists as a political party with exactly 0 seats there.. PJAK never gained popularity as PKK had minor influence in Iran to begin with. Iran quickly crushed them in early 2000s. Before SDF, PYD was the "government" of the Syrian part of KCK Kurdistan and YPG was their "army". How can you convince an ordinary Arab to join a Kurdish seperatist movement? You can't. So the SDF was the solution. "SDF is a joint alliance againist ISIS. YPG is part of it. Maslows pyramid is looking at you" should have been its slogan. Obviously an Arabs can't join YPG in good concience, but forming a rag-tag armed group to fight alongside? Given "more urgent" problems like starvation and the threat of mad terrorists coming to behead them for reasons, this is a much easier pill to swallow. However PYD (government) is *NOT* part of SDF, YPG (military arm) is. SDF is not a governing body... Small groups are given some autonomy for the villages they control (in line with communal and confederal Kurdish state" as KCK says), but these groups can't really exist without support of PYD/YPG, nor they have the freedom to peacefully seperate themselves from SDF. They have no flow of food, medicine or military supplies and obviously no infrastructure to produce them.. They are not "forced" per se, but they are fully dependent on YPG and YPG itself still answers only to PYD and no one else. So really, is it THAT innaccurate to label SDF as PKK? As for good or bad, in a world of finite resources no one is pure Good or Bad anywhere. Given the fact these guys have been at each other's throats for 10+ years, I think all sides deal with the civilians in their regions quite well. There are isolated incidents everywhere, but be realistic; When a faction starts to "brutalise" people, they loose territories quite quickly because lack of popular support... See the fall of SAA controlled regions.

[@aramokurdo]

indeed i disliked and unsubscribed this turkish propaganda racism

[@SIlverbullet108]

The pro-Turkish bias is getting ridiculous.Very disappointing.

[@spacetragedy]

What about your anti Turkish bias, that's just as ridiculous and disapointing.

[@allwaysart7811]

All world watching crossaid propaganda anyway. So called Kurdistan is planned by imperialism as a sister state to Israil. ISIS has been used as "universal key" to invade Syria and cut of eastern part of it.

[@berkekadircelik6282]

You people just want Turkey to be attacked. If that happens "no bias"

[@Sara-008z]

Kurds in Syria are syrians ,because syrian is a nationality and not an ethnicity. There is no reason to divide syria and give areas which are majority ARABS to the kurds. Syria is for all syrians under one government and one country. People so easily saying "they deserve their own state🥺" while they live in usa is so stupid

[@Alex.af.Nordheim]

does this also apply to Isreal?

[@aramokurdo]

then why every arabic government tramples their right?? then why Kurds never gained any identity even face genocide very now?? Syria is a fabricated state, the name is ancient and gone arabs are not actual syrians if you mean that but Kurds lived there for thousands of years! and guess what? Kurds want peace and democracy in there not seperation but arabs prefer cooperate with Turkish genociders that funded ISIS than Kurds that saved them from ISIS!!

[@skilgour44]

You're a Syrian Kurd, I assume? 🙄 The Syrian borders were determined by European powers based on European priorities, not by locals based on local priorities, and should be reshaped democratically to ensure that all ethnicities can have their own homeland. Where should Kurds live if not in the area they have always lived?

[@OttomaniaGaming]

Your hatred blocking your wisdom and vision. It’s not channel’s mistake..

[@johannhorzer795]

Allways a great video, watching for 4 years now amd have never been disapointed

[@Zapata-Cuahtemoc]

He literally glazed the heII out of Turkey and hated on the Kurds so hard

[@codaproto]

how much money you get from türkiye for this one?

[@zmail8566]

Legit

[@DogMania]

Love your channel! Just outstanding! Keep up the great work!

[@Umu_Eri]

Your rerporting on the SDF was loaded with rhetoric, i've never seen you use such personal or biased tone, not even when you covered the nagarno-karabakh war. Please do better

[@borisgurevich5504]

Starts as an objective analysis and then reveals its anti Kurdish agenda. To begin with, SDF are not only Kurds but include many Arabs and various minorities

[@spacetragedy]

Thr arabs and non pkk kurds are revolting against the sdf as you speek.

[@borisgurevich5504]

@ how do you know ?

[@Alex.af.Nordheim]

​@@spacetragedy"trust me bro"

[@quzunarqozi5171]

Caspianreport = Turkishpropagandareport. How much did they pay you for these last two trash videos?

[@uninstaller2860]

I'm surprised by this pro Turkey and anti Kurdish propaganda.

[@7ISK7]

At 16:45 you are saying that Assad loyalists will come back as if they are ISIS. This is horribly incorrect I don't even know where to start. It feels like this video had the primary objective of feeling mysterious and entertaining.

[@uninstaller2860]

Bought buy Turkey

[@FFelesar]

Turkey sponsored this video

[@HappyGuy-cn9po]

The guy is Azeri so it makes sense.

[@momojafar9385]

Alhumdullilah, May peace be upon Syria!

[@yolomuhanad]

Ameen but it would be hard when turkey is involved, Turkey always causes problems for Muslims, in my opinion fsa and sor should be under hts and hts should also control the south part of sdf since it’s mostly Arabs but sdf should control the northern parts and the rest that is stolen by turkey

[@applesflapples9127]

The Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria has regular elections. Turkey has been entirely antagonistic to the SDF, bombing their military, police and villages alike. Turkey does not ackowledge the kurdish minority in their region and a turkish backed militia defeating the SDF would not result in a new government that treats the kurds equally (to say the least).

[@samymarathon6484]

Why don't "Arabs" ever take care of their fellow "Arabs"? 11 billion for reconstruction, but you never see the UAE or Saudi helping out their "Arab" brothers.

[@joshuagraham9770]

Because they don't want other Arab countries to be successful they just want a puppet, why do you think the Gulf states fund militant groups in many wars in Arab countries

[@scatalin09]

Cause UAE and Saudis are very poor. The mother of all wounded is Europe. Now that "peace" is back in Syria, more millions of doctors and engineers will migrate towards Germany.

[@cashewnuttel9054]

@@scatalin09 What are you talking about, they are both very rich, along with Qatar, Kuwait, Oman, and a bunch of others that I can't think of.

[@Dielonthug]

Because they simply don't care

[@Anon-y1v]

because they don't make money out of it.

[@p.c8281]

your maps are some of the best ive seen on youtube, clear, detailed and balanced

[@zoranagavrilovic9403]

They're really not

[@p.c8281]

@ ☝️🤓

[@JojoBojob]

@@p.c8281 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@rsarmitage]

Bravo Caspian team. Thanks for the clarity.

[@cnsresearch]

Thanks!

[@CaspianReport]

Thanks for the coffee!

[@FLLCI]

When some dude makes video about middle eastern issues, everyone is like wow great analysis! When some dude makes a video about middle eastern issues, WHO IS ACTUALLY from the region. Everybody is like he is biased. Now read it again to see who is more biased.

[@austinchase2]

This video is mostly professional, but the coverage of the SDF and the state it defends (the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria) is inaccurate at best. While the SDF are guilty of abusing their power like other factions in the war, their system of local democracy and social policies set them apart from the rest, and Shrivan’s portrayal of them as just a bunch of warlords with simply different ideological rhetoric is dishonest. While I don’t see them remaining for long, their often-committed advocacy for local governance, democracy, gender equality, and social policies can play a role at the negotiating table when it comes to constructing a new Syria and ensuring longer-term stability. This will only work if they are not crushed before negotiations end. Popular support from a properly informed American public can influence the incoming administration’s attitude towards the SDF and its state. Misinforming them in the way Shirvan did can reduce public pressure on the US government, the SDF’s biggest patron, to defend them until the negotiations end, preventing them from advocating for the aforementioned safeguards in the future of Syria.

[@aramokurdo]

indeed i disliked and unsubscribed

[@mihajlodimitrijevic5802]

Turkish Propaganda unmasked

[@Iustin1998]

CaspianReport don't use Turkish Propaganda in your Videos... You are making good work for many years. Its a shame to use the arguments of a Criminal State.

[@Hakankirbas]

🇹🇷🥊🤓

[@RandomGuy-df1oy]

wow he said pkk (a globally excepted terrorist organisation) is terrorist, what a turkish propoganda

[@Anonim-xc3su]

@@Hakankirbas Şunların göt yanıklığı geceme keyif kattı.

[@ashrafuluzzal9058]

We always approve and love what you do

[@heanvisalseyhak9487]

I’m so early to this that Assad’s already having dinner with Putin

[@Indubb]

Its really questionable if losing a single drone is news worthy. How many drones/military vehicles or bases has Russia, Iran or Hezbollah had to abandon in Syria recently without a single news story written about them? Its countless.

[@napoleonbonaparte8628]

Pro turkish Propaganda Video.

[@gualasaida]

You haven't taken into consideration decades of Arabization in Syria and Iraq. Afrin is a Kurdish city. So is Derezor! What's needed is dearabization. Your sources of geographic and demographic data are biased towards the Turks and the Arabs. There are no Kurds from Iran, Iraq, or Turkey in Syria. SDF is the most democratic force Syria has ever experienced. Speaking of elections. Who holds elections during a war for survival of a nation? Turkey itself threatened to wipe out SDF if they were to hold a planned election. Please do not be a puppet and do your homework first!!!

[@djgunner258]

Great video. Broke down all the parties very well!

[@ar-mq7bw]

Not really, he's views are very pro Turkish

[@bastamtajik512]

Please turn down the Turkish bias or you won't be taken serious! Just an honest opinion.

[@lordofvurgun187]

I hope he talks about Tajikistan